Heart Starts Pounding: Horrors, Hauntings, and Mysteries - 44: Thanksgiving Day Terror: The Unsolved Case of The Blount Family

Episode Date: November 22, 2023

On Thanksgiving Day, 1985, Susan Blount awoke to screams coming from her living room. What she would find remains one of the strangest cold cases in Texas today. Subscribe on Patreon for bonus conte...nt and to become a member of our Rogue Detecting Society. Patrons have access to ad-free listening and bonus content. Follow on Tik Tok and Instagram for a daily dose of horror. We have a monthly newsletter now! Be sure to sign up for updates and more. This episode is sponsored by Miracle Made. Miracle Made sheets are thermoregulating and designed to keep you at the perfect temperature all night long. Go to trymiracle.com/hsp to save over 40%. AND, if you use our promo code 'HSP' at checkout, you’ll get 3 FREE TOWELS and SAVE an extra 20%! Heart Starts Pounding is written and produced by Kaelyn Moore. 

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 It's that feeling when the energy and the room shifts, when the air gets sucked out of a moment and everything starts to feel wrong. It's the instinct between fight or flight. When your brain is trying to make sense of what it's seeing, it's when your heart starts pounding. Welcome to Heart Starts Pounding, a podcast of horrors, hauntings, and mysteries. I'm your host, Kaelin Moore. Happy Thanksgiving to all my U.S. listeners. I hope you're enjoying time with your family and eating some really good food. And even if you're international or just don't celebrate, I hope you can find a moment
Starting point is 00:00:46 to think about what you're grateful for. That's always been my favorite part of Thanksgiving, taking time to actually think about my life and how grateful I am for it. That and funeral potatoes. My aunt used to always make funeral potatoes for Thanksgiving, and it's probably the one food I could eat for the rest of my life. For those unfamiliar, it's those potatoes that have the cord flakes on top. Ugh, they're just so good. If you're listening to the ad-supported version of the show, I am grateful for you. Our sponsors
Starting point is 00:01:16 make this show possible, and if you're listening on Patreon, I'm also grateful for you. You'll have access to ad-free episodes as well as other perks like bonus content and extra episodes. Also, if you have the Patreon app on your phone, you can join the Heart Starts Pounding Patreon Group Chat, which is a really cool new addition to Patreon. We're in there recommending books and talking about episodes, you should definitely come join us. recommending books and talking about episodes, you should definitely come join us. Alright, I'm really eager to jump into today's story. It's about a Thanksgiving Day disaster and the search for who was responsible. The actual event itself is wild, but the turn
Starting point is 00:02:01 it takes when the police are hunting down who did it is also unlike anything I've read before. Our story starts on November 28th, 1985, just outside of Fort Worth, Texas, and a small mobile home community on the edge of Lake Worth. That day, the blunt family gathered in their new mobile home to celebrate Thanksgiving. The Blunts didn't have much money. If you asked Susan, the mom, about it, she would tell you that they were, quote, the broken people in the world. Earlier that year, they had to move from the Seattle area down to Texas to help her husband Joe's father.
Starting point is 00:02:41 And they were really limited on what they could get because of their finances. But they needed to find somewhere where their two teenage kids, Angela and Robert could go to a decent high school. So they settled into the hilltop mobile home park. And that Thanksgiving, actually, they didn't have a phone line. Susan had to stop paying the bill and the phone company just shut it off. They didn't even really have enough furniture to have Joe's brother and nephew over that day. Joe had to go to the shop where he was a mechanic to borrow some chairs.
Starting point is 00:03:15 But a makeshift Thanksgiving is still a Thanksgiving. And as long as they had each other, that's all they needed. And this Thanksgiving marked a good new era for the blunt family. Joe's brother, Ray, was there with his son, Michael, and the two had actually been estranged for years. But Michael had flown in from Tulsa and here they were breaking bread together. It felt like a step in the right direction
Starting point is 00:03:42 of repairing their relationship. Joe, the father, also had a lot to be grateful for. He had struggled with alcohol a lot in the last few years, and it was making it hard for him to hold down a job. But he recently had gotten a job as a mechanic nearby and was feeling really fulfilled by his work. He told his wife, Susan, he quote, wanted to work with those guys for the rest of his life. This took a huge weight off of Susan's shoulders. She had been keeping the family afloat
Starting point is 00:04:15 with her job at an insurance agency, and while she couldn't pay the phone bill, she paid their rent on time every month. But back to that day. The family had an early dinner, and then, around 5pm, Ray went home. He felt really good about how the day went with his son, and apparently Michael felt the same way. He called his mother afterwards to tell her about how well it went.
