Club Random with Bill Maher - Richard Dawkins | Club Random with Bill Maher
Episode Date: December 12, 2022Bill Maher and Richard Dawkins randomly riff on how eating ruins everything fun, how most mammals are nocturnal, the New Zealand bird that’s forgotten how to fly, the trouble with prolonging life, t...he one bad thing about Bill, the science behind certain diseases, Bill’s sitcom role as the office creep, and why Richard’s part in Religulous was left on the cutting room floor. Â
Transcript
Discussion (0)
I can't tell you what a great pleasure it always is to talk to you.
Well, especially in this setting because like, you know, we've had dinner.
I mean, we've been out.
We've done shows.
But I've, if I really want to talk to them money, I want to talk to them right here.
Smoking pot, drinking, breaking down, whatever barriers.
So I'm going to try to get you very fucked up.
I know you taught at Berkeley in the 60s.
So you must have...
I never did.
Weed?
No, never.
Even in the Berkeley in the 60s?
I've never even offered it, actually.
Well, you know what?
There's no time like the present.
No, I'm not in public.
I see. Well, you won't mind if I do.
Of course not.
What about a drink?
No, thanks. I've got other water in there.
You don't drink either?
I do drink, but only with food.
Oh, but doesn't that...
See, I'm the opposite, because food is a buzzkill.
Okay.
You know what I mean?
Yeah.
Food kind of like absorbs the high, or kills it.
Yes, okay.
I mean, whenever I eat, it's always like when the fun is over.
Sex, drinking, drugs, that's like that has to go.
Because once you eat then all you want to do is like something passive, admit me.
I mean, I'm like a wolf or some animal that must be in your books about, like why did
we develop that way where we eat and then sleep?
Yes.
I think many animals do that. up that way where we eat and then sleep. Yes.
I think many animals do that.
I know, but why?
It must be part of evolution.
Didn't you ever come across that?
I've never thought about this.
Really?
Does it help us survive?
It doesn't seem like napping is the greatest tool to help people survive. It doesn't seem like napping is like the greatest tool to like help people survive.
But we do it. I mean like lions, you see them.
They sleep much of the time. Right.
But I guess they, I guess when you're an animal, you sleep with one eye open all the time, right?
I open all the time, right? Since night is a very different environment from day,
and no animal can be perfectly adapted to live in either
of those things, feel good at living by night or bad
by day and vice versa.
And so sleeping is a good way of keeping out
of mischief during the off period.
And you say it works the opposite way
for a nocturnal animal.
Yes.
Did not really that comfortable in the day.
Must be hard to be that,
I mean, when you're asleep,
you're like the most vulnerable, right?
Yes, but you're going to be vulnerable in any way.
So it's better to be passive and not moving around.
Right.
But it's also got to be kind of a detriment
to be at your most vulnerable asleep
when it's bright out,
because that people can see you sleeping.
But there is a living to be made at night.
And so,
Yes.
Yes.
And it's true.
Most,
very large number of mammals are nocturnal.
I see a possum around here.
Yes.
Sometimes like he, and he's very chill.
He does not, he crawls outside the living room.
I can watch him.
He, sometimes he looks up and sees me.
It does not freak him out at all.
He's not scared.
He doesn't move faster.
He just sniffs around and then goes back up where...
Just by day or night night.
Night.
Night, always at night.
Have we started by the way?
What?
Have we started?
Oh yes.
Okay fine.
Sorry.
I know.
I should explain this is a different kind of.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I mean, and that's the whole point.
It's like, have we?
What universe are we really in?
But no, we've started and hopefully we're going for quite a long time.
I know you have a new book.
What is it called?
The Flight of Fantasy?
Flight of Fantasy.
Yeah, I mean, it seemed like something that is not right in your, I mean, I have so many
books of yours about evolutionary biology, but this is really not that.
Well, it is sort of, you figured it was.
It's partly about how animals fly, but also how humans do as well.
So it's part of the physics of flight, and it's partly the evolution of flight. So true flight has evolved four times in birds, bats,
terrassos and insects.
Really?
You mean, got better?
Like better flying capabilities?
Yes, I mean, they fly properly in the sense
of this day up indefinitely.
There are plenty of other animals that glide.
So they just sort of float within a controlled way. Lots of them in flying squirrels, flying birds.
Some birds can't get off the ground at all, right?
That's true, yes.
So lovely line in Douglas Adams is, last chance to see about this New Zealand bird, the
Kakapo, which it's, it's, it's, it's, Douglas says, it's forgotten how to fly, but it's
forgotten that it's forgotten how to fly. So it's forgotten that it's forgotten how to fly.
So it climbs to the top of a tree, launches itself off and plummets to the ground.
So the, it's evolved an, an inability to fly and this nervous system hasn't yet caught up
with that. Wow. That's, that's his interpretation.
How does it still live? Doesn't it wind up pulling itself?
Well, it's, it's all the way out. I'm sorry to see.
Yeah. That's why he went to study it. It's a book about animals that have vulnerable to extinction.
And Jack Parr, who was the host of the tonight show before Johnny Carson, way back, before my time,
but I heard about him. And one of his favorite things I heard was he would, he got this film of animals drunk.
Yes.
And you can, you know, birds like trying to take off and fucking it up, you know, that,
and I guess they do get drunk on...
Well, they get drunk on berries of fruit that have gone bad.
Oh, right.
Sure.
It's presumably how we discovered alcohol as well. I imagine it was right. It just
Isn't that grapes are fermented or I mean, but you're right. It's really they've gone
Anything will ferment and so right
Well, that certainly was a banner day in
human history
Because it changed a lot really. Yeah, yeah, I mean
Not all bad yes. I mean, not all bad, right?
No.
I mean, Romans certainly had back in alias and really worshiped being drunk.
Yes.
