Mind Pump: Raw Fitness Truth - 1222: Low Carb vs. Low Fat... Which is Better?
Episode Date: February 6, 2020In this episode, Sal, Adam and Justin dig into the pros and cons of low carb and low fat diets. Making the case for low carb vs low-fat diets. (2:34) Why so much of these diets and ideas around eatin...g are all based around marketing and sales. (4:24) The history of the diet fads. (6:35) The distinction between low carb and low fat. (12:54) Which burns the most body fat? (16:48) The benefits of a low carb/higher fat diet. The positive effects on satiety levels. (17:35) Why Mind Pump is NOT a fan of the ketogenic/carnivore diets for long-term success. (23:27) Improves gut-health issues. (25:35) Better for cognition. (27:56) Prevention of diabetes. (31:23) How does Mind Pump utilize low carb vs low-fat diets with their clients? (32:14) The drawbacks of a low carb/higher fat diet. Decreases strength and performance. (33:50) Difficult to bulk. (38:58) Not as convenient. (40:54) It costs more money. (42:14) The benefits of a low fat/higher carb diet. Will lower your cholesterol levels. (43:26) Increases athletic performance. (46:04) Less expensive. (51:28) The drawbacks of a low fat/higher carb diet. Can lead to lower testosterone levels. (52:10) Brain fog and energy crashes. (53:13) Which is better? (54:37) Is this something you can see yourself doing for the rest of your life? The importance of learning from your body. (1:00:28) Related Links/Products Mentioned February Promotion: MAPS Split ½ off! **Code “SPLIT50” at checkout** Check out Mind Pump Live to get tickets for their next live event! Visit Vuori Clothing for an exclusive offer for Mind Pump listeners! Visit Magic Spoon for an exclusive offer for Mind Pump listeners! New federal guidelines may lift dietary cholesterol limits Mind Pump 1215: Dr. Becky Campbell On Thyroid Disease, Autoimmune Disease & Histamine Intolerance Keto-Like Diet May Improve Cognition in MCI, Early Alzheimer's Mind Pump Free Resources People Mentioned Dominic D'Agostino (@DominicDAgosti2) Twitter Mikhaila Peterson (@mikhailapeterson) Instagram Joe Rogan (@joerogan) Instagram Zach Bitter (@zachbitter) Instagram
Transcript
Discussion (0)
If you want to pump your body and expand especially, you've probably heard of both approaches.
The low fat diet was all the rage for decades,
and then it was all about low carb.
Now we have kind of this debate,
which one is better at burning body fat?
Which one is better for athletic performance?
Which one is better for health?
So we break it down.
We break down both diets, all things being equal. Which one is better for athletic. So we break it down. We break down both diets, all things being equal.
Which one is better for athletic performance, strength, which one's better for dieting,
which one's going to get you to lose more body fat? What do they look like? What are the foods
within each of these diets? You're going to love this conversation. Also, if you want to come see MindPump live. We have a few tickets left for the MindPump live event
on March 7th at 11 a.m.
This is in, I believe it's in Columbus, Ohio.
Here's what you got to do.
Go to MindPumpLive.com and sign up.
We have some general admission tickets left
and we have some VIP plus tickets left.
By the way, the VIP plus includes a private dinner
with Adam, Justin, myself, and Doug.
We're gonna hang out, answer any of your questions.
We're gonna give you free maps, super bundle
with a bunch of programs in there.
You're gonna get a swag bag, you're gonna get a Viori outfit,
you're gonna get some magic spoon.
This event is sponsored by Viori,
which is the makers of amazing Athlete Aware
and magic spoon, the makers of amazing at the ledgerware, and Magic Spoon,
the makers of the serial that's in very high protein,
great macro profile.
Also, before the episode starts,
maps, split, our advanced body part training program
is 50% off.
If you wanna build muscle, sculpt your body,
shape your body, if you're somebody with some moderate
experience in the gym
and you wanna take it to the next level,
this is a phenomenal program to follow.
It's a body building inspired workout routine,
great for developing the arms, the shoulders, the back,
the butt, and the legs, and of course,
the rest of the body.
Here's how you get the 50% off discount for that.
Go to mapsplit.com, that's MAPS,
S-P-L-I-TIT.com and use the code split50. That's
SPLIT50, no space for the discount. Watching Paul's debate with the lawyer or the ex-judge on the
doctors, I think strikes up a great conversation, Sal, that you wanted to have.
And that was talking about, you know,
whether or not you should do low carb or low fat
since people make an argument
in a case for both of those.
I think we should kind of dive into the pros and cons
of both of them and give our, create our own war.
Absolutely.
And someone listening might be thinking,
well, why low carb and low fat?
Why aren't we talking about protein here? And you can. You can definitely have that discussion
around protein. But the two reasons why I think it's low carb and low fat are one,
the traditional ways of dieting through restricting a macronutrient has either been low fat or low carb up until now. The really hasn't been a push
For a low protein type diet, although I'm waiting for it because I think that's the next available macronutrient
That someone's gonna, you know, say that you need to have reduced
But here's a second reason the second reason is because a high protein diet
benefits
People regardless of their goals that The studies seem to show that whether or not you want to burn body fat, build muscle, increase
athletic performance, improve cognitive function, whatever a relatively high protein diet
seems to benefit everyone.
Where you start to see the differences really lies in the manipulation of carbs and fats.
That's where you start to see some studies show low fats.
Does this better?
Some studies show low carb does this better
and in terms of personal preference.
But of course, at the end of the day,
there's always an individual variance where,
neither one of these may work for you may want to have
a moderate intake of either one.
But I mean, early on when I first became a trainer
back and was at 1997, when I first became a personal trainer.
Low fat.
Yeah, and before, right?
It was all about low fat.
Fat was actually, strongly, that was a bad guy.
It was demonized.
Everything was, everything was fat was bad.
Fat was bad across the board.
It was blamed for every chronic illness.
It was blamed for obesity, diabetes.
It was blamed for...
Ardrin was cancer.
Yeah, it was a best off.
I mean, don't you remember, at least I remember, as a kid, when you first, the first time
you heard proteins fat in carbs, my assumption was that fat made you fat.
Yes.
It just, it makes sense, right?
I mean, fat.
If you don't, if you don't have any understanding,
no nutrition background at this time in my life,
but I don't remember how young I was,
but I was young enough to be smart enough to understand,
to look at labels or macronutrients
and to understand like, okay, what a protein car fat
is to a point, to a certain point,
but not enough to really understand
that fat doesn't make me fat.
You just seem like that made logical sense.
And what I always try and remind myself when I'm coaching clients or working with people is,
you know, if you had cared nothing about nutrition and you have a profession and something
completely different that you love, you're passionate about, you spend all your time,
you know, we forget sometimes the level of knowledge of the average consumer
that's getting this information or reading this.
And then you have the fitness side who is overly educated in this space and then knows how
to use things like this to market and manipulate a message so they can sell whatever.
And that I didn't learn until way later in life and really getting into the fitness base that I understand,
like, oh man, so much of these diets and ideas of eating are really all based around marketing and sales.
There's very little of it that's great research done to save the world.
It's more, oh wow, we can make a case and point why this has been official.
We could take a study, we could take some science, and now let's run with it and create
a thing.
And that thing is normally a new space or a new market to make money.
Right.
Now the big low fat push in the US really kicked off late 60s, 70s, and didn't start
to really take off until about the 80s.
And this was because of a report that was produced
because we were noticing climbing rates and trends
of heart disease in modern societies.
And so governments, US government being one of them
said, hey, we need to fund some research
to figure out why this is happening.
And they did, they did some research, terrible research.
