Dear Hank & John - 388: Turtle the Moon
Episode Date: May 1, 2024How could ping pong balls be considered a liquid? What do you mean "there's no free will"? What is toothpaste? What counts as a rare book? What is Applebees? What's the worst accent you got? What woul...d happen if Gamera hugged the moon? Hank and John Green have answers! If you're in need of dubious advice, email us at hankandjohn@gmail.com.Join us for monthly livestreams at patreon.com/dearhankandjohn.Follow us on Twitter! twitter.com/dearhankandjohn
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Hello and welcome to Dear Hank and John.
Or as I prefer to think of it, Dear John and Hank.
It's a podcast where two brothers answer your questions, give you dubious advice, and bring
you all the week's news from both Mars, the planet, and AFC Wimbledon, a soccer team.
John.
Yeah.
What do you get when you cross a turtle in a porcupine?
What do you get?
A slow poke.
Oh, slow poke. Yeah.
Maybe that's the one. Maybe that's what you need.
You just need them to be like cute and not trying that hard.
Maybe I need to be... First off, I think that also is what you get when you just have a porcupine.
I don't think porcupines are particularly fast, are they?
You have a thing called poke fast.
Oh, I see.
Okay.
Well, a couple things are happening, Hank, that I need to talk about.
Oh my gosh.
We're going to, what is, okay.
One is that the Turtles All the Way Down movie, the movie adaptation of my book, Turtles All
the Way Down, comes out.
Is that why I did a turtle joke?
Yes.
I assumed.
Was it a complete coincidence?
I feel like it must be. JL Yes, I assumed. Was it a complete coincidence?
AC No, I was looking at turtle jokes specifically,
so there must have been a reason.
JL Yeah, I think that must have been the reason.
In your heart of hearts, you knew that I'm feverishly promoting the Turtles All the Way
Down movie nonstop, both when I'm awake and when I sleep. By the way, I've been having
horrible nightmares, I have to tell you about one. But the other thing is that, so the Turtles All the Way Down movie comes out May 2nd on
Max. I really hope you like it. We got to show it to 1600 people at the LA Times Festival of Books
and it was magical, Hank. That room was amazing. It really confirmed my opinion that the movie is
really good. I hope that you're able to watch it. And I also hope that you're able to watch it with family and
friends. Like it's just, I think it's best experienced with people you love. And I know
that HBO Max doesn't want me to say that because it lowers the number of logins,
but like that's how I feel. I mean, we should do that more. I love to have friends over for a movie.
And then while you're there, you can, you can celebrate the Turtles All the Way Down
movie.
There you go.
Did you just say celebrate?
I did, because turtles have shells.
I noticed that.
I just want you to know I noticed that.
The other thing is that I have a new podcast that just came out with Dr. Katie Mack.
She's an astrophysicist and I'm an idiot.
The two of us have made a podcast called Crash Course Pods, the universe, which is a crash
course on the entire history and future of this, the one universe we all belong to, to
borrow a line from Mary Oliver.
You should check that out.
You might even call it a tortorial.
Oh, God.
It's a tortorial.
Yes, Hank, thank you.
How do you do this over and over again?
What is it like to live in your brain where the highest form of thought is pun?
Anyway, it's a really good podcast.
I love it.
It is.
I'm very excited.
And you should check it out wherever you get your podcasts.
Stop listening to this piece of crap and go listen to Crash Course in the Universe.
Oh, John, do you know what your favorite pasta is?
What is my favorite pasta, Hank?
Turtellini.
Oh, of course it's turtellini.
What else could it be?
Oh, I feel like I've run a marathon
and I've just been told, so I've been traveling nonstop.
I just got home and I leave again tomorrow morning
at 4.30 a.m.
And I just, I feel like I've run a marathon
and at the end of the marathon,
instead of seeing the finish line,
somebody whispered in my ear, just 20 miles to go, buddy.
Well, you know what, John, slow and steady wins the race.
Oh, jeez.
It's true, the tortoise does emerge ahead of the hare in the long run.
All right. Let's answer some questions from our listeners.
All right. This first question comes from Peter, and I don't know how I'm going to answer it,
but I'm going to try how big of a container would I have to have for the ping pong balls
inside to be considered a liquid?
If a giant alien went swimming in a galaxy sized pool of ping pong balls, is that a liquid? Thank you Peter
What you got John? I assume not. I mean, it's a different state of matter
Yeah, so so I think like like the high school definition of a liquid is anything that, any substance
that can take the shape of its container.
Okay.
And so you look and you're like,
ping pong balls are kind of a liquid,
but they're also definitely not a liquid.
If there were enough ping pong balls,
they would basically take the shape of their container.
They can act as a liquid.
If you have a lot of ping pong balls,
you can observe that they do fluid dynamics stuff.
They like pass over each other,
they roll around and they create drag
and like you can model them as if they are molecules,
which is like the weird part
that like little water molecules are like little balls. They don't look like little balls to us. They look like water water molecules are like little balls.
