Judge John Hodgman - Double Histameanor
Episode Date: February 13, 2019Britton files suit against her boyfriend, Jackson. Britton is allergic to cats and avocados, but she won’t cut them out of her life! Jackson is worried about her health and would like her to stay ou...t of contact with allergens. Who's right? Who's wrong? Thank you to Matt Crocker for naming this week's case! To suggest a title for a future episode, like Judge John Hodgman on Facebook. We regularly put out a call for submissions.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Welcome to the Judge John Hodgman podcast.
I'm bailiff Jesse Thorne.
This week, double histaminer.
Britton files suit against her boyfriend, Jackson.
Britton is allergic to cats and avocados,
but won't cut them out of her life.
Jackson's worried about her health.
He says she should stay out of contact with allergens.
Who's right? Who's wrong?
Only one man can decide.
Please rise as Judge John Hodgman enters the courtroom and presents an obscure cultural reference.
This is an obscure cultural reference, but it is in the form this time and for the very first time in the history of Judge John Hodgman podcasting.
It is in the form of a riddle.
So listen carefully, litigants.
You have to answer this riddle. What do you get when you cut an avocado into six times 10 to the
23rd power pieces? What do you get when you cut an avocado into six times 10 to the 23rd power pieces.
Think it over while bailiff Jesse Thorne is swearing you in.
Britton Jackson, please rise and raise your right hands.
Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth,
so help you God or whatever?
Absolutely, yes.
I do.
Do you swear to abide by Judge John Hodgman's ruling
despite the fact that he is allergic to injustice? I do. Do you swear to abide by Judge John Hodgman's ruling, despite the fact that he is allergic to injustice?
I do. I do. Judge Hodgman, you may proceed.
You may be seated for an immediate summary judgments in one of yours favors.
Can either one of you answer the riddle and or name the cultural reference that I made as I entered the courtroom?
We'll start with you, Britton.
What's your guess?
Oh, no.
I was so unprepared for a riddle.
What were you prepared for?
Nothing.
I did not have answers prepared.
Oh, okay.
Me neither.
I'm going to say the word algebra.
Algebra.
What do you get when you cut an avocado
into six times 10 to the 23rd power pieces?
I love that answer.
Algebra.
And that's it.
Good guess.
Solid guess.
I'm putting it in the book.
What about you, Jackson?
Well, that's a terrible guess.
It's clearly trigonometry.
Trig.
And that's it.
And that's it.
Trig or nothing.
I'll put that guess in.
Bailiff Jesse Thorne, do you have a guess?
My guess is guacamole.
Bailiff Jesse Thorne, you have answered the riddle correctly.
What led you to that conclusion, Jesse?
I'm a native Californian.
Very good.
Obviously, there is an avocado theme to this case,
and this is an avocado themed riddle. And if you determined that this riddle was not very funny, you are correct.
vis-a-vis this cultural reference because this case involves the fact that you are allergic to cats and avocados which kind of feel like uh you picked out two random tiles from a bag of nouns
and i literally had nowhere to go but to type into a search engine quotes about cats and avocados
and the only thing that came out that was anywhere close was this stupid riddle printed
in meme font over a cat sitting at a chemistry desk wearing glasses and a bow tie and a bow tie
right exactly this is terrible this is the worst i don't know what the source of this meme is and
i'm using meme in the latter day sense of just a funny photo of a cat with
funny words on it. But it was the closest thing I had, nor did I understand the riddle, nor did I
think it was funny. And I had to go to a friend of our podcast, Jonathan Colton, the musician
whose latest album, Some Guys, is just out now. It's wonderful.
But he's also a science guy.
And I said, what am I missing here?
Is there a science component to this?
And he wrote back saying, yes, it is a joke about Avogadro's number.
Avogadro being a mathematician, which is a quantity. And Avogadro's number is roughly a six with 23 zeros or six times 10 to the 23rd power.
And it is a quantity known perhaps as a pun on Avogadro as a mole or a mole.
That still doesn't look.
We'll post this dumb riddle on the Judge John Hodgman Instagram page and the show page at MaximumFun.org.
It still doesn't make sense, but it does. At least it's closer.
Britton, Jackson, what's the beef here? What's the guacamole?
Well, it's a multifaceted issue here.
Probably not. Probably it isn't. Let's try to keep it simple. It's been a long day.
Start with one facet and we'll move on from there. And the beautiful diamond of argument that you were cutting. Yes. Beautiful
girlfriend of mine, Britton, four years. She has two severe allergies and that is avocados and
cats. Two things she loves very dearly and two things that cause a lot of allergic reactions, a lot of pain.
And it's a very distressing problem for me and those who care about her, her friends,
her family.
It's a crisis would be a stretch, but it is something we do.
We are worried about.
Okay.
And do you live together?
We do.
We do.
We've lived together for three and a half years.
Oh, wonderful.
And where do you live?
We live in New Orleans, Louisiana.
Fantastic.
Laissez les bons temps rouler.
That's my motto.
What's the motto of New Orleans?
It's hot all the time.
It's hot all the time.
And muggy.
Are you guys native Louisianians?
No, no.
We are both college students.
We are both from Albuquerque, New Mexico, originally.
Oh.
So did you meet in college, or did you meet in Albuquerque?
We went to high school together.