If you look at the actual research being done,
they excluded other countries that didn't fit this model.
But the research came out and said,
oh, it's fat and in particular,
saturated fat, that's bad for you.
And so we were told to completely reduce our intake of fat.
And then like you say, Adam, dietary fat, body fat,
they're named the same thing.
It sounds kind of easy, right?
Fat also is very calorically dense. dietary fat, body fat, their name, the same thing. It sounds kind of easy, right?
Fat also is very calorically dense.
One gram of fat has more calories than one gram of protein or one gram of carbs.
So it all kind of made sense.
What's funny though is before that, the traditional ways of dieting, if you go beyond that,
before that, because people have been dieting or eating in ways
to lose weight or to become more trim
for quite a long time.
The original ways of doing it was to cut out
starches and sugars.
That's what they used to recommend.
If you look at old, like really old advertisements
for diets, it was like, don't eat sugar,
don't eat bread, don't eat starches and lose weight.
The irony in that is that's older wisdom and probably better for the majority.
It might be right, we'll get into that.
Let's talk about that.
And then later on what happened is you had decades of us getting hammered with low fat.
People were not getting skinnier.
The obesity rate was still climbing.
Heart disease diabetes still going through the roof.
It had showed no signs of slowing down.
Even though we were eating less fat,
even though there were more low fat products than ever
on the market, people were still getting fatter.
And it was the perfect, perfect storm for somebody
to come out and say, hold on a second,
you know all that fat that they said that was bad for you?
Eat as much of it as you want,
it's the carbs that are bad,
and that's when Atkins exploded, totally took off.
I mean, do you guys remember when Atkins hit the scene?
Well, originally it was in the 70s.
First time, yes.
But do you guys remember when it hit like late 90s?
The resurgence of it, yes.
Big time.
And he came out and said,
oh no, all that advice you were
getting you heard was wrong. This is actually the cause of us being overweight. And he had
his own science to support whatever. But it was perfect storm because we had already been
indoctrinated for decades. It's not working. Now someone comes and hears us what we want
to hear. Oh, what do you mean? I can't believe I can't believe that.
We're indoctrinated with, you know, our cholesterol numbers being like the most important metric that, you know, we need to lower this. And
like every time you go to a doctor visit, they're looking at, you know, the cholesterol intake
and those numbers, you need to get rid of this fat and your diet. It's, it's evil. Well,
it wasn't until, I mean, my pump was already going. It was, I want to believe, I want
to say it was year one or year two
when we shared this on the podcast,
when the American Heart Association had to recant
what they had been saying about dietary cholesterol,
affecting cholesterol for so many years.
That wasn't enough until just recently.
Did they, they,
the place plays a much bigger factor.
So for a very long time,
we've always connected,
oh, high fat, high cholesterol, high cholesterol
on your body and dangerous for your heart.
And it wasn't until just four years ago, did the American Heart Association have to take
that out?
And what they said.
Oh, egg sales declined dramatically for a while because eggs are very high in cholesterol
plus the Yo-Kas fatness.
Everybody was eating egg whites.
Red meat sales declined.
Everybody started consuming other white meats.
In fact, one of the, it was a huge advertising strategy.
Do you remember that for pork?
The other white meat.
The other white meat.
Chicken sales.
Chicken sales went through the roof.
But none of it was working.
People were still getting fatter and sicker,
and none of it was working at all.
Even though the, and now people had success, some people had success going low carb, just
like there were some people that had success going low fat. Here's the one thing that they
both had in common. They were low calorie. All those diets.
Well, that's what's in common with all diets. All diets. And you die always the underlying thing. Yeah, if you read between the lines on the zone diet, the adkins diet, all that, when
you calculate, calculate out what the total calories ends up being for the foods that they're
telling you to eat, they all are low.
Totally.
They're all based off of low calories.
Absolutely.
I'd say you guarantee they're going to have success.
Yeah.
It's right.
You know, follow this diet.
And then we know if you really keep your calories around 1500, you're going to lose weight. That's right. In the context of low
calories makes a big difference in terms of how your body reacts to the foods that you eat as well.
So, for example, a high sugar high calorie diet, terrible for a higher sugar low calorie diet,
not nearly as bad for you as for your health, not nearly as bad.
A high saturated fat, high calorie diet can have some detrimental effects. A high saturated
fat lower calorie diet doesn't seem to have nearly the negative effects and in fact,
may actually in some cases show protective effects. So calories make a big difference for
your health, but they also of course come in when it comes to body fat, make a big difference for your health, but they also of course come when it comes to body fat,
makes a big difference.
You can't gain body fat if your calories are lower
than you're burning.
In fact, they'll lose weight every single time.
So all diets have this in common.
Low calories being the most important number one thing
and then everything else kind of follows.
So in my experience as a trainer,
and there are benefits and
detriment to low carb and low fat based on your performance goals and all that stuff.
But at the end of the day, it always boiled down to whichever one the person, the client,
preferred to follow. If they're both low calorie, if you eat a 2,000 calorie lower carb diet
or 2,000 calorie lower fat diet and you're burning,
you know, 3000 calories a day.
They're both going to equate to about the same amount of body fat loss.
Yeah, the real game is which one is sustainable for your lifestyle.
Well, it also, there's other things that matter too.
Like, have you guys ever noticed those?
Sometimes when you get somebody who has been running a low fat, like how many times you've
got this client, who's been running a low fat diet for a long time, maybe they're in decent aesthetic shape too, but hormonally
they're off, or they have hair or skin issues, they have things like that, that foods that
tend to come in higher fat sources are providing certain nutrients for said body, and that
person has been low for so long that they're seeing deficiencies elsewhere, although they're
body fat percentage.
Total. That would be a concern of mine.
It being an essential macronutrient.
That's one of those.
The carbohydrates side, you got to build up more of a case, the relevance of intake and
carbohydrates versus proteins and fat, those are essential.
How do we work that in?
That's why I wanted to bring this up, because fat tends to be one of the number one things
that I actually include and tell people to bump up because I even though the this what we're talking about is kind of old news
It's not old news for a lot of people if you're an 80s baby and you grew up around that time hearing all those messages
And now you're an adult and you're in your busy and you got things going you still remember all that that messaging
And so then you go to dieting and one of the first things you do is, oh, cut out all
the high fit. Oh, I switch over from having things like tritip and rib eyes. Now I'm having
leaner cuts, or I'm doing all white meat, like you said. And right away, they get rid of
the oils, get rid of butter. That's kind of like the old way of cutting calories in your
diet is just to cut all those high fat things. And then I'll send I have got a, you know,
a client who I'm working with who's 135 pounds,
and she's eating 30 grams of fat every single day,
which is really low.
And for months and years of eating that low,
you start to see things with hair, skin, hormonal issues
because of this.
That's right, you bring up a good point
because you can define low carb and low fat
can be defined totally different.
Low carb can be as low as zero. You can have no carbs, zero. Every single day and you can be
totally fine. Carbohydrates are not essential for any bodily function, hormone production.
They're not essential. You don't need to consume carbohydrates. Now it doesn't mean it's
not preferable to consume them. For some people I think they are,
it is preferable to consume carbs.
It just means you don't need to consume them.
Now fat, essential.
If you eat zero fat, zero grams every single day,
you will get sick, you will get problems,
and eventually you can die
because you have to consume them.
So that's an important distinction between the two.
And this is why, this is why this is why this one is my least favorite strategy
to lose weight.
I absolutely hate low, because I think the messaging
hasn't got around the other way,
and people don't realize how detrimental it can be,
and how good you feel when you eat higher fat foods.
