Judge John Hodgman - Habeas Cropus

Episode Date: September 28, 2022

Alan brings the case against his wife, Tawni. Tawni has accumulated a lot of plants in their apartment. She says that some of the plants need to have grow lights in order to thrive. But, Alan does not like the lights. He would rather have plants that don’t need the lights. Who’s right? Who’s wrong?Thank you to Twitter User @IronyMaiden for naming this week’s case! To suggest a title for a future episode, follow us on Twitter for naming opportunities: @JesseThorn & @Hodgman. Or keep track using the Twitter hashtag #JJHoCaseNames.

Welcome to the Judge John Hodgman podcast. I'm bailiff Jesse Thorne. This week, habeas cropus. Alan brings the case against his wife, Tawny. Tawny has accumulated a lot of plants in their apartment. She says that some of the plants need to have grow lights in order to thrive. Alan doesn't like the lights. He'd rather have plants that don't need them. Who's right? Who's wrong? Only one can decide. Please rise as Judge John Hodgman enters the courtroom and presents an obscure cultural reference.

Enough of Famintzen and of Darwin. I hope you will not be offended if I say that what we think is not only not important, but that old men like us preparing to appear before capital H him should even be ashamed that it is disgraceful and sinful to talk and think about growing plants indoors with artificial lighting. Bailiff Jesse Thorne, please swear the litigants in. Allen and Tawny, please rise and raise your right hands. Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God or whatever?

Absolutely. Yes. Do you swear to abide by Judge John Hodgman's ruling, despite the fact that he has no green thumb? Well, he has two green thumbs because his entire hands are green. Yep. Yep. Judge Hodgman. I dip them in a bucket of paint. Alan and Tawny, first of all, you may be seated for an immediate summary judgment on your favorites. Can either of you name the piece of culture I referenced when I entered the courtroom? Alan, any guesses? Let me just read it again. I'm going to read the correct

quote this time. See if that makes a difference. Okay. I did make some adjustments there. Enough of Famintzin and of Darwin. I hope you will not be offended if I say that what we think about how species originated is not only not important, but that old men like us preparing to appear before him, that's capital H-I-M as in God or whatever, should even be ashamed that it is disgraceful and sinful to talk and think about that. He was not, and all right, there's some more information.

It is a he, he, him pronouns on this diarist. I'll give you one more hint. Oh, but he was not talking about growing plants indoors with artificial lighting. He was actually talking about Darwin's theories. We shouldn't even speculate on the origin of species. Very famous Russian author, Alan. Let's go with Dostoevsky. All right, Tawny.

Well, I guess I'll go with one of the other ones, Tolstoy. Tolstoy is correct, Tawny. Tolstoy did not like Darwin. I was going to guess Smirnoff. Sure. Of course. Yakov, of course. Indeed.

Yeah. Tolstoy did not like Darwin. You probably cannot guess what academic study I found this quote in, however. That would be the great Tolstoyists, HughLean's book In Quest of Tolstoy. And the reason that I brought it up is when he says we know who he's talking about, Darwin. But one of Darwin's defenders in Russia as the principles of evolution were first being published was Andre Famintzin, a Russian botanist who in 1868 was the first person to grow plants indoors with artificial light. That was Famintzin's innovation and Tolstoy didn't like him because he was palled up with Darwin. That was

a very contentious time. And by I mean palled up with Darwin, they would go drinking together all the time. Famintzin and Darwin would go nuts on the Smirnoff vodka in this case. At the Smirnoff vodka in this case. At the Smirnoff show. At the Yakov Smirnoff show in Branson, Missouri, of course. Yeah. Well, you know what? They were eventually both banned from Branson in 1868.

In any case, Tawny Allen, we have to hear this case. So who comes to seek justice before this court? Be it Allen or Tawny? It be I, Judge. All right. So who comes to seek justice before this court? Be it Alan or Tawny? It be I, Judge. All right. English is a living language. Okay, it be I.

That's a sentence now. What is your complaint, Alan? So my lovely wife, Tawny, who is a whole human being in her own right, has these finicky tropical plants that require lots of sunlight. She keeps our plants by the large south-facing window of our apartment in Vancouver, BC. Above the finicky plants, she has these several plant lights that she leaves on for at least 12 hours a day, which I inevitably am the one who turns them off at night. And this is sort of part of a bigger problem, which is that Tawny is both beautiful and brilliant in equal measure. And I love her immensely, but she can be something

of a light switch goblin. She often leaves lights on wherever she goes in the apartment. I find that leaving lights on around the apartment is a wasteful carbon expense. It's also a sensory issue for me. I'm quite sensitive to bright lights, especially at night. And we plan to move from Vancouver, BC to Halifax, Nova Scotia this fall and buy a house. I'm worried that with three times as much space, we'll have three times as many plant lights and three times as many lights that I'll have to turn off as I wander the house, like the 35-year-old curmudgeony spirit that I am. So I'd really love it if Tani could avoid buying these high-maintenance plants that require their own lights and be more mindful of leaving lights on when she leaves a room for

the sake of our carbon footprint and my wee peepers. Wow. Well, that was very cogently put and very well expressed. I am able to see you out there by the magic of teleconferencing in Vancouver, British Columbia. Do I guess correctly that you were glancing down at some notes from time to time? Uh, it's actually like an SNL setup where I have cue cards, um, that are being flashed to me across the room. Well, no, Tony's a lawyer. So I had to come with my a game and, uh, I don't want to be trying to beat her in an oral argument. So. Uh, it was extremely well-prepared counselor and delivered with all the Brio of a best man toast at a wedding. Thank you, Judge.

Thank you. Everything Alan says sounds eminently reasonable. Tawny, how do you respond? So I love caring for plants. It gives me a lot of joy. I'm not very good at it by any means. I picked it up maybe five years ago or so. I started with one or two here and there that

would die. And then I would do some research and get some advice from friends. And I started figuring out what plants needed to thrive when they needed to be watered. I have little instruments that help me know when they need to be watered. And one of the things that I got advice on is that some plants, well, most plants, in fact, that regular people buy for their houses at the plant store down the road are tropical plants for whatever reason. I don't really know why. I haven't looked into it. The kind that thrive in the Pacific Northwest. The kind that thrive in Pacific Northwest living rooms anyway. Right.

