Judge John Hodgman - Sport Reform

Episode Date: August 16, 2017

Karen brings the case against her husband, Tom. Tom has been teaching their 8 year old son about faking injuries on the soccer field. Karen doesn't think this is okay but Tom says this is an accepted part of the game! Who’s right? Who’s wrong?

Welcome to the Judge John Hodgman podcast. I'm bailiff Jesse Thorne. This week, sport reform. Karen brings a case against her husband, Tom. Karen is unhappy with the idea of Tom teaching their eight-year-old about faking injuries on the soccer field. Tom says this is simply an accepted part of the game. Who's right? Who's wrong? Only one man can decide. Please rise as Judge John Hodgman enters the courtroom and presents the obscure cultural reference. There are different circumstances when a litigant must be cautioned for unsporting behavior in the court of Judge John Hodgman, e.g. litigant verbally distracts the other litigant during the hearing, or if a litigant holds the other litigant for the tactical purpose of pulling the opponent away from the microphone

or preventing the opponent from getting to the studio, or if the litigant uses a deliberate trick to pass justice to his own side with his head, chest, knee, etc. in order to circumvent the law, or if the litigant attempts to deceive the judge by feigning injury or pretending to have been fouled, a.k.a. simulation. If these laws are understood, Bailiff Chessie Thorne, please swear the litigants in. Karen and Tom, please rise and raise your right hands. Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth,

so help you God, or whatever? I do. I do. Do you swear to abide by Judge John Hodgman's ruling, despite the fact that he only plays soccer using popples? I do. Yes. Very well. Judge Hodgman?

I don't even know what a popples is, Bailiff Jesse. It's a plush sports ball that you turn inside out and it turns into a plush friend. Oh, yeah, that's my kind of sports. You got it. I enjoy that very much. Plush friends. Speaking of plush friends, Jesse,

it's nice to have you back after our little summertime hiatus. I hope you had a good break. A joy to be back. Well, here we are. And, oh, these guys are still standing up. Karen and Tom, go ahead, sit down. For an immediate summary judgment in one of yours favors,

can either of you guess the piece of culture that I paraphrased as I entered the courtroom? Karen, why don't you make the first guess? I'm guessing the FIFA rulebook. The official FIFA rulebook. The official FIFA rulebook. I'm still here, by the way, in Maine with Joel Mann, engineer here at WERU-FM in Orland, Maine. Joel, do you know what FIFA means?

Never heard of it. All right. It's a football's term. All right. Tom, what's your guess? She took my answer. So you make the same guess? Yes.

Right. All guesses are right. Therefore, this little game is over, and the new game is afoot, the game of justice. Sorry, you guys guessed correctly. Both of you guessed that it was the FIFA official rules of soccer, a.k.a. football, a.k.a. the laws of the game. And that is appropriate to this because why, Karen? You are bringing your husband, Tom, into my courtroom for what misbehavior, according to you? We have an eight-year-old son who plays soccer, and I don't know anything about sports. I didn't

play sports at school. I don't know anything about soccer. Tom is a very good soccer player. He's a good soccer coach. Recently, I heard him have a conversation with our kid about how if you can't get the ref's attention when someone is wronging you on the soccer field, it's appropriate to fake an injury. And I think that is you should not teach your kid to fake anything in sports or otherwise. All right. Now, you have a nice accent. What part of the world are you from and where do I find you? We live in North Carolina.

Where? We live about 45 minutes out of Asheville. Oh, Asheville is a beautiful country. Yes. And are you a North Carolinian? Most of my life I lived in Tennessee, but my family is not from the South. Oh. Not that there's anything wrong with that.

No. Where are they from? My mom is from California. My dad's from Ohio. And so they raised you in Tennessee and you took on that accent yourself. I was not aware that I had such an accent. Joel? Yes, Judge?

Do you confirm an accent? I definitely do. Yeah, okay. Let me tell you what. Here in Maine, you sound like you have an accent. Okay. But it's nice talking to you. It's nice to hear.

I'm not going to suggest that you affected an accent. It sounds very natural and authentic. Okay. Tom, what accent are you faking? I don't have to fake an accent judge no i'm just kidding no i'm i'm from the south actually you are pointed out yes i get the impression that he was trying to do two different accents just now and failed completely that's it's like when i try to do a eastern european and german accent i get so i can't do of them, so I do a mishmash of them both.

And that's my Ayn Rand impersonation. But moving on. So, Tom, you are from the South? Yes, I grew up in North Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, in Kingsport, Tennessee. Okay. And did you grow up playing, do you call it soccer or football? What do you call it? Well, I call it soccer.