You know, they, I think they understood that it was sort of part of something that was
more important than just having fun.
There's some sort of release there that I don't know if everyone needs it.
You don't plainly I do.
Well, but I enjoy it with food, as I say.
But I'm talking about people who get fucking blitz.
There's something about people,
well, people are always trying to not be themselves.
What is acting?
What is, I mean, they're trying to escape reality.
And who they,
Do you try to not be yourself, I'd die?
No, but I'm not typical in many ways.
I also never got married, never had kids.
I'm not sure I do a lot of
things that would be considered normal, but we all have masks, don't you think? Yes. I mean,
that's right. Some of them are more profound, but I think everybody has, sometimes it defences,
but sometimes it's just, I don't want you to know
who I really am, or I'm playing a part
that I would rather be than me.
I know people who literally don't know their own age.
They've lied about it for so long.
Oh, yes, yeah.
And they must know the year.
Yes.
They could.
They just don't go there.
Yes.
I don't think they're faking it either.
Yes.
Yeah.
No, that's kind of first, and then isn't it?
Well, I'm pretty comfortable being who I am, I think.
I don't think I'd probably be.
You.
Yes.
You and me.
We're comfortable.
But I'm talking about others.
Yes.
Yes. You know, there's a lot of that.
I mean, you're what, 81?
Yes.
Wow, you look great.
Thank you.
Yeah, you don't look at.
That's nice of you.
I mean, I'm 66, so I'm very curious as to what you have to say about age and aging because
like your
obviously is what I'm looking at. My you know not tomorrow but next phase. I mean
let's be honest it only goes one way time. I've tried to move it. It's the most
irrecooperable thing. Somebody said the trouble with prolonging life it all comes at
the end. Meaning that it's good at the end?
No.
Meaning the reverse.
That's funny because I like my life so much better now.
Yes.
Then when I was young,
even though I'm aware of that little detriment
of I'll be dead or sooner,
that little thing is obviously, the monster that's always chasing us.
But as far as the life itself, I wouldn't go back even if I could be younger,
if I still had the brain I had then.
I would hate to go back in, I mean, I couldn't bear to write all those books again.
I mean, and struggling through life, or again, I couldn't bear to write all those books again, and struggling through life, again, I couldn't bear that.
I'm looking forward to writing books in the future,
but I wouldn't go back and go through all that stuff
about being an Oxford professor of things.
I wouldn't go that again.
Really?
But at the time you enjoyed it.
I enjoyed it at the time, yes.
Right.
No, I mean, I just know that if somebody said,
you know, if the Jeannie said you could be 30 again,
but you have to have the 30 year old brain
that I knew I had, I just know I'm in there
so much unnecessary pain and stupid things I'm gonna do
and that I don't do anymore.
I'm so much more comfortable and there are very few days that are shit.
The only thing that can really cause a shit day
is health issues, which become obviously
the thing that we care more than anything else in a way
that I never even thought about that shit
when I was 30.
Yes.
Well, I had a stroke about six years ago.
It was fairly well, it didn't feel minor at the time, but
but I seem to have recovered totally from it. Totally. Oh, you know John Federman.
Do you know how I heard it? I just started reading about that. Yeah.
Yeah. He's the Senate candidate. He's a Senator governor, I think Senate in Pennsylvania, which is a very
important state for our upcoming midterm elections.
Swing statutes were a biteness from originally Boats and Delaware, but Pennsylvania is huge.
And so one of the candidates is Dr. Oz.
He was a doctor on TV who sold sometimes very questionable.
Is he a real doctor?
Yes.
I am.
That is the question.
All of America is asking Dr. Dr.
is he a real doctor?
Is he a real doctor?
I happen, like, I am a medical skeptic, meaning I just question everything.
You know, I think it's somebody as scientist like you.
I know, I know, it's the only bad thing about you.
Why, you think there's only one answer about you?
I don't think that, but I mean, you're such a hero of science in all other respects.
Exactly, which is why I have this point of view.
Yeah.
I don't know if you know exactly what my point of view is,
or maybe you're just going by things other people.
I kind of, I kind of do.
Okay, well, I'm not an anti-baxer.
Okay.
I believe vaccines are a medical intervention,
like every other drug, which has some drawbacks benefits.
I don't believe that everybody has the same health profile.
So every medical intervention, just like any other drug, isn't believe that everybody has the same health profile. So every medical intervention,
just like any other drug,
isn't appropriate for everybody.
Yes, that's true.
So that's not enticing.
There is something about vaccination, though,
which makes it different.
Which is that it's not just for you.
It's for, it's for, well, that's not right.
It's not right with COVID.
Sorry.
That's not right with COVID,
because we found out the vaccine does not prevent transmission
or or getting it. So that argument is at best out of date. Well, it's certainly right for
measles, mumps and rebella. Well, I already had measles, mumps and rebella. What the disease
or the or the vaccine? Both, probably. Okay. yeah. When I was a kid, that's, yeah.
I had measles as a child before the vaccine was invented.
I think I've had mumps too, is that I'm not sure about that?
Well, you know, I'm not an anti- measles vaccine crusader.
I mean, do you think, but the issue now is COVID
and that is an outdated argument.
It's only for you.
And there's 16,000 doctors and scientists
signed something called the Barrington Letter.
Did you hear about this?
Okay, well see, stuff doesn't get in other people's silos,
but that's an awful lot.
And that's just the ones who are brave enough to sign it
because anytime you go against the prevailing pharmaceutical
medical view, you're intimidated as many doctors are.
So the fact that 16,000 doctors would sign this letter,
it was a descent about how we were dealing with COVID
and some basic things like thinking natural immunity,
it's superior to pharmaceutical immunity.
It wasn't anti-vax.
Just why are those doctors quacks or wrong and the CDC and the Western medicine
who said the vaccine, no, look, the vaccine obviously saved a lot of lives,
but they were wrong about the transmission, they were wrong about getting it.