But Vancouver, which is what we call Stop Podcasting Yourself Country, is very lush, to be fair. Very wet and lush. It's verdant. It's a more verdant and peaceful world. Absolutely. Vancouver, British Columbia. I hope that we can return to it soon on tour. Please do. Right.

But you're talking about tropical plants like southern tropics. Tropical is what you mean. Tropical. Yeah. Yeah. Like I haven't looked into where they're from, but. Banana plants and coconut trees is what you're talking about. Similar.

Yeah. Jungle, Costa Rica, you know, Malaysia, these types of places where they originate from. Now, I also, through the magic of teleconferencing, can spy on you. And you seem to be, there's a background, which is either a fake background or a real background. And oh, boy, that came as a surprise. Hang on. Hang on. Let me screenshot that so I can, could you lean away again? Thank you. Wow. All right. That, uh, did not see that giant cat tapestry coming that is, uh, directly behind your head. Is that a virtual background?

No, it is a real background. Um, Alan found this tapestry, which is about maybe it's probably five feet tall, um, at a garage sale in Toronto in 2016 or something. I think he paid $5 for it. He brought it home thinking that I was going to hate it and demand that he put it out onto the curb. But I love it. I think it's fantastic. And obviously, we'll put this photographic evidence with your permission if you grant it up on the Judge John Hodgman Instagram account and the show page at MaximumFun.org. But what we're looking at is a tapestry of a rather giant cat in front of a very lush forest with fake trees like that.

Hang on a minute. I just remembered a really corny joke. With fake trees like that in your house, why do you even need these plants? I mean, that's a good question. I could just stare at cotton trees all day. Cotton tapestry trees. Tell me why you love the plants so much and what kind of plants do you have? What kind of tropical plants do you have?

Yeah. So my favorite plant is the one that I got first, which I've sort of had the longest and I've had the most time to figure out exactly what it needs, which is a pothos plant. They're super beginner friendly. They're really easy to take care of. And they're kind of they're vining. So what I like about them is that they grow long vines and I can kind of drape them here and there and I can make them look kind of bigger and more beautiful. The pothos, I'm looking at a photograph of it on the internet and I would characterize this as like the classic fern bar indoor plant that's not a fern. So it's the kind that grows in a hanging pot and drapes down below.

Hang on. Now, Alan, stay exactly where you are, Alan. I'm going to screenshot you there. Now, Alan is showing us that plant in his own using his own teleconferencing camera. And there it is. A vining green plant that is slowly reaching for Alan's shoulder and soon will devour him because that's what plants need. Right. They need light.

They need water. They need earth. They need air and they need water, they need earth, they need air, and they need human blood, right? Yes. Feed me, they say. Feed me. That's what they say. Feed me. The toothed plants say feed me. Well, that's a very lovely plant. Is that one of the ones that needs a special grow light, Donnie? Well, right. So the pothos plants don't necessarily need grow lights. They do okay in low light situations. So those ones, I generally don't have a grow light turned on them unless I'm sort of wanting them to grow thicker and more lush because they do grow faster and with thicker leaves if I put a grow light on them, but they don't need them in order to spread new leaves.

Right. That sounds that I have- That sounds like the perfect plant for your apartment, whether it be Toronto, BC, or Halifax, Nova Scotia. It's the perfect plant for any province. They're wonderful. I do really love them, and we have several. And Alan's giving a thumbs up to these plants. Why are we talking about a non-controversial plant? Which are the plants that need the grow lights? are we talking about a non-controversial plant which are the plants that need the grow lights right so last year i got a monstera plant which is also right next to alan at the moment um and these ones are bigger and they have bigger leaves um and they get is it called monstera

like monster with an a yeah okay also known as a swiss cheese plant uh monstera, like monster with an A? Yeah. Okay. Also known as a Swiss cheese plant. Monstera is better. Monster A is better, I think. It's probably the best name. I agree. So these ones have quite large leaves and large stems. So I have found that if I don't put a grow light on them, the stems get very, very long and the leaves get small. long and the leaves get small. So the plant ends up looking just like a lot of skinny stalks rather than sort of a lush big leafed plant.

Okay. So your monster A plants need to grow light. And what kind of grow light are you using on them? Do you have photos of these monster A's? It's in the evidence. Well, let's take a look at that evidence then. Yeah. First of all, here's a wonderful dog named Hazel standing in a bunch of fallen cherry blossoms that is a really nice looking dog

yeah yeah now i'm going to explain for the listeners and they can check it out for themselves at the instagram page at judge john hodgman or at our show page maximumfund.org but this looks like a fairly handsome grow light to me because when I grew up, my mom grew some stuff in the, in the basement with grow lights and she had some hanging fluorescent lights hanging on like clang against each other, like a haunted wind chime. And I don't know what my mom was growing down there. It was probably nothing, probably getting some tomatoes started. You know what I mean? But these fluorescent lights in the basement looked very creepy and they looked really illegal. That is not what we're seeing in this photo. So Alan, what do you find so offensive about this? So in Tani's defense, she is the

crochet queen. So she took a very everyday looking plant light and she added these beautiful tassels to the bottom of it. So she made it look as good as it does. And I don't find anything necessarily offensive about the light. Wait, Tawny, you crocheted this grow light cover? I didn't crochet it. I have access to wool and I tied little knots and I made tassels and I tied them around the plant, around the lampshade. Yeah. First of all, I appreciate your commitment to the truth. And second of all, I appreciate your access to wool. Most of the lamp came intact, but she added the tassels.

I'm just a proud crochet observer. And this piece of personal handiwork by your beloved partner, Tawny, along with the lamp that it is covering is what you want to throw in the garbage. No, I love all of her crochet. In fact- This isn't crochet, Alan. She has access to wool. I would like her to crochet all of the walls of our apartment. I've even

sort of tried to inspire designs for my birthday. I think I know my verdict. I'll be back in a moment with my decision. She just has access to so much wool. We have about 10 pounds of wool right now, to be honest. Uh-huh.

So I love the look of the lamp. I just wish it wasn't on for 12 hours a day um and so that's really the the big issue with it okay this just looks like a lamp it's being on all the time offends you from a conservation like of energy yeah it's a conservation issue point of view as well as your own sensitivity to light it's a a conservation issue. It's also one of the many lights that I have to turn off in the evenings or just at some point throughout the day. Tawny, do you not remember to turn off these lamps? I would remember to turn them off at my preferred time to turn them off. But Alan always turns them

off before I would rather them be turned off. So that's why he always turns them off. You know, I just realized that I have the perfect solution to this dispute. Jesse Thorne. What's that? Well, Alan has light sensitivity issues and doesn't want to see these lights on all the time.

