Rotten Mango - #117: The Monster of Italy And His Sick “Trophies” (Serial Killer)

Episode Date: November 24, 2021

In Florence, Italy - it’s said that 1/3 of people are conceived in cars. Young couples would drive up the isolated hills to have some fun - and creepers would flock to watch them. They would watch, ...record, “enjoy” themselves, and then go home. Except for one creeper - he wanted more. He would ambush the couple right after they were done - and drag the woman out of the car to take something for himself. His little trophies… Book Rec: “The Monster of Florence” - by Douglas Preston & Mario Spezi (Might by me favorite read of the whole year - you need to pick it up) Full Source Notes: rottenmangopodcast.com To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Rambles. Rambles. Whether you're doing a dance to your favorite artist in the office parking lot, or being guided into Warrior I in the break room before your shift, whether you're running on your Peloton tread at your mom's house while she watches the baby, or counting your breaths on the subway. We are inhaling and long exhale out. Peloton is for all of us, Wherever we are, whenever we need it, download the free Peloton app today.
Starting point is 00:00:28 Peloton app available through free tier or pay subscription starting at 12.99 per month. Butting butting. Welcome to this week's main episode of Rotten Mango. I'm your host Stephanie Sue, hit it. And I just work here. And we're just gonna jump right into the story. Let me tell you a little bit about
Starting point is 00:00:45 Florence, Italy. Listen, I've never been. But this is what Google tells me. This is what my research tells me. Most young people in Florence, Italy, they live at home with their parents till they're married. Now, the average age of marriage is pretty late. So that means you're with your parents for a while. Now, what kind of happens because of that? There's an interesting result that takes place. Something that I didn't think about. You were thinking, ah, the housing market. No, no, no, it's not that boring.
Starting point is 00:01:11 It's actually fun. It's fascinating. Car sex. In Italy, car sex is a national pastime. It's speculated that one out of three Florentineans alive today, people from Florentine, Italy, they were conceived in a car. If you go out on the weekends, you might see a ton of cars parked around the hills,
Starting point is 00:01:29 just filled with young people like it's steaming on the inside, who still live with their parents, they can't have sex at home, so they're just doing it in their cars. So this by itself would be a super cute story, but of course no, someone has to ruin the fun. Some creeps got the great idea, why don't I go and I spy on these young couples having sex? super cute story but of course no someone has to ruin the fun some creeps got the great idea why don't I go and I spy on these young couples having sex is illegal to do that here in America um no but it's done it is done yeah yeah but I don't think it's legal I think it's public in decency yeah I don't think it's legal in Italy either but I mean who which cup is gonna pull you over? I guess you're already pulled over. Who's gonna pull you out?
Starting point is 00:02:06 No, I'm kidding. Okay, sorry. So they say, okay, I'm gonna wait out in the hills of Florentine with my spy gear. I mean, some of these creeps, they would buy electronic equipment, suction cup microphones, tape recorders, night vision cameras, and they would just have a blast.
Starting point is 00:02:22 So many people were creeps essentially that they were given a nickname and I find this nickname to be a little bit racist so I won't repeat it. We'll just call them creepers. Now the creepers, they start outnumbering the amount of car sex couples. They start zoning in the hills.
Starting point is 00:02:37 So what they do is they decide each group, each clan of creepers is gonna have their own section of the hills and they're gonna dominate that area That's their territory like a drug lord and if you are a creeper from a different territory And you want to enter this territory this zone of the hills to watch those car people have sex Then you need to pay the original creepers money to enter like Disneyland. Does the couple know? No So each part of the hill was managed by a group of creeps who tried to cover their territory for the best sex-watching voyeurism that they could find.
Starting point is 00:03:10 Some part of the hills were highly sought after because they had good coverage. You could hide in a bush that's relatively close to the dead end where the couples park. You could get closer to the cars or there was a hill that good cars came by. Good cars meant couples worth watching. So maybe it's like a hot couple or maybe they do a lot of not like a BMW. No, no, no, no, like a BMW bought. Does that make sense? And then these creepers would buy and sell their spot. So if I'm sitting here and this is my creeping territory, a car pulls up, Very attractive couple. My visibility is good. I can sell my spot to the highest bidder in real time.
Starting point is 00:03:50 This is the bestness. Oh, just you wait, where's the bidder you ask? Did you know a lot of wealthy lawyers would actually do creep tours? Yeah, they would do tours. So they would hit up multiple zones of the hills to creep on car-sex couples in one night like a Disneyland tour Like a tour bus Hollywood Boulevard you just go from car to car and you watch people have sex with binoculars from behind a bush That's wild so business turns booming so much so that another business develops because I mean your economics professor is quaking in her Boots right now because listen to this once people started realizing that there were wealthy creepers or creepers that had Families, there was a new business. Another business idea that spurred up. People started watching the creepers. And then blackmailed them. Yes, so the creepers would watch the couples have car sex and then people would watch the creepers and blackmail them.
Starting point is 00:04:41 So creepers could be stalked by people with huge cameras. They would follow them, get to know their home life, get to know if they have wife and kids. What's their job? When do they go out to creep? Then they would catch them in the act. The creeper would be peacefully masturbating away in a bush. And then boom! What was that?
Starting point is 00:04:59 Busted. It was like a bright flash of light. What was that? And then they zip up their pants and they rush home to their wiping kids and then the next day, they got a phone call. Hello? Remember that flash in the woods? The photo came out impeccable if you ask me.
Starting point is 00:05:14 You look simply marvelous. A likeness that even your second cousin would recognize would, by the way, the negative for the picture is for sale. So you would buy your own creepy picture of you masturbating in the bush, so your wife never finds out. So let me get this straight, okay? Young couples are having sex in their cars in the woods because youth young love. Creepers would spy on them, watch them, masturbate to them,
Starting point is 00:05:37 and then there's this whole economy of the creepers finding the best spots. And then the creepers stalkers would stalk the creepers to catch them in the act and blackmail them. I love it. Cycle of life. The cycle of life, and you know, you can always start a business. I don't care what they tell you. There's opportunities everywhere, I guess.
Starting point is 00:05:56 So what does all of this have to do with a serial killer in Florentine? Was there a creeper that happened to be a serial killer? Was there someone who loved watching these couples have sex in their cars so much that he thought, why don't I just kill them? And why did he always take their private parts? He always mutilated and stole the private parts of the women of the couples. As always, full source notes are available
Starting point is 00:06:17 at rottingmangopodcast.com, but it's not just a regular book today. This might be one of my favorite books of all time. It's a nonfiction book, but it feels like fiction. It feels like all categories. This would be my standout favorite book of the year. It's called The Monster in Florence by Douglas Preston, who by the way, worked as an author for the American Museum of Natural History. He taught writing at Princeton University, which I know sounds bougie, but this book is not bougie. This book anyone can read it. It doesn't sound pretentious. It's, I feel like I'm watching a movie. I believe there is a movie. I think Leonardo DiCaprio is in the movie. Yeah, I think so. Uh-huh. I mean, he's written a ton of books, Douglas Preston, and all of them are super popular, and honestly, he's the type of author where I'm like, I know that I can't go wrong with any of his books.
Starting point is 00:07:05 Now that I've read this one, I'm gonna go pick up all of that. And then it was also co-written by Mario Spezi. He's an Italian journalist who was so heavily involved in the case. He went through so much trying to find answers and when I say, when I say so much, I mean so much. We're gonna get into it. I don't want to spoil anything. Outside of this case, he's an investigated big mafia boss's terrorist. He's also been an author prior to this.
Starting point is 00:07:28 So I think one author is amazing. Having two in one book, it's hard to say that I love a true crime book because of the story and what it's about, but I think if if the author is delivering a story so heartbreakingly well, that you shed tears for the victim, you get flustered and frustrated for the families, and you feel something for these real life people. I mean, that's a good book, that's what the book is supposed to do, and that's what it does. I mean, the whole thing is crazy.
Starting point is 00:07:52 It's hard to believe that this is a true story. There were so many times where I'm like, is this like a dramatic recreation of a story, like, is it inspired by? No, it's a true story. So go check it out. Now, let's get into the monster in Florence. The monster of Florence is one of the longest and most expensive criminal investigations in Italian history and you are going to get frustrated. It's intense. Sixteen people murdered. Close to 100,000 men were investigated
Starting point is 00:08:20 by the police. More than a dozen men were arrested and a lot of them were released because once they were in jail, the monster of Florence had struck again. They arrest so many weird people, journalists get arrested, so let me give you the lowdown. Again, this is coming from someone who has access to Google and has never been to Italy, right? This could either be spot on or horribly incorrect, so for my Italian listeners, I am deeply sorry. There will be a formal apology coming soon. Tuscany is a region in Central Italy, and Tuscany's capital is Florence. I think it's one of the most famous cities in Italy, from what I've heard, they're known for their Renaissance art. They've got even the Michelangelo's David's sculpture is in Florence. The architecture there just seems out of this world. The whole city sounds and feels like it's one of the most picturesque places in the world.
Starting point is 00:09:06 They've got vineyards, mountainside vineyards, they've got some of the most beautiful olive groves. Every part of it is like an Instagrammer's dream, okay? I mean, the setting itself is perfect. For car sex, let's be real. You drive up into the hills, the mountains, the florentine, and you see these beautiful vineyards, these olive groves. I mean, you're just kind of in the mood, who wouldn't be.
Starting point is 00:09:28 Every couple would be. So, I'm sure that there were people out there that thought, well, something bad's going to happen in this economy. With the creepers, with the blackmailers, something is going to go down. I mean, these young people in these cars, they don't realize they're being watched. So imagine the horror when amongst the safest, most pleasant scenes of Florentine Hills, two bodies are found. Giovanni and Carmella.
Starting point is 00:09:52 They were both found shot and stabbed in the Florentine Hills. Giovanni was still in his car. His head was pressed up to the window. Yet a bullet hole in his head. Carmella was found outside of her car near some flowers and she was naked. She was completely naked. The police theory was that someone had, um, watched her have sex with her boyfriend because that's what they were doing. And before she could even get dressed, he shot the boyfriend, dragged her out of the car to a local flower bed, like
Starting point is 00:10:17 right there, there's a little wild flower patch. And the killer even cut out her pubic area with the knife. Like a scoop? Yeah, like a scoop. Just scooped it out and took it with him. And when the police get there, I mean, none of this makes sense. This doesn't seem like a crime of passion. This doesn't seem like someone who was jealous of the couple. Like, you know, in this situation, you might think,
Starting point is 00:10:39 well, maybe one of them was seeing someone else since there's some sort of a fear going on. None of this makes sense. Nobody wanted the couple dead. sort of a fear going on. None of this makes sense. Nobody wanted the couple dead. They were a working class couple. Carmella worked for the House of Gucci, Giovanni worked for an electric company.
Starting point is 00:10:52 Hardly the type of people where you would want them dead. Like they didn't have access to a lot of privileged information or a lot of money. It just, who are there enemies, you know? The couple had headed out for some exercise in the car and they were playing John Lennon's Imagine, the song, and in the middle of the songs, when it's shown up on the side of the car, out of the dark and shot them. So when the police started investigating, they started realizing, whoa wait, this feels really familiar. This doesn't feel, I feel like we've kind of covered this
Starting point is 00:11:19 case, I feel like we've done something like this and they go through their records and they find that not long ago, another couple was found dead. We have 19 year old this and they go through their records and they find that not long ago another couple was found dead We have 19 year old Pascal and 18 year old Stefania So they worked they were also another working class couple they worked at like a bar and she was an accountant They were madly in love. I mean teenage sweethearts who went out on the weekend together and both murders happened on a Saturday By the way, so first they go to a club on that Saturday, a teen club, and the original plan was to hang out with their friends, but they thought, they thought, why don't we just sneak off real quick in the car, have a rendezvous?
Starting point is 00:11:52 Nobody will know. They snuck out of the club into Pascal's car, they drive not too far off from this super packed club. I mean, this is all the cars they're jammed in there. There's a lot of people in this area. They get down to business, and just like the other couple, a man had appeared out of the darkness. Shot the boyfriend, dragged Stephanie out of the car.
Starting point is 00:12:11 This just least stabbed her 97 times. Now this 97 times though, was not just random, frantic, stabbing. This was almost like a pattern. Like it seemed like you had an elaborate way of doing it. It wasn't just, oh I'm so angry, I'm getting my anger out. It seemed like there was something he was trying to either draw, or maybe it was like a direction like he did like right left, right left middle, like pivot, you know, does that make sense? It seemed almost natural, right?
Starting point is 00:12:38 Yeah, it seemed almost planned. It's very elaborate. It's not, it seems methodical. They were mainly around her chest and pubic area. And again, a big chunk of her private parts down there were missing. So he had taken them out. He had carved them out once she was dead.
Starting point is 00:12:52 So he goes to pick up an old piece of grapevine from the local vineyard. And he picks it up and there's vineyards all over the place here. And he used the grapevine to assault Stephanie as corpse. The reason that the police were able to connect these two murders together was because the same gun was used, a 22 caliber beretta. It's like a long rifle handgun.
Starting point is 00:13:12 It's like a pistol. So it's typically used for target shooting, but there was no silence around the gun either. Now this is a little side note. This specific gun, the firing pin in the gun, had a small defect that left an unmistakable mark on the rim of the cartridge. So if that wasn't there, they might have just said, oh well maybe the same gun and the same bullet was used, but how do we know for a fact it was the same person.