Why are those 16,000 doctors?
Why are your doctors better than my doctor?
I don't know about those 16,000 doctors.
Well, you, it's true.
I just know that the COVID pandemic has been a triumph of silence in the speed with which these vaccines were developed.
And it's a beautiful story.
Agreed.
As soon as the virus was sequenced, as soon as they are in the virus was sequenced, immediately
they got to work.
And by the way, the technique of which they've developed, the mRNA technique,
is then going to be adapted to other viruses
when these come along.
As soon as it's sequenced,
they'll be able to produce it.
All that a vaccine is doing
is just doing the same as the immune system,
but doing it in a harmless way.
Well, at best, yes, that's how it's supposed to work.
It's also like any medical intervention,
every medical intervention, every drug is supposed to do that. Mimic something that your body should do
naturally, but is not. But as we know, every medical intervention, including vaccines, you can
read a literature for all of them, will say they have side effects. So it's not exactly mimicking
what your body does. And it should be anyone's personal right to say,
you know what I know has always worked for me,
my immune system.
No, would I say that about every pathogen of questiona?
I've said it many times.
There are vaccines I would fight you for.
But COVID was not one of them.
I think it, and we know from the literature,
from the facts, it killed mostly elderly
people and obese people. That's who mostly died. Now, there are many other reasons why
you could have compromised health situation. We don't know everything about it. But I certainly
should have the right to judge how I want to treat my own body.
Yes, well, we disagreed about, I mean, I was surprised with
to hear you say you thought that the herd immunity
thing didn't work, and I think that's just...
I never mentioned herd immunity.
Well, I did, and then I thought you said the argument
for herd immunity was not important.
The idea that provided enough people get vaccinated
then the epidemic has nowhere to go.
But it didn't work that way.
The head of the CDC just got like her fourth shot, I think,
and then got COVID three weeks later.
Well, that's an anecdote.
We don't.
It's not an anecdote, but it's an anecdote that is very typical.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I remember when I got, I was fine for 14 months without it.
I got the vaccine. Then like a month later, I got, I was fine for 14 months without it. I got the vaccine.
Then like a month later, I got COVID.
Okay, look, no.
It just an alley, look.
Okay, but I'm just, I'm getting to a point.
Yeah.
When it happened, people said, oh, wow, that's weird.
That's a breakthrough case.
And then it became the story changed.
The news changed, the facts changed.
And the facts changed to, news changed, the facts changed, and the facts
changed too.
That's actually very typical.
When it happened to me, people were surprised.
In six months, they weren't surprised, because that was a more typical...
I'm not...
Again, yes, you're right.
There was a heroic scientific moment when they came up with the vaccine so quickly, faster
than they thought, and it's a... it is a different technology than the old vaccines.
It is a completely different way to do a vaccine.
We're calling it a vaccine because it's a shot, but it's a very different way to do it.
Okay. So I think it's a superior way to do it.
Yeah. I'm glad they came up with that technology because there could be something around the
corner that may be making it in a lab
in Boston right now because they've been fucking with that, making a worse version of COVID,
where again, I would be first online. But, you know, I just didn't think this one
merited that for me and I think I was right.
Well, I think we both agree. We both love science.
Right, do. Well, I think we both agree we both love science.
Right do.
I think that the DNA technology
that it had, it's identically gave rise to these vaccines,
it's just marvelous.
The fact that we've actually sequenced,
they get the sequence of anything,
any animal, any plant, any fungus, any bacterium,
it's a gosh darn whatever.
What do you think that the implications of that are for cancer?
Well, the same mRNA technique can be probably can be used to develop vaccines against certain
kinds of cancer. Cansers are, as you know, somatic mutations.
You say you get evolution, natural selection,
going on in the body.
So a cancer is evolving to get better at being a cancer.
Right.
And so from a Darwinian point of view,
it's grim, but it's fascinating as well.
It's natural selection in action.
Why do you think we have not been able to crack that one?
Why can't you go to a doctor and the doctor say,
oh, you have cancer?
We know exactly what caused it.
Oh, and we know exactly what?
I think it's because the cancer cells are your own cells.
And so although it's easy to kill, relatively easy to kill invaders, because the cancer cells are your own cells,
with just maybe one mutation. So when they give you chemotherapy or something, it kills the cancer,
it almost kills you at the same time, because it's your own
cells.
That seems like, I mean, that's what we have.
We're getting better with therapies for cancer, but we still, a lot of what we have is, it
reminds you of the Russian army.
Let's just fucking kill everything.
And then maybe a city will grow back, but like first and you know see this is again my thing with vaccines
Like I don't think vaccines are evil. I just
Until they figure out basic things like what causes cancer and there are so many influences
Inside my body going on and we don't know how they mix together and they don't ask. They don't study
how many what kind of metals are in your body. These things really affect your health.
I know you can't quantify them usually on a chart at a regular doctor's office. They don't even
ask you what you eat. What are you putting in your body? Do you live near a lot of electromagnetic
energy? There's lots of stuff that isn't crazy. It's scientific. And we don't,
again, we don't know what is causing cancer. So, like, I'd like to keep it as natural as I can,
unless it's an emergency. I have the same basic philosophy about vaccines as I do about antibiotics.
Am I clear they exist? Yes. Would I like to avoid them if at all possible? Yes, because I know
Yes, would I like to avoid them if at all possible? Yes, because I know I'd rather handle it naturally. That's not un-scientific. No, I like to encourage science to proceed and to improve and to work further.
In the case of COVID, it was a case of working extremely fast. It said, Brad,
new thing, nobody knew about it. Learning on the job, naturally they made mistakes.
Learning on the job, naturally they made mistakes, learning on the job, plenty of mistakes to begin with. And I'm still learning and it probably have
to go on learning. And as new Newton strains pop up, I have to learn again.