Right. Yeah. Why doesn't Tawny just pull the wool over? She has access to it. Holy. Holy sheep. More like it. If she made me a crochet body bag, I would has access to it. Holy cow. Holy sheep. More like it. If she made me a crocheted body bag, I would gladly live in it.

John, do you need me to go get Monty Belmonte to fill in? I'm trying to make a podcast. She has access to the wool. Why doesn't she just pull it over his eyes? Let's take a quick recess and hear about this week's Judge John Hodgman sponsor. We'll be back in just a moment on the Judge John Hodgman podcast. Hello, I'm your Judge John Hodgman.

The Judge John Hodgman podcast is brought to you every week by you, our members, of course. Thank you so much for your support of this podcast and all of your favorite podcasts at MaximumFun.org, and they are all your favorites. If you want to join the many member supporters of this podcast and this network, boy, oh boy, that would be fantastic. Just go to MaximumFun.org slash join. The Judge John Hodgman podcast is also brought to you this week by the folks over there at Babbel. Did you know that learning, the experience of learning causes a sound to happen? Let's hear the sound. Yep, that's the sound of you learning a new language with Babbel. We're talking about quick 10-minute lessons crafted by over 200 language experts that

can help you start speaking a new language in as little as one, two, three weeks. Let's hear that sound. Babbel's tips and tools are approachable, accessible, rooted in real-life situations, and delivered with conversation-based teaching. So you're ready to practice what you've learned in the real world, and you get to hear this sound. It's not just like a game that pretends to teach you a language. It's also not a rigid, weird, hyper academic chore. It is an actually productive app that actually teaches you while you are actually having a nice time. And you get to hear the sound. Here's a special limited time deal for our listeners right now. Get up to 60% off your Babbel subscription, but only for our listeners at babbel.com slash Hodgman.

Get up to 60% off at babbel.com slash Hodgman, spelled B-A-B-B-E-L dot com slash Hodgman. Rules and restrictions apply. The Judge John Hodgman podcast is also brought to you this week by our pals over at Made In. Jesse, you've heard of Tom Colicchio, the famous chef, right?

Yeah, from the restaurant Kraft. And did you know that most of the dishes at that very same restaurant are made with Made In pots and pans? Really? What's an example? The braised short ribs, they're made in, made in. The Rohan duck, made in, made in.

Riders of Rohan, duck! What about the Heritage Pork Shop? You got it. Made in, made in. Made In has been supplying top chefs and restaurants with high-end cookware for years. They make the stuff that chefs need. Their carbon steel cookware is the best of cast iron, the best of stainless clad.

It gets super hot. It's rugged enough for grills or an open flame. One of the most useful pans you can own. And like we said, good enough for real professional chefs, the best professional chefs. Oh, so I have to go all the way down to the restaurant district in restaurant town? Like we said, good enough for real professional chefs, the best professional chefs. Oh, so I have to go all the way down to the restaurant district in restaurant town? Just buy it online. This is professional grade cookware that is available online directly to you, the consumer, at a very reasonable price.

Yeah. If you want to take your cooking to the next level, remember what so many great dishes on menus all around the world have in common. They're made in Made In. Save up to 25% this Memorial Day from the 18th until the 27th. Visit MadeInCookware.com. That's M-A-D-E-I-N Cookware.com. Tawny, tell us a little bit about Grow lamps what they do why they're necessary i understand that a monster a plant which usually has a lot more light pouring on it in the in the american tropics than in the pacific northwestern cloudics of vancouver they're just getting more light on it.

But what else would our listeners need to know about the necessity of a grow lamp? What does it do? So it just provides light energy to the plants to do their photosynthesis thing. That's what they do, all right. Yeah. I mean, I'm not a scientist. Do you have a special bulb in this lamp? Yeah.

Well, sort of. What I did learn is that most light bulbs, regular light bulbs, will actually sort of do the trick. You can get other kinds of special light bulbs that have like a broader range of the UV spectrum that more simulates sunlight that will do a better job. But basically, light is all that matters. Um, and, uh, judge, you pointed out something, which, um, I'm glad you brought up because I actually have already made small concessions that Alan might not have noticed, which is the fact that grow lights can be very hideous and extremely bright. Um, and in fact, if I had gotten one of the hideous bright ones, it probably would be more effective. There's plenty that are like big bars that emit purple.

Yeah. I was going to ask if you have, because purple and red tend to be the hues of grow lights you see advertised because supposedly, I mean, and there are light recipes that are provided and have been researched by the Phillips Corporation, which provides a lot of commercial grade grow lighting, different kinds of crops that you might grow indoors, be they cucumbers or tomatoes or whatever, they prefer different spectra of light and for different periods of time. So there, I mean, there really is some fine tuning that's going on here. And I'm glad to see those red and purple lights are really, I mean, unless you want to live in a Spencer's Gifts in a mall, the red and purple light is not

very appealing. Absolutely. Tawny, are you concerned that without those classic grow light bars, your plants will be insufficiently dank? He's suggesting that you grow cannabis. We don't have to grow cannabis in our homes here in Canada. Yeah. You have access to wool and cannabis legally? Readily. Yes. How about that? So you don't use the pink and red and blue kinds? No.

And how many grow lights do you have overall? Well, so really only one, one official one. That one that I just saw? Yeah. That's the official grow light? Yes, that's the official grow light. All right. Of the Toronto Blue Jays.

I do have two more that I use as grow lights, and they're just lamps that I have sort of turned onto a plant that I try to leave on before Alan switches them off. No fancy bulb is what you're saying. And would that be what's pictured in Exhibit C, this torchiere lamp, Alan? Correct, Judge. The torchiere lamp. Okay. And what's interesting about this torchiere lamp is, first of all, the plants are very beautiful and they seem to be quite healthy. They're also getting a metric system, right, in Canada?

Just like the rest of the world, Judge, yes. Right. So they're getting a metric feces ton of sunlight at this moment as well as getting light from the torche here what's what's this setup all about this was a very opportune photo that alan took which is sort of the uh 30 minutes 45 minutes per day that our front window shines direct sunlight onto my plants. Which is not enough time. Not enough time.