I mean, you talk about some of the benefits,
like, you know, one of the things that I like showing clients is that, man, when you eat a avocado or a little olive oil or enjoy butter and some of the benefits, like, you know, one of the things that I like showing clients
is that, man, when you eat a avocado or a little olive oil
or enjoy butter, some of those things,
watch how satiating it is and how great it tastes.
Right, right.
So there's a lot of benefits to having a higher fat.
So fat is actually one of the things I almost always
when assessing a diet, I end up having
to increase in most people.
There's very, unless you have somebody who I'm coaching,
of course it matters, everyone's different.
And they have just, they eat McDonald's three times a day
and they're eating a lot of processed garbage.
Just reducing it.
Right. Right.
And those people tend to take in a higher concentration
of saturated fat in the diet.
And I'm looking for healthy dietary fats,
like your avocados, your butters,
your olive oils, things like that.
For the most part, those people tend to under consume on that and I've got to address
that.
It's one of the first even people that are overweight and trying to lose weight more
often than not.
It's not due to an overly ridiculous amount of fat unless they were like a major fast
foodie.
Yeah, let's get into the benefits and the detriment of each one so people can kind of figure
it out for themselves.
But before we do, if you want to know which one
will make you burn the most body fat,
besides the individual factor, which one you're going to stick to,
which one works better for you, type of deal.
If the studies are clear, neither one burns more body fat.
Now, low carb loses more weight than low fat,
but not more body fat. And the weight loss that you get from low carb loses more weight than low fat, but not more body fat.
And the weight loss that you get from low carb
has to do with the fluid,
you're holding less water in your body.
Carbohydrates, you know, turn into glycogen,
which stores more water in your body.
So going low carb on the scale,
you may actually notice more pounds coming down,
but when they go in and they, you know,
check body fat percentage, body fat percentage is equal.
So it's really at the end of the day down to calories.
Both of them can be equally effective at burning body fat
so long as everything else is controlled.
All right, so some of the benefits,
Adam, he touched on the first one.
I agree, some of the benefits of low carb dieting,
it is more satiating.
In my opinion, low fat.
Low fat.
I mean, low fat. No, low carb. Low carb is more satiating. Oh, you, low carb. Low fat. Low fat.
No, low carb.
Low carb is more satiating.
You're going to start with low carb
and all the positives.
Yeah, I think you're going to stick with all fat
and then talk about that.
Low carb is higher fat, right?
So a low carb diet, okay.
So when we say low carb low fat,
that means that the opposite one is high.
So low carb means carbohydrates below, fat is higher.
Low fat means fat is low, carbs are higher.
So a low carb diet is a higher fat diet by default. And it is more satiating for more people
in my experience. I've trained lots and lots of people. And one of the number one things that you
need to tackle with nutrition is overeating and is somebody wanting to eat more food.
And my experience, if you're constantly starving
and craving food, it's really a hard thing to control over time.
And a high fat low carb diet seems to control that much better
and more people.
In fact, I have clients come to me on low carb higher fat diets
and they tell me they can't eat as much as I'm telling them,
even though it's still in a caloric deficit.
I noticed it for myself.
I, you know, when I eat low carb higher fat,
I just don't, I'm not as hungry.
And I think that's a huge plus.
You satisfied.
Yeah, I think, again, it's like an empty pit,
the other way around, like for me.
Like if I'm higher on carbohydrates,
like I just have this need to then,
like I get more snacky, I feel like more cravings are involved with that versus like when I'm loading up my fat a bit more
I it the cravings tend to sort of you know go away and that's definitely a benefit for me my clients 100% one of my favorite strategies
When helping somebody else. So again, I tracked see what's going on with their week super common thing for most people
Saturday and Sunday you work hard during the week, right? You're consistent with your job. You bring your meals to work.
You do all in your busy. You get your workouts in Saturday and Sunday. You let your hair down a little
bit. Sleep in maybe a little bit. Watch cartoons in the morning. Sunday maybe you're sitting around
at church or having Sunday, Sunday. So I and this is when normally a lot of the bad behavior,
so one of my favorite strategies to,
when I'm manipulating somebody's diet,
is actually to have them eat a higher fat, low carb diet,
and have them focus on that on the weekends,
because I know they're gonna be more sedentary,
more of them not, they won't need as much carbs and fuel.
And because I know they're being sedentary too,
I'm concerned about them doing snack-y type foods, chips and things like that.
And then just consuming like crazy.
And I don't tell them what I'm doing.
I just say, hey, for this weekend,
bump your fats up to this, reduce your carbs to that.
So they have it like just a little weekend goal for them.
So they're not like Adam saying, I can or can't have something.
It's just, oh, this is our weekend goal
to increase up my fats this way.
Then after the fact, I coached to it. And then I explain, like, this is why weekend goal to increase up my fats this way. Then after the fact, I coached to it.
And then I explained, like, this is why I did this to you.
How did you feel?
That's why we used that strategy.
Notice how much easier it was for you to not binge on things
or not snack like you normally would do,
because I gave you those targets.
That's how I like to use low carb, low fat type of diets
is teaching like that.
So same here.
When I hit palate fatigue much faster
with a high fat meal than I do with a high carb meal.
High carb meals for me personally, I can keep going.
I can even have to I feel full, bloated, whatever.
With a high fat meal, it's like I get sick of the food.
I can't really do any more.
And then I'm not hungry for a longer period of time. This is the experience with my clients as well.
Where again, I would put people on a restricted calorie recommendation because they're trying
to get leaner. And when I would have them eat lower carb, higher fat, sometimes people
come up to me and say, hey, I can't eat this much. And it's still a deficit, it's still in a deficit.
When I would do a lower fat higher carb diet,
I wouldn't hear that nearly as much.
The appetite tends to be a little higher.
You don't hit palate fatigue as much.
Now, the studies do show that protein
is the, the produces the most satiety.
Fat is up there with protein.
It's not quite, it isn't produced satiety quite as much, but it's still up there with protein. It's not quite, it isn't pretty,
satiety quite as much, but it's still up there.
And this is why I love fatty meats as a recommendation.
You know, enjoy a nice try tip everyone's well.
Have a rib eye, have something that's juicy and fatty
and high in protein, high in fat,
and you feel amazing afterwards for hours later
and you don't feel like you need to end it to your point.
I could have a pizza,
in fact, I had pizza with my nephew after his game.
And I had four slices of that,
and it's like 30 minutes later, I'm like ready to eat more.
And the size of those four slices of pizza,
I mean, when I first was eating it,
it would feel the same as if I was eating like a rib-eye steak
I know what I'd feel like though after a big rib-eye steak. I'm good for the next four hours fun
And I found that with clients. It's the same thing and so it's a it's a great strategy
Here's a thing that I always take into consideration whenever talking about diets. It's like all diets are made up
It's there's such an individual variance with so many people so So I'm always looking at the psychology behind all of it too.
Like how behaviors?
What, what do I know about certain,
when people eat a certain way,
what are the most common behaviors?
And when you've had enough people
that you've tried all of a sudden,
because I've tried every diet you could think of
with clients and paid attention to how they respond,
their results, how long they maintain it,
are they happy while they do it?
Pay attention to that stuff for many, many years,
and then you start to realize that,
you know, the psychological part is as important,
if not way more important than the science that supports,
oh, why I should go low carb or oh, why I should go low fat,
it's okay, how is this client that I'm dealing with right now going to respond with it?
Now here's the little disclaimer with the satiety effects of low carb higher fat diet.
It's easily overridden as soon as you eat carbs.
So what I mean by that is when I have someone eating low carb high fat, so long as they stay
low carb high fat, their appetites tend to be, by the way, it's not
true across the board.
I've had clients where this doesn't satisfy their appetite or whatever.