We are brought to you by SignalWire. SignalWire powers the future of cloud communications. Built
by the tech OGs, the original geeks of software defined telecom, their mission is to make it simple for you to build whatever you can imagine using real-time voice video or text messaging.
The OGs at SignoWire have spent decades solving the most complex and awkward problems and communications. The only thing that can't help you with is when a Christmas,
your wife wanted a diamond bracelet and you somehow heard that as dustbuster.
But for the computer related communications problems,
SignalWire has you covered.
From broadcast quality video to ultra low latency voice and messaging,
SignalWire has the APIs and SDKs to create unique and intelligent communications
experiences from with an existing applications or websites or building a new app from scratch.
Join the millions of other customers like Amazon, Ring, and Home Depot who are using SignalWire
technology to build the communications experiences of the future. And in the spirit of a holiday season, SignalWire wants to give you a gift.
Visit SignalWire.com slash random
and claim a free t-shirt when you sign up for a demo.
Go to SignalWire.com slash random
and claim your free t-shirt.
Go to SignalWire.com slash random.
You did hear about this thing in the lab in Boston, right?
That they've made a worse version of COVID.
I didn't hear that.
Oh, yeah.
What do you...
Well, I mean, it's this, you know, gain of function.
Is that what they call it?
Where you're...
They think that that's maybe how COVID started in the lab
in Wuhan to begin with is that there was this gain of function.
I think that's the term.
I haven't heard that phrase.
I've heard the theory, which is which,
my friend Matt Ridley is keen on that.
Have you ever had Matt Ridley on your show?
No, should I?
Oh, you sure?
Yeah, he's...
Well, anybody you recommend?
He's a great science writer.
And he's present pushing,
that he's written a book together with a woman pushing the idea, which
is an unfashionable idea, but he's pushing it.
That it did indeed leak from a lab in China.
Well, of course, see, this is again why this whole issue should never become political.
In this country, it became hyper-political. If you thought the virus started in the lab,
you're a Republican somehow.
And if you thought it started in the wet markets
with batch, you were a liberal.
That's insane.
It is insane.
It is insane.
It's a very depressing fact that
and Stephen Pinker goes, I'm sure you've had him.
And love him.
Yeah, love him too.
He's very keen on the idea, well, he's depressed by the idea,
that what we believe depends upon our,
what our tribe, our political tribe, our religious tribe,
is our Republican, you believe, sir?
Yes.
It was democratically believed something else.
What matters is evidence, never mind what is politics.
Exactly. And so, okay, we matters is evidence. Never mind what is evidence. Exactly.
And so, okay, we'd be about that.
Now, did you read recently that they discovered
for the first time a bacteria that is visible
to the naked eye?
I'm not totally surprised.
Really?
They said it would be like finding a human
the size of Mount Everest. Yes, that's right. Yes.
Okay.
Go ahead.
No, I don't. I'm not.
Well, when I hear something like that, again, it just says to me,
all the people who are saying,
the science, you know, we have the science.
You don't know shit. We know a lot more than we used to.
We just don't know very much,
like how to cure a cancer,
and that there could be a bacteria
the size of Mount Everest.
They just found out all that they were doing therapy-wise
with serotonin, thinking that that was causing the rep-
wrong.
There was one paper in 2006.
It had wrong information. They knew it at the time.
It didn't care.
What a metabolism they found out does not slow an age
like they thought it did.
We just don't know.
Science progresses from ignorance.
Right.
So it's important to recognize what we don't know.
Thank you.
Also, what we do know.
Yes.
And there are things we do know.
Yes.
And way more than we used to. I mean, can you imagine being somebody in the Middle
Ages or even, you know, only really up until 100 years ago, and the things that doctors
did to you made it so much worse. Bleeding you and well, putting dirt like a
mean, one of the things that my found when the CFI has sent for inquiry, which I know
you've said. Yes, great. One of the things we're doing at the moment is lawsuits against
selling homeopathic remedies as on the same shelf as other things.
And that can't be right, because homeopathic remedies contain no active ingredient.
But the reason why...
Because I'm so sorry, but I always want to know about this.
And I need you to explain to homeopathic.
Just go back and tell me what that is.
Okay. Very vague.
It comes from the idea that...
Same. Yes, homeo. That is very vague. It comes from the idea that same homie.
Yes, homie.
So you take what might be a poison, what might be something that makes you ill, and you dilute
it and dilute it and dilute it and dilute it.
And then you, so it's the same stuff.
Right.
And that hints the word homeo from the Greek.
Right.
And they believe that they believe that a tiny, tiny, tiny amount,
they believe that the more diluted it is, the better it is,
and so sometimes the approved level of dilution is such that
it's equivalent to one molecule in a volume, the size of the universe,
I mean the size of the solar system. So if you imagine doing a double-blind control trial
to test experimental against control, there can be no difference between experimental and control.
They're both water. So we've got this lawsuit going against that. How did I get into this?
Because... Oh yes. Yeah, go ahead.
Oh, I'm sorry. I interrupted you. I'm sorry. I needed to know what homeopathic was before you.
I think it's something with homeopathic because you said homeopathic.
And I was like, before you go on, it'll count to me what I was going to say.
Well, you know, are you on a book tour right now?
No, I'm part of the book tour.
When is the book tour for a flight to the state?
Looks there won't be one.
And so I'm here for the conference of the charity
that I'm involved in.
It's called the Cycon Conference.
We had it in Las Vegas because hotel's a cheap
in Las Vegas because of it.
Yeah, it's one of Las Vegas.
And you can go to the Teddy Bar after.
You can go see a show.
Oh, the Michael Jackson Cirque du Soleil, when I recommended highly.
Forget about the kids stuff.
Just enjoy the music.
