Mind Pump: Raw Fitness Truth - 2250: How Eating More Can Make You Leaner (& How Eating Less Can Make You Fatter)
Episode Date: January 15, 2024The guy’s first experiences with the law of thermodynamics. (1:41) Defining the law of thermodynamics and how your metabolism is adaptive. (7:58) Highlighting how difficult this can be even wi...th TRAINERS. (21:28) Signals to teach your body (and what not to) to get leaner and burn more calories. #1 – Strength train and eat a high-protein diet. (25:01) #2 - Building muscle requires fuel and tells the body it’s safe to burn more. (27:50) #3 - Eating too little tells the body to slow down (pairs muscle down). (30:28) #4 - Eating too little reduces anabolic hormones and raises catabolic hormones. (31:15) Communicating this message to a client. (35:40) Related Links/Products Mentioned Visit Entera Skincare for an exclusive offer for Mind Pump listeners! ** Promo code MPM at checkout for 10% off their order or 10% off their first month of a subscribe-and-save. ** Personal Trainer 3-Day Training – Starting Jan. 15, 2024 January Promotion: New Year’s Resolutions Special Offers!! New to Weightlifting Bundle | Body Transformation Bundle | New Year Extreme Intensity Bundle Body | Transformation Bundle 2.0 Mind Pump #2037: How Eating Too Little Can Make You Fatter Energy expenditure and activity among Hadza hunter-gatherers Strength training can burn fat too, myth-busting study finds Mind Pump #1915: How To Re-Ignite Your Metabolism Why The Scale Is Not Always The Best Way To Measure Progress – Mind Pump Blog Mind Pump #2237: From Fat To Fit To Fortune With Mari Llewellyn Mind Pump Podcast – YouTube Mind Pump Free Resources People Mentioned Mari Llewellyn (@marillewellyn) Instagram
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Are you a business owner or marketer looking to reach highly engaged podcast listeners
like yourself?
Advertise Cast can help.
Whether you're looking to promote a national brand across Canada or a regional event or
service, we've got you covered.
Reach out today to bobatadvertisecast.com.
That's B-O-B at Advertisecast as as in podcast.com. Bob at AdvertiseCast.com.
If you want to pump your body and expand your mind,
there's only one place to go.
Mind, mind, up with your hosts.
Salda Stefano, Adam Schaefer, and Justin Andrews.
You just found the most downloaded fitness health
and entertainment podcast.
This is Mind Pump.
Today's episode we're going to talk about how eating more can make you leaner and how eating
less can actually make you fatter.
I swear we're telling the truth.
Listen to this episode.
We break it all down and yes, it's based on science and experience.
Now this episode is brought to you by one of our sponsors in Terra Skin Care.
Check this out.
They use peptides to improve the look and feel of your skin.
These peptides actually signal the cells in your skin
to regenerate faster, to look healthier,
and to feel younger, they really, really work.
They also have a hair product that if you apply to your scalp,
encourages the growth of new hair.
Again, it's all legit stuff.
Go check them out.
Go to interaskincare.com.
That's ENT, E-R-A-S-K-A-N-C-A-R-E.com forward slash M-P-M, use the code M-P-M, and get 10%
off your order.
We also have a sale going on right now on some workout program bundles.
That means several workout programs put together.
These bundles are 300 to $350 off.
So massive discounts.
One of the biggest sales of the year because it is January.
This is fitness month.
Check out the bundles.
We have the new to weightlifting bundle,
the body transformation bundle,
the new year extreme intensity bundle
and the body transformation bundle 2.0.
All of those available right now at mapsgenuary.com.
All right, here comes a show.
One of the biggest misconceptions in health and fitness is the following.
Believe it or not, you can eat more and get leaner, and you can also eat less and get
fatter.
In fact, this happens all the time.
People try to lose weight.
They just eat less, they do it wrong. They end up
fatter. Today's episode we're going to explain how this happens. Can't wait for that to get clipped
and everybody smash it. Yeah, of course. Of course. How can you defy the law throwing
amicel? How daring? I'm going to break it down. I'm going to break it down. I refers to
a tell story. I remember when I experienced this as a trainer myself
for myself, not for my clients, it was for myself.
It was one of the first times that I was trying
to really get super, super lean.
So I was never like overweight, I always worked out,
but I was trying to get like super ripped at one point.
And what I did is I cut my calories, did a bunch of cardio,
which is what people typically do.
This is the wrong approach.
This is what I did though,
so I thought you were supposed to do. Did a bunch of cardio cut which is what people typically do. This is the wrong approach. This is what I did though, so I thought you were supposed to do.
Did a bunch of cardio cut my calories,
lost weight on the scale.
And I had one of my friends who was a trainer
at the time who worked for me,
testing my body fat percentage with calipers.
And I'll never forget.
I lost, it was a relatively significant number
on the scale, like eight pounds or something like that
on the scale.
So I lost eight pounds.
I'm like, oh my god, I'm getting leaners, totally working.
This is awesome.
Can you come test my body fat?
He came and tested my body fat
and I went up almost a percent.
Now I thought for sure, I was convinced
you tested my body fat wrong.
You're doing it wrong, do it again.
Came back the same.
I had someone else test me, came back the same.
I'm like, how is this even possible?