We were band nerds.
Oh, nice.
What did you play?
We were band co-presidents together, and I played flute, and Jackson played bassoon.
Bands have presidents?
Yes, co-presidents.
Well, our band did.
Wait a minute. Was there always co-presidents. Well, our band did. Wait a minute. Was there
always co-presidents?
This was set up to settle some dispute
between the two of you. No.
This is a very interesting dilemma.
I'll decide. The year before
we were co-presidents, I was vice president.
Britain wasn't an elected office.
So essentially what happened
was we were both wanting to be
president. I was vice president. I had the qualifications.
And we both ran.
And there was a tie in the college of band students.
And it was like 24 votes to 24 votes.
And I recognized, you know, that perhaps cooperation would be great.
So I went over to the band director before we were dating, of course.
And I said, you know, co-president sounds great.
Why don't we do co-presidents? And Britton agreed. And we were co-presidents for a full year
and became very close friends. And I asked her out shortly after that.
But the election was on my birthday. I think that's really important to say.
Why is that important?
I think that Jackson should have given it to me as like a gift.
That's her day.
Got it.
And the power sharing arrangement,
other than your deep resentment written,
the power sharing arrangement worked out well.
There were no major trade wars that you had with other bands.
No, no, no.
I'd say it worked out as well as it could have. And that's how you guys fell in special friendship?
That's how you fell in love?
Yes.
Yes, we became very close friends.
And at the end of the year, she was about to go to college,
and I asked her out a couple weeks before graduation.
And then you ended up going to the same college?
You followed her there, double read?
Okay, this is also complicated.
So I went to school originally in Des Moines, Iowa for two years and I hated it
and it was really sad. And Jackson went to Tulane in New Orleans a year after me. He was a year
younger than me. So he went to Tulane and I was like, I have to transfer. I'm so sad. And so I
applied to a whole bunch of places and it, it came down to money, uh, cause college
is very expensive.
It certainly is.
And so, uh, the university here offered me more money than a university in other places.
And so I came here, but it wasn't for Jackson.
And I, I need people to know that.
Important distinction.
Did you try breaking up so that you could have your own independent life and so that
people wouldn't think that? Interesting question. It never came to that. Important distinction. Did you try breaking up so that you could have your own independent life and so that people wouldn't think? Interesting question. It never came to
that. We like each other. We enjoy each other's company. Absolutely. She's my best friend. Right.
But you're trying to kill yourself with cats and avocados. For some reason, I need to get to the
bottom of it somehow. Tell me about your allergies. Is it just cats and avocados and why those two
random things?
And are you allergic to t-shirts that have a picture of an avocado with a cat face in
the middle that say avocado?
Oh, no.
But I should get a shirt like that.
Yeah.
Just to spite Jackson.
Ouch.
I would say that my cat allergy is more severe than my avocado allergy.
With avocados, my lips just get numb, but nothing else really happens. And so I
don't feel like that's like enough to justify me getting rid of avocados. And with cats, I mean,
have you ever seen a cat? No. What is it? They're like this animal and they have ears and they have
like fur and they're very cute. Oh, okay. And they meow, they go, they meow, meow.
And it's like their own communication with humans.
They don't meow to each other.
So they just want human attention.
And I want to give that to them.
Thank you very much for straight-facedly explaining what a cat is to me.
You're very welcome.
It was hard.
They meow.
No, excuse me.
They meow, meow.
That was my favorite part of that moment.
And do you have a cat?
Jackson has three cats at his parents' house in Albuquerque.
And then in New Orleans, I have halfway adopted the neighborhood cat.
I've named him Patches, and and i feed him but he does not come
into our house that is not true and he has a collar so he clearly belongs to someone else
oh okay so he's not feral and you feed patches we're out on the backyard or something uh on the
front porch uh patches comes and meows at the door until i come outside and give it treats
and then uh and you say thates does not come into the house,
but Jackson, you sort of disagreed there.
Yes, yes.
So Patches, as a rule, doesn't come into the house
because we have roommates,
one of which is also very allergic to cats.
But one time when the roommates were out of town,
Britton opened the door and let Patches inside for a while.
It was raining.
It was drizzling.
And so I just think, you know, Patches doesn't come in all the time.
I just think saying that Patches never comes into the house,
that's a gross exaggeration.
I wouldn't say gross because it was only once,
and he was inside for like two minutes.
So how does your allergy to cats manifest itself?
I haven't
determined what kind of cats cause my allergies or not because it's very hit or miss. Sometimes
when I pet cats every once in a while, I would say that my eyes get very, very red and tears
uncontrollably stream down my face and I break out in hives.
Sort of like me when I watch Babe Pig in the City, except for the hives.
No hives for you.
That's lucky.
So you don't have a difficulty breathing.
It's not a life-threatening allergy. It's a discomfort allergy, would you say?
I would say so.
Jackson is narrowing his eyes at me, but I would say it's not life-threatening.
The worst it's ever been,
my throat was just itchy, but it never closed up. I'm still alive.
Let's take a quick break and hear about another wonderful show provided to your ears
by MaximumFun.org. We'll be back in just a second on Judge John Hodgman.