But generally speaking, so long as they stay on that protocol, it's not an issue.
As soon as they go off and start snacking, oh boy, the reverse is a novelty.
And not only that, but it actually, it's, it gets real bad.
I've seen good people go so opposite because they had a weekend
where they started snacking on chips.
And that pallidability kicks in.
And now they're not just high fat, low carb,
but high fat, high carb.
That is such a good point.
This is why I'm not a fan of the ketogenic diet
and the carnivore diet for most people.
Because I know that most people are not gonna stick with it
for the rest of
their life.
And what you don't realize happens if you were somebody who was a popcorn eater, a chip
eater, love ice cream all the time, snack on sweets, you eat carbs, carbs, carbs all the
time and you're used to that and you want to make a change in your life.
And so you hear that the ketogenic diet or now the carnivore diet, which is what popular,
people are having all this success and all the science to support how great is you want
to try it. Oh, is, you wanna try it?
Oh, okay, you may try it and see.
But they're getting tip-toeing with it.
Incredible results for a set amount of time
that you follow it, but the rebound effect
when you fall off is way worse,
had you not dieted with a more balanced diet
because you get the body adapted,
you become fat adaptive, right?
So now the body starts to use ketones
instead of using glucose, right?
It's not getting any more carbohydrate source,
so then it adapts, gets efficient to then do that.
Then all of a sudden you fall off your diet three months later
and you go bananas or the weekend,
and then you going bananas over the weekend
ends up harming you more than it had it would have harmed you
had you dieted more with a more balanced diet.
Yeah, so I mean, it's definitely more, produces more satiety, so long as you more than it had it would have harmed you had you dieted more with a more balanced diet.
Yeah, so I mean, it's definitely more produces more satiety so long as you stay on
it.
You start to go off and then it's like a it's like a floodgate and your appetite goes through
the roof.
The second benefit of a lower carb higher fat diet is it tends to be better for people
with gut health issues.
And this I think has more to do with the fact that there are more food intolerances in plants and grains
than you tend to find in animals and in fats.
So, for example, when I would work with clients
with gut issues, aside from dairy,
it was typically things like gluten and peanuts
and starches that would cause the bloating and the distension and
the digestive issues.
Cutting carbs oftentimes you find that they feel much better in terms of their gut issues.
And then we had Dr. Becky Campbell on, she said, yeah, that could be a sign of SIBA, which
is quite common in people with gut issues, is that they eat carbs and it messes up their
gut.
Definitely.
So in my experience, when I work with people with gut issues,
low carb, more often than not,
is a better diet for them in terms of their gut.
I think part of that too is the psychological part
that it plays too.
You mentioned earlier about the carbs,
so your body pairs water with carbohydrates
for every three grams of carbohydrates.
You intake your body,
holds on to three ounces of water.
So if you're somebody who already has inflammation, already has an intolerance to a certain
food, say it maybe it has, it is some sort of gluten or carbohydrate, you intake it not
only do you feel the inflammation effects or maybe it upset your stomach, the dentition
to that.
You're also holding on to an extra, you know, half a gallon of water on your body.
So you feel extra below
and water retention.
So I think there's that part of that role that why people feel so much better isn't just
for what it may potentially be doing intolerance-wise for them, but even just what it does psychologically,
because there's something to be said about, if you do hold on to a lot of water like that,
how people think it's their fatter.
That's one of the things I constantly have to speak to
when people see fluctuations in their weight up and down,
they always think it's a direct reflect
if they're diet being on or off, it's not necessarily.
And your gut bacteria that breaks down carbohydrates
does produce more gases.
So you'll notice, even if you're healthy,
no food and tolerances, eating a low carb diet, just your stomach just feels,
doesn't feel as full, doesn't feel as, it's, it isn't bloat
out nearly as much. And that has more to do with the bacteria,
even if you're perfectly healthy. Here's another benefit with a low
carb high fat diet. Studies show it may be better for cognition,
especially for people with impaired cognition. So especially for
people as they age, as their brain isn't operating like it used to, especially
when you go really low carb and high fat, like more of a ketogenic type diet where the ketones
are high, studies show beneficial cognitive effects on people with dementia, Alzheimer's,
and other cognitive type of declining disorders.
And some people who don't even have those issues, I've had quite a few clients tell me,
I can think sharper since I've eliminated or reduced carbohydrates out of my diet.
I tend to be one of those people, not always, but if I start to get a little foggy, cutting
carbs and bumping fats, I start to feel a little bit sharper.
And again, the studies support this a little bit.
So, this is a relatively new research that came out about Alzheimer's, right? In terms
of like like using ketones then to help to prevent, uh, it was dumb, right? Well, there's
new research, but it's also been old observations. So they've observed, it's one of the first
medical interventions for, uh for disease was fasting.
So thousands of years ago, these practitioners noticed,
here comes a person who's having all these ailments
if I fast them and take away food, then it goes away.
The problem with that is eventually you have to eat again.
So later on, they discovered the ketogenic diet
and because they figured out that it was the lack of glucose
That was causing, you know, some of these problems go away namely epilepsy. That's a big one
It's it was a first treatment for epilepsy, but they also find cognitive
All you know disorders. Well, I remember when we when we all went ketogenic for that
You know, however many months we were all running the diet like years ago when it first was getting popular
for sure you know, however many months we were all running the diet like years ago when it first was getting popular. For sure, I think feeling satiated was number one, like big thing that I noticed as far
as benefits that I got that was most beneficial for me.
And then second was the cognitive function.
I could just, we felt, I felt more clear and sharper on the podcast.
Now that being said, I also noticed that exact same effect when I'm fasted.
Yeah. So it's less that I, the low carb so much is just me not taking it.
Skitting the ketosis. It's really, it was the ketones. And they show this that the mitochondria,
the powerhouses of the cells operate better off of ketones, a cleaner burning energy. And a lot of cognitive decline, some scientists say is a result of the brain becoming, just
not being able to utilize glucose well or work with insulin well.
Some scientists would call things like Alzheimer's type three diabetes.
So maybe some of the cognitive decline we're noticing is because our bodies aren't utilizing
glucose very well.
So eliminate the glucose or lower it, bump up the ketones, now we feel sharper.
I personally feel sharper eating a low carb higher fat diet.
If I know we're going to do like a big event or I'm going to do a speaking engagement or
a podcast, I eat that way because I feel sharper.
I feel like I'm faster with my thinking. I don't have to search for words as often. That's my own personal
experience. I've heard lots of people say that. And again, the evidence shows that at
least for people with cognitive decline, a lower carb higher fat diet seems to be a little
better for most of them. The second one would be diabetes. Low carb diets might be better
for the prevention of diabetes. I think that's kind of obvious. Your bodies, your insulin level
spike after each sugar and carbohydrates, and they don't spike as much when you eat fats and
proteins. And so it seems like it makes perfect sense, right? A low carb diet maintains insulin sensitivity,
increases insulin sensitivity.
So for people with who have maybe diabetes in their family,
you might be better off reducing your carbohydrates,
bumping your fat up, needing that way.
Although there are, I've seen a couple of the studies
that show that a low calorie, low fat diet
works well for diabetes as well.
But again, like we said at the beginning of the episode,
the low calorie context, right?
Makes a big difference.
Makes a huge difference.
Oh, that's everything.
Now, how do each of you guys personally,
because I find that I use low carb, low fat,
I do carb cycling.
I mean, I use all different, I use fasting occasionally. So I think
it would be valuable to hear how each of you utilize the tool. You understand, you understand
the science, you understand the psychological benefits and drawbacks of low carb low fat.
Now how do you individually use it or how do you use it with clients?