Starting point is 00:04:42 Then at 9pm, Joe, Angela, Robert, and Michael decided they wanted to go to a convenience store and grab some more snacks. And Joe wanted to grab a little more beer. Susan was way too tired after cooking for everyone that day, so she told them that they can just go ahead without her. She's gonna go lay down in her room for a little bit. without her, she's gonna go lay down in her room for a little bit. This episode is brought to you by Miracle Made. I don't know about you, but I am usually freezing all day long, and then the second I lay down under my covers, I'm so hot I can't sleep.
Starting point is 00:05:18 Turns out, that's terrible, since your temperature at night can have a major impact on your sleep quality. That's why I'm so excited about miracle-made bedsheets. Miracle-made uses silver-infused fabrics inspired by NASA. They're thermo-regulating, meaning they're designed to keep you at the perfect temperature all night long, so you can actually sleep. They're also super comfortable, like roll around in the bed at a luxury hotel comfortable. And they're self-cleaning.
Starting point is 00:05:47 That silver infusion prevents up to 99.7% of bacterial growth, so they stay fresher longer. Not that I don't think you guys clean your sheets all the time, I do too, but I'm just saying if you were super busy with everything these holidays and sheet washing wasn't top of mind, these sheets can help. And speaking of holidays, these sheets also make the perfect gift for friends, for family, your partner who doesn't like doing laundry. And right now, if you order, you get three free towels, so even more gifts. So if you are too hot, we're too cold when you sleep, want to keep your sheets fresher
Starting point is 00:06:25 for longer, need easy holiday gifts or all of the above. Go try MiracleMade.com slash HSP to try it today or gift to someone special this holiday season. And we've got a special deal for our listeners, save over 40%. And if you use our promo code HSP at checkout, you'll get three free towels and save an extra 20%. Miracle is so confident in their product, it's backed with a 30-day money back guarantee. So if you're not 100% satisfied, you'll get a full refund. Upgrade your sleep with MiracleMade. Go to trymiracle.com slash HSP and use the code HSP to claim your free
Starting point is 00:07:09 three-piece towel set and save over 40% off. Again, that's trymiracle.com slash HSP to treat yourself a friend or loved one this holiday season. Joe jumps in the car with his kids in FU and they drive off. As the car peels away, Susan can hear the sound from her bed of the unpaved gravel driveway crunching beneath the tires. She hasn't fallen asleep yet, and for a little while, she's kind of in and out of sleep. She falls asleep for a little bit, and then she's awoken when she hears the tires on gravel
Starting point is 00:07:53 again. And she perks up a little bit in anticipation of her family being home. There's a knock at the front door. Joe took the car he should have his keys to get in, so Susan doesn't get out of bed. If she hears banging on the door, she'll get up. But there's no more knocking. She listens, expecting someone to come through the front door. Instead, all she hears is that sound again, the crunch of the gravel under tires as whoever
Starting point is 00:08:28 came up to her door drives off. Must have been the wrong home, she thinks, and with that thought, she drifts back off to sleep. The next sound Susan hears is screaming. Deep, guttural screams coming from the living room. She's ripped from her sleep. What the hell is going on? Susan runs to open her bedroom door, and she could never have expected what she saw. Right on the other side of the door were flames.
Starting point is 00:09:07 It looked like her entire home was on fire, and in the middle of the living room, sitting in the same chair he had Thanksgiving dinner in, was Joe, fully engulfed in the fire. Susan's memory is shoddy from this moment on, but somehow she ends up outside of the trailer in her front yard, where she sees Robert, her 14-year-old son laying in the gravel. The front door of their home had been blown off the hinges and laid beside him. Through the open front door, all she can see are flames, now taking over the entire foundation of the mobile home. If her family is inside, she can't see them.
Starting point is 00:09:50 She can't even hear them over the roar of the fire anymore. Roberts, not responding, he's not even moving. From the looks of it, his face and hands are burned badly, and his shoes look like they've melted into his feet. The rest of this moment comes in flashes. As any mother's worst nightmare unfolds around her, Susan catches a glimpse of her neighbor James running over to help, and then there's a moment in her memory of James being treated by an EMT, oxygen being held up to his face.