You're listening to Judge John Hodgman. i'm bailiff jesse thorn of course the judge john
hodgman podcast always brought to you by you the members of maximum fun.org thanks to everybody
who's gone to maximum fun.org join and you can join them by going to maximumumFun.org slash join. The Judge John Hodgman podcast is also brought to you this week
by the folks over there at Babbel.
Did you know that learning,
the experience of learning causes a sound to happen?
Let's hear the sound.
Yep, that's the sound of you learning a new language with Babbel.
We're talking about quick 10-minute lessons
crafted by over 200 language experts that can help you start speaking a new language in as little as one, two, three weeks.
Let's hear that sound.
Babbel's tips and tools are approachable, accessible, rooted in real-life situations, and delivered with conversation-based teaching.
So you're ready to practice what you've learned in the real world, and you get to hear this sound.
It's not just like a game
that pretends to teach you a language.
It's also not a rigid, weird, hyper-academic chore.
It is an actually productive app
that actually teaches you
while you are actually having a nice time.
And you get to hear this sound. Here's a special
limited time deal for our listeners right now. Get up to 60% off your Babbel subscription,
but only for our listeners at babbel.com slash Hodgman. Get up to 60% off at babbel.com slash
Hodgman spelled B-A-B-B-E-L dot com slash Hodgman. Rules and restrictions apply.
The Judge John Hodgman podcast
is also brought to you this week
by our pals over at Made In.
Jesse, you've heard of Tom Colicchio,
the famous chef, right?
Yeah, from the restaurant Kraft.
And did you know that most of the dishes
at that very same restaurant
are made with Made In pots and pans? Really?
What's an example? The braised short ribs. They're made in, made in. The Rohan duck. Made in,
made in. Riders of Rohan. Duck. What about the Heritage Pork Shop? You got it. Made in,
made in. Made in has been supplying top chefs and restaurants with high-end cookware for years.
Made In has been supplying top chefs and restaurants with high-end cookware for years.
They make the stuff that chefs need.
Their carbon steel cookware is the best of cast iron, the best of stainless clad.
It gets super hot.
It's rugged enough for grills or an open flame.
One of the most useful pans you can own. And like we said, good enough for real professional chefs, the best professional chefs.
Oh, so I have to go all the way down to the restaurant district in restaurant town?
Just buy it online.
This is professional grade cookware that is available online directly to you, the consumer, at a very reasonable price.
Yeah.
If you want to take your cooking to the next level, remember what so many great dishes on menus all around the world have in common. They're made in Made In. Save up to 25% this
Memorial Day from the 18th until the 27th. Visit madeincookware.com. That's M-A-D-E-I-N cookware.com.
Court is back in session.
Let's return to the courtroom to hear more of the case.
Well, you sent in some evidence and we'll put these photos up on the show page at Maximum Fund dot org and on our Instagram at Judge John Hodgman.
And the first one is this photo.
What am I seeing in this photo?
I see you, presumably, and then you're holding something and then there's something next to you with a hat.
Oh, that's Patches. Patches is what
you're holding? Yeah, we're on the front porch,
I believe. So that's what a cat
is. Okay, I got it now.
I got it. Oh, I see. It was part of your
bit. Whoa.
All right.
You know,
it's not only cats that say meow.
Sometimes humans imply meow
the claws are out along with the hives you scratched me bad
yeah sorry it was part of my bit it's so aggressive i'm so sorry i would never call
out a bit like that john are you sure that you're not having some kind of weird allergic reaction now?
Are you on an antihistamine that is causing you to take greater risks?
Or maybe you have toxoplasmosis.
I hope that my abrasiveness doesn't affect your judgment.
We shall see.
So this is an adorable photo.
Sorry about my bit being confusing.
see. So this is an adorable photo. Sorry about my bit being confusing. Of the two of you and you're holding Patches who looks to be a very adorable, maybe even a Maine Coon cat. Kind of
got that big majestic ruffs around his or her or their neck. So very characteristic of a Maine
Coon cat. And here's another picture of you petting a local cat named Creamsicle.
I named it Creamsicle.
Okay.
You don't know who owns this cat either?
No, it's always in front of the same house.
Okay.
How many neighborhood cats are you threatening to kidnap?
Those are the only two that I see on a consistent basis, but there are some other like orange
cats around.
Okay.
And then there are more pictures of more cats here.
Some delightful ones of Jackson in your bed that you share in Albuquerque when you're back in Albuquerque.
Yes.
With his cat, presumably, who is Rookie.
Yes.
Very cute.
And another Albuquerque cat, Teddy, on the couch.
And then there's Rookie again on the dining room table.
And Rookie seems to be perched over like a stuffed animal, like a stuffed monkey of some kind.
Is that right?
Yes, that is correct.
I don't know if it's a monkey.
It is a little stuffed monkey.
And the little hands you put on like a cup or you put on a different cylindrical object.
And the monkey hangs off.
So it's extra cute.
And then, oh, here's another one.
Tallulah, quote, doing nothing wrong, but I don't want her to feel left out.
And she looks very handsome as well.
So what are you showing me with this evidence that has been submitted?
Jackson says he claims that he cares about my health.
Jackson says he claims that he cares about my health.
And yet he lets his cats lie down in our bed without changing the sheets.
And Tallulah, I didn't get a picture, but she leaves giant tufts of fur on my side of the bed.