It's been a great conference.
I gave you the Richard Dawkins award a few years ago.
Yes you did.
I still have it.
Actually, I hate to tell you, it was a lot more than a few years.
2009.
Okay.
Yes.
Okay. Well, that was a high spot for me.
I still have it.
I know it's that great fossil.
Well, this year we had Neil deGrasse Tyson.
Of course.
Who I love.
I just had him on my show Friday.
I know, I love him.
I think he's terrific.
Oh, he's a warm character.
Oh my god.
And what a communicator.
Yes, yeah. Oh, he's a warm character. Oh my God. I'm what a communicator. Yeah.
Yeah.
Now, I mean, the world is lucky to have you, him, Sam Harris,
who's coming.
He's just coming, yes.
He's here in a half hour.
I mean, there are some great scientific communicators.
I mean, I think it's very important.
I mean, the night we went to that award show,
as you may recall, my girlfriend at the time, was a scientist.
Yes. A young young beautiful one,
one kind of James Bond movie, but a real scientist. And I mean, I found that immensely attractive.
You know, I just thought it was so cool. And anytime I had like fuzzy scientific notions in my head,
you know, I'd ask her and, you know, she would like straight me out. And, you know, I'd ask her. And, you know, she would like straight me out.
And, you know, I mean, just like you and I just had a discussion,
people don't always see exactly either.
Right.
No, that's the beauty of science, you wouldn't.
Exactly.
That's, yes.
Yeah.
Well, we enjoyed having you that year very much.
And it would like to get you involved in our set up again.
Even it's an event out here, like it was at that time.
Every year. Every year. Yes. So what do you want me to do, like 10 minutes? in our set of again. Even it's an event out here. Like it was.
Every year.
Every year.
So what do you want me to do?
Like 10 minutes.
Well, I'm going to do some God material.
Little right to you.
And that is so funny about you.
People, when they hear the name Richard Dawkins,
I'm sure when just the man in the street who knows that name,
the thing that comes to their mind first,
atheists, which really is like not the main part of your
urever.
Thank you for that, I agree.
Thank you.
Right, it's not.
No.
No, you're almost like a guy who got a sick call.
You know, he got known as the office creep or something.
But he's really a great actor.
Not that your God book was the office creep. I played the office creep or something, but he's really a great actor. Not that your God book was the office creep.
I played the office creep.
But it's like you got known for something that isn't the main thing, although that book
is just a fucking awesome book.
I mean, I will always swear by it.
That's my Bible on my book.
Oh, lovely.
The God delusion.
Well, you know that.
I love that.
Well, I mean, I interviewed you back and we walked around
on that windy, cold day in 2006.
That was for religious.
Do you remember?
Oh, yes.
But I think I was cut out of the final show.
I think we just agreed too much.
It was a comedy.
Yes.
And you were just so reasonable.
Oh, we were, it was in April.
Was it?
Yes.
It was a stone circle.
Yes.
I mean, I still love, have treasure the memory,
but yes, you were early.
For a movie that was aiming to be funny,
I mean, it was much better to have the guy you thought he was,
Jesus Christ, and you know,
so, you know, when you make a documentary like that,
you just don't know what-
Is that still available?
Is that from now on? Oh, absolutely.
And still doing well.
Yes, so great.
You know, it was so embraced.
I...
Because it's funny.
You know, it was never mean spirited that movie.
We weren't like laughing at religious people.
Oh, who am I kidding?
We were laughing very much at religious people.
I was gonna say that.
We were doing it in a very nice way.
Yes. But, so, you're going to do a book tour for this?
No, I'm not doing a book tour for it, but the publishers don't seem to be very active in America,
which is a pity. I don't quite know. Oh, is that right? Oh, I think I do know. I think I was being cancelled or something. And so that's right. It's such a trouble.
American publishers was scared of the young people in their organization who are all woke to a fold.
And so they didn't take me on.
Oh, for fuck's sake.
Oh, I just fucking hate this world.
So do I.
Oh, fuck man.
Really, is that what, that is my God.
You know, I was listening to Sam's podcast today,
and it's all about this woman who made this movie called
G-Hod Rehab.
And then he tells the story magnificently,
of course, you should talk to him about it.
This brilliant documentary that was really a political
trying to understand one of those guatónimo-bay detainees
who we captured in Afghanistan,
and then they would release them back to Saudi Arabia where they went to terrorist rehab, not that some of the more terrorists
to begin with, really.
But it's a very human story.
And of course, the usual suspects, just Islamophobia, they probably, they wouldn't even have to
see it.
It's just, we've come to this place where you can't even go near a topic, certain
topics, without the mob coming after you.
Yes.
Well, I was cancelled by KPFA, which is a radio station in Berkeley, California, a few years
ago for Islamophobia.
Right.
Because I object to stoning gay is to death and so insane.
How backward they're thinking is in the people
who are purporting to uphold liberalism.
And then they can't condemn just the women thing.
If it was just, and it's way more than the women,
it's free speech, it's separation of church and state,
it's homophobia like you say,
but if it was just the women, if there was just a society that decided tomorrow to throw
a fucking burlack bag over every woman like head to toe, like a tarp on a motorboat.
And the liberals, what would you say about that, liberals, if it was the news in the paper
tomorrow?
You know, Iran to begin covering women completely, would we just, oh, okay, well, you
know.
Well, they're terrified of being thought racist, that's it.
It's just this, what do you make of that? I guess we need to have
a psychiatrist here to answer that, but I feel like especially this country, there is a segment of
white people that liberal white people for them. It's almost like a kink, like satan masochism, like this white loathing.
This guilt, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's,
it's original sin.
It's this, it's, yes.
Yeah.
Right.
But it's a crazy, I mean, religion is a crazy thing
to begin with, I know we agree on that,
but it's a crazy thing just psychologically
to want to create either like a God
who's always
disappointed in you.
