Judge John Hodgman - Scheduled For Adrainment
Episode Date: August 31, 2022Karen brings the case against her husband, Matt. Part of their property has a pasture that slopes downward. This creates a low spot that fills with a foot of water during certain times of the year. Ka...ren calls this area the “frog bog.” Matt wants to fill it in, but Karen wants to leave the bog alone. Who’s right? Who’s wrong?
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Welcome to the Judge John Hodgman podcast. I'm bailiff Jesse Thorne. This week, scheduled for a
drainment. Karen brings the case against her husband, Matt. Part of their property has a
pasture that slopes downward. This creates a low spot that fills with a foot of water during certain
times of the year. Karen calls this area the frog bog. Matt wants to fill
it in. Karen wants to leave that bog alone. Who's right? Who's wrong? Only one can decide. Please
rise as Judge John Hodgman enters the courtroom and presents an obscure cultural reference.
I was sitting at the edge of the marsh when the council came to bring me the news.
They handed me a bowl of cooked wild grasses and they gave me the ceremonial shoes.
Swear them in, young Danish women. Swear them in, Danish sky. Swear them in, cold air, I am going
away. Swear them in, swear them in, swear them in.
Bailiff Jesse Thorne, please swear the litigants in.
Karen and Matt, please rise and raise your right hands.
Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth,
so help you God or whatever?
Yes.
Yes.
Do you swear to abide by Judge John Hodgman's ruling,
despite the fact that he has moral objections to amphibians? Yes. Yes. Do you swear to abide by Judge John Hodgman's ruling, despite the fact that he has moral objections to amphibians?
What?
Yes.
No.
They live in too many kinds of places.
Judge Hodgman, you may proceed.
I got nothing against our amphibian friends.
I love a frog.
I love a newt.
I love an olm.
Do you know what an olm is?
No.
It's a kind of salamander. I don't know that it's amphibian, so don't write me letters, but it lives in total darkness its entire life. It is so creepy looking.
I had a pet frog when I was a kid. Boutros Boutros Froggy.
Of course I knew that. Karen and Matt, you may be seated for an immediate summary judgment in one
of your favors i should have made the cultural reference about putra's putra's froggy but i
didn't can either of you name the piece of culture that i uh references i entered the courtroom
karen well i'd only start with you okay um boy i thought you were gonna go like an agricultural
route but that sound why did you think why did you think that i don't know i feel
like um if we were better agriculturists we would already know exactly what to do with that
and obscure agricultural references that's not what it's called a cultural reference
it's gonna be a movie or a tv show or a song or a book almost almost always. It felt very dystopian to me.
I got a Margaret Atwood vibe.
Oh.
Now, before you make your guess,
let me be clear
that when I said,
swear them in, Danish Sky,
swear them in, I'm going away.
I was doing a classic
obscure cultural reference game
where I was swapping in something
from the podcast
for a different line in the cultural reference. The first part I said was all right. I'm sitting at the edge
of the marsh where the council came to bring the news, et cetera. They gave me the ceremonial shoes.
That's all correct. But the real second part is, and I'm going to give you a hint now. Goodbye,
young Danish women. Goodbye, Danish sky. Goodbye, cold air. I am going away. Goodbye. Goodbye. Goodbye.
Does that help?
No.
Okay.
And I will admit.
It was the grain predictions for Benjamin Franklin's Old Farmer's Almanac, 1959 edition.
No, it's not an agricultural reference.
What is your guess?
Okay.
Oh, Margaret Atwood.
Margaret Atwood.
Anything by Margaret Atwood.
Yeah. Okay. That'd be cool Atwood. Margot Atwood. Anything by Margot Atwood. Yeah.
Okay.
That'd be cool.
What about you, Matt?
I feel very stumped.
If I had to guess. Stumped is not an agricultural reference, but it is sort of a landscape reference.
Oh, yeah.
Oh, yeah, I would have to say that it sounded very prose-ish.
Interesting. Prose-ish. Like a lot of things that rhyme are prose, right?
Yes. A lot of short pieces that rhyme, especially short pieces that are sort of elegiac and not to be literally taken necessarily
you know what my favorite poem
is John no sorry Jesse we're talking
about prose sorry go ahead
sorry Jesse we're on a very specific
thing here called prose but if you
want to sidetrack to poetry
or lyrics
tell me it's the
manual for my dishwasher what piece of famous piece of prose do you think
this is from matt okay well the whole goodbye goodbye thing gave me the vibe of like tolstoy
war and peace when he's like laying there dying and saying goodbye um but it wasn't quite right because the dutch wasn't it so i don't maybe it was some other tolstoy where he was doing dutch
stuff tolstoy doing dutch stuff yeah because apparently danish and dutch are the same now
oh yeah yeah well i don't know whatever you do though i don't know hey just as a
as a as a warning to our viewers don't put tolstoy doing dutch stuff into the urban dictionary you
don't want to see what it comes up i've watched every or listened to every episode and i've only
known one cultural reference and it was because you did a mountain goat song so i knew i was well maybe you should
have guessed a mountain goat song are you kidding no of course it's a mountain goat song oh and matt
it's from listening to the mountain goat i know we failed honey what what was the album released by the Mountain Goats in June 15th, 1995?
Matt or Karen?
Any guesses?
Wrong.
It's Sweden.
Sweden is the name of that album.
And this song is called Toland Man.
Toland Man.
And it is a song from the imagined point of view of the Toland Man, who was, as historians speculate, the victim of ritual sacrifice, having been killed and then drowned for some obscure reason to aid the crops or whatever.
I guess in that sense, it was probably an agricultural reference after all.
And then was discovered almost perfectly preserved in the bog in which he was drowned in 1950.
in the bog in which he was drowned in 1950.
That's right, Toland Man,
one of the most famous and perfectly preserved bog people in history,
of which there are many bog people.
There's the Cashel Man.
There's the girl of the Uctur Moor.
There's the Gala Man.
There's the Boromos Bodies.
There's the Cloncaven Man, the old Crowan Man.
And of course, Lindau Man, my very favorite,
right there in the British Museum.
Why do bodies get preserved in bogs, Karen, Matt? Lack of oxygen. Exactly right. Lack of oxygen.
They do not drain. They are almost anaerobic environments. They're cold. You get surrounded
by peat. And also they have a particular acidity which preserves bodies. And that is why I referred
to the Toland Man.
You don't know how much time, Karen, how much time I spent this morning paying no attention whatsoever to the notes of your case because I had to find some cultural reference for a bog person.
And I went through all of them.
I went through the Lindau Man.
I went through the Wierding Man.
I went through the Boxton Man.
You would think some people would write songs about these people.
I went through the Boxton Man.
You would think some people would write songs about these people.