Starting point is 00:13:35 But because of that, it's almost like every single bullet that came out of this gun was as unique as a fingerprint. So when Stephanie is friends here that she's been murdered, they start rushing to the police. One of them said she was telling me earlier. Stephanie had told me earlier that there was a weird guy that was creeping around. Once I was with her the other day for a driving lesson and there was this creep that kept trying to talk to us, trying to bother us.
Starting point is 00:13:57 Another couple came forward in that area and said, well, you know where they were found? We were parked there the other day and to do some things. And there were a lot of creepers. They were trying to watch like a lot of weird middle aged men just trying to look at us. Some of them were acting weird. Just not normal. I felt like they were unpredictable. So of course now that these two young couples are murdered, they were sharing an intimate moment of love in their cars. People start freaking out. The number one suspects right off the bat are the creepers. It makes sense. So the police had their sights on one in particular. Enzo Spiletti. Now Enzo, they didn't necessarily think he was a suspect, but they thought that he could be their inside scoop for the creepers.
Starting point is 00:14:36 He was like a well-known creeper, you know, because these people they're not going around advertising the third creeper. So they need an inn. The police need to infiltrate this group. So they heard that he's an ambulance driver, and at night his favorite hobby was to blow off steam and spy on couples having sex. Even though he has a wife and an entire family at home, in a little house outside the village, he would go out all the time. He was known to be very quiet, neighbors hated him. He always thought he was better than everyone else.
Starting point is 00:15:03 He was so full of it, his head was so full of thoughts about himself. He was conceded. He even sent his children to dancing lessons as if they were the children of a lord or someone important. That's what his neighbor said. When in reality, the whole town knew that in his free time, he was a voyeur. So the police rushed to interview and so, see if he knew all the other creepers. Give them a lead. Give them some insight. But the whole interview interview he's incredibly arrogant defiant he said that
Starting point is 00:15:29 the night that the second couple was murdered he was just driving around town and he found a sex worker picked her up and had sex in the woods and dropped her right back off. I mean the police thought this was weird because no sex worker in Florence is just gonna willingly get into a stranger's car and let them drive her 20 miles away Outside the city into the woods So when they confront him with this he says okay, okay well I didn't pick up a sex worker. I'm a creeper. Now the police already knew this
Starting point is 00:15:56 But he thought this was the first time. I like watching people have sex That's what I was doing. I was watching young people have sex in their cars, okay? But I know it's gonna sound suspicious, but it's not. I trust me. I was spying on Giovanni and Carmella that night And it wasn't my first time either. I've been watching them for a while But so what? I'm not the only one that spies on couples especially them. They're actually known as a good car Yeah, but there's no way I'm the killer because I was with somebody else I was with my friend Fabri for most of the night Now is unfortunate for Enzo because when Fabri didn't really back him up like when he was interrogated
Starting point is 00:16:32 He was like, yeah, I don't know. I think there was like a huge two-hour gap that I didn't see Enzo So they're like Fabri tell us about that day and he says well Enzo and I met up at a local restaurant where yes a lot of creepers would go to this very specific restaurant to exchange intel, to exchange information about good cars. So he was there before we start the day, so we're, you know, trying to figure out what zone to go into. Yeah, zone. It was like a full-time job. This is not even worth the hobby, no? And he's like, so I see him. And then he kind of disappears in the hills, and then I see him probably a little after 11 p.m. Where did you run into him? He was on the way down
Starting point is 00:17:09 from a hill called Via del Arigo. That's about 30 something feet from the crime scene. Is that not fabric? Yeah, and he was coming down the hill around 11 p.m. That's the time that the police suspect the couple were murdered. So they went from talking to Enzo to get information, but now they felt that he was their strongest suspect. I mean, it's fishy. So they go back to him and they ask him more about that night. But there was no proof. Even his wife told the police that she went to bed at 2am and he still wasn't home.
Starting point is 00:17:38 So that's about 2, 3, 4 hours that he's not accounted for. And he was in the place that the murder took place. I mean, it's just all weird, but there's not concrete evidence. They arrest him, they lock him up, but for whatever reason, they have to release him. In the meantime, they keep talking to his wife. And they ask, do you know what he was doing when he was in home? And she says, yes. Many times he promised me that he would stop, but then he would get back into it.
Starting point is 00:18:04 And he always said that he would go out to quote have a look That's what he called it to have a look But I know he's not a killer because he's got this huge fear of blood a terror of blood Even at work if there's a highway accident He never gets out of the car He refuses to get out of the ambulance because he's scared of blood So the police decide that they're just gonna arrest him for murder. With no evidence, they're just gonna charge him for it because I mean all of it's so fishy. Now that's
Starting point is 00:18:29 strange, right? But I'm not necessarily on team Enzo here, I promise. But they really had no piece of evidence that would hold up in court. The newspaper is also pointed it out. They said, listen, we all want justice. I'm sure of it. But police, this feels like an easy cop out. Pun intended. You guys just want to tie up this case with a cute little bow and a ribbon, and you feel the heat, this is a scapegoat. And while Enzo was in prison, a few months later, while he's waiting for his trial, a new headline takes over.
Starting point is 00:18:57 The killer returns. Young couple found brutally murdered in Farmers' Field. It was another Saturday. Stefano and Susana had gone out to the movies with Susana's whole family, and afterwards since they had taken multiple cars, they decided, well, okay parents, you go home, we're just gonna stop by some ice cream. They didn't get ice cream, okay plot twist. They went into the hills and they were trying to have sex. They specifically went into these Farmers Fields because, I mean, it was kind of cute. Stefano said that he had these vivid memories of playing in the field.
Starting point is 00:19:26 That's where he grew up. And he just wanted to take his high school love there. You just wanted to show her around. And they stopped for a little while and they start having sex near the vineyards. The night sky was beautiful. You could see the moon, the beautiful stars. And in the moment of perfect ambiance, this romantic scenery, there was a loud boom. A bullet flies through the driver's side window, hits Stefano in the head.
Starting point is 00:19:49 Another bullet flies in, hits Susana. Now she's not dead yet, Stefano is. The killer opens her side of the door, drags her body 32 feet from the car onto a patch of grass, and starts stabbing her in a pattern around her chest and her pelvic area. He mutilated in Toka, vagina, and the couple was found the next morning by an elderly couple taking their morning walk. So the police they start gathering some evidence. This one was a little bit different because something had been left at the crime scene and they believed that it belonged to the
Starting point is 00:20:20 killer. Now right now it's gonna seem like such a small detail. Trust me this story gets so crazy I don't even want to spoil it, but you're going to need to remember this for like an hour later. So there was, um, there was like a little triangle, like a small stone. It looked like a door stop. Do you know what I'm talking about? Like a elongated triangular shape that you would stick under the door and the shape of like somewhat of a pyramid, I guess?
Starting point is 00:20:41 If you really want to look at it like that. And this is the only thing that they had found of significance for the past three murders outside of the bullets It's all they have It's it's like a random object. Yeah near Susanna's body. So they're thinking well Maybe he used it to break the car window so that he could get a better shot Okay, or to open the door afterwards. I mean, I don't know Or to open the door afterwards, I mean, I don't know. 20 years later, it would lead into another arrest and a bizarre investigation, okay? 20 years later.
Starting point is 00:21:10 So the day after the murders ends, it was released. And the public is unraged. Firstly, they've never really heard of a serial killer in Italy. That's something that happens in America. Or northern Europe, not here. We've got like really good food here. That's some stuff that happens in the UK. Germany, like places that are violent, not Italy. What is this? Are we American all of a sudden?
Starting point is 00:21:32 You know, these young couples, they were terrified, they stopped having sex in their cars in the hills. They continued to do it in their cars though. Just not in the hills, they did it in the city. So they would park right next to each other in the parking lots, and they would like bumper to bumper because they were terrified of creepers and just being murdered. So they would cover their windows with newspaper and towels and they would do it. So you would just see these cars lined up where you can't look inside. No, it's like rocking all the cars are shaken, you know. They're all just moving with emotion so that nobody can see them having sex because it's said and it's speculated that the monster would watch the couple have sex all the way through. Watch them finish,
Starting point is 00:22:09 and right before they can put on their clothes, at that moment where they're probably the most relaxed, the most happy. He shoots a. Meanwhile, a ton of people were outraged. I mean, the police had just accused the wrong guy, are we just gonna let that go? That's kind of crazy. Are the police in over their heads on this one?
Starting point is 00:22:27 Yeah, we never really have serial killers, but can we like call the FBI or something? Cause they got a lot over there. Like, do you guys know what you're doing? So people start helping the police. They're like, okay, I'm gonna help you solve this case guys cause you guys suck. They start writing letters.
Starting point is 00:22:41 Listen, I know it's my ex husband, I just know it is. Because I always knew that if Italy was gonna have a serial killer, oh boy it would be him. I know it. It's my dad. If he's capable of taking away my phone, if he's capable of grounding me, he's capable of anything. My son-in-law. I know he's family, but he's not. He's a serial killer. He's already killed my daughter's hopes and dreams. What more evidence do you need? This guy loves to kill. There were rumors, conspiracies. There was a headline that said, The Surgeon of Death is back.
Starting point is 00:23:11 A newspaper headline. So instead of buying the newspaper and realizing that it was a little bit of a clickbait title, people just saw it on the newsdance as they were walking by to work and they're like, The monster of the world, the killer, it's a surgeon! I saw it on the news. I saw it on the news. Everyone's like, oh! The monster of the world, the killer, it's a surgeon! I saw it on the news. I saw it on the news.
Starting point is 00:23:27 So everyone's like, oh my God. Cancel your appointments with the doctor. I know you're dying, but you're gonna die there. The killer is a doctor. I knew my dentist had it out for people. He's always been a rough person. Oh my God. The police just stopped by my anesthesiologist's office.
Starting point is 00:23:42 He had put my grandma under for surgery just last week. He could kill her grandma under for surgery just last week. He could kill her. We came so close, grandma. Not only is he a regular doctor, but he's a surgeon. He's a man of the upper, upper class. He's a man of culture. We can't trust anyone.
Starting point is 00:23:54 He could be at our next country club dinner. So who even came up with this theory? Why did the newspapers print that? Well, it was released to the public that the women that were murdered had their pubic areas cut up and cut out. Now, even though the autopsy stated that this was not a surgical procedure, this was not like a crazy, methodical, you know, type of situation, when you hear that, I guess you might only think that a doctor would do such a thing.
Starting point is 00:24:18 So everyone started talking about, have you heard about the operations? He did on the girls, he took his scalpel and cut up their bodies. The private areas were cut with such calculated precision that he's a sick doctor. He's probably been wanting to do this that's why he got into the medical field. Even though there was no evidence pointing in that direction. So the police are flooded with everyone accusing their just family doctor of being a serial killer. And if the letters were specific enough, the police couldn't ignore it. They had to investigate it as a lead. So they found themselves investigating what felt like
Starting point is 00:24:48 all the doctors and Florence. Now, the police probably got the most calls about a gynecologist in particular, which makes sense, you know, the public hysteria of like taking away the pubic area of these women. And it was a man by the name of Geremetta Gentile. I just know I'm saying that wrong. I just know. Like I cannot even feel so engraving their phone right now and typing out an email and sending me like a YouTube link which honestly I appreciate it. How do you even YouTube link a name? I got to do that. So anyways, he was one of the most successful gynecologist in Tuscany and he was the director of a clinic. But there were some nasty rumors about him. His wife
Starting point is 00:25:24 had allegedly planned on leaving him because she had opened up the fridge one day and found the trophies. The pubic areas of the woman. Oh, and guess what? They were right between the mozzarella and the arugula that she was gonna use for her salad. So of course, this sounds like a very exaggerated
Starting point is 00:25:42 account of events. When the public realized he still hadn't been arrested because the police found no information or no evidence against him other than this weird rumor that was going around about his about a vagina being found next to the mozzarella balls, they couldn't they didn't find one. So the public take it upon themselves to start protesting outside the doctor's house and the head prosecutor on the case had to go on to TV and say this is a rumor if you are spreading this rumor we will charge you. We have investigated him he is not the monster of Florence then Mario Spezi okay do you guys remember this guy he's the co-author of the book Mario Spezi gets involved he's
Starting point is 00:26:21 actually the one that coined the name monster of Florence. He is the main journalist that was working on this case from the beginning and honestly there's a lot to impact. So a little about Mario Spezi. He was already a super notorious reporter and now with this serial killer case he was doing interviews for news outlets. They called him the monstrologer. This was a young journalist dream being at the center of this case. I mean, are you kidding? He was working with the police. He was even called out to the murder sites. He saw the crime scenes with his own two eyes. He wrote articles with heart, passion, and a lot of people were just drawn to his reporting.
Starting point is 00:26:55 And he too, also tracked down some leads. So the first being that, he found that the investigators were talking to a quote medical examiner. And I say that with quotes quotes because his name is quote Dr. Carlo Santa Jello It's called Dr. Carlo So his name is These names you're pronouncing
Starting point is 00:27:15 I'm telling you His name is quote doctor Carlo now these are strange character He claimed that he was a medical examiner, which I don't think is true. So anyway, he goes around, he's 36 years old, and he's always dressed in black, he's wearing these weird eye glasses. He's always carrying around a doctor's bag that was filled with glistening scalples, like perfectly meticulously maintained scalples. If you passed him on the street, he might hand you one of his cards, and it would read, Professor Dr. Carlo, Medical Examiner of Institute of Pathology, Florence Institute of Pathology, Forensic Section.
