Morbid - Spooky Lighthouses Vol. 2
Episode Date: April 19, 2022Yo ho ho (and a bottle of rum) it’s time for some spooky haunted lighthouses!! Alaina brings us the in depth haunting of St. Augustine Lighthouse which involves quite a few tragedies but al...so some really cool points in women’s history. And once you’re uplifted from that Ash will bring you right down diggy down down with the story behind how Execution rocks lighthouse received its name and a tale of murder at Wood Island Lighthouse! As always, thank you to our sponsors: Noom: Sign up for your trial at Noom.com/MORBID RO: Right now, if prescribed, new members will receive 10% off of eyelash growth serum from Ro Derm when you go to RoDerm.com/MORBID Simplisafe: You can customize the perfect system for your home in just a few minutes at SIMPLISAFE.com/morbid. Go today and claim a free indoor security camera plus 20% off with Interactive Monitoring. Daily Harvest: Go to DAILYHARVEST.com/morbid to get up to forty dollars off your first box! Notion: Learn more and get started for free at notion.com/morbid See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Hey, Prime members, you can listen to morbid, early, and ad-free on Amazon music.
Download the app today.
You're listening to a morbid network podcast.
Whether you're running errands on your daily commute, or even at home, you can enjoy all
your audio entertainment in one app, the Audible app.
As an Audible member, you can choose one title a month to keep from the entire catalog.
This includes the latest bestsellers and new releases.
Plus get full access to a growing selection of included audiobooks, audible originals,
and more.
If you've been wanting to form good habits, break bad ones, and improve motivation, atomic
habits written and narrated by James Clear is a great lesson.
It'll reshape your mindset on progress and success by helping you develop strategies
to transform your habits.
New members can try audible free for 30 days.
Visit audible.com slash wandery pod or text wandery pod to 500-500 to try audible for free
for 30 days.
That's W-O-N-D-E-R-Y-P-O-D.
Audible.com slash wandery pod or text wandery pod to 500-500 to try audible for free for
30 days.
Angie has made it easier than ever to connect with skilled professionals to get all your
home projects done well.
Just bring them your project online, or with the Angie app, and answer a few questions.
With Angie, you can book instantly at an upfront price, or request and compare quotes from multiple
pros, so you can find the best price for your project.
So the next time you have a home project, just Angie that and start getting the most out of your home.
Download the free Angie mobile app today or visit Angie.com. That's ANGi.com.
Hey weirdos, I'm Ash, I'm Alina and this is morbid and something really fucking creepy just happened.
So this is morbid haunted as fuck edition and first it was haunted edition and now it is haunted as fuck edition because when we started this out we're like cool it's spooky
lighthouse guys it's volume two we're very excited haunting things are fun and then I
was moving my microphone around a little bit to get it more comfortable and I was like
oh you know what let me stop recording and just check to make sure that it's not making
any like boom boom boom, boom, sounds.
Right.
And this is what happened.
This is what happened when we recorded the first one.
Be ready.
Hey, we're the I.M.S.
And I'm waiting up in this is
Merbant Spooky Lighthouse's Edition
Merbant, Merbant, Merbant, Merbant.
I'm so excited for most of the ride houses.
Yes.
So, uh, so yeah, I don't know what that means.
I don't know if we're supposed to be doing this episode,
but we're gonna forge ahead.
We're gonna go forth and conquer.
It's gonna be like the Oragon Trail,
and we're just gonna forge across the river.
Yeah, that was a lot.
Let's hope we don't get like yellow fever.
Yeah. Well, yeah, we cut most of that like first part because we didn't want your ears to start
bleeding in your car. But we were explaining that we're gonna do like a fucking haunted week
this week. Yeah. And just have a bunch of haunted episodes because they're fun. They are fun.
We're just feeling in a spooky mood. We're feeling like we
want to be ghosty. Yeah. I just like the summer is starting and it's making me miss October.
Yeah. And you know, I feel like every haunted place obviously has to do with some tragedy or death
some murder of some kind that happens with it. So it's very interlocked with true crime. At least
we're going to find ones that are. And I feel like, you know, sometimes we just need
a week of spooky true crime instead of just like straight up
true crime.
And that's why we named it morbid,
because it's all encompassing.
It's morbid, man.
And you know what?
If you have ghosts, you have everything,
so we're just not gonna explain that further,
because if you know, you know, and if you don't,
you don't, but go listen to ghosts. But that gets it away. That's how you know, you know, and if you don't, you don't. But go listen to ghost.
But that gets it away.
That's how you know.
You know, I just love you guys.
I know. I want you to be right.
So I'm giving you this.
Alright, well, let's start.
Yeah, let's get into spooky lighthouses because I'm ready.
Okay, so we each picked, you have one right, like one massive one.
Yeah, I have one that was just too much.
Too much. That's shocking shocking that's so crazy. Yeah, so yeah, Elena has one
Super like haunted lighthouse and I have two and just to start this whole thing off
We thought it would be fun to start with a listener tale from a lighthouse that we did in volume one
Exactly, so I'm not sure if I can say this person's name
They'll probably tell me while I'm reading it. So it starts off and it says my adventures in the St. Simmons lighthouse. Hi weirdos. I think it's Simon's
Is it I think it is yeah. Oh my bad. Is it S.I.M. Oh, and yeah, it is
It is Simon. You're right. I'm leaving. So
We're already off to a great start here. Hi weirdos fellow. Hi, weirdos. Fellow millennial Capricorn here.
Oh, hey.
Oh, oh, oh, hey.
I hail from the pretty OK state of Georgia.
I was delighted after a shitty day at work
to select your haunted lighthouses episode
to listen to it while crying in the shower.
Oh, my goodness.
I'm sorry that you were crying in the shower,
but like we've all been there.
Yeah.
Although I live in Athens, my home away from home is St. Simon's Island.
Growing up, my family would visit at least once a year.
I've spent days, if not weeks, riding my bike up
and down the island.
And I have come across some seriously spooky places
and stories.
I love that.
I've been to the lighthouse countless times
and the stairs to the top are indeed very creepy.
You can tour the lighthouse, including
the living quarters on the second floor.
I have attached a photo of a creepy doll that hangs out in the nursery.
Ooh, I haven't heard any doggo's barking in that lighthouse.
But there definitely is a feeling attached to the building.
The first floor is a museum.
There is a bust of an amazing black woman named Nora August.
As a young enslaved woman during the Civil War,
she was freed and went on to live her own life.
The inscription on that bus reads, quote, Nora August, slave at age 23 years, purchased from the market, St. Augustine flaw.
Oh, that's so weird.
Oh, I didn't even do that on purpose.
Oh, that's weird. Super weird. Whoa. April 17th, 1860. Now a free woman. And then it says, Nora Auguste, know her, respect her.
Yes.
I love it.
And also that was weird because the lighthouse
that I'm doing is the St. Augustine lighthouse.
That's why that was weird.
It's strange.
Yeah, we were like, that's weird.
And we're not going to tell you why.
We're not going to tell you why.
I think very secretive today.
Ha ha.
So here are a few other St. Simon's tales.
Igbo landing. I think that's right. Maybe should we look it up? Igbo? Igbo?
I'm gonna look it up. I guess it could be Igbo, but I'm feeling like it's Igbo landing.
Pronouns.
Pronounsiation. It's like pronounced names.com.
Let's see.
Oh, that's British, so it sounds better.
She said, Igbo.
Igbo landing.
Igbo landing.
You can just say it like that.
Okay.
Igbo landing.
There you go.
In May, 1803, the Igbo, people of Nigeria were stolen as captives
that arrived in Savannah, Georgia to enter the slave trade.
These enslaved people were chained and packed under the deck
of a coastal vessel,
which would take them to St. Simons. Before they could land ashore about 75 Igbo people rebelled,
took control of the ship, drowned their captors, and finally landed the ship in Dunbar Creek.
Following their arrival in the muddy marshes, they turned back to the water. Rather than live as
enslaved people, the men died by a mass
suicide. Supposedly still in their chains according to blackpast.org about a dozen bodies were uncovered
and the rest were lost to history and legend. Wow that is heavy. That's why that place is so heavy.
Oh man. All right the next tale next tale. There's one of those souls coming out.
You're always lurking.
Mary DeWanda.
As with most islands, there is a legend of a love story
that ended in tragedy on St. Simon's.
Hundreds of years ago, a woman named Mary lost her
be trough to a violent storm.
Horrified in heart sick, she ran into the waves,
perhaps on a horse and died.
There's now a rumor of a wandering lover haunting the shores of St. Simon's.
There's always a wandering lover.
There always is. I have to be.
I want to be a wandering lover, but like I don't all at the same time.
No.
I want to see a wandering lover and like give her a hug.
Yeah, I want to see one and just be like, it's going to be okay.
Yeah, but I don't want to be one.
Here's Tinder, starts my day.
Here you go.
And we're like, actually, it won't be OK.
It will not be OK.
So what are you trying to do to this poor person?
I was making her more lost.
Looking for her lost bow who drowned at sea.
Known as Mary DeWanda or Mary the Wanderer,
she can be seen in the evenings walking up and down
the beach with a lantern.
Oh.
Always with a lantern.
I got chills when you said that.
Doesn't she's unbeautiful, though, I picture this woman just walking along the beach holding the lantern.
And I see like the wind blowing these really like ethereal skirts back.
And they're white.
Yeah, and it's all very gauzy and very just like,
Yes.
Airy and,
Oh, back then was like so much spooky.
It wasn't better, but like it was better than now.
It just looked, it was like prettier at times.
Yeah, it was more surreal. More surreal. Yeah, that's better than now. It just looked it was like prettier at times. Yeah, it was more more surreal
Yeah, that's all it was it was aesthetic. It was all right the light in the graveyard is the next one for it
Christ Church Cemetery is a gorgeous old graveyard near near Ford
I can do this near Ford, Frederica on St. Simon's Island. You did it
I did it long ago a man lost his wife to an. The widower knew that his beloved was terrified of the dark,
so he visited her grave every night
to make sure that she had a lit candle
on leaving her tomb.
And I can't even get a textbook.
My heart just exploded!
What love!
That's literally love.
I don't want you to be scared of the dark when you're dead.
So I'm going to light a candle by you all the time.
Oh my goodness.
They say that you can still see a flickering light
in the cemetery after dark,
long after both lovers have passed away.
I'm obsessed.
Oh, I love that.
They also say, my friends and I run a YouTube channel
called CountryFried Cryptid.
Stop it.
I think I've seen their YouTube channel.
I think I have two.
And it's awesome.
Yes.
Oh my God.
Where we explore spooky sites in Georgia.
We even visited the place where Mary and Stembridge lived his worst life in Millageville.
Stop it.
We are on a hiatus, but hope to get back to investigating Haunted Georgia again soon.
I hope so.
That is amazing.