They don't look like little balls to us.
They look like water, but they're little balls.
And so a ping pong ball with a giant in it, ping pong ball galaxy sized swimming pool
with a giant in it is acting like just a regular lake with a boat in it.
But still the ping pong balls will molecularly be a solid.
Okay.
So solids can act as liquids.
There's two definitions of liquid
and that's how you're getting your way out of this question.
Yeah, I guess what I should say is like a solid can act
as a fluid, but it's never a liquid.
You know what is weird to me about this whole thing
is that this all presupposes that galaxies are real
and that the universe is full of these things.
And the truth is that the earth is the only
actual heavenly body and it's a flat plane
resting on the back of a giant turtle.
Yeah, what is the turtle on? Oh, thanks for asking, Hank. The turtle is resting on a giant turtle. Oh, yeah. What is the turtle on?
Oh, thanks for asking, Hank. The turtle is resting on yet another turtle.
Well, what's under that turtle?
No, you don't understand, Hank. It's turtles all the way down.
This next question comes from Rebecca, who asks,
Hey guys, just a quick clarification about episode 386. Blame me some more fiddle.
What do you guys mean there's no free will?
Do you guys know something I don't?
Are my choices not mine?
Thanks, bye Rebecca.
Actually, Rebecca, if you're interested in this question,
and I hate to keep going back to this,
but you should really read the hit YA book,
Turtles All the Way Down,
which is concerned so much with free will
that the epigraph of the novel is from Schopenhauer, man can do what he wills, but he cannot will what
he wills. And to me, that is the ultimate solution to free will. Yeah, you can make whatever choices
you can make, but you can't will what you will. You can't choose what you're choosing.
I mean, my own experience of this, Rebecca,
is that there are many times
when I do not get to choose my thoughts
and many times when I do not get to choose my behaviors.
And ergo, not only that,
a lot of the thinking that I'm doing
is actually being done by the bacteria that colonize me.
They don't just tell me when to be hungry,
but also it seems tell me when
I feel sad.
They don't think for you, but they might make you feel sad sometimes.
They affect my thoughts, and that is thinking on my behalf. If you are affecting my thoughts,
it's complicated, but they aren't. I don't think that you can say that you're doing entirely
your own thinking when you're thinking if half of the cells that constitute you are not yours.
I think it is, yeah, like my thinking is affected by many things, including random chance.
But I think that we, like, look, I think that I can make choices. I think I do make choices, but I think that you're right. I cannot really, I don't know how to change how I,
I don't really know how to change what I want.
And like, that's tricky.
But also I sometimes I feel like I have changed how I want,
but not like the way that,
not like through making a decision,
usually by taking an action and
by putting myself in a different situation. But anyway, even with all of that, the question
of free will remains like, is the universe just sort of like the pieces were set in motion
and now they are falling down the hill and we are just part of them falling down the
hill and all of our decisions are just sort of inevitably decided by the preconditions of the beginning of the universe.
And like maybe the reigning philosophical perspective
at the moment seems to be
that we don't really have free will,
but the sensation that I feel is that I do.
Yeah, this is actually something that we get into
that Dr. Mack and I get into in Crash Course
the Universe because you're exactly right. I'm sorry, but it's like half the podcast is about
this because we're trying to understand. I hate to do all this promo. It causes me physical pain.
Just kidding. I love it. But if the first thing was decided and everything else has happened as a direct result of that
first thing and all of that is predetermined, then it is hard to argue that like, oh, but
we're not predetermined. And so this is something that I keep running up against in recording with
Dr. Mack is that I want to hear that I have some semblance of free will and I want some kind of cosmological
proof of this and it just doesn't seem like it's going to emerge. I think instead what we have is
that it doesn't really matter whether we have free will in that grand universal sense of everything
was determined at the very beginning and has been rolling downhill since then. What we do have is the experience of choice.
It's important to remember though that in celebrating the experience of choice that
we have, that our choices are endlessly limited and that our choices are limited by everything
from outside forces to interior experiences and that judging people
for what you perceive as their choices
might be a little bit unfair
given how much their choices are in truth restricted.
This next question comes from Joshua
who asks Dear Hank and John,
what is toothpaste, tasty soap,
turtles and toothbrushes, Joshua?
Oh.
Hmm. This is, I feel like this is secret knowledge Turtles and toothbrushes, Joshua. Oh.
This is, I feel like this is secret knowledge that toothpaste industry doesn't want people to know.
What is toothpaste?
Now let me answer before you tell me what toothpaste is.
Let me make a guess.
Toothpaste is fluoride.
Okay, yeah, yeah.
And soap.
Uh-huh.
And flavoring.
Yeah, there's other components,
but that's the most important one that you missed is polish.
Polish.