It wasn't until I got to the Toland Man, literally minutes ago,
that I saw that John Darnielle, our friend who is also the Mountain Goats,
wrote a song called Toland Man, 1995.
And that was the lyrics of the complete lyrics, actually.
Check it out, Mountain Goats.
So you don't win, though, Karen, though you came closest.
Matt, you came the furthest away.
Your dispute, of course, is about a bog or what you call a bog at the edge of your property in Washington state.
Is that correct?
Do I have that correct?
Yeah, that's right.
And who comes to seek justice with regard to this bog?
I do.
And Karen, what is the nature of the justice you seek?
Well, I love my bog and I want it to stay just the way it is.
Tell me about your bog. Tell me about your property. Tell me about your bog.
Okay. Tell me and tell me about how many bodies you've ritually sacrificed down there.
Because that's what I think this is about, right? You don't want Matt to dry up the bog
because he's going to find all the midsummer tributes that you've left down there.
Of course. Well, we have a barn cat that came with the
house when we bought it and he he gets rid of a lot of bodies so maybe it's his area that oh okay
yeah yeah um so i didn't know where that story was going we had a barn cat when we got the property
oh no we still have him he brings us okay he didn't drown
in the bog and that's why you want to keep it he's an excellent murderer so the bog is i'm terrible
at measurements but i feel like it's about half a football field um wide and long so i'm guessing
it's like 40 yards each way so it's pretty good size jesse thorn how
large is a football field 100 yards 100 yards okay so 40 yards wide uh-huh it's about square
what's that about 120 feet yes so it's 40 by it's 40 by 40 yards. Correct. So 120 feet.
Boy, I'm wishing I would have taken a tape measure out now.
14,000 square feet of bog in your property?
Yeah.
Does that seem about right, Matt?
I think that might be a little on the high side, but it's not wildly inaccurate.
What would your bog guess be?
I would put it more at, i'd say more 30 by 30
okay you're 30 feet by 30 feet and 30 yards by 30 yards 30 yards excuse me 30 yards by 30 yards and
you all right it's hard it's hard for me to understand this uh you're on the property now
the two of you we are all right let's take a recess i want you to go down there and walk the
bog walk the bog with a tape measure okay and go down there and walk the bog. Walk the bog with a tape measure, okay?
And then come back.
Pace off the bog.
Pace off the bog.
No.
That's a big bog.
That's a bigger bog than I was expecting to hear about.
Okay.
How long have you lived on the property?
About a year and a half.
Okay.
And what goes on down the bog bog how far away is it from
your house um how far away would you say it is matt uh like it is our view like while i'm doing
the dishes it's what i'm looking at it's right outside of the kitchen window um and so basically side lawn that is quite small, you know, normal side lawn size. And then at the edge of that lawn,
then we've got our fence that delineates the start of the pasture. And that's where the land
starts sloping downwards. And then once it's all the way down as low as it gets that's where i say the bog
starts so as low as it gets is usually where the bog starts i would agree so it's beyond the it's
beyond the fence is what you're saying right beyond the fence yeah but it's just so if i'm
doing the dishes in your house yeah first of weird for you, but let's imagine it.
I'm doing the dishes in your house.
I'm looking out the window. First, I see a yard.
Then I see a fence.
Then I see a slope.
Then I see a bog.
Correct.
And the most striking feature of this bog is there are five willows in it.
They're huge, healthy, happy, weeping willows.
Okay.
And I love them.
And I don't want to mess with them.
And you've sent in some evidence, some photographs of your property in Washington.
This is not in downtown Seattle, I take it. No, Portland is only 30 minutes south of us.
So you're in rural southern Washington. Yes. Okay, gotcha. And what I'm seeing
now, we'll put, if you don't mind, we'll post these photos up on our Instagram account at
Judge Sean Hodgman, also at our show page at MaximumFun.org. But what I'm seeing here
is some beautiful photos of some what look like willow trees. And I see some sort of like
low depressions in the earth, but it seems grassy. It
doesn't seem very bog-like to me. What, what am I, what am I missing here, Karen?
The, um, it's only bog-like in the winter when it's raining all the time. And I don't have any
pictures of it during that time of year. So, um So everything I was able to submit to you was just
so that you could get a basic idea of the size and the general landscape of what we're looking at.
The look and feel of the dried out bog. And we're calling it the frog bog, although it is sort of
like the Holy Roman Empire, neither
holy nor Roman.
It is not really a bog because a bog is a specific kind of wetland.
Correct.
That has that high acidic, you know, and I don't want, I don't want wetlands people writing
me letters.
I appreciate that.
We're speaking colloquially of the bog here.
Yeah.
Because I don't, I don't know that a bog would necessarily dry out.
I think a bog is a bog most of the time.
I think you're correct.
I chose that name because it rhymed with frog.
And we do have a lot of frogs.
You have a lot of frogs that hang out down there during the wet and dry season or during the wet season?
We definitely see them in the fall.
They come up and are near our house.
We see them a lot. But we hear them in the fall. They come up and are near our house. We see them a lot. But we hear
them all. I feel like we hear them all year, but I might be incorrect there. Because we haven't
lived here for very long. And when we first moved here, we had a baby a few months later. So a lot
of the time that we've spent here was kind of a blur. Okay. Where did
you move from? Vancouver. Vancouver, Washington? Yeah. Yeah. We lived there for two years. And
before that we were in Portland. So we've just been slowly migrating north. I'm presuming that
you're sort of rolling your eyes at Vancouver, Washington, because it is the most
confusing city in the United States, in North America. You can't have a Vancouver in Washington
and a Vancouver in British Columbia. Pick one, pick a different one, Washington.
Yeah. I actually have had the pleasure of teaching Washington state geography to seventh graders for
quite a few years. And they don't even know that they don't live in
canada they get so confused they're like oh vancouver bc cool yeah that's where i live
very strange so karen you want to leave the frog bog alone because you're a conservationist cart
yeah sure you like the frogs i like it i like it the way it is it seems happy and healthy it's not a monoculture like it seems like
honestly the healthiest part of our property all the rest of our property had a lot of horses on
it and now has uh you know like thistles and blackberries and holly that are all trying to
take over that we're having to really combat. But none of those things
are in that area. This primordial prehistoric bog is the healthiest part of your property,
including your own home. Got it. I understand. Matt, why don't you want to leave well enough
alone? What's your problem with the bog? Okay. my problem with the bog is a couple of things
but once it starts raining any amount the it immediately turns into just a muddy
kind of nightmare down there you can't walk anywhere near anywhere down there when it's dry
can you walk that ground carefully yeah it's it. It's very uneven because when it dries out,
you feel like you're going to break an ankle walking down there.