And at the time, I had a trainer
working for me. It was highly educated. And I sat down with them and I said, do you
think that there's so much user error on this body fat caliper that it could read so
wrong that I lost eight pounds and gained body fat? And he goes, no, not necessarily. I
said, what do you mean? He goes, if you lost muscle, then you're going to be fatter.
And I said, what?
And then he said the following.
And this, of course, blew my mind.
It's totally true.
Body fat percentage, which is what matters,
not your total body fat.
It's the percentage that matters.
Body fat percentage is a percentage
of your overall body weight.
And what I had done, because my approach was wrong,
which is what lots of people do, especially girls,
they, in women, this is what they do
when they try to lose weight.
Overdoes the cardio just drastically, drastically under eats,
they end up losing muscle,
and now they're left with the same total body fat,
but on a smaller frame.
Your body fat percentage just went up.
In other words, 10 pounds of body fat on a 100 pound person is less, sorry, is more
in terms of body fat percentage than 10 pounds of body fat on a 200 pound person. It's not about
the total body fat, it's about the percentage and that's just one of the ways that can happen.
You know, there's a story I don't think I've ever shared on this podcast before that this
conversation reminds me of and this happened early in my career. So I'm in my early 20s.
I've got a client, she's mid 30s.
I'd say mid to late 30s, I think she was.
Absolute sweet heart, about 100 pounds overweight.
And I had her for a long time.
At this point, we're probably, I don't know,
two months into training.
And I had put her on a diet and I've been training, I'm training her three times a week,
and we're not losing weight at all.
And at this point in my career is,
you've never heard of reverse dieting.
That's not familiar.
A lot of the time I'm having this is all the work
taught as trainers.
Yeah, cut calories.
And I have her on this like super low calorie diet and I remember her telling me that's a lot of food
I'm like a lot of food is like heart-leading calories I'm cutting calories
But she's like no, I normally eat less than that and I remember at this point in my career like I think she has to be lying to me
She's sitting across me. She's a hundred pounds over way. She's not a little petite little thing and
She's sitting across from me. She's a hundred pounds overweight.
She's not a little petite little thing.
And she's telling me she's eating like 1100 calories
and she's not losing any weight
and she's not going anywhere.
To the point where I went to her house,
like I showed up at her house,
I wanted to see what was in her cupboards
and as I go through her cupboards,
I don't see anything that jumps out at me
that okay, she's binging on this
or this shouldn't be in there. Like unless she was drinking olive oil straight out of the bottle everything in the house was
pretty solid we should have been okay and then I remember continuing on still not seeing progress
with where the calories that and then it got to a point again where I still she's gotta be lying
to me and I'm like every time you put anything in your mouth I want a picture of it and then she
started like snapping photos of it and then sending to me.
And I remember looking like this is like nothing.
It made zero sense to me at that time.
I had no idea and it wasn't until,
and I felt terrible because I actually
never helped this girl.
I had a lot of clients.
I could never solve at this point in my career,
at this age, I'm just baffled.
Such a mystery.
I think so.
Well, because we were taught,
like, and you still see this permeates the fitness space.
Like, my point I may, when I said, watch when that gets clipped, there's going to be
trainers that we'll try and there'll be people that we'll try and tear apart what Sal said
and says, Oh, that's not scientific.
And the law of throwing out his calories in versus calories out.
And that's what we're all taught.
And so you think, how is this possible?
Well, it's, it's very possible.
If this, if this girl, this one that I'm talking about, has been yo-yo
dieting her entire life and over time has slowed her metabolism down through cutting calories,
cutting calories, cutting calories, cutting calories, doing if she ever does any sort of exercise,
it's cardio, cardio, and less calories and less calories.
And so she's got herself in this spot where she has been, she's metabolically adapted
to only eating 1100 calories
and yet still being a hundred pounds overweight.
What the hell do you do as a trainer?
And at that point in my career, I didn't know what to do.
I had no idea, I didn't know what a reverse diet was.
I didn't know what we should have done
to help build our metabolism.
I only knew the tools I had, which at that time was,
oh, Cal are you push her harder?
And I had already tried all that.
You know what's crazy about this is that we now,
by the way, all of us experienced this as trainers.
And at one point Adam, I want you to tell a story of the challenge
you did with your trainers and how angry they were
when they found out that they lost weight.
So we have a body fat presentation.
But we now have studies that prove what we're talking about.
Now first off, let's talk about the law of thermodynamics.
This is a law of physics.
And what that means is, if you want to lose weight, you take in less calories and you burn,
you want to gain weight, you take in more calories and you burn it.
And the reason why it's a law of thermodynamics is, energy cannot be created nor distorted.
It just gets turned into something else.
So if there's more calories, which is energy, coming in, then you're burning, those extra calories have to be stored as something or turned into
something that don't just disappear. And if you're taking a less calories in your burning,
your body has to get those calories from somewhere. So it's going to start to burn some tissue. So
that's true. Now, here's the part where everybody gets confused. The calories out part of the equation
the part where everybody gets confused, the calories out part of the equation can vary radically and not just because of activity.
Everybody thinks it's just activity.
Move more, burn more, move less, burn less.
No.
The metabolism, human or mammalian metabolism in particular, is extremely complex.
I'll bring up two studies right now that have been quoted on the show many times.
You can look them up yourself.