Jackson has made no effort to try and minimize my allergy attacks when we're home in Albuquerque.
I see.
So supposedly he cares about you, but he hasn't done the right thing yet and put his three cats into a sack and drive them out of town
and leave them somewhere to keep you safe.
Yeah.
Right.
Jackson, this does seem to be a little bit contradictory.
If you are concerned, I mean, what is your concern, first of all,
about Britain's health? I'm just concerned she gets very sick. It becomes a whole night thing.
She gets very sick, doesn't want to eat, you know, becomes very lethargic, wants to go to bed early,
doesn't feel good. And her throat doesn't get numb. It gets a little closed off. She has a hard
time breathing. That's not something I think was mentioned.
Well, I asked her about that specifically, and she did not say that that happened.
She said she's short of breath.
So I'm just concerned.
It's not fatal.
It's not incredibly dangerous.
But I genuinely am concerned about her being sick.
And it's just, she just doesn't feel good.
Yeah, I got it.
But if you are so concerned, sir, why are you letting Tallulah
tuft all over her side of the bed?
Why aren't you taking precautions to clear those cats out?
Absolutely.
Absolutely.
That's a great point.
You know, if...
I know.
If being around cats was, or being around hair was the thing that made Britton sick,
I would absolutely agree.
But what makes Britton sick is directly interacting with cats, putting cats in her face, getting really, you know, so Rookie, for example, is the one that really gives her a lot of allergies.
And she really likes a pet Rookie, likes to be around him and then feel sick.
So, you know, it's not necessarily just the presence of the allergen in the house.
It is the fact that the cat is, you know, she picks him up.
She cuddles him.
She pets him.
She really, really loves touching
cats. That's a very big facet, I think, of my argument here is that what really causes the
allergic reaction is the aggressive handling of the cat. Let the record show that Jackson
has submitted photos of his beloved girlfriend written getting hives. Yes. Yeah. Describe what I'm seeing here and why you chose to share this,
not only with the podcast, but the entire community at the Instagram account of Judge
John Hodgman. Absolutely. I just think it's very critical for yourself to see that the allergies
aren't minor. You know, it is visible. It is painful. This isn't just a minor allergy. I sneeze. It's more serious.
Have you tried taking an antihistamine, Britton?
I have taken Zyrtec, and I don't think that it helps.
But also, I hate taking medication in general for no reason other than laziness, I guess.
And I've tried Benadryl as well, but it really knocks me out and it makes me feel very sick.
Yeah, no, that's heavy duty stuff.
I will say my parents have allergies.
We have Zyrtec in the house and every time she gets sick, I do offer to grab some Zyrtec.
My parents offer, but the offer is repeatedly turned down.
So I will offer to actually pick it up and get it for her. We have it in the house.
We'll bring her the water and the medication. So I just don't really see the point in taking medication if I'm already in the middle of an allergy attack. I might as well just ride
it out because it'll make me stronger. Are you a doctor? No. I just don't know how to evaluate
that claim that you are inoculating yourself to the allergens by going through the discomfort that you feel. It might be true. I
don't know. I don't mean necessarily that going through the allergy attack will take away my
allergies. I just mean that it makes me a tougher person. Have you ever gone to an allergist? No.
So your perception of your allergies is basically just what you've experienced in life.
It's like, oop, throat's numb, can't breathe, it's got to be the avocado.
Well, I can always breathe.
It's never gotten to that point.
But yes.
When we discovered the avocado allergy, maybe like a year ago, I would say, because I'd always noticed that my lips get pretty numb.
And that time it was really bad, particularly.
And I was trying a new brand of store-bought guacamole.
And I had always just assumed that it was the salt in chips.
Right.
Do you have health insurance?
I used to not.
And then we recently, my parents recently got health insurance.
But I only have health insurance in New Mexico.
And at this point in time, I am very rarely home in New Mexico.
Do you not have a health plan through your university?
No.
My university has some bad things happening to it.
Oh, okay. We will not get into that. Suffice it to say, jaguar attack. I was going to presume
that it's a Louisiana-based side campus of Miskatonic University from the H.P. Lovecraft
universe. And I was going to say Cthulhu attacks, but it could be both Cthulhus and Jaguars.
No, it's alligators.
Is it really?
No.
Don't joke about alligator attack with me.
I'm sorry.
I don't know what's going on down there.
You got me very excited for a second there.
That's very fair.
I'm very sorry.
You know what they used to call avocados?
Alligator pears.
I'm not joking.
Okay.
Because you're being marauded by jaguars that have little avocados dangling around their necks,
the university's budget is strained and therefore cannot offer you a health plan there in Louisiana.
Correct?
Right.
They just can't offer me a very comprehensive health plan. So I can get like basic things done. Like I can go get a strep throat test, but they could never do allergy
tests or anything like that. But that is something that you could avail yourself of in Albuquerque
if you wanted. Yeah. Right. And when you go to Albuquerque, you're staying with Jackson's family?
Yeah, I usually stay over at their house just because my parents gave my room immediately to my little sister when I moved to college.
And we live in a very small house with a lot of kids.
I thought you were going to say, I usually go over to Jackson's house because my parents, after I moved out, filled my room with guacamole.
Just to keep me away.
Numbers.
We just didn't know you were coming back.
Well, I guess between this and the cats over there, the cats are less of a risk.