Yeah. Yeah, I played soccer. We won a 12 and under boys state tournament in Tennessee, and then I went and played in the national tournament in Florida. And that was the best part of your life, and it's all been downhill since? It's been downhill since then. I'm sorry. What did you do since you didn't become a professional soccer player? I ended up running cross country in college. Oh, fantastic. And that's how you make your living now? No, I actually work for the state, the Department of Public Safety. Oh, cool. And Karen, what's going on in your life on a day-to-day? I work for an agency and I facilitate

assessments for people with intellectual developmental disabilities. That's very honorable, too. So here we go. Nice family, 45 minutes outside of Asheville, some lovely accents, a love of soccer, and this dispute over teaching your child to fake an injury. Tom, I have had to do some research into this to understand what we're talking about here, but I'm not just going to explain it to everybody. I'm going to let you do that since the case has been brought against you. I had never heard of this before. Tell them what it's all about. Well, faking injuries in soccer happen professional

level often, and it's frowned upon mostly. I recognize that. But in our case, we're in a rural kind of area. A lot of the kids come from football practice to soccer practice. And a lot of kids have a more aggressive type mentality. Some of the kids vary in size. Yes, I did say that maybe you should consider faking the injury, but it was under the circumstance that if a kid had been almost bullying on the soccer field and the refs, there's only one ref. If the ref did not catch that attention, that he should maybe draw attention to it in order to keep from other things happening. And what specifically did you advise your son to do in order to draw attention to himself? Yeah. Well, my wife, she, she called in, there's a conversation about at this point and I said, no, not falling on the ground and acting like you broke your leg or anything like that. But if a kid is continuing to push you and the ref's not seeing it, then maybe you need to go to the ground and draw attention to it. push you and the ref's not seeing it, then maybe you need to go to the ground and draw attention to it. But that was the last of the order of the soccer policy we created. We wanted to try to

outplay the bullies first on the soccer field, as I will say, the bullies, because they tend to be bully, very physical. And so I wanted to outplay them. And then I wanted to let the ref know, use his communication skills. And then if that him to let the ref know he uses communication skills. And then if that didn't work, try to draw attention to penalty because I don't want him to give up on the soccer field. I don't want him to stop playing. I don't want him to get into a fight. I don't want there to be an issue. So as a last resort, let's try to draw some attention to this.

Tom, how many referees are watching over one of your kids' games? One. So it's a big field, right? Yes. No further questions. Okay. Okay, I appreciate that this is a cheat of last resort. And as you point out, Tom, this is done at the professional level, especially outside of the United States.

Yes. It's called flopping or diving, and it is a technique that I learned about using the internet. So you can tell me if I understand it correctly. It is a technique where you exaggerate or feign an injury, sometimes by flopping down to the ground and spasming an agony in a highly theatrical way in order to draw attention to a foul or to pretend that there has been a foul against you in order to gain your team the advantage of a free kick.

Is that correct? Yes. And as we have noted, since I paraphrased from the laws of the game, this is beyond frowned upon. It is against the rules, correct? Yes. Right. But you're saying that it is okay to break the rules in this case because your poor son is going to get mauled by these football ogres, these double football ogres playing both football and soccer, and they're just running all over your son all over the place.

Yes, correct. But more want to enhance or overemphasize the penalties that they are already doing. So you're not counseling your son to be a liar just to break the rules when necessary. Correct. Would you say that it is your intention that, i and i'll remind you that you're under fake oath is your intention here to help your son protect himself or to gain his team an advantage both form a free kick oh both well i appreciate your honesty yes you could have easily lied in this non-court and just said, oh, it's just to protect little.

Would you like to say his name on the air? Shall I make one up for him? You can make one up. All right. We'll call him. We'll call him. Eli. That's his name.

He would love to hear his name. No, we're trying to toughen him up here, Karen. Too late. We'll call him Little Fauntleroy because he's being pushed around. He's being pushed around in his knee pants out there on the soccer pitch. Tom's trying to toughen him up. But you know what? Asheville is a lovely country, but youth soccer there seems like a Mad Max Fury Road situation.

Karen, is the danger to your son such that he needs this kind of protection, the protection of lies? No. All right. What do you see going on out there? I mean, is Eli Fauntleroy in any danger of getting pushed or picked on or bullied out there physically or even emotionally? I don't feel like he's ever been singled out. And I also don't feel like it's a big issue at this age group. Maybe it is as they get older.

But I would still say you should teach your kids to cheat or fake, even when they're older. Have you heard Tom explain to Eli Fauntleroy why this is happening? What do you think about the explanation? They didn't have an extended conversation about it, but I felt like it was not very explanatory. I feel like it could easily be interpreted like you did as far as it's okay to break the rules when it suits you. Tom, how do you respond to that? Do you think that maybe you're giving Eli Font-Laroy a bad lesson here?

No. All right. That reminds me never to ask yes or no questions. What is the lesson that you are trying to teach Eli? Well, we teach lots of lessons to Eli. I have taught him to use his voice and to not fight or don't let his temper get the best of him. And sports is a major mental game. In all sports, they have people that over-exaggerate fouls.

You take advantage of people's weaknesses. In this case, I'm trying to take advantage of an aggressive, larger soccer player that might not stop or the ref might not call a foul or penalty and, and trying to show him another way to show this without having a fight or walking off the field upset or stop playing soccer. Cause he's a very good soccer player. He's been invited to play in the local Spanish league because he does very well. I've spent a lot of time coaching him and at home. And we have actually had a larger kid in a soccer game come through and just knocking kids over before. And the next game, I told my son, just deny him the ball. Don't let him get in the ball. Don't let him get in the play. And my son did that and the kid never touched the ball. And unfortunately that kid walked away crying.