We'll put up the links for them. One of them was a was a study done and I quoted this one on my book
on the on modern hunter gathers. So hunter gathers are people who live the way that humans lived
a hundred thousand years ago. So no modern agriculture. They don't grow crops. They don't have
electricity. They literally hunt and gather. Okay, so these people that's called the crops, they don't have electricity, they literally hunt and gather.
Okay, so these people, they're called the Hodson tribe
of Northern Tanzania, they lived the way we all lived
a hundred thousand years ago.
They, if they wanna eat meat, which they have to,
because it's calorically dense, they have to track it,
then they have to wound it, then they have to run after it
until the animal collapses, this is how humans hunt,
because we can actually out-trek most animals, a lot of people don't is how humans hunt, because we can actually out trek most animals.
A lot of people don't know this about humans,
but we can do this.
So animal gets exhausted,
and eventually they can sprint towards the animal,
take it down or it collapses,
then they bring it all the way back,
and this is usually like a 20, 30 mile process.
Gathering is also very active.
They don't sit down and rest like we do.
They have what's called active sitting positions,
like they sit in a squat for the most part. They don't sit on couches. They don't sit down and rest like we do. They have what's called active sitting positions, like they sit in a squat for the most part.
They don't sit on couches.
They don't have electronics.
And so what scientists did is they went down there
and through at the time,
and I think it's still true to this day,
the most sophisticated technology at measuring metabolism.
How many calories are these people burning every single day?
Now, the theory was,
they're gonna be burning a lot of calories.
They're running after animals, they're gathering.
Just based on activity, that's what you would assume.
They have to, right?
Here's what came back from the data
and it blew everybody's minds,
but if you understand evolution, it makes perfect sense.
These hot said tribes people burned roughly the same calories
as the average Western couch potato.
Now you might think to yourself, that makes no sense. The average Western couch potato. Now, you might think to yourself, that makes no sense.
The average Western couch potato gets up,
drives the work, sits at a desk,
drives home, sits at the dinner table, sits on the couch.
The hot-suit drives person is hunting, gathering,
moving, if they do rest during a squat position.
How is that possible?
Because the metabolism has to adapt.
If our bodies just let us burn 10,000 calories a day
because we're hunting and gathering, guess what?
You disappear.
We wouldn't exist.
We wouldn't exist.
You're not gonna find 10,000 calories in nature
until you understand agriculture
and you can raise cattle and all that stuff.
It just go out in nature.
Go try to find that many calories you're not going to.
The body's smart.
It has to find a way to be energy efficient.
That's right.
And the kind of activity that the HOD said tribes people engage in is the kinds of activity
that don't require lots of calorie burning machinery.
So their bodies pair muscle down, learn how to reserve calories.
They're not big bulky, strong looking people.
They're just lean, athletic, maybe looking not very big.
And their bodies learn how to burn less calories.
Here's a second study.
There was a study that compared strength training
to cardio to strength training plus cardio for fat loss,
and there were a lot of controls on there,
diet and the whole deal.
Now of strength training versus cardio,
cardio burns way more calories.
You do an hour on elliptical,
or you go run for an hour,
you're gonna burn three times at least as many calories
as if you lift weights for that time, you're gonna burn three times at least as many calories as if you lift weights
for that time, okay?
So you would think, well, cardio was probably
gonna cause the most fat loss or cardio and strength training
would definitely cause more fat loss
than just strength training, not true.
The study came back and showed that strength training
by itself, the lowest calorie burning form
of exercise in the study, burned the most body fat.
It was better than either one of those individually or those put together.
Put together.
Now, you might wonder why?
Well, because of how the body adapts and strength training tells the body, we need muscle.
Muscle burns a lot of calories.
It speeds up your metabolism.
And because I'm lifting weights, I'm not burning tons of calories while I do it, my body
is not getting this crazy signal that says conserve calories. So it allows me
to burn body fat, which body fat is a stored source of energy in case of, you know, stress
and famine or whatever. And it allows me to speed up my metabolism. So the study showed
that they got leaner. So it's important to understand that metabolism is adaptive. So if all you
do is eat less calories, what your body will do, and this is how you get fatter. You lose
weight on the scale, but the reason why you lost weight on the scale is your body paired
muscle down. Now you're just a smaller, flabier, or fatter version of yourself. By the way,
if you look up online, hopefully we can find this online. If you put a picture of two individuals that weigh exactly the same height next to each other,
one of them low body fat, one of them high body fat percentage, same weight, they look
really different. So I want people to understand this because the scale just tells you weight,
it doesn't tell you what you look like, doesn't tell you a linear.
There's another, there's another factor that's happening or what's going on here too that
you have to take into consideration too, is, okay, this person who's been cutting
calories, cutting calories, let's use the client I'm using example to a point where 1100
calories and she doesn't lose any weight anymore.
And the only way I could get her to lose any more weight immediately at that moment is
to cut down to say seven or 800 calories, which is unhealthy or make her do an absurd amount
of movement to create a core deficit in order to do that.
The part that really sucks for that person is that if she goes out and decides one time
that week to eat out or one time to have a glass of wine, the ratio of the amount of calories
her body is used to eating every day to what that one meal or that one treat is,
is so much higher.
So the person whose body is used to,
or is adapted to a thousand calories a day,
that's what they're burning at a thousand calories a day.
And anything over that is considered a surplus for them.
And then they go have a glass and a half a wine
that's four or five hundred calories.