Starting point is 00:10:22 There's a small flash of robber inside of an ambulance. Is she crazy or did she just see his arms move? After a moment, he seems to be coughing, choking back up some of the black smokey inhaled. Susan is taken to the hospital and the ambulance with her son, and as she's being taken away, firefighters are super soaking the trailer. The angry flames are being replaced by billowy smoke, and soon the smoke dies down as well. All that's left of the mobile home is its charred skeleton. At this point, Susan is in the hospital with Robert and has no idea what caused the fire in her home, or what happened to her family.
Starting point is 00:11:06 She catches a police officer in the hospital. What's going on? Where is Angela? This is when she's informed that Angela and Michael were found inside of the trailer with Joe. They didn't make it. The officer watches as this devastates Susan. He knows pressure is on him now to figure out what caused the fire that took half of her
Starting point is 00:11:32 family. Well, reporters from the Fort Worth Star Telegram were on the scene right on the heels of emergency services, and they started interviewing neighbors who witnessed the events. Tim Tortella was a 29 year old neighbor of the blouse who told reporters something that shocked them. He was watching TV in his trailer when he heard what sounded like an explosion. He said, quote, it sounded like a stick of dynamite going off. It shook my house when it went off. The reporter made a note of this. If a blast started the fire rather than say a cigarette, that's a big deal. Tim didn't miss a beat. He grabbed his brother Sean right when he heard the blast and together they scaled the fence separating his home and the blunts.
Starting point is 00:12:22 Sean stayed down on the lawn with Robert, tending to his burns, but Tim saw the flames coming out from the windows and knew he had to do something. He tried to run in, but could only make it halfway down the hall towards the living space before the smoke and heat became too much. She doesn't remember it, but it was Susan who told Tim her family was still inside the living area. Another neighbor named Aline Bruce was about 50 yards away and described hearing a similar explosion. Reporters got to her when she was standing outside watching the plumes of smoke rise from the blunt's home. She told them that the blast was so loud, she thought something had exploded in her own home.
Starting point is 00:13:06 Again, Susan doesn't remember this, but there were multiple neighbors who ran over to help. Elton Walsh was woken up from sleeping by the blast, and he put on his shoes and ran over with his fire extinguisher before he even knew what was going on. The community didn't have many resources, but the firemen said that as they arrived, multiple neighbors were trying to put out the fire with just their garden hoses. As for the family inside, it just wasn't enough. A fire that strong, and a blast of that magnitude, A fire that strong, and a blast of that magnitude, probably killed everyone instantly, a firefighter told the Fort Worth Star Telegram. It seemed like Robert had been standing perfectly, so the blast pummeled him out the front door,
Starting point is 00:13:55 and that was the only reason he survived. But none of that answered the burning question. What caused the blast? And while doctors, police, and Susan were waiting for Robert to regain consciousness so they could ask him what happened, investigators started to search the remains of the home for any clues. They do this, however, with an eye towards Susan. It did seem suspicious that her whole family was killed or gravely injured and she somehow escaped untouched.
Starting point is 00:14:29 It seems, at first, at least, like it may have come from the furnace in the home, which was located inside the trailer underneath the living room area where the family would have been sitting. Was there a chance something went wrong and the whole place blew up? But one of the investigators sees something inside of the mobile home that definitely does not look right. Among the ashes of a few pieces of furniture the blouse owned were some scraps of metal that looked out of place. He's seen this before, but only
Starting point is 00:15:08 in targeted attacks. This blast was not in accident. He calls back to the police station and says someone needs to question Robert now. It's around this time that Robert starts waking up in the hospital, and before he can really get his head wrapped around what happened, they need him to remember as much as he can leading up to the blast. And that's when Robert confirms their fears about what they found in the house. According to Robert, that night he got in the car with his family and they made a quick trip to the convenience store to grab snacks and beer. When they arrived back home, Angela noticed that on the steps leading up to their mobile home was a brief case. She bent down and picked it up, giggling as she inspected it.
Starting point is 00:16:04 Ooh, what did they think was in it? They all joked and gave answers. Angela imagined that it was filled with some sort of untold treasure. She brought it inside so they could all open it together. Only when they all gathered around, Angela clicked open the latches of the briefcase. Robert remembered the sound. It sounded heavier and more biting than just a latch. It sounded like a mouse trap. heavier and more biting than just a latch. It sounded like a mouse trap. Next thing he knew, his body was hurling backwards out the door.
