Good Inside with Dr. Becky - Deep Dive: Gentle Parenting, Race, and Cycle Breaking With Kobe and Kyle Campbell
Episode Date: October 5, 2021How do you raise your children differently than you were raised? For trauma therapist Kobe and her husband Kyle, this question isn't just about breaking cycles. It's about healing generational trauma,... too. In this episode, Dr. Becky talks with the couple about their gentle parenting journey—and the important questions they've raised along the way about how this approach applies to their Black children. Their conversation often asks more than it answers, encouraging all of us to reflect on race, cycle breaking, and the generational influence of our parenting choices today. Join Good Inside Membership: https://bit.ly/3cqgG2A Follow Dr. Becky on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/drbeckyatgoodinside Sign up for our weekly email, Good Insider: https://www.goodinside.com/newsletter Order Dr. Becky's book, Good Inside: A Guide to Becoming the Parent You Want to Be, at goodinside.com/book or wherever you order your books. For a full transcript of the episode, go to goodinside.com/podcast
Transcript
Discussion (0)
You're listening to Good Inside with Dr. Becky.
I have so many ideas, strategies, and scripts to share with you right after a word from our
sponsor.
Hey, Sabrina.
Hey.
So, I've been thinking about toys recently.
I don't want the toy to do that much of the work.
I want the toy to inspire my kid to do the work
because actually the toys that get really busy
and do a lot of things, kids actually lose interest
and so quickly.
Oh, totally.
There's certain toys that my kids have just played with
throughout the years.
I have a six year old and a three year old.
Like what?
So I have these wooden blocks from Melissa and Doug.
They're super simple.
Just plain wooden, no color.
And my kids love them.
They're always building castles or like a dinosaur layer.
And then my oldest will tell my youngest to like decorate them
after he's built this crazy cool structure.
My go-to's are Melissa and Doug too.
I feel like we have this ice cream scooper thing
that my kids use when they were two.
And then they used again when they were developing
better fine motor skills.
And then for my kind of four year old,
my seven year old still using it in imaginative play.
I really only like talking about items and brands
that we actually use in our own home and Melissa and Doug.
I just don't know if there's any other brand I feel
so good about naming the way that their toys actually inspire,
creativity and open-ended screen-free child-led play. It's just unmatched.
And like what's honestly so exciting is to be able to offer everyone listening to this podcast,
20% off. Visit molissaandoug.com and use code Drbecky20DRBECKY20 for 20% off your order.
Molissa andoug toys, endless possibilities.
Hi, I'm Dr. Becky, and this is Good Inside.
I'm a clinical psychologist and mom of three on a mission to rethink the way we raise our children.
I love translating deep thoughts about parenting into practical, actionable strategies that you
can use in your home right away. One of my core beliefs is that we are all doing the best we can
with the resources we have available to us in that moment. So even as we struggle
and even as we are having a hard time on the outside, we remain good inside.
Today I speak with a couple that I've gotten to know over the past few months.
Kobe Campbell reached out to me very early in my Instagram journey.
She was an active commenter on posts, a shareer in her stories, and she was very present
in my DMs.
I was immediately drawn to her, and then she introduced me to her husband Kyle, who I felt
drawn to as well. Kobe and Kyle started raising some really important questions.
How can they raise a child who feels truly good inside, who has the space to get to know
himself, who receives connection when struggling not punishment?
When they were both raised with, uh,
your feelings don't matter, just stay in line, approach.
Do we live in a world where the approach I put out there
is as safe for their black children
as it is for my own white children?
How can they respond to criticisms
from their families of origin
about their new, gentle parenting approach.
Comments like this approach is going to get your child killed.
Well, let me tell you in this episode, we ask more questions than we find answers.
That's usually how things go with important nuanced topics.
I can't wait for you to get to know Kobe and Kyle and let me say right away.
Thank you Kobe and Kyle for allowing so many people to start to get to know you. So
with that in mind, let's jump in. Kobe and Kyle so so excited to be talking with you for you both to be here. Why don't we start out?
Just tell me a little bit about each of you,
about the two of you together, about your family.