I presume because the earth is moving around and it's bog form,
there's some ooze that happens.
Yeah, absolutely.
Listen, bog experts, you've got to grant me some wide berth with this, okay?
I know you're going to be writing me.
I know the bog fans are going to be writing me i know the
bog fans are going to be writing me some letters but you know what we're talking i'm going to refer
i'm going to keep referring to it as the bog it's in its boggy state and it's non-boggy state and
it's non-boggy state it's uneven it's uneven ground it's sort of it's sort of treacherous
and when it's in its boggy state what happens matt when it's when it's rainy so when it's rainy it it is just
really really thick mud um with a little bit of water over it and it makes it uh impossible
to do any sort of mowing uh down there at all so the the grass why are you trying to mow the
bog in the first place it's a bog well there's grass that grows through that
whole area um and it gets just because grass exists doesn't mean you have to mow it this is
true um one of the things that i worry about um especially in the spring as we transition from
the bog season to the dry season is that we have grass that's then over six, seven feet tall and it dries out and creates a whole lot of fuel down there.
That if someone were to toss a cigarette butt out from the road that it could,
it could cause a pretty big fire.
So I like to try and keep it at least somewhat mode,
somewhat low to the ground.
Six, seven feet tall grasses.
Easily. What are you living in the land of the lost? What is going on in Southern Washington? I think it's a different variety
of grass because it is that tall. It goes way over my head. Not that I'm particularly tall,
but it's only the grass that's in that area that even gets that tall.
All the rest of our pasture grass grows to like two feet and it's done.
So you're telling me, Matt, and you're familiar with these photos?
Yes.
Right.
You're telling me that this picture of the bog that I'm looking at or the bogland in the sunshine when it's dry,
picture of the bog that I'm looking at or the bogland in the sunshine when it's dry if you don't mow it when it gets wet and it grows again this whole area is going to be overground with
six foot stalks of grass yeah I um so I cut that um before the the rainy that I cut it completely down as low as I could get it with the, the,
the tractor and the brush hog. And yet by, um, early spring, that grass was over, over my head.
Listen to these people, Jesse, they got a tractor and a brush hog. Do you have a brush hog, Jesse?
I got three.
What? For your property in, in property in Los Angeles, California? Yeah. Do I need to get
two? You're going to need four if you want to beat me. Well, it's not a competition, but as long as
I win. I have six tractors. What? Wow. All right. Very exciting to have all these tractors and
brush hogs. And of course, I guess
if you need to mow, if only for one reason, which is to reveal the hidden corgi in the bog,
because you sent in this other photo from the bog point of view of your house.
If this were a horror movie, this would be what the monster of the bog would see as it's
plotting your demise. But of course, you're being defended by this hidden corgi in the bog.
Bog dog.
Bog dog.
Who's this bog dog?
That's Mare Bear.
It's a cute dog.
And if you don't mow, you would never see that corgi, right, Matt?
Yeah, absolutely.
We have, so I kind of, we had just kind of three rail pasture fences and I put a wire fence on the inside of the entire area so it would be fenced in so the dog can play there.
So it's kind of like our at home dog park.
And when that grass is that tall, all you see is some rustling kind of kind of Jurassic Park, you know, coming through there.
park, you know, coming through there.
And when Mare Bear comes back from playing in the tall grasses into your home, can you see Mare Bear or do you just see the outer coating of ticks that cover your dog?
You know, we've been talking about ticks a lot lately.
Neither Matt or I have ever seen a tick.
I don't know if, are there ticks in Washington state?
We do have them. And I've seen them on branches and on other dogs or bushwhacking.
But we have a lot less of them in the western part of the state.
There's a lot more of them in eastern Washington.
Not enough people watch the tick.
That's how Hodgman ended up out of a job.
Oh, wow.
It was a great show.
You're really pouring salt into my tick wound there. It's a great show. You're really pouring salt into my tick wound there.
It's a great show.
Unlike certain networks, Amazon is not erasing its programming out of spite.
You can still watch The Tick and The Tick Season 2 on Amazon Prime.
The black-legged tick, it says here, is the most common species found in western Washington,
while the American dog tick and Rocky Mountain wood tick can be found in the eastern portion of the state. You're in southwestern Washington.
Great.
Yes. And Mare Bear stays up to date on her preventative flea and tick medicine.
Let's take a quick recess and hear about this week's Judge John Hodgman sponsor.
We'll be back in just a moment on the Judge John Hodgman podcast.
Hello, I'm your Judge John Hodgman. The Judge John Hodgman Podcast. Hello, I'm your Judge John Hodgman.
The Judge John Hodgman Podcast is brought to you every week by you, our members, of course.
Thank you so much for your support of this podcast and all of your favorite podcasts at MaximumFun.org.
And they are all your favorites.
If you want to join the many member supporters of this podcast and this network,
boy, oh boy, that would be fantastic.
Just go to MaximumFun.org slash join.
The Judge John Hodgman podcast
is also brought to you this week
by our pals over at Made In.
Jesse, you've heard of Tom Colicchio,
the famous chef, right?
Yeah, from the restaurant Kraft.
And did you know that most of the dishes at that very same restaurant are made with made-in pots and pans?
Really?
What's an example?
The braised short ribs, they're made-in, made-in.
The Rohan duck, made-in, made-in.
Riders of Rohan, duck!
What about the Heritage Pork Shop?
You got it. Made- of Rohan. Duck. What about the Heritage Pork Shop? You got it. Made in. Made in.
Made in has been supplying top chefs and restaurants with high-end cookware for years.
They make the stuff that chefs need. Their carbon steel cookware is the best of cast iron,
the best of stainless clad. It gets super hot. It's rugged enough for grills or an open flame. One of the most useful pans you can own. And like we said, good enough for real professional chefs, the best
professional chefs. Oh, so I have to go all the way down to the restaurant district in
restaurant town? Just buy it online. This is professional grade cookware that is available
online directly to you, the consumer, at a very reasonable price.
Yeah. If you want to take your cooking to the next level, remember what so many great dishes on menus all around the world have in common.
They're made in Made In.
Save up to 25% this Memorial Day from the 18th until the 27th.
Visit MadeInCookware.com.
That's M-A-D-E-I-N cookware.com.
The Judge John Hodgman podcast is also brought to you this week by the folks over there at Babbel.
Did you know that learning, the experience of learning causes a sound to happen?
Let's hear the sound.
Yep. That's the sound of you learning a new language with Babbel.
We're talking about quick 10-minute lessons crafted by over 200 language experts that can
help you start speaking a new language in as little as one, two, three weeks. Let's hear that sound.
Babbel's tips and tools are approachable, accessible, rooted in real-life situations,
and delivered with conversation-based teaching.