Because he didn't touch the ball. Correct. Tom, are you familiar with the logical fallacy, the appeal to nerd? No. That's when you tell a nerd who's sitting in judgment over you that your kid needs to cheat because he's so little and the big kids are picking on him. Is Eli a small kid? No, he's average size. What percentile? I actually, I think last time I found out it was like in the upper 40s. Oh, yeah. So that's middle to a little bit small.

Yes. Yeah. Let's take a quick break. We'll hear more about Karen, Tom and their soccer dispute in just a minute. You're listening to Judge John Hodgman. I'm bailiff Jesse Thorne. Of course, the Judge John Hodgman podcast always brought to you by you, the members of MaximumFun.org. Thanks to everybody who's gone to MaximumFun.org slash join.

And you can join them by going to MaximumFun.org slash join. The Judge John Hodgman podcast is also brought to you this week by our pals over at Made In. Jesse, you've heard of Tom Colicchio, the famous chef, right? Yeah, from the restaurant Kraft. And did you know that most of the dishes at that very same restaurant are made with Made In pots and pans? Really? What's an example? The braised short ribs, they're Made In, Made In.

The Rohan duck. Made in, made in. Riders of Rohan. Duck. What about the Heritage Pork Shop? You got it. Made in, made in. Made in has been supplying top chefs and restaurants with high-end cookware for years.

They make the stuff that chefs need. Their carbon steel cookware is the best of cast iron, the best of stainless clad. It gets super hot. It's rugged enough for grills or an open flame. One of the most useful pans you can own. And like we said, good enough for real professional chefs, the best professional chefs. Oh, so I have to go all the way down to the restaurant district in restaurant town? Just buy it online. This is

professional grade cookware that is available online directly to you, the consumer, at a very reasonable price. Yeah. If you want to take your cooking to the next level, remember what so many great dishes on menus all around the world have in common. They're made in Made In. save up to 25 this memorial day from the 18th until the 27th visit made in cookware.com that's m-a-d-e-i-n cookware.com the judge john hodgman podcast is also brought to you this week by the folks over there at babble did you know that learning, the experience of learning, causes a sound to happen? Let's hear the sound. Yep, that's the sound of you learning a new language with Babbel. We're talking about quick 10-minute lessons crafted by over 200 language experts that can help you start speaking a new language in as little as one, two, three weeks. Let's hear that sound.

Babbel's tips and tools are approachable, accessible, rooted in real-life situations, and delivered with conversation-based teaching. So you're ready to practice what you've learned in the real world, and you get to hear this sound. It's not just like a game that pretends to teach you a language. It's also not a rigid, weird, hyper-academic chore. It is an actually productive app that actually teaches you while you are actually having a nice time. And you get to hear this sound. Here's a special limited time deal for our listeners right now. Get up to 60% off your Babbel subscription, but only for our listeners, at babbel.com slash Hodgman.

Get up to 60% off at babbel.com slash Hodgman, spelled B-A-B-B-E-L dot com slash Hodgman. Rules and restrictions apply. Welcome back to the Judge John Hodgman podcast. You're listening to Sport Reform. Karen doesn't want her husband Tom to teach their son about faking injuries on the soccer field. What's she worried about happening? Let's get back to the court run and find out. Tom, so it sounds like Eli is pretty deft with the old soccer orb, if you could keep it away from the brute who was knocking kids over. Yes. Yeah.

the brute who was knocking kids over. Yes. Yeah. So it seems like he's got a defense available to him. So in this situation, Tom, let's do a little role play. I'm little Eli Fauntleroy, Mr. 40% himself. And I'm like, Daddy, what does he call you? Papa?

Father? I'm just Dad. Honorable Father. Yes. I want to play by the rules. You're telling me to break the rules. Why, Honorable Father, why? Well, unfortunately, it is a part of the game that I go back to,

and I speak with him in real terms. No, no, no, now I'm your son. You talk to me now. I speak with him in real terms. No, no, no. Now I'm your son. You talk to me now. Honorable Father, I am a good boy, and I read the rule book, and you're telling me to break the rules. How can that be part of the game? It's an unspoken part of the game, son, that you're going to have to learn one way or the other.

And if you're going to play on the professional level, you're going to know how this works. And you need to learn early if you plan on playing further. You are saying, Father, that in life there are unspoken rules too? Correct. Now I feel like rules have no meaning at all. Are these brutes going to murder me? On the soccer field, they might. murder me on the soccer field. They might.