Starting point is 00:16:31 The investigators all looked at each other. They had heard stories like this before. What Angela picked up off her porch wasn't just a briefcase. It was a bomb. But not just any bomb. It wasn't a pipe bomb that had been placed randomly to go off and kill as many people as it could. No. It was disguised so the victims would pick it up and bring it inside, thinking it was something else. Whoever left this had specific people in mind they were trying to kill.
Starting point is 00:17:07 So the FBI got involved in the investigation and they were able to reconstruct the explosive device. There was a mouse trap inside, opening the briefcase triggered the mouse trap, which triggered the bomb that was made out of materials that included two galvanized metal pipes filled with smokeless gunpowder and a nine-volt battery. So the police had the how, but what they needed to find was the who and the why. Still, they were looking at Susan, had she placed the bomb on the porch before heading off to sleep. One detective asked Susan if she had ever taken out
Starting point is 00:17:47 insurance policies on her family, to which she responded, yes. And as she tells him she had, she can see the look in his eyes change. He gets this kind of gotcha look on his face. Like the insurance policy was the missing piece that was going to tie this whole thing up. He asked her how much they were for. But remember, the blunts were poor. Somehow the detective
Starting point is 00:18:12 must have forgotten that when asking about the insurance policies. It wasn't like Susan could have taken out hundreds of thousands of dollars on her husband and kids. Ultimately, she had a $2,000 policy on her husband and a $1,000 policy on her daughter. After that, the police stopped looking into her as a suspect. But then, she tells them about the car. Remember, when Susan laid down to fall asleep, she heard the sound of a car pulling up and driving off, and someone had knocked on her door. That must have been the person that left the briefcase on her porch. Susan never got up though. She didn't see who was at the door, or even what car they were driving.
Starting point is 00:18:55 She only heard the sound. So the police started asking neighbors if they saw anything that night. And thankfully, one neighbor did. As he was pulling into his driveway, he remembered seeing a red, late model station wagon pulling away from the blunt residents. He also said he remembered seeing that car around the neighborhood before. It feels promising, but authorities aren't able to locate the car. They're not able to do anything, really. At least that's what they tell Susan and Robert. That December, Robert lay in a hospital bed,
Starting point is 00:19:32 getting skin grafts to heal his burns, and waiting for any news of who did this to his family. They had no enemies. They had only lived in this specific trailer park for two months. They hardly knew anyone. Why would anyone want to do this to them? The police were asking that same exact question, and at first, the only person they could
Starting point is 00:19:55 think of was Matthew Huff. Immediately after the bombing, rumors started spreading around Azal High School where Angela went. There, a 15-year-old boy named Matthew Huff had a crush on Angela. He had asked her out only to be rejected. And sure, that happens to lots of high school kids, but Matthew had a particular darkness to him that the other kids had picked up on. Right after the bombing, Matthew started telling other students that he had at one point built a bomb.
Starting point is 00:20:31 He didn't say that he had built this particular bomb, but just that he had built a bomb before. When other kids started saying that Matthew had bombed the blunts, he never corrected anyone. And actually, a little while after the bombing, Matthew was sent to a juvenile correctional facility. Everyone assumed it was because he had killed the blunts. But in fact, it was for burglary.
Starting point is 00:20:57 And when police questioned Matthew, he said he just wanted to seem tough to his classmates, so he let them believe he had built the bomb. The police kept him on the suspect list, but there wasn't enough evidence that he had really done anything. Then a few months later, in early 1986, the Bureau of Alcohol Tobacco Firearms and Explosives or the ATF was running a sting on a man they thought was illegally selling firearms in Azal, Texas. The man was named Douglas Brown, and he was a business owner in town who had a license to sell firearms, but not automatic weapons, and not explosives, which they had received
Starting point is 00:21:38 a tip he was selling. Oh, and drugs. He was also selling drugs out of his office, which my family near Azul informed me was not very shocking for the 80s. On March 5th of 1986, an undercover ATF agent met Brown at a restaurant in Azul where she asked if she could buy an explosive from him. Brown responded that he could build her a bomb. The two met at a mall a few weeks later, where Brown presented her with a brief case.