So you're ready to practice what you've learned in the real world, and you get to hear this sound.
It's not just like a game that pretends to teach you a language.
It's also not a rigid, weird, hyper-academic chore.
It is an actually productive app that actually teaches you while you are actually having a nice time.
And you get to hear this sound. Here's a special limited time deal for our listeners right now.
Get up to 60% off your Babbel subscription, but only for our listeners at babbel.com slash
Hodgman. Get up to 60% off at babbel.com slash Hodgman spelled B-A-B-B-E-L dot com slash Hodgman.
Rules and restrictions apply.
All right.
So the bog is hard to mow.
It's a fire hazard if it is unmowed, right?
Is that what you're saying, Matt?
I believe so.
Sure.
Who am I to second guess someone who owns a brush hog and a tractor, all joking aside?
And what would you like to do with this bug?
Just cement it over?
No, no.
I like how it is.
It's really nice.
I love the willows down there.
It's a great area.
I would love to just bring in, you know.
Just a Starbucks and a yoga studio.
Just 10 or so dump trucks of fill dirt and level it out a little bit. It's kind of great it so it's not such an extreme slope and just kind of bring the level of the ground up a couple of feet.
So it's a little bit drier and a little bit more stable and smooth so that you can walk on it, play on it, have the kid run around on it and not fall into a pit. So you live in the country now and you've obviously taken to it.
I enjoy it.
You have a tractor and you have a brush hog.
Yes.
What is a brush hog?
tractor and you have a brush hog yes what is a brush hog it's um kind of like a giant terrifying version of a lawnmower where the blades are a lot heavier and it's like four feet wide uh deck and
it's it hooks up to the back of the tractor and it uh you can mow down trees bushes um just about
about anything and this is obviously something that you had with you in Portland that you just moved with
you.
No.
Oh, no.
Okay.
So you lived in the city of Portland, then you moved to Vancouver, Washington.
Then you moved, which, are you moving more and more rural, would you say?
Yeah, that seems to be the trend for sure.
Look, I don't know a ton about living in the country, but I do know what happens in the
movies.
Young couple from the city moves from Portland, Oregon, buys a homestead out
in the country of Southeastern Washington, gets themselves a fancy new tractor and a brush hog,
decides they're going to be of the earth. And then they start tampering with nature.
They fill in the bog with fill dirt in order to cover over nature. And then nature takes its
revenge and sends a haunted bog man after them in the middle of the night.
Isn't that what's going to happen?
It sounds as plausible as anything else, I think, with this bug.
Karen, you seem like you want to say something about it.
I think you hit the nail on the head.
Matt is from the city.
He grew up between Olympia, Washington and Portland, Oregon.
from the city he grew up between olympia washington and portland oregon i'm from wyoming and grew up on seven acres and other than the lawn that was right around our house we just
left everything else alone um and and that's what i want to do here is yes we have our lawn
that we keep mowed and i'm even fine with a lot you're saying
that the that matt's certified and he wants to come out and tame nature and you want to respect
nature correct how do you respond to that matt well i would quote my father-in-law karen's father
and say that man is allowed to leave a footprint is what her father is said to me.
Are you sure you want to quote that?
It's not my philosophy on life, but I think that it already has a road running right through it where the field used to be.
And what's creating the drainage problem is actually the road.
The water's running off the crown of the road, which is sloped towards that field.
And it's not draining out along towards the creek that's down the road a ways where it naturally would drain towards.
So it's pooling right there.
There's actually a culvert.
So you're saying that this is a human made problem that you're trying to resolve?
Absolutely.
Judge Hodgman, read the Bible.
God gave us dominion over beast and bog.
Yeah.
Also, Genesis 19.7.
I don't know if that's a thing, but I'm pretty sure what it says is you don't need to worry about road drainage.
Just put your roads wherever you want.
Yeah, there's a lot of weird stuff in Deuteronomy.
I bet that's in there.
Man, it's okay.
What does your father say karen i don't something
about like man is supposed to leave a mark um i don't i look i'm sure you love your dad but that
feels very problematic to me um how would you describe your dad?
A Mark Levin man?
Well, uh, he had an excavation company.
You see, Karen, it's supposed to have strip mining supposed to happen.
Man is supposed to leave a mark.
You've got to destroy the earth to show God you were there.
Karen comes from bog building stock.
I'm sorry.
I don't mean to pick on your dad, but that's a real, that's a real, uh, uh, that's a real statement.
I got to say, I'm just want to get to the bottom of it a little bit.
Yeah.
It clearly stuck with Matt.
Well, I just, since we were talking about your parents' property and the philosophy regarding that and land management, I was just kind of pointing out that I don't know if that is the land management philosophy that you're trying to go with.
Yeah, I don't know.
It just felt relevant to me.
Well played.
well played so your suggestion then matt is if it's a drainage issue can't you repair the drainage can't you create a drainage solution rather than a fill-in solution yeah and that's
that's kind of what i want to do is that i mean it's actually there's a ditch that runs next to
the road and the field's actually lower than that so i I don't want to raise it up a ton. What I want to do is just raise it up enough to create flow to that ditch and to the culvert that's right at the neighbor's driveway at the bottom of that field.
All right. Yes. I understand, you know, being an accidental landowner myself, I understand about half of what you're talking about. I'm just going to pretend that I know what you mean.
I know.
I think I know what a culvert is.
That's fine.
The goal here is to sluice off the gunk into the neighbor's driveway.
Yeah, absolutely.
Sluice the gunk to the neighbors.
That's right.
Have you talked to any professionals, Matt, about this ecosystem that you're looking to
change?
No, I have not um i you know i kind of try to to diy things as much as possible and it's not
like it's a protected sort of wetland it's it's not there's no real flow through there there's no
protected species down there it's just grass and mud we have a lot of frogs that live there well that's
all the frogs that we have around here they're all pacific tree frogs so i'm not gonna mess with
the tree so so they're they'll be fine do you know that the trees will be happy in this new
in this new ecosystem i i don't um i do worry about damage of the trees but i mean although
moisture is still going to be there it's just just hopefully going to be lower in the soil and not on the surface as much.
That's your hope?
Yeah, that's my hope.
And it's a hope based on your professional understanding about how water drains through soil and soil types and that sort of stuff?
soil and soil types and that sort of stuff? Well, I would say that, I mean, we have a basement in our house and we have two sump pumps down there and they run constantly throughout the rainy
season. So there's plenty of water running under the property that the water table's fairly high.
And at that down there, it's going to, I mean, there's just flooded underneath the soil. It's
going to be fine. So if I were to say, okay, go for it, uh, fill that bog. How,
how would you do it? How would you, what would be job one?