And then they said, side note, for my birthday this year, I ventured up north to sleep
over at the Lizzie Board and house. Yes Yes! While I didn't get any spooky vibes.
Whoa! Interesting. That's shocking. I did find an amusing that someone left an
ibuprofen in the offering plate upstairs in the John Morse room. That's amazing.
You know, for those headaches that the Borden's must have been having in the
afterlife. Yeah. I think it's probably nice to do. I hope you enjoy these photos,
including me cosplaying Mary DeWanda,
one of Dunbar Creek,
and one of me trying to climb an oak tree.
I will be sure to keep it weird down south
for both of you.
Thank you.
I'm not gonna say this person's name
because they didn't specify,
but their YouTube channel, that's true.
It's pretty red.
So check out their YouTube channel.
Oh, that's so funny.
I definitely have come across that
and I've definitely watched videos and like,
as soon as I read it, I was like,
been into it. That sounds really familiar. That's really cool. That was also just like the perfect opening to this episode
because it gave us like a little tidbit of each tail and I think you said it so beautifully. Thank you for doing that because that was like a really
Well put together. It was history there. I liked that a lot. I loved that. All right, so should we start off with St. Augustine?
Do you think? Yeah, let's start off with St. Augustine because I also have a listener tail that can set us up for that. All right, so should we start off with St. Augustine, do you think? Yeah, let's start off with St. Augustine,
because I also have a listener tail
that can set us up for that.
Oh, my goodness.
Listen to you.
And by the way, if you've sent in,
which you've sent in tons of lighthouse stories
and suggestions and listener tails,
we love them, keep them coming.
We're going to read those on listener tails episodes as well,
so they won't get lost in the shuffle
and not used if they're not used
with the particular lighthouse episode. So just I wanted to make sure people knew that.
And as a specify, you can totally like go because I saw a couple that were like, I won't bore you
with like my whole experience there and I'm like, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, give it to me.
Yeah, like suggest it and then tell me your experience. And also I just realized that this is even
weirder because this one's about St. Augustine, but it mentions St. Simon's.
What the five guys realized that we did not plan this whatsoever. We each pulled these tails separately completely separately. Wow.
We're what's happening today. There's a lot of fun to shit happening right now.
This feels just like that. It feels in line. And also you and I have like been really in line lately.
Like we were recording screen last night,
and I swear I took a thought from your head
and you just set it aloud.
It happened several times.
And it was like a complex thought.
Like not just a regular like,
yeah, I want chicken for dinner.
Yeah, you would suddenly say something
and I was like, I was just thinking that.
Yeah, maybe it's the room.
Maybe it's the room.
Yeah, that's what it is.
It's like a nice vibe.
Yeah, maybe the shwee is going to be nice.
The shwee is good.
[♪ OUTRO MUSIC PLAYING [♪
Unlike other programs,
Noom White uses a psychology-based approach
to help people better understand their relationship with food.
It teaches them how to be more mindful of the way
that they eat and gives them the skills and knowledge that they need to build long-lasting, positive habits.
Guys, personally, my experience in the past is always being so overwhelmed when I start
the process of getting back on my health grind.
Not only is it super intimidating heading back into the gym and familiarizing yourself
with all the equipment and every person that you have one to high school with. But the wellness industry is throwing things
that you left and right between all the different supplements
and like what feels like really strict rules
around eating healthy.
That is exactly why I love noom.
Noom believes that the only place
you really need to start with is your mind.
With noom weight, you'll take a path toward better health
one lesson at a time.
Their psychology-based approach helps you change the way you think about food and health,
rather than demanding you to change your entire lifestyle.
That is just not going to be good.
When I started noom, I had no idea that there was actually so much psychological meaning
behind all the different choices that I made surrounding my diet.
I'll give you an example.
I always felt like I was supposed to finish
the plate of food in front of me,
because that's how I grew up as a kid,
and I know that's how a lot of people grew up as kids.
So over the years, I did not listen to my body
when it felt full, but instead,
I was like subconsciously following rules for my childhood.
Ever since I've recognized that,
it's become so much easier to just listen to my body,
and now I recognize when I'm
truly done with a meal and satiated. I'm also enjoying exercise so much more than I used
to, because I'm eating cleaner, fueling my body, and looking at exercise as an amazing
thing that my body can do instead of like a weird punishment for eating a cupcake.
Nume truly catered to my personal experience, and I really appreciate that, because noom
doesn't believe in restricting what you can or can't eat.
Instead, noom gives you the knowledge and the wisdom that you need to make informed choices
that are going to help you to get closer to your goals.
Noom understands that building long-term, positive habits can be hard and filled with ups and
downs.
That's why noom believes that it is about progress, not perfection.
Because everybody's journey looks different.
Start building better habits today. Sign up for your trial at num.com slash morbid.
That's n-o-o-m dot com slash morbid to sign up for your free trial.
Num.com slash morbid.
So let's start, shall we?
Well, hello there, spooky gals.
My name is Liana.
I hope I'm saying that right.
It's Liana.
Let me see.
Liana.
Liana.
Liana.
Hi.
Feel free to use my name on the off chance this tale graces your eyeballs and magically finds itself
in a future episode that time is now.
Or the on chance.
I was so excited about your new haunted lighthouse series.
I'm so glad you guys were excited about that,
because I love these.
Your girl loves a good haunting,
and I have a personal experience with lighthouse ghosts.
My BFF and fellow weirdo sent me
the first lighthouse episode, shout out to my girl, Diana.
Oh, Diana and Lena.
Oh, Diana and Lena.
I love that.
Because we were actually planning a trip
to St. Simon's late island later this summer.
We are here.
I immediately started looking into lighthouse tours.
I'm a veterinary nurse.
Oh, I love you.
You're an angel, you mean?
Yeah.
And would love for the chance to see the ghost of the bull the dog.
Now onto my own personal haunted lighthouse experience.
Feel free to edit as needed if you feel the need to convince, condense down to the juicy
parts of the lighthouse episode.
I will not do that.
Nay.
I grew up in Florida and would visit the St. Augustine lighthouse almost yearly as part of school field trips.
I remember as a child getting always getting a strange feeling when we went up the iconic lighthouse.
But it wasn't until I was in my late 20s that I finally got the chance to do their ghost tour.
As an empath who has had my fair share of paranormal experiences, I was excited to finally
hopefully experience something at a place I grew up visiting and learning the history of.
I've submitted another listener tale of the other ghostly encounters if you're interested
in hearing more.
Obviously.
I'm going to keep your name in consideration and I'm going to search that shit right
after this.
Me too. You're on the next listener too.
At the start of the tour, guests were handed one E.M.F. reader per group,
and were instructed to try to be as respectful
and take things as seriously as possible in hopes of maximizing the chance for an encounter.
This is where I shot a glaring side-eye at my two-cool for school younger brothers,
who at this point were scoffing and dissent-rested to mildly. My husband Matt was the one who was most excited for the
tour, so he started as the one holding the EMF reader. Everything started
relatively uneventful. We walked around, Matt asking questions, hoping to cause the
EMF to light up. So far nothing. During the tour we learned of a lighthouse keeper
who to talk about him, Peter Russ Musin, who to summarize was fond of two things,
cigars and being strict.
Who loves that.
It was like Pappa.
It really is.
He's fond of more than just that, but.
Yeah, but cigars, he loves.
He does.
It was said he was a stickler for manners,
and he hated when gentlemen would wear hats and doors.
Well, guess who was currently breaking that rule?
My husband and two brothers,
are all prancing around inside with their ballcaps.
I suggested a mat that I try holding the EMF.
The second it touched my hand,
it lit up like a fucking Christmas tree.
Oh yeah.
To test, it wasn't a fluke, I asked some questions.
Is somebody here with us?
Lights.
Did you used to work here?
More lights.
Do you wish these young gentlemen would remove
their hats while inside?
Lights going fucking crazy.
He's like, take your fucking hat off.
He's like ding, ding, ding.
The lights timed perfectly with the questions.
So as decided, I was the designated EMF gal
for the remainder of the tour,
much to my husband, Shagrin.
This is also where my brother started switching
from disinterest to the Hebe-Gbees.
They felt extremely on edge the rest of the tour.
That'll come into play later.
Oh, and when I returned to that spot
of the initial interaction later in the evening,
I couldn't help but detect the faint smell of smoke,
even though the area was a smoke-free zone.
My Asmatic ass has been well-trained to know
when smoke is present.
It ain't easy me and weasies.
Ha ha ha ha.
Always funny.
My other experience, I believe, was with one of the young girls who tragically passed
while playing in a construction cart that smashed into the bay.
I'm going to go into that when I go into that place.
Oh, sad.
We are at the In Keepers' house where there are several tales of the girls tugging on clothing
and playing hide and seek.
Women are primarily who report having these interactions.
I was sitting on a bench
with my husband and one of my brothers. The other was already waiting in the car at this point.
Still holding the MF, I decided to ask some questions targeting the little girls.
Are one of the girls here? Nothing. My name is Liana. I'd like to play a game with you if you'd
like. One little light flash. Would you prefer it if the boys left? Another teensy flash.
little light flash. Would you prefer it if the boys left? Another teensy flash. At this point my brother, my brother declared, fuck this and went to join the other by the car.
My husband switched to a bench further away. I placed the EMF reader down on the bench on
the exact spot where my brother was sitting. Lights all the way to red. I locked eyes with
my husband who saw the whole exchange and he gave me a nod to continue.
I spent the next 10 minutes or so playing a guessing game with whatever spirit had grace
me with her presence.
I would try to guess things like her favorite color, and the EMF would light up like crazy
when I got the answer right.
Even though I didn't experience anything crazy like a full body apparition or disembodied
voices, I still can't deny that the experiences I had were anything but paranormal and very exciting.
My brothers to this day don't like talking about the tour, and I'm convinced they sent something that made them uncomfortable.
Thanks for reading my spoopy tales, and definitely keep it so weird that you stay open to experiences, because you never know what little ghost girl just wants to play a game with a kind stranger,
but not so weird that you traumatized some teenage boys who just wanted to wear a baseball cap. I love it.
I love that.
Thank you, Leanna.
Thank you.
And that's going to play really nicely into my tale now.
Let's go.
So I'm covering the St. Augustine Lighthouse.
Yeah, y'all.
It was built in 1874, the one that is at least, so it was actually on there in one form or
another, on this island. the one that is at least, so it was actually on there in one form or another
and on this island from way back in 1586.
It actually, when there was like versions of this lighthouse.
That was a long ass time ago.
But the one we're gonna talk about was built in 1874 originally.
It is on, it is 100 Red Cox Road is where you can find it and that's in St. Augustine, Florida.
Alrighty.
Now, I didn't realize while I began researching this, that St. Augustine is the oldest city
in America.
Oh, I didn't realize that either.
I had no idea.
For some reason, in my mind, it would be like Salem.
Yeah.
Salem?