And then from there, we can jump into what's on your mind
for our discussion today.
Yeah.
I'll go first.
On the way.
I am, in my sense, traumat therapist.
Mother of two have a super energetic, deeply
feeling three year old. And then a really docile six month old too is just the chillest baby
ever, honestly. Kyle and I really started to embrace positive, respectful, present, parenting, just because of the work I do,
I feel like I'm just in a really peculiar situation
where I get to see the end of lots of repetitive actions
that happen in childhood.
And then my own childhood trauma,
which has had me in therapy for about eight years,
and then Kyle started going to therapy and we were like,
huh, there's a lot of stuff that's at year 28, 29
that happened at year three and five, you know?
And so we just-
To cut that off at the pass.
Yeah, yeah.
Yeah, so we're really passionate about figuring out
how to treat our child like he is a human being
made in the image of God now
and not wait till he gets older
to start treating him with some dignity and tenderness.
Yeah, and I'm Kyle.
I belong to her.
Also, the father of an incredibly rare and bunch
just three year old and a little,
just he's probably sleeping right now.
Our six-month-old.
So I don't know if that's poetic justice or what but we're really, really grateful for that. I'm not a licensed Trump therapist at all. I am the
CFO of a church and have my own consulting company from Richardson
acquisitions. So I'm just a finance number guy. Yeah, a numbers dude.
Yeah.
And tell me a little bit more of this journey to respectful parenting.
You mentioned that right away and that seems to be such a kind of goal post, such a focus.
But tell me more about that and about how your upbringing's even influenced kind of coming to those beliefs about how important it is to
treat a child early on with respect and dignity and gentleness.
Yeah, I feel like in my work, I like came to find personally through my clinical work that
trauma is preverbal. And that I like recalled and remembered feelings
that people had towards me
that I didn't really have any reference
for like the words that they ever said.
Like it was never like anyone said like,
you're like a terrible human or you're a nuisance
or you're so annoying or stop bothering me.
But I remember like feeling,
as I got older, I got the words for those.
And I was like, oh, that person was embarrassed of me.
Oh, they were annoyed by me.
And as I started to do my own work, I started realizing so much of what I would have before my clinical work said kids don't remember.
I remembered it my body.
You know, I remembered the sensation.
I can remember in middle school sweating in my body. I remember the sensation. I can remember in middle school,
sweating through my clothes.
And I would name that now as anxiety,
but I just thought it was weird.
Just like, oh, I'm just sweating a lot.
My hands are always really wet.
I always sweat through my clothes.
It's just a thing that happens.
And I remember the looks adults would make between each other.
When I would do something wrong or do something bad,
I would remember some of those things and found
that like those seeds were bearing fruit
in my relationship with Kyle and my relationship
with my sons, in my relationship with myself.
And the deeper you get into therapy, at least for me, the more I was like, oh,
like I wasn't treated like I was a full person when I was a child.
And just to piggyback on that for a second, you're saying, pre-verbal is, right, it's kind
of the years before or three.
Yeah.
Right?
I don't know about.
And so you're speaking to the influence that
Parenting and our kind of family environment have on us in our earliest years the years that it's so easy to say
And I think we all hear this phrase our kids won't remember that anyway
Remember those years. They're so resilient right exactly so So the years, and this is something I think
a lot about too, that the years we don't remember with our words have some of the biggest
influences on us for the rest of our lives. And you pointed to that by saying, our bodies
remember our bodies remember these patterns, the set of expectations we have of
others, our beliefs about ourself, what's allowed, what's not allowed, what's good, what's
bad, what brings people closer, what pushes people away, that kind of looking at that
arc is one of the things that led you to feel so passionately about parenting your own child in a specific way.
Yeah, and I remember being a deeply-feeling child
saying things like, that makes me sad
or that makes me angry.
And the responses were like,
what do you have to be sad about?
You don't pay a bill, you know?
And I remember truly experiencing sadness.
Like, you weren't nothing you did or felt was valid until you were an adult.