Oh, it's going to be a big job. Um, uh, job one would be, I would,
I would probably do a little research and make sure the willows are going to
be okay. Um, and then I would start, um,
grading a path for trucks to get back there. And then I would start grading a path for trucks to get back there.
And then I would call up some dump trucks to come dump some fill dirt.
And then I'd be getting to work with the tractor.
It would take weeks.
Have you graded a path for dump trucks before?
No, I've not, but it'll be fun.
Like, I like learning new things.
What are you going to use to grade the path for dump trucks the brush hog i have a box scraper for for the tractor and
it does a pretty good job at smoothing things out our entire south pasture was all just muddy
horse tracks and i regraded the whole thing took some of the hill out and it worked out pretty good so i i'm feeling good about my uh my
my grading abilities i i you know what i give you a i give you an a that's my grade for your
grading abilities based on the fact that you're able to discuss it with a certain amount of
knowledge which i cannot karen seems like you have a pretty pretty handy handy partner there
when it comes to moving dirt around do you think matt can do this or no
yeah i think he can do anything there's not an issue of he wants to undertake a project that i
think is over his head and he's going to drown in this bog this is an issue of i think he can do it
and i'm afraid of what happens if he does correct lots of times he comes up with like, you know, oh, I would like to do blank.
You know, he gets project ideas in his head. And most of the time I don't worry about them because either it's a project that I also think is a good idea or it's one that I know he's not actually going to do.
This one concerns me because I think he actually wants to do it.
And I really don't want him to.
Before we go on to your feelings about it, what projects has he proposed that he has done and what projects has he proposed that he has not done?
One of each, if you can think of them.
So he has a he's a he loves to buy and sell vehicles of all sorts of kinds sure so
right now he's got a little diesel jetta in the garage that he's like completely taken apart
and is basically building and i'm fine with that i think it's super cool that he's going to have an old diesel jetta
it's going to be a great commuter car in the time that we've been together what year is the what
year is the jetta would you say matt oh it's an 01 oh okay so not like a 90 not a 91 hatchback
no it's it's a 01 turbo diesel jetta i thought it might have been my friend anna henchman's car
that i learned to drive manual on in college.
But no, that would have been a fun coincidence, but I guess not.
Okay, so he's working on the Jetta now and you think that he'll complete it?
I think he will.
He has had, I think...
That's a good Matt project.
That's a good one.
Right.
I think he's had five or six different boats in the time that we've
been together and he's only finished one of them we've only had one of them on the water
so he currently has a boat i don't think he's ever going to finish that i'm fine with that
what counts is finishing a boat getting it so that it can float being able to put it on the water right
okay what's the boat you have in the water currently matt uh it's not on the water i just
have a tiny little like aluminum rowboat it just needs some paint like it would float if you stuck
it in the water so by that by that metric it's already done there's just nowhere to sit did you
did you weld this together yourself no this is like, it's a 60s classic little Klamath rowboat.
It's just for fun.
Just extra thing to work on.
What else do you have going on in your lives?
You have this child, this corgi, and this cat that you all have to take care of.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Why does Matt have nothing else to do with his days but scavenge
old aluminum rowboats and and work on jetas and dream about paving over bogs so here we're coming
to the crux of it um he also no i'm glad i'm getting heated he also has uh about seven different
two-wheeled motorized
vehicles of
various...
I want to make a list of the stuff that Matt has.
Hang on.
Brush hog, tractor
with road grader.
Several boats, only
one of which you will admit to owning, which is a seatless aluminum
Klamath rowboat.
That needs paint.
That needs paint.
It only needs a coat of paint.
But it's a classic.
But it's a classic.
And then also, what did I miss?
Oh, yeah.
Disassembled Jetta.
And now what are we talking about?
Mopeds, scooters, dirt bikes, motorcycles.
So again, a hobby that I'm fully in support of.
He goes out and rides.
And here's the thing.
He has lots of hobbies.
I'm super happy for him for that.
My hobby is staying at home with the baby. So it's not a hobby. I know.
So if he then also takes on this other project, it's just more time that he's going to be outside
working on this project. And I'm gonna be alone with the baby and remind me how old this baby is 14 months
all right Matt do you think the baby could help I absolutely think she she's a little she's a
little shaky at running the tractor yet um she can't quite walk so I think once she can walk
she'll be she'll be fantastic hand at
that put her on a dirt bike and have her do the surveying i like that what was your life like in
portland in your in the city were you were you together then yes we were it was uh our lives
are totally different i mean we met both oh really it was totally totally different it's because it certainly doesn't sound like you've got the vibe of a city person who went to the country and is just going buck wild, going deep into country stuff.
Well, we both, like, we, both of our bands are playing the same house party was how we met.
What was the name of your band?
Mine was Necessary Means uh a big lebowski reference
uh for a band name yeah all right i like it and i was in race of strangers what kind of songs did
you play mountain goat songs or what just kind of like ours were kind of like silly generic
rock and roll sort of songs i was playing the
trumpet kind of just adding some horns to this band before you were filling in bogs you were
filling in the the back line on the in the on the horn section yep that's right and racist strangers
what did they play um kind of like i don't know like kind of more grungy rock songs um i played the violin
yeah we were in two rock bands in portland i played the trumpet obviously and i played the
violin that makes sense that tracks i was in a punk rock band at the same time and and she was
in like another band we were just we were crazy kid we're running around doing whatever you do in the city you know john in the space between
portland oregon and olympia washington you're actually required by law to be in a band
i think so it's what's known as the slater kinney corridor
yeah you wanted to escape you wanted to escape the uh the the tyranny of having to be in at least two bands and finally get some room to breathe and fill in a bog.
Was this your mutual dream to move out to the country or did one of you lead the way?
Karen?
I think it's mutual.
Yeah.
I'm from the country, especially I don't want to raise a kid in the city.
Like I want her to have the same kind of childhood that I did, which is just, you know, running around free and in the dirt and making mud.
Falling in the bog and never being seen again.
Gotcha.
Not being caught in the urban morass of Olympia, Washington.
Karen, it seems to me that your primary argument is you don't want to lose
your husband to the bog. That's well stated. And Matt, I ask you, like, you're going to grade this
path for the dump trucks. Can you, beyond that, you're just going to be, you said calling dump
trucks, which I guess is something you can do in the country is pick up your phone and go, hello, dump trucks. Yes. Dirt, please. Once it gets filled in, how much, how much more labor
intensive is it going to be? How do you respond to Karen's concern that you will be absent during
the bog project? Um, I, I appreciate her concern on that front and i think that's totally valid um i do have a lot of
projects and i would like to point out now though that i'm not working on any of my projects
the big project i'm working on right now is building a pavilion and outdoor kitchen for
karen uh right now which is a big 24 by 24 structure, 24 feet by 24 feet structure,
not yards and a big, uh, cement pad for it. And, you know, getting water and electricity
run out there. How the heck did you get so handy cement pad? If I, if I had to save my
children's life, I could not pour a cement pad.