If it helps, honey, we covered the top in lemon juice so it wouldn't go brown.
So how often do you go back to Albuquerque? I would say probably three to four times a year.
Britain is actually going back to Albuquerque pretty soon as well. Yeah, it seems like it's
a part of your life. Absolutely. Absolutely. That's where both of our families are from.
It's very important. And Britain, you know, just so that I understand, like,
families are from it's it's very important and britain you know just so that i understand like jackson says that it's not the cat's fur that's left all over the bed and all over the couch and
all over the counter and dander but it's your getting up in rookie and talula and other one's
face that is causing the problem do you dispute that or do you agree that that's true? I don't really agree with what he's saying, but I mean, I don't really, I don't think we have a way
of knowing exactly what's causing it because I always pet cats, but I also, I also always lie
down in a bed with cat dander. So what's the worst reaction you've had either with a cat
or with an avocado or a cat smeared in avocado i would say that my
worst reaction um there i'm i'm sure jackson submitted it there's like a picture sorry that
that was my impression of millennial alf um i would i think i am pretty sure he submitted it
there's like a picture of uh me with my eyes, really red, making a pouty face.
And that's like right at the beginning of an allergic reaction.
And then after that, my whole face swelled up and I got home and my eyes were swollen shut.
Whoa.
My roommates had to had to help me sit down.
I would say that's the worst it's ever been,
but that's the only time it's ever been that bad.
Eyes swollen shut is a meaningful allergic reaction.
And also a little known sequel to eyes wide shut by Stanley Kubrick.
Although he did not direct it.
It was actually directed by Uwe Boll.
That's serious stuff how did they aside from
helping you sit down which literally seems like the least they could do did they help you get
some medical attention or take some medicine or or how did how did it resolve yeah i took one
i don't know what what it was i think it was probably a zyrtec uh I took a Zyrtec and then I went to sleep.
And then I woke up the next morning and my eyes were a little bit less swollen.
How long was it before you felt 100% again?
I would say like the middle of the day the next day.
But notice I did not die.
This is taking a real turn.
Oh, no.
Well, mostly I was like, you know, let a person scratch a cat.
If they get a little runny eye, a little snotty, then that's a transaction that they're making with the cat.
And they're paying the price that they're willing to pay.
But eyes swollen shut, that's heavy.
That's heavy stuff.
It was only one time.
Why do you think it happened that one time and not every time?
I was cat sitting um
like two pretty fluffy cats um that weekend so this was uh i i want to lie but i can't lie
because i'm under oath yes that's probably that reaction probably happened three or four hours
after i went over to that house those cats in particular were out to get you there's one more
piece of evidence that i need to understand what it is.
It's a picture of you feeding a goose,
Britain.
Yes.
Yes.
I,
I did submit this.
So I,
uh,
I submitted this,
you know,
Britain,
Britain loves animals,
uh,
but she doesn't always have the best judgment of when to pet an animal or what
animal to pet.
Um,
and you know,
this was,
we were taking a little road trip and there were some geese outside of our, uh, hotel and Britain wanted to pet. And, you know, this was, we were taking a little road trip and there were some geese outside
of our hotel and Britton wanted to pet one. So she chased it around. And then she, I think the
specific picture that you're seeing is when she got some bread and was feeding one, but she fed
them for the purpose of petting them. And she did pet the goose, but the goose was very aggressive.
I just think it's important to know
that her judgment surrounding certain animals
and when to pet them is a little into question here.
Yeah, you can't pet a goose.
Geese are nasty.
They're mean creatures.
But I did pet a goose.
This is kind of one in a series of incidents.
Hang on a second.
I'm sorry.
Wait a minute, Jackson.
I just don't want you to talk over
the incredible moment of pride that Britain expressed when she said, but I did pet a goose.
That's something I got to stand behind.
You set out a goal.
You set out to pet.
We're not talking about cats anymore.
We're talking about, we may need to bleep this out because this is a family friendly podcast.
We're talking about the a**holes of the animal kingdom.
Geese are the worst.
It was good.
It sat right next to me.
It was plucking bread out of my hand, and I ran my hand down its back.
And did you get an allergic reaction?
Of course not.
No, you're not allergic to goose or goose down?
No, but maybe I didn't pet them long enough to find out.
Well, just something that might inform my verdict and my sentence.
All right, Jackson, what's happening here?
Why?
I know, I know.
Let her have some fun.
Let her have fun.
Well, so, okay, I would like to say this is one in a series of incidents
with animals.
One time she was bit by a dog that there was a suspicion that had rabies
because she was petting it.
And so I just,
it's one of several different incidents.
The same incident with the goose,
she also threw bread at the geese.
Look, a brave, brave soul,
but the judgment I don't necessarily know
was really there.
People throw bread at geese.
That's not a crime.
But do they hit geese? It's just pointless because you'll never get geese to like you.
That is true. What is your real fear that might, I mean, obviously the
allergy fear is a concern. What would you have me order if I were to find in your favor?
You know, there's a few things. I think one, maybe, you know, me and Britton can go to an
allergist and see, you know, what the allergy is can go to an allergist and see, you know,
what the allergy is. Maybe it's a certain type of cat, you know, maybe the avocado allergy is an avocado allergy. I do believe it is, uh, just so we can get the facts straight and then we can,
you know, make our next move. You know, I know nowadays what they have medications you can take
that, you know, shots or medications that get you used to cat allergens. You know,
I want, I love cats. Britain loves cats. We love cats together. I want that to work.