It's funny because you don't, I don't watch, as you can probably tell, I don't watch a lot of sports and I don't watch a lot of soccer. And I would have guessed that I could watch a lot of soccer and not feel like I was going to see a lot of hard sacking going on, but it's pretty physical, huh? Yeah,

definitely. All right. Tom, are you your son's coach? No. Have you talked to your son's coach or has your son's coach talked to Fauntleroy about the situation? No. So this is sort of a wildcat deal. Yeah. Homeschooling. Honorable father, it's me again. Little Lord Eli Fauntleroy of the 40%. How do I do it? What do I do? Teach me how to take a dive, Father. Well, if a kid starts pushing you, you let the ref know,

and you tell the kid to stop pushing you. But if he does it again, and he pushes you, then maybe you need to go to the ground and say, Ref, he pushed me to the ground. And so, Honorable Father, do I fall to my hands and knees? Do I fall on my back? Yeah, fall to your hands and knees, and then maybe get up with a slight twitch, and maybe limp back into normalcy.

I should use my body language to lie? Definitely. But Father, isn't lying wrong? Not in this case. Do other kids on the team do this? Probably not intentionally. Subliminally, yes. We have a lot of kids that walk off crying or frustrated or faking injuries because they're upset.

Yeah, I have to keep reminding myself that these are eight-year-olds. Yeah, you know, I don't know if their fathers are at home telling them to lie or not, but sports is like war, all's fair in war, right? So sports is different in every sport. Like LeBron James flops when he's charged. He fakes an injury. He draws the other team out, and it's a part of the game in every sport.

Unspoken. Yes. So, I mean, if a guy is right-handed, you make sure you stay on his left-hand side in basketball or boxing. You move to that side. I took jiu-jitsu. You don't go to the man's strength. You find his weakness, and you try to exploit that. You mentioned that sports is like war and everything is fair.

It seems to me that's a not entirely accurate simile. Probably not. I mean, there are rules in war, perversely. But sports in particular is metaphor for tribal warfare. But sports in particular is metaphor for tribal warfare. It is to help us get through our tribal instincts to battle with the person on the other side of the river, but to do so in an organized way where people play by certain rules and can expect those rules to be the same across the board. Would you not agree yeah i i do and american soccer has been that way traditionally right but american soccer has never been on top of the uh on on the pyramid of soccer yeah i mean i'll be a uh satan's advocate here for a moment and say uh hail satan uh he is great but also has this point of view which is that um american soccer where flopping and diving and faking and lying in this way is much less prevalent

and much more punished is is part of the reason that that lack of this lying technique is part of the reason why American soccer is not more successful throughout the world. Is that true? Yeah, that's actually very true. And you mentioned that kids are walking off the soccer pitch crying and hurt legitimately, and you don't think that they're necessarily faking it. I guess what I'm asking you is what the hell is going on, sir, in this eight-year-old soccer game? Have you been to an eight-year-old sporting event? Not since I was eight. Oh, gosh. Between the parents and the fits thrown on the field and the cheap shots,

it's pretty interesting. Karen, how do you feel about the sports program in general in Eli Fauntleroy's life? I don't have any problem with it. I think he really enjoys it. He's good at it. And do you think that he's in, in danger of physical harm? No. All right, good. Do you think he's learning good values generally? In soccer? Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. This is the one bad value. Yeah. So Karen, Tom has made the point that this is not just run-of-the-mill cheating that he devised in his own cheating workshop back home. This is the way the game is played at a certain level. Shouldn't Eli Font-Lauroy be trained in all of the both light and dark arts of soccer if he's going to pursue it with some success? I don't think so.

I think if he was a really good player, he would be a really good player without having to do that. I also don't think he's going to be a professional soccer player. But Tom pointed out that the world's best players, in soccer especially and in other sports as well, do this sort of thing. I don't think that makes it okay. You'd rather your son be a less skilled player than go over to the dark side and become a round ball Sith? I don't think it would be less skilled. It just would be less fake. What are the values you're concerned are being taught to Eli Fauntleroy by his daddy in this regard?

That if it suits your purpose, it's okay to cheat, fake, lie. Or if that's just the way people do it, then that makes it okay. Yeah, but if Tom drew a bright line around soccer, is it just soccer, Tom, or any sports? Oh, definitely just soccer.

And why? Because it's such an ingrained part of the game? Yes. Because you were talking about LeBron flopping too. Are we talking basketball? Well, he doesn't play basketball. He's in the 40 percentile. You know what? I'll give you credit for it. I'll give you credit for it, Tom. You see the world as it is, not as you want it to be.

That's exactly right. My son's 40 percentile. He's not going to play basketball and he's definitely going to have to go to ground. Have you drawn that bright line around soccer for Eli Fontleroy already? I mean, you've had the talk with him, right? Yes. Right. You've had the this is how you cheat son talk that every father and son has. Yeah, this is exactly when you do it now. And do you say to him, but don't, this obviously doesn't apply to your math quiz.

Exactly. No, I tell you, we have, and I'm going to pat both of us on the back. in this day and age of internet and all the technology, we have tried to keep him with some traditional honest values, minus soccer, but he says, yes, sir, yes, ma'am, and he's a good boy. It's not prompted. He does that on his own. He's a very good kid, very smart, very good at sports, but I also just don't want him to be blindsided one day by the reality or the truth of the world.

Can I make an objection? Yeah, I'll allow it. Two things. He does not say yes, ma'am, no, ma'am. Except occasionally. That means one of you is lying. She said occasionally. I didn't say the frequency.