I'm an electrician by trade.
Okay.
We have to do a lot of different stuff besides just play with electricity. So I've picked up a lot of stuff.
My family were contractors and framers.
All right.
It's in the family.
Yeah.
We've always kind of wanted to do everything.
I apologize for the calumny that I put on you.
I apologize for the calumny that I, that I put on you.
Try, even though, even though you play trumpet in a,
in a big Lebowski theme band in Portland, Oregon, you are not merely a hipster who had the dream of becoming a gentle person
farmer. You have this, you have handiness in your,
in your bones and in your family,
just as Karen has country in her, in your bones and in your family just as karen has country in her in
her bones and her family so i apologize for painting you in that even though you did play
in a punk rock band and a big lebowski theme band and karen played violin in a rock band yes jesse
thorne you wanted to say something when i lived in portland i played in a band called concrete pad
it's a great name for a band i played cello well i was gonna say what did you play accordion
timpani yeah marimba yeah marimba glock oh glockenspiel i played a little bit of glockenspiel
right and a double harp that's one harp on top of the other yeah you can only play it while driving
them while riding a penny farther motorcycle to get up high enough it has to wear an overcoat to pass for a single arm well it definitely sounds within your means
matt to do this how long is the project going to take to the bog fill-in project um i would estimate
that that project i mean i work during the, so really the only time I have to work is on weekends. So I'd say it'd probably be about a month
of weekends. A month of weekends after you finish the
outdoor kitchen pavilion? Correct. And when's that going to be
completed? I'm hoping by mid to late
September. What's your weekend childcare arrangement?
Karen.
Hmm.
Good question, Bailiff Jesse Thorne.
Karen,
you going to cook outside all winter long?
Oh, it doesn't get cold here.
So yeah, it'll protect us
from the rain and that's all that happens in the
winter. Our house is
really small on the
inside, so we can't really have people over. So we are
building this so that we can host dinner parties and stuff. And yeah, we'll be able to use it year
round. But it'll have an outdoor kitchen. Yes. Oh, that's incredible. Yes. And how will you keep
the bugs out? Or do you not have bugs there either in this paradise that you live in this tickless, bugless paradise?
Uh,
we don't have a bug problem in the winter,
but we have talked about,
um,
getting netting that we can kind of,
that'll be like magnetized on the edges.
So that,
um,
solution magnetized netting,
which is my band in Portland.
If I were to rule in your favor,
Karen, what would you have rule in your favor, Karen,
what would you have me rule?
Just leave that alone.
He is able to mow it in about July.
By then it's dried out and he can mow it
and that's fine.
I don't even think it needs that.
But other than that, leave it alone.
And Matt, if I were to rule in your favor?
Yeah, I would want the go ahead to get that project rolling after the current one is finished.
So Karen, you are the childcare for the weekends. Yeah yeah is this an agreement that you agreed to oh it's totally
fine um i and it's not like he's outside all weekend he always comes we always have dinner
together as a family and he always does the bedtime routine with the baby.
And so it's really not that bad.
And I'm pretty lucky that I am a teacher. So I'm home with her all summer.
Right.
So I just get a lot more time with her.
But I want him to be able to also have a lot more time with her.
She's only going to be this age this once.
We're not going to have any more kids.
So this is his one opportunity to be with her.
And that's more important than anything else.
Do you disagree?
Is filling the bog more important than spending time with your infant daughter?
No, I don't think filling the bog is more important than spending time with your infant daughter uh no i i don't think filling the bog
is more important than spending time uh with fern at all um no i i agree with her there um i
i guess yeah it's not like a necessary thing but i definitely would like to see it happen
do you feel that do you feel by filling in this bog, you're leaving your daughter
a legacy that she can enjoy for the rest of her life and therefore it's worth not seeing her
father on weekends for a period of time? In some ways, I don't know if I go quite that far as her
legacy, but I think that it's a space that she would enjoy. And I think that she would have a
good time playing there for years to come. And that could be worth a month of weekends.
When you come in and she looks up and she goes, who are you?
You're going to say, I'm your daddy.
You have never met me because I was leaving a mark, a filled in bog for you.
Her first words are going to be, bog man.
Bog man.
All right.
I think I've heard everything I need to in order to make my decision. I'm going to go
into the outdoor chambers pavilion that I just had constructed by competent people like Matt.
I'll be back in a moment with my verdict. Please rise as Judge John Hodgman exits the courtroom.
Karen, how do you feel about your chances today? I think I feel pretty good.
I felt super confident coming in, though.
And yeah, I still feel confident.
I think that it's clear that that area is beautiful and it's managing itself just fine.
Matt, how about you?
I'm not super confident, but I'll be cautiously optimistic.
Why is that?
I feel like you made my case about the dangers of untended yard debris.
We'll see what Judge Hodgman has to say about all this when we come back in just a minute.
Hello, teachers and faculty.
This is Janet Varney.
I'm here to remind you that listening to my podcast, The JV Club with Janet Varney, is part of the curriculum for the school year.
Learning about the teenage years of such guests as Alison Brie, Vicki Peterson, John Hodgman, and so many more is a valuable and enriching experience.
One you have no choice but to embrace because, yes, listening is mandatory.
The JV Club with Janet Varney is available every Thursday on Maximum Fun or wherever you get your podcasts.
Thank you. And remember,
no running in the
halls.
If you need a laugh and you're on
the go, try S-T-O-P-P-O-D-C-A-S-T-I-R.
Were you trying to put the name of the podcast there?
Yeah, I'm trying to spell it, but it's tricky.
Let me give it a try.
Okay.
If you need a laugh and you're on the go, call S-T-O-P-P-P-A-D-I.
It'll never fit.
No, it will.
Let me try.
If you need a laugh and you're on the go, try S-T-O-P-P-P-D-C-O-O.
Ah, we are so close.
Stop podcasting yourself a podcast from maximumfun.org if you need a laugh and you're on the go
judge hodgman we're taking a quick break from the case what's going on with you
well of course jesse uh the animated show that I co-created with our friend David
Reese is still available. Both seasons are on Hulu. Season one, 10 episodes. Season two,
10 episodes. It's a lot of fun. A lot of your friends are there, including the occasional
guest bail of Jean Grey. Check it out at Hulu.com or go to Hulu on whatever streaming device you
use and just search for Dicktown. Don't worry. If you Google Dicktown, you'll find Dicktown. And I mean our Dicktown, not the Dicktown you're afraid of.
