Rotten Mango - #353: CHAINED Woman Found In Shed Of Tiktoker’s Home, Went Viral, Then Disappeared From Internet

Episode Date: May 1, 2024

A family TikToker that posts wholesome videos with his 8 kids goes viral in China. HIs account starts blowing up with followers and a journalist decides it’s an easy story. Wholesome Tiktoker, wholesome interview, an easy article.  But when he gets to the man’s house - he notices something very odd. A woman.  Hidden inside his shed.  Chained.  He quickly records the woman before the TikToker notices. He exposes the wholesome TikToker but the question on everyone’s mind remains - who is the chained woman??? Netizens start digging but as they’re getting close - the video of the chained woman is wiped from the internet. Like she never existed.  How do they save her now?  To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

ramble badabing badaboom this video is going to look a little bit different i don't know if you guys watched the last one but i was sick for 2 weeks i'm fine now but i tried my best to research and do all these things in bed it just was not very good

but i'm back, i feel a thousand times better and we are working on a lot of very important cases right now we're working with a victim's family member on a case there's a lot of just strange things that have been happening that we want to bring these cases to you guys, but we want them to be good. So it's taking a little bit of time and we didn't want to go without any videos. So this is going to be the video that we are posting that is not totally new and fresh. This video was actually filmed maybe a year ago and it was posted on a different channel

of mine, a separate one called Stephanie Su. The story is about two different women in China who lived very drastically different lives. One woman was kidnapped by a TikToker, a Doi-inger influencer in China, and she was held hostage in his house for a very long time. And then another woman, she cried tears of joy 30 minutes before she was executed by the country for murder this was from a year ago uh i might look a little bit different i might sound a little bit different but i hope you guys enjoy and i will see you guys in the next one you're used to. I'm just gonna start with a universal truth, okay? You should never buy stuff illegally. I feel like that's just a global law, especially things that shouldn't be and can't be sold in the first place. Like pandas. Did you know that you can't buy a panda? Did you know that

all pandas are owned by China? They are only native in China and all the pandas that are in all the zoos across the world they're on loan from China. But it also means unlike any other animal, no other government, no other individual can own a panda. So in China, the punishment to buy a panda in the underground breeding market, which I assume is not that big of a breeding market, but if you do end up somehow buying a panda, you will be sentenced to more than 10 years in prison. That's actually less than I thought. They're considered national treasure, so it's a big deal.

I mean, yeah, but 10 years, that's the minimum sentence for buying a panda. That's a lot. I mean, there are people that have done worse things that get out in like two years. If you buy two parrots, special breed parrots, you will be sentenced to more than five years in prison in China. And I'm telling you this because recently a case in China has taught everyone that a woman is less than a panda and even less than two birds. Let's talk about the viral TikTok Daoying case of the chained woman. Okay, so there is like a whole niche of creators online

and you're gonna see them pop up from like all over the world on TikTok. Like you see them in America, Europe, Asia, Africa. They're called feel-good influencers. So it's not that they're happy. They're not influencers that are, you know, your happy place. They're literally in the business of making you feel good. So most of their videos, they go something like this. First video. This man right here is without a home. You guys, I'm gonna let him tell his story. Then the person will share their

struggles with being without a home and how that's impacted their lives, their children's lives, their family, and then later a follow-up video will be made using the donations that viewers have sent in where the man without a home is surprised with all the money. It's like this universal moment even if you don't understand the language because I've seen different countries do this and it pops up on my TikTok feed because because you know it's like a thing I do watch until the end okay and it's a moment of like intense understanding humanity hope for the future that we can all change the world, make it a better place.

And almost always, it's a select number of trending heartwarming uplifting music that is playing in the back. Listen, I'm not on these influencers. I hope that majority of these influencers are genuine because I'm literally on that side of TikTok. I will watch every single one of them. I will even donate to the GoFundMe

because it just makes my heart hurt. but in the end it also makes me and everyone else feel good, you know? You feel good in the end almost. You're on this like emotional journey, you feel so bad, you feel grateful for your life, you feel like you should be thankful for your things, and then you feel good in the end. They're in the business of making people feel good. And if these good positive energy influencers are legit, then they are changing the world. But in every industry where there are no regulations and there's money to be made,

how do you know if all of them are legit? How do you know which ones are hiding dark secrets behind their positive energy facade? Recently in China, a father of eight went viral on Douyin, which is the TikTok in China, and the dad's name is Dong Chimin. We're gonna call him Mr. D. It's literally like daddy of five all over again,

but daddy of eight. And I can see why everyone was just quickly obsessed, okay? I would probably be one of those people. Mr. D had a really intense story. His mom was in her 80s, and he was taking care of his disabled older brother. He had eight children that ranged from three years old to ten years old, and he was raising them all by himself in this tiny little village in China.

He had like no heat during the winters. They had no flooring in their house. It was just like dirt in the floor, and with no partner in sight to help him. He's like a single father of eight. But the crazy thing is, I mean, nobody would even blame Mr. D for being a sour mean old man, just a douchebag. Imagine that kind of pressure to feed that many people to do all this housework. You know, if he was a little bit mean nobody would be mad. His life was pretty miserable. But even though that he's barely making it by, the children have

no clothes, they have like no food, it was rough. He was such a happy positive person online. I'm not helping you. I'm just doing what I can. It's not easy for the kids to eat milk powder. Brother, have you ever regretted it? No, I don't regret it. If I had a big mouth, I would still be hungry. I still have a child. Now, although life is a little difficult, it doesn't mean that the children will grow up in the future. It's a little difficult. But it's a little difficult for the kids to grow up. My biggest dream is to slowly pull the kids out of the city

and watch them grow up. So his story starts getting attention on social media. Bigger TikTokers are reposting his videos, giving him shoutouts, being like, hey guys, look at this family, go follow them, go show them some love. Some of the local TikTokers that live in nearby cities or the towns, they would go and visit Mr. D

and they would draw more attention to Mr. D. They're like, go look at this family, guys. Look, I'm with this family, this is what we're doing, look at how he lives, guys, I'm gonna link his GoFundMe. It was like this whole ordeal. And the TikTokers, they would show the whole world the harsh truth that everyone likes to ignore. I mean, most of their audiences were like

in their heat controlled homes in the winter, laying in their clean sheets and blankets with the smell of dinner, seeping up and downstairs. But a good majority of the audience had never seen conditions like this. So it was eye-opening and it was what people call poverty porn in a lot of different industries, like the reality shows that show that,

yeah, we've talked about it before. That's like the label people put on it. So it was kind of a mixture of that. Like people were amazed at how tattered the clothings of the children were and it just was heartbreaking. They even interviewed Mr. D for their TikToks where he shared more about his life. They were like, okay well tell us about your life and he's like, okay well I receive maybe $430 from the government every month to feed all these kids.