And so it just was a very, I think, lonely experience as a child that I'm now finding language for,
and a lot of that, it's kind of like recapitulated itself into my mid-late 20ss and I'm realizing, oh, how I was treated as a child,
truly is a foundation for how I see myself,
the world, God, all of it.
And Kyle hop into some of these themes.
What's connecting for you about this?
Or what's different?
For my own part, I was raised in a really,
I'm the son of two Marines.
So my mom is Marine, my dad was Marine.
And they're both black.
And so there's two cultures that really value
a certain amount of authority and obedience
coming together at the same point.
And a way in which the world really affirmed.
Like I can remember, like school assemblies,
our principles would like call out
what great parents my parents were
because they produced such obedient children.
And it wasn't until Kabe and I got together
that I was even able to reconcile that,
okay, well, I always thought I had the greatest
upbringing in the world with the greatest upbringing in the world
with the greatest parents in the world, and I still believe that. My parents are better than
everyone else's, so if you're listening, it's not your fault. My mom's better than your mom.
It's, you know, it just is what it is. And yet, in all of that, my parents have four kids,
and I can say this because each of our stories are public in some way
and maybe just a minor trigger warning here, but each of us has dealt with suicide and suicidal
ideation. Every single one of us. And with with a level of like commercial success, we've all been
very successful. We are like the poster children of what it looks like to raise good kids,
they do well, they go to the right school, they get the right job and all of that stuff and each of us
deteriorating internally. And so the question came up while Kabe and I were actually arguing about this whole present
positive thing, which I thought was amazing.
You were very resistant.
Very resistant.
She dragged me kicking and screaming,
chloroformed me, I think, at least twice.
And then somehow I wake up and I find myself sitting here
because she just, she said, and it hit me right in the gut.
She's a Kyle.
Why in the world would you think
you doing the things that your parents did
would produce anything different than what you got?
And I had never really considered.
I always thought it was a myth.
Now obviously there's levels to it and there's nuance,
but I'd never considered like,
no, my parents were amazing parents,
especially within our cultural framework.
They were like the gold standard.
And yeah, four for four.
Like there's something missing, something significant, because apparently you can have all the
other things that people want out of their children and be missing something incredibly
important, which is this sense of self-worth and value,
intrinsic beyond what you do or don't do, which I didn't have until far too late in life.
Tell me about the word obedience.
Just like what, what, what, that word you say to obedience, right?
What, what comes up for you?
Where is that in the value system?
What does that mean?
What does that look like?
Just what, what memories, what images?
Tell me more about that.
I'm African.
My parents are getting immigrants
and cause African-American.
And so I kind of described to both African culture
and African-American culture.
And I think for both cultures
and for black people in the diaspora,
obedience is the highest form of value a person can have. Like you are most valuable,
most good, most desired if you're obedient, right? And we see that not just internal to the
culture, but like within how other cultures see black people, right?
If a black person is arrested or or argue, why did you resist?
Why did you argue?
Right?
Why didn't you just do what the officer said?
Right?
And so how that has like that value is infiltrated our homes is as a way of keeping our kids safe
as a way of keeping our kids safe. As a way of survival, we have really adapted a model
of obedience as the highest value to hold onto
for the sake of survival.
Because if you don't obey, there is a lifelong consequence,
not just for you, but for the people you're connected to.
And so I think from a really young age,
it's not about connectedness, to be honest,
it's not about connectedness, it's not about autonomy,
it's not about knowing your inner voice,
it's about keeping your kid alive.
Like even, I remember growing up and it was,
it was like odd until I got to college,
but it was a huge thing if like a black child
made it to the age of 18 and like didn't die
at the hands of like whatever violence, right?
And the idea is like we want to keep our kids alive.
So we we've based everything we do on obedience.
Everything needs to be through the lens of obedience.
Our faith through the lens of obedience, connection to each other through the lens of obedience,
child rearing through the lens of obedience, which I understand because it's adaptive, right, it's adaptive. I think that Kyle and I have gotten to see the mal-daptive traits that come from it, right, which is surviving long enough to not know who you are.
are. Yeah, that one. It's prevalent. And to put even more color around that, right? Like, so she's African American. I'm African American. And yet, and the cultures are similar,
but they have some key differences. But still, there is this unifying theme because I can remember being,
I think it was seven or eight years old when this started, but my dad would wake me and my brother up in the winter
at like three or four in the morning.