I mean, I feel like once is pretty much world champion for an eight-year-old in 2017 exactly i would say so too oh bailiff my bailiff sir that's how i'm supposed to address him apparently i'm glad you read the memo i only got a thousand copies of it shoved down my chimney by owls. Well, I train those owls well. Yes, sir. My bailiff, sir. Where were we? Right.

Your objection, please, Karen. Please continue with your objection. My main objection was that when you asked him if he's had the extended conversation about how this only applies to soccer, if that has happened, I've never been there to hear it. How much of the conversation did you hear? I heard up to the part where he told him to cheat and fake I didn't leave it's not like I left I just thought that was the end of it what set the scene where where were you guys I was in the kitchen and they were in the living room it wasn't a really extended conversation but then I voiced my opinion and was told that I was incorrect.

Did you hear that? Did you hear the part from the kitchen? Could you hear Tom saying, you have to understand, son, sports is war? And he said, yes, sir. What was Eli's reaction to this instruction? Well, he listens pretty well. But this was not too – this has never come into play. He's never had this issue on the soccer field. This was just a talk.

We were talking about the kid that he denied the ball and how that worked so well. And then we went into the conversation is what if it didn't work? What if it, what if the kid kept pushing and what if the worst case scenario, you know, what, what will we do? And we're like, we don't want to fight. We don't want to walk off the field. We don't want to walk off crying and quit the game of soccer. We want to keep playing. So we have to use all of our tools. So you were giving him speculative cheating advice. Yes. Yes. Speculative cheating. But I have done this in other areas of his life that have worked well. So he responds well. So you want to make sure that he knows that cheating is an option to him.

Correct. In soccer, Jesse. Got it. And there's no way that someone who is told that cheating is okay in one area isn't going to maybe apply that to other areas of their life. That's just not how humans work. Once they have the idea, it's like, nope, it's regimented into this one activity. Got it. If lying works here, why would I try lying anywhere else to get what I needed or wanted in life? Well, certainly with, and I'm sure both of you are familiar with this, this sort of rich and complex set of understandings of social rules and expectations that every third grader has. Exactly. There is no greater creature of nuance than an eight-year-old.

But Tom, I must press you. You did not answer my question when i said what how did eli respond when you gave him this information you went ahead and gave me the information again what did your son say but if anything besides yes sir i really don't remember exactly how i responded because i was getting the beat down from my wife. Oh. Did this fight happen in front of Fauntleroy? It wasn't a fight. Oh.

I mean, really, it wasn't. Really? No. No, it really wasn't. He said his thing, and then I shared my opinion, and that was it. Then I wrote into the show. So when you say it wasn't a fight, was that because you simply expressed your contrasting opinion to Eli and to your husband or that you beat your husband down so severely with your rhetoric that he wasn't even feigning injury? He was spasming on the floor.

It was not a fight. It was not a fight. But why am I still asking this question? What did Eli say? I don't think he said anything. He just took it in. He probably just was kind of like, okay. Yeah.

He's just said, daddy's teaching me to lie. Daddy told me to lie on soccer. Who is my daddy? I thought he was one person, but now I know he believes in lying. Is he lying to me now? About soccer? Maybe my daddy is telling me something he made up himself. And now I'm going to do this thing

and the referee is going to go, you can't lie in soccer. And my daddy will laugh and laugh. It's hard. What would you have me rule, Karen, if I were to rule in your favor? I would ask that you rule that he not do that. That he not teach him how to

cheat or fake. But if he has to... You can't unring a bell. Okay. Okay. So I think there needs to be further explanation, detailed explanation, and follow-up conversations about how apparently this is just going to apply to soccer there's precedent for him not being able to not generalize what do you mean we have

some issues with him sort of not knowing when to tell on someone and when not to and so we've had a hard time with that because we don't want him to let someone else be bullied or mistreated, but I guess it's been our problem because it's hard for us to know how to teach him to know the difference. Would you say he out here dry snitching to the poe? I'm not prepared to say that. In other words, he needs to learn not to talk about the family business.

Basically. Got it. Okay, so a clear delineation. This is only for soccer, correct? Yes. Well, this is what Karen wants. Well, I guess it's, yeah. I mean, if that's the best we could do.

No, you ask. It's your... Well, no, because you told me that it's, yeah. I mean, if that's the best we could do. No, you ask. It's your... Well, no, because you told me that it was too late. I can't go back. Because the damage had already been done. Look, would it be even more confusing to your son if a strange bearded man traveled to Asheville from Maine? Jesse, that's a state in New England. Got it. from Maine, Jesse, that's a state in New England, and talked to your eight-year-old and did a full lecture to him about where his daddy is right and wrong, and then I'd drive away,

I think that could be extremely damaging and confusing, even more confusing than it already is. But I guess I may have to do that. John, have you thought about sitting in a chair with its back against your front? I think that would really help. Oh, I mean, turn a chair around and sit, have my hands over the back of the chair? Yeah, I mean, I just find that really useful when I'm talking with children or teens

or just anyone who needs straight talk. Yeah. You know what? I always turn my judge's chair around when I do the verdict. Great. I'm sorry we haven't put that sound effect in for the past four years. Good rapping with you, Judge. Yeah. Tom, what would you have me rule if I were to rule in your favor? I would have you rule that my wife, Eli's mother, needs to trust that I have his best interest in mind when these talks I have with him and that I'm talking about things that really do happen. I do explain to him, you know, this is in soccer, this is this occasion, but

I don't teach him to lie in general. But in soccer, this is sports, and this is a sport issue. It really does happen, and he's going to deal with it eventually. So I would just like for her to recognize that and just kind of leave me alone. We can all hear you, even if you whisper. We all know that you're saying, please order my wife to leave me alone.