So there is very fine grit in toothpaste
that actually is designed to not be harder than your teeth, Polish. So there is a very fine grit in toothpaste
that actually is designed to not be harder than your teeth,
but to be harder than the stuff on your teeth
so that it can polish that tartar and stuff away.
So yeah, toothpaste is primarily tasty soap.
It is a surfactant, which is what soaps are.
That's why it gets foamy in your mouth.
And I kind of wish I didn't know this,
so I feel bad telling you.
But it's tasty.
So like we figured out how to make tasty soap.
It cleans the inside of your mouth.
It's weird, but that is the case.
And then also sometimes in addition to there being polish
and soap and flavorings, you know, there's fluoride,
which we have added because it strengthens the enamel.
And then there's also other stuff.
Like there might be some whitening compounds in there
or there might be like the stuff
for sensitive teeth, et cetera.
Right. Yeah.
Toothpaste is primarily tasty soap slash tasty polish.
So when we were kids and mom was like,
if you say that word again,
I'm gonna wash your mouth out with soap. Like she, what we didn't know was that actually we were washing our mouth out
with soap every night. Well, first of all, I don't remember that ever having happened. So I want to
say that on behalf of our mother. I honestly feel like we were raised in different households.
I, I, I, I, you didn't ever, you didn't ever taste soap.
Did you ever get soap in your mouth?
No, no, no, just the threat though.
Just the threat of it was plenty intimidating.
The threat person certainly may have happened.
Yeah, I mean, I think I might have said that-
That's the kind of thing I would forget about
and you wouldn't.
That's so true.
That's so true.
The axe forgets what the tree remembers Hank.
But that's not down to our choices, John. That's just how we are as people.
That's right. That's right. And I was like Lady Gaga, born this way.
Yeah. That's what I always tell my Pilates instructor when she's like,
why can't you stretch more than that? Yeah, I know. My hamstrings were just,
God made them like this. He was like,
He was like, you don't get those.
God set the universe in motion and as a direct result of that initial nudge, I have tight
hamstrings. The particular protons inside of me that are left over from the Big Bang
organized themselves into extremely tight hamstrings. And that's just the way that it was always going to go.
Why did God do it that way? If I knew, I would be terrified. I would be a monster. I would
be a prophet. I would be Paul-a-traities.
Oh God, don't bring up Paul-a-traities. I love the fact that the first prophet that comes to your mind is Pauletraites, not Jesus or Mohammed or Moses.
All the real ones, you can't say that they're bad.
Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh,
oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh,
oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh,
oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh,
oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh,
oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh,
oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh,
oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, horror that accompanies such knowledge. Prophecy, yes.
Yeah.
Yes.
No, fair enough.
All right.
Fair enough.
Let's answer another question.
Was that one still about toothpaste?
Yeah.
Now we were still on toothpaste, believe it or not.
I don't know how we got there.
We're real focused on the universe being set in motion and then ever forever after things
just were as they are. Annie writes,
Dear John and Hank, I recently visited an independent bookstore that had a rare book
room and in that rare book room I found a signed first edition of Turtles All the Way Down on sale
for $35. The signature was not unique. It was a black sharpie, no drawing, no DFTBA. I love the
idea that if there's a little Hank or fish on it, then it's worth 35 bucks, but otherwise, nothing
special.
I asked if John had visited to personally sign the book and he had not.
This led me to wonder, are there universal standards for what booksellers can include
in their rare book room?
Does rare mean the same thing to every bookseller?
Because I happen to know there are 250,000 such signed copies of Turtles all the way
down.
By my own count, I own at least
five things that have been signed by a Green Brother, including a plastic turtle that I
raised some teenagers through a Bi-Lo parking lot for in 2018. Am I a rare book collector?
Thanks so much, Annie. Remember when we signed those plastic turtles and then we would like
hide them and take pictures of them almost like a geocache
and people would have to try to find them?
Yes, I had forgotten about it until now.
Yeah, that was fun, man.
We have lived so many lives.
We should go on tour again.
I know, whoever set the universe in motion
really did us some favors.
Yeah.
We've lived a lot of lives.
We've gotten to do some fun stuff over the years.
For sure, for sure.
And shout out to everybody who has one of those turtles.
Yeah, I know that all of you still
are hardcore nerd fighters 10 years later.
I'm so glad you have Five Things Signed
by a Green Brother, Annie.
I think that you do have a rare book
and plastic turtle collection.
The truth is no, there are no rules, there are no reasons, there is nothing to stop them from selling that book for $70
if they can get a buyer for it. That said, $35 isn't that unreasonable a price given
that the book itself was like $23. And if it's in good condition and it hasn't been
read and it's, you know, I could see a justification for that price tag, even if there's 250,000
signed first editions out there.
Well, the thing to know is that this is all about
the market and the information that the people
who make up the market have access to.
And you have access to the information
that John did this 250,000 times,
but the bookseller might not.