That's not a lot. That's for everything. My housing, feeding them clothes. I mean I gotta make sure that they get to college. That's my dream. And the TikTok would end with the influencer saying, guys, please go follow Dadavade on Douyin. Please, and check the link to see how you can help their family and donate. I'm gonna make you a little bit of a to this family because I mean who wouldn't? And soon father of eight children gained like 200,000 followers on Dull Ying and he's like okay, I can make money this way, it's like the best way.

Which makes sense, nobody's dogging on him for that. So dad of eight children starts live streaming, accepting donations, accepting gifts, and in the early videos Mr. D would show his children and he tried to answer all the questions that were most frequently asked. Like, why do you have eight kids? And he said, I never had a wife until I was 34 years old. I was single and in the village, that's something that everyone looks down upon when you're single for that long. So when I finally got a wife, it just happened. We started having kid after kid after kid and

yeah, I guess it makes sense, you know, no judgment. Then another frequently asked question was, will you ever put up the kids for adoption? And he said without any hesitation, I wouldn't. As the children have already been born into my family, I have to raise them. They're my responsibility, you know. We never terminated any pregnancies. He was very proud of that by the way. You think of that, which you will. And he said, among the eight children, seven of them are more boys, and one of them is a girl. Now, this is where the story starts taking an interesting turn.

People are like, wait, what about the one child policy? What the fork is going on right now, okay? And people start asking, well, what are the kids' names? What should we call the kids? And he responded, well, you guys wanna know the kids' names, so the girl's name is Silver Phoenix. Literal translation. So it's not like a meaning. Okay, so you know how Chinese characters can have a deeper meaning and stuff? It's like that in Korea. If your name is Ji-Soo, the Ji has a meaning in the traditional

hanja, like the traditional Korean character, and then Soo has a meaning. So it could mean like beautiful angel, but the direct translation would not be CHI SU in English is beautiful angel. But his direct translation was like silver phoenix. Yeah, that's the meaning. Yeah. Yeah. That was like really direct. And then the boys had very peculiar meanings too. Names. Hong Kong. Aerospace. Hong Kong? Yeah. Hong Kong. His name is Hong Kong? Yeah. Hong Kong. Yeah. Interesting. Aerospace. Gold mountain. Silver Mountain, Treasury, International. Okay, so of course the viewers, I mean they had the same reaction like we did, which was like,

okay, we're not judging, but like, what? Who named these kids? Was there a meaning behind, you know, all these different names? There's got to be a story behind this. no one names their kids that without a good story Right and he calmly explained the story is the money from the gold mountain goes to the silver mountain Then it goes to the bank and the bank's money goes to the Treasury and if the Treasury is unable to keep the money It goes international or into aerospace or to Hong Kong What? Okay, so basically What in the world?

Basically, he was, I think, he was really adamant that at least one of his kids would have money. It's obvious that his education level isn't high. And that's how they usually name kids. I think it's also supposed to be like, okay, the money is going to end up in one of my kids' pockets. Because if it doesn't stay in the bank, it goes to the treasury. If it doesn't go there, it goes to this, and it goes to go there it goes to this and it goes To aerospace does that make sense? So he's like thought of all the loopholes of where the money could be sent and he was like got that covered got it covered Okay, I mean the sentiment of it all was just hope which is a good sentiment

We can get behind fine a little bit strange, but that's fine We can get behind some fun names people are naming their children all sorts of weird things I mean have you heard these celebrity kids names these days even weirder. I think the only frequently asked question that wasn't well answered was Where the hell is their mother? And all he would say was the children's mom is the hero of the family That was like it. Nobody wanted to push it because maybe he didn't want to air out the dirty laundry online Maybe he didn't want the kids to see him talking the mom Maybe the mom passed away and it was too sensitive of a subject. Maybe he didn't want the kids to see him talking to the mom. Maybe the mom passed away and it was too sensitive of a subject.

Maybe she cheated and left, right? Everyone tried to remain respectful. Like guys, stop asking, stop asking. Like we don't need to know, okay? That is until January 27th of 2022. The whole case blew up. I'm talking wide open. All of Douyin, TikTok, everything blew up. A famous TikTokker

had traveled to the village to do like a collab of sorts with the father of eight children. He wanted to show his followers how you know Mr. D was living and how they could help. And as he's browsing around the whole, taking some time to think about how to best film this type of video, he saw this little shed in the corner. It is like a very small shed that even upon his arrival, he had seen it, and in his head he's thinking, that's probably like a dog house, right? But there was a small door, and it wasn't boarded up.

There was no chains around the door. There was no like crazy padlock. And inside, he sees like a tiny pale person peeking out and staring at him. So he's like, okay, I'm going to go in there because that's really weird. Is that another child? Maybe that's the brother. I want to meet this person. He goes into the shed and he sees that there is a woman in there that looks hungry, malnourished. There was evidence of torture. She was chained to the wall through her neck, like a dog collar, and it was chained to the wall through her neck like a dog collar and it was chained to the wall.

She scurried back when he saw her and this is where it just starts really getting crazy, okay? He runs into the shed and he's filming the situation. Inside the shed, there's a woman and a tiny mattress on the ground. That's about it. The woman was in freezing cold winter. She was barefoot, very thin clothes on, and chained up. Even her food was given to her in like a dog bowl. There was a food bowl that was just kind of sitting on the ground and inside of it was just frozen kanji, which kanji is like rice boiled in water. It's not very a nutritious-ly dense dish. There was a cold steamed bun on top The only warmth that she had was like this moldy beat up blanket if you could even call it a blanket

Honestly, I think it's too thin to even be called a towel. Yeah, she was standing there and um her eyes You can see it in the video briefly I don't know if that's how I would describe it, but people keep saying they look glassed over. Like she looks like she hasn't been herself in years. You know, it looks like her soul had been ripped out of her. She only had a couple teeth left, and even when she tried to talk, she was slurring her words. 冷吗?不冷。我给你拿个衣服穿上吧。 我给你拿个衣服穿上吧。 我给你拿个衣服去,好不好?

我给你拿件衣服。 我看你再用爱心一次卷出衣服, 我给你拿一件。 你饭凉了吗? 饭凉了吗? 你能不能,我这样说话, 你能不能听懂我给你说话? 能听懂吧?

不能? 是不是能听懂一点点? I'm talking like this, can you understand me? Can you understand me? No? I can't understand you. Can you understand me a little bit? No, I can't. You can't? Put down the chopsticks. You can still eat this, right? she seemed incredibly timid. He asked her if she was cold and whether she could understand him and she shook her head repeatedly.

He was genuinely shocked. He looked up at the camera and he said what has this woman gone through in this cold weather? Where did all the donations go? This is a child's clothes. You can wear it. You can wear it on the boat. Let me ask you. The weather.