Are these monster A's here? The Monstera is the one beside the table on the floor. And then the Pothos is the one up on the shelf. But this is a different, I'll call them what you want me to call them, Monstera. This is a different Monstera from the one that has the non-crocheted lamp on it right no so this was an earlier photo that alan took before i hung the official grow light over the monstera so what do you try this is this is outdated evidence alan this is outdated evidence yeah what are you trying to pull it was the smirking gun of that light basking upon the plants from our window. Okay.

But I, oh, I see. So you were trying, you got me. Cause I was like, this looks like it's very sunny there. Why do you need a light at all? And Tawny, with your legal expertise, you just wiped that argument up like a, like a spilled container of yogurt, which I want to talk to you about in a second too, by saying that it gets light for 25 minutes a day. Yeah, maybe 45 max. And those are metric minutes, of course, but that's not enough for a Monster A, is it, Tawny?

No, it's not. How much light does that Monster A want to have? Or maybe put it this way, how long would you like the grow light to be on that Monster A? I would like the grow light to be on during the regular sunlight hours. So 8 a.m. to 7 p.m., 8 p.m., something like that. Okay. And that's not tolerable to you, Alan? No. Okay. Especially in the evenings, I find the light especially glaring. It's just quite bright and it sort of hangs behind our couch and it glares onto the TV.

If the dog wants to watch something, you know, it's I just find it quite distracting. I would I would honestly you were talking. Sorry. Did you. Sorry, Alan. Did you say if the dog wants to watch something? Just some Paw Patrol or what have you. Do you do you have a toddler that you call your dog? No, Hazel's Hazel's a pit bull. But her her preference is that we watch TV every night. Is Paw Patrol Hazel's favorite show or does she have some other faves?

She likes Great British Bake Off, Canadian Bake Off. Sure. All the bake offs. Got it. All the bake offs. To answer Jesse's question, I would much prefer those purple or blue lights that you were referring to before those sound relaxing

have you seen one in action? I had black lights in my room when I was in high school for different reasons danker reasons they were flourishing the glow in the dark stars that I had all over

my ceiling. But yeah, no, I would love black lights. I've actually posed to Tani that we get random colored lights for different parts of our apartment, which she has next on several occasions throughout our life. How large

is this apartment? This apartment is 600 square feet. Okay. So that's, that's fairly small for a family of three, two humans plus a dog. Right. And I mean, obviously with a situation like that, it's like you have, this is obviously in the main room of the house. This grow light is in the main room of the house where you're watching your dog's favorite TV shows and so on. Exactly. And storage is an issue as well because, you know, you don't have a lot of pantries or whatever. So that's why you would store this knocked over yogurt container

in the base of your Monster A plant. All of our pantry is full of wool. So I don't know where you expect us to put those containers. Why did you take this picture of this plant with the knocked over yogurt container? I can explain. Thank you. So, monsteras also need,

they have what are called aerial roots and the roots kind of like go through the air and search for water. Sure.

So, I have little containers of water. You can kind of see them in the picture but our dog, you know, Hazel. Our Hazel, being a scavenger, just slurps up water wherever she finds it. So this was originally a non-tipped over yogurt container.

Yes. And it was full of water that the Monster A was reaching out its creepy tendrils for. It was not. No. So the container of water is underneath the yogurt container um okay and hazel kept going for the container of water to slurp at it so i took the yogurt container and put it on top of the water container to block the water so that hazel couldn't so that hazel couldn't so this is this is your this is your plant hack yes and so is this the way it's supposed to look?

No. It looks really bad and awful. It does. It looks terrible. I'm sorry to say. It doesn't look like that anymore. I took that away. And in fact, it wasn't working anyway.

She was just knocking it off and getting to the water anyway. So. Tani, I have a broader question about these photographs. about these photographs. Obviously, there is an exciting Instagram and TikTok trend toward indoor plants in interior decorating. Let the record show that Alan is nodding vigorously, and now he's beginning to do a little dance of pre-victory, it seems like. I object to this dance. I'll allow this line of questioning and the dance. It's one that has been reinforced over the last few years is as many people have spent more time in their homes and more time tending and nurturing in their homes. It can be fantastic.

I'll stipulate that. Nothing wrong with an interior plant. Let's stipulate to Fantastics. Fantasticness. Let's stipulate to Jerry Orbach and the Fantastics. Tawny, when are the plants decorating your house and when are they running your house? I'm going to be frank. As lovely as this hanging lamp with the macrame that you've put on it is, the plants are starting to look a little junky.

And not just because there's a discarded, an empty yogurt container tipped over in the base of it? They're in what can only be described as a miscellany of pots. They appear to be in good health. But they seem to be kind of piled around near miscellaneously in like a mishmash of vessels that suggests someone who loves growing plants more than they love managing the aesthetics of their 600 square foot apartment. I don't think that's a question so much as an accusation, but I'll allow Tawny to respond. Yeah, that's fair. I don't know if you can tell, but our general aesthetic is a bit chaotic, a little bit eclectic, not too concerned about aesthetic principles. We generally have kind of a lot of just things here and there.

Let the record show that when Donnie referred to their chaotic aesthetic, she gestured at the giant tapestry of the cat. the giant tapestry of the cat. Yeah. Yes, and I would agree that my priority is caring for the plants. I get my joy out of seeing them grow and grow new leaves and, yeah, flourish rather than the aesthetic value they give to our apartment.

You seem to have a semi-outdoor patio. That's true. Alan submitted some more evidence of a semi-outdoor patio. Alan, what do you want to say about this evidence? You can stop dancing and gloating for a moment and talk on the podcast. mainly because Hazel gets out there and starts barking at all the dogs that walk by. So the patio goes mainly unused, and that thing could be filled with plants as far as I care. But it's mostly just got more junk on it. Why not fill the patio with plants, Tawny? I mean, it looks like there are plants on the patio, as far as I can tell. There are plants on the patio.

So, yeah, I have used it. It's not completely unused. Just because that I don't have the plants for the primary reason of their aesthetic value doesn't mean that they don't have aesthetic value to me. I do like them to be in my living space. I like to enjoy them as I walk around in my life in my apartment. As Alan has said, we don't really hang out out there that often. So I just wouldn't get to see them very often if they were out there. The majority of our plants are in sort of my office space in the apartment, the place where I do all of my work when I'm working from home. So I get to surround myself with, you know, my own little mini jungle.