Starting point is 00:22:09 He opened it and showed her the contents. A white, putty-like substance wrapped in a green colored substance, which he said was a homemade plastic explosive, all wrapped in napalm. It also contained electronic circuits and a place to put a blasting cap to detonate the bomb. I looked into the contents of Douglas' bomb a ton, and I could tell you what it was made out of, but I won't because FBI. But I will say, in everything I read about it, there was no mention of
Starting point is 00:22:42 a Maustrap detonator. Still, Brown was immediately arrested and brought down to the police station where he was questioned if he knew anything about the blunt family. He didn't, and police were never able to find any connection between him and the blunts. But he was kept on the suspect list because even if he didn't place the bomb, perhaps he had sold it to the person who did. After these two suspects were investigated, the case started cooling off. There just weren't other suspects at the time to look into. That December, a tip line was set up for any information the public had on the case.
Starting point is 00:23:23 No one called. The police said that had never happened before. It was so strange that there was a brief case bomb which insinuated some sort of organization or skill. I mean, this was not just some pipe bomb a high schooler could have built, but still there were no leads. At this point, they didn't even know if it was targeted, was someone really trying to kill the blunts, or was it placed on the wrong porch.
Starting point is 00:23:51 For how helpful the neighbors seemed to be initially, there was also a cd underbelly to the community. Drug dealers, meth makers, maybe the bomb was intended for one of them. We're going to take a quick break, and when we get back, we're going to talk about the event that opened this case back up. On April 19th, 1995, ten years after the blunts were bombed in their home on Thanksgiving, a gauky young man drives a rental truck full of homemade explosives to the front of a federal building in Oklahoma City.
Starting point is 00:24:34 The man is 26, though he presents as much younger, and he's waging an imaginary war with the government in his mind. This, he thinks, is the way to win. At 9am, the truck detonates, killing 168 people inside of the building, 19 of them children. The Oklahoma City bombing remains the worst act of domestic terrorism committed on American soil. One of the immediate after effects of this tragedy was it caused a surge of financing to flow into the ATF to make sure a bombing of this magnitude never happened again. And with all of this extra money, the Bureau had the extra resources to look into some unsolved bombings. So the blunt family tragedy, which at the time was the biggest unsolved bombing in America was reopened.
Starting point is 00:25:27 As the ATF starts looking into how this could have happened, they get a tip. In the summer of 1997, a man by the name of Jack Ferris asked to speak to police. He's been sitting a half hour from Lake Worth in Parker County jail for some time, but he tells police he might have some information they want. That is, if they're willing to set him free for it. Police are skeptical, but they take the meeting. They've heard a lot of tall tales and confessions from prisoners looking for commuted sentences. Many of them false. But Ferris tells them that he's been having conversations with another inmate who confessed
Starting point is 00:26:09 to something pretty disturbing. This prisoner told Ferris that he was the one responsible for the blunt family bombing. Ferris gets released, his bargaining tactic was successful, and a man named Michael Tony starts being seriously investigated. Tony was 31 years old at the time, and he had grown up in Cottonwood, California, a few miles north of Sacramento. To say Tony's childhood was tough would be an understatement. His father had walked out on the family when Tony was young, and what followed was a series of terrible and often abusive boyfriends
Starting point is 00:26:50 his mother brought home. Tony once recounted the time when his mother's boyfriend tied him to a chair and lit his hands on fire by spraying lighter fluid on them and sparking them with a lighter. He did this over and over for his own sick enjoyment. Tony was about 10 at the time of the event. Then, when Tony was just a preteen, one of his best friends, Annette Selix, was killed by a serial killer targeting young
Starting point is 00:27:18 woman and cottonwood. Darryl Keith Rich was eventually caught and executed for the murder of four young girls in the area. In 1990, his aunt was sexually assaulted and murdered. Her killer was also given the death sentence for his crime. And after years of heartbreak, grief, and abuse, Tony decided to leave Cottonwood for Texas before he even made it to the 10th grade. He dropped at a high school and never looked back. By 1997, when he was being investigated for the blunt family bombings, he was already in jail for theft while on parole.
Starting point is 00:27:55 Police were able to track down a woman named Kimberly who was married to Tony from 1986 to 1989. She was with him the night of Thanksgiving 1985, and remembers what Tony was doing that night very well. She said on Thanksgiving, he had been trying to exclude her from his plans, but she convinced him to let her tag along. He was going fishing with his best friend, Chris Meeks. Kimberly told police that on the way to the Fort Worth Nature Center, Tony stopped by a business near the hilltop mobile home park where the blunts lived.