Yeah, like somewhere in St.
I mean, that was like what, 16, whatever.
Yeah.
So, yeah, I could see why you thought that.
And then like, you think like Rowan Oak So yeah, I could see why you saw that. And then you think like, row and oak.
Oh, yeah.
And this was before that.
It's just crazy.
Yeah.
Now, it was established by the Spanish in 1565.
And it was named after Saint Augustine, who
was the patron saint of Brewers.
He was apparently a hard partier with a quote,
with wicked living and false beliefs.
And then he was converted and became chill.
So he's now the patron, the patron saint
of stopping vices and chilling the fuck out, basically.
I kind of feel like in the beginning he was me.
Yeah.
And then he became you.
Yeah.
So Shane Agasin is kind of like the dual sides.
He runs throughout us. Yeah. Wow.
Yep. He sounded like a really fun time. Yeah. So he's just now the patron saint of, you know,
stopping fucking around and chilling the fuck out. He's the patron saint of fuck around and find out.
Truly. Now there were lighthouses before this one, like I said, as early as 1586, but they were
destroyed by, you guessed it, the Civil War.
Yeah.
Or just felt prey to the elements and erosion,
like at least one of them just like fell into the sea.
On average, and just like,
yeah, he's just like, like, whole scoop.
I'll take that.
So this one was built in 1874, and it still stands.
And in 1981, it was added to the National Register of
Historic Places. And you can go visit if you want. I want. I want to. I literally wrote, go do it.
I will. Do it. It had keepers, like actual lighthouse keepers until about 1955, when they were
able to use the wonder of technology to make the light automated. I feel like every lighthouse that I read about at some point or another became automated.
Oh yeah.
It was usually around like the 50s or 60s.
And it kind of takes away the spooky greatness of a lighthouse to me, which is like a bummer.
Like it needs a keeper.
You'd get the electricity out of there.
I need a keeper.
Right.
Just light the fun.
I digress.
Now it has 219 stairs in it and it and the observation deck is 165 feet up, although you'll very
high up.
Now back in the good old days, there were sometimes up to three lighthouse keepers at once.
That had to be running this lighthouse.
There was always a head keeper, like two assistants.
And shit went down, my friends.
There were some real tragedies that happened
with the keepers over the years.
And I get so excited when I can find a newspaper
about a ghost story, especially the origins of a ghost story.
Because then you can actually be like,
oh, this is for real.
Like, this isn't just like a rumor.
Exactly.
And I found one for this one.
So happy.
It's like, yes, confirmed.
So we're going to go through the tragedies and the deaths that have occurred here. And
then we're going to talk about the paranormal activity that has cropped up as a result
of these. LFG. Now, the first thing that I want to chat about is the tragic tale of Joseph
Andrew, who was the keeper in 1859. He was 60 years old, and he was known as a kind and respectful man.
Hell yeah.
He was doing his thing, in fact, called a very worthy keeper,
and a very worthy man by the Charleston Daily Courier.
Okay.
And at the time of his death,
he was whitewashing the siding of the lighthouse,
so he was like, way up.
And he was still working.
60 years old,
and according to the reports that day the wind was wild
Oh, he was standing on some scaffolding and it was bucking to and fro
Tragedically he fell from the scaffolding and according to the article which goes into graphic detail about exactly what happened
Because it was probably like an old-time you newspaper of course. It's from 1850 something
Yeah, they're like he fell off and three of his ribs fell out and his eyeball was over
there. Well not quite that but it's still crazy. It said quote, he first
struck the roof of the oil room 30 feet down once he glanced off and struck the
stone wall which encloses the lighthouse and thenced to the ground a stone
pavement. Oh. It said it was about a 60-foot fall from where he went,
and he died almost instantly.
But neighbors heard his screams that day from very far away.
Oh, that stresses me out.
Yeah. Now, a very interesting and cool thing
did come from this tragedy.
So there is something good that came out of this a little bit.
Joseph's wife Maria was obviously devastated
by the tragic loss of her
husband, and so according to reports, she said she went to the top of the lighthouse afterwards,
all the way 165 feet up, and in her grief, she just walked out onto that observation deck in her
night-gown, and she just said into the whatever, what do I do? And she claims, and she claimed very adamantly
that she heard her husband's voice in the wind,
say, 10 to the light.
My body did the,
like that too, that little like,
woman.
Yeah.
And he said 10 to the light.
Love, you're gonna make me fucking cry out here today.
And she crying in the club is what you're gonna do.
Ryan and the Elena loves when I say that. I love when you say that. But yeah, he said
10 to the light so she knew exactly what she had to do. She was sick alone in VIP.
I don't know what that means, but yes. Oh my goodness. Absolutely.
Candy Muse. Oh yeah. Absolutely. And she said. So she knew exactly what she had to do here.
And she got the entire community to back her.
They all came together for her.
And she became the first female lighthouse keeper
in Florida history being paid equally as the man
and the men in the job.
And became the first Hispanic American
in the United States lighthouse service.
Hell to the mother fucking yeah.
Isn't that amazing?
That come out of that tragedy.
She went up there and her husband said,
take care of the light and she said, I will.
I will, I will one up that.
I will do even more.
She said, I will become the first woman ever to do all the things.
Isn't she amazing?
So she like did the damn thing.
Hell in the guest.
The community was totally behind her.
Amazing.
Which is just really cool.
Wow, I love this and I feel like it's gonna get so sad and creepy.
It gets really sad, but no one is like evil in this.
Yeah.
Everyone, and we'll get to it at the end, but like people who go to see this place, there's
definitely some heaviness because there's a lot of tragedy.
Of course.
But nothing feels unwelcoming or angry people say.
All right.
Nothing feels like malignant.
Yeah.
Well, because it seems like, I mean, obviously,
we're at the beginning, but the two people,
or the one person who has passed away
seemed like a great guy.
Well, and everybody who ran this place
seems like they loved it.
Right.
And then the people who take care of it now
really love it.
So they're like, there's just a lot of like
care put into this place.
That's the thing.
And I think it comes out. The energy you put into your house.
So the place you live is the energy you get back.
Exactly.
Now next we have William Harn.
He became head lighthouse keeper after all of that.
Now he had a lot of military service and then he moved to Charleston actually where he worked
on a light ship before coming head, coming head keeper of the St. Augustine Lighthouse in 1864. So he
was right after Maria's turn as head lighthouse keeper. He moved there with his wife Kate
and their five daughters, Ruby, Molly, Catherine, Charlotte, and Ida. Eventually they would
have a six daughter named Grace, adorable. So he's got Ruby, Molly, Catherine, Charlotte,
Ida, and Grace. I love.
And it auto corrected to grave.
And I was like, the young is about to be like,
graves so metal.
But he was the head keeper of this lighthouse for 14 years,
dang, tragically though, he suffered from tuberculosis.
And in 1889, he passed away from it.
And he passed away in the actual keeper's home on the property.
So during his illness, his wife Kate took over everything.
She ran the lighthouse.
There's a lot of bad bitches in this.
A bad bitch is a plenty.
Yeah.
This is like a real like, the women are just taken over.
And it seems like it's like all equal and awesome.
Yeah.
She helped with the keeper duties while raising the children
and also taking care of William.
There was like 86 kids. Yeah. After his death, the community rallied right around her too,
and they signed a petition to have her appointed as the lighthouse keeper.
Dude, do you feel like that was like Maria and like-
I feel like Maria was pushing that over this.
Yes.
And she was actually given the second keeper position, and another keeper was moved into the head position
But she's still second keeper. Lame of them to not give her the head keeper position
Well, and still really cool that the community rallied around her like they did. Yeah, that's really cool
so
We have him who died in the house and then we have like another cool like boss story. Yeah, boss bitch
But then September 24th 1894. We're gonna that the next headkeeper had moved into his spot.
That guy was Joseph Ranthia.
His wife ended up dying in the keeper's home.
Yeah, we got to.
Yeah, it's unknown how we think it's just an illness
or something happened.
There's no murder involved.
There's no anything pretty easier sensational.
It was the 1800s.
It was natural losses because she was 25.
Exactly, because she was just a person.
Yeah.
Now, he was the keeper, the head keeper for 12 years.
OK, so people really love this job.
They stick around for a while.
They do.
Now, in 1873, a truly harrowing tragedy
happened at St. Augustine Lighthouse.
This is where it gets bleak.
During this time, there was a massive amount
of construction being done on the lighthouse. They were renov it gets bleak. During this time, there was a massive amount of construction
being done on the lighthouse. They were renovating some of it. A man named Hezekiah Pitti lived on
the grounds of the lighthouse and took the job as superintendent of lighthouse construction. He and
his wife Mary had five children, four daughters, and one son. In order to make things move smoother,
a system was created for construction.
The workers used a railway cart to bring the supplies to and from wherever they needed to go.
This cart ran a path from the lighthouse construction site all the way down to the water
where the ships carrying all the supplies would come in.
The cart would travel down this path.
It would be stopped by one single piece of wood that acted like a makeshift gate
to keep the cart from flying into the water when it was on the path.
Right.
And it worked because this cart was going down to the water empty at all times.
Yeah.
And then returning the other way, full.
But that wasn't always the case.
Oh.
You see, kids in the area like to use this as a ride.
Yeah, what the hell is for the kids to do?
Not a lot else to do.
They would hop in this nice, you know, this once it was empty, they
would hop in at the construction site and would ride it down the path to the water, only
to be stopped by that all important wooden board at the end. Uh-huh. They loved it, seemed
like an assent fund to the adults because 1800s. Right. You know, now on July 10th, 1873, 15
year old Mary Pitti,
13-year-old Eliza Pitti, and four-year-old Carrie Pitti,
were in the cart with a friend who was never named,
but has said to have been about 10 years old,
and they believe that she might have been the daughter
of a worker, one of the construction workers.
They took the ride down without knowing
the wooden makeshift gate was lifted
from the last supply trip.
Oh, no.
And I'd just never been placed back down.
So the cart flew directly into the water and it flipped over on top of the girls
and basically pinned them underwater.
Oh my god.
A worker named Dan Session, a construction worker, saw this,
ran as fast as he could to save them.
I mean, he like lifted that cart up.
He pulled them out himself like
hero status with his bare hands, but three of the four girls had drowned by the time
he had grabbed them.
Only four-year-old Carrie lived.
Oh, wow.
Yeah, the other three had died.
Now the entire project was stopped.
The entire town of St. Augustine completely shut down for the memorials and funerals.
So sad. And so that is a huge tragedy that occurred on this land. Right outside of the lighthouse. That's direct tide in the water. So we're going to keep up, remember, we're going to keep all
these tragedies in mind, and then we're going to connect them back to some paranormal shit.
Okay. But then in 1901, a man named Peter Rasmussen took over. That's who the listener, Taylor Liana, was talking about.
Cigars and manners.
Yep.