Is this an issue, her not leaving you alone? Is this an issue in other areas of your marriage that you need to tell me about? Well, my wife has a great feeling of fairness in her life that this probably applies to. She always has to be fair and always feels bad for the underdog in any situation. I remember her saying when this happened that that was not fair to do that to the other players, that that was cheating. And she always feels bad for anybody that is being treated unjust, I guess you would say. So we had a dog that was 45 pounds. We had one that was 75 pounds. She gave them both the same amount of food because she felt bad for the little dog getting less food at one time.

So it's hard for her to deal with things that might not be fair. She was literally rooting for the underdog. Yeah, she was feeding for the underdog. And did the little dog get obese and die early as a result? Yeah, it gained 15 pounds and then we had to put it on a diet. obese and die early as a result. Yeah, he gained 15 pounds and then we had to put it on a diet. Tom, if your son goes to ground because of a real or perceived foul in order to draw attention to himself and then gets an extra kick for the team as a result, that's not

a problem for you? Definitely not. Because the bully initiated the foul. Right. But you're not instructing Eli to make up a foul. No. Mm-hmm. Once he gets mad with power,

those go-to-ground spasms, and he realizes what he gets out of that. Teaching him to have a tantrum. Gets what he wants. Extra points. Hmm. All right, I think I've heard everything I need to in order to make my decision. I'm going to go into my personal full-size soccer pavilion that I have never used, it turns out.

And I'll consider my decision there, and I'll be back in a moment with my version. Please rise as Judge John Hodgman exits the courtroom. Tom, do you think this is your place to teach your child these sporting lessons? Would that be better left to a coach or someone else involved in his team? Yeah. I mean, I think as his father, I have to teach him about the real world. I mean, his soccer coach can teach him about soccer, but these are things that kind of don't come up until later. You look back on and you realize they never told me that part.

So you're saying that his coach is bound by the rules of morality while you live a life without rules as a father. Right. Well, I live in a world where people don't follow the rules of morality while you live a life without rules as a father. Right. Well, I live in a world where people don't follow the rules because of my job. So you can say that in a great situation, nobody would break the rules and we can all follow the rules and everybody's going to play fair. But I'm faced with that every day I go to work that people are not being fair. So you're basically taking out your anger about people texting and driving on your child. Sure. Karen, how are you feeling about your chances in the case?

I hesitate to say this, but I kind of don't see how I could lose. I've been asking that question for five years. That is by far the boldest declaration I've ever heard in that entire time. Wow, that's amazing. Do you trust the judge to be as fair as you were with those two dogs? Oh yeah Tom, how do you feel about your chances? Do you feel certain to lose? I just don't know Well, we'll have to see what Judge John Hodgman has to say when we come back in just a second

Hello teachers and faculty Hodgman has to say when we come back in just a second. Hello, teachers and faculty. This is Janet Varney. I'm here to remind you that listening to my podcast, The JV Club with Janet Varney, is part of the curriculum for the school year. Learning about the teenage years of such guests as Alison Brie, Vicki Peterson, John Hodgman, and so many more is a valuable and enriching experience. One you have no choice but to embrace because yes, listening is mandatory. The JV Club with Janet Varney is available every Thursday on Maximum Fun or wherever you get your podcasts. Thank you.

And remember, no running in the halls. me give it a try okay if you need a laugh and you're on the go call s-t-o-p-p-b-a-d-i it'll never fit no it will let me try if you need a laugh and you're on the go try s-t-o-p-p-p-d-c-o-o ah we are so close stop podcasting yourself a podcast from maximumfun.org if you need a laugh and you're on the go. Please rise as Judge John Hodgman re-enters the courtroom. You may be seated. I have so many places to go, and I don't even know where to begin. First of all, I should stipulate if you've ever listened to this podcast for any period of time or know my work at all, sports is not my bag.