You can take a look. The weather is like this. When we were in the army, where did our love went somewhere. Put this down. It's cold. Put it on. I'll hold it for you. Is it cold?

The video ended and he posted it online. And this is what blew the case up. I mean the question remained and lingered and everyone that was watching was you know, who the hell is she? Where did she come from? Where why she chained up? Where is her family? Why did nobody care that there's a woman chained up in the shed like they didn't try to hide her that well So are you're telling me no neighbors knew no villagers came over and never investigated this shed So these people they're blowing the netizens are blowing up the comments like we gotta do something, which like, yeah, we do.

But the TikToker who posted this original video, he made a response and he was like, you guys don't have to call the police. I just wanted everyone to care for the poor family and urge the father to treat his wife well with the help of the public opinion. Wait, the TikToker who exposed this story? Yeah. Post the story saying you guys donToker who exposed this story? Yeah.

Posts the story saying you guys don't have to freak out anymore? Yeah, like we're handling it, and this is his wife and he's gonna treat her well. And that's all I wanted. Meanwhile, the father of eight children was still active and he was responding to all the questions and the backlash. Like, can you imagine that he's still active

on social media right now? And he's saying that, hey guys, everyone, this is not like a kidnapped woman. My wife was mentally unstable and she was pretty violent. So to prevent her from smashing things and hurting my elderly mother, or even the children, I chained her up in an isolated room in the house. Like a dog? Yeah. In the freezing cold?

This was his defense. This was his like, Hey guys, like don't be mad at me because I have a good reason. Okay. And then he said, but whenever she was not violent, I would let her out. That was his best argument. Wow. That was his defense.

So yeah, no, the public was like not satisfied. So the video starts circulating everywhere and the internet theories are going crazy. Some speculate that she was human trafficked rather than being a mentally unstable wife and mother. Some thought that she was an insane mother. And some people were even commenting, if she's insane, then I'm worried that her kids have mental illnesses that were passed down.

Some people commented, I think that she probably was good looking and mentally stable, but because she had been chained and trafficked and probably assaulted, she gradually went insane. She can be insane and still a victim. You guys know that, right? Another comment read, she doesn't look very old. Why did her teeth all fall out? Someone made a wild guess under that comment and said, maybe she bit someone to defend herself while they tried assaulting her and they broke her teeth off. another theory was the woman was probably abducted when she was like

12-13 years old. i heard that mr d and his brothers and even his own father used to use the chained woman and nearby villagers knew about it but nobody intervenes because all the villagers are like animals. So very quickly, Mr. D goes from this like loving father of eight children to human trafficker overnight. Listen, no angle of this is looking good for this guy. Even if what he said is true, who chains up their mentally ill wife? Like who does that? People replayed the video over and over and over again and tried to decipher what she was saying because remember I said that she was slurring her words. She didn't seem fully there Somewhere far away, it's impossible for me to leave.

The world doesn't want me anymore. The world doesn't want me. And netizens all agreed that she was saying these couple of phrases, will they let me back? They would never let me back. The world doesn't want me. The room is full of this. That's what they gathered.

And it completely set this whole thing on fire. Everyone was outraged, like rightfully so. And they started a nationwide campaign for justice, for answers. And finally, someone other thanckers responded to the backlash the county the county that the village was in and I said, hey guys Calm your tits. We are going to be interviewing the locals. We're gonna do like an investigation Okay, and we're gonna work with the local medical institutions to get you some answers and in their announcement They told the public there's no human trafficking in this case okay like we

know this no one's being human trafficked y'all you guys need to calm down these internet theories are wild this woman was not abducted and second you know she is chained up because she's mentally ill and she beats people so we're gonna handle this thank you for your concern internet yeah that went over really well the internet was like okay that's a good day. Let's call it a night, guys. Let's go on Twitter and do something else. Yeah, no. What kind of response was that? That only made everyone feel like something extra shady was going on.

Are the authorities involved? Why are the authorities on this random dude's side when it's clear that he's chained up a woman in his shed? Netizens wanted to know, okay, if she's not abducted, whose daughter is she? Like, we're not gonna rest until her biological family, not her little husband and his family, her biological family come forward

and tell us that she was never taken and that she's fine. Second, just because you're mentally ill, does that mean anyone can chain you to a cold, shabby shed and force you to give birth to eight children back to back? How is that not a say? The initial response only angered the netizens more and it just added more fuel to the fire. And finally, Fengshan County?

Fengshan. Fengshan County was forced to release a second announcement, stating that the woman's name was Yang Qingsha, and they said Ms. Yang was a woman without a home. She was begging for help when she came across Mr. D's house and his family let her stay with them. She was battling all sorts of mental illnesses at the time, but the two fell in love. So Ms. Yang and Mr. D fell in love and decided to get married. So yeah, that's what happened. So there should be paperwork, right, of the marriage certificate.

Well no, the authorities said don't even try looking for it because Mr. D said that the staff who did their marriage registration, they were negligent and they did not identify Miss Young's identity, so it was complicated was complicated yeah we don't really have like an ID for her like an actual physical copy of the ID but she's Miss Young we're pretty sure yeah and and she's married and those are her eight children we did a DNA test we even gave government subsidies to the family they were like saying this as a flex they were like you know we gave them $400 a month for eight kids don't even get me started on that.

Like, someone get the county a PR team. They also mentioned that the chained woman, allegedly Ms. Young, had been sent to the hospital for psychiatric treatment, and they never denied, confirmed, or even mentioned human trafficking, assault, forced birthing, abuse. None of that, again, in their second report. So yeah, their second report went over just as well as the first one.

The netizens and journalists alike were so fed up, they started traveling to the village to demand answers. What? Meanwhile, netizens were doing some detective work because I mean, the police aren't doing it, right? They found a woman that had gone missing like 26 years ago. Her name was Lee Ying, and she was 12 when she went missing.

She had this very like sweet looking face, very soft features, double eyelids, a round face, a small mole in the corner of her mouth. And the missing person's report stated, she went to school one day and just never came home. Netizens did a comparison of the facial proportion. So this is like, I know it's kind of tricky to see if this is like viable, but usually the proportion of like your chin to your lip to ratio,

they say it does get bigger as you age, but it stays pretty consistent. Like the gap between your nose and your top lip, it stays pretty consistent. You know, these types of proportions in your face. And they put the missing posters, missing poster flyer picture picture as well as the chained woman's picture that was screen grabbed from the video and they looked kind of similar I'm not gonna lie to you so they're like okay maybe this is the woman and it's not miss young because nobody believes the county with anything they say they don't even believe that this is miss young because if she's human traffic do you think that

they would put her real name on the marriage certificate? Get out of here. No, they wouldn't. The chained woman was also said to have a thick Sichuan accent and the missing girl was from that region. So now the authorities are getting even more dragged because it looked like the internet was doing more for this woman than they were, which the internet was. So they were forced to come out with a third statement. They said Miss Young has been identified and that's not her name. Sorry guys. Sorry third statement. They said, Ms. Yang has been identified. And that's not her name. Sorry guys, sorry, sorry. Don't hate us, okay?