Aren't there enough people in your life who are disappointed in you for real?
You really have to create a new person who's disappointed in you, you know?
But also to fucking hate on yourself so much for stuff you didn't do.
Like I acknowledge my race, the white people were bad in this country to the black
people. But I mean, my people didn't get here until after the Civil War, the Irish, they
weren't themselves exactly welcomed. You know, they didn't have it as bad. No, nobody had
it as bad. It was your people. You as an individual. Right. That's the thing.
So I think we're always trying to find some balance between,
how can I acknowledge my race's guilt
and recompense people in some way
for forcing them to live in a lesser version of this country
while I didn't have to live there?
I mean, I acknowledge being my age when I was a kid.
I was just very different than it is now.
And there was way more racism.
There's still racism, for sure.
But it was just a very different world.
England, I know, was different.
Because I was there in 1984, and it was a complete,
London was a completely white city.
I remember walking through the streets of London.
It was, now it looks like New York, for the better.
Yes, yes indeed.
And you have a new prime minister, who's the first Indian.
That's correct, yes.
That's kind of exciting.
Yes, well, he's not my party, but at least we've got some of these.
We've got a grown-up, we understand how the world works now.
Right.
What the fuck, where was that?
That lady for six weeks?
Well, the reason for that was that the Tory party handed over the decision to 170,000
party members around the country.
I mean, what a crazy thing to do.
You were going to get, they're all crazy right wingers.
Of course, they elected her.
But England has crazy right wingers.
I feel, maybe I haven't heard of it.
Well, it only takes 170,000 of them
or around the country.
The decision to choose the next prime minister
was handed over to this minute minority
of people, the party members, that's the Tory party.
But I mean, I'm sure there are crazy right wingers among the population.
I meant like of the members of parliament, do you have people like Marjorie Taylor Green?
No. But Liz Truss economically was the nearest approach.
And so she was the favorite of the party members.
I mean, constitutionally, it should be the members of,
it's constitutionally, it's anybody who couldn't
command a majority of the House of Commons.
And so theoretically, the King,
someone's who ever can command a majority
in the House of Commons, but the Tory party and the Labour party too actually, hands over the
decision to the party members who are just people who have paid their subscription, they're just
and not that many of them. But don't you think your system is still better than ours?
Like, the fact that with a parliamentary system,
that these changes take place so quickly,
whereas in our country, it's lumbering,
it's every four years, like, on a certain day,
it's a post-acalling in election.
I think it's unfortunate to have it on a certain day,
because then they start electioneering.
They never stop. Two years. Right. And also if a guy has, if you've lost faith in a guy in your system,
they go. In our system, he's the guy still around. Yes. Now, of course, that can work in a, in a bad way too,
because maybe somebody just needs a little time. I mean, they didn't give that lady much time to get out of the whole she calls
such a chaos. I mean, I know. But I think the American system would be better if you
got rid of the electoral college. Right. And I would think probably get rid of the primary
elections as well. No, no. And Jerry Mandarin, I mean, the whole thing is a complete shitshow.
And it's, you know, very, very likely Trump will be president again.
Oh, yeah.
Either he will...
Yeah, I cannot believe that.
Either he will...
He's definitely going to run.
He will either win or even if he doesn't, I promise you, he's going to show up on inauguration
day.
Yes.
Well, I mean, of course, if it's rigged, if if if if if his supporters
in individual states can just simply decide that, and that is there's a lot of that going
on, we're about to elect a Congress that is going to be majority election deniers. That's
that. That is terrible. And that I cannot understand how this has happened.
I cannot understand how obvious lie.
But it's not exactly unprecedented.
When Germany, not that we're Germany, we're not Nazis yet, not quite, okay.
When Germany went down the Hitler-Rybet Hall, there was a lot written about how could the nation of Schiller
and Schopenhauer and Beethoven go to?
How could this, because it was not like it was a bunch of dummies?
How could they, so...
Well, they'd been hit by draconian reparations for the First World War.
There was inflation such that people were carrying
wheelbarrow for worthless marks to buy a loaf of bread. Under those conditions, in a way,
it's not surprising that some Hitler, who's the full horror of Hitler was not then known. And the cost of wheelbarrows, which is a little bit...
Because you couldn't even get the fucking big pile of money
there without a wheelbarrow.
So wheelbarrows, you've been first thing in here.
Before you've got a car, you've got a wheelbarrow.
That's not America today.
And America is not suffering from rampant inflation like that.
Well, they think they are.
Now, that's exactly what the issue is in this, like...
They think they are, yes. Yeah. Well, they think they are. That's exactly what the issue is in this election. They think they are, yes.
Yeah.
Well, they are, but it's not, no,
it's not like wheelbarrow inflation
or what they're going through in Venezuela.
But we're such babies, yes.
Any, and of course, I shouldn't talk
because I'm well off now, so I don't feel inflation.
I certainly had times in my life when I did,
where I was poor, were you ever poor? Oh no I couldn't, I couldn't. Really? Never poor? No, I don't
think so. Middle class. Yes. And where did you, where did you go to college? I mean,
university whenever Oxford. Oxford. Is that the Harry Potter one? Everywhere you go in England, is Harry Potter, Harry Potter, Harry Potter.
Mind you, I love JK Rowling, but...
Well, she's in big trouble.
Yes. She's another brave.
She's brave.
Exactly. Like you.
But another person cancels.
Or like, certainly put on this in this like...
Not just cancels, but death threats and... Yes. ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... ...and... Not just cancel, but death threats and...
Yes.
Unbelievable hostility.
And all because she believes that
there's sort of like a default setting for humans,
which would be man and woman.
And we, you know, liberal people acknowledge, yes,
it's not always that way.
Of course, there's homosexuality.