And we'd wake us up and tell us to watch his car.
I'm prompted like no warning or anything.
And we were frustrated, but the whole point of it
was he wanted us, and he told us this.
This wasn't like we had to intuit it.
He said, hey, I, I need you to get used to not showing
when something makes you upset.
Because one day someone in authority overview
is gonna tell you to do something
that you don't feel like you should have to do
and it could kill you if you,
if you show too much aggression, right?
And so he was like, he was trying to love us
the best way that he knew how and to make us safe.
And so he was literally training us to be obedient
regardless of how convenient and convenient
or how right or wrong it was
and to show no emotion
because it would be dangerous to do that. And it was nine or 10 when that started. And it stopped after a while when he felt like we really had
the lesson that he could wake us up at 3 a.m. You could be mad and tired. And you would
know that there's certain things you just can't say or let yourself express. And so this theme of like maximizing for survival,
maximizing for safety, that as long as my child
can get far away from their feelings,
from their anger, from their wishes,
from their wants for themselves,
which my guess for you, Kyle, is I would rather be sleeping
than go wash your car.
But as long as I've developed a system to shut that off
or suppress that or actually shame it and blame it
and scare myself of that part of me,
almost kill that part of me off. Then I've achieved this ultimate
goal. I am the obedient child who will survive, not necessarily thrive, but survive. And that's
the goal. Yeah, and I think even beyond that, it's I from a very young age, we were taught, and if you
don't, you might die.
You know, like I think that like death, starting being teary.
The idea of death and like dire consequences are introduced at a really young age.
And so I remember just feeling like terror in my body,
like you don't do anything.
Like you might die, something might have
the mom and daddy, something might happen to this person.
And you know, it made me think Levi,
deeply feeling child, extremely autonomous,
knows exactly what he wanted to actually,
it makes me very proud,
but it also terrifies the living daylight side.
So I was washing his face in the morning
cause he had little crusties in his eyes
and I say to him,
hey, leave I need your clothes dry.
So I can get the crusty out.
He said, no, mommy, don't touch me.
I don't want you to get crusties out.
And I'm like, okay, I still need to get them out.
So like just give it a moment a second.
And he looked at me, squaring the face and said,
no, mommy, don't touch me.
I don't want you to touch me.
And as soon as he said that, it was like immediately,
I just saw my little preteen kid
saying that to a police officer. and that being his last words.
No, don't touch me. How do I teach? My little black boy boundaries and autonomy and agency
when if he exercises that out in the world and it puts his life at risk. It is hard and the application, I think, absolutely has to be different for
little black and brown, little boys and girls.
If I think you dispelled out something so powerful that when your son
says to you, no, don't touch me, there's such a conflictual response, right?
There's a, a gentle parenting perspective in a vacuum, right? There's a gentle parenting perspective in a vacuum, right?
Or a Dr. Becky perspective in a vacuum, be like, that's amazing. Your child knows what
feels right and can say no. And yes, it's an inconvenience, but wow, what a moment to elevate, and that's a sign of my amazing
parenting, right? There's like one voice. And there's another
part of you that might be different, let's say, from me and
my deeply feeling child, who's a white, tiny girl, where I'm
not that worried about her asserting her body boundaries as she
gets older. And I can't wait for the time she says to someone,
I don't know if I'm thinking of a police officer
or maybe I'm thinking of someone else
and I was like, no, don't touch me, I don't like that, right?
That feels like a moment in her teenagehood
where you're thinking, you're fast forwarding
and you're thinking, holy shit.
Yeah.
I just, and just like you said, death and threat comes in so early.
Yeah.
You're having an enter early and you're three year olds life.
By when he says no, don't touch my eyes, you're picturing him getting murdered by a police
officer.
Yeah.
And figuring out what does my child need? What actually does my child need in this moment to prepare him for life?
Is it the exact same as what Becky's daughter would need?