They're saying the name that they gave first time was not it. Yeah. What? Yeah, they're like, not my fault. Not my fault, not my fault, guys. It was the county registration person's fault. It's not my fault. Her real name is Xiaohuamei.

We're gonna call her Mei. And she's from the Yunnan province. Now, both of her parents are dead, and a report claimed that a neighbor on the request of Mei's parents went out to find Mei a good husband. You know, her parents were worried because Mei wasn't a good catch.

She was battling some mental illnesses. She had slurred speech. So the neighbor and Mei went out to search for her husband and in the process they got separated, right? You know how that happens. And the neighbor never called the police to let them know. Never let May's parents know either, just came back home and was like, yeah, she's married.

May's parents had no idea to whom, to where, like nothing. And to show you a map, to get from the province that May was originally from with the neighbor to the Place she was found it was across the country and China is a big country the county also claimed that May lost her teeth due to a genetic issue and not abuse and Other than that they said that she was in a good mental and physical state and like guys Move on where are the Kardashians? Move on everyone. Nothing to see. They also claimed that they did DNA testing and all eight children were Mays and I still don't know what the county was thinking

This was just not a great announcement and the public they still didn't understand. Okay, if this is true Why did nobody care that May was gone? And also how did she get from the other side of China to this village? And you know what, here's a really good question. Why the fuck was she chained? Like none of this answers why the fuck she was chained. None of it.

So because she was missing, she can be chained? Because she's mentally ill, she can be chained? Like, what are you saying? And mind you, up until this point, nothing was happening to Mr. D. He was a free man with no consequences. In fact, oddly during this time Um, a wedding company had asked him to be a- him to be a spokesperson. A wedding company. The public went insane They said how can a scum who chains his wife up and treats her like a birth-giving machine talk about happy marriages?

What on earth is going on right now? But back to the chained woman, who is she? So was she Li Ying whose face matched up according to the netizens or was she Mei? You know Li Ying's uncle came forward to ask for a DNA test because based on the videos and photos he was sure that was his niece who had been missing since she was 12. You know the one that was walking home from school? Again this announcement only made people question the county more. Everything, everything that the county said just felt so fishy at this point. Even if they start telling the truth,

nobody would believe them. That's how people felt. So the county issued a fourth statement, February 10th of 2022. They said, hey everyone, calm down, okay? This woman is not Lee Ying. Geez, this is May. We found May's half sister.

We did a DNA test and it confirmed that this woman is not Lee Ying. Geez, this is Mei. We found Mei's half-sister, we did a DNA test, and it confirmed that this woman is not Lee Ying, but Mei! Who, I mean, technically by all definitions went missing, but it was just never reported. And okay fine, you know how we said there was no human trafficking involved? Maybe there was a little. We don't know. We're gonna, we're gonna, we're gonna look into it, okay? So it just left a bad taste in everyone's mouth because in the beginning, the county was like, oh my God, absolutely, you guys are, the county was literally gaslighting the internet.

Like you guys are crazy, there's no human trafficking, what are you talking about? And now, now that people are getting upset and the anger, the outrage is not dying down, they're like, we will, good point, we're gonna look into it, you know? But still, no answers. If this is May and she did go missing

because her neighbor took her out of the city or the village, who took her? Why didn't the neighbor report her missing? Why didn't she call the police? What happened from that day that she went missing to all the way to today because that's decades? And how come Mr. D is not arrested? Like what has this woman gone through?

Let the woman speak. It was so frustrating that a few volunteers drove all the way to the village, tried to break into the hospital that May, the chained woman was in, that was heavily guarded, which by the way, and they snuck in, tried to talk to May, but they were kicked out and those volunteers went missing for a week. They lost contact with their friends, their family, they stopped posting online, wouldn't talk to anyone, they went dark for a week. They were arrested right? Yeah. Wow. Which of course this incident blew up even more. Two women try to save a woman and now these two women are in jail with god knows

what happening to them. So this incident blows up more. Meanwhile other netizens are getting riled up. The DNA results were never posted and even May's sister said that she had DNA taken from her, and the police told her that's her half-sister, but they never provided the actual physical results. And everyone that knew May said that when she was younger, that just doesn't make sense. Like, this doesn't feel like it's May. So what if the county is just lying all over again?

The public was dead set that this was Li Ying, and all the trust in the local officials was out the window and gone, and nobody was trusting them ever again. And then scandal after scandal and discrepancies, and then people started doing the math. They're like, wait, if this is Mei, and they said that she went missing in this year and she was this old, if you did the math with all her children, that means that she had her first kid in her 20s, and then she had back to back kids in her 40s? That doesn't even make sense.

People are like, I don't even understand. And she wasn't even going to the hospital for the kids, for seven of her kids. So she's in her 40s, having like a peak in fertility out of nowhere, and then giving birth in the shed? what's going on? so from 42 years old to about 50 years old she gave birth to seven kids? like none of this is making sense. are we sure that this is May? like people were just getting more and more confused and then internationally it became a whole thing. so this got so much attention nationally and it also happened to coincide with the Beijing Winter Olympics. A lot of the big publications

internationally, I believe the New York Times was one of them, and they had posted articles that were titled and I quote, who is the real China? Aileen Gou or the chained woman? And a quote started circulating. When no one is paying attention to the chained woman people could see her on the internet but when the whole world is paying attention to her we can no longer see her a lot of allegations were that China was censoring and suppressing the story especially after it went a little bit more international with enough outrage they kind of had to do something even though they were suppressing the story

as much as they think they could have I think okay personally allegedly they were suppressing the story people were still they think they could have. I think, okay personally, allegedly they were suppressing the story. People were still outraged. They were not getting over it. So the province came out. So this is basically like a going from a county investigation to like a state investigation. The province came out and was like, hey we're gonna investigate. Don't worry. We got this. Trust us. The public was a bit more optimistic that there would be results. And a week later results came out. A 6,000 word detailed report on their investigation. So finally, the truth had come. The chained woman was Mei from Yunnan.

The DNA showed that the woman was Mei and not Li Ying. And as for the picture that showed that Li Ying and the chained woman were similar in appearance, apparently it was edited before it was posted. So the viral picture that was circulating with the proportion lines and everything, that was kind of altered a bit. So it's a bit misleading. So what the hell happened to Mei? Her parents had gotten divorced. Mei moved to a new city with just her mom. You know, at the age of 17, everyone who knew her said that, you know, she was a very physically and mentally well young girl.