That's 50% of their total intake.
So it only takes them going off the wagon a little bit
or having what, yeah, or one bad day
to set all that great work they did for two,
which is what so many clients can say,
it breaks my heart when I think back to the story
because I never helped this girl, I had her for a year
and I never solved this problem
because I didn't understand.
I kept trying to solve it through more activity or cutting more things out of her diet and I never solve this problem because I didn't understand. I kept trying to solve it through more activity
or cutting more things out of our diet
and I never truly helped this.
Now, ask me what I would do if we go back all over again
with my knowledge and experience.
Now, that client, which is, by the way, so crazy
and so hard for people to wrap their brain around
is what I would tell that girl today is,
we need to eat more.
We're not gonna actually do any cardio.
And we're gonna lift weights. And we're going to lift weights and we're going to lift heavy weights.
We're going to speed up your material. We're going to get strong. We're going to build muscle.
I'm not worried about you burning about your calories. I don't want you doing any sort of cardio.
And I actually want you to eat more food. We're going to hit your... And it's so counter to what I
think the messaging has been for so many decades that you wouldn't even think that's the way to go,
but yet that is what would have solved the problem.
Look, if we really think about it, it makes sense.
Look, anybody watching or listening right now,
you know, you have that friend that seems to eat whatever they want
and just can't seem to gain a pound.
And you have that other friend that thinks about food
and gains body fat.
That's how drastically different a metabolism can be.
And your metabolism is very adaptive. It's extremely adaptive. If it wasn't, you would
die. It's very adaptive. And what makes it adapt up or down are the signals that are being
sent to it. And just cutting calories, especially in combination, I'll get to this in a second,
especially in combination with high calorie burning to this in a second, especially in combination
with high calorie burning forms of exercise that don't tell the body to build muscle.
If you do those two together, what you're telling your body to do is we need to learn
how to burn less calories quickly.
Let's adapt and serve as a whole.
Down just possible because the demand is so crazy.
Like we're in basically a state where food is scarce
because that's what we're signaling to the body.
And two, we have to maintain this high level of activity
on top of that.
And so, the body's just doing what it's supposed to do.
And that's to keep you alive and just from...
So imagine the vicious cycle that most people get into
when they head this way.
It's, they start off, okay, I'm doing this cardio
and it's moderate, it's somewhat intense, but it's not crazy.. It's, they start off, okay, I'm doing this cardio and it's moderate.
It's, you know, someone intense, but it's not crazy.
You know, they're pushing, they're getting after the trying to burn
30 minutes of optical.
Yeah.
And they cut their calories and then their body doesn't move.
And so what they think to do is what?
More.
More or harder of that.
And so they only send a louder signal to what you're saying.
So their body was already going, oh shit, we're doing all this cardio, we're not eating heart of it,
I need to become efficient, I need to slow down,
I need to slow the metabolism down,
I need to conserve this energy,
because she's not feeding very much,
and she's starting to push the body more than we're used to,
and then you, as a client, get on the scale,
you don't see results, and so what do you go,
oh shit, cut less, push harder,
and so you only send a louder signal,
and so here you are week after
week, putting in more effort, more consistency, pushing harder than you ever have. And the
results are slowing to an absolute stall or nothing at all, or sometimes even worse starting
to reverse and then it feels impossible. So here's what it looks like. I'll be more specific.
And I guarantee people watching this of experiences,
they'll do exactly what you said at them.
They're like, okay, I'm gonna eat less, maybe,
I don't know, no carbs or I'm gonna skip breakfast
or I'm gonna eat these salads and that's it
or something like that, right?
Cut their calories, get on the treadmill.
Here's what that looks like.
Initial weight loss on the scales, like 10 pounds gone.
Now, I'm gonna be very clear
and the data shows this 100%.
Of that 10 pounds, close to half is muscle.
So you lost maybe six pounds or five pounds of body fat,
and maybe four to five pounds of muscle.
So now what happens is your metabolism now
is matching the amount of calories that you're eating
and your body fat percentage barely budged
because half was muscle, half was body fat.
So you're essentially the same body fat percentage barely budged because half was muscle, half was body fat. So you're essentially the same body fat percentage
with the slower metabolism, same flabbyness.
But now I'm stuck, plateau.
Oh my God, I lost 10 pounds for the first four weeks.
I'm not losing any more weight.
What do I do now?
Okay, I'm gonna get fat.
I'm gonna eat less,
or I'm gonna do more cardio, or both.
Then you get another bump down, five more pounds because it starts to slow down five more pounds, but uh-oh
More of the way now is muscle because the body's getting the louder signal
So now you lost five pounds and now maybe three of them are muscle two of them are body fat
Guess what's happening body fat percentage is going up?
Metallicism is slowing down even more. What do I do next? And maybe you've been trapped in the cycle
where you do this over and over again,
and then you're in this position where you're like,
man, I'm doing so much cardio,
I'm barely eating anything,
I still have 15 pounds to lose on the scale.
What do I do?
And then you end up with this thought,
this isn't for me.
I have terrible genetics.
I meant to be fat.
It runs in my family.
This isn't happening. Maybe I should starve myself. Oh my God, I'm terrible genetics. I meant to be fat. It runs in my family. This isn't happening.
Maybe I should starve myself.
Oh my God, I'm a failure.
I can't do this.
And then here's what happens.