And if not, what do we do in that gap is really confusing, really overwhelming, really terrifying,
and really cycle- breaking to even think
about pivoting and approach.
Yeah, and even as we,
so we've been in this journey for how long it's been,
been about a year?
Yeah, I started following A.K.A. stocking.
Yes.
During quarantine.
I love your stocking.
Yeah, because we were trapped with Levi and
like this tiny two bedroom apartment and I was pregnant. Nonsense is all get out. Kyle's working.
Levi is bouncing off the freaking walls and I'm like parenting. She did stalk you. It was problematic in the beginning, but we've turned the corner.
But as we started applying some of these principles, and really just like light ways, we got
a lot of pushback from like my family.
And then we talk about that, like you talk about it rather, the conversations you have to
have with family members as you're doing is,
and it's a hard conversation for everybody.
But I think for us, it was telling that the first thing
my twin brother said to me was like,
bro, like you're gonna get your kid killed.
Yeah.
Like you told him to stop and he didn't stop.
Yeah.
I think that conversation is probably not necessarily
the conversation that is happening for other folks
as they interact with their family members
over positive parenting.
Because it's not like my brother
is some angry man, he's very sweet, loves his nephew.
And it's just like, I don't feel comfortable with it,
you know, like as if it's like this
almost evil taboo thing we're doing, like when we're not necessarily being as hard-nosed,
disciplined in the way that they're used to, in the way that we're used to, you know,
waking people up with it, yeah.
Can you walk through an example just to make it specific and real vivid,
where may we'll make it up.
Your whole family is around or the extended family.
And Levi does something, whatever it is.
And then walk through the kind of these different ways
of parenting in that moment, probably
with different goals in mind.
What's really common is Levi, don't do that.
Levi, don't pick that up. leave I don't blank, right?
Um, he may do it two or three times,
and then I'll go over to him and say,
hey, it seems like you're having a hard time controlling your body.
Let's go calm down or you have a lot of energy.
Let's do a little shake, chick, chick, chick, chick,
let's wiggle, wiggle, wiggle, wiggle, let's go outside and run.
And the stairs are like,
like, let's go outside and run. And the stairs are like, are you? So you're rewarding your child for not listening to you. And it's almost like, you know, I don't know if you heard of
this, but it's very common in the black culture. Like, I'm not watching your child unless
I can whoop on. And I'm like, well, I guess no one's watching our child. Because that's the boundary that we've set. And I think that when people see the parenting,
they think it's permissive. Just let the kid do whatever they feel, whatever they want. But I think
for us, because we're noticing, like, okay, first of all, we've all been cooped up in this room for
the last three hours. I'm getting restless.
There's no other toys here.
There's no other kids here.
He needs to have an energy.
Of course, he's going to destroy something.
You know, there's glass.
He's, of course, he's going to kick it over.
And that's what I'm thinking.
But what is on the other side when other people are perceiving it is you just told your
kid to stop and he didn't stop.
Now he must be punished for that.
Like, it's very punitive in nature
and I think that the reason why it's punitive in nature,
the culturally the way people see things is because
it's almost like they're trying to get people,
honestly trying to get black kids ready
for a punitive system when they leave the house.
We're kind of talking about this moment
where Levi doesn't listen
and then there's this fork.
Do I respond with punishment?
You have to listen.
Or do I respond with kind of a boundary and maybe a redirection or a stepping in on
my child's behalf.
But before that, there's also this fork in the road around assumption of intention.
Negative intention, right?
Or positive, right?
So am I assuming that my kid is purposely not listening, trying to pull one over me,
doesn't respect me, a ton of kind of negative assumptions.
Or am I assuming my kid is missing some skill,
overwhelmed with something else and doesn't hear me,
struggles to switch from one task to another,
struggles to inhibit an urge, right?
So tell me about that.
Yeah, so it's funny because one of our like,
cultural things in me and Kyle's home is API,
assume positive intent.
But we struggle with that. It's a tenant we
struggle to embody. And I think that also because of generational trauma, it's hard for people to see
there's no, there's no degree. It's either you fully understand or you don't understand,
degree. It's either you fully understand or you don't understand, right? And I think that oftentimes the idea is that the kid can understand the words that you're using, then
they can understand the responsibility behind responding to it. And that's just not true,
right?