She gets married at 17. That marriage lasted about two years and when she divorces and joins her mom again, everyone is shocked. They're like, this is not the Mae that we knew. She has slurred speech. She has very different behavioral discrepancies. I mean they believe that she was suffering from, if not one or many mental illnesses. So a year later, a neighbor named Sang took her to a neighboring village by request of Mae's mom. Mae is like, listen, Mae needs a husband. She's getting old. She's not a good catch. Take her to like one of the villages and see if someone will marry her, you know? Please. And the neighbor, Sang, was not just just a neighbor they were a human trafficker

wow they had already done a prison stint for child trafficking and that is how 21 year old May became a trafficking victim Sang sold May to a man in a local village for $620 and after about four months May ran away and somehow she wandered around 400 miles away from where the first purchase happened. And a couple took her in. This is a restaurant owner. And for a month she was okay. She was eating, you know, she was being housed, she was helping out around the restaurant. And then they decided to sell her to migrant workers at a nearby construction site. Basically she was sold again to construction workers. And these construction workers were like, let's take her to our hometown, which is the village that Mr. D lived in.

And they were like, we don't really want her, we don't really need her, so let's sell her to someone in the village. They sold her to Mr. D's dad when he was still alive. So May had been sold like an animal three times. And finally she was sold to Mr. D as the wife. Now on the registration forms, she was forced to use. D as the wife. Now, on the registration forms, she was forced to use a fake name so that nobody knew who she was

because, you know, it's illegal to buy a wife. And from there, it just seemed like her life is pretty horrible. It wasn't as horrible as being chained up because it seems like she gave birth to her son in a hospital, and at that hospital, because of China's one-child policy, they put an IUD into her body,

which means she can't get pregnant again. It's like those little copper things that they stick in your cervix. And about 10 years later, the IUD was ineffective. So we don't know when she started getting chained up. It could have been like a year after she gave birth to her son, six months. It could have been like five years.

But we know that she was chained for a while. The IUD became ineffective, and she was having this surge of reproductive hormones. And she was getting assaulted. And she gave birth seven more times from the time that she was 34 years old to the time that she was 43 years old. The longest gap between kids was 14 months, which is insane. Before she was chained up,

and if she had not been found by a TikTokker, she had no idea how many more years or how much longer she would even survive being chained up. Once the report was released, the authorities confirmed that they did arrest Mr. D for abuse, as well as several other county leaders who did the investigation. They carried it out the way they did,

as well as people who were willing to turn a blind eye on marriage registrations like these people that worked in the marriage registration office they knew what was going on They didn't ask her for her ID because they knew that she was a purchased woman This case drew a lot of attention to the fact that in these villages just all around the world not just in China It is still not uncommon to buy wives to buy human beings and And just in this province, since 1986, close to 50,000 women have been sold and bought by traffickers. And that's just the ones we know of. Even villagers who knew said that they weren't surprised. This isn't something new or wild. They said in

villages, women are sold like pigs and dogs because they saved the village. Because what kind of woman wants to live in a village and have a bunch of kids so that they can work in the fields? No woman But Mr. D will probably get off light because in the criminal law of China it reads that the crime of buying abducted women and children shall be sentenced to a fixed term imprisonment of not more than three years Are you freaking kidding me? Sometimes it's jail, sometimes it's public service. So-

What? Yeah, in this like province area. So- I mean, this is basically kidnapping. Yeah. And assault sexual essay. It's kind of a loophole from what I read and tell me if my research is incorrect on this one

because it was getting really complex because it's like the code of law and it's constantly changing, and also translation. I did have professional translators with help me on this one, but kidnapping a woman, you get a higher sentence. But for some reason, when you buy a kidnapped woman, like it's like a different sentence.

So when you're the kidnapper, you get a different sentence. I feel like- What's worse, right? That's what I'm saying, but it's like, it's kind of a weird, like a really weird thing. I don't know why. A lot of people in China are saying this is the case that really showed the true colors, that a woman is still considered less than a panda, and even two parrots.

And to make things worse, some netizens even took to the internet to blame the chained woman. They said, now that the case is clear, did the public get what they want? Just because of your so-called morality and wokeness, the family is torn apart, the children don't have a mother, and the man doesn't have a wife, and the children don't have a father, and you know what the most pitiful person is the chained girl. If one of her eight kids had been successful, she would have been well taken care of for the rest of her life. But that hope is all gone now. Insinuating that since she's been freed, she has no hope that one of her kids

will succeed and support her later on. I can't believe this. Yeah, so if that's true, okay let's just chain everyone back up. Another person wrote, besides no matter how righteous the government is, family ties are not as important anymore these days. There's already no love from the mother and now the father's gone. What will the children feel? Probably not good. To that someone responded.

Finally, someone with brain cells. They wrote, the young children are innocent, but the kidnapped mother is more innocent. To sympathize with her best is to stab the chained mother. And that is the story of the TikToker who chained a woman up and almost got away with it. Wow, that is so dark. I don't even know how to like feel about this case or how to dissect this case

because there's so many different weird levels to this. And just, I think definitely just the fact that it was happening during the Beijing Winter Olympics, it just adds such a even more depressing like anytime when there's a crime happening it feels like there's like ten worlds going on. Like how can all these things happen in the same world? Just doesn't make sense. I'm gonna play you the video of this woman's last words and I don't even speak Chinese but for some reason it just like got to me. My fiance showed me this.

I had no idea what crime she committed. I had no idea why she was about to die but just watch. What did you tell your family? I hope my parents are doing well Anything else? We will take him to the police station and hand him over to the police What did you ask Wang Zijian? Why did you ask him the first time you saw him? I don't know You said you wanted him to stay

You are willing to let her stay Really? Why are you so happy? She is afraid of being relieved What did you tell your parents? So this clip goes viral, and just to give you some context, this woman right here is a hospital worker that's about to be executed and she was asked if she had any last words and she just responds really emotionlessly like she's no longer even here on the planet like she's accepted her fate she just says I hope my parents are doing well like I feel remorse for my parents I feel sorry to them and that was it it's like the

most standard textbook type of response but the interviewer who worked for the news station decided to pull a shot, to press on. So she brings up this woman's boyfriend, the one that was about to be executed for murder because they killed somebody together, and the interviewer says, I know I probably shouldn't tell you this, but just, you know, because you're going to die anyway. Your boyfriend is no longer being executed. His sentence was commuted to life in prison and you just see this woman's face. she starts crying like tears of joy of happiness. she's like nodding and crying and it's oddly emotional and oddly moving. she said at least one of us is going to live and I'm not holding him back anymore." 30 minutes

later she was executed and this huge clip almost became like a morality debate for years to come like is this woman evil is she not evil did she deserve this I mean it seems like she has a soul she's like so excited that her boyfriend's gonna live is her boyfriend evil did he manipulate her did she manipulate him so let's answer all those fricking questions because it gets wild. It all started at the hospital, the fricking hospital. So Dr. Feng is like a big name in the hospital.