And so it was just like put it in there and it's like,
oh, this is a signed one, the signed one goes in this room and it gets this, you know, this the bookseller might not. And so it was just like, put it in there and it's like, oh, this is a signed one.
The signed one goes in this room and it gets this,
you know, this much markup or whatever,
or I'll look on eBay and see what they're selling for.
The, but like you are-
You know what they're selling for on eBay?
What?
Five bucks.
Well, they didn't look on eBay then,
or they did and they were like,
Or they did and they were like,
I think I could get more than that for it.
I could probably get 35.
I've got to pay rent.
Maybe I should buy some of these signed first editions
of Turtles All the Way Down.
I don't have any and they're only five bucks.
It's the shipping, man.
If you could get them all at once.
How much is the shipping?
Like four bucks.
It's always, no, I don't know.
You think that's how they get you?
I don't know.
I think, well, I think that that dramatically influences
the, your ability to get them all.
But Annie, what you, the situation you find yourself in
is that you have access to all of this information.
So now you are like the antiques road show appraiser,
but for John and Hank Green signed things.
And you can sit down at the antiques road show
and somebody brings up a Turtles all the way down
signed by John Green and you can be like this,
the reason why this is worth nothing is,
and then you can tell the whole story
of how John Green got obsessed with signing his name
more times than any.
There will be, I will hear people talk about
like signing a book hundreds of times
and they'll be like, I just couldn't do it anymore.
So inconvenient.
And I'm like, where am I?
What world are you in?
Well, maybe they have more complicated signatures
than I do, that's the hermeneutic of generosity
I try to share with myself.
Sure, sure.
There's one, okay, so there's one that's $83.60.
That's the 199,973rd signature on my way to 200,000.
Does it have to do write that?
Yeah, yeah, yeah, I wrote that beneath the thing.
Well, that seems like it could be valuable.
There's one that's like 85 bucks that has a hankerfish.
So you're right, the hankerfish
is significantly more valuable. But these are not things that people have bought. They're just things that people are
charging a lot for. So anyway, my signature is worth somewhere between negative $10 and $20.
Oh, look at the signed first edition of The Fault in Our Stars, 30 bucks, 19 bucks, nine bucks.
Nine bucks, that seems reasonable.
Yeah, okay.
Nine bucks for a signed first edition of The Fault in Our Stars.
I mean, there's 150,000 of them.
What are they worth?
It's been 14 years.
They're worth nine bucks.
Yeah, and that's what we want.
Long story short, hold on to your signed first edition of The Fault in Our Stars,
not because it's valuable,
but because you can't get anything for it on eBay anyway.
Oh, this signed by Shailene Woodley Fault in Our Stars
script is worth $300.
I have one of those.
Or best offer.
Oh, or best offer.
That's how they get you.
This next question is from Nola,
who asks, Dear Hank and John, but mostly John, I was rereading Turtles All the Way Down and I
live in Canada. So what the heck is Applebee's? Thanks, Nola.
What is an Applebee's? An Applebee's is a sit down restaurant where you have a server and you can
buy alcoholic drinks. So that distinguishes it from say a McDonald's, but it's also not a super high-end fine dining
restaurant where all the entrees are like $30 a piece or whatever.
And so it inhabits that middle space.
So I'm going to try to go Canadian on you.
It's not a Tim Hortons, but it's also not a fancy Canadian restaurant.
It's in the middle.
Do you know that there's an Applebee's in China?
I'm not surprised.
I'm not surprised.
I once went to one in London.
Do you know that Applebee's was originally a pharmacy?
No way, seriously, is that real?
Are you tricking me?
TJ Applebee's prescriptions, edibles and elixirs
in Decatur, Georgia.
What, are you serious? Edibles and elixirs in Decatur, Georgia. What?
Are you serious?
Edibles and elixirs?
That sounds like they sold the real stuff.
Yeah, this was also 1980s, so I don't know.
Wait, one-
It's like in between when edibles and elixirs
were like a thing that people actually did
and when they were just weed.
Wait, 1980? Like 1980?
No way. It was a pharmacy in 1980.
And then within like a decade, it became the world's leading fast,
casual dining restaurant.
Yeah, yeah. In 1986, by 1986, it was Applebee's neighborhood
Grill and Bar. Wow.
What a journey T.J TJ Applebee went on.
Well, he sold it in between those times.
I think, I don't know.
Where does that word Applebee comes from?
I've never heard of it.
No, TJ Applebee is a person, right?
No, his name was TJ Palmer.
Oh, he just, he named it Applebee's.
The way that some, maybe that was his nickname in high school.
People were like Applebee. Yeah.
Maybe he got bit by a bee while eating an apple and he was forever after known as TJ Applebee.
That would be great.
But it seems like it's one of these Matchbox 20 situations where it's just terribly boring.
And they just sort of like looked in the phone book
for a while and came up with a name.
That's disappointing.
Is that Matchbox 20 got their name
because they just thought it sounded good?
I can't tell you, it's too boring.