Well, it depends on the person, it depends on who I'm working with and we're gonna get into some of the bed
Determincent benefits of both
But I mean if I have an athlete, they're not gonna go low carb if I have somebody who's really interested in putting on size
I'm not gonna go low carb
For me personally because my my job requires you know, I need to be sharp, I need
to be good on the mics or whatever, I tend to lean more towards a lower carb, tend to
not have the higher carb. And my diet really depends a lot on those types of things.
Yeah, digestive issues, things like that. I'm considering all of that, especially in my
own diet and performance, just speaking and not being as active
as I used to be as well.
So that's something that I'm definitely playing with the amount of carbs I'm introducing
in my diet a lot.
And then also fasting occasionally to just just regain that sort of clarity and also allow
for my metabolism and everything to kind of get a break.
So I can kind of help my digestive process on its own.
Right, right, right.
Now, okay, so let's get right into some of the drawbacks of low carb.
I mentioned one of them.
It's not great for strength or most athletic performance.
This is unequivocally true.
Okay, so I know people like to debate, oh no, there's study.
No, there's tons of studies have been done on this,
and if you want maximum athletic performance
for most sports, not all sports,
most sports where you need to be explosive,
have power and strength,
you'll do better eating carbohydrates.
I gotta say something about that too,
because I know with the carnivore diet,
and with a lot of these other diets,
like maybe the ketogenic diet,
there's been some athletes that have claimed their energy just spiked through the roof, and now they're getting of these other diets, like maybe the ketogenic diet, there has been some
athletes that have claimed their energy just spiked through the roof.
And now they're getting all these PRs.
Like, I suspect that they might have had an underlying issue, you know, gut-wise, that
you know, they're fighting internally, which then now this, this made them healthier as
a result, which then, you know, bled into their performance.
Well, that annoys me just as much as the vegan documentary
of the strong man promoting a vegan diet
because they broke records now that they've done that.
And it's the same exact thing.
So I think that's, and I think we're very fair
the way we are that way.
Like both of them are being zealots.
Like you're not somebody because you are low carb,
the studies are very conclusive
that it's not ideal for performance.
This is a reason why
The paleo diet has felt falling in a favor for the crossfitters, right?
That was the original diet everybody was eating when when CrossFit first started to just started to happen and then enough people
Understood the studies and the research. Oh, they just felt better. Well, I'll fight some sweet potato and some rice right?
I'm gonna hit new PR. I have accessible energy.
Yeah, it's, wow.
But look, at the end of the day, the diet that makes you healthy
is gonna be better than a diet that makes you unhealthy.
Even if the unhealthy diet is the one that all the studies
support, and sometimes you're right, you run into that.
Like you look at, like,
Michaela Peterson is a good example of this.
Joe Rogan now went carnivores, said he felt better,
said his autoimmune issues, started
to decline.
Well that's probably because he needed to be a little healthier and that diet provided
that for him.
But across the board, generally speaking, if you're fine with either, carbs are going to give
you better performance than fats.
Hands down.
Now there is an exception in this.
Yeah, low level, long duration type of endurance.
Zach Bitter.
Yeah, he's a great example, right?
Bad adapted athlete.
I experienced this myself.
I remember, was it maybe four years ago,
Jessica and I went on a trip.
And the goal was to drive from, you know,
San Jose all the way up to Corde de Laine.
So we had to go through Oregon and Washington
and on the way we would stop at different places
and go camping, whatever.
Anyway, the one of the first stops was the Lake Tahoe.
And at this time, I was really, really deep keto,
ketogenic diet.
It was working for my gut issues.
I felt healthiest on it.
I had almost no carbohydrates in my diet.
We get to Lake Tahoe.
We had to get there early and we had to kayak to our camping spot.
And I was fasted.
So my ketone levels were very, very high.
I had no glycogen or minimal glycogen in my body,
no carbohydrates.
We get in the kayaks and we start kayaking.
And it's at a low to moderate intensity.
I'm not sprinting, but I'm definitely going.
And we got lost.
We ended up kayaking for something like seven hours trying to find the spot. And I felt perfectly fine. Now, had you had
me try to max out my strength and match out my explosiveness, I would not have done
very well, but I was just going, going, going. I noticed this great low level type of stamina.
Key tones, the energies you get from fats that you burn when you're not using carbohydrates
are great for that.
So if you're an athlete that's like,
you wanna do like a long distance slow run or swim.
Ketogenic diet may actually be perfectly fine.
Now that being said, I believe,
and I know Zach Bitter does this,
but I believe most of these athletes
that tout being ketogenic or carnivore and their endurance,
they actually utilize carbohydrate.
During the event they'll supplement.
Exactly.
And what's so brilliant about that is they've become so fat
adaptive because that's the only way they eat
their entire training process.
But then when it comes to race day,
where they've got to go for five, six, 10 hours of ad nitrous.
Exactly.
Then they shoot some of that, you know, 30 grams.
Not much, like 20, 30 grams of carbs in their mouth is like rocket fuel for them because
they've become so adaptive fat.
Now they get this flood of glucose.
So most even the people that seen the benefits for endurance running or endurance sports from being fat adapted
or running a high fat no carb type of diet
still utilize carbohydrates.
And that's a brilliant way to do it.
It is, it's a very smart way.
But at the end of the day again,
you may, the impacts you'll have on athletic performance
have more to do with the explosive athletic type performance
and strength.
That's really, I'm way stronger
when I carbohydrates in my max lifts.
I don't notice it as much when I go hiking.
Like I don't notice a big difference
when I do that kind of stuff.
Sprinting, I'll notice a big difference.
Here's a deal, low carb diets, also not good for bulking
or trying to put on a lot of size and muscles.
Hard, really hard to bulk on a low carb high fat diet.
I have not, I think out of all the clients
that I've ever helped bulk,
I've had maybe one or two that did well
on a low carb bulking protocol.
I, being somebody who typically does better low carb,
I still can't bulk well on a low carb diet.
It's just too satiating. I get
too. I can't eat enough. And when I work out, I don't get the same pumps. I don't get the same volume.
That part kind of sucks on the low carb. That's a really good point too about low carb. That's a
drawback. And especially for somebody who's no understand, if you're in the competitive world and
you compete and you manipulate carbs, you've felt this before
when you go low carb, how awful your workouts
and even the psychological part,
it doesn't feel just awful because of how physical,
the physiology, you're tired and weak you are,
it's also the mental fuck
because if you're somebody who is used to seeing
your muscle bellies all filled up with fluid,
you get that what they call flat look because you have no carbs, you have no glucose in your muscles,
and your body's not holding on to all this extra water in your muscles that it normally would.
It's harder to get the feedback. If I'm training a client and I'm trying to get them to connect and
feel their glutes in an exercise, for example. The pump is an amazing feedback.
All of a sudden they're like,
oh my God, I feel my glutes are getting a pump
or wow, I feel that in my lats.
When you're low carb, that's hard.
It's like we're connecting, we're pushing whatever,
but you're not getting the feedback of the pump
and the pump helps you connect, it really does.
If I have a pump in a muscle,
I can squeeze and contract and connect the hell out of it.
If I don't have a pump, I have to think a little harder
and really search for that connection a little bit more.
So the bad pumps is another drawback of the low carb diet.
The big, here's one of the biggest drawbacks,
it's for me personally, not as convenient,
just really isn't.
You go try and find snacks and shit,
you can buy that you can eat really easily
on a low carb diet.
There's, what do you got?
Jerky and nuts. I can't think of too much cheese. Those a low carb diet. There's, what do you got? Jirky and nuts.
I can't think of too much cheese and jerky nuts.
Yeah, there's some eggs.
Yeah, there's not much in terms of convenience.