Starting point is 00:27:50 But he didn't work there. He also didn't live anywhere near there. He would actually live out his days at hotels or random boarding houses in small towns near Florence, which I don't think anything's wrong or weird about that, but he did have a quirk. He only wanted to stay in hotels that were in close proximity to cemeteries. Okay, guys almost strange. Maybe we shouldn't investigate him. He would specifically ask for a room with a view, a view of the tombstones. So maybe he's just obsessed with life and death, maybe some doctors are just weird. What does he do all day? He's a doctor. Well, he does checkups, of course. He writes prescriptions for people. He claims that he operated on people
Starting point is 00:28:26 But the problem was who's not a medical examiner. He's not a physician. He's not a pathologist. He was in a doctor at all Of course, this is going to catch up one day, right? Well, while he's checked into a hotel There's a little accident and some monster screaming. Oh my god. I know what to do There's a doctor staring at the hotel. I'll grab him. Dr. Carlo. He's good Yeah, he's the one that performed all the autopsies on the monster's latest victims. That's what he told me. That's what he told the hotel staff, so we'll be here to go get him.
Starting point is 00:28:52 They rush hesitant Dr. Carlo to the scene, and when he shows up, there's no denying it. This guy's not a doctor. I mean, even the civilians knew how to perform better first aid on the crash victims. And a lot of people started worrying, well if he's not a doctor, what does he carry around that stuff all day? Maybe the doctor is a cover for the fact that he wants to carry around scalpals so that he can mutilate the victim, he must be, the monster. So he became the next target of the investigation, even his ex-girlfriend came forward to say that this guy's a creep. Whenever they had sex while they were dating, he would take these sleeping pills right before, sleeping pills.
Starting point is 00:29:29 Right before sex? That doesn't make sense. Why? Why would you want to be sleepy? No, no, no. He'd say, this is the only reason that I can resist the temptation to leave you in this bed and take a turn around for the tombstones. What? Yeah, so he's saying, you're not really that fun and hot for me. Like, I want to go jerk off to a tombstone. So I got to take this. So I don't do that. Nothing only problem was. When the police interview him, he had an airtight alibi.
Starting point is 00:29:57 And he had gone asleep early that day at a hotel. The hotel staff confirmed this because he wanted to go to the cemetery the next morning. At this point the public was over the doctor theory. They were like, yeah, it's run its course, it's no longer fun. The newspapers were no longer selling off the shelves when they said, doctor, doctor, you know, it's just, it's old news. They needed a new fresh theory. So that's where the theory that the monster was a monk comes about. There were shell casings left at the crime scenes that were old and discolored, so they believed that maybe this came from a super old pistol or super old bullets, which you know what else is old? Monasteries.
Starting point is 00:30:31 What kind of a connection? Yes, oh oh, and it gets crazier. Maybe it was a monk because he wanted to show the young sexual kids the wrath of God. They're having sex in the car before marriage or just having sex in general! He's got to get rid of them! Remember how he assaulted one of the victims of the great vine? That could be a religious reference. There's a biblical reference that essentially says vines which produce no fruit.
Starting point is 00:30:54 He take it the way. So maybe like if you're not producing children fruit? While having sex, he take it the way. Okay. Now the police take this lead seriously, and sex workers start coming forward to say, well, we were approached by a very strange priest at one point. Oh yeah, he wanted to pay us extra to shave off our pubic hair.
Starting point is 00:31:16 The police are intrigued. pubic hair. Well the monster took pubic areas of woman. pubic hair is not what he wanted. So let's talk to the holy priest that loved Bald Vagina's, okay, let's go talk to this guy. So the police, they show up and they approach the priest, they show him the warrant and he fainted. And he wakes up and he goes, listen, I'm not gonna deny that I like sex workers a lot, I'm not gonna deny it, but I deny being the monster.
Starting point is 00:31:42 Eventually he was cleared, he had an alibi. But I think that this just goes to show. Question any and all authority. Behind closed doors, everybody's full of secrets. Everybody likes bald cats. There was another instance where a couple driving in the area, the night of the murders, in the farmer's fields, said that they saw a man driving a red alpha rameo. When they passed it, they could have noticed the man looks anxious, just strange, just weird. Once the news of the killings breaks out, they rush to the police, they have a sketch drawn up. But before the police released it, they're like, oh wait, I mean
Starting point is 00:32:13 think about it, this guy could be completely innocent. Maybe he's cheating on his wife, maybe he's just, maybe it's a stolen car. Maybe he doesn't know how to drive the car well. Think about it, think of the public hysteria. His life would be over regardless of if he's the monster or not. So they choose not to release it. For now, they will release it in years. And it's going to cause a... It's going to get weird.
Starting point is 00:32:36 So about a year passes without any killings. Back to Mario, the journalist. So during this year, he's writing these stories, following the leads, and he's giving the public the information that they want, but he starts having these crazy nightmares, anxiety attacks. He felt like the monster would comfort his wife and his daughter. He even had to get a psychoanalyst, like a psychiatrist essentially, but he was a monk, which just instilled a little bit more fear on him because there was speculation that
Starting point is 00:32:59 the monster was a monk. It just really forked with his life. Now after he's getting his sanity back, finally, because of your passes, it was the first Saturday of the summer. It was a dark night. Like the other murders, they called it a moonless sky. Like the moon was very faint. The hills were darker than normal, and a young couple, Antonella and Paolo, who was
Starting point is 00:33:20 20 and 22 years old, were peacefully driving on the countryside of Florence, like they used to do so often, on the countryside of Florence, like they used to do so often before the monster of Florence. They love these cute night drives, they were inseparable, they were madly in love. Their friends would actually call the two of them. Vinaville, it's like a popular brand of superglue in Italy, because they were always together. They were stuck on each other.
Starting point is 00:33:40 That's cute. That's cute. So that day after going to a cute little ice cream spot, they decided to go to the countryside like old times. And she's like, I don't know, they haven't caught the monster yet. You know, he kills in those areas. And he's saying, come on in to Nala, like, we'll go somewhere safe, I promise. And they ride off into the night. They pass a beautiful castle. That was over 900 years old, a beautiful river. And they they took a wrong turn. And they ended up in a dead end lane.
Starting point is 00:34:07 Those heavily wooded. Now, at that moment, Antonella and Paolo were almost at the geographical center of what might be the map of the monster of Florence's crimes. Now, Paolo wasn't scared. He's like, see, there's nobody else here. It's just us. And he starts kissing Antonella. The couple have sex in their car, and Antanala hops into the back seat to put her clothes back on. And while Palo is waiting in the driver's seat, he must have seen something, because he books it. Just out of nowhere, Antanala slams into the back seat of the car, because he's reversing
Starting point is 00:34:37 out of the dead end, like as fast as he can. This shakes up the monster who's watching this and he fires a shot into the car. It hits Paulo in the shoulder. What did he see? He sees that they're driving away and he saw the monster face and everything with a gun in the bushes or coming out of the bushes. Okay. So he's like, we're going to die. So we're bursting out of there. The monster shoots him in the shoulder and to know is screaming. She throws her arms around Paulo's head and she's holding onto him so tightly that her watched class would later be tangled with his hair. Pallos backs out of the dead end, tries to drive to the main road but he gets caught and
Starting point is 00:35:14 lands in a ditch. He tries to drive out of the ditch, but he's stuck. They were essentially sitting ducks and the monster was standing on the other side of the road and because of the way that they had backed out, their headlights were on, and they could see him clearly. He was holding up the gun, and he fired. They both shut their eyes in anticipation. This is when we die, you know, that's what they're thinking, but when they look up, they realize that he had shot twice, one into each headlight, two perfectly placed bullets,
Starting point is 00:35:43 and now it was dark. The monster calmly crossed the road, threw up in the door, and he shot each one of them in the head. He did try to get the car out of the ditch because it was very close to the main road, but it didn't work. So he gave up,
Starting point is 00:35:55 and instead he mutilated Antonella. Next to her body, they found a bottle of medicine that was, it's like sold over the counter, but they could never really connect it with anyone. What a police! It was the height of the crack era, and instead of locking up drug dealers, some New York City cops had become them. I would suit up in my uniform and we're going to want some drug dealers, and I know how to do it really well.
Starting point is 00:36:39 This is the inside story of the biggest police corruption scandal in NYPD history and the investigation that uncovered it all. Did you consider yourself a rat? 100% I save my soul just like everybody else does. Listen to and follow the set, an Odyssey originals documentary podcast series available now in the Odyssey app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you get your shows. I'm not a big guy man but I love being that dirty mother f***er. And now what's even more surprising is that a lot of the monster's crimes up until this point was in incredibly isolated areas.
Starting point is 00:37:21 But this one, I mean, the main road people were jogging, like not even a mile up. There were cars passing by, I think the police said at least six other cars drove by this area during the time of the killings, where he had thrown Antonella onto the floor and was mutilating her. They're not tucked away into the woods, so when Paulo was found, I mean, he was still alive, but barely, so he died in the hospital without regaining his consciousness, and Tnella had since passed. But the fact that he was alive gave the police an idea. They called up Mario, they called up a bunch of other journalists and they said, we're gonna scare the monster.
Starting point is 00:37:52 I want you guys to lie. Right that the victim was taken to the hospital alive and he might have said something useful before passing away. If this scares someone, it might cause the monster to be so freaked out that he messes up he panics, he gets ahead of himself. Who knows? This is our best shot. So the journalist slide, but nothing came out of it. Well that's what they thought.
Starting point is 00:38:11 Because the police were launching their own coordinated attack that day on the monster. The same day as those articles were released, they were going to release the sketch that they'd been holding on to over a year ago. From the last murder, the guy in the red alpha Romeo. Now as soon as these were printed, police were flooded with cops. I know what I know I'm actually quite a bit of people thought that it looked like this local butcher that owned a little butcher meat shop.
Starting point is 00:38:32 And so outside this small shop, there was an angry mom holding the sketch doing like marches. They had to close down for a week. He was not the monster. He was just a butcher. Then there was a pizza maker at Red Pony, Pizzeria, and a bunch of younger boys kept coming in to tease him that he looked like the monster. He was just a butcher. Then there was a pizza maker at Red Pony, Pizzeria, and a bunch of younger boys kept coming in to tease him that he looked like the monster. They were bullying him essentially. They would run in
Starting point is 00:38:51 and say, Oh my God, it looks like him. They would run out in terror and then repeat the process. The next day after lunch, the pizza worker slid his own throat and then there was another lead, a taxi driver. The police thought that this was really solid lead. He looked just like the sketch, so they called the taxi requesting that specific driver to come to the police station. They ordered him out and they were shook. I mean, this guy at least looks like his twin, but probably not even that.
Starting point is 00:39:17 They looked the same. This is the same person. The sketch looks like it's based off of him. This is our guide. This is the monster. They rush him into the interrogation room and he's kind of sobbing. He's like, listen, if you hadn't called me, I would have come myself once my shift was over.
Starting point is 00:39:32 Ever since that picture was published, my life has been total hell. I've had nothing but clients who suddenly want to get out of the cab in the middle of the ride. I've unfinished jobs. And this guy had an alibi, an airtight alibi. The resemblance was just a pure coincidence. So the public is exhausted. All the sketch look-alikes are exhausted. The police are exhausted. And that's when they get a letter in the mail. Inside of it, there was nothing but a yellow clipping
Starting point is 00:39:57 of an old article, a long forgotten murder of a couple who had been making love in a car parked in the Florentine countryside and that's when they realized the monster didn't just start killing recently. His first murders were 14 years ago. Someone had tipped them off, they wrote on the newspaper clipping, take another look at this crime. So this is not sent by the killer? No. Anonymous.
Starting point is 00:40:19 Weird. So what happened 14 years ago? Well, let me tell you, because this is what's going to put everything back together, okay? 14 years ago a young couple Antonio who is 29 and Barbara who is 32 They were shot with the same gun that was used in the rest of the Florentine killings The police reopened the case, but the strange thing is the case is already solved The murderer had confessed to the crime. He's in prison and he's been out of prison for a while But he was at a halfway house
Starting point is 00:40:43 So there's no way that he's the monster of Florence because he's been tracked ever since. But if he didn't kill these new couples, then maybe he didn't kill that couple 14 years ago, but then why would he confess to the crime? I mean, it's confusing, so they go and they question him. And here's what happened. Barber the victim was married, but not to the person she was in the cart with, not Antonio. She was married to an older man by the name of Stefano. Now Stefano was a Sardinian immigrant from the island of Sardinia. Now, I say immigrant because it's part of Italy, but it has its own domestic autonomy. So, I mean, if you were to immigrate to the mainland, you would just say like, I immigrate it, I guess.
Starting point is 00:41:20 Barbara's cheating on her husband goes out to the movies with Antonio and afterwards the two of them have sex in the car. Meanwhile, her son's in the back. Natalino. Natalino is her son with Stefano, or her husband. He's just sleeping in the back. She had taken him out to the affair. I mean, it's kind of crazy. A man ambushes them, shoots them both.
Starting point is 00:41:40 Now, this is the part where Natalino wakes up to the gunshots screams because his mom is dead, rushes out, two hours later, he finds his way to a house that's 1.5 miles away from the crime scene, which is weird, the police thought that was really weird. And he's like, please open your door, I'm sleep, daddy's sick and bed, and you have to drive me home because my mom and my uncle, they're dead in the car. The police rush there, they realize that Barbara was an interesting woman. She was having a lot of extra marital affairs. She forced her six-year-old son to call all of her, you know, people that she was having affairs with Uncle. Everyone knew that she was cheating. The townspeople called her Queen Bee.