Of course, sometimes, there's a mix up at the factory
and the, you know, genitalia don't match the, you know, usual use of them.
But I've never met a, never met.
I've never witnessed a generation that was so anxious to sort of just abrogate the whole thing. Like when you
have a baby, it's just like, we don't know, could be anything. I mean, there's a penis there,
but that really tells you enough. That's just a social construct. That tells you very
little penis. It's like a sixth toe.
It's a vestigial appendage of not much use.
No, but that's, isn't that her whole thing?
I think she objects to deborching language
and saying, somebody just says they're a woman,
they are a woman.
Right.
Right.
Well. But she and I are sympathetic towards people with gender dysphoria.
Of course.
Dislikely.
Of course.
Deporting of language and saying.
No.
And this is always my gripe is when people say, well, aren't the woke and liberals the same
thing?
No.
They're very often opposites. Like you say, this is the liberal position. We're
very, you know, compassion is our byword. Exactly. So it's not that we're lacking compassion.
But yeah, I mean, boy, the people who go, they don't believe in science. Yeah, we used to say that about the right wingers
and global warming, which is still true about them,
but the left is catching up in their ways, too.
I mean, there are things going on at medical schools
in this country that are pretty crazy.
I mean, doctors apologizing for saying
the phrase pregnant woman.
Oh, yes.
Yeah.
I mean, that's got to bug you.
It's going to change.
Yeah, I don't know.
I mean, colleges are, what was your experience in academia?
Did you find it to, you know, ethereal little two pie in the sky,
where people were in their ivory towers.
They weren't realistic enough. That's the reputation.
Yes, um, probably true. I like ivory towers. I like...
Of course you do.
I like, um, I'm fascinated by things that are...
Right.
For all, the whole universe and for all time. I mean, I'm not interested in
parochial, little frivolous things that concern humanity. Now, you're probably John McWater always
says, you know, I'll do your interview, I love doing your show, but I just know I'd always
really rather be sitting in my chair reading a book. Yes.
And I've never met him.
I would never be so enticed.
I've never been bothered about him.
I admire him very much.
Oh, he's fantastic.
I mean, now it's not like the world and the country
even dumb old Americans.
I like we don't have a nice group of thinkers
and smart thinkers and common sense thinkers, it's just that everything
is so polarized that if you're the person in the middle without a team, you are really
going into battle, unguarded.
Yes.
And yeah, I can see why you would not want to go on a book tour, by the way. I know you said you were
No, I don't mind going on book tour. I know. I enjoyed
I used to enjoy going to the deep south as well
So did Hitchens. Yes, Hitchens love the deep south and said you that atheist got huge crowds. Yes
Yeah, I got no they they come because they're beleaguered.
They come because they get a chance to see who is there in their own country by this.
That's why I love doing stand-up comedy in the South and places like that.
And that's most of the country.
And they don't have a stick-up there, as, about political correctness.
There's lots of liberals in Oklahoma.
But you're right that you come to town,
they come out of the woodwork.
Yes.
Otherwise, they're quiet,
because they're surrounded by it.
Once you're right next to Trump,
and we're gotten to this place in this country
where you can't really mix with the people
who are not in your tribe.
Like if you wore a Trump MAGA hat in Beverly Hills,
they check it.
You were something.
You know, I mean, that's a sad state of affairs.
A country.
Yes.
Do you think, I mean, I'm not,
I'm surely not talking about a second civil war,
but there's such a polarization.
There's much talk about it.
There's much talk about it, and there's lots of people rooting for it.
There's many people who think that we are so divided, and they hate the other side, the
term that both sides use one against the other, but they have this in common is existential
threat.
Yes.
The other side is, they're not just somebody I disagree with.
It's just that the distinguished gentleman from across the aisle.
No, no, no.
It's existential threat, hates America.
Yeah.
And that's a bit...
That couldn't really be...
I mean, in the first Civil War in America, it was between states and so each state picked
a side and we stayed had its own militia.
And also, there was a border between one side and the other.
So if you captured the other sides, you know.
In America now the armed forces are federal.
Yes.
And so you couldn't imagine having a civil war.
You could.
You absolutely could imagine that part of it.
The part that you
can imagine is the part you were just alluding to in our first Civil War. It was the northern
states and then the southern states. So, you know, there were four rays of each army
into the other's territory, but we got it if they captured Washington, they'd win the
war, and if we captured the Southern capital, we would.
We're all marbled together now.
There's four million Trump voters in California,
the bluest state in the country.
So we can't have a battle there,
but could you have a battle as many countries have
within the armed forces?
Absolutely, you could.
You could have factions.
Trump has factions also in police, FBI.
Yes.
I never know how that works because would they obey
their officers or would they eat?
That's what you find out when the shit hits the fan.
And we've seen the play out in many other countries.
This, some kernel takes over.
Yes. That kind of shit. There's some kernel takes over. Yes.
That kind of shit, where it's a kernel now.
Everything that they say can happen here, of course it can.
They used to say terrorism couldn't happen here.
And then that happened big time here.
And we're not exempt.
Americans, they think their shit don't stink.
And they think that they somehow live in this
gilded cage where the stuff that other countries endure, well, no, well endure it too.
And that could include authoritarianism.
And I don't know, you know.
Well, I wish the Russian army would turn on, I wish they'd mutiny and turn on Putin,
that would be...
That could very well happen.
I wish it were.
Because the Russian army, I mean, there are reports of no shoes.
I mean, like really bad shit.
Yes, yes.
I mean, we give our soldiers pretty good equipment.
Yes.
Yeah.
Well, so if you were doing a book tour and you're on a normal show, unlike this crazy show,
where we just ramble, but I think it's
much more interesting and I'm loving being able to talk to you like this.
But what would you, what's your thing with this, how do you, when the guy says, how are
you going to sell this book?
What do you say to him?
I see.