I like it. You say 600 feet. How many rooms are we talking about? It's a one bedroom apartment with like a sort of a long living room that we've divided into two, like the living rooms on one end and then the dining room and then my office is on the other end. Right. And then the other room would be the bedroom. And the kitchen is its own room or is it an open concept living situation? No, the kitchen is sort of its own room without a door or anything, but it's separated. So two rooms that you use for living in,

and not just living, but also working. Yeah. I mean, this whole scenario is going to be in the rear view mirror very soon. You're moving to Halifax, Nova Scotia, the provincial capital of Nova Scotia, and you're going to buy a whole home. Yes. Alan is concerned that you are going to fill this home with monster A's. What size of a home do you hope to get, and what are your plant plans for this new home?

We are looking at somewhere between a 1,500 and 2,000 square foot. That would be a dramatic increase of square footage. Dramatic increase of square footage. That's right. And if those property brothers haven't gotten to it, it might actually have rooms in it instead of being in a completely open concept living plan. Sorry, Jonathan and Drew. Sometimes partners need walls, but you might have some extra rooms in it, correct? Yes. So yeah, we're looking at hopefully a three bedroom. So yeah, some extra rooms, a guest bedroom, an office. Yeah, but we are also prioritizing a house with a lot of windows and a lot of sunlight

which is different from what we have here. We only have one end of our apartment has windows and sunlight on it. And in this new house, we are hoping to have windows and sunlight everywhere so that I can put plants in any room that I want, but I can put them near the windows. And I would like to make the judgment call and have the discretion to place the grow lights as needed, but I think that we're not going to need as many grow lights as maybe Alan's nightmares tell him we will have. What kinds of plants do you feel like, shall I say, branching out to? New kinds of tropical plants?

Yes, I would love to have more and different kinds of plants. There's many kinds of plants that, yeah, that I would love to branch out for sure. Yeah, it was pretty good fun, I have to say, but not as good as pull the wool over his eyes or frowns like these. Any particular kind? There's different kinds of Monstera plants that I would like. All in the Monstera world. All the Monstera, yeah. There's, yeah, there's plenty. Like I said, I'm still a beginner, so I don't know a lot about them,

but I've seen a lot of different pictures, and there's tons that I haven't had before, so I would love to learn more about it. Alan, do you like any plants? I love plants. I haven't had before. So I would love to learn more about it. Alan, do you like any plants? I love plants. I'm pro plant. Do you hate the look of these plants? How do you feel when you see these plants? I would just, I would, I get so angry when I see these plants. No, I don't know. I would just,

I would like plants that are, that grow well in wherever we live, whether it be Vancouver or Nova Scotia that are indigenous to the area. Um, because my, my theory is if, if we already have plants by a south facing window and those require plant lights, I assume in our new house, which may or may not even have south facing windows, that there's going to be a plant light, um, spreading up. Do you have a moral objection to having non-indigenous plant life in your home you want all canadian plants um i just don't want things that are meant to grow on the you know around the equator uh brought up above the the 49th parallel just get some pine trees you can put some pine trees in your house precisely yeah alan i know you're not a botanist, but can you give me an example of a plant that's native to a living room? Oh, boy.

Wow. I'll allow that, Your Honor. Wow-y. I mean, no, but— Very cutting bit of legal—you're a lawyer, right? Right, Tawny? Yes, I am. Yeah, that was pretty cutting, wasn't it?

So to speak. It's pretty cutting. The first plants we got were so hardy, we traveled with them— He really pruned you down, Alan. Pruned you down. I know, but let's turn over a new leaf here for a second. I think I've heard everything I need to say. The original, the first plants that Tani ever had were so hardy that we traveled with them. We stuffed a bunch of plants into a cat carrier and drove from Toronto to Halifax several years ago.

And those plants were thriving, living their best life on that road trip. They weren't watered or anything. She just pulled them out of the cat carrier when we got to Halifax. She put them up on the wall near or far from a window and they thrived. They were just, they were hanging. They were hanging out. And so I want more of those plants that can thrive on a road trip. What kind of plants were those?

Those were pothos. Those were the pothos. Yeah. Okay. You got them already, Alan. You got the pothos. Exactly. You got one right next to you.

I saw it earlier. Alan, are there times when you would find these lights being on to be acceptable? would find these lights being on to be acceptable or are there different styles of lights that you would find appropriate? I would just say, you know, if they were just sort of not in the middle of our living space and not on, especially at night is when I find them particularly bothersome. And yeah, if they could be like a warmer color or yeah, even purple, I would be down for that for sure. Have you investigated any other grow light options?

I mean, I know that we brought up pink and purple. I have not. No, okay. Didn't do any of that homework. All right, gotcha. Tawny, can you explain to Alan why caring for non-Canadian plants gives you joy? Variety is wonderful and exciting.

And different kinds of plants need different kinds of care. And I really enjoy learning about the different kinds of care that different plants require. And if I only had pothos in my life, it would not be nearly as fulfilling of a hobby. Tawny, what kind of light bulb is in your grow light currently? Is it a LED? Is it incandescent?

Is it a high intensity light? Is it a special light bulb? What would you say it is? So it is a special light bulb for growing plants. It's an 11 watt LED light bulb. Really energy efficient, does not use a lot of energy at all. Alan, you mentioned in your opening statement, which by the way, again, was beautifully worded and very compelling, that you have a sensitivity to light. Can you tell me a little bit more about

that? Yeah. At night, I tend to require lights to be turned down to a pretty low level. Otherwise, I find it really distracting and jarring and I find it harder to get to sleep. So pretty much the less light on, the better. A lot of people sleep with the lights off. I'm not sure if you've tried that. Yeah. So Tani goes to bed later than I do. And the light beside her bed, light beside her side of the bed is, I find it quite bright and quite hard to fall asleep if it's on. But this has nothing to do, is she shining a grow light in her face so that her fronds will grow? She's just a human being reading a book or something, right? And what do I do, Alan, at nighttime when I'm reading my book?