Plus, speaking of Jean Grey and David Reese, I've mentioned it before, but I'm going to mention it
again. Check out Jean Grey on twitch.tv slash Jean of the Greys every Sunday. She's doing her
Church of Infinite You show at 1 p.m. It's wonderful to have on on a Sunday afternoon.
She's so terrific. And David co-hosts
the Election Profit Makers podcast with his old friend John Kimball and mine, but they went to
elementary school together, he and John. It's hard to laugh about politics, but they make me do it
every week and I enjoy it so much. And it reminds me to check out mobilize.us and to find political engagement in candidates and causes that I care about.
Mobilize.us will offer you opportunities to volunteer for campaigns near you or ones that you are particularly invested in.
And we're entering into a very serious midterm fight.
It's time to get off the sidelines.
Voting is not enough.
And advocate for the values that we believe in
through the people
who are doing the good work
of running for office.
So check it out,
mobilize.us.
What do you have going on, Jesse?
I host the comedy podcast
Jordan Jesse Go
with my friend,
comedy writer
and double Eisner Award nominee
this year,
Jordan Morris.
As he pointed out to me,
the E in EGOT.
That was a whistle of extreme.
I'm extremely impressed.
Like, wowee, double I's.
That guy's got double I's?
Double I's noms?
Got double I's.
I got to go out there to the award ceremony at San Diego Comic-Con.
Oh, it was a great time.
It is a classic freewheeling conversation comedy podcast.
My apologies for that, but we've been going for quite a long time, won quite a number of awards
over the years. I think you might actually enjoy it. If you need a place to start, we just have
Patton Oswalt on the show. You just had Patton Oswalt on Jordan Jesse Go? Absolutely. He's got
a new comic out. Run, don't walk is what I say. That sounds like a very fun conversation. I'm
going to go and download it right now and listen to it.
Who's funnier than Patton?
Very few.
Very few are funnier than Patton.
Is that the name of his new comedy album?
Yeah.
Very few are funnier than me.
Jordan Jesse Goh in your podcast app right now.
You've got your podcast app running.
That's how you're listening to this.
So just open it up and subscribe to Jordan Jesse Goh.
It's that easy.
We'll be back in just a second on Judge John Hodgman.
Please rise as Judge John Hodgman re-enters the courtroom and presents his verdict.
Karen, Matt, your father slash father-in-law is wrong. Sorry, dad, dad-in-law.
Is it man is meant to leave a mark or is it okay for man to leave a mark?
I heard him say it's okay for man to leave a footprint.
It's okay for man to leave a footprint.
That is one of the rarest declarations of excuse for destroying the environment that I've ever heard. And I know that he doesn't mean it that way, but it just really resonated with me. I mean, I don't know
what may means it. Maybe he does mean exactly that way. It's okay for man to leave a footprint.
I mean, cause you know, when you, when you, when you walk on the trails,
the preserved trails of Acadia national park or any state park or whatever. You know, the rule is leave no trace.
Do not leave a footprint.
And I would argue not only that we'd be a little better off if a bunch of men felt a lot less concerned about leaving a physical mark upon this earth,
but also, man, and I'm being very gendered here because that's Karen's dad's phrase.
Man, people, they don't leave a lot of marks in the longer term.
I mean, we've destroyed the planet.
I mean, that's a big old mark.
That's a big old mark that we left.
And we left it for a lot of guys in particular.
If you ever walk through a Greenwood Cemetery in Brooklyn, you look at the giant tombs and palaces that they built to themselves in death and you realize,
oh, these were guys who were truly believing that they were so important upon this earth that they
would be, that they needed to leave this phallic obelisk upon the earth as a testament to their
unforgettable manhood and their presence on this
planet. And guess what? They're all forgotten. They're all forgotten. We can work really,
really hard to destroy this planet. Short of blowing it up though, we will go before the
planet goes. There is no mark that we can leave upon the earth that I think does anything better than make our
lives, our personal small little lives slightly more convenient for us. There is very little
physical mark we can leave upon the earth that makes it better for the earth. Makes it a little
better for us. Usually in the aggregate makes it worse for the earth. I'm, you know, look, I, uh,
I, I, I'm, I'm not saying
that we ought just to sit around and twiddle our thumbs and do nothing and let nature consume us.
Nature will take care of that. I'm just saying that as a philosophy, it's not, it's not one that
aided you in this particular courtroom. You're half remembering of what your father-in-law said
to you. I mean, look, I'm, I'm'm sure i'm sure he's a terrific guy but that really
i gotta be honest left me a little a little gob or whatever smacked it's okay to leave it for no
you want to because the truth is there is one place where humans do leave a mark in a way that
is potentially very very beneficial and that is not scarring the earth literally and physically,
but influencing the people around them.
And in particular, if you have children, your children.
There is an accrual of influence upon the earth.
The only immortality, there is no immortality,
but the only thing close to it is the values that we pass along to other people, whether they're our own children or just younger generations that we mentor.
That's where humans can not only leave a mark, but a mark for betterment, as opposed to, I'm going to dig a hole here, or I'm going to cut off the top of this mountain,
or I'm going to fill in a bog, or I'm going to build a road over this perfectly good
lowlands that I'm going to turn into a bog because I didn't do drainage properly.
This isn't to say that these things shouldn't happen. This is just a statement of reaction to that comment.
So Matt,
I'm not sure that exactly helped you in your case here.
And Karen,
I hope that I haven't hurt your feelings about your dad.
Maybe your dad means that it is okay for a person to influence the world
around them.
And in other means,
other than digging a thing or filling in a thing,
because the things that you dig in that you fill in,
they're not going to last.
None of it's going to last.
We're all going to be erased.
We're all going to be erased in time.
So what do you do, as Gandalf says,
with the time that is given to you?
Well, do you fill in this bog or not?
I think that Matt has a real point
in that this bog may be great for frogs most of the time,
but if it grows to be untamed six foot dry grassland, it's not going to be fun for frogs
when the bog is on fire. And that's a compelling argument to me. I mean, Karen, do you think that
that's a good faith argument that Matt is making? Or do you think he's just making something up because he wants to get his brush hog out there?
No, that's true.
That's a genuine concern of his.
Now, Karen has argued that you can mow out there anyway during July, that it may be difficult.
But I'm glad that you're doing it.
I'm glad that you are keeping yourself and your neighbors safe from fire.
I'm glad that you are keeping yourself and your neighbors safe from fire.