Took over as the headlight housekeeper, and he is actually the longest running keeper.
He did it for 23 years.
Wow.
I told you, people love this job.
They do.
Now, like we said, Peter also, aside from loving cigars and loving to be like hate tourists
and like being very strict, he loved good fancy shit
He loved smoking the best cigars, but he was super cranky
No visitors and staff. Well, I don't think he was like a bad guy. I think he was just strict strict guy
Have you ever seen the movie Grumpy Old Men? Yeah, he's just grumpy guy. They're all like that now visitors and staff will distinctly
smell cigar smoke. When they go into the lighthouse keepers' home and grounds,
like Liana said, she smelled smoke,
and it ain't easy being weasy, she knows smoke.
She's asthmatic, so she could smell it.
And that is something that all the staff say they smell
all the time, very distinct cigar smoke.
Oh, man.
The guys and our family love to have a cigar.
Well, they're together and the freaking odor
that they come back inside with.
It's very distinct, too.
It is.
That's you know some cigar smoke.
It's like a musky.
Yeah.
It's just like very you know it.
Yeah.
They also, people will see a man in a suit in the basement of the keeper's home walking
around and causing people to feel anxious.
Oh.
And they believe it looks like Resmiessen and it in an economy sense that he would make people feel anxious because
he's very strict and they're like, I'm underdressed. And like
Leanna said, he did not like when people wore hats indoors.
Gentlemen, don't wear your hats. So I think he's two. He just has a
vibe that's like, don't fuck up around me. I mean, I feel like
I would strive to impress him. Yeah, I would. You know what I mean?
Like, I feel like I could make him my good old buddy. Yeah, I think I would. I think you would too.
I absolutely love the look of false lashes. They instantly give my eyes like more definition,
more drama. They make me feel sassy, you know? But I don't love how hard they are to apply sometimes,
or how messy lash glue can be if you make a mistake,
I've literally glued my eye closed once
like I'm not joking you.
And plus for me, it's too much of a hassle
to put them on every single day.
That is why I am freaking stoked
about today's sponsor, Roaderm.
Roaderm offers access to a clinically proven eyelash growth serum for people who want longer,
thicker, darker lashes.
And if this treatment is right for you, you can get it prescribed online.
The results speak volumes.
In a 16-week clinical trial, eyelashes grew by 25% in length, 106% in fullness, and 18%
in darkness.
To get your prescription eyelash growth serum,
all you have to do is complete a free online visit
and answer standard questions
about your eye, health, and medical history.
After you submit your information,
a road-derm affiliated healthcare provider
will get back to you within 48 hours.
And if prescribed, your eyelash growth serum
will be delivered to your door with free two-day shipping. There's no need for an in-person appointment, and
you always have the option to message your provider with questions, which makes it so
convenient. Right now, if prescribed, new members will receive 10% off eyelash growth serum
from roadderm. When you go to roadderm.com, forward slash morbid. Shipping is free, and you'll
get free, unlimited follow-ups with your healthcare provider
To support you throughout your eyelash growth journey roderum.com forward slash morbid
So you heard it here first. We're gonna make Peter rest me sin our good old buddy. You can sit with us Peter. Yeah, you can
It's fine. I meet Peter at the boat. I get being cranky.
I get it.
Sorry if you can hear my chair moving.
I'm like moving a lot.
Sorry if you can hear my chair moving.
I'm like moving a lot.
I'm like that.
There's a lot of movement.
I'm like moving here.
I'm moving a little bit.
My chair is like, squeaky and yours is like not.
I know.
Yeah, my nose on you're right.
Because I'm moving around and I don't hear it. My husband, you're right. Because I'm moving around.
And I don't hear it. I have like a farting chair. You have a gassy chair. Yeah. She has
ebbs. I was about to say it, but I was like, I'll let you say it. I'm always gonna. I'm not
gonna out your ebbs more than you already do. Peter would hate this conversation. Oh,
Peter would be hard. Oh, no, maybe we wouldn't make him work. I don't think old buddy. He
would want to think of how often we burp. Yeah. He would not want to be our friend. Oh, no, maybe we would make him I don't think old buddy would want to think of how often we perp. Yeah, he would not want to be our friend
Man, sorry Peter and I do love a hat
It's true. I do love a hat, but I personally feel as though indoors. It's bad luck
So oh there you go. Mm-hmm. There's a lot of bad luck stuff. There is I can have you make a list
I can do so because I feel like I commit a lot of these
Treasonous acts that are gonna get you.
Luck gonna get me got you.
So, now, luck, now, luck, now, luck.
Well, let's get to the last light housekeeper.
You know, shall we?
Let's get to him.
We shall.
He manned the lighthouse from 1953 to 1955
when it became automated.
Oh, wow.
Oh.
His name was James Pippen.
Every, yeah, is this the audition for Pippen? Is this the audition for Pippen? Every lighthouse keeper
lived on site in the keeper's home during their time at the post and James did as well,
but he eventually moved out of that home, an off site, which was never done before. I
feel like that defeats the purpose of being the keeper.
Well, he said the reason was that he said,
quote, that big house was haunted
and I will not stay another night in it.
Ooh, so he was like, fuck that, no way.
He said he would hear maddening footsteps
all night upstairs, but no one was there.
And he said he just couldn't stand it anymore.
It just felt like people were walking around everywhere.
I hate that.
Now, I mentioned before that after that last lighthouse keeper,
like we said right now, that light became automated.
So now the lighthouse keeper's home was rented out
because they didn't need to use it anymore.
A man who was a leather crafter was renting it in the 1960s.
He later reported that one night he woke up
and he saw a little girl wearing a
lace dress standing next to his bed just staring at it. Get out of my room. And he said
he shot up to look at her and she just closed her eyes and vanished. Well thank you for
getting out of my room. She got out of it. She was like, sorry. She just closed her eyes
and left. Just closed her eyes and vanished. Oh check it. Honestly, what a superpower
I know you're just uncomfortable and you're like, oh, and I'm gone and poop. Bye. Yeah, she was out of there
She was like, oh sorry sorry to me to wake you. I don't know. She's like a little creepy
She's watching you sleep and then she's like, oh you woke up. No fun. Well, that's kind of what kids do though
It makes sense. I guarantee you that was like a poor year old or something
Well, you'll just wake up and your kids just standing there
and they're like, mama, mama, like just staring at you.
And you'll open your eyes like, what?
Ah.
And they just like, yeah, they're weird.
That's actually true.
Your kid slept at my house not that long ago
and I woke up to one of them just at the foot of my bed
like needing something and I was like, what the fuck?
What the fuck?
I was like, whoa, that's what kids do.
They freak you out in the middle of the night.
They do.
So I believe it.
Now, there's a ton of activity in the basement
of the keeper's home.
And up to this day, and since 1955,
people have reported it.
And there are stories that a man may have hanged himself
down there.
That's the only like real like, oh, like, you know what I mean?
But I didn't find any newspaper articles about this.
But again, it could have been a long time ago and some of that stuff
just wasn't reported. Yeah. So, but it is a story that is often told in the reason why there's a
lot of activity down there. They also think that maybe the kids like to play down there, and that's
why there's a lot of activity with the kids. Like they're still playing in the afterlife. Yeah. And we'll
get to that because they definitely are still playing in the afterlife. Awesome. Now, in the living room slash sitting room area, staff will often hear an older man coughing
in the evenings when the place is completely empty.
That would drive you insane.
It would make me crazy.
Elena fucking hates the sound of a cough.
Oh, coughing.
And loud sneezes, slurps, slurps, sniffs.
I have like a real issue with sound.
You have me so phony.
I really do, because that it would make me absolutely baddy.
No, I could not have lived.
No, we've said, you know, and you're really talking,
but something I'm like, I need to cough now.
I know, I almost, I'm like, I have to clear my throat now.
Oh, look, clear my throat.
Now, they think this might be William Hahn,
who died of tuberculosis in the home.
It makes sense.
It reads.
It does, it really does, because I mean, consumption, I'm literally due to cough a lot,
and cough up lead, and awful things.
So sorry.
And he would spend a lot of time in the sitting room being taken care of, and when he was
like, ailing.
So it kind of makes sense.
I hate that he's still sick in the afterlife.
I know, it's kind of a bummer that you just like perpetually cough.
Or do you think maybe, I don't know, I don't want to get too theological with afterlife. I know, it's kind of a bummer that you just like perpetually cough. Or do you think maybe,
I don't know, I don't want to get too theological
with it, oh good, get with it.
I like, do you think that like certain parts
of your energy like stay somewhere
but other parts of your energy go off?
Yeah, like maybe he's off somewhere
but his like coughing is just
yeah, because you will hear these stories
like I've read a little bit about like people just
in a like perpetual loop.
Right.
Right.
Like if somebody fell off a building,
they're just perpetually in a loop
of falling off that building.
Oh, fuck that.
And it's like, is the person in a loop
a foreign actor?
Or is their energy in that loop?
Right.
And is it all of their energy?
Because their energy didn't have other things
while they were on this like earthly place.
Yeah, it's like, are they really defined by that energy
at the end of their life?
Or are they, because that's the thing
that ended their life?
Oh, God, but then, like, oh no.
Yeah, I don't know.
Because I think of people that got brutally murdered,
they just get brutally murdered in the afterlife forever.
I don't know.
That's horrific.
I don't know, I don't,
because there's all kinds of,
I think there's all kinds of different like spiritual
Like energies and how they present themselves. I read things about like perpetual loops like that where you'll hear the same thing over and over again Yeah, but I just it's very complicated
Well, and then is that like somebody in like a perpetual loop or did they have unfinished business?
And that's why they're in that loop. Does it need to be broken somehow?
Oh, fuck you know, I'm a much unfinished business., like, all the right, you, I'm like, I can't die yet.
I can't die, I have to finish filing my taxes, you know?
I do.
I do need to do that.
My dad.
My dad is hastily approaching.
It is a loom and can you say hastingly?
No, you can.
I was gonna try to keep it to you.
Heastily, thanks.
Hastily, yeah.
Approaching with haste.
All right, I'm listening.
With my haste.
I need to learn basic robotics before I die.
You've got it.
Unfinished business.
We'll get you there.
No.
People will also see a woman at the top of the observation deck
in a long white night gown with her hair flowing.
And they believe this is, this is Joseph Andrews wife Maria
Oh, I will manning that light asking him what she should do. We're going. I need to meet the fucking legend
That is for you. I need to meet my I would just say to her you bad bitch. Yeah, and then I would explain
That's a good thing now. Yeah, that is a good thing. Now like let me preface this by saying yeah
I'm about to say is is the highest form of complement
one can bestow upon me.
Right.
And then say, you bad bitch.
You bad bitch, you are totally rufus.
You are rufus.
Spread it around like wildfire.
So a guest who went there because you can still go there,
you can take these tours.
I'll link it because it seems like a really cool place
to go.