If she's being very generous, she puts on this cool miner's lamp on her head and she reads books like she's 100 feet underground. Because I love him. When you are trying to go to sleep and let's say Tawny is not reading and she

is asleep. Let's say a miracle occurs and no one is shining light on you in your bedroom do you sense let's say if the grow lights are on in the other room do you sense them i mean either do you see them or like you see the light under the door or is the door open is it disruptive in that way or do you just mentally know they're on and it and it and it makes you a little itchy uh probably to be honest i wouldn't bother me in the bedroom but probably to be honest if i went to the bathroom in the middle of night um which you know i do um it

probably would would wake me up more than i would like it to just the idea of those lights just being on for no reason other than these monsters need to grow. Exactly. Alan, have you ever investigated getting what they call smart lights that can be turned off from a phone or a tablet or a device that can be set to timers? Anything like that? I'd be super keen on like a clap on, clap off situation. All right. That's fair.

An old school clapper is what you're talking about? Exactly. That would be great. Maybe you can find that by the side of the road in Toronto. I'm not sure where you would get a new one. Alan, if I were to rule in your favor, what would you have me rule? Just to work with plants that don't require plant lights and then, you know, be more mindful about turning lights off around the apartment when she leaves the room. And Tawny, how would you have me rule if I were to rule in your favor?

I would like you to give me the discretion to have as many grow lights as is necessary for my hobby and to have them on for as many hours of the day as no limits you get whatever you want yeah i would like to have whatever no right to complain for an hour yeah right yeah okay i think i've heard everything i need to in order to make my decision i am going to go into my 19th century glass house to sit underneath the cavendish banana tree on the grounds of chatsworth house in england in order to contemplate my decision. And then I will come right back here to North America to render my verdict. Please rise as Judge John Hodgman exits the courtroom. Tawny, how are you feeling about your chances?

I feel okay. I feel like maybe I might have asked for a little bit too much there by his somewhat snide comments to me at the very end. But I think what I'm asking for is not unreasonable. I think I'm in a good position. How about you, Alan? The judge is brilliant and all-knowing, and I'm sure he's going to make the right decision. He can't hear you right now. He's in his chambers. I he's he's in his chambers but um he can probably feel it he can feel the vibrations when we listen to the podcast at home i go isn't i tell tony isn't the judge is

brilliant she okay shut your pie hole alan shut your pie hole shut your pie hole t Alan. Shut your pie hole. Shut your pie hole. Tawny, you're about to buy a house in Halifax, Nova Scotia. Have you thought about just getting a conservatory? Or are you too concerned about candlestick murders? That sounds wonderful and romantic and wonderful. That's a new idea that I'm going to definitely entertain. Well, we'll see what Judge Hodgman has to say about all this when we come back in just a moment. Hello, teachers and faculty. This is Janet Varney.

I'm here to remind you that listening to my podcast, The JV Club with Janet Varney, is part of the curriculum for the school year. Learning about the teenage years of such guests as Alison Brie, Vicki Peterson, John Hodgman, and so many more is a valuable and enriching experience, one you have no choice but to embrace because, yes, listening is mandatory. The JV Club with Janet Varney is available every Thursday on Maximum Fun or wherever you get your podcasts. Thank you. And remember, no running in the halls. If you need a laugh and you're on the go, try S-T-O-P-P-O-D-C-A-S-T-I-R.

Were you trying to put the name of the podcast there? Yeah, I'm trying to spell it, but it's tricky. Let me give it a try. Okay. If you need a laugh and you're on the go, call S-T-O-P-P-P-A-D-I It'll never fit. No, it will. Let me try.

If you need a laugh and you're on the go, try S-T-O-P-P-P-D-C-O-O We are so close. Stop podcasting yourself. A podcast from MaximumFun.org. If you need a laugh, then you're on the go. Judge Hodgman, we're taking a break from the case. What's going on with you?

Well, as you know, Jesse Thorne, Dicktown, D-I-C-K-T-O-W-N is the cartoon I made with David Reese. It is available both seasons on Hulu right now. And I encourage you to check it out. And I encourage you to check out Hulu, get into the Hulu world. I'm just saying, this is just something I've observed. I'm not being prompted by any company. I'm not being prompted by any company other than self-interest wanting you to watch Dicktown. I've also happened to observe that a lot of the shows I'm watching right now are on Hulu. And so I'm going to go ahead and recommend one, which I am frankly embarrassed that I missed for so long. Reservation Dogs on Hulu is one of the funniest and best shows that I've enjoyed in a long time. And the actors on that show are so incredible and it is so funny and great. And there are two seasons of it. I believe a third is on its way.

And if you get that Hulu subscription, not only do you get to enjoy Reservation Dogs and also Dicktown and other shows that they've got on there, but also up here, the TV show that I spent the summer filming. I had a small acting role in it and it was so much fun. And it's co-created by Bobby Lopez and Kristen Anderson Lopez and Tommy Kail and Steven Levinson. And if you know musical theater, you know who those people are. Otherwise use your Google. It's going to be such a fun, romantic comedy, musical theater, eight episode

comedy with Carlos Valdez and, and, and May Whitman may whitman and uh it'll come out sometime in 2023 i believe uh so get a get a little subscription to to hulu or ask your ask your people in your life for a for a for a gift of a of a subscription or a password or whatever and watch reservation dogs won't you can i shout out this fool i've been loving this fool on hulu by the way hulu we're not sponsored by you but sponsor us because of this because we're just shouting out shows that we love i love this fool with chris estrada chris estrada was on bullseye a few weeks ago uh he's a totally amazing dude uh also on jordan jesse go recently uh totally amazing dude and such a great like la comedy show about uh a dude that lives with his lives with his

parents and works at like uh homeboy industries type uh rehab for criminals program yeah and uh his uh cousin his cousin comes home from jail and uh they basically live together and uh again in a lot of hijinks. It's great. It's so much fun. Yeah, reservation dogs rule so hard. You're absolutely right. Jesse, what else do you have going on? You mentioned Bullseye, your incredible interview show on public radio and, of course, on streaming via podcast on the Maximum Fun Network every week where you talk to incredible artists and creators from across the artistic spectrum. Branum is also in.