I just don't like seeing her in pain. I don't like seeing her sick.
You don't want to put Britain in a bubble? Oh, maybe you do. Maybe she should go in a
bubble boy bubble. Then she'll be safe forever. If you rule that way, I'll have to abide by your ruling. Britton, Jackson just wants you to get some medical attention, consultation, and a plan in action so that you not only will avoid life-threatening or at least eye-closing allergic reactions,
but also maybe it sounds like transitioning to having a cat in your own home so you don't have to be creeping on all the neighborhood cats and also the dogs that might be rabid.
Well, the dog wasn't rabid, to be fair.
I don't have rabies.
No, I understand.
Jackson brought that up for no reason.
But you understand that going around and petting a bunch of animals that don't belong to you Whether they're dogs or they're geese or they're the neighbor's cats or whatever
We're rolling some dice there
You could get a rabid dog at some point
You could get accused of being a cat thief in the neighborhood
You can get a rep
Would you like to have a cat of your own or are you just into playing the field as it were?
I definitely want a cat someday and I also want a dog.
What's your dog allergy situation?
My dog allergy situation is non-existent.
Dogs are great and they love me and I love dogs.
So why aren't you getting a dog?
Why don't you have a dog today?
My roommate, Andrew Lewis, refuses to let us get a dog.
First and last name.
He refuses.
You're out there doxing people to get a dog.
He says that we're too irresponsible to get a dog.
And I say that if I can take care of Patches, the neighborhood cat, I can take care of a dog.
But that's, I'm sorry, that's a different dispute.
So wait a minute, you guys live together, right?
But you also have a roommate.
Is that what's happening?
Yeah, so we live close to campus.
Me and Britton share a room, and then we have two other roommates.
We live in a three-bedroom house.
Yeah, and so of the four roommates, three out of the four say we should get a dog.
One out of the four does not.
Oh, would this be Andrew Lewis?
Andrew Lewis of Virginia.
Whoa, Virginia Andrew Lewis. Andrew Lewis of Virginia. Whoa. Virginia
Andrew Lewis?
Of the Virginia Lewis's?
Yes. Well, you can't
get a dog in a
shared apartment unless there is unanimous
consent. Yes. Did you take a
vote on a cat as a possibility?
Andrew Lewis of Virginia, who is blonde,
is very allergic to cats, so
he claims. Brynn is also blonde, I would is very allergic to cats. So he claims.
Britain is also blonde.
I would like the record to state.
This is a comedy fake justice podcast, not a eugenics podcast.
Let's not worry about it.
I just wanted to circle back really quickly to this medication thing.
Yeah.
Because I've done a lot of research on getting shots, which is what Jackson is
suggesting I do. And shots are very expensive. The odds are not that great that they'll work.
And you have to go get a shot every single week for months. And there's no way I could do that
because I'm not in Albuquerque for months at a time, ever. Right. So what would you have me rule if I were to find in your favor?
I just think I should be able to pet cats and eat avocados and deal with my allergies.
I would find it fair if Jackson and my roommates wanted me to stop complaining about my allergies
because I think that that is probably, underneath all of this, their main qualm.
Oh, is that what's going on, Jackson, that she complains too much?
No, no, not at all.
I'm okay.
I'm totally, she's in pain.
I want to know.
I want to know how I can help.
But quick question.
Do you guys intend to get an apartment or home situation of your own without roommates
sometime in the future? I mean,
I know that you're young and you're in college and everything else, but.
Yeah, we do intend to get an apartment or hopefully eventually a home after we graduate
and maybe after graduate school. But we do hope to live alone in a few years.
What are you guys studying?
I'm an English major with a political science minor.
Good.
And I study, I'm a history major with a philosophy minor and an Africana studies minor.
Well, maybe an apartment might be in your future.
I'm not sure about a freestanding home.
History and English major.
Ouch.
Sorry.
If Apple computer hadn't come to the rescue, I'd be living in a hut.
So I went to UC Santa Cruz. When you graduate,
they issue you a yurt. So I'd be living in a tiny home in my parents' garage. So just pull that
right in there. Pull my minivan in there and sleep in the back with my family. Oh, so it's not a tiny
home. It's a minivan. It's a minivan. Yeah, it's a minivan. I call it a tiny home, but it's really a Chrysler Pacifica, which is where I'm going to go right now.
I'm going to climb into my mobile chambers and think this over.
I'll be back in a moment with my decision.
Please rise as Judge John Hodgman exits the courtroom.
Britton, you filed suit.
How do you feel about your chances?
suit. How do you feel about your chances? I don't want to be too confident, but I do want to say that I had notes and Jackson did not. So I think my argument was better. But I do think that I may
have ruined my chances by admitting that my eyes did swell shut once. That was a mistake.
Jackson, how are you feeling? I'm feeling pretty good.
I think my argument is on pretty sound logic.
And I thought the questions that the judge asked were very much directed towards Britain and her position.
So maybe that means something good for me.
But, you know, I'm ready to accept the judge's verdict.