The people who run it seem like they really care about it.
And they run a really cool place there.
So I want everybody to give them as much business
as they can if they can.
Now, a guest was walking up the staircase,
like ready to start a tour.
And suddenly they almost tripped.
And they were like, oh, what the fuck?
And they looked down and their shoelace was tied to the railing. Oh my God. And they were like, oh, what the fuck? And they looked down and their shoelace
was tied to the railing.
Oh my God.
And they were like,
they clearly didn't do that themselves.
There was no explanation for it.
No one on the tour could account for how it happened.
There were other people on the tour
that were like, I didn't see anybody do that.
Like it was like one of the little kids.
And they think it might have been one of the little kids
because that's a very much a little kid thing to do,
to be like, yeah, I'm too naive and young
to know that you could fall to your desk by me doing this.
Or plot twist, was that person wearing a hat?
Maybe, was it Peter Resmiu said,
you're saying, you're gonna learn a lesson today.
You are gonna learn today.
I don't know.
Either way, you can also hear giggling a lot.
They hear that little girl's giggling.
They hear it, staff members here at visitors will hear it. That just like reminds me of the Blair Witch project when they're in the
tent that one scene. And it scares the fucking day hates that part. Because it and you
see like the little hands on it. And you hear like kids like. No, I hate that shit.
No, look at my arm. Look at my arm. That's I have goosebumps. I hate that part. I hate that shit. No, look at my arm. Look at my arm. That's, I have goosebumps. Oh, I hate that part.
I hate that whole movie.
Fucks me up, man.
It fucks me up, man.
It does.
It really does.
It does.
No, staff members will say that often they hear giggling
at the top of the tower.
And they'll go up to check.
Marie is so long.
I hope that's not an actual child up like 219, like,
stairs up there.
Oh, yeah, usually. 219 like stairs up there.
Yeah, usually so they'll head up there and as they get up there,
they don't hear it anymore. And then all of a sudden,
they hear it down at the bottom and they go down to the bottom.
They hear it at the top. So they're just like fucking with that.
That kid just wants you to get your cardio.
Yeah, they're like, you know what? Heart Health is important.
Honestly. So the owners and staff, yeah, right.
The owners and the staff think that this is definitely
the pity girls and their friends like playing hide and seek.
Cute.
They'll also lock and unlock doors.
Not so cute.
And doors that are very hard to push open
will like slam open or slam shut for no reason.
Like they can't be blown by the wind.
This is just like a force is actually doing.
That's wild.
Now during another tour, visitors in a guide used an EMF reader to ask the girls if they wanted
to play hide and seek. And they got really intense readings and walked around trying to
like play along with them. Now apparently they were like walking around being like, are you over
here? Like I'm going to find you like pretending to act like you would with a kid. And apparently they
found that it was spiking again
under the staircase.
And so they pretended to find them,
but they found you, then the reading dropped,
and then they found it again by the kid's play table.
So it was like they were like found you,
and they were like, aha, and they ran somewhere else.
Like it worked out, and it only stopped
when more guests arrived in that area.
And then they were eating stocked.
Because they didn't want to do it in front of everybody.
Oh my goodness.
Now this next one gave me chills.
The whole fucking thing is giving me chills.
So there are times when people on tours will see a young girl
and they'll talk to her and then they find that she vanishes.
They either look behind them and look back and she's gone
or she's just not there all of a sudden.
You don't understand how badly I want to talk to a ghost kid, right?
And I want to not know, and then later find out that I had the combo with a ghost kid.
Yeah, I want to not know as it's happening.
Right.
Now often these girls are wearing period clothing, and people think they're just in costume
like at a tour or something.
But one time during a tour, a woman walked up to another woman on the tour
and was like, your daughter is so adorable
and she was so well behaved.
Like, I just wanted to tell you,
like she was just like being like a really cool
woman complimenting another woman.
Which I was like, fuck yeah.
Cause she just, right?
She walked up to her and was just like,
your daughter is just so well behaved.
Like, I just wanted to tell you like, great job.
Great job, Mama.
And this woman was like, wow, that's really nice of you to say but I don't have a daughter
Oh, fuck and she was like what I'm not sure what you're talking about not only was she like my daughter's not here today
She was just like I straight up don't have a daughter. I love that she took the time to say thanks first
She was like that's super nice. Thank you so much
Like I'm all about women supporting women and like mom supporting moms and like that was really cool of you to do
But and like continue to do that with other people
But I don't have a daughter
So the woman who had complimented her was like, oh, I'm sorry
There was a little girl standing next to you this entire tour and she was being so well behaved and the other guests confirmed
This as well. They were like yeah, we saw that little girl and the woman was shocked
It was like I don't have a child. It was like, I don't have a child.
Oh my god.
I don't have a child with me.
And it was later confirmed with records
that no child had been present on that particular tour
or any tour going on at that time.
Which I'm vibrating out here.
Yes.
So that one freaked me out the most that it was like,
there was a little girl standing with you the whole time
and she was like, excuse me.
Oh my goodness.
They also found footprints in the dirt
of a little kid with bare feet.
Fucking the dirt.
But no children were on the grounds
and the footprints just vanished into the keeper's house.
That's so cute.
Yeah, I feel like a lot of people would not have that reaction
to that statement, but I think that's adorable.
Like a little barefooted ghost kids.
Just be like, dude, I'm just gonna go in first.
Just gonna play some hide and seek.
I'm gonna hang out on this tour
and see what they say about me. I know. I'm just gonna see how this goes. They're just gonna play some hide and seek. I'm gonna hang out on this tour and see what they say about me.
I know.
I'm just gonna see how this goes.
They're probably like,
why are these people dressed like so cheesy?
So weird.
They look horrible.
No, people around the lighthouse and visitor staff,
this is a little scarier.
They hear horrifying screams daily and nightly here.
Awesome.
And in fact, it has happened so often
and the screams are so intense
that the police have been called a lot because people think someone's being like injured or hurt.
I love that at one point you were like, nobody feels like it's like, you're level-in.
Well, it's totally fine. Everyone feels happy.
Here's the thing, it's true. I will stand by that still. This they are attributing to Joseph Andrews fall. That's what I was thinking.
And the fact that his screams were hurt so far away,
but you're right, like, it's not a great thing,
but it's not something like that.
I think people feel it's gonna hurt them.
Yeah.
But it's just like sad.
That's more than anything.
Yeah.
Is that like you hear this like painful scream all the time?
Right, because you're like, is that just happening?
Like you're not saying.
You're not just gonna like let it go.
No.
Like they would have us believe happened
in the Kitty Genoves case.
They would just even, but you're not just gonna be like,
oh, someone else will take care of that.
You've got to call and be like,
hey, I don't know what's going on,
but I hear some shit.
Like, you should probably check it out.
Don't, don't fall for the, for the bystander effect.
Yeah, don't do that.
But Shane and Ryan from Buzzfeed Unsolved came here
in 2019.
Are like character parts.
It's a great episode.
Yeah, because you were showing clips.
It's really good.
And Ryan was very excited about going into this place, like as he should be.
When they were in the parlor, I thought it was really interesting.
They distinctly heard a man cough and they got it on tape.
Yeah, I heard that one.
It's spooky as fuck.
And is it Ryan who tries to explain it away?
No, that was Shane.
That was like, yeah.
He's explaining it away a little bit.
And I was like, I don't know, man.
I was on Ryan's side.
I will say, even Shane couldn't really explain this one away.
He tried to and he's usually pretty successful
at making me be like, oh, you're right.
Yeah, but counterparts.
This one?
No, I was on the cough.
It was a cough.
It was with Ryan. I was like, that was a was on the car. It was a car with Ryan.
I was like, that was a car.
It was.
That was a man's car.
And they were sitting in the living room,
like parlor area.
Right.
It was crazy.
And also just to leave you on this,
they did have a ghost hunters episode
on this location, also in 2019, actually.
And they set up REM pods on each level of the lighthouse.
And a REM pod are like little
electromagnetic field readers. So anytime like there's an ambient temp change
and an energy field disturbance, it will set them off. You'll hear beeping and
like lights. Very cool. And as they went up the spiral staircase, they all started
going off together. And they were responding to questions. And there's also
footage of a huge bang
coming from the top of the stairs,
when no one else was in it.
A huge bang forced me the fuck out
because that used to happen at Mon Puppet House.
Like from time to time.
Yeah, that's scary to me.
It sets my whole body on like a flame.
It just, I sporadically combust every time it happens.
It's really scary.
Despite the tons of paranormal activity they found,
Grant Wilson, who's like one of the ghost hunter guys,
he said he felt safe.
He didn't feel any malice from any of it,
which makes sense because it's all either, you know,
tragic accidents or keepers who just loved that lighthouse
and seemed not to want to leave it.
And he actually told Kelsey Lloyd,
who is the special programs manager at the Lighthouse
that he believed it's becoming more and more active
each time they visit,
because he said it just keeps getting more
and more each time they're there.
He said that's because he thinks the people
who run that Lighthouse love the building,
they love and appreciate the history,
and they love and appreciate and respect the people
who called it home for so long.
So they said, I think the spirits feel safe here and they feel like they can't let themselves
out.
Which is like a really nice thing because you're like, wow, it's nice that it's being
taken care of by people who want to like respect the history and show it.
Yeah.
That was like so scary and beautiful.
Yeah.
And that's the same Augustine lighthouse.
Much like yourself.
Very beautiful.
Very beautiful.
Wow.
The ultimate compliment. You're welcome. Thank you. Wow, I really liked that one because that one was like very wholesome.
It was. It really made me like, I was like, I can't stop one stop and there's also just so much
history with it. There it is. I want to go. It made me feel like, not because I felt bad for all
these like tragedies that happened there. But it also made me feel like, wow, like these keepers
really love to the fucking lighthouse. Yeah. Like I was like like damn. I love that. It's just like a nice
thought. Um, mine are not as like wholesome at all. In fact, my first lighthouse is called execution
rock's lighthouse. I love that. It's in Long Island. Sure. And if you don't say Long Island
has been your wrong. Long Island. Long Island. Long Island. We went through a period the other day where we just couldn't stop saying that.
So the execution rock's lighthouse. I'm going to tell you about it. I love it.
It is smack dab in the middle of New Rochelle City and Sand's Point Village in Long Island.
Long Island. Long Island. Long Island. And it was built in 1849. And this is a fun fact.
Designed by a man named Alexander
Paris. Does that sound familiar? Yes it does. He fun fact designed Boston's
Quincy Market. I know that sounded familiar. When I was reading and I was like
Alexander Paris, who why do I know that name? Is he I wonder if he's related to
Reverend Samuel Paris from the Salem should. Should Google that. I should.
I'm gonna look that up, because all of a sudden,
I was like, wait a second.
It's for in Boston.
Double R.
It might be.
Oh my gosh, imagine.
I'll send it.