It would make people's lives worse.
Okay, fair enough, fair enough.
I believe that anything is interesting
if you pay the
right kind of attention to it, but maybe the name of Matchbox 20 is an exception. I don't
know if I could write a whole episode of the Anthropocene reviewed on it, but I'd be willing
to try.
Look, maybe Matchbox 20 got named in an Applebee's and that makes it interesting.
All right. So that's Applebee's. It's really good. It's prominently featured in the Turtles All the Way Down movie.
It really is.
There's quite a lot of Applebee's in it.
And you know, the waitress in the Applebee's
is played by our director, Hannah Marks.
Oh!
She's like Quentin Tarantino. Amazing.
She gave herself a little role.
Quentin Tarantino's a weird pull for that one.
Isn't that like famously the Hitchcock thing?
Yeah, but I just feel like Hitchcock often just gives himself a little cameo.
She got a real role. Oh, OK.
Which reminds me, John, that this podcast is brought to you by Applebee's
as if you didn't already do enough work for them already.
We've just given them a free sponsorship
and the fake sponsor is part of our podcast.
I do really appreciate how cool they were about us making a couple Applebee's jokes.
They were reasonably self-aware about Applebee's, which is great.
Situation re Applebee's.
It's a good restaurant.
I go there Applebee's.
Is it a great? No.
Today's podcast is also brought to you by the Rare Books Room where my signed books are $35.
That Rare Books Room, I mean, a little bit of a markup, but you know.
Everybody's trying to make it work.
This podcast is also brought to you by a galaxy-sized swimming pool
full of ping pong balls.
Sure.
Not a liquid.
No. Well, except maybe.
A fluid. And of Well, except maybe.
A fluid.
And, of course, this podcast is brought to you by The Universe.
The Universe.
Determined?
Ahhhhh.
All right, we also have some Project for Awesome messages to read, including this one from
Marinda to Ellie and Ed.
Dear Honkin' John, this message comes to you in three parts.
One, today I learned that bees have five eyes.
Wild. Two, the passage of time. A friend said, why not? Time continues. How
wonderful and how terrifying. Three, hope perseveres and I am in love with living. I'm
lucky enough now that I can afford the luxury of spending all my birthdays in dandelions,
wishing the same for others. So lovely, Marinda. Thank you. And also we have a message from
Krista who wants to write to Nerdfighteria.
Every year when we come together to the P4A,
I am reminded that I am a small part of a greater whole.
This community is the place I go to
when hope is difficult to come by.
My song without the words, if you will.
Thank you all for being a part of Nerdfighteria with me,
DFTBA.
That's so lovely, Krista.
Hell yeah.
I've been reading through the Nerdfighteria census, which went out.
If you have not filled it out, you can go fill it out.
There's a link in the description of my most recent Vlogbrothers video, or not my most
recent one.
But there's, look, I'll put it in the most recent one as well.
Take that, because I haven't done it yet.
But the, it's just, it's always so lovely to read
through the census and to hear people's thoughts on all the things that we've done and to see how
the community continues to change and how we respond to the world being this world.
And I'm so grateful to everybody who spends a little bit of time filling it out and also
writing little messages so that we know what you're thinking.
It's a great thing to be a part of.
And a lot of the things that I've heard is like that people really like it when we act
as a community together and we do that in a lot of different ways.
And so I wanna have ideas, we have ideas for how to keep doing it in the future.
Yeah. Yeah. It always makes me think of the fact that a lot of attention goes to the leaders of
a community, especially like in online communities that resemble fandoms. A lot of the attention goes to Taylor Swift or whoever or Hank and John. But the truth is that the community accomplishes
things that have very little to do with that creator. And most of what they accomplish together
isn't about the creator and it certainly doesn't come from the creator.
The community accomplishes stuff together and what we really are, if we're lucky Hank and me, is parts of Nerdfighteria,
not leaders of Nerdfighteria.
Alright Hank, let's answer some more questions before we get to the all-important news from Mars and AFC Wimbledon, beginning with this one from Anonymous who writes, Dear John and Hank, John I've read all your books. When I first read Turtles All the Way Down quite a few years ago, I found it a fascinating
read.
However, after watching the trailer for the film adaptation, the story has taken on a
much deeper meaning because my partner of three and a half years has OCD and has been
going through a particularly tough period over the last year, particularly with relationship-oriented
OCD.
And so I found myself sobbing after watching the trailer.
I think I'm so moved because it gives voice to the pain we both experience from the strain OCD puts on our life together, though naturally more her than me,
and it gives me hope that the story will highlight to society just how truly debilitating living with
OCD can be while also offering hope to people like my amazing girlfriend. I just wanted to read that,
Hank, because it means a lot to me. As we go into this experience, I just needed to be reminded that
to read that, Hank, because it means a lot to me. And as we go into this experience, I just needed to be reminded that as overwhelming as this is and everything,
I'm ultimately doing it because of that, because I think this story matters and can matter to
people. And I wouldn't be pushing so hard myself and also nice people who work with me if I didn't really think that it could
be a useful thing in the world.