Starting point is 00:28:31 She saw him take a briefcase out of the car and bring it into the business. Just a few minutes later, he returned without the briefcase. Kimberly remembers a lot of details about being at the nature center, like the gun that Tony used when he shot and killed a beaver, but even though they were in close proximity to the hilltop mobile home park, she never remembered the sound of an explosion. Chris Meeks, the best friend who also attended the fishing trip, was questioned by police as well, and he tells them that Tony told him he needed to quote, fulfill a contract, and that he had seen a briefcase on him that day. Michael Tony was arrested, and in May of 1999, his trial began. Both Kimberly and Chris were
Starting point is 00:29:19 brought in to testify. And that's where Chris revealed that on top of seeing the briefcase, Tony told him he needed Chris to help him with, quote, a mission. They all drove down to the business near the hilltop Mobile Home Park, and Tony sent Chris out through some bushes in the area where he could see the Mobile Home Park on the other side. Chris wasn't sure exactly what he was supposed to be looking for, but he reported back to Tony that it looked like no one was home in one of the trailers on the end. That's when Tony got out of the car with the briefcase and was gone for a few minutes. When he got back, Chris said he was almost giddy. He told Kimberly and Chris that he had fulfilled the contract, and then they went fishing over at the Nature Center. He testified that weeks before the bombing, he knew that Tony was hanging out
Starting point is 00:30:10 with some guys that spoke Tongan, one who went by the name Larry. About a week before the bombing, Chris overheard a conversation between Larry and Tony in which the words bombing and contract were mentioned. He didn't hear the rest of the conversation, but days later, Tony showed him the briefcase and said he needed to blow something up. Okay, I'm going to call this part out because if you feel like something's missing in the case against Tony up to this point, you'd be right. There's still no why. Why was this mysterious man asking Tony to blow up a mobile home?
Starting point is 00:30:52 What was this mysterious contract for? The next witness to testify adds a little bit more color to the deal that Tony had set up. So surprisingly, the inmate who gave police the original tip on Tony wasn't the only cellmate to testify. Another cellmate of Tony's, Finis Blankenship, also took the stand and said Tony told him he was being paid $5,000 for the job, $2,500 to make the bomb the bomb and 2,500 to place it. He also said that this was a drug-related hit, but the briefcase was put on the wrong doorstep. This testimony conveniently answers the question of why, but this is also the point where the case against Tony starts to fall apart.
Starting point is 00:31:43 Blankenship was a serial informer who would drum up information to give police to commute his sentences. Sentences he got for being a pedophile, mind you. So now the only case for why Tony would have done this is coming from someone we don't really know if we can trust. And on top of that, would you believe that months before the trial started, Jack Ferris, the initial informant who tipped off police to Tony, redacted his statement.
Starting point is 00:32:15 On a cold winter day, Jack Ferris went back to the police and told them he fabricated the entire story with Tony. He had been given permission by Tony to accuse him of the bombing in order to get out of prison faster. Tony also took the stand in his own defense and admitted to telling Jack he could blame the bombing on him to get out of jail earlier. He had learned about the bombing from a man named Benny Jo Toul, who was friends with Michael Huff. Remember, the suspect who liked Angela, but she didn't like him back. Huff had told Benny a lot of specific details about the bombing that then made their way to Tony.
Starting point is 00:32:55 But what about Tony's ex-wife? She was with him that day. She saw him get out of the car with a briefcase and come back without it. That seems pretty damning. Well, when she told that story to police, that wasn't the first time the police had questioned her. The first time she spoke to the police, she admitted to them she had never heard of the bombing. She later admitted to going to the library to research the case. It was only after she had learned about it that she and Chris Meeks went back to the police with their story.