I'll wait Paris.
I'll send it, Hamilton.
Samuel.
Samuels.
Paris.
Samuel.
Paris.
Are you bros?
Are you related?
Let's see.
We're just on like ancestry.com. We're going to check.
BRB.
All right.
There is an Alexander Paris that is related to him.
Okay.
I'll look deeper into this and I'll let you know.
Okay.
Cool.
Very interesting question.
Yeah.
So yeah, Alexander Paris built this light house
and built more than just Boston Quincy's market.
He built a few other things.
He built some stuff.
He was an architect, so things and some building.
They do be building.
But it wasn't until about like 20 years later
that the Keeper's house was built right next to the lighthouse itself.
And before that, the keeper of the lighthouse
would just sleep in the actual lighthouse itself.
That's amazing.
For me, I feel like that sounds like one of the scariest
things ever.
100% it does.
And not only because this place is haunted,
but because it's literally just in the middle of the ocean
on a wall in desolate Asylens surrounded by scary rocks
named execution rocks.
Yeah.
I also just generally live by the rule
that if there's like not a target nearby,
it's not the homestead for me.
And I doubt there's a target nearby. There wasn't, no. I don't think in 1849. No, really not.
Yeah, I don't know. So you had to be like, it goes without saying, a brave ass human to decide to be the keeper of this lighthouse.
And because of the reputation of this area was like so haunted and fucking precarious. It was actually the first case
in which the US Lighthouse board allowed the keeper to take the job without signing a contract.
Wow. Yeah. The book Spookyest Lighthouses by Terence Zepke I think it is
suggested that this was because quote, the only way to entice applicants was to let them know they
could leave whenever they wanted. Oh my god! Like they were like, so we would love for you to stay and take care of this light
house but we do understand that it is a desolate and scariest fuck and also a
little bha-hanta.
Little bha-hanta.
So you don't have to sign the dotted line.
Like so you know what?
You leave whenever you want.
Yeah.
You are not bound here.
Yeah so they're, you're sitting there and you're like okay it's haunted but like why
do they need the option to leave like whenever they yeah literally in the middle of the night
Because this lighthouse is incredibly haunted
What do us news PC magazine and popular science have in common they all ranked Simply Save Home Security as the best home security of 2021.
In fact, US News just named Simply Save the best home security system of 2022 as well.
And Ashkel also named it the best ever because I'm obsessed with my Simply Save.
In fact, while we were recording this episode, I got this notification that said somebody
was at my friend's door,
and I said, who the hell is at my friend's door?
And then it turns out it's just my male lady,
and I love her.
So I was like, hey girl, thanks for the male.
That's the other thing.
You can talk to the people,
through your little door knob video thing.
I love it.
Simply safe protects your whole entire home around the clock.
Every door, every window, and room.
It's backed by the best 24-7 professional monitoring
in the business, and they're ready to dispatch police,
firefighters, or EMTs to your home.
With a comprehensive set of sensors and cameras,
including the all-new wireless outdoor security camera,
which I personally have in love,
you always know what's going on inside
and outside of your home.
Literally, we'll be like sitting in the living room watching TV at night and I hear
a noise and I'm like, what the fuck was that?
And then I'm like, oh wait, I can literally just look at my camera and find out that that
was probably a raccoon and not a burglar.
A burglarer.
Yeah, that's right.
Simply safe as less than a dollar a day and you can set it up in around like 30 minutes.
It's really simple to use.
It didn't even take me 30 seconds to, it took me a lot more than 30 seconds. It didn't even take me 30 seconds to it took me a lot more than 30 seconds
It didn't even take me 30 minutes though is what I meant to say
There's a customer in the lane 30 seconds didn't even take me that long
There's never a long-term contract you can even try it for 60 days risk-free to see if you like it
And if you know send it back free of charge simply save protects over a million homes in the United States alone.
You can customize the perfect system for your home
in just a few minutes at simplysafe.com slash morbid.
Go today and claim a free indoor security camera
plus 20% off with interactive monitoring.
Go to simplysafe.com slash morbid.
Dude, life is so freaking busy.
You got work, you got to like clean your house. if you don't want to live in a pig's die.
You have groceries to buy if you want to eat and feed yourself.
It's like so much to do.
At the end of what can feel like an endless work day, the last thing I want to do is cook
dinner.
I'm like, no.
In fact, I just texted Drew.
What are we making for dinner?
And he said, how about daily harvest?
Because when your fridge is empty, the urge to order in and skip the cooking happens all too often.
But thanks to daily harvest,
I don't have that take-out temptation anymore.
Daily harvest helps me keep my freezer fully stocked
with options that are delivered right to my door.
They're delicious, nourishing,
and the best part is that they're ready within minutes.
Daily harvest delivers delicious harvest bowls, soups, flatbread snacks,
smoothies, lattes, cookie bites, and more,
built on organic fruits and vegetables.
Daily Harvest has delicious options for any time of day.
You got breakfast, lunch, dinner, snacks, dessert.
Everything is always on hand in your freezer
and ready to enjoy when you need it.
I am obsessed with daily harvest.
They have this fricking smoothie that tastes like it's ice with daily harvest. They have this freaking smoothie.
That tastes like it's ice cream. It's the strawberry and peach smoothie. I swear to god, I feel like
I'm eating breakfast, dessert. It's so good. And then at dinner, I just actually recently tried
the tomato and basil flatbread. And my mouth is actually starting to water. Like I'm going to have
to swallow my spit in a minute because I really want that it is absolutely delectable. See I had to swallow my
spit. With daily harvest I never have to question if the food I'm eating is good
for me. They create food that is both good for my health and the health of the
planet. I love that. By supporting farmers who invest in practices that
increase biodiversity and improve the health of our soil and delivering food
and recyclable and compostable packaging.
Daily Harvest does the work, so all you have to do is eat, and we all know I'm good at that, so thanks a lot, Daily Harvest.
By the way, new on the scene is their delicious harvest bakes, for those moments when you're looking for like homemade feels without any of the work.
They are ready to bake, veggie packed dishes, sizzling with gourmet level flavors that are
big enough to share, but like you're not going to want to.
Avoid the takeout temptation and get daily harvest.
Go to dailyharvest.com slash morbid to get up to $40 off your first box.
That's dailyharvest.com slash morbid for up to $40 off your first box.
Dailyharvest.com slash morbid.
It got its name execution rocks because any ship that wrecked onto the rocks would lose all its passengers like right away.
Cool. Because they were just so intense. Like immediately your boat would just be like,
goodbye. Just shattered. Goodbye.
Goodbye. Ciao.
Tata for now. Tata forever.
And over the years, people just started saying that everyone on board was executed by the rocks.
Oh, that's really creepy, but like really metal.
Yeah, both.
Yeah.
Get you a rock who can do both.
Yes, and they did, and they did the damn thing.
I'm also like, I'm sure some of the hauntings
came from the sailors who lost their lives on the rocks.
For sure. But sailors were not the only ones who lost their lives on the rocks.
Rocks, man. Say rocks again. If these rocks could talk, rocks. Back in the day though, the British,
they were like trying to avoid doing public executions because they didn't want to give the colonists
another reason to be all pissed off at them. Yeah, of course. So they decided on this other totally
humane way to, you know, execute those who had broken the law.
And it involves rocks.
And it involves rocks.
And it's super humane.
Yeah.
They would bring the criminals to the rocks surrounding the island during low tide.
Chain them to said rocks.
See where this is going.
And leave them there to wait until the tide would come in and eventually drown them.
Slowly.
Yeah, oh.
Did you buy it?
I want to know how slow.
Yeah.
The whole process of them being drowned would take 10 to 12 hours.
Why?
They would just slowly watch that water rise.
Yeah.
Oh.
And the tide would keep going in and out,
so it would get a little bit closer,
maybe cover your waist, and then go back out again, and then coming even more, and you're starting
to swallow water, so you're drowning as slow as humanly possible.
Curly, so that's not humane.
Curly's that-
It is not humane.
That is not.
You are incorrect.
It was torturous.
And if the whole process itself wasn't torturous enough,
they, like some people said that they would apparently
leave the bodies of the previously executed people there.
Just still chain to the rocks.
I believe that.
In order to just scare the next batch of criminals
that would be brought to their final rest.
Yeah, please.
Like this is what you have to look forward to.
Yeah.
So people who lived nearby would hear the men
like screaming from the beaches.
Oh, God. And it went all hours of the men screaming from the beaches. Oh, God.
And it went all hours of the night.
And still to this day, people report hearing screams
coming from the island in the area of those rocks.
Ah!
Yeah, like that.
Yeah, like that.
Just like that.
Louder, though.
That was like not even in my control.
No, that scream was.
That just came out.
That's all I had.
That was an involuntary movement.
Just then.
Yeah, I don't like it.
That's like...
That's really gnarly.
The most.
That's very gnarly.
You think that's gnarly too?
I do, I'm gonna...
I'm, yes.
It is gnarly.
Yeah.
But we're gonna introduce the character that you know.
So I know that I love...
No.
Okay.
I hope not at least.
Oh no.
Okay, so according to that book that I mentioned earlier,
Spookyest Lighthouses.
Spooky.
There was this psychic and I know how you feel,
but like I think she was on to something.
All right, hey, some of them are.
Yeah.
She visited the lighthouse on one occasion
and she said she felt the spirit of a quote,
aggravated male.
Oh, there was an aggravated male energy in the air.
It was a devilish.
Exactly.
It was like, yeah.
You could just say that. You could say that I like a Tedesque. There's an aggravated male energy in the air. It's a devil-y for. Exactly. You could just say that.
You could say that at like a tidesque.
There's an aggravated male.
Yeah.
So looking into the history of the lighthouse
and the area surrounding it, a lot of people
have come to the conclusion that that man could be someone
we've talked about on the show before, one Carl Pan's Ram.
Stop.
Because he used the ocean surrounding the island
to dispose of a good amount of people that he had murdered.
Yes, when you said execution rock,
for some reason, I remember being like,
why do I know that?
But it just wasn't ringing a bell.
He would literally throw the bodies like
a hundred yards away from the lighthouse.
Holy shit.
Yeah.
Carl.
Freaking Carl.
Pan's Ram. Pan. Holy shit. Yeah. Carl. Freaking Carl.
Pan's...
Ram.
Pan's...
Mania.
Yeah.
Some people are like, okay, it could be Carl definitely.
I mean, he was an aggravated male.
He was an angry spirit.
It's one way to describe him.
So, they're like, it could be Carl, or it could be one of the people who Carl murdered
and then disposed of in the area.
Yeah.
And interestingly enough, people who stayed at the lighthouse say that they feel pressure
on their chests, especially in the living room of the house, I guess.
And Carl Panzerim did strangle a few of his victims.
Yep.
So I wonder if that could have something to do with it.
Oh, if Carl's just hanging out there, just like hurting people still.