There's a lot of debate over whether art needs to be useful to be good and I don't know exactly
where I sit on that debate, but I do know that I like it more personally to make art
that can be useful to people and I really hope that this is a movie that can help people
in the way that so many people
have told me the book did.
So I just wanted to read that and just kind of be reminded of why I'm doing what I'm going
to have to do over the next couple of weeks.
Yeah.
Yeah.
This next question comes from Marie who says, hello Hank and John, that's not a Danish accent.
In Kielsen, Marie. Hank, what is your Danish accent?
Tell me in a Danish accent how excited you are to see the Turtles All the Way Down movie
on May 2nd.
No, I will not do this.
I cannot do Dutch.
I do German instead.
That's all I can do.
First off, you can do Dutch.
It's not even good to German.
It's not particularly good German, but it's definitely I can do. First off, you can do Dutch. It's not even good to German.
It's not German, too.
It's not particularly good German,
but it's definitely not Danish,
which is definitely different from Dutch.
Did I say Dutch?
You did.
You did, so here. Well, look.
I'll give you all-
It's not my fault.
Where is Danish from?
Denmark.
Which does not start with the syllable Dane.
Where is Dutch from?
Dutchland? The Netherlands, which does not start with the syllable Dane. Where is Dutch from? Dutchland?
The Netherlands, which does not start with Dutch.
It's not my fault.
All right, I'm gonna do all three.
All right, I'm gonna do all three, Hank.
Are you ready?
So this is just a kind of a tutorial for you
for people who maybe aren't experts
in Northern European accents.
I'm gonna just help you through them.
This is German.
Ja, ja, wie it prezels, ja? Wie it prezels, ja. experts in northern european accents i'm gonna just help you through them this is german
look no one will judge you for skipping through this part of the podcast all right but continue john that was german this is dutch
it's very nice here yeah it's very nice i like it yeah and then thank, it's very nice here. Yeah, it's very nice. I like it.
Yeah, and the thank you.
Very good, very nice.
That seems right to me.
Seems right to me, man.
And this is Danish.
Ready?
Hold on.
It's gonna take me a second.
I gotta get in character.
I gotta grow by six inches.
I'm six foot six.
I'm blonde.
I'm maybe like, I think I work in private finance. Hello. Hello, yeah. Over the next six weeks,
we will look at these problems and we will try to get some problems solved for you.
That does sound like the last one, but okay. Those are my three accents.
I got three looks and that's it.
Shorten that as much as you can, Tuna.
Can we look at the way the English has named languages?
Sure.
If you are from Italy, what do you speak?
Italiano.
Oh my God, no, in English.
Italian. Oh my God, no, in English. Italian?
Oh my God, look, I'm trying to do something here.
Keep going, keep going.
If you're from Sweden, do you speak Swedenian?
No, you speak a Swedish.
Oh my God, I don't know if I can do this.
Swedish? No, that's better.
And if you're from France, do you speak- Wait, let me do it again, just one more time. Wait, if you're from France, do you speak-
Wait, let me do it again. Do it one more time.
Wait, if you're from Sweden, give me Sweden.
And if you're from Sweden, do you speak Swedenian?
No, you speak Swedish?
Okay, this is great. I don't know if we can continue, but I will.
No, we're offending everyone. This is great. This is, we're working our way through the only accents
we're allowed to butcher. Now give me one more.
Du France.
I just don't know why we could...
What about, and if you're from France, do you speak Francish?
Eh, I don't know. I don't know what you speak.
If you're from France, I just know that...
I just know that, uh, I just, we, yeah, we speak French.
The, I mean, the part where no matter what accent you're doing,
the character you're playing is just like, no, yes, no!
That's all I can say in these foreign languages.
We, no, oui, un peu.
Yes, si, wah, ha ha.
Yeah.
Ha ha ha.
Ha ha ha.
I can laugh, I can laugh in all those languages.
All right, now do American laugh?
Yeah.
Yeah.
Great, that's perfect.
That seems right.
Can you do a Dutch laugh?
They don't laugh.
That's a great joke.
Dutch people everywhere just burst out laughing.
All right.
John. Yeah.
Abby asks, dear Hank and John,
before we completely lose everyone,
dear Hank and John, I had a dream last night
that a massive turtle came from space,
another space turtle, John,
and attached itself to the moon,
and then it took the moon out of our orbit.
My question is, what would happen
if a turtle or any object the size of the moon
became attached to the moon?
Turtly curious, turtly curious.
Turtly curious.
It wouldn't be great, Abby.
No, it depends on what actually happened.
Like, did it smack into the moon?
Then definitely bad.
If a moon-sized object smashed into the moon,
that would be objectively bad.
And there is no other way.
So your other argument is that this moon sized object somehow like
gently attaches itself to the moon.