Starting point is 00:42:17 Because Natalina was only six years old, he had a hard time keeping his story straight. He was traumatized. He kept changing his answer and the police thought, well, we already know who did it, so who cares? Let's bring in Stefano. Let's test his hands for Gunpowder residue. That's when he broke down crying and said that he killed his wife and the lover because he was jealous. So due to his confession and due to the circumstances, he was given a reduced sentence of 14 years. Where's the gun Stefano? Oh, I threw it in a ditch on the way home. But when they went to search the entire area, they couldn't find the gun. Now, it's weird, these are the same bullets I was used for the new Florentine killings. So you're saying somebody else picked it up? No. It's him? Well, here's where it gets
Starting point is 00:42:59 weird. Now that it was brought up again, the police are now searching for the monster of Florence. They rushed to question him. What did you do with the gun after the killing? But his mind was like gone. His mind had deteriorated in prison. He was barely there. He was tense. He was suspicious. He was not trusting.
Starting point is 00:43:14 Whatever he knew, whatever he was thinking, he didn't want to tell anyone. But maybe he would talk to journalist Mario. So Mario arrives at the halfway house, and he persists. And he lets somehow the priest that runs the house lets Mario talk to Stefano and at first Stefano is cautious but he starts trusting him. And there was really nothing that he got out of it until he was about to get up and leave. Stefano grabs his arm, this is like straight up like a movie, you gotta read the book, he grabs his arm and says, they need to figure out where the pistol is, otherwise there will
Starting point is 00:43:44 be more murders, they will continue to kill, they will continue. Mario leaves and he's like a criminal. What does he mean by that? Maybe he truly is, I don't know, losing his mind a little bit. I don't know, that's weird. Is he paranoid? Does he think that some strange organization is out here killing people, but then it struck him. Maybe when Stefano killed him Barbara, he wasn't a thorn. Maybe he had gone with friends, or people he knew, and they had taken the murder weapon. And now these people were on a killing spree. What? Maybe there's not one. Maybe it's not the monster of Florence. Maybe it's the monster's of Florence. But why wouldn't he just say the name? He's terrified.
Starting point is 00:44:32 So the police also get to the same conclusion, and they start looking for anyone that might have been there at the night of the murder. Who would be with Stefano? Because Stefano was from Sardinia, the police assumed that it was a Sardinian gang of some sort. You know, a lot of Sardinians they immigrated at that time and Sardinia at the time was one of the poorest parts of Italy. So to the mainland, I mean, they're going for better education, a better life, and it took a lot for them to do that. The book states it so beautifully, but it said that Sardinians were afraid of the sea. Because the only thing the sea brought to their island was death, pillage, and rape. Their ancient expression is, he who comes from the sea robs.
Starting point is 00:45:07 They had Christian ships that came to kill their forests, to build their boats, pirates who came to take their women and children back for their own sexual comfort. Legend has that there was even a giant tsunami that wiped out all the seaside towns, and that's why the Sardinians were forced to move up into the harsh mountains. So when the police started investigating Stefano, they come across a village called the village of VSC Dro. Okay, it's a super isolated, even by Sardinian standards, type of village. It's got a lot of wooded areas in the mountains. Locals hated it. They called the village a cursed land, the country of shadows and witches. Everyone's at the witches in the village were long dresses that
Starting point is 00:45:45 touched all the way to the ground to hide their tails. And inside this village lived a family named the Vinci family. Now the Vinci family consisted of three brothers. Giovanni, who he had a bad past, okay, he was one of his sisters, so he was put in jail for a little while. Then we have Salvatore, who married a teenage girl by the name of Barbara Rina or little Barbara and they had a son together by the name of Antonio Then we have the youngest brother. I mean it really does feel like the vampire diary's later Francesco Francesco was just a violent kid like he was known to love killing sheep in the area and to skin them and Got them like he was obsessed with killing animals which you know is a bad bad sign
Starting point is 00:46:24 Okay, so these three brothers they're wreaking havoc in this village, and one day, Salvatore's wife, Barbarina, is found dead in her bed. Now, the authorities said that she had committed suicide via propane gas, but everyone in the town felt different. She had been murdered, but her good for nothing has been. Now, this suspected murder of Barbarina was the last straw for everyone. The brothers were essentially exiled and forced to immigrate to mainland Italy. The Sardinians were like, get out of here. We're going to drown you in the waters unless you leave because you're killing Sardinians. Get out.
Starting point is 00:46:54 So they bored a little fairy. Now the youngest two brothers were the ones that will be the most important. Salvatore and Francesco. They were the opposites from hell. Salvatore was introverted. He was considered to be a bit more thoughtful, Francesco was young and he was extroverted, he was violent, and even though together they hate each other, they will play a big role in this. Once they get to Tuscany, Francesco spends all of his time at a bar outside of Florence
Starting point is 00:47:19 that was notorious for Sardinian criminals. It was like the hangout spot of some of the most famous gangsters. What's their business you ask? The Sardinian criminals. It was like the hangout spot of some of the most famous gangsters. What's their business you ask? The Sardinian gangsters were known for kidnapping for ransom. They would kidnap a bunch of people and if they don't get their ransom, they would kill their victims. Feed the bodies to pigs. And it didn't seem like Francesco participated in this, so I mean, I guess we don't know.
Starting point is 00:47:41 Salvatore on the other hand, he gets a job laying brick. He rents a room in a rundown house of one of his girlfriends. The dad of the house was Stefano, and the wife was Barbara. The one that was killed in the car. Stefano is the husband. So they're all living together. Yeah. So yes, Salvatore's girlfriend is Barbara.
Starting point is 00:47:57 It's that that Barbara was a beautiful woman with plump lips and a cute little nose, and she was thick-ooms. She came from a really poor family, and they ranged for her to marry an older man to provide for her. And she did not like Stefano. She thought that he was a bit stupid, too much of a simple ten. So Barbara cheated all the time. She stole money from Stefano's parents, she would gift the money to younger men, she would even bring some of these men home to have sex with, and Stefano's parents were living with them at the time. So they're just seeing their daughter-in-law do all these crazy things. They tried
Starting point is 00:48:27 to stop her, they put iron bars on the first floor windows, but it didn't work. She would still sneak out, so Salvatore meets Barbara and they hit it off. Stefano doesn't even try to discourage Barbara at this point. He's even the one that suggested Salvatore come live with them. Salvatore would tell the police, he was in jealous, he was the one that invited me to live in their house when I was looking for a place to live. Come live with us, he said, we've got a free room. And I told him why I don't got the money
Starting point is 00:48:52 and he said, oh, just give us what you can. Why, he's just a nice guy. It seems like maybe, maybe I had a kink for watching his wife with other people or maybe I don't know, maybe he just thought, like, I gotta do this so she stays with me. Salvatore moves in and right away, Stefano brought Salvatore into the bedroom and said why don't you take my wife to the movies?
Starting point is 00:49:12 Come on, take her out. I mean just weird stuff. Stefano would go out with his friends knowing dang well that he's leaving his wife alone with Salvatore and it was clear that they had an attraction for each other, like they were dating. It was weird. So it's so bad that Barbara had natal for each other, like they were dating. It was weird. So it's so bad that Barbara had natalino, all of Tuscany thought Stefano was not the father. Now I don't know how Stefano is feeling, but his parents are fed up.
Starting point is 00:49:33 So they throw out Barbara and they throw out the child and now even Salvatore is on the street and Barbara starts renting a hotel and staying with Salvatore. So it seems like they're dating, which it seems like also Stefano is encouraging her to keep dating Salvatore, which is the confusing part. And that summer, Barbara gets bored of Salvatore and moves on to his little brother, Francesco. He was hotter, he was more masculine, he was a bad boy. So she starts going to these bars with him, she'll talk to all these tough Sardinian guys, and yeah, sometimes you should flirt with him. And Francesco would grab her by the hair, drag her out the bar onto the street, rip off her dress, leave her practically naked in the middle of the street, outside of a bar
Starting point is 00:50:12 that honestly I probably wouldn't even order a drink, let alone trust someone with my drink there. But even that, the thrill wore off in Barbara found another man, Antonio Ló Bianco. Now, it's said that he also laid brick and he was hot, sexy, muscular and tall. That's what the book says. He feels weird. He was married as well, but he didn't care. He was hurt telling his friends, oh, Barbara, yeah, I'm gonna fuck her in a week.
Starting point is 00:50:35 So now you've got both the brothers, Salvatore and Francesco. They were pissed. They were humiliated. And on top of that, Barbara had stolen money from Stefano and Salvatore. The brothers wanted it back. The night Barbara goes to the movies with her new boyfriend, they bring Barbara's 6-year-old boy. They watched the latest Japanese horror movie, which I don't know why the 6-year-old was allowed
Starting point is 00:50:55 in, but he was. And after the movie, Antonio drives to a near and isolated cemetery, and they start doing it. But the killers were already waiting. They had waited till Barbara got on top of Antonio and it was such a nice night out. One of the windows was rolled down. The killer crept up shot at Antonio four times, shot Barbara three times and Natalie now had woken up after the first shot so he saw the rest of the bullets being fired into his own mom and his uncle. After those seven rounds the gun had one bullet left and it said that whoever was doing
Starting point is 00:51:27 the shooting handed it to Stefano. Did you try to kill the kid? No, because it's Stefano's kid. Oh, right. Who points it at the wife's already dead body and shoots her? That got his hands contaminated with gunpowder residue, which is perfect because the Vinci brothers wanted to take advantage of Stefano's innocence. He was so gullible, he could be talked into anything.
Starting point is 00:51:49 Now he is going to go down for the crime of murdering his own wife. What kind of idiot would agree to this? Of course you are going to be the number one suspect. Whereas maybe the brothers wouldn't be. They search the entire car, they don't find the money, and Natalino is still there, and he didn't run off. He sees Daddy with a gun and he's screaming. He doesn't know what to do.
Starting point is 00:52:05 So Stefano picks up his son, starts singing him a song to calm him down, walks him 1.5 miles to a house and drops him off at the door. Now this is when the police talk to that child and he's really confused. She's like, I think my uncle's were there. I think my uncle like PA Troll was there.
Starting point is 00:52:19 I don't know, there was a lot of uncles there. Like he just kept saying all of this and the officers were so frustrated. One of them yelled, if you don't tell the truth, I'll take you back to your dead mom. Which what? The only thing that Natalie no was sure on was that his dad was there. So the police didn't care. I mean they really only needed one killer. They're lazy. So they bring in Stefano, he cracked and told him, I killed her. And he also briefly brought up Salvatore during his confession. And he also said that his wife had owed Salvatore money and Salvatore had said, I'll kill your
Starting point is 00:52:48 wife for you, that will even out the debt. He really said that. So the police, they bring in Salvatore and he stares at Stefano. I don't know why they were allowed near each other and Stefano throws himself at Salvatore's free screaming, forgive me, please forgive me. Oh my god. Stefano immediately tells the police, I'm the one that did it. I'm the only one that did it. I killed my wife and her boyfriend. It was just me.
Starting point is 00:53:08 And the police were like, cool. Nothing weird to see here. Case closed. Sit on my jail. Now it's time for the trial. The police bring in Salvador to testify against Stefano. And there was just a super strange moment. While Salvador is testifying, he's wearing this flashy ring on one of his hands. The judge asks him, what's with the ring? And he says, oh, this? And he steers at Stefano, not the judge. And he says, it's Barbara's engagement ring.
Starting point is 00:53:31 She gave it to me. What? So now that the case was reopened, the police are now desperate to talk to the Vinci brothers, Savitour and Francesco, and maybe find out where the murder weapon is because it's the same murder weapon. They start looking for Francesco first because he's kind of wild record. He was violent, involved in gangs, constantly reported to be violent and abusive to girlfriends. Meanwhile, Savator had a clean record.
Starting point is 00:53:53 He hadn't gotten into any trouble, so the police thought, well, Francesco fits the monster of Florence. Let's start looking for him. Let's start looking for Dirt. At the time of one of the killings who was in the area, visiting his nephew, Savators son Antonio. Then at the time of another killing he happened to be visiting his brother yet again for his nephew. Or maybe it was all a decoy. Maybe he was there for killing. So while they're searching for him they come across a car in the woods and it's hidden in branches. They run the plates. Guess what? Francesco's car. Why would he get rid of his car? Was it the pressure of the reporters? Now remember when the reporters lied that one of the victims was alive at the hospital?
Starting point is 00:54:28 This was around that time. So it seems like he probably got scared, so that he gets called into the station for questioning and he starts going off on a tangent. Well there's a woman in a jealous husband and he might be after me. I mean it was really rambling, there's no storyline, nothing made sense and what does that have to do with your car? So Francesco is arrested and officials even tell the press the danger now is that a new killing can happen even more spectacular than the one before. So they're thinking we don't know if this is the right guy. That's like what they tell the press straight up.
Starting point is 00:54:55 And if this is not the right guy then the monster might want to outdo himself to show people hey you caught the wrong one. I'm still out here. Besides nobody thought he was Francesco. Everyone for this entire time now was certain that it was a surgeon. Someone of the upper class, not this random criminal of the street. That's not fun. So months passed, no crime yet. But it wasn't summer. That's when the monster likes to strike. The winter everyone's just anxiously waiting. They don't know. Is this the right guy? Mario wrote a book called Monster
Starting point is 00:55:24 of Florence in Italy Which is not the book that um you'll probably read if you get it on like the kindle or an America the the new book has like the full story But anyways, this is like the first version He releases that which didn't help the public get over there fear that summer passed with no murders Everyone's really okay. This is the right guy But September 10th behind the hills of a monastery, there's this super old road that's pretty private. It leads to like an olive grove, so it's not really a place to drive through. It's not a destination road. Like you're going there because you know something there.