I mean, I fully believe that he would do so.
At 100%.
Or it could even be the feeling of not being able to breathe
because of all the people who drowned.
Right.
So while the Coast Guard was running
and caring for the lighthouse before it became automated.
Automated.
Boo to automated light.
Yeah, it's like, come on.
I want it to be a little more.
We need an old wily keeper.
We do.
That's who we need.
So while they were still caring for it,
some members of the Coast Guard who spent the night there
Said that the alarms would go off all the time and they couldn't figure out why and they could never find a source for it
But there were actually two fires that took place in the history of the lighthouse
So I kind of feel like maybe it's the lighthouse itself just trying to keep everybody on their toes. Yeah, it's just like hey you wake
Hey, are you up beyond alert? Hello, Justin Case. So if you are like brave enough
to spend the night at execution rocks like house,
and you know, maybe you want to experience something funky,
you can spend the night.
Okay.
You can spend the night.
It doesn't really sound like a very luxurious experience,
so like keep that in mind.
Keep that in mind.
If you're someone like me, when booking your stay.
Yeah, you have to take, I've saw some people say that the boat ride was 25 minutes
and other people say 45.
So obviously it just depends on where you're taking your boat from.
Yeah.
But you have to be able to like,
enter that boat ride,
be able to climb a ladder onto the island itself.
Okay.
It's literally like you like,
like you like,
like, you pull up.
Yes, like you pull up in your boat
and then you have to like,
reach over to the ladder and study yourself and climb onto the island
Whoa, yeah, like no, thank you and then if you want to go into like the lighthouse
This way you can do so. There's a tiny little passageway that connects the lighthouse to the keeper's house
So you can go through there
I
Want to do that so bad. But I have seen it recommended
in literally every source of the lighthouse
that you have to wear closed toe shoes.
You have to.
I mean, that makes sense.
Also be aware that there's no running water.
Okay, I hate that.
You also need to be prepared
to spend the night on a cot
if you are spending the night.
I mean, all that sounds pretty terrible.
It does, so I would like to make you aware
that day trips are also available.
Okay, I was gonna ask that.
I was like, I would like to do a day trip.
Yeah, maybe you're too scared of the hauntings
or maybe you're like me and you're too scared
of the lack of running water.
Yeah, see, that's where I'm out.
Like, that's where I've checked out of this whole thing,
but like, I'll go at night and do like a ghosty tour
and then be like, bye.
And I think you can.
I thought that they did like this cool, like Halloween boat ride
around the area. Yeah, it was fun. So you can do a day trip, you can do a night trip, you can just do as you please.
It's not that far either.
But please also be aware that according to visitalltheplaces.com, there are cannibalistic seagulls that live on the island,
and there are apparently bird bones all over the place.
And this source visitalltheplaces.com had pictures, like, and there were bones everywhere.
Oh, seagull bones, just everywhere.
Okay, I mean, as, as not a seagull,
I feel okay with that.
Like, I'm like, I don't want, I'm, I'm sorry,
seagulls, but I feel okay.
What if they become like, what if they branch out?
Yeah, what if they branch out?
I'm just like, I'm sick of my own.
What if they eat too many seagulls and then there's none left
and then they have to start eating them at the torus?
I mean, I mean bring a parasol, I suppose.
Yeah, and just whoop whoop.
Choo, choo, choo.
Get out of here.
That's our sounds of fighting off seagull.
You're whoop whoop whoop whoop.
And that's it.
So that's execution rock slide, dude.
Damn, I wanna to go there.
Yeah, it was recommended a lot in the folder where we have it in the Gmail, but nobody had
any experiences there.
Really?
So if you have had an execution rocks experience, I would love to hear about it.
Tell us because we're going to go there at some point.
Yeah, long silence.
It's not that far at all.
How many fucking times have you been to Long Island?
Long Island.
I love a family on Long Island. Long Island. I love Long Island.
I love Long Island.
Hi cousins.
Hello cousins.
I know.
I know who you are.
I hope.
Imagine if somebody was like, I'm your cousin.
I'm, whoa.
23 in me.
I mean, yeah.
I know my cousins, okay.
I know my cousins.
I know most of them.
I know them.
I know them.
I know them whenever.
Cousins, you know what I mean?
Cousins.
It's losing all meaning.
It is.
It's like rocks.
They're rocks again.
So my next lighthouse is Wood Island Lighthouse, and it's in Asako Bay, Maine.
Oh, okay.
We're staying on the east coast.
I like it.
Yeah, I didn't even do that on purpose.
These are places we can easily go to.
I like that.
We could.
So this lighthouse and Keepers home, they were built in 1808 by Benjamin Beale
and Duncan Thaxter.
Yep.
I believe that.
Yeah, yeah.
I was like, I'm for that.
You were born to build things.
Yeah.
Lighthouses especially.
Or maybe not.
Oh.
The original lighthouse was about 45 feet tall
and it stood next to the Keepers house,
which was so fucking small.
I was gonna say.
When it was first built, it was a one-story home with measurements of 17 by 26 feet.
That's tiny. That's a tiny, that's like all you people out there that want tiny homes.
Here you go. That's tiny small. That's tiny small. Close quarters if you will.
Yeah, you got to be real friendly with whoever you live with. Hopefully you just live so low,
no low. Yeah. So the lighthouse itself actually had to be rebuilt
multiple times.
I feel like a lot of them have to.
Yeah, I mean, it makes sense because they're built
in like the 1800s and then next to the sea,
which is like that sea is gonna eat that.
Oh, it's a good thing.
That's how the sea rolls.
Yeah, but this one was built like horribly.
The original builder's work was really bad.
And then the second build was somehow worse than the first.
And just left plaster dripping into the ocean.
Cool, we're learning from our mistakes.
We are, we are totally.
Finally, in about 1854, we did learn from our mistakes.
Cool.
Because that's when the final build took place.
And in the rebuild, they actually attached the keeper's house
to the lighthouse with a covered walkway.
Ooh. So it's very luxurious. I know.
It's for lighthouse vibes.
And eventually in the 1900s, a second story was added to the Keepers House.
Look at that. We're moving up. I know. Luckily, the builder in 1854 knew what he was doing because
it was the last time what island lighthouse needed to be restructured.
Oh. And today, it's known as the second oldest lighthouse in Maine.
Oh, we love to see it.
I know, maybe the next, I don't know if this one is haunted,
but it is the oldest in Maine.
Portland headlight.
Oh, I've heard that, yeah.
Yeah, so hopefully it's haunted.
I'm assuming that's haunted.
We'll look into it right in if you think it is.
Yeah, have you been there?
Yeah, I don't know.
So throughout the years, the lighthouse
has had more than 200 keepers. Whoa. But one of the most famous keepers, I said
famous. It's hard, it's hard. Yeah. One of the most famous keepers. It's famous. Is Thomas
Orkut, Orkut, Orkut? And he served as keeper from 1886 to 1905. Wow, look at him. Turned
to the century. He started almost 80 years after the Lighthouse
was originally built and he moved on to the island with his little dog, Sailor. Yeah, he did.
He did. And in 1873, a fog bell tower was built near the Lighthouse, and a 1300 pound bell was
placed inside. Damn. Thomas's dog, Sailor, somehow learned to ring the bell for himself.
And even though there was an automated way for the bell to ring, Sailor was like us,
and he was like, I'd like to keep it old school, please.
Yeah.
And he was like, I'm working in the Slight House.
He became the famous bell ringer.
Oh my God, stop.
That's precious.
Any time a ship would pass and sound off, Sailor would do the same in return.
That's precious.
Yeah.
Oh my God, can you imagine if you sound off when you come in and hear that bell ring, and you're like, thanks, Sailor. It's Sailor would do the same in return. That's precious. Oh my god can you imagine if you like sound off when you come in
You hear that bell ringing you like thanks sailor. It's sailor. He became famous. They were like multiple newspaper articles about it.
I know. Good for sailor. I know. Got it man. So Thomas Orca was still serving as the keeper in the late 1890s
When the island's most famous tragedy took place. Uh-oh, so I'm gonna tell you a little story.
Tell me a story.
In 1896, there were two 24-year-old guys living in a shack
on the opposite side of the island.
It was a pretty big island.
The shack was really supposed to be used as like a den for hens,
but the man who owned the structure, Frederick Millican,
knew that these two men named Howard Hobbes and William Moses were just
like having hard time.
So he was like, you know what?
Why don't you just live there, just pay me like a small amount and rent and like just
don't be dicks.
Don't be dicks, right?
Yeah, truly all I have to ask.
And Frederick was like a business kind of guy.
He was an officer and also a game warden.
And he lived on the island in his own home.
Now his home in the little shack where where Hobbes and Moses lived, those were the only two buildings on the island,
other than the lighthouse and the keeper's house. And like I said, they were on
opposite sides of the 35 acre island. Oh, so this is fucking huge. Yeah. So on Sunday,
May 31st, 1896, William and Howard had spent the day drinking at Old
Orchard, which is hilarious because that was going on in
1896 and is still happening
It's gonna say it doesn't feel different like I've gone drinking at a little snapshot. I know weird
I'm like that's crazy
So they got to that point where their drinking was making them act to fool and at one point the sheriff in Old Orchard
Actually detained them. Oh, they're really actually. Oh, they were actually fool with a
capital F. Yeah. So the sheriff detained them and they're like, we're going to put you
in the drunk tank if you don't get your shit together. Yeah.
Somehow they were able to convince the sheriff that they would like clean their act up.
But fine. But they didn't. No. They spent the night in Old Orchard and spent most of the next
day in Old Orchard as well drinking the day away.
Oh, I feel sick just listening to this.
I know, honestly, but they probably at that point
needed like some hair of the dog.
Yeah.
So by the late afternoon, they were ready to make their way back home.
They hopped in their small boat and they headed toward Wood Island.
And when they got back to the island,
they ran into their landlord, Frederick Milliken.
And they owed him some money.
And they're acting a fool. And they're acting a fool.
And they're acting a fool, which is of no interest.
To Frederick.
No, no, no.
I'm not interested.
I'm not interested.
So they passed by and Milliken told Howard Hobbs
that he needed to speak with him later on.
I think William Moses seemed to be doing our right
with his rent, but it was really Howard Hobbs.
That was like not killing it with the rent game.
Come on Hobbs.
Yeah, it's like don't keep buying beer.
You're not okay for your hand, Den.
Yeah.
Okay.
You sure do.
So Hobbs and Moses acknowledged Milliken and they were like,
yeah, we'll be out in just a minute.
Like we're just gonna go pee, I guess.
We're gonna go do those things.
Yeah.
So first they wanted to drop off their stuff at home and Hobbs wanted to grab
his rifle so that they could do some bird hunting.
So Moses knew that Hobbes had
been drinking all day and he was still pretty drunk. So he was like, maybe you should like leave
that gun behind because you're like shit faced. Yeah. And Hobbs was like, I'm fine. Direct quote.