I'm trying to help you.
Yes.
Well, it's a book for young people.
Oh, it is. Yes, it kind of
grew out of I did an earlier book for young people called The Magic of Reality. Oh, I know.
You know that one. Yeah, it's perfect for my level. Well, as you know, each chapter in that
asks the question and then it has a physiological answers and then scientific answers. So this is
for what ages are we talking about? About 12, 13, 14, 15, and then up.
Yeah.
And so I thought of this as a starting a new version of the magic of reality, and it
kind of grew.
Oh.
This was going to be one chapter of that new volume, and then it grew into a whole book.
So like the kids who are like playing Twitch,
do you know what Twitch is?
No.
Now you put me on this spot after fucking explain it to you.
And I, it's a game.
What is it?
It's not a game, it's people watching people play a game.
It's a, it's, I, yeah, that's what it basically is.
Yes.
That's like a sport to them.
Watching other people play a video game.
Can you believe that?
I cannot.
So, like, how do you get someone away from Twitch to read a book?
That's my question.
I feel like we are devolving into a completely brain-rewired society because of the phone.
The phone is the portal to evil. I really believe that.
I must say I'm delighted to meet somebody who called himself a fan, but I'm a little bit disappointed
when they say, I've seen your videos. I've seen your YouTube. Oh, sure. Rather than read my books,
I say, well, he's going to read my books. They, they're much better. But that's the world we live in.
You can't, I mean, we can't go back to men's
like going back to the, you know.
But I really slave away at getting every sentence right.
And you can't do that when you're just,
no, oh, I know.
Doing a film.
Oh, I know.
No, I luckily get to do both because I slave away
getting every word right for the ending piece.
Yeah, we should. Especially I do one of my show.
Oh, thank you.
And but then I get to actually perform it.
So I kind of have the best of both worlds because the people
who would never read it can see it.
But they're the pleasure of taking something because the people who would never read it can see it.
But the pleasure of taking something and getting it,
word perfect.
Word perfect.
Exactly.
Was I think the name of the software I had when I
wrote the word perfect.
Yeah, there's one in the other word perfect.
But exactly.
And that's why I like doing a show once a week
because I can take, you can take Monday, first draft,
Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday,
for each day gets better.
And then, I suppose there are some people
who can think in a way that I can't.
I mean, rappers can write songs as they speak.
They can rhyme as they speak. That's an amazing talent to me.
Some people can speak almost in marble prose, whereas I have to go over it.
Shakespeare must have done it actually because he produced so much and it all in in blank words. It must have come
totally naturally to him, I think.
Well, I mean he lives to be 64.
He wrote 37 plays.
Okay, so let's say he started a 20.
That's less than a play a year.
I don't...
Okay, yes, it's...
Put it in verse, it's quite...
It's quite...
But it's not all in verse.
Mostly.
Well, no, not the plays, the act of ends with a couplet. No, no, no
The it's it's blank versus it's not rhyming. It's only the couplet rhymes, but
The rest of you are the meter. Yes. Yes
Yeah, yeah, I can't do that
Well, I bet you you could.
Maybe.
Do you write your own stuff?
Well, I mean, I certainly am the head writer as far as that part of it goes, because I like
to, you know, I have to, has to be my voice exactly.
Make it word perfect.
But I have a wonderful, incredible staff who are amazingly supportive.
You know, I usually come up with whatever notion I want to do, but sometimes they do.
And then we all submit a draft and I go through and find stuff there that's brilliant and
steal it.
It's one of the great things about having a writing stamp.
It's like you're a legal thief of other people's ideas
and brilliance.
So it's not really right, but I'm not giving it up.
But okay, so this book is for kids.
Well, when I think it's between, yes.
But adults too.
And I think a lot of adults seem to enjoy it.
You don't have to sell this country on the idea of adults acting like kids.
I know. We do it every year.
Well, that must be a fascinating topic for kids air travel. Because they like kids
that automatically love planes or they have kite, they think that flies.
kids this automatically love planes or anything like that flies. Yes.
And the physics of it is the same for birds.
I mean, after all, physics is just physics.
And so if you want to stay up there, you've got to obey the laws of physics.
But they do it in a rather different way.
And planes have fixed wings and birds have mobile wings.
It's much more complicated, actually.
Well, I hope it's a huge hit for you.
There's a lot I want to prepare you.
There's a lot of kids in this country who are just really dumb.
So, you are not going to be able to hit the entire market.
But I always think that the people who are really smart,
like the top 1%, there's nothing you can do to kill
it.
Like you could have the worst education system in the world.
Somehow they will, that top 1% always finds a way to learn.
It's almost like us most of stuff, either sticks and gets on their radar.
Some people just lots of stuff sticks in there.
Some it all bounces off.
There's a lot of bouncing off here, but hopefully, yeah, and adults too.
I can't wait to get my hands on it.
I have all your books.
Oh, I wish I had, do we have a copy of it?
I should have brought one.
I don't think I have one with me.
Yeah.
I love to give you one.
That's so perfect for you.
You're a terrible salesman as you should be.
I mean, I'm a terrible salesman.
You're a genius.
You're a intellectual and you're a bad man. I'm a bad salesman. And I mean that in the best way. You are a genius, you're an intellectual, and you're a bad man.
I mean that the best way.
You are a terrible salesman.
Well, let me try to sell CFI to you and the things we do.
I'll try and be a salesman.
It is really, you don't have to sell me.
I'll be there.
It, okay, okay.
Okay.
Thank you. I got to do Sam now.
Okay.
So great to see you.
You look great from the sound, he's great.
I hope you enjoyed yourself and this wasn't too.
So, I'm very glad you're here.
Alright.
Alright.
Always a pleasure to meet you.
Love.
Render.
Render.
What's the pool table for?
That's for pool.
Recreation.
Of course.
Of course.