So if you're like on a road trip or whatever,
you're with your friends hanging out, watching the game,
and your low carb, it's like,
I'll have the macadamia nuts, you know, what else?
Well, that's the part that I found going through
the keto drink that I hated the most was just the inconvenience
in the blah of the same thing.
I mean, you cut out a macronutrient like that.
It's especially a dominant one in our space
where in the food in general,
it's really tough to have variety in the diet.
You end up eating like the same,
I felt myself eating like the same five or six foods,
all the time.
Yes, yes, totally.
No, it's not nearly as fun.
And you know, when you want to, you want convenience,
a lot of the variety is in the carbohydrate,
maybe plant-based type foods, the low carb,
it's really tough.
Even in the low carb process foods are typically not that great
and they're not really that low carb. Often they'll say low carb but they're not really
low carb enough to taste like cardboard.
Yeah, it's just, now here's another one. If we were to map out a 3000 calorie or 2000 calorie
diet and compare the cost of going low carb higher fat versus the cost of going low-carb higher fat versus the cost of going low fat higher carb a low carb diet is more expensive it just is it costs more money you're eating more meats you're eating more
You know, maybe some cheese is more nuts macadamia nuts are great low-carb food super expensive. Yeah, it's like $9 for fat and proteins expensive very expensive very cheap
It is carbs can be very inexpensive.
So if you're like a college student and you're trying to eat on a budget, low carb, you
know, higher fat, it could definitely be much more than expensive.
I mean, they've gotten better these days, but yeah, that's still the case.
I mean, protein is always going to be, you know, a little bit more expensive.
Well, you could go buy on the wise.
10 pound bag of ricer oatmeal and have enough carbs.
Totally. Have enough carbs. Totally.
Having enough carbs for your entire month.
We're all giving it away for free.
Yeah, yeah.
Carbs are really amazing.
Yeah, show me, show me, you know, a month supply of fat that costs as little as a month supply
of carbs.
Right.
You can give it off ramen for like five cents.
That's right.
That's right.
All right.
Do you guys think of any more drawbacks?
I think that's...
No, those are the first ones that come to mind.
Yeah. All right, let's the first ones that come to mind.
All right, let's get into the benefits of low fat.
So now we're talking about low fat diet.
What are some of the benefits of it?
The first one that comes to mind is that it's,
when you want to lower your cholesterol,
total cholesterol number, low fat diets
for some people seem to be superior.
Now, both diets can lower cholesterol if they're low calorie, but there are some people seem to be superior. Now both diets can lower cholesterol
if they're low calorie,
but there are some people who have really high cholesterol
numbers and I've worked with these people
and we can switch around the fat,
we can have calories or whatever,
and they just, their body just produces way too much cholesterol
when their fat intake is high.
And having them on a lower fat diet
just gave them better.
Now, are these outliers?
Because I've heard that dietary cholesterol
really doesn't have that big impact
on overall cholesterol.
It's not the dietary cholesterol as much
as it's just a total fat.
Fat intake can affect cholesterol.
Saturated fat is the big one, right?
Saturated fat has a positive,
you know, in terms of raising the number of cholesterol
in your diet more than, I think, almost anything else.
And some people just, they just need a lower fat diet. I've worked with these people before,
and we've done, we did everything, and their number was still kind of high. Now, personally,
for me, it wasn't anything that I think they should be worried about, but their doctors still
told them, no, I think we want to get the numbers lower. And once they dropped the fat,
the cholesterol kind of went down.
No, this has to be pretty rare though.
Because everybody I ever that had high cholesterol,
the moment I put them on a diet period, low calorie,
and we built muscle cardio, I mean,
almost immediate change.
That's like one of the first things
that I could show a difference in.
It was rare that, in fact,
the few rare cases where my adjustments were not showing a big
result is my clients that lied to me that we're over-consuming.
Still, we're the ones that maybe they made some different food choices, but they were
still we're overeating and they were not following the calorie restriction.
I've only found that.
I haven't found somebody where, oh my God,
we're in a caloric deficit.
I know for sure consistently,
and they're still seeing high numbers.
No, you're right.
It's a subset of people.
It's a, but those people don't get their cholesterol numbers
in the whatever, what we would consider healthy,
range unless they go lower fat.
Now here's the other part though.
You wanna raise your HDL, you do that with fat. Now here's the other part though. You want to raise your HDL, you do that with fat.
So raising the HDL seems to be better with a lower carb higher fat diet. But again, if you're in that subset of people
whose cholesterol levels are not responding well to a low calorie, low carb diet, you might need to go low fat.
That's a sign that that's probably a better diet for you. We talked about athletic performance, carbs.
If you're dieting and you're cutting calories,
as long as you get your essential fats
and your protein is high, you want carbs.
You definitely want carbs.
You definitely want it.
It was an interesting thing, though,
to think back about carbs.
For me, as an athlete, I thought,
like it was just all fair game.
And it was just about loading carbs
on top of all the carbs that you're already eating
to then be better performance, which was not the case.
Not only that, I was fatigued and had mental fog
and had to realize that no.
Me actually abstaining from carbs
and then cycling them back on-game day
made a massive increase in my performance.
Yeah, definitely.
Well, this is what best resembles.
We get asked a lot, like, what are you guys following or what diet you want?
I'm not, right now I'm not competitive, so I'm not tracking and paying close attention
like I used to, but I have general things that I do.
One of the general things that I do with low fat or low carb is, I base it off of what my day is probably going to look like.
So, if I have a day like, let's say, Sunday, right, a football day,
you know, if you looked at my, I used a rice paper wantons,
I did ground turkey, I did a pork shoulder,
I did real high fat protein type of diet, low carbohydrate.
Why? Because I'm sitting watching football all day long.
I don't need very much carbs to power me through,
it's sitting down watching the watching football.
No real exercise there than like low level stuff,
like cleaning house and so that.
So that, that I just naturally try to gravitate
towards those type of meals on a day like that.
Then I have a day like today where I want to get after my
lifts, I've got squats ahead of me.
Like I'm going to let carbohydrates work around my, a larger amount of carbohydrates to work around my workout, both before and afterwards.
Yeah, I remember you saying when you were competing as a professional physique competitor,
when you were bulking or building, you used to say you needed X amount of carbs before your lift.
I remember there was a number. when you were bulking or building used to say you needed X amount of carbs before your lift.
I remember there was a number.
Yeah, no, I could tell,
I mean, that was one of the fun things about competing
and actually weighing, measuring, tracking,
everything I did is I got to a point where I could tell
like, oh, when I had 150 grams or more of carbohydrates
before my one o'clock workout,
it was like guaranteed to have a great lift, great pump,
great energy, felt strong.
If I went into that workout with anything less than a hundred,
I could see how much harder that workout was for me.
I was weaker at a hard time motivating myself,
the pump was worse, so all that.
I could totally, and I got it down to that size.
Now, those numbers have changed for me
because I'm way more sensitive to carbohydrates now.
So now, if I have 50 to 100 grams before I work out,
that's a nice amount of carbohydrates
because my calorie intake's way low.
My body is way more used to getting higher fats
and lower carbohydrates.
I rarely run over 250 grams of carbs.
When I was competing, I was pushing 600 grams of carbs a day on a regular day.
But yeah, that's how I use that.
That's how I train.
I try to educate my client on the benefits of low carb, on the benefits of low fat.
And then how do we learn how to understand those benefits?
And then also psychologically, the benefits and drawbacks of those.
Now, how do we integrate both of them in your everyday?
Because I think there's value to both of them
and I think both of them can lead to major drawbacks
consistently only doing.