And as I've heard the bloodbath of your child's soccer team described, I have no regrets. No regrets. no regrets no regrets i mean with that kind of uh in competition intimidation and take no prisoners uh backbiting and you might you might you might as well have your child in a symphony orchestra that's how bad it is and when i learned about this and i learned about it this morning researching this case this practice within soccer of taking flops and dives and being purposefully misleading and how ingrained it is particularly in soccer playing parts of the world that are not the us of a i was like once again i was like yeah you know what i thought soccer was the nice one but no it's deceptive and it's mean just like every other sport

and so i did not know what i was going to come into when discussing this uh with a dad who literally was teaching his kid to break the rules dads have to be careful and and i tom i'm not i'm not saying this because i feel like you have been uncareful necessarily. That's what I'm trying to determine. But I'm saying it because I know I have been uncareful around these very issues. And my dad has been uncareful with me around the issues of rules. First of all, I order you both to purchase my book Vacation Land, which out in October in which some of these stories are alluded to but my my dad gave me when I was in my 20s my dad taught me to break the rules

now as you know I'm an only child I do not want to break the rules I want to know what all the rules are so I can follow them perfectly so that I can be approved of and loved by every human on earth I don't want to break any rules but this was in western Massachusetts my dad taught me So I can follow him perfectly so that I can be approved of and loved by every human on Earth. I don't want to break any rules. But this is in Western Massachusetts. My dad taught me that we had to take the garbage to the dump, which already was terrible. And that, too, if I was asked where I lived, I was to lie to the dumpman about where I lived because we weren't legally allowed to dump our garbage there because we were in a different town. And this gave me neurosis for 14 years.

I would avoid going to the dump. I was scared because I was afraid at any moment I might finally get called out. They never asked. But at any moment they could and I would get thrown in dump jail for lying to the dumpman. And then it took me a long time to realize that my dad had made that neurosis happen in my head for no reason. Because those dumpmen were never going to ask. They don't care. They work at the dump. But I feel for you because dads do this all the time and they do it with the best of intentions and years later when my own son was facing a situation it's not it was it was the closest to sports we ever got he was taking sailing lessons it was not my idea in fact he

wasn't even doing sailing he was doing rowing because too little to go sailing. And he was getting picked on by some of the kids in this in this rowing group because he had never been on the water before. And they all knew each other since they were three. And they immediately picked him to be the odd man out. And, you know, that's when that's happening. As a father, you feel intensely full of. as a father, you feel intensely full of powerless rage because what can you do? You know, how can you empower your child to stand up to bullies and also make the incredibly nuanced and difficult decisions, contextual decisions of when it's right to stand up and when it's right to ignore them and when it's right to tell someone and when it's better to just let it slide. You know, it's hard to say, you know. And I encouraged my son with a pep talk. And before I said this to him, I said, he was about eight or nine then. I said, you know,

do you mind if I say a swear word in front of you? I know you've heard them before, but I may have to emphasize something. And he said, it's fine. And I said, you know, if these kids say something to you, just point out that you're wearing this shirt that you got from the rock climbing place down in Brooklyn, New York, where you live, because you were able to reach the top and no one else could. And just say, you know, my name is, name redacted, Hodgman, and you don't know anything about me, and I live in Brooklyn, New York, and I climb walls really well, even if I don't rove really well, so you can't give me any feces.

And I used a different word. And I was doing so good, like his eyes were lighting up with confidence, and the moment I said feces, but I used a different word, his face completely fell, because even though he said, yeah, it's okay if you say a swear word in front of me, when your dad is actually saying a swear word in front of you and breaking that rule, suddenly there are no rules. Suddenly he's like, oh, right, the universe is full of chaos and darkness,

and my daddy just swore, and the kids are mean, and now they're probably going to kill me. These things get into little kids' heads in ways that are complicated. And just as my dad damaged me, so I have damaged my son. And the verdict of whether or not or how badly you have damaged little Eli Fauntleroy is still yet to be made. Even if I were to rule you haven't you

will both damage him in different ways it's unavoidable unavoidable now like your wife Tom I also root for the underdog

because I'm a human being, because I don't take delight in weaker people losing because someone else has used every advantage available to them, both in the light arts and the dark arts of war sports. and the dark arts of war sports. But to my surprise, in this situation, Tom, I feel the underdog is Tom. And it's not just because, Karen, you were so confident going into the verdict. You thought, I am totally going to win this. That did make you the overdog and made Tom a little bit of the underdog, especially when he was whispering, just let her, just order her to leave me alone.

But very much to my surprise, what I heard Tom, as you were explaining this, was that A, you've given a lot of thought to this uh b uh you know what you're talking about c it comes from a clear place of not merely trying to protect your your kid but to arm him with the options that are available to him in soccer and in life, that it was part of an ongoing personal coaching habit that you had as the conversation grew out of the other conversation where you're going over how he kept the ball from the other kid. This is considered. My worry was that you're going to be exactly the kind of creep sportsy dad that i thought could only be who's trying to relive his own soccer glory days by telling his kid about this this dark practice and in professional soccer or worse one of these

hipster dads who love football european football more than any other sport on and go to bars and drink and watch the world cup and and adopt teams from all over the world they've never set foot before and because they're really into football european and world football culture they're going to school their kid on this esoteric unspoken rule and you know just to feel smart about themselves none of this is that all of this seems as though it proceeds from an obvious place of love and consideration for your child and as i say a habit of seeing things as they are not as you wish them to be it is the case i am saying this to all of the dads and moms across america that soccer is a dirty sport where people lie as a matter of course outside of the united states and you go online and you watch clips super cuts of of these flops and these dives. And they are ridiculous.