Interesting. There's a real staying up here in the brain, like in cognition. My kid
knows what the word stop means.
As an example, my kid knows what stop means, right?
It makes me think about, you know, all the times,
I'm like, I know what I need to do to exercise,
but like, you know, seems not to be working in my favor,
right?
But there's a real, you're saying,
there's a real focus on my kid understands the word cognitively. So there should be
a direct line into the corresponding behavior. Is that right? Yeah, and I think that that can
be perfectly summed up in adultification. That like when black kids are seen as human,
they're not seen as children, they're seen as adults, right?
Like even thinking about, to me, Arise, how old was he?
12.
He was 12.
They thought he was 18.
And they thought he was 18, right?
There was a study done on the perception
of police officers on children,
and they systematically viewed black kids
at least four years older than they actually were
and saw white kids at an average of two years younger
than what they actually were.
And we've seen that be a reality in our lives
that people will be like,
oh, how old is he like three?
And we're like, he's not even two.
And there's this like, I think sometimes parents
get this weird like, oh my kids so smart like they like look how advanced they are. And like I have honestly had
the opposite. It's like I want my kid to be right on par, not behind, not in front because I don't
want anyone else to think that they're older than what they actually are. And I think that as much
as I believe in the way that we're doing this parenting, reality is
I've still internalized and absorbed some of those beliefs because my automatic thinking
is you knew not to do that Levi.
I told you twice and you knew exactly what I said.
There's something, I keep thinking about like giving the benefit of the doubt.
Like kids get the benefit of the doubt, but not you, right? Because when you're as soon as you look older than 10,
you're not going to.
And so I'm preparing you for that.
And then what happens inside your own home,
inside your own home is you don't get the benefit of the doubt
to prepare you for the world.
And so one of the things you learn around that,
when these various struggles you have
are kind of assumed with negative intent,
is this kind of reflected back version of you
of being bad, of being nasty, of knowing better,
and just purposefully doing
otherwise of kind of not being a good person inside.
Yeah, it's like the first recording of their internal voice
and shame, you know, in your, I think it was your managing
meltdowns course, like you were saying, like, what we reflect
to our kids is what they embody, right? And so like, it's such a
young age embodying to our kids,
rather reflecting to them, like, you know better, you should have,
you should have done better. How did you not know, right? And,
and thinking that that's like creating these guardrails, but like,
it's really creating this internal like prison of shame, where they
don't get to be human. And I think one of the most transformative things
that you've said to us as we've kind of been conversing
with you was we were like, well,
if we implemented this stuff out there
and like out there is scary.
So why would we be soft put them here?
And you said something to the effect of,
if he's not gonna be safe out there,
why would you not create a safe place at your home?
And Kyle and I were like,
that is a really good point.
And I think that safety starts with what we reflect
of our children.
Yeah, so that's like play this out really concretely
because I think so much about kids and development
and what we need.
And yet also, everything I say is influenced by my experience.
And I am a white woman who grew up with white parents.
I have a white partner, my kids are white.
And that obviously
influences things I say. And so I think I'm going to put out some ideas that I just kind of,
you know, are general principles, and I want you to tear some of them down. Okay. That's that's the
goal. Or to poke holes in them, right? So general idea, our kids respond and our kids build up the parts of themselves that we
reflect back. So when we reflect back a version of a child who isn't listening because they know
better and just purposefully don't listen and then we punish them accordingly. Our kids building up the version themselves that's that's bad. I'm bad inside. I'm dangerous. I'm
disrespectful. On the other side of things, the idea that I'm going to pause the
punishment to instead say something like something about listening is really
hard right now. I'm going to help you. I'm going to put that truck away since it's
hard to stop throwing it. And it seems like you have all this energy in your
hands. Let's go get some soft balls and throw, throw, throw.
What I'm doing is I'm reflecting back to my child.
You have some urge to do something.
That's normal.
I'm gonna stop you from being dangerous
and instead redirect that.