It is. I took that from a newspaper. Yep. You delivered it beautifully. Thank you so much.
You're welcome. I worked on it. I knew you did I could tell and he's tough
He took his rifle with him. He did after his war on
Yeah, of course he did he wasn't gonna leave that rifle
He said it. I heard it playing his day. He did. He said I'm taking this with me
Yeah, and then he said I'm gonna hunt some birds. Yeah, so they walk back over to our millikens place and he notices the gun
And he's like is that loaded because he's like you're not in any position to be carrying around a load of guns.
And he's like, I have a little fucking
terrifying right now.
Yeah.
So Hobbs got within arm's reach as he told Milliken
that the gun was not loaded, but Milliken was like,
let me see that for myself and started to grab the gun away
from him.
And that was not great.
He reached forward.
And as he did so, Hobbs picked up the gun and this is a rifle.
Yeah.
Picked up the gun, does whatever he does with it, and shot Millican, point blank in the chest.
Oh no Hobbs.
And Millican's wife had been standing in the doorway the entire time.
No.
So she, her son and William Moses were now witnesses to a crime. [♪ OUTRO MUSIC PLAYING [♪
The remote hybrid world, when information is just scattered across tools, it's so hard
to have the full context to get your work done, especially when you're working cross-functionally.
No shin, though, provides a home base for your organization
and your team by combining note-taking, document-sharing,
project management, and weekies into one tool,
giving your team's full transparency
into each other's projects and everyday workflows.
For companies of all sizes, Notion provides one central
and customizable workspace that can be tailored
to fit any team and bring all teams together to get more done and move faster.
And if you own a small business or a big business or any kind of business, you know that you got to move quickly.
What sets Notion apart from all other project management tools is that it not only allows you to be more efficient in your work life,
but can seamlessly transition into being a useful tool in your personal life.
Notion is an all-in-one team collaboration tool that combines note-taking,
document-sharing, weekies, project management, and so much more into one
space that is simple, powerful, and beautifully designed. With powerful
integrations, an API, and seamless navigation, you'll have everything you need in
one spot so that you can make
speed your advantage without the silos and context switching that slow companies down.
Plus, notion has a worldwide network of millions of users creating templates, tutorials,
and new inspiration. The product is getting better all the time and you will always have the
support that you need. Learn more and get started for free at notion.com slash morbid.
That's notion.com slash morbid to help you take the first step toward an organized happier team today.
notion.com slash morbid.
Oh no!
So Mrs. Milliken goes, it gets her husband and carries him inside and gets him settled
because he's still breathing at this point.
Oh my God.
And she hasn't lay down and she sends William Moses to get a doctor, but he has to like
row to another island to get a doctor.
Oh, fuck.
To another land to get a doctor.
And she tries to get the gun away from Howard Hobb.
She's like, you gotta stop, like, get that out of here.
You gotta stop shooting people.
Please.
So he gets mad and he threatens to shoot her too
if she touches his gun.
He's like, I don't want her touching my gun.
And apparently at this point,
Frederick raised his head, Frederick Billocken,
and was like, she's never done anything to you.
Like you leave her alone.
Oh, what, you know, a man.
Yes, he's like dying from a gunshot.
Look at him.
He's just like, no, what?
Leave my wife alone.
Yeah, you dick. You actual asshole. So instead of escalating the situation more, Mrs.
Milliken looks at Howard and she's like, go get the lighthouse keeper. Like we need somebody to come help.
And remember, this is Thomas Orkut. I was like, what? She sent him the guy who did it. She is.
She's like, I don't know if he's sending me away.
Thomas is fine to work.
I don't know, okay, cool.
So back then, light keepers.
Lighthouse keepers were actually in charge a little bit.
Like they held some kind of authority.
Yeah.
So Thomas Orkut needed to be aware that a man had just been shot
on the island.
Yeah, that's a big deal.
So as soon as Hobbes released the story to Orkut,
the two men run back over to Millican's home,
but they learned that he had died while they were on their way back.
And as soon as he heard Howard Hobbs rushed back
with his shotgun and toe,
or not a shotgun is rifle and toe,
sits on his couch and his hand then writes down a letter,
saying that he's doing what he's about to do,
and he shoots one shot into his right temple.
Oh, so when the police arrive on scene,
Mrs. Milliken explained the whole situation
and told him, told the police the only reason
her husband wanted to speak with Mr. Hobbs
was because he hadn't paid his rent in a while
and there was no sign that any of this would have happened.
No, of course not.
So these days, people who visit Wood Island
claim that they hear shouting voices and they
can hear them from the lighthouse and they will also see dark figures appear out of nowhere
and vanish without a trace.
And a lot of people have come to the conclusion that the island is being haunted by Frederick
Milliken and Howard Hobbs.
Yeah, of course.
Now I believe it.
So like that's the end of that story.
Just ended really tragically.
Yeah, that's like farmer. And now they're haunting the island. Yeah, of course. I believe it. So that's the end of that story. Just ended really tragically. Yeah, that's like, fummer.
And now they're haunting the island.
Yeah, they are.
And now, apparently, there's some like,
wily mischievous ghosts.
Yeah.
Or other people are.
Because during some restoration of the Keepers' Home
and the Lighthouse itself, the people working
on the project would lose their tools
or just misplace different things
and then find them somewhere totally random
and they were like, I definitely didn't put that there.
That's wily.
It is wily.
Yeah.
And a set of keepers once thought that they had lost
a bunch of wax pencils that they needed
to post weather updates.
Oh yeah.
And they found an entire batch of them
just hidden in a storage room.
I just hid them.
I love that they're just hiding things.
I was like, I feel like Howard Hobbs
is like getting Litty Titty in the afterlife.
You can just do it in this for a long.
One hundred percent.
And like maybe Frederick Milligan is like,
it's okay, like I'll help you hide this.
I'm a broad in the afterlife.
You can grow out after you murdered me,
after getting drugs.
It's blood, I know.
For no reason, after just getting drunk for two days,
literally, on Orchard Beach.
And I think he was drunk like all the time,
this time.
It sounds like it.
It does. So one night some of the crew working on these restoration, they thought it would be a good night. your beach and I think he was drunk like all the time. Yeah. He was ton. Right.
It sounds like it.
It does.
So one night some of the crew working on these restoration, they thought it would be a
good night, a good idea if they just spent the night on location because it was kind of
a long drive for them.
Of course.
They were like, we don't want to have to drive the next morning.
No.
But they were up all night hearing different voices and they heard the shouting and they started
hearing people running throughout the building. But like they would wake up and all of them would be accounted for and they'd look around and no one would be there.
And like running. So they were like, no, like we are leaving.
And legend has it, they are not the only people who heard voices in the building.
Apparently, and I couldn't find anything to validate this, but it's a fun haunted thing.
Yeah. Well, it's not fun. But there was once a keeper who was also driven so crazy
by all the voices that he was hearing,
so he jumped off the roof of the lighthouse to his death.
Oh, damn.
Legend has it.
Legend has it.
And that is Wood Island lighthouse.
Damn.
Damn.
Wow, we hit some good lighthouses this time. We really did. And I'm so like I was like there was a
couple that I wanted to put on my list but then this would have been like 400 years long. Exactly. So I'm
already ready for the next one. Oh and now we can just keep going with them. Exactly. This is so much fun. And I
would love to open up the next one with a tale about one of the lighthouses we talked about today. Yeah. So if you
have been to Wood Island lighthouse execution rocks lighthouseution Rocks Lighthouse, or St. Augustine Lighthouse,
let us know about your experience.
Yeah, and keep sending any of them in, because we also, like, we did today, we opened up with
one we're doing today, and one that we've already done, and it's really cool to have that,
like, it's fun, interconnected in there.
So this has been awesome.
And you can send those to morbidpodcast at gmail.com and
just put like light house or spooky light house in the in the subject. I was like, what's
the problem? Anything with just to make sure we know it's a light house thing. Yeah. And
then we can pick it out pretty easily and it's easier just to like organize that way. Yeah.
But you guys have been awesome. We're excited to make this a spooky week. I am like, I'm
living in the spooky zone. Oh, fully in the spooky mood right now.
I feel like I can like hear it in my own voice.
I think, you know what I think happens?
This happens to me every year.
What?
We get closer to June when like summer's about to begin.
And I feel more and more like I need fall.
Yeah.
It's like as soon as June hits, I'm like, okay,
well I'm over this, I want fall.
Yeah.
And I'm already in that mode of like,
we're nearing summer and I want fall. I also want fall, so, but I'm over this, I want fall. Yeah, and I'm already in that mode of like, we're nearing summer and I want fall.
I also want fall, so, but I can smell it.
It's coming.
It's, yeah.
It's coming, for sure.
It's a few months, it's not that far away.
I mean, a few months, it will be summer, but yeah.
It's four months, till pre-october.
That's not bad.
That's really not, four months is nothing.
That makes me nervous, because then that's only like a year until my wedding.
Yeah.
And actually four months until my book comes out, September 13th, the butcher in the
ring.
You can pre-order it at anywhere you want right now.
Tiny URL dot com slash the butcher in the ring.
Or you can get it at Waterstones and that's a signed copy.
Guys, go get it.
Hey, look at that.
Well, natural slip in. That was a good one. I'm saying. Well, we hope go get it. Hey, look at that. A natural slip-in.
That was a good one.
I'm saying.
Well, we hope you finally in this book.
Yeah, I hope you.
I have water stones if you want.
They have signed copies.
And we hope you keep listening.
And we hope you keep it.
Weird.
And definitely keep it so weird that if you write a book someday
and you have a podcast, you just talk about it
on your podcast so everybody buys it
because everybody should buy it
because it's a really great
book tinywearl.com slash the butcher in the room or go to waterstones to buy a
sign
the one that come to bring us sugar and tea and rum one day when the time is
done we'll take our leave and go Hey, Prime Members! You can listen to Morvid, Early, and Add Free on Amazon Music. Download
the Amazon Music app today, or you can listen Add Free with Wondery Plus and Apple podcasts. Before you go, tell us about yourself by completing a short survey at Wondery.com slash survey.
What if you were trafficked into a cult
over shot nine times or fell in love with a vampire
or went into a minor surgery
and woke up one week later, paralyzed?
What would you do?
I'm Whit Missildine, the creator of this is actually happening, a podcast from Wondry
that brings you extraordinary true stories of life-changing events, told by the people
who lived them.
From a young man that dooms his entire future with one choice, to a woman who survived
a notorious serial killer, you'll hear their first-person account of how they
overcame remarkable circumstances. Each episode is an exploration of the human spirit and personal
discovery. These haunting accounts sound like Hollywood movies, but I assure you this is actually
happening. Follow this is actually happening wherever you get your podcasts, you can listen to ad-free on the Amazon Music or Wunderly app.