They are totally bogus and fake and everyone knows it. It is deceptive on purpose. It is contemptible. And it is part of the sport that you love. And here is the only place where I feel that you have gone wrong, Tom. Well, there was that one time when i said are you just trying to protect your kid or give them an advantage over the other team why not both it's one isn't one is entwined with the other in this case because these these faked falls or these exaggerated falls to get the ref's attention do whether intended to or not uh attract that attention

and draw fouls and cautions to the other team that give your team an advantage so that's just the way it is but where you did fall is not at least as far as i can tell and i think i'm right not impressing upon your son that while this is part of soccer it's still cheating and if he were to be found out doing this in american soccer he would be punished for it and what's more people around the world are making youtube supercuts making fun of soccer players for doing contemptible, dumb looking goofball theatrics. It's gross. This is where you have failed as a father. And I think in this case, you are correct to have alerted to your son, this tool that is used by many, many soccer players at the highest level.

But what you really need is to have John Hodgman come to your home outside of Asheville and conduct an ethics and soccer PowerPoint presentation. I've got a hell of a deck on flopping right now. I would really love to show Eli, but I can't do that and it would be weird and creepy. So you need to sit down with your, what father doesn't love sitting down and watching some YouTube videos with his son? Show him what these guys are doing and make it clear that while this is a tool available, you can't even bring yourself to talk to his coach about this, because the coach would catch on and tell you not to do it. Yes, there are dark arts available, even in soccer. But you pay a price for using them. Look at Voldemort. He lost his nose.

With that caveat I find in favor of Tom, this is the sound of a gavel. Judge John Hodgman rules that is all. Please rise as Judge John Hodgman exits the courtroom. Karen. Yes. What is there left to believe in? I kind of feel, I still feel okay.

I kind of still feel like, oh, what? I feel like, oh, what? I mean, you know that in a very true and literal sense, you lost, right? Yes, yes. Are you just fake-newsing the judge? No, I feel good about it. Maybe that's how I should say it. Okay. Everyone wins.

Tom, how do you feel? I feel great. I can say it. Okay. Everyone wins. Tom, how do you feel? I feel great. I can't lie. I just love it when people, you know, I'm sure they're going to win by bullying and bringing their partners on podcast and then get, they take the L. They take the loss.

It feels pretty good. Did you consider flopping at all when you were being bullied by your wife? I have before, yes. Well, Tom, Karen, thank you so much for joining us on the Judge John Hodgman podcast. Another thrilling Judge John Hodgman case in the books. Before we dispense some swift justice, we want to thank Evan LaRocca and Joel Bergsbacon, Bergsbacon, for naming this week's episode Sport Reform. If you'd like to name

a future episode, make sure to like Judge John Hodgeman on Facebook. That's where we usually put the call for submissions. You can follow us on Twitter at Jesse Thorne and at Hodgeman. call for submissions. You can follow us on Twitter at Jesse Thorne and at Hodgman. Hashtag your judge John Hodgman tweets hashtag JJHO and check out the Max Fund subreddit at maximumfund.reddit.com to discuss this week's episode, which, by the way, was recorded by Robert George at Sound Temple Studios in Asheville, North Carolina, and by Joel Mann at WERU in East Orland, Maine. Our brilliant producer, Jennifer Marmer. Now, Swift Justice, where we answer your small disputes with a quick judgment. Rebecca W. wrote in about washing one's legs in the shower. She says, some people say they just get cleaned by the trickle-down effect,

but that seems wrong to me. What do you say, Judge? First of all, I'm glad we specified that that was Rebecca W., so she knows it was her letter that we picked about washing one's legs in the shower, not the ones from all the other Rebeccas. Second of all, the trickle-down effect in the shower, I could not get through. It took me about five reads of this one to understand that it was not about peeing in the shower I don't know why I couldn't get past that I'm like oh no just washing legs not peeing on them uh I will say this I rarely do any deep scrub work on my world beating calves

that everyone knows I have I have the best calves in the podcast industry, that's for sure. And they're all natural. I mean, I've got some big old Popeye hams down there. And they get plenty clean just with the regular old water washing on them. As soon as you said Popeye hams, this whole thing got creepy for me. The peeing in the shower part, being fixated on peeing in the shower was fine, but Popeye hams really upset me. Well, get ready for this then, Jesse. Because I will say that there is a part of my foot just below my ankle bone where if I do wash down there, I realize, yeah, there's a lot of,

there's a lot of dirt and dead skin accumulated there that is not getting washed away by any kind of trickle down. So yeah, I would say, you know, you, you gotta do a full body scrub, let's say every two weeks or so, but for the most part, just let it flow. If you've got a case for Judge John Hodgman, go to MaximumFun.org slash JJHO or just email Hodgman at MaximumFun.org. And we especially want your cases from New York City and London and environs. So if your case is located in one of those places, do let us know. We'll see you next time on the Judge John Hodgman Podcast. Maximumfun.org. Comedy and culture. Artist owned. Listener supported.