And I'm gonna preserve for you the idea
that you're a good kid.
You just were having a hard time.
Now, this is something I know is not new for you. That's like this difference. So tell me your reaction to that. Tell me, okay, Becky,
but here's the difference. Okay, but I'm out with my kid at a grocery store and my kid
does this and here's it would be different. Talk to me about when you hear that. Where
do you feel like there needs to be something a little different, or there needs to be an understanding
of the world the vice entering into,
that's very different from the world.
My kids will immediately experience.
Yeah.
So I hear something like that.
And I think the fear that rises up is something
to the effect of, if you don't punish bad behavior, you're
just going to get bad behavior. And like to act like that isn't reality is to operate
like with your eyes closed. And it's not my dad would literally say, it's not fair to your kids to treat them.
Like they're just going to do the right thing because you were nice to them. And my dad would say
all the time, even as he's like, tried to coach us in parenting early on. We don't necessarily
see her this much anymore. He's been gracious about that. But he would say all the time like, well, no, like your
your kid is selfish. He's a kid. He's going to be, he he's trying to wedge in between you.
Like you guys have to have to have a united front. He's trying to manipulate you. Like that's what
they do. And that may all be true intellectually to some extent, but the posture of those words really
does convey this active negative intent and this idea that, well, it's not even his
fault.
He's a kid.
That's who he is.
You've got it.
So, that's so you've got to help him not be a kid.
But it's the idea of like, no, you can't not punish something and then just expect it to be okay.
There's a reason the rest of the world works the way it does. You do something wrong, you get punished.
Well, it also makes me think about this kind of decision point around
the feelings and urges that we have that end up manifesting as
quote disobedient behavior or a moment where we're struggling,
is the answer to try to shut off, kill off the origin
of that behavior, you punish it away.
Or is there something about the experiencing of it
that helps our kids learn to manage it?
Are we trying to help our kids manage the urge, not to listen?
Or are we trying to kill the urge, not to listen?
They're very different goals.
Yeah, yeah.
I would love to say that we're trying to help and manage it.
And I would say about 60% of the time,
we are trying to help and manage.
But there was like a framework that I started
kind of journaling about.
It was, again, from your managing meltdowns,
you can tell what we're dealing with at home.
Of course, you talked about how dysregulation,
it's a co-regulation, which hopefully leads to self-regulation,
except for, my kid is co-regulating with my dysregulation
because not only am I witnessing his being triggered,
I, you know, like I mentioned before,
I'm having this flashback of,
and you cannot do this in these places.
You cannot say these things, you cannot act this way,
you cannot put your finger up and say pew-pew,
no more power-angers, no more, anything more wrong, you know?
And for me, I'm realizing like,
I had to stop at that module,
because I was like, I don't think,
I don't think the co-regulation demands something of me. And I have to figure that out internally
because if I'm being honest, I think that the desire is to redirect, but the urge in the moment
is to kill. Like kill that, kill that thing that makes you want to run around the circles for three hours.
Kill that thing, at least you want to reach out and touch strangers bags in the store.
You know?
There's the, and it's, it, it is hard to manage, but like that, that dysregulation,
mommy's dysregulation, to co-regulation of dysregulation,
two more dysregulation.
And then there's a real risk that the two of you
have to look at each other every night
and say, we're taking that risk.
There's a real risk of we are trying to raise our kids in a way where they get to know and at some point feel more at home with a wider variety of their parts of who they are of their feeling.
I'm allowed to feel this hopefully over time. I learned to regulate that feeling. I'm allowed to want this over time. I am betting on the fact that he's going to figure out where it's okay to say no, don't
touch my body and where if he's ever in the situation, he stays quiet, right?
But where we're taking on that risk of not shutting it all down.
Yeah.
And that that is a risk as you parent your kids, that you have to take on that someone
like me doesn't really feel.
I don't really feel that risk with my kids.
And that's a huge difference, huge.
And you're taking that risk while having family members who sound like in all their
own ways really love you and love your kids. Tell you you're endangering your children.