I mean, his name wasn't on the building or anything like that, but he ran the hospital technically. He was the director of the hospital personnel department. He was very well compensated for his position and he was able to negotiate like a ton of benefits when he took this job. So he's walking around shoulders tall, like he owns the goddamn place. I mean, he is, he is an accomplished guy. I will give him that.

He grew up in China, graduates college and he's like, I'm going to go to the United States. He goes, he starts going through the ranks and he eventually ends up at Columbia university to do research. Later goes to Harvard University to study molecular biology. What does that even mean? Then he gets married to an ophthalmologist, right? And then the two of them just have kids.

Listen, they're like winning the American dream. And then he gets a call from his old college in China. And they're like, we want you back. We wanna give you a prestigious directorial position. Like we miss you. We heard you've been doing great things in the United States. Come back.

So he couldn't say no. His wife is confused like, what do you mean you can't say no? Our kids want to be here. Our kids are practically American. You know, their whole lives are here. My practice is here. Do you not care that I'm a fucking ophthalmologist?

Like hello? Like what do you mean you're not gonna say no? And he ends up going. He's like, yeah, whatever. I'm taking the kids. I'm sure you'll find your way back to China too ophthalmologist like hello like what do you mean you're not gonna say no and he ends up going he's like yeah whatever i'm taking the kids i'm sure you'll find your way back to china too because you just like need us so much and the wife was like absolutely not uh needless to say it resulted in a pretty messy divorce obviously so dr fang goes back to china gets into his little workplace and he loves it i mean immediately everybody respects him. They

all praise him with these powerful words like, Dr. Feng you were born to be a leader. I don't know. Nowadays after all those cult stories I'm like anytime I hear someone was born to be a leader I'm like you gotta run the other way. You gotta go as far away from that person as possible because I don't think that's a good thing anymore. They're like Dr., you are someone I would blindly follow. You're just so smart. I mean, he was intelligent. He was, you know, competent. He was respectable. He was a natural leader, some may say. It was normal to see nurses and other doctors just excitedly greeting Dr. Feng in the hallways, but there was always like this one, one employee that was a bit more lively a bit more cheerful than the rest

She looked like she freaking loved her job, which is rare and well being head of the personnel department He was like I like that. I like that energy. I wish everybody had that energy That's how I pump up the vibes in this hospital So when his 40th birthday came around dr. Fang's like I'm I'm going to go out with all my coworkers and we're going to get drunk. He's like, hey, that random girl that always greeted me so excitedly, looks so happy to be at work. What's her name? Let's freaking invite her to the party. So her name was Guo Shuang.

I'm going to call her SG because listen, I'm going to trigger this guy with my pronunciation the whole time. So SG was 22 years old, she was just trying the best that she could. I mean, who isn't at 22? Like, who's just living the best life? I mean, that's what she was doing. It's 2005, she graduates from college,

she studied medicine, but she didn't go to med school. She studied nursing, but she didn't go to nursing school, so she was kind of stuck in the middle. Like, I can't go be a nurse, I can't really have these title jobs, but I want to work in the hospital. So she gets an opening at this very hospital, and her parents are retired at this point.

She's feeling the pressure. She's like, I gotta provide for them. So they're getting old. She's down to take anything at this point. She sees this position, and it was, it's kind of like a position where you're just administration, but not even really. You're an assistant to administration.

You're doing some paperwork here and there, but you're fetching coffees. You're cleaning up messes, literal messes. It wasn't prestigious. It wasn't in the field that you wanted, but at least it was in a hospital. So she was a part-time worker, a temporary worker, which meant the pay was even less. She had no benefits, no control over her schedule. She didn't even know if she was going to even work 20 hours that week. She could have just been cut from the schedule. But SG was the type that felt like, if I work hard, they're going to make me full time. So she puts up with

all the horrible treatment, all the being the end of the group, having to fetch people's coffees, you know? And every single day she saw any superiors in the hallways, she would just be so excited. Like, hello, Mr. Dr. Feng, like, happy to be at work. So when Dr. Feng invites her to his 40th birthday party, I mean, she's freaking over the moon. This meant her hard work is finally paying off. She's gonna go make this amazing impression on her superiors and hopefully she would get

that full-time position, right? She didn't know that Dr. Feng wasn't thinking about a full-time position, but rather a position for being his girlfriend. So during his birthday party, he just kept pushing more and more drinks on SJ. And I feel like it's similar to Korean culture, SJ found it really hard to turn down his superior's drinks, when he kept insisting that she take another shot and another shot. And she's with her work bosses.

They're all doctors. She felt safe. I mean, think about it. Even if she's drunk and she tripped and fell, with her work bosses. They're all doctors. She felt safe. I mean, think about it, even if she's drunk and she tripped and fell, they knew what to do, right? They could clean her up. If she had alcohol poisoning, they knew what to do. I mean, can you think of a place that you would feel more safe drinking

than in a room full of doctors? But SG was still worried when she felt her vision started to blur and she's like walking and tripping over the stools and over the table ledges She's like, okay keep calling like it's okay. I gotta put a good impression. I gotta walk straight But why did she feel so drowsy? So dr. Feng couldn't take it anymore. He laughs and he gets up and he's like, alright party's over I guess you guys have fun on me. I'm gonna take the rookie SG home. Guess

she's not used to the way that we party as doctors am I right? So everyone's waving. They're not thinking anything of it. I mean this is a nice guy. Yeah have fun like SG's in good hands. SG thought so too. She just remembered being in his car and then the next thing she remembered was waking up in his bed and immediately she was crying. Immediately. There was no like oh my god what happened happened? She knew what happened. Come on. So instead of driving SG home, Dr. Feng thought, why not bring her to my house? She's already losing consciousness. It'll be so easy to rape her. And in the morning, I can just tell her that she came on to me. Like he knew what he was doing was bad, but whatever. That's how the world worked. That's what he's thinking to himself. Besides,

SG would probably be so embarrassed that she slept with her boss that she would scurry out of his apartment. He had no idea that SG would wake up bawling her eyes out. That was not according to the plan. I mean, 23-year-old SG is laying in that bed. Her life just feels like it's been shattered to glass. Her hope in the world was gone.