Oh, wow. And was a co-producer of. And, yeah, the movie's a hoot, and Billy is, as always, a fascinating dude. So I would check that out. And then we also have next week coming up an interview with this guy called Hua Xu, who folks might know as a staff writer for The New Yorker, but one of my favorite culture writers forever and a day. And he has a memoir out called Stay True, which is just breathtakingly beautiful. So look forward to that. And then over in the Put This On shop, John, it's Hat Central right now. Put up so many hats. Put up those hats. Put your hats on. I don't tolerate low quality hats, John. When I'm at the flea market or the vintage markets or whatever, there's a lot of garbage hats out there and I'm not messing with those. Only really, really good hats in the Put This On Shop. So if you're buying a hat from us, know that you're getting a hat that frankly is, frankly is probably better

than any hat you could buy new in 2022. PutThisOnShop.com. Let's get back to the case. 22. Put this on shop.com. Let's get back to the case. Please rise as Judge John Hodgman re-enters the courtroom and presents his verdict. Salon Creeper, Hunter's Robe, Ivy Arum, Money Plant, Money plant, silver vine, Solomon Island's ivy, marble queen, devil's vine, devil's ivy. These are not different kinds of plants. These are but one kind of plant. And because this is my verdict, I will not ask you, Alan, if you can name the one kind of plant. I will tell you. Pothos. All of those plants

are simply pothos, aka Epipremnum aureum, a species in the Arum family of plants native to the Mororea and the Society Islands of French Polynesia. That's right. These pothos that you love so much, Alan, they're not Canadian at all. They're from the tropics. They're just heartier, heartier than these monsters, eh? So let's set aside this whole,

frankly, I think, bogus argument that you want to turn your new home in Halifax into some kind of museum to Nova Scotian botany. Taney has explained and expressed that most decorative houseplants are from areas of the world that are not the maritime provinces of Canada. And whether that's true or not, I don't know. I don't go shopping for plants.

The plants that she's interested in are the ones that do come from the tropics and require some extra care. Some extra, you know, not just to just throw a thing on a dorm room windowsill and water it every 90 days and it'll never die like some kind of indoor shrub but something a little bit more of a hot housey flowery type of plant i don't know if these things flower but you know what i'm saying that's the hobby that she enjoys it's the hobby she enjoys and it is very unusual as might know, if you listen to the Judge John Hodgman podcast, Alan, and recognize my brilliance and talk about it to your partner, as you claim. It's very unusual for me to rule against someone's passion and hobby. Unless they lived in a 600 square foot apartment with two rooms in Vancouver. Because I'm going to say I have to agree with my bail

of Jesse Thorne. These plants are lovely, but their tendrils are starting to overtake things. Tawny, I'm not quite as critical of their arrangement. I appreciate the eclecticism of their arrangement and decor. It seems fine enough to me, aside from that grody, empty yogurt container. Tawny is exploring something here. But I think that now that I have seen enough of your apartment through these teleconference cameras and the evidence, and the evidence, I would agree that the space in which Tani is expressing her passion and practicing her hobby is not merely shared, but very shared. And I am someone who does not have

any kind of medical light sensitivity, but I definitely know when a light is on in the living room when I'm in my bedroom. And sometimes if I wake up at 3 a.m. and there's a light on in the living room, that would be extremely distracting to me and it will make me feel unrested and nervous that maybe there's a home invasion situation going on or something. And I have to go through a very, very deep internal debate about whether or not it is worth it to get out of bed and turn that light off. And Alan, like you, I have some frustration with the people who leave the light on and don't turn it off because as cogently and

as well written as your opening statement was, you did not. And I venture to say that if you had used this phrase, you would be walking away with this judgment long before we got to any discussion. You did not quote the settled law of this court that one should be mindful of the work one leaves for others. Tawny, there are two possibilities here. One is that you are forgetting to turn out the grow lights and leaving that work for Alan to do, knowing that it annoys him. Or two, you're leaving them on on purpose because you value the monsters A more than you value Alan, because you want them to have more light and you don't care that it

poisons his eyes. Either one of those situations is not okay in this court. Now, all of this, however, both my appreciation of your hobby, Tawny, and my appreciation of your arguing, Alan, and my feeling that accommodation must be made to Alan in this apartment, all of this is meaningless because your whole situation, your whole world is about to change. You're going to leave accommodation must be made to Alan in this apartment. All of this is meaningless because your whole situation, your whole world is about to change. You're going to leave Vancouver and go to the wonderful maritime province of Nova Scotia. And I hope very much for you. And in fact, I order you to find a room in the house that you are going to buy or rent or acquire that can be, first

of all, Tawny's office, which Tawny, you deserve to have an office if you're working from home, that is not a zone of the living room. Since you're making this change, I think you should prioritize that. And I think you should also, if you cannot find a house with a conservatory or greenhouse attached, you should make sure that that office can be a place where you can throw as many grow lights as you want into that room. So long as the heat is tolerable for your work, I think you absolutely should pursue your hobby insofar as it does not invade upon the well-being of Alan or your dog.

I encourage you to get more plants and even trickier plants to raise so long as you have the room to raise them in. Because another piece of settled law in this court is that the difference between a hoard and a collection is proper display. And while I don't think that the plants have exactly reached hoard status the way my good friend and bailiff Jesse Thorne has determined in your current apartment, you're verging on a plant takeover. This is your hobby and therefore curation and tidiness and containment has to be part of your plan and your hobby as well. The last thing that I will say is that,

Alan, the solution in my life to people leaving lights on is that I can turn them off with my phone. There is no clapper anymore, Alan. Let's clap off to that whole idea. I don't know whether you're a time traveler or whether you've been unconscious for a while, but there are things called smart light bulbs and they are programmable. You control them through a hub. I learned this from our friends, Paul F. Tompkins and Janie Haddad Tompkins, co-host of the great Stay F. Humpkins podcast and Life. They introduced me to this concept that you can get these networked LED bulbs that last forever. They're not cheap. I'll tell you this.