And you're saying let's reverse that or take the risk of I want Levi to feel like a good
kid inside. That doesn't mean hoping when he's 18, he has tantrums
like now and I'll just be saying is a mom, oh, look at my free child. That doesn't feel good.
That doesn't feel good to an 18 year old, right? Like no one wants to be dysregulated.
But I think what's key is it's taking the risk of tolerating this really messy period.
Yeah.
In the hopes that you have a kid who feels good inside
and has learned how to manage so many different feelings
and urges, but with the core belief
that those feelings and urges are okay to exist inside.
I don't have to kill them off or reject them.
And my core story is no matter what I'm feeling, I'm good.
Nothing inside me is toxic.
Nothing inside me is poisonous.
Nothing inside me is bad.
And I think one of the huge paradoxes is the wider range of feelings we help our kids
with when they're younger, the less likely over time, and that's a huge asterisk over time,
when does the time switch?
I don't know.
But the less likely over time, those feelings all convert into dysregulated behaviors,
because the feelings we don't allow inside of us, right?
Our feelings are forces.
I always think about them.
They're forces.
And if you can't allow and manage a feeling inside, it has no choice but to catapult out
of you and some totally dysregulated behavior when you're older. And yet having said all of this, the two of you are doing something so, so massive.
Yeah, it is, and it's, I feel like it is heavy
and it's hard and I think accidentally a billion times,
but the fruit is so sweet and unexpected.
He had a soccer game last Saturday
and we're noticing that he loves to play with people,
but he doesn't necessarily like to be watched by people.
So here's this line of adults sitting in their pullout chairs,
just staring, and he is nervous.
And most of the parents, and this is no shade or shame to them,
most of the parents are like, just left their crying kids, right?
And they're like, just go and their kids crying
in the middle of the field and they said,
you know what, Levi, I'm not gonna leave you
until you're ready for me.
And I stood there and I held his hand the entire game.
She played more soccer than all of those children.
She didn't want my apple, I actually closed a ring.
But I stayed there the entire time. And there was a part of me, this really small part
of me that was almost embarrassed. I can get it together. But
then there was like, it was really big, overwhelming part
that was like, how cool that I get to experience this for my
kid. They're like, when I wanted something so ridiculous, huge
for quotations, as like my parents holding my hand through a
soccer game, like the times I just longed for someone to hold my
hand in times that other people have said, doesn't make sense. And I
got down and I looked in the face and said, leave my how you
feeling. And she didn't say anything, but he did this.
say anything, but he did this.
And it was like one of those moments where I was like, and that's why we can't stop.
I love you guys, you know that really do.
Dr. Mickey, I'm making the family. Yeah.
We love Dr. Becky T-shirt.
I'm going to show up right now.
Thank you so much. Thank you so much.
Thank you so much.
I love talking with Kobe and Kyle.
They have truly taught me so much, but maybe more importantly, they've helped me ask
more questions and consider new perspectives.
I feel the need today to not tie things together with any clear takeaways.
Instead, I just want to let this conversation sit with me and hopefully with all of you.
As we consider the different realities we all face, the ways our past lives on in our present,
the ways we are cycle-breaking and the bravery of each and every person in
this community to reflect, consider new ideas, and be vulnerable about our parenting and
self-discovery journeys.
Thanks for listening to Good Inside.
Let's stay connected.
At GoodInside.com, you can sign up for workshops
and subscribe to Good Insider.
My weekly email with scripts and strategies delivered
right to your inbox.
And for more ideas and tips, check out my Instagram,
Dr. Becky at Goodinside.
Goodinside is produced by Beth Roe and Brad Gage,
and executive produced by Erica Belsky and me, Dr. Becky.
If you enjoyed this episode, please take a moment to rate and review.
And if you really like the episode, please share it with someone you know.
Many of you tell me that sharing an episode has allowed you to start conversations about tricky
topics with spouses or extended family members and
To bond and connect with fellow cycle breakers. I actually do read each and every review
So please know that your feedback is meaningful to me
Let's end by placing our hands on our hearts and
reminding ourselves even as I struggle and even as I have a hard time on the outside,
I remain good inside.
you