You stop, but you got a slow metabolism.
The way you game back is body fat.
And now you can't go eat.
You can't even go back to what you were doing before that.
Right.
Right.
Instead of the following, sending the right signals, which we'll get into, but they include
eating a little bit more to fuel what you're about to do, send a signal to build muscle.
Initially, the scale probably won't move.
However, you got leaner.
How's that possible?
Well, you probably lost two pounds of body fat and gained two pounds of muscle.
So the scale will reflect zero, but you're actually leaner.
By the way, if everybody
watching this right now lost 10 pounds of body fat and gained 10 pounds of muscle, you
would weigh the same on the scale. You'd be much leaner and you would look smaller, because
here's the other awesome thing about muscle. It's dense. It takes up about three fourths,
maybe a little more three fourths of the space that body fat does. So if you trade pound for
pound, you keep getting smaller and smaller. So thatfourths of the space that body fat does. So if you trade pound for pound,
you keep getting smaller and smaller.
So that's why with the picture that I talked about earlier,
of an equal body weight person, one lean, one higher body fat,
they don't look like a 200 pound man at six foot tall,
who's 10% body fat,
looks very different than a 200 pound man
at 20% body fat who's six foot tall.
They look drastically, drastically different.
So you have to think about,
if you wanna do this in a way that's successful,
is how can I teach my body to get leaner
and to burn more calories on its own?
Because it's sustainable.
That means later on,
because here's what that looks like.
The weight loss on the scale
does it start really quick at first,
but I am getting leaner,
and then the metabolism kicks in,
and then you get this snowball effect where, which we've
experienced this many times, you're eating a little more at the end of your weight loss
journey than you were in the beginning.
That seems like a much better place for most people.
And to highlight to the general population that's probably listening to this, how difficult
this can be and how frustrating is the story that you were alluding to with
my trainers.
I mean, to me, that was the moment when I realized, like, wow, what a fine line this is, because
here I have all these professionals that went to school for this or had been doing this
for years, yet they still make this mistake that our clients are struggling with.
And that was when I, it was really obvious to me, like, oh, we're really going about.
This was a body fat percentage loss competition.
Yeah, so what I would do with my trainer, this became an annual competition.
This was actually the first time that we had done it, though.
So this is like a year, maybe eight into my career, whatever.
One of the things I used to do to make it fun and competitive.
Obviously, I'm the boss of like 18 trainers, part of my desired
outcome, build team camaraderie also have a fit looking staff that's only going to be better
for us business wise. And so it was like this kind of, and then also have some fun, right?
We could win some money. Every trainer would put in a, I can't remember, I think we did
a couple hundred bucks. Each person put in a couple hundred bucks into the pot and then
the person with the greatest body fat percentage change would win right so whatever
Wherever you're at the ratio of where you're at to where you went would be the winner and
And we had actually had we'd have a non bias, you know
Third party the dumb in we had the hydrostatic way which is you submerge under a lot of most accurate Yeah, it's most accurate
We have one person doing it the same company they came in they'd on Friday morning
We did everybody.
And then I think I did three months from that.
I think it was the time frame.
They came back, same thing Friday morning.
Everybody did it again.
And so it was going to be this really consistent.
And the room for air so the audience knows and something like that.
I mean, you could try and screw that test up.
And you still would only be about a half a percent at most.
It's not like those handles you put your hands on to the scales,
you put your feet on like underwater weighing is extremely accurate.
There's nothing more accurate.
Extremely accurate.
Which that was what made this so interesting because we all know this.
We all know like we're aware that that's why we wanted to use that.
We're like we're going to use the best.
We're going to use the best way to track this and all the trainers do it.
And three months come by and I see all my trainers. You know, everyone's carrying their
top wear now and everyone's staying after work. And I see people on the stairmaster. And
it's, I mean, it's on. Everyone's getting into it. Everyone's super competitive about
it. And at the end of it, at least half of my trainers were just pissed and they were so pissed and they were so certain
that this thing was inaccurate. It was broken, something wasn't right because they knew how much
work they had put in. They knew how consistent they were with dieting and cutting calories. They
knew how hard they were working cardio wise and they know they didn't eat out or do anything bad. They knew they dropped weight on the scale.
They looked smaller and then they got on there and many of them, their body fat percentage
stayed the same or even some of them saw an increase from three months later.
You move them last week.
Even though they lost weight and they just baffled them more.
And it did not understand, but that just shows you what a fine line it is
of cutting calories and increasing activity like that
and how quickly the body will adapt
in the opposite direction that you wanted to go to.
And it was at that moment when I really realized like,
whoa, we're probably going,
if my trainers are doing this to themselves,
how many of our clients are we going about the wrong way when it comes to diet and exercise?
100% so you know rule number one or step number one with sending the right signal to the body for your metabolism to either not slow down or speed up and direct adaptation, the direct signal is to build
muscle.
Now, other forms of exercise may send an indirect signal because maybe you'll need a little
more strength because you never run, so now you're running a little bit or maybe because
you never do whatever yoga, but the signal is weak at best.
In many cases, in some cases, you actually lose muscle because the body learns how to become
more efficient, like long duration cardio is like this.
Long duration cardio, you don't need strength to run for long distance.
You just need stamina.
In fact, too much muscle becomes detrimental.
This is why long distance runners have no, don't have a lot of muscle either.