Not only is she traumatized, but this is like the worst way to be traumatized. She's thinking, if I can't even trust a respectable man, my boss, who on this planet can I trust? I mean, she just had this image of Dr. Feng as a mentor, a leader, someone who looked out for his subordinates, but then that just shattered like glass. It's like everyone in the world is so full of deception

and nobody is good and you can't trust any- She was having like a quarter-life crisis. She was genuinely having a moment of like, what the fuck? She thought this were people that looked really gross and they come up to you and they harass you and catcall you and they like Spike your drink. She never thought it would be her respectable boss who studied at Columbia and Harvard and everybody respected him Dr. Feng was shocked too. Not at himself for being a disgusting deplorable human being, but I guess he really didn't think that SG would have such a strong reaction to the assault. He thought that she would just blame herself and push it under the

rug, which honestly is so sick when you think about it. So to try and defuse the situation, Dr. Feng offers SG a compromise. He's like, she's too emotional. She is unpredictable. I don't know if she's gonna go tell the cops. I don't know if she's gonna go tell my bosses. So to keep her quiet, he's like, I'm so sorry. I'm so sorry that this happened to you. You know, violence against women is never okay. I take it very seriously. But how about I help you out? I can try to make sure that you're offered full time the minute a position opens up. SG left Dr. Feng's apartment and she didn't agree, she didn't say anything, she just like literally left in tears. But when she gets home, you know,

she's thinking about it. And this is the part that people really come at SG for. They say she must have not hated the assault if she went back for more. But SG from that point decided to sleep with Dr. Feng now. Psychologists say that there's like a ton of reasons that victims will actually choose to sleep with their assaulters after their trauma. One of the main ones being if I choose it this time then it feels like the last time it happened the actual assault was an assault right? Like it makes me feel like I'm regaining the power and if I chose it this time that means I didn't actually experience this intense

Unconsensual thing last time right? It's not that bad. It's like a way for your brain to protect yourself things like assault are so nuanced I feel like we're just touching the surface We have stories where people victims fight the whole way through and immediately go to the police after but in most cases I think it's because so many people know they're a solter or their lives are connected with the rapist that it just becomes so nuanced and complicated. If it's a boss that could jeopardize your career, if it's a schoolmate that could ruin your reputation and make you a social outcast, if it's a family member that can uproot the entire family ecosystem, I mean, we're just, it's too complex, right?

So people seem to do things that almost seem unfathomable to other people. But all I'm saying is nobody really knows what they would do in that situation unless they've been in that situation. So SG starts an intimate relationship with Dr. Feng. And I think there was another reason for it too, other than her trying to convince herself that she had the power here. Psychologists agree that this is very normal for victims who are

assaulted by people who have power over them. So Dr. Fang had offered SGA full time position at work and at first she was disgusted and traumatized but maybe when she got home she reasoned with herself like, listen, this terrible horrible thing has happened to you but it's in the past. Like you can't even change it. What can you do? There's in the past. Like you can't even change it. What can you do? There's no way to go back and rewrite history. You can't go to the cops, they're not gonna believe you.

You can't go to your boss, he's your boss. You know, it's like his word against yours. This is rape culture. So yeah, you've been assaulted, humiliated, and now you're unemployed if you do something. Or maybe you get something out of it. Maybe you can win something, right? Take advantage of the situation. If you sleep with him, maybe he will feel forced to give you a full-time position. Yeah, it's like your brain trying to survive basically. Yeah, and

like try to like reason, okay well if I get something out of it then it's fine. But from the outside, what a lot of people people saw was oh this is a girl who's like sleeping her way to the top and she's mad that people found out about it or that it stopped working but before then SG was promoted to a full-time position it's so frustrating so people were really coming at her for the fact that she did get promoted to a full-time position now dr, Dr. Feng being the complete asshole that he is, I don't even know what to say. Like, he's a freaking squad, okay?

He didn't even give her the full benefits. He was like, oh, since you're transferring like to part-time to full-time, I'm just gonna like give you full-time. But usually all the full-time people that were hired, they got housing benefits, they got an allotment for housing, they got all of these things,

they got amazing different health cares. She got nothing. She just got a full-time position and she was just grateful to have 40 hours a week where she was guaranteed to get paid as long as she did her job well. So now with this full-time status SG is hopefully hoping that she can transfer to a different hospital soon, one that's connected to this one. She wanted to see what Dr. Feng could do about it. This would be the least that he could do after traumatizing her for the rest of her life, right? She just wanted a full-time job and to transfer so that she didn't have to be around him anymore.

But Dr. Feng was getting annoyed. She was asking for too much and essentially he slammed the door shut in her face. So as she tries to move on, she doesn't have to see him anymore because he's upset with her for demanding too much. For demanding too much, you know? They would just nod at each other awkwardly in the hallways and that was about it. So all the while this is happening. He just blew it out. So all the while this is happening.

She goes out with her cousin one night to blow out some steam and they run into Zijian Wang? Wang Zijian And we're gonna call him Z. So they know each other's cousins. Anyway, he's like a nice guy He's freaking 18 years old and SG at this point is 25 or something or 23 So again a little bit a little bit. He's very young. That's all I have to say, but it's fine He's of age they start dating and Ashi just felt like Z was mature. He was someone that liked to take care of others and take care of her and he was listening to her.

She felt secure enough that a month after dating, she just told him everything. This is what happened at work. This is what Dr. Feng did to me. And then two weeks later, she brings him a pregnancy test. It was positive. She knew it was in Z's. The only person that it could be possibly was Dr. Feng's. She goes to Dr. Feng and she

tells him and without even a moment's thought about it, about if she wanted it or like how terminating a pregnancy can be so traumatic for patients, nothing. She had no power over her body. He dragged her to the hospital and forced her to get an abortion right then and there. And this was when all hell broke loose. SG was a freaking mess. Like I think all of that trauma was behind this like powerful wall and she was trying to hold on tight. And then eventually this, this is the straw that broke the camel's back. So she's telling Z about everything that's going on and like he's listening intently. You could see his ears are turning red like

he's angry. I mean who wouldn't be like what kind of boyfriend wouldn't be? He felt genuine pure hatred for the first time in his life. That's how he describes it like genuine hatred and that is how the whole tragic story began. Both of them say that it was they that brought up the whole idea of killing Dr. Feng. SG said, it was me. I hated Dr. Feng. I wanted to get, you know, revenge. I wanted to ruin him or at least make sure that he could never assault someone again. If you know what I mean, I wanted to castrate him. Does that make sense? I told Z what I thought about it and he asked if this was the

only way that I could move on and to heal and to be a whole person again and I said yeah, that is. That's the only way and I want you to help me. She claims that Z thought about it for a while and finally he agreed and they started planning. Meanwhile Z said we both felt like Dr. Feng needed to die in order to like let this darkness get out of SG's mind I mean she needed this she wanted to kill him so together we started planning so even now it feels like Z is like kind of covering for her now I mean regardless of who started the planning it was in motion and there was no stopping it 23 year old SG and 18 year old Z went out together to buy a large hammer and some surgical blades. They genuinely

wanted to castrate this guy. They didn't want to kill him, they just wanted to take his little thing off so that he could never hurt another woman again. September 30th 2006 at 4 p.m. after work SG tells Dr. Fang that she needs to show him something and it's very important that she had to drive him there and show him it. I don't think that Dr. Feng wanted to go, but I think that he was curious because what if he didn't go? She would go to the police. What if she was unstable? What if she was showing him like a shrine? What if she was showing him, you know, evidence that she had of the assault? So he hopped into her car. He's like, uh,