Pretty confident for a guy with no notes.
Thank you.
Although, to be fair, as Shakespeare once wrote,
you may do it extempore, for it is nothing but roaring.
She's the English major.
Shakespeare.
Wow.
Yeah.
Whoops.
You might consider a different major.
I have very little interest in Shakespeare.
Whoa.
Can I tell you a secret?
Yes.
Do you also have a very little interest in Shakespeare?
I went to theater school for four years, and I think Shakespeare is super boring.
Oh, thank God.
I thought you were about to say that you loved Shakespeare so much, and you were really offended.
Oh, thank God. I thought you were about to say that you loved Shakespeare so much and you were really offended.
We'll see what Judge John Hodgman has to say about all this and the Bard of Stratford-upon-Avon when we come back in just a second on the Judge John Hodgman podcast.
Hello, teachers and faculty. This is Janet Varney. I'm here to remind you that listening to my podcast, The JV Club with Janet Varney, is part of the curriculum for the school year. Learning about the teenage years of such guests as Alison Brie, Vicki Peterson, John Hodgman, and so many more is a valuable and enriching experience, one you have no choice but to embrace,
because, yes, listening is mandatory.
The JV Club with Janet Varney is available every Thursday
on Maximum Fun or wherever you get your podcasts.
Thank you.
And remember, no running in the halls.
Please rise as Judge John Hodgman re-enters the courtroom and presents his verdict.
You may be seated.
So, you know, my time for consideration was limited.
So it may be that there is a Shakespeare quote regarding allergies, but I was not able to find it in the time allotted to me.
I also did not have any notes.
Today was a bit of a seat of pants flying day for me due to a project that got me here to my chambers a little late.
And so we just had a nice conversation.
chambers a little late and so we just had a nice conversation both jackson and i thus were winging it and i don't think either one of us were well prepared at all for the
incredibly derisive zingers that britain was going to throw our way my way in particular about my
bits nor the withering disdain for andrew lew, or equally withering hatred of the Bard of Avon.
Britain is a person of strong opinions and obviously strong will.
And I appreciate why she might bring Jackson to this court to stop mother-henning her with regard to her love of animals and her agency over her own body, hives and swollen eyes.
That that is the price that she is willing to pay to get her face up in the face of a cat.
Now, Jackson, if it were the case that you were honest and truthful and could say the truth is Britain just complains about this so much, it's so annoying, then that could be done in your favor in this regard. Because she is submitting to willingly to discomfort for her own pleasure, but then making inconveniencing you with a bunch of whining and moaning about it after it was her own dumb fault to begin with.
But you're too nice a guy.
You know, I understand co-band presidents
don't like to snitch on each other. You're too nice a guy to say that she complains too much,
even when she gave you that opportunity. That would have given you some standing for me to
find in your favor. Britain, you claim that you are handling your allergies and that you should be left alone to handle them.
And I would say this.
True.
But I don't think you're really being responsible with your own body.
I don't think that this is a life-threatening allergy.
You're saying, I tried a Zyrtec once. It didn't work. I don't
want to take medication. I want to have a cat someday, but I don't want to go to the doctor,
et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. You know, I get it. You have strong opinions. To you,
allergists are the Shakespeare of the medical community. Who cares? Overrated.
overrated.
I agree with you that as someone who was absolutely treated to every allergy shot I could get when I was growing up,
all the allergy tests were done upon me.
My,
that almost sounds like Shakespeare there.
All the allergy tests were done upon me.
My skin was pricked by many a test needle. And yet, and yet,
nothing could cause the allergies to disperse my humors, except time and inundation of dander.
That's pretty good. That's pretty good fake shakespeare a little bit no rhymes i don't
don't talk to me about any pentameter eventually i got over it i guess i got used to cats
and so i have owned many a cat with nary an allergy problem but do i keep a supply of zyrtec
on hand yeah do i think that having antihistamines on hand proactively, especially if you're going over
to a house sit two white fluffy cats? Yeah, you should take those precautions. And what's more,
though I don't necessarily feel, and I appreciate your not only unwillingness, but the sheer
inconvenience of going through a course of allergy shots to try to get over your cat allergy.
I don't think it would be of harm.
And indeed, I would encourage you to, next time you're in Albuquerque, get thee to an
allergy-uree and just talk about what's been going on and seeing what that doctor might
recommend to A, see if there's something you could take prophylactically
so that you can enjoy these cats without having to worry about it,
and, B, whether or not you should have, like, an EpiPen with you
in case you should ever have a really serious allergic reaction that you did not expect.
You know what an EpiPen is, I'm sure.
It's a self-stabber with a medication in it that gets you over that
throat swelling and eye swelling stuff. I think those would be reasonable precautions
as an adult that you should take. And yet, because it is your body and it is your life,
I am not ordering you to do these things. I'm just suggesting that you consider it strongly, not only for yourself, but for the peace of mind of Jackson, who obviously cares for you and does not want you to suffer and worries.
If I were to find out that my loved person had their eyes swollen shut, I too would be extremely worried.
And I might even ask very seriously for some action.
So I am finding in your favor, Britain,
that you should be able to live your life as you like,
as riskily as you wish,
presuming that you've already been infected with toxoplasmosis,
the cat-mouse-poop-bacteria virus.