They're just very small, right?
So you got to lift weights to at least send a signal that says build muscle.
Now, the first step with diet is to eat a high protein diet.
This is such a big deal that they now, we even have studies now that show this, which
is blows people, when these, when these studies were coming out, blue people's minds.
They'll have studies, well, they'll have the same calories.
So the, the energy intake is the same.
But the difference between the two is that this group over here eats adequate protein
So like whatever the RDA recommends and this group over here eats what is considered a very high protein diet
Which usually breaks down to about a gram of protein
per pound of target body weight. So if you're listening right now and
Let's say you want away 110 pounds
That means you're aiming for a day
every day 110 grams of protein, okay. RDA would tell you something like 30 or 40 grams
of protein, but this 110 is considered high if that's your body wake hole. When they do
these studies, same energy intake, high protein is leaner with more muscle. So just because
the protein is high, they have more muscle and
it's there seems to be and it's probably an indirect effect from the muscle gain, a fat
loss effect. So if you want to eat more to be leaner, combine it with strength training,
you got to hit those protein targets. By the way, this is a lot harder than people think.
Even if you're small and your goal is eat a hundred grams of protein a day,
that would mean you'd eat 33 grams of protein three times a day. That's not like a typical two-way
breakfast. It's a single first place I would go with all of my female clients that were trying to
pursue weight loss. Yes. Strength training, increased protein intake, 100% across the board, not most, not some. Everybody. Everybody under was under consuming protein.
And or they were not even hitting, they weren't hitting optimal.
So even if they were okay, RDA-wise, like health-wise,
but not for building muscles.
So the other thing I understand is that another reason
why that's so important, not just because for health purposes,
and what it does for the types of foods that you choose,
and it's muscle sparing,
but it's how you're gonna build muscle.
If you go in and you send a signal
by lifting weights to build muscle,
but then you don't give the body the building blocks
to build that muscle,
you're only gonna get so much muscle out of it.
Now, if you're consistent and you give the body
what it needs nutritionally by E protein
while you're sending that signal,
then you're gonna build the most amount of muscle you're going to build the most amount of muscle.
And if you build the most amount of muscle, your metabolism is going to go up because those
pounds of muscle require more calories to survive than fat does on your body.
Therefore, it speeds your metabolism up.
Plus the benefits psychologically too, because you're eating and seeking out protein, which
is challenging to eat adequate amount of protein per day that's required.
But what you're doing is you're focused on increasing calories.
When in fact, it's so satiating that a lot of times it just naturally sort of lowers
the amount of calories you're consuming anyways.
And so what you're focused on before was a negative in terms of like, I had to reduce
and cut out all this stuff out of my diet
And you're almost like in that punishing sort of mentality versus I need to grab something that's gonna help me build and fuel myself
That point you're making is so true that when I had these clients that were trying to lose
20, 30, 500 pounds that trying to lose weight and
Where my my female clients and we started to do this,
I wouldn't even care about calories.
All I would say is go hit the protein take
because I knew how hard it was to hit the protein take
consistently and if they were doing that through whole foods.
People who've never done it had no idea.
They would have such a hard time,
they're not gonna overeat, they're just not going to.
If day every day they hit that,
especially if they eat it through whole foods,
it's gonna be really tough.
It's gonna be tough for them just to get
to the amount of calories that I want to get.
Much less over-counter.
Building muscle requires nutrients like protein,
especially, and it also requires fuel.
So for a lot of people,
if you really want to go down this metabolism-boosting highway,
if you really want to see your metabolism boost,
you eat the protein and you still try to eat a little more
because you have to fuel that metabolism boost
and you have to send the signal to the body
that says it's safe to burn more calories.
Remember, like the HODZ-a-TRIBE study showed,
your body, if it feels like calories are scarce,
it will adapt and slow its
metabolism down. It will change its caloric requirements,
feeding yourself and feeding yourself appropriately tells
your body, hey, it's okay to burn more calories. By the way,
on the flip side, eating two little calories tells the body
the opposite. It tells the body, slid out in fact, in fact,
although the effect isn't massive in a 24 hour period you can measure this
Right now if a person ate less or more their metabolism would adapt that day
You would see it the following day if you all of a sudden dropped your calories below
You would see a little bit of an adaptation not a huge one, but it's because it's only a day
But you'd see a little bit of adaptation in
Not a huge one, but it's because it's only a day, but you'd see a little bit of adaptation in caloric burn.
So eating more calories, reverse dieting is part of this, right?
Reverse diet is where you slowly bump calories as you strength train and the goal is to boost
the metabolism to a point where it gets so high, then you can cut calories and end up in
a really safe, maintainable place.
The other thing too is that when you eat too little
and you just try to burn calories through activity
and don't tell your body to build muscle,
there's something very interesting that happens.
So your body's part of the way your body signals muscle growth,
fat storage, tissue remodeling,
is through the hormone system.
Hormones are chemical signolars in the body, okay?
When you cut your calories too low
and you do lots of calorie burning exercise
that doesn't say build muscle,
your body will organize its hormones
in a way to reduce muscle mass
and to promote fat storage.
Remember, your body, think about it this way.
Think about your bank account.