who's the guy in the back? Oh, don't worry about him, that's my little brother. Okay, okay, that's weird. And the three silently head off in the car that S.J. is driving with Dr. Fang in the passenger seat and Zee in the back just sitting quietly, he's not even talking. But then slowly, as they're getting out of the city and you see less buildings, less people walking around,

less cars on the road and you see wooded areas less people walking around, less cars on the road, and you see wooded areas and fields and nobody for miles, Dr. Fang starts to get nervous. Where are we going? And Z said he talked first. He said, Dr. Fang, I know what you did, and we wanna make something clear to you. We're giving you a chance right now

that you're going to make SG a formal employee with full benefits within three business days and let her transfer to another hospital with housing accommodations and everything. And if you do that within the next three business days, we're not going to hurt you. So yeah, consider this a threat. I can't do that. Even if I genuinely wanted to, I don't have the authority to do something like that. Okay, then I guess it's too late. And in the back seat, Z takes out the surgical blade and slices Dr. Feng's neck from behind. And Dr. Feng puts his hand to cover his neck. It's now literally splirting with blood. They said that

the blood was getting on the windshield all over the dash. I don't know what he cut, but it was a vein. And Z used this opportunity to grab his wrist, Dr. Feng's wrist, and slash it. And Dr. Feng starts screaming, oh my god, oh my god, you you slashed my aorta I need to stop the bleeding quick and he successfully is like reaching for everything he's like trying to hold on to his wrist and his neck he opens the door and in this chaos he jumps out of the car into the field nearby so Dr. Fang is literally squirting blood just running through this field now he tries to get a few cars to stop and help him but nobody did. They're like this feels like straight out of a horror movie. Z runs out of the car chases him down and uses the hammer to beat up

Dr. Feng's head like literally bashing his head in and when he was confident that Dr. Feng was not gonna be able to get up and get help or survive any of this he walked back to SG's car where she was waiting and they just left. They just drove off with Dr. Fang in the field to die. They said that they drove in silence and the smell of the blood was making both of them so nauseous. It just was like that rusty smell, almost metallic. They drove to an abandoned roadside, lit the bloody car, literally the bloody car on fire, and just walked off. They had no plans no

thoughts just each other and homicidal vibes honestly they walked back to the city they were arrested within a few days I mean a lot of the hospital staff knew that SJ and Dr. Fang were having an affair so it's pretty easy to consider them suspects and connect the dots neither of them tried to hide anything they just immediately confessed and on August 17. Neither of them tried to hide anything, they just immediately confessed. And on August 17th, 2007, both of them were sentenced to death. So it seems like the story is over, right? I mean, kind of. But the internet picked up this case and ran with it.

I mean, there was kind of this clear divide in the middle. Half of the people were saying things like, evidence? What evidence? I didn't see anything. All I see is one less rapist gone in this world. Who's crying about that? I'm not crying, are you? Killing for love after someone raped your partner is hardly a crime to be executed for. They said they should execute rapists with this level of passion. Some people said, and these are all quotes

and translated, the one who should die is dead. It's the rapist. Why should we lose more people in this world? If he hadn't raped her, she wouldn't have lost her mind and killed him. I don't see the problem here. Listen, the killers were too young, too traumatized to know better. But guess who wasn't too young and too traumatized? The doctor who raped her. Some people were kind of in the middle. Like, you know, she did commit a crime crime They do need to get punished. They do need to get consequences, but considering the fact that she was raped by this man I don't think the death penalty. It's a bit too harsh and Then you had the other side of people who were very much victim blaming seeing things like well She kept sleeping with him then is she truly traumatized for being raped? Maybe she wasn't even raped

Maybe she was just upset that people found out that she was sleeping for a full-time position. I think that she did this for greed. She just wanted to get promoted and promoted without putting in the work and then when he stopped promoting her and sending her everywhere she wanted, she killed him. You know, the young boy was dragged into all of this by the black widow. She's pathetic, hateful, manipulative. I mean, she tried to sleep her way to the top and it backfired, so she gets her boyfriend and ruins this guy's life by convincing him to kill.

Okay, side note, that comment is so telling because nowhere in that sentence is there any responsibility put on the men in this case. The 18-year-old that physically killed someone, nor the 40-year-old that raped, abused his power, and then threatened a woman. Like, none of that at all. Like, how? So they kept going. I mean how does a 23 year old find a teenager attractive?

It means that she was looking for someone young and impressionable that she could control. She was looking for someone to help her kill. She was using her sex appeal to get to this 18 year old. She wasn't satisfied until dr. Feng was dead besides there's no proof of the anyway I mean it caused up such a start that Z's appeal was taken up by the Supreme Court and in the last minute before both Of them were scheduled for their death sentences Z's death sentence was commuted to life in prison and that was the moment that we saw earlier So those crying of tears of joy and saying at least I don't have to drag him

Down anymore. I'm so happy he gets to live. She was just so happy at the end He said that it wasn't your fault. He said that he could make his own choice. But it wasn't your fault. It's just that he was too ignorant. He was too ignorant of the law. If I can, if he says he's willing, please take care of my dad for me. If he says he's willing, please find my father for me Criminal executions last words be that emotionally charged Usually you have the serial killers who are sick and twisted till the end They're like I ain't got nothing to say, but I love my mom Or you have the ones that are like I feel bad for what I did

I found God love Jesus by and the fact that her just the her emotional switch went from cold No emotion to all of a sudden Overflowing of emotion like a lot of people I think they were also saying like the love they have is that... Is it because she really, really loves him? Some people say that the feeling is that maybe she actually, she did convince him to kill. So now she feels that at least I don't have to... Does that make sense? Like I'm the only one that have to, you know...

Bear the death penalty for this. It's just so sad. I mean, okay, do I think that what they did was wrong and twisted? Yeah, I do. Would it have been better if they castrated Dr. Feng? Probably, yeah, because he's dead now and he has kids and it's just all around, don't kill people. But I think it's also telling that they're so young and they truly felt like they had no other way like the fact that she was traumatized and raped and then they feel like they have no other way and they're backed into a corner and the only way to escape this trauma is to kill him that says a lot about society and the justice system because if she had an outlet to

just punish him he gets fired from his job, he is no longer her boss, she gets some sort of support, like I think she would have been fine. Yeah I saw some comment also said that if this case happened today, like 2022, she probably wouldn't have to be in the death penalty. She probably would have gotten life in prison. Probably, but it's probably not going get you know executed so and that is the story of what happened to just the most intense last words I have ever heard what do you guys think of it do you feel like she has some sort of remorse than her do you feel like she has a soul I mean she was so emotional about her boyfriend not

being executed do you think it's real love do you think it was a trauma bond do you think she manipulated him and then felt remorse afterwards I don't know let me know in the comments