Starting point is 00:55:54 And the city had no signs up in this area, so we have Willem and Jens, Hens, Willem and Hens, I believe. They were from Germany. They were here for a vacation in Italy. They had no idea about the monster of Florence. It was a gay couple and they had started camping out around this beautiful spot. It's actually considered one of the most beautiful spots to soak in in the Florentine Hills. They start listening to some music, they're gonna have some fun, they start taking off their clothes, and a man comes out of the woods and shoots them. Now it's unclear whether he chose them, considering up until this point,
Starting point is 00:56:26 he had been clearly targeting straight couples, maybe in the dark, hence smaller frame and long blonde hair maybe believed that it was a girl, or maybe the monster believed he was a girl, or maybe the killer was inclusive and didn't care. I don't know. Or maybe he was just like, I gotta kill ASAP to show that the monster
Starting point is 00:56:43 is still free, right? In any case, Francesco is still gonna be sent into prison. Because the police are like, no, no, no, that doesn't make any sense because they killed the two men from Germany on a Friday. Not a Saturday, the couple was gay, he's not straight. You know, the monster always kills on Saturdays and straight couples, so we're not gonna release Francesco. Now even Francesco's nephew Antonio, Sal's son, became a person of interest because he
Starting point is 00:57:09 had been arrested for a possession of illegal firearms. He was brought in to be questioned and Francesco was super close to Antonio. I mean, the Vinci family are all about doing things as a family, even killing people, potentially. Antonio's thrown in jail. It seems like the police really only threw him in jail to get him to talk about his uncle. Maybe he knew something about Francesco. The police spread rumors in the prison that there's a rift.
Starting point is 00:57:31 Oh yeah, Antonio told the police everything about his uncle. He's a snitch. Don't trust him. Oh, you see that guy over there? He's even Ratnana's nephew. Kind of loser. Who rats out there? nephew.
Starting point is 00:57:42 So the rumors started circulating and they hoped that one of the brothers or one of the family members would hear it and get so spooks they would indeed talk to the police. But they did not. The family was smart in their own twisted way. One time the police yelled at Francesco's face, I know you're the monster, I know it just confests and you spray it in spit like they had spit all over his face. And Francesco was cool as a cucumber. He said, I beg your pardon, sir. But if you want to press your response from me, tell me first, what is that thing on the table? It's a pack of cigarettes.
Starting point is 00:58:15 Is it empty officer? Yes. Then it's not a pack of cigarettes. It was a pack of cigarettes. Now it's merely a pack. Please may I ask for another favor officer, please take it in your hand and crush it. The police were curious, so they did it. They crushed it and he said there. Now it's no longer even a pack. Your evidence serves like this. You can crush and manglid to fit any theory that you like, but it will always remain the same, an empty speculation and never proof. Wow, smarty pants. Smarty pants. I'd be like, listen, I don't even smoke, but I need a smoke right now.
Starting point is 00:58:50 Even Antonio didn't crack, the nephew not only stood up to the police during interrogations, he represented himself in trial for the illegal firearms possession charge. He said the guns were not found in my house, they were found a distance away from my house. There was nothing tying me to the house except that it was somewhere near my house, which is public property. Technically, anyone could plant it, no? To put me in jail, to pit me against my uncle, is this some elaborate way to get my uncle to talk? Am I just a pawn in the police's game? We can only imagine. And the judge released him. So they're not getting out of the Vinci family, so they bring in Stefano again,
Starting point is 00:59:25 and he's not talking. He's obviously scared of someone, but they did find in his wallet a tiny little piece of paper that was folded over a hundred times, which is insane. And when you open it all up, it's handwritten on there. It's almost a script, talking points of what to say if you were arrested by the police. And the letter was written by his own brother. I mean it was weird a lot of things were misspelled half of it was written in capitals the other half incursive there were a lot of weird phrases that the police didn't understand it was a mix of Italian and sardinian and soon two more people would be arrested regarding the case of the
Starting point is 01:00:00 monster of Florence Giovanni Melli Stefano'sano's brother, and Piero, okay Piero, this is his brother-in-law, so Barbara's own brother. And when the police searched Giovanni's house, there was a scat-ball, knives, ropes in the trunk of his car, a stack of porn magazines, and notes with phases of the moon on there. Was he trying to find the night without the most moon? Is that what was happening because they were moonless nights? Giovanni's ex-girlfriend even said that he had some weird sexual habits. It was hard to keep up with him. He had such a large eggplant that even normal sex was so painful. The police were like, this is perfect.
Starting point is 01:00:34 This is great, the monster. He's the monster. They were charged with the double monsters of Florence. But Francesco was still not released. So now they're saying these two guys are the monsters of Florence, but we're gonna keep Francesco anyway. And the police said we're confident now. I'll tell you guys all one last thing. Florian teenians can now rest easy. The only thing with this is that the public was not buying it. They weren't having it. How many times had they been through this?
Starting point is 01:00:58 They were tense, they were staying off the roads at night, and advisor to Florence proposed an idea. Why don't we create villages of love? Governments can create a safe space that were surrounded by gardens to set the vibe. We can even offer special services. He didn't specify what kind of special services. What? It'll be fancy. We'll have a government official stand watch and the whole idea was laughed off with people saying why don't we just open up poor houses now? Yeah, let's just make Florence that place! That's what a lot of Florantinians were saying. Meanwhile, Mario is doing the investigating.
Starting point is 01:01:31 He looks up that there's only two nights in the summer that had no moon, July 28th and July 29th. And something does happen. Pia and Claudio, a young couple, they had driven out to an idyllic little field of flowers about five miles away from one of the monster's killings. And as usual, the monster watched Pia and Claudio have sex and bush them, shot them in the heads, dragged Pia out, mutilated her where he didn't just take her genitals, but he took her left breast.
Starting point is 01:01:58 Something to note, it wasn't cut off, it was literally ripped off. Didn't the two brothers, so they're a rest of one of them, right? What's his name again? Francesca. Francesca. Why didn't they arrest the other brother? You know criminal record, they just didn't think it would be him. He was like living his best life, working.
Starting point is 01:02:13 Are you kidding me? Yeah. What? I mean, either you're gonna rest both with no evidence or don't arrest both with no evidence, because it didn't seem like they had crazy evidence against Francesca. So if you're already do some illegal stuff arrest both of them, I don't know. It's weird, right? Because he's already suspected of killing his wife back in Sardinia. So this guy's not a good person I don't know why they're in a rest time. Maybe they didn't know that yet
Starting point is 01:02:38 So during all of this Francesco, Pierre-O and Giovanni were all in prison So now it's time for the anger to be turned into the police or onto the police. Which one with you guys? You made us feel safe. Maybe these young people might not have gone out if you didn't give us this fake sense of security because the monster is still out there. Meanwhile the police refused to release the three men and they're still flooded with tips that they have to follow.
Starting point is 01:03:02 There were claims that it was a single man in his 40s who lives with his mom and she's protecting him. They go to church on the weekends, a claim that the monster was a woman, a British woman, who teaches at a local school for kids that are under the age of 13. People even showed up to the police department claiming that they were the monster of Florence. A prosecutor working this case with later said, I never would have thought that there were so many strange people in Florence.
Starting point is 01:03:25 Like, just weird. Why are you guys doing this? Even letters being sent to journalists, which honestly they were disregarded most of the time, was just strange, but Mario had received one that he couldn't stop thinking about. It was handwritten, it said in all caps. I am very close to you.
Starting point is 01:03:41 You will never take me unless I choose it. The final number is still far away. 16 is not money. I don't hate anyone, but I have to do it if I want to live. Blood and tears will run soon. You will make no progress the way you are going. You have gotten everything wrong. Too bad for you. I will make no more mistakes, but the police will. Inside of me, the night will last forever. I cried for them. Expect me." And he's thinking, wait, what? 16? The total number of deceased at this point was 12. 14, if you count the killings of Barbara in the car. So what do you mean 16? Then they look it up in the history. There was another killing of a young couple in their car, but the gun
Starting point is 01:04:18 wasn't the same. No mutilation, no trophy taken. Maybe it was him? Maybe that was the monster? So to add more fuel to this Florence fire, Prince Roberto Carcini disappeared. It was a local prince who lived about seven miles away from the last murders in a very very massive castle by himself. He was actually the last of the bloodline of this royal family in Tuscany. He came from a super wealthy family and he vanished. He died. he came from a super wealthy family and he vanished. He died. So what happened to Prince Roberto? A lot of people assumed that he was the monster. Well, one night he had some friends over from Germany and they were all staying in the castle and he thought, mine was a little bit of some fresh air. So he heads out with a pair of binoculars with him and he was never seen again.
Starting point is 01:04:58 His body was found in the woods later, shot by a shotgun. His face was obliterated. His point blank range, and Prince Roberto wasn't that well loved in Florence. He was a prince, he was a loner, he was strange, he lived by himself in this massive castle, in an area that the monster was operating in. Maybe he wasn't killed by the monster of Florence, but what if he was the monster of Florence? Then the castle was broken into two days later, but nothing was taken. Why would you break into a huge place like that that's under police surveillance right now, and not steal anything of value? Well, maybe the idea is that the prince's partners or family had hired someone to go in there
Starting point is 01:05:34 and take out anything that might have point at the prince for being the monster, such as the boobs, you know, the genitals. Prince Roberto's killer was caught four days later, and you'd think that this would make the public be like, okay, maybe we're getting a little crazy here. No. The guy was a hunter. He was talking a fessant. It's like a quail, like a small bird. Like smaller than a chicken, I believe. And he shot it, which by the way, the prince was found near a fessant that had been shot. And he said that the prince was starting to chase him in anger because this was the Prince's property. You shot one of my peasants. So he's literally screaming at this peasant, I guess, this hunter, and is chasing after him,
Starting point is 01:06:11 and he tried to shoot the prince and the leg, but he couldn't do it, and the prince had shot, like, tried to duck because he thought he was going to get shot in the head, but then now that he was aiming for the leg, the bullet went into his head. Oh, he's giving me the WTF face, and that's what the public said. The public was like, what kind of weird BS lying little story is that? That doesn't make any sense. Why would you shoot the prince over something so small, like killing a peasant near his property? That doesn't make any sense, even if you shot him in the leg successfully, that's a very,
Starting point is 01:06:41 very, very big thing to do. You shot the prince. So a new story emerged in the papers that this is all a decoy. The prince's family are in their powerful people. They had sent someone up for this, but the prince is the monster. Maybe he had met up with someone who was trying to threaten him, blackmail him, and to stay inquired about being the monster. Someone had found out.
Starting point is 01:07:00 You, Prince Roberto, are the monster. So he showed up in the woods to talk about this secret, to talk about how much do you want. But I'll end up in a fight and the blackmailer shot him to death. And now this local hunter is going down for it. It's weird. I mean he didn't even go armed. I mean, allegedly, if the prince is the monster, he loves killing people and he didn't even bring a gun.
Starting point is 01:07:21 So this is kind of like the theory that the public has. And a year later, another murder takes place. So they're like, okay, so it wasn't the prints. And this case becomes an international sensation that even the book Hannibal, you know, Hannibal Lecter was inspired by the Monster of Florence. The Hannibal Lecter moves to Florence and lives under the fake name Dr. Fell.
Starting point is 01:07:42 A Japanese publishing house, the largest one, in fact, asked Mario to write a book about the monster name Dr. Fell. A Japanese publishing house, the largest one in fact, asked Mario to write a book about the monster for them. There were movies about the monster documentaries. A documentary even speculated that the monster came from an incestuous family. His mommy knows that he's a killer, and of course she's protecting him.
Starting point is 01:07:58 The documentary makers also recreated the crime scene. Parents of the victims were so upset they told a judge about it, and it was blocked from being shown in Florence But you could see it anywhere else in Italy Around this time, another serial killer is operating in Florence. Six sex workers were killed one after the other and the main central part of the city Everyone was shocked. They were murdered in their own homes where they brought their clients back. Nothing was stolen. It wasn't a robbery They were tortured. They were violently stabbed death in a stabbing pattern that wasn't the same as the monsters, but it was, there
Starting point is 01:08:29 was a stabbing pattern. So it's clear that these murders are different from the monster murders, but also very similar. Was the monster trying to throw off the police? Maybe they're trying to switch up their style. Maybe they're, you know, evolving. Maybe this is a copycat. Is the monster inspiring people to become serial killers? Now this is where it gets crazy. The last victim of the six women was a woman who lived in a super shabby hotel. Her entire walls were decorated with drawings from her daughter that the state had taken away. Her arms were tied with a sweater. She was suffocated with a cloth. Pushed down her throat. Now here's the fascinating detail. The hotel's water supply had been recently fixed by none other than quick house repair.
Starting point is 01:09:07 Guess who works at Quick House Repair? The brother? Salvatore Vinci, the brother! So finally the police are like, oh yeah, we forgot about the brother! Let's look into the brother! When they finally check into his background, they find out, wait, he suspected the locals of Sargenia believed that he killed his own wife Barbarina before he came to the mainland. I mean wait what even the way that he married Barbarina was Despicable it was not a high school romance. It wasn't even a college romance when Barbarina was just 16 years old She was dating a boy by the name of Antonio
Starting point is 01:09:41 Salvatore didn't really care about Bararina at all, but he hated Antonio. So he wanted to do something to get back at Antonio. So he follows Barbarina into a field and raps her. Now from this assault, she gets pregnant. And because this is, you know, back in the day, this is, you know, different cultures, he felt it was his duty. Oh, yeah, because the sky just cares a lot. Salvatore felt like it was his duty to marry her. And he did. He was the worst husband He beat her didn't give her enough food. She barely had enough food or money to buy milk for the child She was starving. The baby truly was the only happiness in life and she named him Antonio
Starting point is 01:10:16 The ex-boyfriend. Yes, that she continued to see Antonio behind Salvatore's back as well So Salvatore feels disrespected by this. He even starts to question if maybe he's not the real father of the child. Now he's upset because November of that year, Barberina and Tonyo were doing it in the countryside and when I'd taken pictures of them, the picture started circulating in town and Salvatore was embarrassed.