If all of a sudden you lose your job or the economy slows down, you're trying to save money. You're
not trying to spend more money. You're like, look, we're not getting any money. I just lost
my job. I'm going to try and conserve as much as possible. I'm going to take the bus or
I'm going to walk. I'm not going to eat out, et cetera. Now imagine if all of a sudden
you made tons of money, you win the lottery, economy's crushing. Well now you're like, yeah, I'll buy those expensive shoes.
I'll get that purse.
I'll go spend on that streaming service
because I got plenty of money that's coming in.
Well your body will do this as well
and it does that through its hormones.
So you have what are called catabolic hormones.
You have what are called anabolic hormones.
Anabolic hormones are the ones that tell your body
to build calorie burning tissue, mainly muscle.
Okay?
Caterbolic hormones tell your body to burn calories, but also tell your body to learn how
to slow down.
It's metabolism.
Cortisol is a very popular one, right?
Too much cortisol all the time, by the way, you need cortisol.
But if it's always high all the time, your body will eat away at its muscle.
And we'll start to learn how to store more body fat.
In fact, it'll actually change over time how your body stores body fat.
Too much cortisol over time,
there's some evidence that shows that it may actually
promote belly fat storage or visceral body fat,
which is actually harder to burn.
So what happens to you is if you overwork out
and under eat, your hormones become more catabolic
and less anabolic.
Here is a sign.
This is a very, for men, there's a sign for men and women,
and there's a sign that's specific to women.
But for men and women, one of the signs is reduced libido.
That means anabolic hormones are dropping,
sleep disturbances, excessive fatigue,
hot and cold intolerance.
If all of a sudden, like you're always cold,
or the heat is just too bare and you like you just have
This really bad intolerance to temperatures. That's the sign women. Here's a very clear sign. You lose your period
If a woman and you see female athletes do this all the time because they'll over train themselves and under eat if a woman
loses her period and she stops menstruating it means her body literally believes it is not safe
to conceive.
There's not enough calories, there's too much stress,
we're gonna make you infertile.
When I used to train female clients,
those that had a regular menstrual cycle,
if they came to me and I'm looking at their diet
and exercise and they also didn't have a period
and they're like, I haven't had it for a year or whatever.
Oh yeah, we're strength training, we're cutting your activity,
and we're gonna make you eat more calories,
and we're gonna reverse diet, and like clockwork,
almost every single time, unless there was a bigger issue,
you would see their period come back.
What's so important about that too, Sal,
is that if that's out of balance,
and then you're also trying to ask your body
to burn fat or build muscle,
it's gonna prioritize health first.
When the hormones are out of
whack like that and you're still pushing the body, you're putting on all this work, hoping
you're going to get this return of, you know, I'm lifting weights and I'm running like crazy,
so I'm hoping I'm going to build some muscle, I'm hoping I'm going to burn some body fat,
but your hormones are so out of whack that it wants to just be healthy and balanced. It's
not going to listen to what you're trying to tell it with building muscle and building muscle.
No, it's dangerous to build muscle without that.
It's not healthy to have a baby.
It's not going to listen to you
about burning body fat and building muscle.
And so getting that balanced
and getting that healthy first is far more a priority
than what we're doing as far as the cardiovascular work
or even in the strength training field.
You've got to figure that out first.
Yes, so the strategy for many people when it comes to real fat loss, the kind that shows up in the strength training field, you gotta figure that out first. Yes, so the strategy for many people, when it comes to real fat loss, the kind that shows
up in the mirror, the kind that makes you feel good, the kind that's sustainable, is
eat a high protein diet, don't drop your calories too low, build muscle.
If you do those things right there, then you're on the right track.
If your strategy is, I'm just gonna do a lot less, I'm just gonna move as much as possible,
then you're probably gonna lose muscle
and put yourself in an unsustainable position.
I think it's important to talk a little bit
about the psychology of this
and the way we would have to communicate
a client through this process,
because you gotta understand that you take a client
who is used to hearing all the things
that we were talking about the beginning,
and then this is like a complete paradigm shift
of like, wait a second like
you're gonna tell me to eat more, stop the cardio, lift weights, it's a major hard pill this
is very hard pill this wall so when I get clients that are like this the things that I'm
communicating to them when it comes to like their ultimate goal which is let's say lose 50 pounds
or whatever number it is is I'm not concerned about that right now. In fact, I want the scale to stay the same, maybe even go up a little
bit, which wrap your brain around that. This is tough. Someone comes in, I want to lose 50
pounds out of them. I'm paying you to help me. And I'm telling you, okay, in the first 30
to 60 days, we might actually see the scale go up one or two pounds. I don't want you
to fret. We're actually doing great. You need to mentally be ready for that.
So as you're hearing this advice from us,
you also need to be mentally prepared
for the possibility of training for 30,
even sometimes 60 days of increasing calories,
hitting your protein takes, strength training,
and the scale staying the same or going.
That's why I tell people to throw the scale away,
especially if you're sensitive to that.
Don't look, you know it's funny about that by the way.
I used to get the, when I figured out how to do this,
this is what would happen on my clients all the time.
We'd have this conversation and I'd tell them,
don't weigh yourself and I, because it's gonna mess with you,
I'd have this whole conversation with them.
So they would do that, they'd take their scale,
put in the closet, I was very popular,
put under the bed, not weigh themselves.
Then 60 days, 30, 60 days, they'd come and see me and be like,
you know, three people today asked me how much weight I lost.
I really want to weigh myself.