Like anyone I know that tries to run a ketogenic diet
for a really long period of time,
goes, ends up happening with the point you made, Sal.
You fall off the wagon and then you over consume my crazy.
Anybody that I've known, even if you've had aesthetically, you've done well on low fat
for long periods of time, then I see things hormonally, skin, hair issues like that because
sure they've maintained not putting body fat on, but they've been lacking in nutrients
for so long that they're seeing deficiencies in other places.
I mean, I remember I was low carb for a very, very long time
and then I started introducing carbs into my diet
and man, my workouts were insane.
My strength went through the roof.
I had the most insane pumps.
It was easier to put on muscle.
I, if I'm gonna pack on muscle,
if I'm in a contest and I need to be get strong and pack on muscle, I am'm going to pack on muscle, if I'm in a contest and I need to be
strong and pack on muscle, I am not going low carb.
I am going to eat my carbohydrates.
And if I'm trying to diet and get lean but still maintain lots of strength and
performance, I'm going to cut my fat before I'm going to cut my carbs.
Now I'm not going to go below essential fat, that's stupid.
Remember we talked about how you need essential fats, but I'm not going to go bottom out carbohydrates, that's stupid. Remember we talked about how you need essential fats,
but I'm not gonna go bottom out carbohydrates
if I wanna maximize my performance.
And that was, I think those are some of the main benefits
of, you know, going lower fat.
And also when you cut fat, that's an easy way
to cut a lot of calories.
Really is.
I mean, if you're, if you're just talking about pure calories,
right, if you cut 10 grams of fat at your diet, that's 90 calories. You cut 10 grams
of carbs, that's 40. 40, you have to cut more than twice as many grams of carbohydrates
out of your diet to equal the same amount of calories that you get from cutting fat.
I had to be careful combining them. Yeah, definitely.
So add up quick. Definitely. So it's an easy way to cut to cut
calories. And then we talked about earlier, it's less expensive.
You know, you could fuel, you could feed yourself with a lower fat
diet with way less money than you could with a lower carb diet.
And for some people, that's a very big plus, especially if you're
bulking. Yeah. If you're bulking and you're trying to consume
4,000 calories a day. oh my gosh, a 4,000
calorie a day diet that's low in carbs and high in fat, that's an expensive, expensive
ass diet.
You do that with carbs and like you said Adam, you got some good organic white rice, good
quality and you're paying a dollar or a serving or less for it and you're getting nice
meals out of it. It's phenomenal for bulking. you know, for, you know, a dollar or a serving or less for it and you're getting nice meals
out of it.
So it's phenomenal for bulking.
Let's talk about some of the drawbacks of the low fat diet.
We talked about the appetite for some people that's a drawback, for some people that's
a plus, you're trying to bulk, that's a good thing, you're trying to get leaner, that's
a bad thing, can definitely cause gut issues in people.
Here's one that may cause problems.
Too low a fat intake has been tied to low testosterone levels.
This actually been shown in men.
When they cut their fat too low,
because fats are essential,
and they're a part of the hormone making process,
their testosterone levels tend to drop.
Now to be fair, any low calorie diet
for too long can cause that.
Even a low carb high fat diet. If the calories are low, too low, for a long period of time,
we can start to see some negative hormone changes. But it seems to be stronger
with a low fat diet. And I think that has to do with the fact that the fats are essential,
and they're what's used to turn into the fat to hormones or they're
part of the process.
And then of course, high fat food send it, contain cholesterol, cholesterol may have a connection
to testosterone.
Another drawback that I find kind of comical now, because I think we all probably had moms
who fed us a stack of pancakes in syrup and a bowl of cereal or whatever on big test
day or whatever you don't say. Or a glass of orange juice stack of pancakes, syrup and a bowl of cereal or whatever on big test day or whatever you
don't say or a class of orange juice stack of pancakes, syrup all over.
Like a picture of the cereal commercials.
It's no different than cake.
Yeah.
It's in the name.
You give me cake for breakfast.
I know.
But that was right.
That was kind of the go to.
And then you'd be in class and you're like nodding off.
Right.
You're tired.
So that's one of the drawbacks of Icarb is I would get the brain fog, get the crashes.
So that you have the spikes when the carbs are hitting really well.
And then when they come back down, the crashes seem to be hard.
That was one of my favorite things about the higher fat type of diet.
And it makes sense when we talk about all the studies that support endurance athletes for high fat is I noticed it just being an average person. I just felt like I
have this nice consistent energy all day. Right. It's even. Maybe I don't feel the peaks
for performance. Like when I go to the gym and I'm like, yeah, let's go hit it with carbs.
I do. When I get with I time my carbs just right. I go into my workout. I feel amazing.
But the drawback is high carb like that
also causes the high drops.
Pretty hard.
So then I want this mid afternoon nap
after I had that amazing spike in the middle day.
So that's one of the drawbacks.
So what's the consensus between us
for the average person generally speaking,
generally speaking, if somebody's gonna cut their calories,
what do you guys think?
What tends to be a better approach
for someone, for the average person,
to reduce their carbs or reduce their fat?
Yeah, only because the majority of people
are trying to lose weight and lose body fat,
I would say, yeah, lowering down your carbohydrate intake.
And most people are not trying to become athletic champions.
Most people are like, it's just like-
And I want a smaller subset of people. Yeah, I want to get more fit. I want to build some muscle. I'm not trying to go athletic champions. Most people are like, I want a smaller subset of people.
Yeah, I want to get more fit.
I want to build some muscle.
I'm not trying to go crazy with my strength and performance.
I need just consistent energy throughout the day
and I need to maintain my weight.
I'm sedative.
I would agree for more often than not,
a lower carb diet would be what I would record.
Yeah, most people, so I prefer a balance even, right?
Of fat and carbohydrates, wouldn't it?
But most people when I assess a balance even, right, of fat and carbohydrates when I, but most people when I assess a diet almost always I have to reduce carbohydrates increase fat.
Exactly.
It's just, I think, again, I think we're still in that era of, you know, fat was making us fat.
And so, and it's the easy go to for the points that you make about how high a calorie is that as soon as someone decides they're on a quote unquote diet, or they're gonna be eating better, you know,
oils, butters, greasy foods, kind of the first place
that everybody or fast food, they kind of carve off
and then they're fat and take drops to the floor,
but then their carbon take is still high.
Sugar is especially, like sugar is almost the number one
thing that I, and I actually address sugar
before I address even carbs by myself.
So I actually don't even, I don't even tell them,
oh, you can't have more carbs.
I go, let's look at your sugar and I actually want to
reduce that.
And so I know like-
Yeah, it's not uncommon to see people consuming, you know,
70, 80 grams of sugar in a day.
Oh, very.
Yeah, super, super common.
Yes, very, very.
And, you know, if that was all coming from fruit,
not a big deal, but-
Never.
They're eating, and the fruit choices that even make I even
start to change.
I always try and tend to push clients when I'm trying to manipulate their sugar intake
of the carbs to berries, blueberries, backberries, raspberries, strawberries, all these berries,
lower in calorie, higher in eye and an oxylisymic, higher fiber, lower glycemic, just the benefits
of those versus bananas, which we love, apples.
These are the ones that are higher in sugar, lower in.
Yeah, those things have just less value,
even though it's fruit, and it is good.
I love melons.
Quote them, quote, good for you.
And we also have to remember this,
and this is why I love like sharing this with clients.
Like one banana today does not look like a banana in,
you know, 1870.
Oh no, we've engineered, we've raised plants
to become carbohydrates.
To impress a banana.
Yeah, it's true.
You can get a banana at a grocery store right now.
No joke, okay?
If you actually do this the next time you guys have a banana,
put it on the scale and actually weigh it,
then go look up what it is.