Starting point is 00:33:29 But none of that seemed to matter. During the trial, Jack Ferris' redaction wasn't brought up. Kim didn't change her accusations, and the prosecution went hard against Tony. They brought 80 pieces of evidence collected at the scene of the explosion to show the jury just how violent the blast was. They brought up every piece of Tony's past they could, that he was a thief, that he was violent against his ex-wife and former girlfriends,
Starting point is 00:33:57 that one time he forced an ex-girlfriend to play Russian roulette, she survived. His lawyers insisted, though, that none of that made him a bomber. On May 25, however, just 15 days after the trial had started, Michael Tony was sentenced to death for the Thanksgiving bombing of the Blunt family. It took the jury just four hours to find him guilty. jury, just four hours to find him guilty. For those familiar with the case, the news seemed shocking. There was no physical evidence that put Tony at the scene at the time of the bombing, and witness accounts had largely been retracted.
Starting point is 00:34:41 The surviving blunt family members, however, seemed relieved. Susan came forward and said that she knew, without a doubt, that they had charged the right man. Lin Blunt, the mother of Michael, the cousin who died in the blast, said she knew he was guilty 100%. But the more Tony's defense attorneys looked into the case, the more they were able to pull his conviction apart. They looked into the gun that Kimberly remembered Tony using to kill the beaver the day of the bombing, and they were able to find out that Tony didn't buy that gun until December. He couldn't have used it the day of the bombing. Kimberly and Chris had also said they had been driven around in Tony's pickup truck.
Starting point is 00:35:24 Mind you, this is not a red station wagon. Kimberly and Chris had also said they had been driven around in Tony's pickup truck. Mind you, this is not a red station wagon. But the truck also wasn't bought until December. If they did take this fishing trip, it didn't happen on Thanksgiving. There was also the way that some of the witness testimony was collected. A cognitive interview specialist was brought in to collect the testimonies, and the defense believed that this person shaped and could jolt what the witnesses remembered. For instance, it wasn't until Kimberly sat with the cognitive interview specialist
Starting point is 00:35:56 that she remembered Tony's involvement. The fact that she didn't know anything about the bombing the first time police spoke to her was completely emitted from the trial. The defense was also able to find the man who spoke Tongan and went by Larry. His real name was Tissilelli Lupahecki, and he was 17 years old at the time. It turns out he was questioned by police after the bombing, and he was cleared by a polygraph test of any involvement in the case. This piece of evidence also did not get shown to the jury, and while the defense was trying to put together enough information to have Tony's life sentence dropped, Tony himself was causing quite a ruckus while sitting on death row. In May of 2000, he tried selling tickets to his execution to bidders
Starting point is 00:36:46 on eBay. However, the listing was up for just four hours before it was removed. No one had made any bids. This was not a good look for him getting released. But in October of 2008, nine years after he was sentenced to death, the state of Texas was presented with 14 pieces of evidence that were withheld during the first trial, and Tony's conviction was overturned. He was released from prison on September 2nd, 2009. It was a bittersweet moment. The defense believed that they just saved an innocent man from being another casualty of
Starting point is 00:37:28 the blunt family bombings, but the surviving blunts were devastated. They felt like they were on the path to justice for Joe, Angela, and Michael, and now they felt further away than ever. This story does not have a happy ending. Even though Tony was released, one month after he was set free, he was killed in a car accident. This happened as the state was deciding whether or not to retry him for the crime. As of today, the case remains unsolved, though investigators do believe that it was a targeted attack probably related to drug activity that was happening in the mobile home community
Starting point is 00:38:10 that accidentally landed on the Blunt's porch. But there's still questions that I would like to have answered. If the red car scene pulling out of the Blunt's driveway was seen multiple times in the community before, how did the driver not know which house their target was in? Why wasn't the car ever located when there's such a specific description of it? And was the bomb made by the man who was arrested earlier for giving a bomb to an undercover agent? The case is now completely cold, and it seems like it's not under the jurisdiction of anyone after the Tarant County Police Department recused themselves of it. It seems now to sit on the Attorney General of Texas' shelf. If you have any information on what happened,
Starting point is 00:39:03 Thanksgiving Day 1985 to the Blunt family, I'll include information in the show notes on how to get in touch with the Attorney General of Texas. This has been Heart Starts Pounding, written and produced by me, Kaelin Moore. Sound design and mix by Peach Tree Sound. Thank you so much to all of our new patrons. You will be thanked by name in the monthly newsletter, which you can all sign up for on our website. Special thanks to Travis Dunlap, Grayson Jernigan, the team at WME and Ben Jaffy, and a special
Starting point is 00:39:39 thank you to AudioBoom. Have a heart pounding story or a case request? Check out Heart StartsPounding.com. Until next time, stay curious.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.