And I'd say, don't do it.
Don't do it.
And they said, no, no, my husband says I lost weight.
I had two coworkers come up to me,
said that my weight, my waist looks smaller.
Everything looks later.
People think I lost 12 pounds.
I'd say, okay, are you ready to weigh yourself?
Because the scale might show, might throw it off. And they'd be say, okay, are you ready to weigh yourself? Because the scale
might show my, my throw it off, and they'd be like, yeah, let's do it. We get on the scale,
one pound lost, no pounds lost. And they say, how's that possible? Why does everybody
think I'm leaner? Because you are leaner. You just built muscle while burning body fat.
You're smaller. The scale lies to you. It's a, it's a, it's a, it's a, it's a,
evil lie.
I don't teach you.
Yes. So what should you monitor then? If this is you? Here's what you look at.
Strength.
Am I stronger in the gym?
Can I lift more weight?
Can I do more reps?
By the way, if you want to do this right, don't do circuit training.
Don't do 15 exercises strong together because you're just doing cardio.
You have to lift weights like someone who's trying to build muscle.
Straight sets, rest for two or three minutes, straight sets, two or three minutes,
reps between five to 12, do those compound lifts,
try to get strong.
If you're getting stronger, you're going in the right direction.
Now, if you wanna measure anything else,
then use body fat percentage testing.
Do it every two weeks and look at the trends.
Don't freak out over the number one number to the next,
but over the course of four, six, eight weeks, look at the trends and that'll tell you, oh, I'm getting stronger
and my body fat percentage is going down. I'm moving in the right direction.
I would also add that to this client, I'm communicating to them that I know the goal is,
all the ultimate goal is to lose 50 pounds, but our immediate goal is to build our metabolism
first. And where I want you to be before we decide to get to the 50 pounds of fat loss, right,
where I want you to be is I want you to be at a place caloricly that when I cut calories
from you, it's sustainable long term.
So that means if you eat 2,200 to 2,400 calories and you feel good eating that many times, that feels like it's
sustainable, you enjoy that, that's plenty of food for you. That means I need to get somewhere like
2,800 to 2,900 calories. So then when I cut you down to 24, that's a place that you like to be.
And so you need to take that into consideration that wherever your clork intake currently is at,
that if you want to start cutting that aggressively. Yeah.
You got to know that that cut is somewhere you can sustain.
And that's the mistake a lot of these clients make is they're like, okay, I'm going to go
do this fat loss journey.
And they cut their calories and they all say the same thing.
Like, I just want to lose 50 pounds.
Then when I get there, I'll figure it out.
Well, it doesn't work that way.
It's like, you're going to keep cutting these calories.
You may even get close or on, you know, halfway towards your goal. And then you're going to realize you're in a place where it's like, it doesn't work that way. It's like you're gonna keep cutting these calories. You may even get close or on, you know,
halfway towards your goal.
And then you're gonna realize you're in a place where it's like,
I can't live off a 900 calories.
You know, who's a great example of this, by the way?
We just had her on the show,
Mari Luellen, am I saying her name right?
Okay, so she, young lady,
she was lucky in the sense that she did this
the right way right out of the gates.
As a young lady, 99% of the time,
when they're trying to get leaner,
they do the wrong thing.
They just do tons of cardio and cut their calories.
But her husband, boyfriend at the time,
was like a bodybuilder guy.
So she just did what he told her.
And she did it the right way.
So she didn't run into any of those obstacles.
In fact, we interviewed her.
Oh, I remember when we were talking with her.
That was the thing that I pointed out.
It's like, it's so crazy to me when she was telling her story.
I'm like, you did the right one.
I'm like, yeah, do you realize like,
how many of the right choices you made
and how rare that is in a major weight loss journey
like you had, and she did,
she attributed a lot of that to you.
And she's like, I eat a lot, I feel good, I look way,
it's like, man, most people, especially your age,
they do it the wrong way.
They end up coming to us broken,
and it takes us a while to fix that.
So think about that too, Like in a more simple way to say that is
if you are a female who's trying to lose 10, 20, 30 plus pounds,
you want to train like a bodybuilder who's trying to build muscle.
100% that that is what's going to get you to do the fastest and the most sustainable once you get there.
Perfect. Look, if you like our show, go to mindpumpFree.com and check out all of our free fitness guides.
You can also find all of us on Instagram,
Justin is at MindPump Justin.
I'm at MindPump to Stefano and Adam is at MindPump Adam.
Thank you for listening to MindPump.
If your goal is to build and shape your body,
dramatically improve your health and energy,
and maximize your overall performance,
check out our discounted RGB Superbundle at MindPumpMedia.com.
The RGB Superbundle includes maps and a ballac, maps for formants, and maps aesthetic.
Nine months of phased, expert exercise programming designed by Sal, Adam, and Justin to systematically
transform the way your body looks, feels, and performs.
With detailed workout blueprints in over 200 videos,
the RGB Superbundle is like having
sour, animal, and Justin as your own
personal trainer's butt at a fraction of the price.
The RGB Superbundle has a full 30-day
money-back guarantee, and you can get it now
plus other valuable free resources at
MindPumpMedia.com.
If you enjoy this show, please share the love by leaving us a five-star rating and review
on iTunes and by introducing MindPump to your friends and family.
We thank you for your support and until next time, this is MindPump.
you