Yeah, I'm just imagining like a moon sized piece of slime,
you know, from your kid's slime.
OK. And it just like bloop.
After hurtling through space, it somehow doesn't smash into the moon. It just sort of sidles up. Yeah. OK. Okay. And it just like, bloop. After hurtling through space, it somehow doesn't smash into the moon. It just sidles up to the moon.
Yeah. Okay. Yeah. So imagine the turtle from the
Godzilla movies, Gamera. And Gamera is, he's up there and he's the size of the moon and he's like,
I love that thing. I'm gonna live there. And he gives the moon a big hug and he just sort of hangs out.
In that case, things would change.
So tides obviously would get stronger,
which would be very bad for anyone living on the coast.
It would also be very bad for coastal ecosystems
that are not designed for tides to be twice as strong
as they currently are.
There would probably be some amount of long-term changes to...
But I think that long-term, my guess is,
long-term enough that it would not affect us
to the length of the day
and also the distance of the moon from the Earth.
But I think that that would probably happen slow enough
that that wouldn't be a big deal in the next few thousand
years, which is most of the scale that we think on.
I think that the big concern would probably just be the tides,
but I might be wrong.
I'm curious to hear if anybody else,
if you submit your thoughts on this, what am I missing
that might really mess things up if the moon became suddenly
much more massive.
Now, I know that if the moon ceased to exist,
we would have a massive problem, like-
Yeah.
Pun intended.
Because the Earth's tilt would increase really dramatically.
So we would have these like ice ages in some places.
We would be way wobblier, yeah.
We'd be wobblier.
And if the moon were bigger, we would be less wobbly.
So we might actually get fewer climate variations
from wobbles, though we have another sort of
climate variation we have to deal with right now.
I would not be helped by that.
Right, it wouldn't solve, so we couldn't solve climate,
that's what I was gonna ask you,
is can we solve climate change with a bigger moon?
No, I mean, honestly, if there's a giant space turtle,
I feel like he's going to have just advice.
Oh, God, can you imagine help?
Yeah. And then just the mass.
Yeah. Can you imagine him like shouting?
It would be really loud shouting from the moon.
Just like, hey, guys, I don't want to come down there
because I know that I would mess things up if I got any closer.
But like, you need to work some stuff out.
Y'all need to collaborate more effectively and build systems that include more people.
Yeah.
Why are you creating outs...
Why are you so obsessed with creating outsiders?
Yeah.
Like obviously there's a great deal of untapped potential down there.
Usually to provide resources for more folks.
Like those are the folks that could be solving the problems.
You're stifling the number of potential future innovators you have by not giving people educational
opportunities and treating some people like they're more special than other people.
That's very weird from the perspective of this one turtle. That's not how we do things
at all where I come from, though I will say that my planet has to be so big
for there to be an organism the size of me,
that likely there aren't that many of us
and we move very slowly and make decisions
on a very long time scale,
which I understand probably is difficult
for you little wet soft ant things.
You know what that giant space turtle would also say?
Yeah.
He'd be like, you're being really cool to your turtles, right?
Like...
How cool are you being to the turtles?
You better be cool to those turtles if you catch my drift.
John, can we... I know that you're busy.
Yeah.
And maybe we should, because you're so busy,
we should turn this to're busy. Yeah. And maybe we, because you're so busy, we should turn this to the community.
Yeah.
Can we write some kind of space turtle zine?
I love it. Just real fast.
I love it, real fast.
This week.
People send me, first of all,
send me your drawings of your space turtles.
If you made it through the accent portion of the program
to get to this portion of the program.
Your reward is that you can contribute
to our hit new charity zine, Space Turtle.
Right, so you can either submit,
and you can do this twice, but not together.
So it's gonna be like a game where we're gonna pair
captions with space turtles.
So we need people to draw space turtles
and we need people to send in captions.
And then we're gonna match the caption to the space turtle.
And the caption is like whatever the space turtle
is thinking or saying.
Right, what is the space turtle saying
to the people of earth?
And then what does the space turtle look like
sidled up to the moon?
Yeah, yeah.
These are the questions we have for you. And we need you to email us at hankandjohn
at gmail.com with the subject line space turtle.
Yes.
Hank, you've made a major discovery. You were just talking about how as a community,
we need more projects, and then you found our most important project of all, space turtle zine.
and that you found our most important project of all, space turtles, Ian.
Forget about bullying large corporations
into reducing their price of their tuberculosis tests.
Now we're onto something.
There's a, first of all, we're not bullying,
we're asking respectfully and nicely.
Second, I can't wait to show off all the space turtles
in our, we're here, the newsletter of Nerdfighteria, which you could sign up for by searching for that, I can't wait to show off all the space turtles in our... We're here! The newsletter of Nerdfighteria,
which you can sign up for by searching for that, I guess.
But also, maybe I'll make a video with it.