They're not cheap, but they last for a long, long time. Obviously, all LED lights last a lot longer and are much more energy efficient than any of the old fluorescent bulbs that my mom used to have clanging around in the basement. But these, you put them in, in whatever, whatever place you want to put them in and they all communicate to a hub and you can turn them off from your phone one by one, or as a group, you can set them on timers. So that for example, uh, if there is a monster a plant, Tawny, that you would like to have in a shared space, you don't want to, I don't want you to have to put all of your plants in one room. Do you know what I mean? But you could have a grow light aimed at that plant and set a routine such that it goes on automatically from say 10 PM to.m and then turns off and alan will never know i'll never know

that that plant got all that extra light during the during the nighttime hours and they change colors so you could enjoy some of the benefits of a spencer's gift style purple or red light vibe on your plants. You can change the color scheme completely from day to night. All of a sudden you could go from a nice normal house in Nova Scotia to Alan's weird dorm room from when he was a child. All with the touch of a book. I'm not, I'm not being sponsored by this. I'm saying I use this product myself and you can trust that my wife was a whole human being in her own right and i have do not see eye to eye on these programmable lights she's

the dumbest thing in the world she thinks it's a waste of it's a waste of time and she doesn't understand why the lights dim at certain times she's like why don't we just turn them off and on and she's absolutely right it may not they're not for everybody i enjoy them because when when she falls asleep and leaves her light on next to her i just press a button it turns off just like that that said in a situation like this in particular the i think your lighting needs definitely merit investigation into this technology and seeing if it is going to be useful and affordable to you. And while it pains me to do it, I suppose that I'm actually ruling in Alan's favor here.

I really respect your hobby and I think the plants look beautiful, Tony. And I don't buy Alan's arguments about native Canadian plants or maritime plants or the whole argument about energy efficiency, because I think that we have ways of lighting now that do not have as much of a footprint as we might have had. It's enough that Alan just says, it's too bright. It's too bright. Who matters more, me or the plants? Anybody who shares space with someone else, especially a small constrained space, has to be considerate of their needs,

of their happiness as well. And I'm very happy to hear that, A, you're probably moving to a space where you can share your passions for plants, Tawny, and darkness, Alan, a little bit more equitably and happily and b that there is this technology that i think you would probably find i mean i don't know how it fits into your chaotic interior design ethos i know you just like to find cat tapestries by the side of the road

but with a little determination a little curation i think you can both live happily with all these plants until they come and get you this This is the sound of a gavel. Judge John Hodgman rules. That is all. Please rise as Judge John Hodgman exits the courtroom. Tawny, how are you? Good. Yeah, I think that's that's pretty fair.

I'm happy with it. Alan, how are you feeling? that's pretty fair. I'm happy with it. Alan, how are you feeling? I'm super excited for Tani to get her chance at curation and maybe even a greenhouse or something in the backyard. That is not what he said. But we could do that. Or, and you know, a conservatory inside the house as well, maybe. Alan's plan right now is to buy a bunch of seaweed and crabs or whatever they have in whatever's native to Halifax. We're just going to have lobsters running around the yard. It's going to be cute. I think that Alan would find it very satisfying and exciting and perhaps a little bit intoxicating to have the power to just flip on and off lights with his phone at his own will. So

I'm excited about that too. Well, Alan Tawney, thanks for joining us on the Judge John Hodgman podcast. Thank you. Another Judge John Hodgman case is in the books. In a moment, we'll have swift justice, but our thanks now to at irony maiden for naming this week's episode habeas corpus. That's somebody with a with a pun lifestyle. If you want to name a future episode, follow us on Twitter for the opportunity to do so, at Jesse Thorne and at Hodgman. While you're there, you can also hashtag your Judge John Hodgman-related tweets, hashtag JJHO, and join

the conversation over at the Maximum Fun subreddit at MaximumFun.reddit.com. Evidence and photos from the show, including those screenshots John took, are on our Instagram account at Instagram.com slash JudgeJohnHodgman. You can follow us there. Our producer is Jennifer Marmer. Our editor is Valerie Moffitt, who's filling in his producer this week. Now, Swift Justice, where we answer your small disputes with quick judgment. Jared says, I'm a huge fan of the Iron Maiden song Empire of the Clouds. I think it's the best and most beautiful piece ever written about airships. about airships. My friend Joe says the song is too long, boring, and has no historical significance. I seek your ruling that Empire of the Clouds is in fact the best song ever performed on the topic of dirigibles. Or airships of all kinds. I had never heard this song before. Speaking of Iron Maiden, it's by Iron Maiden

from their album, The Book of Souls. It is 18 minutes long. I have listened to some of it. It's pretty good, but it is literally about an airship disaster, specifically the crash of the British airship R101, which crashed in Northern France in October 1930 during its maiden voyage. It's a tragedy that not a lot of people know about, but Iron Maiden wants to bring it to the world. And I'm going to say, you know, one of the pieces of settled law of this courtroom is one likes what one likes. So I can't deny Jared's enjoyment of Empire of the Clouds, but Jared is going further to posit it is the best song about airships, blimps,

dirigibles, semi-rigid dirigibles, semi-rigid air ships. And I don't know any other ones and I would like to know what they are. So I'm going to withhold judgment until you, I hope the listener send me more songs about blimps. I hope the listener send me more songs about blimps. If you know about a song about a blimp or an airship or a Zeppelin or whatever,

send it to me, send me a link so I can listen to them. And, uh, and I'm, and I'm going to do a, depending on how many there are, I'm going to do like a March madness style bracket competition until we can

settle this once and for all. Is Empire of the Clouds the best song ever performed on the topic of dirigibles? You'll find out in the coming months or years of Judge John Hodgman. But I guarantee you, Jerry, we'll get to the answer. We're eager to hear about your disputes on any subject. No case too small. Submit your cases at MaximumFun.org slash JJHO. Hey, John, before we go this week, something big happened to me that I just wanted to mention on our way

out the door here. A lot of Judge John Hodgman listeners have heard My Dog Coco. And this was her last week, so sorry. She was almost 17 years old. She lived with us for 15 years. You know, she's been my best pal since You know, she's been my best pal since Maximum Fun was me working by myself, making $10,000 a year in an apartment in Koreatown. You know, I was really lonely back then and, you know, she was my buddy and she's lived with us through of, I shared her passing on social media. A lot of Judge Sean Hodgman listeners told me about their pets and told me about hearing me talk about Coco. And I'm grateful to all those people and, uh, to pals like you, John, um, who've been so kind about her and to me. Um, so yeah, so, uh, thanks to Coco for all that she's, she gave, uh, me and, you know,

she gave me and you know I honestly I don't know if I could have done all this stuff that is max fun without that dog so you know I got really lucky to

to have her in my life so yeah just just saying goodbye and thank you to her. She was a very good dog, Jesse, and you're a very good friend to dogs and humans. That's all. Okay. We'll talk to you next time on the Judge John Hodgman podcast. Maximumfun.org. Comedy and culture. Artist owned. Audience supported.