I am not averse to the idea of investigating how to quote unquote improve this land to make it more usable for the humans that are temporarily inhabiting it and to make it easier to maintain to prevent fire and to correct the error of the bad drainage of the road. All of that I think is a fine project to consider, but I would not suggest that you go
and do it just the way you would take apart a Jetta and put it back together again. You know,
if you fail to put that Jetta back together again, you're already dealing with man-made
waste on this earth. If you rebuild that Jetta, then you have reclaimed something from the waste
process. If you fail to, if you fail to rebuild that Jetta, then you have reclaimed something from the waste process if you fail to if you fail
to rebuild that jetta then you just got junk in your own garage and everyone's entitled to have
a man is entitled to have junk in his own garage i'll say that that piece of gendered wisdom but
if you mess around with the land it's going to have implications that are bigger than i never
put together that jetta i don't know what those
implications are you're a lot more knowledgeable about your land and frankly about land than i am
both you matt and karen um so i'm not i'm not the city kid coming here to tell you guys what to do
in the country you know you've proven to me that you know more about all this stuff than i do i'll
never throw down a crunky pad i'll never understand exactly what a culvert does, even though I have one. I defer to both of your
expertise. And I obviously emotionally defer to Karen's feeling that you should just let nature
be nature as much as possible. There's no inherent nobility in getting out there
and mucking around with it. But that said, I don't think it's a, it's a dumb project. I do think that
Matt's instincts and desires are good, but I don't think it's a project that you should just go out
there with your brush hog and your road grader and start messing around with before you consult with people who are even more expert than you are.
I mean, I would talk to an arborist about those willow trees. I would, I don't know what resources
you would go to, to find out about what the ecological impact of filling this bog would be
and whether it would even be successful in what you intend to do.
You know, I don't know what happens when you fill in a bog up to that ditch level that you have next to the road. Maybe it stays dry forever, or maybe it just becomes deeper mud, or maybe it catches
on fire. I don't know. I'd walk the land with someone who really knows the land really well.
And if you've got the number to call a bunch of dump trucks, I bet you got the number to call some environmental consultants who'd be more than happy to talk
to you about what the impact of this would be. All of that said, the most important thing here
is that you don't give all of your weekends away to mopeds and scooters and Jettas and
pavilions, even karen is asking for
that outdoor kitchen pavilion which is going to be amazing oh an outdoor kitchen would be the
greatest thing in the world especially you don't have any bugs you live in a paradise like southern
washington where they don't even have deer ticks yet looks like i don't know maybe not
ah what fun you're gonna have but i would you know, the next project should not be filling the bog.
The next project should be finding out what happens when you try to fill the bog and what's
the best way to fill the bog and picking the time to fill the bog.
And while you're going through that consultation process, spend more of the weekend with your
child.
You're obviously both really good parents and you've already named your child.
You let it slip. Normally I don't ask the name of children, but if I remember it's Fern,
is that correct? Yes. Yeah. You've already named her after a low land, low light plant,
a bog plant, if you will. Yes. Whatever work you do in the bog has got to honor the bog.
And it's also got to honor, honor the bog and what it is meant to be
and not to destroy an environment potentially that is doing some work that you may not be able to see
and it's got to honor fern and that you are not taking time away from the most important mark you
will leave on life which is your influence and your values upon your child. Right now, she's just 14 months.
Yeah, Karen, she doesn't even know that Matt exists right now.
No idea.
Barely any idea.
But Matt, be careful because she's going to start noticing you soon.
You don't want to miss the fern for the bog, if you will.
It's a very famous saying that Karen's dad says.
I just want to be clear that
the verdict is technically in Matt's favor. I'm sorry. But it is contingent upon two very
important things. One, true consultation with environmental experts and people who know how
to fill bogs to make sure that this effort is worth putting in
with absolute right to abandon it if you are advised to leave it alone.
And two, spacing out this project long enough so that Matt has time to provide you with the
parenting backup that you require on the weekends. So is it a compromise? I'm sorry to say probably
yes. Is it technically Matt's favor? Yes. This is the sound of a gavel. Judge Sean Hodgman rules
that is all. Please rise as Judge Sean Hodgman exits the courtroom. Karen, it sounds like you lost. How are you feeling?
You know, I don't feel like a loser. I feel pretty satisfied with the ruling because Matt will not be able to just dive into this project. He has to consult some experts first. And I think that I
will have a little say in next steps as well. So I feel good about it.
Matt, how do you feel?
I feel good. I think that I got a lot of good advice and it was a very insightful verdict. I
appreciate Judge John Hodgman's opinion there.
Matt, Karen, thanks for joining us on the Judge John Hodgman podcast.
Thank you for having us.
Thanks for having us.
Another Judge John Hodgman case is in the books.
In a moment, we'll have swift justice.
Our thanks to Twitter user at Irony Maiden for naming this week's episode scheduled for a drainment.
If you want to name a future episode, make sure to follow us on Twitter at Hodgman and at Jesse Thorne.
You can also hashtag your Judge John Hodgman related tweets, hashtag JJHO.
You can join us in conversation on Reddit at MaximumFun.reddit.com.
Evidence for the show posted on our Instagram account at Instagram dot com
slash Judge John Hodgman. You're going to want to see this bog dog. Follow us there.
It's a really handsome bog dog. Our producer is Jennifer Marmer. Our editor is Valerie Moffitt.
Now, Swift Justice, Twitter user at M Salamander asks, when visiting friends or family who don't know what motion smoothing is, is it wrong to secretly disable it on their television sets?
Motion smoothing, Jesse Thorne, if I understand this, is a very controversial thing among cineasts.
It's a feature on new televisions where the television manipulates the picture to
make the motion seem more smooth, hence the name. But instead it makes everything, including
great works of cinematic art, look like they were shot on a soundstage in 1985. They make
everything look like they were shot on video in 1975, like it's all iClaudius or whatever.
It makes beautiful footage look like daytime soap operas.
And you will find film nerds on whatever discussion board you can find getting so mad about motion smoothing.
So I guess Ms. Salamander is one of these who has gone home to visit friends or like their, their, their parents or whatever have motion
smoothing on and they just want to, they want to switch it back secretly. They hate motion
smoothing that much. But what I say is don't do anything secret to your parents' televisions.
They probably don't even know how to turn on the TV. It's not their fault.
They're just wanting to watch their stories. They don't know about motion smoothing.
Just sit down with them and say,
hey, would you like it better if it looks like this beautiful or like this cheap garbage?
And then they'll say, it's their TV.
Don't mess around with someone's TV without asking.
Have you got a dispute about film and television?
Send it to us, MaximumFun.org slash JJHO. You can't have a dispute with film and television, send it to us, maximumfund.org slash JJHO. You can't have a
dispute with film and television because film and television can't speak for itself.
Also, I would say any disputes about bogs or swamps, I'm still into bog and swamp justice.
Of course, we're willing to hear disputes about anything. Go toumFun.org slash JJHO and share your disputes with us.
We'll talk to you next time on the Judge John Hodgman podcast.