You can get easily get a banana that has 50 to 75 grams
of sugar in one banana.
And it's funny because when you look up
the nutrition facts on bananas, they're like small to medium banana. You're like, oh, it's funny because when you look up the nutrition facts
on banana, they're like small to medium banana.
You're like, oh, it's dirty,
there's none exist anymore.
They don't exist.
They're all these huge giant bananas.
Queue cumbersize bananas that are just,
you're absolutely right.
And I'm not saying that bananas are bad.
I wanna make that clear too,
because if that was all of your sugar and carbohydrates
and everything for that,
you'd probably be fine.
You just have to account for it.
Right, exactly. You just have to count for it. Right, exactly.
You just have to count for it and understand
that there's better.
So, long story of explaining what do I like.
I prefer a balance.
I want my clients to eat an even amount of carbs
as far as calories, not the grams,
because we know the grams are different.
And even amount of calories coming from fat,
even amount of calories coming from carbohydrates.
And then I like to coach and manipulate those
like I was telling you guys, is I know the-
Yeah, some days are lower-
Right, some days are lower-
I know the behaviors that people tend to do on weekends
are all, if I'm communicating like a good coach should or client,
I know what my clients are doing this weekend,
like this Super Bowl weekend, I gave specific goals for people
because it's the Super Bowl and I know they're gonna be sitting down watching it.
So I know that.
And so then I'll have them manipulate fat or carbs
for that day and show them how to learn,
how to benefit and do that.
Because what I have found when you're not paying attention
and you just do what you wanna do,
we tend to gravitate towards the worst choice.
When you sit down and you watch television,
that is like the worst time to be in taking all this carbohydrates.
That's when we do it most often.
When you decide to avoid all the car process type foods,
is when you're moving around all day at work
and you're busy and you're dialed in on your routine,
and that's actually the time
that you could probably get away with some of those.
So I really teach people.
And I like to have people alternate
because it more mimics real life anyway.
You know, I don't want you to get so stuck
on a particular macro recommendation
that you avoid a whole group of foods
for so long that then it becomes a binge desire.
I like to let people have those types of foods
in their diet.
Today's a lower carb day, tomorrow's a lower fat day,
because it allows it me
to wide variety and doesn't produce
that psychological phenomenon where it's like,
oh my God, I can never have carbs.
In the second I go off, I go way off.
Oh no, I can never have fat.
And then I go way off.
It just mimics real life a little bit better.
Here's it, dear.
Yeah, I would say generally speaking,
low for me, lower carb is better for most people.
If I'm training athletes, it's
higher carb, especially if they're high performing athletes, it's higher carb. If I someone's
trying to bulk and gain muscle and size, I'm going to have them eat more carbohydrates.
If they're trying to get leaner, I tend to cut carbohydrates, but I also tend, I like to
cycle them like you said, Adam. But at the end of the day, the diet that makes you feel
the best, that you can stick to the longest, that makes you the healthiest is gonna be the best.
And so you may be an athlete listening right now,
and you may be best on a low carb diet,
or you may be someone who trying to get lean,
who does better on a lower fat diet, totally fine.
So at the end of the day, you have to listen to your body,
but generally speaking, I think that what we said is true.
Yeah, I think that what we said is true.
I think it's important though,
that because right now the ketogenic and carnivore diet
is making a surge.
Sure.
And that's something I want to reiterate what you said,
because I think it's so important,
is whichever diet that you can be consistent with,
it's going to be the one that you're most successful with.
And one of the most appealing things about the carnivore diet
or the ketogenic diet is the simplicity of the things.
Especially carnivore.
Right, it's so simple.
Like, what do I eat?
You just eat fuck a meat all day long.
That's all you eat.
It's that simple.
Just avoid everything else.
Now, that's fine.
And I know there's people that are promoting it
that are having success with it.
And I do believe there's definitely some huge benefits
for the general population because of the behavioral things
we talk about around carbs and diabetes
and yada yada yada.
But the question you have to ask yourself is, is this something I could see myself doing
for the rest of my life?
And if you can honestly say that, yeah, you know what?
I didn't really, I don't care to have cake or chips or any popcorn or any of those things
that fruit.
Yeah, fruit or vegetables or any of those things ever again.
I actually love meat that much
and I don't only wanna eat forever like that,
then 100% I think that's probably a great strategy for you.
But for most people, you need to really think about
that long and hard before you step into any diet,
is this something that I can do?
Because the repercussions when you come out of it
are worse, have you just can eating the way you were
and just restricted calories?
It's always a rebound.
It's always a really big, strong reversal and rebound
because you've been so restricted in one direction
for so long.
And look, if you really want to learn your body
and you want to learn how to read your body,
which is more important, so learning how to read
your body is more important than learning your body because you can learn your body now and your body, which is more important. So learning how to read your body is more important than learning your body.
Because you can learn your body now, and your body could change in five years.
Your circumstances can, but if you learn how to read your body,
well, now you know how to feed yourself as you go through life,
as you age, as your goals change, as your circumstances change.
Now, the best way to learn how to read your body is to eat a wide variety of food.
change. Now the best way to learn how to read your body is to eat a wide variety of food. It's to experiment with lower carb, lower fat, different options of foods, fasting, eating
the morning, eating at night. Because then you can understand how to feed your body when
you want to feel a particular way or you have to have a particular goal or what your body
needs and what it doesn't need. But do that with different intentions, right? Like most
people, most people do a low carb low fat
with the intentions of losing weight on the scale
or whatever.
Don't ignore those and pay attention to,
like, you know, if you've never run a low carb diet before,
run a low carb diet for three to four weeks.
During that time, you're not paying it to,
even though your maybe your goal is fat loss,
who cares about that right now?
Pay attention to your workout performance
Your mood your energy throughout the day your sex drive all these other other things that are markers that your body is trying to respond you that it agrees with you
And see how you like that and that's how you learn about your body don't just
Attach which one is easier for you to restrict calories and lose body fat
Yeah, cuz then all you're gonna learn oh, this one I lose weight and this
one I lose weight less.
And you're not learning any of the other potential benefits that you could get from eating
100% and with that, go to mindpumpfree.com and download our guides, books, and resources.
They're all totally free.
We have fat loss resources there.
We have resources for building muscle, for training, particular body parts.
We have a guide on there for personal trainers.
If you want to become a trainer
and you have a lot of questions,
how do I become one?
What do I do to become successful?
There's a personal trainer guide there.
They're all totally free.
We did this as a way to pay back our audience
for their wonderful loyalty.
Again, it's at minepumpfree.com.
You can also find the three of us on Instagram.
You can find Justin at minepump.
Justin, you can find Adam at minepump. You can find Justin at Mind Pump Justin.
You can find Adam at Mind Pump Adam and me at Mind Pump Sal.
Thank you for listening to Mind Pump. If your goal is to build and shape your body,
dramatically improve your health and energy and maximize your overall performance,
check out our discounted RGB Superbundle at Mind Pump Media dot com.
The RGB Superbundle includes maps and a ballad, maps performance and maps aesthetic.
Nine months of phased, expert exercise programming designed by Sal Adam and Justin to systematically
transform the way your body looks, feels and performs.
With detailed workout blueprints in over 200 videos. The RGB Superbundle is like having sour,
adamant, just as your own personal trainers,
but at a fraction of the price.
The RGB Superbundle has a full 30-day money-back guarantee,
and you can get it now plus other valuable free resources
at MindPumpMedia.com.
If you enjoy this show, please share the love
by leaving us a five star rating and review
on iTunes and by introducing Mind Pump to your friends and family.
We thank you for your support and until next time, this is Mind Pump.