Starting point is 01:10:40 There was only a few things he could do, either kill her or throw her out. So she said, okay, I'll leave with my baby and she a job, and just as she's about to leave and move out, she's murdered. You know, it just didn't make sense. The way that the murder happened, it said that she poisoned herself with propane gas, but the propane tank was empty earlier in that morning. She couldn't even heat up her baby's milk, she went to her neighbor's house. There was a lot of weird things. She had scratches on her face, but the police ignored all of these weird details and just moved on with their lives. When the police start asking about savator and sardinia, someone comes forward and says, my gun was stolen right before he went to the mainland and it was a 22-berreta or whatever. Okay, so let's say he kills his wife, steals the gun, heads to Tuscany.
Starting point is 01:11:24 What else did he do once he get there? So before Barbara, there was another woman. He had married Rosina. They were divorced by the time that he meets Barbara, but she had a lot to say about Savator. Sure, his criminal record is clean, but he's an evil guy. Like for an instance, in their marriage, they had a couple over for the night. They were going to sleep in the guest room, and after dinner, she had whispering.
Starting point is 01:11:43 She had Savator in their guest room and after dinner, she had whispering, she had salvator in their guest room, which is weird. So she kind of burst in and salvator was having sex with the couple. And she's like, oh my God, you two get out of here to the couple, she was pissed. Like, you get out of here, you guys are sleeping with my husband, this my husband. Savator got violent and he forced her by the hair
Starting point is 01:12:00 to kneel in front of the couple and apologize and beg for their forgiveness. And that's not all. He would force her to date other couples with him. the hair to kneel in front of the couple and apologize and beg for their forgiveness. And that's not all. He would force her to date other couples with him. Sometimes she would wake up in bed to someone touching her and not only was saboteur in the bed but so was his friend. And he would force her to have sex with all these people.
Starting point is 01:12:16 Not only was he forcing her into three sums but with other couples like four sums or gays, he would beat her if she didn't want to. He would force her to have sex with his friends while he watched, and he would even have sex with all of the men. It's said that when he was having sex if he had an eggplant or like a cucumber around, he would just stick it up his butt as well. Like there was just a lot going on, and honestly, none of this is really damning evidence.
Starting point is 01:12:39 It's just people have preferences, but it was forced upon Rosina. So this guy's not a good guy. This is not consensual. This is not a married couple having fun. So after they divorced, Rosina runs away. Salvatore meets Barbara, and he thought his prayers had been answered because she loved sex as much as he did. And they did it all the time.
Starting point is 01:12:57 So here's Salvatore's son, by the way, just growing up in this chaos. He has no idea what happened to his mom back in Sardinia. He's hearing some rumors here and there that his dad what happened to his mom back in Sardinia. He's, you know, he's hearing some rumors here and there that his dad might have killed his mom, but he doesn't know. He was really attached to Rosina. It was almost like a mother figure in his life, but then of course, she left. And now he's lost and Salvatore is out here just like having sex with the world, and he's confused. He needs a dad in his life. And eventually he just spends all of his days with Uncle Francesco,
Starting point is 01:13:25 who became like a second dad to him. Now the police are convinced that Savator was the monster of Florence, and he was the fourth accomplice in killing Barbara. He owned the gun, he was one of the conspirators, it was him. So the police released Pierre Ro, Giovanni, and Francesco, and they put Savator under 24 hour watch. Well, not really, because sometimes they wouldn't watch him. I mean, we'll get to that later.
Starting point is 01:13:48 When Francesco gets out, Mario actually has a conversation with him, the journalist, and he asks Francesco, what is your vision of the monster? He says, someone who is intelligent, someone who knows how to move at night in the hills, even with his eyes closed, someone who once upon a time experienced a very, very great disappointment. Like, why did he, I mean, if someone asked you, what's your vision of the serial killer? You'd be like, freaking crazy, I tell ya. Scary! But he said someone who had once upon a time experienced a very, very great disappointment.
Starting point is 01:14:17 Yeah, very specific. Yeah, and it's almost sympathetic. And like, how would you know all of that? Yeah. What? So that summer was one of the hottest summers in recent Florentine history and it was also Sabrina's 19th birthday. So Sabrina, that Saturday with her boyfriend, went into his car, pulled off to the main road and they were hoping to have sex there.
Starting point is 01:14:38 But already another car was there with French license plates. There was a tent set up near the car and something was off. There were a lot of flies surrounding the tent. It was smelly. So they're like, we got to get out of here, but another car was turning in. So the couple thought, wait a minute, what just happened? They alert the police to the scene because something about it just felt off and they had no idea that they had run into the monster's latest victims. It was Nadine who was 36. she owned a shoe store and she was with her 25 year old boyfriend at the time.
Starting point is 01:15:08 They were vacationing from France. They still had no idea about the monster, so they set up this tent to just have some risky sex and the monster had slowly snuck up on in the tent and killed them. Now what's important is that Jean, one of the guys, the victim, he had run out of the tent and he was actually fleeing from the monster and he runs a lot of marathons in France. He's actually an amateur track star, but the monster out ran him and killed him. No way. Keep this in mind for later because it comes back to bite the police in the butt.
Starting point is 01:15:40 Nadine's genitals and her breasts were also taken and cut off and um, I mean this was just gonna be a crazy show The letter shows up at the prosecutor's office a little while later and inside wrapped in tissue paper is Nadine's left breast So this causes the only female investigator on the case to resign She said this present changed her life. She only worked at the police station from then on. She was locked in her office. She had two bodyguards outside her door. At all times, she had PTSD. The police contemplated, do we put out a reward or what? There was an opposition to the reward.
Starting point is 01:16:16 Some people said it felt too American. It's gonna be a witch hunt. We're gonna have bounty hunters. And a few weeks later, a rumor starts. In a nearby town, a young doctor, Francesco, he was a son of one of the richest families in the area, committed suicide by drowning himself in a lake. Well, that's it. He must be the monster. He was overcome by remorse. Perfect!
Starting point is 01:16:37 Now, the police were divided on this. Two groups of people had formed. One group believed that the Vinci family were at the center of all of this. It's got to be somewhere with Savatoran, Francesco, involved. Then the other people believed, no, it's just one person. You guys are, it's a doctor. That's the first theory that the public had. It's got to be a doctor. Another thing that made the whole investigation difficult was that in Italy, there's not really clean cut jurisdictions when major crime happens.
Starting point is 01:17:02 So you just have like two agencies rush to the scene trying to claim the scene. For instance, there was a robbery, a heist, if you will, a bank robbery, a bank heist, and a two agency showed up and in front of the robbers, they were arguing about who gets the case. So one of the judges ordered Stefano to be arrested and forced to talk.
Starting point is 01:17:20 And the public was outraged. This old man who already served his time like just let him be. And Stefano finally broke down and said the reason that he covered for Salvatore being involved in Barbara's murder was because he was having sex with Salvatore at the time. Stefano was the one having sex with Salvatore. So they're kind of lovers too? Yes. And other men and Stefano did not want to get it out. So the judge is like, wait, what? Let's go back to the evidence. Hey police officers, remember when you searched
Starting point is 01:17:48 Salvatore's house? What did you find in his house? And they said, well, we found a woman's purse covered with powder residue, drops of blood. Okay, well, did you analyze the blood? No, we didn't. Because if Salvatore was really guilty, why would he have such a blatant clue just lying around?
Starting point is 01:18:05 So we thought that that wasn't a clue at all. You like what we did there? So you didn't, you didn't analyze it at all, but then analyze it now and they go, see you judge, we can't do that because we never took any samples from the crime scenes. So we have nothing to match it to. Yes, we could analyze it if that's what you want, but there's nothing to match it to. So, are you kidding me? Well, what about that weekend of the recent murders? The last murders? Did you see him go? Does he have an alibi? We took that weekend off. What in the world? We, um, yeah, we just were kind of busy. So you watched him during the weekday when the monster never kills and decided to take
Starting point is 01:18:49 off not watching him on the weekends when the monster always kills. Yeah, we had the thing, we had like a little donut party. This was all being exposed by the judge who was super pissed and he officially deemed a salvatore an official suspect. He would later have him ordered to be arrested, not for the monster killings, but for the murder of his wife, Barbara Rina. And for two years while Salvatore was in prison, the prosecutors put together a case against him, and during this time, the monster did not kill again, only furthering half the people's theory that it had been Savator all along!
Starting point is 01:19:32 So the trial begins in the capital of Sardinia, and during this, Savator talked to the reporters, including Mario, about sexual freedom. Even Antonio, Savator's own son, who is 27 years old now, came to be forced to testify against his own dad. There was a lot of tension, and Antonio refused to talk, he just stared down his dad. And he would later tell reporters if it hadn't been for the police officers, I would have strangled my own father right then and there. And all of this led to a disastrous outcome of Salvador being acquitted.
Starting point is 01:20:02 What? For the murder of Barbara Reena, his first wife. There was no proof that he was a monster, so he was yet again free. And he disappeared forever. And a lot of officials' reputations were crumbling at this point. The police decided to launch a fresh investigation into the monster of Florence. They had a new head officer in charge who decided I'm just going to make a name for myself. He didn't care about justice. He cared about making a name for himself. He started running the name
Starting point is 01:20:29 of every guy between the age of 30 and 60 in Florence who had ever been in trouble with the law. From there he filtered out the ones that were convicted of sexual crimes, then the criminals who were active during the same time as the monster killings. So this narrowed it down to a dozen people and one of these names stood out to him. Pietro Pacciani. Pietro, he, I mean, someone had accused him of being the monster. Pietro was in prison for having killed his own fiance.
Starting point is 01:20:57 He was a very cunning man, intelligent. He was a farmer, but quick-minded. He would, he would hold his entire family hostage. His daughters were never allowed to go out. They had no friends, overall just a scummy dude. The police never followed up on this tip because it turned out Pietro hadn't actually killed his fiance, but instead he killed a man that was seducing his fiance. So the officers were like, well she would I'd kill the dude seducing my fiance too, so they're like, the guys innocent.
Starting point is 01:21:23 I mean it made sense. So after the last of the monster killings, Pietro was sent to prison for being his own daughter, and that would explain why the monster was silent for three years. So all they really did was fit this guy's timeline and his criminal history into the monster, but not because of any hard evidence, not because of any clues. So the police were so excited, they didn't even consider the inconsistencies. So for one, Pietro's murder of his ex-Fiancé's lover was messy. It was a crime of passion. He beat the guys head with a rock and then stabbed him.
Starting point is 01:21:53 He threw his girlfriend on the grass next to her dead lover and whopped her. Then he tried to dump the guy's body at a lake, but it was too heavy, so he left him in the field instead. It was so unorganized that he was caught immediately. He left clues everywhere, as opposed to the meticulous manner of the monster. But the police were busy. They were trying to tie anything together.
Starting point is 01:22:13 I mean, it's kind of like when you like someone in middle school, and you start connecting all these random things with them, and you're like, they like me too. I just know it. OK, I sound like a stalker. You do that, really? You know, but like, when you're young, you're just like connecting all these,
Starting point is 01:22:26 or when you're about to bed on red in Vegas, I don't even gamble in Vegas, I don't know, but then suddenly a guy's t-shirt is red and you're like, red. Does that make sense? It's like, doesn't make any sense. I can't believe the police are doing this. They pulled Pietro's past confession,
Starting point is 01:22:43 and it said this. I was hiding in the woods, I was buying on my fiancee in her lover. They were about to get naked in the car and I saw my fiancee start to take off her clothes and that's when she had taken out her left boob and that's when I just snapped and I went into a frenzy. I'm pleased you're like, oh my god, the monster of Florence took left breasts. It's a thing. Even though there were details that didn't support this theory, such as Pietro was 60 years old. He was short.
Starting point is 01:23:12 He had a heart attack in the past three years. Remember 25-year-old Jean, who was an amateur champion of the 100-meter dash and a marathon runner, who was outrun by the monster? You think Pietro did that? He didn't have the athleticism for it. He had a bad knee, he had chronic ear infections, hypertension diabetes, kidney issues, to name a few. He had more than that. The police found a rifle and a porn magazine in his house
Starting point is 01:23:34 and they're like, this guy's the killer. He likes guns and he likes sex. He's a sex sadist. They also find a painting in Pietro's house. It was a centaur, like a science fiction animal, like a centaur, like a dinosaur. I don't know what a centaur is House. It was a centaur, like a science fiction animal, like a centaur, like a dinosaur. I don't know what a centaur is. So there was a centaur. So inside of a large cube, there was a centaur, and the centaur had female and male sex organs, and big clown feet. There were seven crosses on the ground surrounded by flowers, and the police were thinking, the seven crimes of the monster. Seven crimes? Because he killed a lot of people, but it was seven times, because it was couples.