We can review them on the next episode of the pod.
I really hope we get some space turtles.
We might not get any.
In which case, I will be sad.
But I'll be feverishly drawing my own to make up for it.
All right, so listen, we got to get to the all important news
from Mars and AFC Wimbledon because I have a meeting.
Yes.
And the news from AFC Wimbledon
is both brilliant and terrible.
I'll start with the terrible news.
AFC Wimbledon's men's team, their season is over.
They still have two games left to play technically,
but they don't matter because we can't make the playoffs
and we can't get relegated.
Now, in a way, if you told me at the beginning of the season,
we were gonna have two stress-free games,
I would have been like, that's wonderful,
thank you so much.
Yeah, because there were some times
when we didn't have any of those.
Exactly, many years where we have no stress-free games
because we're facing relegation until the last day
and then sometimes we do get relegated.
So yeah, it's great. We had a successful season, but it's a little bit of a bummer. However,
however, the women's team who wear Partners in Health on the back of their jerseys sponsored by
Rosianna and myself just won their division, which means they also, in addition to winning the trophy get promoted which means
also that they will next year be a third tier English football team. Incredibly exciting.
Wow!
For so many years the women have finished second in their league. They're up against big teams like
QPR and Norwich. Norwich might be in the Premier League next year, the men's team, but the women's
team got beat by AFC Wimbledon.
And so AFC Wimbledon's women's team, an incredible group of women who, many of them
have been playing together for many years.
It's just really remarkable what they've managed to achieve.
They finally have the financial support to be successful, and so they have been successful.
And it's awesome, awesome to see.
And so I'm so excited for the
promoted women's team. And by the way, if you live in London on May 5th, so just a few days after this
podcast comes out, you can see the final women's game of the season at Plough Lane, celebrate the
champions. It's going to be like a packed house. It's gonna be awesome. So, and it's only like five pounds to get in.
So the transit might cost you more than the game.
If you're under 18, it's actually free.
So check that out at just Google AFC Wimbledon Women's Team.
All right.
That's so cool.
What's the news from Mars?
Well, sample return is the thing that we want to do.
Right.
The Rover's perseverance has been dropping these vials for maybe some future mission
to come pick them up and take them back so that we can study these rocks here on Earth
where we have whole labs and not just one robot car.
This is tricky and difficult, and NASA was going to send that and they were designing the
mission. And the European Space Agency was going to build some of the stuff and there was a whole
thing. In 2020, there was a report that estimated the cost of this to be between like three and $4 billion-ish.
It's now estimated that mission would cost
8.4 to $10.9 billion,
which everybody's like,
actually we love rocks so much,
but not maybe that much.
Last fall, an independent review board
said the mission would need to be overhauled.
And in the past few weeks,
NASA has announced that they're looking at proposals
to help make that mission faster and cheaper. So the good news is that for now, need to be overhauled. And in the past few weeks, NASA has announced that they're looking at proposals
to help make that mission faster and cheaper.
So the good news is that for now,
NASA is looking to continue with the mission.
It's just not clear what that mission is gonna look like
or how they're gonna do it.
Because, yeah, there's some price sensitivity.
Inflation obviously happened, but not that much.
And these things don't tend to come in on budget either.
So.
Well, I mean, that's a bummer.
It feels like we just said send people at this point
and maybe sometime in the next couple of years,
if at all possible.
Just send people to retrieve those rocks by 2027.
I tell you what, that seemed like such a long way away when we made that bet.
I know.
I know.
And now, what do you think?
Do you think 2040 is realistic?
For humans on Mars?
Yeah.
No?
No. Oh, it's really a story of Hank and John going from being excessively optimistic to relentlessly
determined to remain optimistic.
Yeah, no, I mean, look, things could certainly happen.
It's just very hard. We've learned more about Mars in the
last 10 years that has made the prospect of people going to Mars harder. And so it hasn't
gotten easier in the last 10 years. It's gotten harder because we understand more about Mars and
how what it's made of and how hazardous that stuff is to people.
So it's tricky.
Well, Hank, I still believe
that we're gonna live to see it
and I can't wait to live to see it.
So I haven't given up that hope,
even if I have and I hope you have as well
given up all hope that this podcast
will always be called Dear Hank and John.
I have.
I have.
All right, Hank. Well, thank you for podding with me.
Thanks to everybody for listening.
We look forward to your space turtles.
Oh, gosh.
I'm going to draw a line right now.
It doesn't have to be good.
No.
It should be bad.
Or it can be good.
It's up to you.
Okay.
Read the credits.
Oh, of course.
That's my job.
This podcast is edited by Joseph Tuna-Medich.
It's produced by Rosianna Hals-Rojas.
Our communications coordinator is Brooke Shotwell.
Our editorial assistant is Debuki Chakravarti.
The music you're hearing now and at the beginning of the podcast is by The Great Gunnarolla.
And as they say in our hometown, don't forget to be awesome.