It's a virus, not a bacteria, sorry.
That causes people to act irrationally
and erratically and go up to cats all the time to get near them even if and especially if they're
cats they do not own but that said i think you can fight your instincts and be a responsible
human being if only in consideration to the person that you love. But that is a strong
suggestion and not an order. And Jackson and Britton, I hope that you guys get a place of
your own soon so you can at least get away from that cad, Andrew Lewis of Virginia.
Oh, the Virginia Andrew Lewis. I hope you get away from that guy soon and replace him with
a beautiful cat of your own. Maybe a sphinx cat.
They don't have hair.
This is the sound of a gavel.
Judge John Hodgman rules.
That is all.
Please rise as Judge John Hodgman exits the court.
Britton, how do you feel about the result?
I feel great.
I feel a little attacked by the judge, but rightfully so.
I said some inappropriate things to him.
You scratch me, I scratch back.
Come on.
Absolutely.
The claws are out and so are the hives.
I completely admit that it is my fault.
And yeah, I'm happy just because I told Jackson very confidently that I was going to win.
And I did.
So, ha.
Ha ha.
In conclusion, I pet a goose. Ha. There's this one Root song where they go, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha. And whenever someone says, ha, that's all I can think
of. Jackson, how do you feel? I think the judge is correct. And, you know, Brynn's correct.
Absolutely.
It's her body.
She's got to make the choices.
I would feel very uncomfortable if the judge, in fact, ordered a specific medication or, you know, it's her choice.
I felt that his additional conclusion to, you know, think about, you know, being responsible adult and taking medication was a great uh a great piece of that
but i i'd absolutely agree i was very confident um it stings but you know you learn you learn you
fall down you pick yourself up and you learn so uh i feel pretty good i feel pretty good
jackson britain thanks for joining us on the judge john hodgman podcast
if you need a laugh and you're on the go try s-t-o-P-P-O-D-C-A-S-T-I.
Hmm.
Were you trying to put the name of the podcast there?
Yeah, I'm trying to spell it, but it's tricky.
Let me give it a try.
Okay.
If you need a laugh and you're on the go, call S-T-O-P-P-P-A-D-I.
It'll never fit.
No, it will.
Let me try.
If you need a laugh and you're on the go, try S-T-O-P-P-P-D-C-O-O.
Ah, we are so close. Stop podcasting yourself. A podcast from MaximumFun.org.
If you need a laugh and you're on the go.
Another Judge John Hodgman case in the books. Before we dispense swift justice, we want to thank Matt Crocker for naming this week's episode Double His Demeanor.
If you'd like to name a future episode like Judge John Hodgman on Facebook, we regularly put out our call for submissions there.
Follow us on Twitter.
John is at Hodgman.
I am at Jesse Thorne.
Hashtag your Judge John Hodgman tweets.
Hashtag JJHO.
And check out the Maximum Fun subreddit to discuss this episode.
We're on Instagram at Judge John Hodgman. Make sure to follow us there for evidence and other fun stuff.
This week's episode recorded by Thomas Walsh at WWNO Radio in New Orleans, who, let the record reflect, totally got the avocado guacamole
joke.
Our producer is the great Jennifer Marmer.
Now, Swift Justice, where we answer your small disputes with a quick judgment.
Are you ready, Judge Hodgman?
I am ready.
Thea says, when I have a cold or flu, my partner insists on sleeping with his head next to my feet and vice versa.
He says this will protect him from germs.
I think it's ridiculous.
And it kind of hurts my feelings.
By the way, we share our bed with a 10-year-old pug who routinely sneezes on one of us or the other.
I don't like any of this.
This bed sounds gross.
I don't like any of this.
This bed sounds gross.
I don't think it is fair to stigmatize your partner when they are feeling sick by shoving your feet in their face.
I think that under extreme circumstances, you know, it would be fair to give the sick person the bed and go and sleep on the couch or something.
But I feel like there's just something weird and aggressive about putting your feet in someone's face.
And I know that sleeping head to toe is something that's been done for many a year.
Most famously in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory.
Yeah, right.
I mean, well, that's the thing like having four people sleeping in a bed in the middle of your one living space it's just like that's something you have to endure it's not a good idea it's just something
you have to get through till you can get that sweet glass elevator money everyone does you
know what we want what we deserve in life is a little bit of dignity when we go to bed and we're at our most vulnerable.
And if possible, you know, have a comfortable place to sleep that's well heated.
It's one of the great, unfortunately, a great luxury for many a human being on this earth.
Shoving your feet in your beloved's face, not affording them dignity.
And I might encourage Thea to purposely get athlete's foot and just rub it in his face the next time he does this.
But maybe a better thing to do is,
if you're afraid of getting sick because your partner is sick,
feel compassion for them.
Maybe you can wear a mask or maybe go sleep on the couch.
And as far as the pug is concerned,
I'm sure your little snot bucket is delightful,
but that's between you and
you and you guys. I don't want to hear about your pug drooling on you all night long. That's gross.
That's about it for this week's episode. Submit your cases at MaximumFun.org
slash JJHO or email Hodgman at MaximumFun.org. No case is too small.
Apparently.
We'll see you next time on the Judge John Hodgman podcast.
Maximumfun.org.
Comedy and culture. Artist owned.
Listener supported.