Starting point is 01:24:06 Oh. So the, I mean, this makes sense. They brought the painting to be psychoanalyzed by a therapist, and they said, the painting is compatible with someone that could be the monster. So the police are like, yeah, yeah, it's the guy. But how do you explain the connection to Stefano
Starting point is 01:24:21 and Barbara, because it's the same murder weapon? And he's like, well, this random guy must have just been there. Like he was like, hey guys, what are you guys doing tonight? Let me join the party. And I just kind of, you know, spurred his love for Killin' I guess. Seven years past since the last monster killings and there still wasn't enough to arrest Pietro. He was denying all the allegations, the police were so upset they facilitated a massive 12 day search of his property.
Starting point is 01:24:46 So Salvador is free right now? Yeah, and missing, like he just disappeared. And he didn't kill for seven years. Yeah. Which is weird too, all of it's weird. So I mean, nobody's killing, and Pietro, they're doing a 12-day search of his property, and this would be one of the longest, most technical searches of personal property in Italian history.
Starting point is 01:25:05 Just this random guy that the police were like, you, you're the one, you're it! They examined the walls inch by inch. They lifted up the roof tiles one by one. They excavated three deep into the garden. They used ultrasonic technology to survey every square millimeter of the land surrounding the house. In April 29th, they were about to throw in the towel, but then they found it. A Winchester Series H cartridge, which is the same brand of bullets as the one from the monster's crime scenes.
Starting point is 01:25:34 Now, it's not the same box. It's also not the same bullet, but it's the same brand. I mean, but when you buy ammunition, maybe you buy multiple boxes of the same brand. I don't know, right? But because it hadn't been fired at, they don't have the monster's signature mark on them. Now expert said, well it's it's possible that these bullets could fit into that type of handgun so the bullets are like that's enough for us. We're gonna arrest him even though we don't have the murder weapon nor do we have this specific bullets as
Starting point is 01:26:02 long as you say there's a possibility, we're just gonna bounce on it. So Pietro is thrown in prison. His trial is gonna start April, and the public was torn. I mean, who are they gonna side with? Some girls even wore shirts that said, I heart Pietro to the court house, which, I mean, honestly, in this one, I don't think that he's the monster, but I don't think we should be supporting him because he did piss daughter, and he killed his fiance's lover and then turned his fiance in front of the dead lover's body.
Starting point is 01:26:31 What? So why are people supporting him? Because they don't think he's the monster and they think that the police are corrupt. So I think that they're like, oh, we either side with the police or we side with him and we're going to go all out. Instead of being like, maybe we should have a middle ground where we look for justice but not really support the guy. So while in court, Pietro would cry out, I'm a sweet little lamb. I am here a Christ on the cross. Like he would just cry like a weenie baby on the stand and he was accused of being the monster. He would just spit
Starting point is 01:26:58 and curse at the jury and then cry and then just use a wreck. The trial took over six months, even his daughter testified against him. They were crying, like they told about the r... That they endured from their dad, and one of them even said, he didn't want daughters. Once mom had a miscarriage, and he knew that that boy, it was a boy that she had miscarried, and he told us, you both should have died and he should have lived. He beat us when we didn't want to go to bed with him, and he would always try to feed us weird things, like the meat of a groundhog. Like it just made them eat weird
Starting point is 01:27:28 stuff. The star witness in this case was a man by the name of Lorenzo who honestly conveniently he was just like one of those witnesses that the police had found and were like hey you should do this so you get an incentive maybe he was already trying to be maybe he was already being arrested for something maybe he was already being arrested for something, maybe he was caught for something, but he just kept conveniently recalling a lot of precise stories when it was useful, because mind you, I mean things took place like 10 years ago. So why didn't you report it 10 years ago? And he was like, well, I saw Pietro in the car near the area of the murder, and I was
Starting point is 01:27:59 only like 70% sure that it was him 10 years ago, but now I'm 90% sure. But crazy enough, Lorenzo got the color of Pietro's car wrong. He said it was red, when in fact it was white. So I guess it's that 10%. Even with all of this, the judge declared Pietro guilty. The last words that Pietro had during the trial when this one was, an innocent dies. So it's kind of clear that a lot of people think the police framed him, the judge is in on it, they just want to close the case of the police framed him, the judges in on it,
Starting point is 01:28:25 they just want to close the case of the monster of Florence. They don't want this hanging over their heads. I mean, yeah, they haven't been active, the killer isn't killing yet, but it's bad. Like, what are you doing? Like, we gotta catch the killer, we're gonna look like idiots. How many years have we been in office? How many years have we been the chief inspector of the police department, and the killer still on the loose with technology getting better with all these things getting better We're a laughing stock So they just wanted to throw this guy as the scapegoat It's hard to believe that the police and the judge even believed it was him because
Starting point is 01:28:55 Then you'd really have to question how stupid are these people? Yeah, right like just what? So Mario just freaked out. He was talking to some marshals of a different agency. So he wasn't talking to the police, but let's say our counterpart would be like the FBI. He was talking to an FBI agent who really didn't have as much skin in the game, because the police were the ones leading the investigation. They weren't really doing much. So that FBI agent had allegedly said, I don't think it's him.
Starting point is 01:29:20 I think that the police had planted evidence, and Mario secretly taped recorded all of this and he felt so bad But he um he knew he had to be done The truth had to come out so he leaked it to the national TV channels and he knew that the next day would be Explosive news so the next day he sits on the couch turns on the TV ready to watch it all go down. There was nothing Everything had been suppressed and Mario knew he couldn't sit around anymore because clearly someone in power was behind this. Someone in power said no, we're gonna let Pietro go down and we're gonna act like this is justice. Wow. So in Italy, your sentence to life in prison, if you're sentenced to life in prison, you're automatically
Starting point is 01:30:04 granted an appeal. So there's gonna be a new panel of judges and a new prosecutor who will kind of go through the trial again. And this time, with Pietro's case, the judges were shocked. They're like, whoa, whoa, whoa. So it's like a different jurisdiction. So it's not the judge that would be over this area. So these judges are like, there's no reason for him to even be in jail. There's no evidence. The police were further embarrassed because the prosecutor was like, I think Pietro is innocent.
Starting point is 01:30:28 I don't even know what I'm doing in this job because I'm here, but I'm not gonna even list out why I think he's guilty because I don't think he's guilty. So as the police are waiting for the verdict to come in to see how this is gonna end, the police rush into the courtroom and they say we have some witnesses.
Starting point is 01:30:44 For their protection, they're unnamed. We will call them Alpha Beta Gamma and Delta. We've got four witnesses who said that they were there and they had watched him kill Barbara. They had watched him kill some of these, you know, victims. They saw it all. We've been silent for 10 years, the witnesses said, but now we've got to speak out because the monster must stay in prison.
Starting point is 01:31:07 The judge is like, well who are these people? I can't tell you. What? I mean that doesn't make any sense if you can't name them, then dismiss them. So Pietro is given an acquittal and he was released to crowds wearing I love Pietro shirts. So the journalists uncovered the identity of these witnesses and they were all mentally ill men who had troubles with the law. Delta was a pimp, Gamma was an alcoholic sex worker, a lot of the witnesses were beggars, like they were always laughed at, joked at because
Starting point is 01:31:35 this is so sad, but they were seen as like the like the town's laughing stock. And I'm sure that it was really mental illness by someone's like, oh, there's just, you know, alpha going around doing that. But the police kept going. They kept beta, the star witness, and witness protection. And he started slowly fitting more parts of the evidence into his story, but none of it really made sense logically. Like, yeah, the evidence fits into his story,
Starting point is 01:31:59 but as the public viewing it, it's almost like the print story. Why would you shoot the prints of the like? That's not even the crazy part. Another witness, remember Gamma? So Alpha, Beta, Delta, Gamma? Gamma said, oh I saw Pietro and he's obsessed with black magic, witchcraft. And the police jump on this. Oh this is great, Gamma tell us more. I saw Pietro always performing rituals at this wizard's house. Who's the wizard? All the wizard died 10 years ago, but he would go there and he would,
Starting point is 01:32:25 the entire place had pentagrams, candles, condoms, liquor bottles. To me, it sounds like an abandoned house that like kids go in like graffiti and have sex, you know? But he's like, no, no, it was a wizard's house. So that explains the mutilated taken body parts. He took it. Pietro took it for the satanic cult rituals.
Starting point is 01:32:43 Da! So while the police are prepping for another trial against Pietro took it for these satanic cult rituals. Duh! So while the police are prepping for another trial against Pietro, he dies of a second heart attack. The witnesses were sentenced to either life or 28 years in prison, and the whole thing was sad because they were rambling, it was clear that they were coached, they had no idea that they were throwing their entire lives away, maybe thought that they thought that this was a better option than their lives. It was just bad, but there was a question of, what about the body parts?
Starting point is 01:33:07 But that didn't matter. Maybe someone ate it, maybe it was thrown away. You know, why do we need that? Why do we need the murder weapon? The police investigator, the head investigator, tried to tie everything up with a pretty bow on it and decided that he was going to start writing a book on the case. The case that he had just cracked so well.
Starting point is 01:33:23 And a lot of it would center around satanic sacrifices and cults. The cult he presumed that Pietro belonged to was the school of the Red Rose. It was an ancient forgotten, diabolical cult that loved ritual killings and sacrifices. He claimed that the school of the Red Rose is a huge organization that is said to be behind some of the craziest crimes. The kidnapping and murder of a former Italian prime minister at a Belgian pedophile ring. It said that some conspiracy theorists even blame the School of Red Rose to be behind 9-11. Now remember that odd door stop that was found at one of the first crime scenes, the triangular one? Well that makes sense. Triangles are the bridge between this world and hell, it's like the Illuminati. It's a cult.
Starting point is 01:34:08 This is the head of the police. Yeah, the chief inspector. Now as this whole cult thing, I mean it's a really, you better read the book because it's an entire saga. Like he builds a fantasy world around this cult theory. There is like an allegation that this foreigner named Claude was at a local village motel and he had left behind drawings of mutilated women's parts. There is an allegation that a doctor who had drowned himself remember in a lake had drowned in a lake. Oh, he was the one that was harvesting the genitals for the sacrifice for the cult. I mean, it's just there's like a whole world. It's like a whole Marvel movie that he had built around this cult idea.
Starting point is 01:34:45 But when, one of the few people who did not believe in it was Mario, the reporter, the author of this book, the co-author. He just, it didn't make sense, you're just sensationalizing the whole thing. The police are just trying to cover for their horrible detective work. He didn't think it was a cult, he didn't even think it was salvitor because of this. He believed, Mario believed, the monster is impotent. He suffers from sexual dysfunction and would have little or no sexual contact with women his own age. He kills to satisfy these desires, which can't be satisfied in the normal way.
Starting point is 01:35:16 There's strong evidence of that at the crime scenes, so there's no evidence of rape, malastration, sexual activity, or even semen. But Salvatore was the opposite of sexually impotent. I mean, he just doesn't even match the profile that the FBI made for the monster of Florence. In this psychological aspect, it just doesn't fit together. So you wonder, who do you think it is, Mario? And he said, well, four months before the monster's first killings, Savator went to the police and filed a complaint that the door of his house was forced in and the house was intruded
Starting point is 01:35:44 upon. The police said, well, was it a robbery? Did you get robbed? And he said, I don't know if they stole anything. So what if at that time the gun was stolen and Salvatore knew, but he couldn't report it because that was also the murder weapon for Barbara's murder? So he just said, I don't know. But at least this report later, if that gun is used to do something, he can come back
Starting point is 01:36:04 and say, oh, well, I reported it years ago. I don don't know someone broke in. I don't know if he was stolen I didn't even think about the gun Four months after this report the monster had killed So what's going on here? So who do you think Mario is implicating as the monster? Antonio Vinci salvators own son He couldn't turn him in he couldn couldn't say, hey, my son stole my gun. He couldn't even mention the gun. But maybe this was his way of, you know, kind of getting it on file.
Starting point is 01:36:33 He was one of the two people left alive from the Vinci family connected to all of this. So at this point, it had been years since the last murders. Francesco had been murdered. His body was hog-tight and locked in the trunk of a burning car. Stefano, Piero and Giovanni, they were all dead. Salvatore and Antonio, they were alive. And Antonio was the only one that was connected to all of this. He didn't have alibi. He was there at the time of the murders. He lived in that area. It made sense. He would have access to Salvatore's gun. Do you think Salvatore knows? I think so. And I think that's why Antonio was so mad at Salvatore's gun. Do you think Salvatore knows? I think so.
Starting point is 01:37:05 And I think that's why Antonio was so mad at Salvatore at the trial, not because he believed that Salvatore killed his mom because he had already heard these rumors. I'm sure he already knew, but I think it's because you're getting too close to home. You're gonna get me in trouble. It also makes more sense that the uncle Francesco is protecting Antonio versus the other way around.
Starting point is 01:37:24 Like if you're a young kid, you get arrested because your uncle is suspected of doing something. It's so much easier for the young kid to break and say, I did it or they did it, you know? So Mario teamed up with Douglas Preston, which is the co-author of this book, and they launched their own investigation. They tried talking to Antonio. They show up at his door and Antonio comes to the door and says, Ah Mario, it's you!
Starting point is 01:37:48 The monstrologer, I've wanted to meet you for a long time now! And Mario slipped out a tape recorder and said, can I use this? No, no. I'm jealous of my own voice, it's too velvety, it's too rich and toned to be put in that box. Now he's very smooth. Even the way he rejects being tape recorded is so charismatic and he's doing it all with a smile, but it's very assertive. There's really nothing you can say to that. Like why? Why are you scared? He didn't say that. He didn't say he was scared. So he says, well, what kind of relationship did you have with your uncle, Francesco? Ah, we were very close. There was a friendship with a bond of iron. I'd give you the inside scoop. Do you know when Francesco was arrested? Well, I was with him
Starting point is 01:38:24 that day? Nobody knows that till now. That night was also the night of a murder near the castle. Antonio was living in that area, and it was the murder that led the police to arrest Francesco. So, I mean, the author's just thought it was weird. So that means your uncle Francesco had a witness in his favor. You could have helped him by, you know,
Starting point is 01:38:43 avoid him being accused of being the monster and spending years in jail. Why didn't you just say that you were with him the night of the murders? Oh, because I don't want to get mixed up in his affairs. So you let him serve two years in prison because you don't want to get in his business? He wanted to protect me and I had faith in the system. Antonio mentions that he was married at one point, but now divorced because his wife couldn't bear children. Or maybe he was impotent. This triggered Mario who thought it was him, and he said, if your dad owned the gun, you were in the best position to take it. There was silence. I have proof I didn't take it. Oh yeah, and what's the proof? Well, if I had taken it, I would have fired it into my father's head. Well?
Starting point is 01:39:25 Wow, what a proof. Well, Antonio, following this line of reasoning, you were away from Florence the precise time that there were no more killings. When you returned, they began again. And he leaned back in his chair and smiled. And he said, those are the best years of my life. I had a house, I ate well and I fucked all those girls. So because of that, you
Starting point is 01:39:45 were away having a great time, you're not the monster? No, no, it's not because of that, it's because I like my pussy alive. And with that, he courteously kicked them out. And as they were headed out the door, he said, Ah, Mario, I forgot something. And suddenly his voice changed from that velvety, smooth to a dark threatening tone and said, listen carefully, I don't fucking play games. And he slammed the door shut. So those two, the authors, they get to work. Douglas and Mario, they start writing up this article and they submit it to the New Yorker who buys it from them.
Starting point is 01:40:17 But then 9-11 happens in the US and they decide we don't really want to run these types of stories right now. So they give it back to the authors and this only made the two more obsessed. They start writing a book together and this is this book, one of my favorite books of all time. They just started when the head of police just released his book. Remember because the chief inspector was writing a book and that book was something else, okay, really something else. May 14th of 2004, Mario is just kind of shocked by that book and goes on to a TV show like
Starting point is 01:40:48 America's Most Wanted but the Italian version and he was hoping to discredit the police investigation and prove that it was bogus. But nobody cared what Mario had to say. Nobody wanted it. They wanted just to have like this crazy sensational true crime story, the serial killer, right? They didn't want! They wanted the cult! That's what they wanted. That's what the people wanted. Mario, you're boring. We want a crazier
Starting point is 01:41:08 cult. If you're not going to give us one, you're lying. So the police hurt it, and they were pissed. Nobody else cared. The public didn't care, but the police they cared. A few days later, they show up at Mario's house with search warrants. He was accused of 19 crimes that they wouldn't tell him. And he said, what do you mean? You have to tell me what I'm being accused of doing. And they said, no, it would take us volumes to explain them. Let us in.
Starting point is 01:41:31 They took his computers, all of his hard drives, except the one hidden in his couch cushions, with all the information that they needed for their book. Mario was shook, he kept asking, what are you doing? And as they're leaving, smile is a very, balsy guy. He points at his door stop. In the library of his house and he says, you see that? That looks like the one that you found at the crime scene. This esoteric cult object. It's a door stop.
Starting point is 01:41:56 It's a door stop. You can find them everywhere in Tuscany. Oh, cool. It's a door stop. And that was the moment the police looked at him, looked at each other, seized his door stop as evidence, and now he was directly tied to one of the crimes. Oh my god, I can't. For a year between January 2005 and 2006, Mario's lawyers tried to learn what the charges were. They still didn't know what he was being charged of. Meanwhile, Mario, you think he's staying out of trouble waiting for his trial? No, he's out here trying to get more leads on Antonio.
Starting point is 01:42:29 This is his passion, this is his job. They find a friend of Antonio's who confessed to Mario that something strange had happened. This friend allegedly had gone out to an abandoned house with Antonio and inside were six locked metal containers. And he said, hey, what is that? And Antonio slapped his chest and said, that's my stuff. Six boxes for six female victims? Because at the time, there were six.
Starting point is 01:42:53 So he gives Mario the location and Mario goes out there, but he can't call the police. He also can't just walk in and investigate. So he writes a letter and passes it to the police and says, hey, listen, an anonymous viewer, anonymous reader sent me this as a tip because I'm a journalist. And when he tried to give it to the police and says, hey listen, an anonymous viewer, anonymous reader sent me this as a tip because I'm a journalist and when you tried to give it to the chief inspector, the higher ups came.
Starting point is 01:43:11 Now here's the crazy thing. Everyone had lied to Mario. I don't know why. Maybe these people were threatened. Maybe they were paid by the police. Maybe the police wanted it. But the story of the house, the abandoned house and those metal boxes was fake. Now this gave police a reason to believe But the story of the house, the abandoned house, and those metal boxes was fake. Now this gave police a reason to believe that Mario is lying to them. But they need to stop spending time
Starting point is 01:43:32 like making up stuff and fixing their stories. They just... Yeah. So they bring in both the authors and accuse them. Now, Douglas is an American citizen. He's an American author. So he's being yelled at by the Italian investigators and they're screaming, you and Mario, either planted or were trying to
Starting point is 01:43:49 plant a gun or other false evidence at that abandoned house to frame an innocent man, to do rail this investigation and to deflect suspicion from Mario. That is what you were doing. Douglas said, well, that's just a theory. Well, it's not theory. These are facts, Dr. Preston. You know a great deal more about this than you're letting on. Do you realize the utmost seriousness, the gravity of these crimes? Do you know that Mario is being investigated for the murder of these victims? That makes you an accessory, Dr. Preston. I can hear it in your voice.
Starting point is 01:44:18 I can hear the tone of your knowledge, the deep familiarity of these events. You have one last chance to tell us what you know, or I will charge you with poetry. I don't care, I'll do it. I told you the truth. I don't know what more I can do. Now, it's clear the police were trying to frame Mario, the monstrologist, as the monster. Because yeah, they had done it with Pietro,
Starting point is 01:44:37 but it still wasn't good enough. And Mario was out here making sure that their claims were getting debunked left and right. So what's better than this? Besides the press would love it. The lead, leads psychoanalyst, journalist for the case turns out to be the serial killer. Are you kidding? So Douglas, he gets booted. He gets sent back to America and right after Mario's apartment was raided, he was placed on surveillance, his phones were tapped, he was being recorded, his apartment was bugged, and a week later he goes to an auto shop because his car radio wasn't working, turns out the car was bugged, with a GPS and a mic system. And around this time, the police chief, the chief inspector, his second book is released.
Starting point is 01:45:19 It's called the monster, anatomy of an investigation, became a huge, bestseller, even mentions Mario, for being an an accessory to murder hinting that Mario himself was involved in some of the killings Mario filed a civil suit against the chief inspector for a libel and in April of 2006 Mario was arrested Mario's wife told Douglas they tricked him to coming down to the gate He was in his slippers. He had nothing on him not even his wallet They refused to show in the warrant. They threatened him, forced him into the car, and took him away. What's fascinating is that their book, The Monster In Florence, was due to release in 12 days. So this could have been a great big ploy to stop it. Italian law has something that, when dangerous criminals like terrorists or mafia kingpins are arrested, they can be denied a lawyer.
Starting point is 01:46:05 They can be kept in solitude for as long as the police feel that it's necessary. And that's what they did tomorrow. They kept him in isolation. Now this is technically to use against violent criminals who might order hits on other people or like threatened people, but his treatment was worse and prison than some of the most notorious horrible criminals. You would think that the public would be upset, right? But a lot of people didn't know.
Starting point is 01:46:29 Other journalists were too terrified, so they kept it shut. They didn't even want to test the waters. They did not talk about how Mario was arrested. After five days, Mario was allowed to meet with his lawyers. Twelve days after his arrest, the prime minister of Italy receives a letter from the committee to protect journalists. It's an international committee. And they said journalists should not be fearful to conduct their own investigations into
Starting point is 01:46:52 sensitive matters, or to speak openly and criticize officials in a democratic country such as your own, one that is an integral part of the European Union. Such fear is unacceptable. We call on you to make sure Italian authorities clarify the serious charges against our colleague and make public all available evidence supporting these charges, or release him immediately. Government efforts to promote this climate of self-censorship are a danger to democracy. Now there was international outrage from journalists. So you got a lot of people right now, a lot of articles and a lot of different languages about this situation.
Starting point is 01:47:28 Okay, there was, it was flooded. Foreign journalists were so outraged. So finally, with the backing of their international colleagues, Italian journalists were ready to unleash their ferry and come back with a fire burning vengeance, I tell you. and come back with a fire burning vengeance, I tell you. They said, Mario's arrest was an attack on journalism itself. For the crime of disagreeing with an official investigation, that's what he was arrested for. The crime that Mario committed was journalism. Protest started taking place all across Italy. The Prime Minister got involved.
Starting point is 01:48:01 I mean, it was a show. The judge and the prosecutors on this case still claimed though they were not going to release Mario because he is extremely dangerous. Why is he extremely dangerous? He has demonstrated his enormous dangerousness by succeeding even while locked up in a prison cell in organizing a mass media campaign in his favor. Oh my gosh, this is bizarre. So it took him 23 days in prison to be released.
Starting point is 01:48:27 And Mario is like a crazy person. I love him so much. I don't know him, but I love him just by reading the book. When it was time for him to be released, the guard told him before you leave you have to clean yourself. And Mario screams, I never asked to come here and I was put here illegally. If you want to clean, clean it yourself. And the guard says, well, if you like it here so much, you can just stay. Listen, you idiot. I know your name. And if you don, well if you like it here so much you can just stay. Listen you idiot, I know your name and if you don't let me out immediately I will sue you for false imprisonment you understand. And the guard let him out to a crowd of cheering people. The police submitted a quest to the Supreme Court to try Mario's case of being the monster
Starting point is 01:49:01 and they dismissed all proceedings against Mario. Then the police homes were searched. The chief investigators' home was searched. They had a list of journalists that didn't like them, a list of journalists that were against the police in this situation, and they were wiretapping their phones under the anti-terrorist law. So they were legally wiretapping these journalists. Just because I don't like you.
Starting point is 01:49:24 Jeez. So they were legally wiretapping these journalists. Just because I don't like you. Cheese. He was even taping phone calls between judges and investigators, including the prime minister of Florence. We thought they were all working against him. It was all a big conspiracy, and that's why Mario was like, go. This guy's insane. Oh, he gets crazier. Summer of 2006, they were indicted for abuse of office.
Starting point is 01:49:40 And I say they, because there's like five core investigators here, and they're going to actually be tied to another true crime case. Do you remember Amanda Knox? Yes, she was a she was a broad in Italy and her real mate was murdered. And they all said it was her even though it wasn't her. And she went through hell and back. These are essentially the same people. Yeah. NBC had interview the authors on this case. They even got a comment from Antonio who was more annoyed that the authors were accusing him of being impotent rather than accusing him of being the monster. He said straight up,
Starting point is 01:50:11 if Mario's wife were younger and prettier, I'd show them who isn't impotent. I'd show them right here right now on this table. And then another woman was killed. And guess who the police accused this time? There was headline set says, is this another monster? But no, the police did not time? There was headlines that says, is this another monster? But um, no, the police did not think it was another monster. Instead, they thought it was a mandanox. Yeah, that case. That I will be covering in upcoming weeks,
Starting point is 01:50:32 so I don't want to spoil it. But it all kind of weaves together in this show of craziness. And I think like in America, we were all sitting here like, how did the police do that to a mandanox? Why did they think that that was okay? And then you hear the story and you're like, oh, okay. I mean, I guess that's just what they do.
Starting point is 01:50:48 Here's the crazy part. The monster of Florence case was never reopened. They caught away. The monster got away. Now, you could say maybe it's one of the people that were arrested and released or Pietro who was arrested and then died in prison, but essentially, yeah, I think it was Antonio.
Starting point is 01:51:06 I think it was Antonio. I think Salvatore knew. I think Francesco knew. I think they were all there at the night of Barbara's murder. And I think Antonio went on to kill more people. What? I don't want to psychoanalyze, but I don't know. I'm just thinking his mom had passed away
Starting point is 01:51:20 when he was so young. He's had this void in his life. And sometimes a void isn't just sadness. Sometimes it turns to anger. And so maybe that's had this void in his life. And sometimes a void isn't just sadness, sometimes it turns to anger. And so maybe that's why he mutilated these women. There was this anger of his mom not being there for him when he needed her. And then also the fact that he's impotent allegedly,
Starting point is 01:51:35 maybe that also adds to the anger. Because the way that it, I mean, the killings happened, the boyfriend of the two was just shot. They all died rather quickly, but the girl was put through torture. So who did the police claim to be the killer? Oh, I think it was Pietro and then Mario, but I think now they're back on Pietro. The guy who already died. But I guess we're going to end this one with, who do you think the monster is?
Starting point is 01:52:00 And I hope you guys enjoyed this crazy story of one of the most notorious serial killers in Italy. I just, like if you read the book, you're gonna cry for the victims, you're gonna cry for the victims' families, but you're also gonna feel this burning frustration that just doesn't go away, that it's like so overpowering. I haven't been able to stop thinking about it. I don't know when I'm gonna stop thinking about it. So I hope you guys enjoyed and I'll see you guys on Sunday for the mini-sode. Bye! been able to stop thinking about it. I don't know when I'm going to stop thinking about it. So I hope you guys enjoyed and I'll see you guys on Sunday for the mini-sode. Bye!

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.