Rotten Mango - #60: The Death Room Murders (Serial Killer - Dorothea Puente)
Episode Date: May 3, 2021You look out your window - the landlord has dug up another large hole in the backyard… they’re always doing strange gardening projects late at night. You walk into the kitchen - there’s that... smell again… the landlord says it’s new fertilizer but the smell is distinct. There are usually 8 tenants but once in a while, one will disappear without notice… what really is going on in this house? Source Notes: rottenmangopodcast.com To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Rambles.
Whether you're doing a dance to your favorite artist in the office parking lot, or being guided
into Warrior I in the break room before your shift, whether you're running on your Peloton
tread at your mom's house while she watches the baby, or counting your breaths on the subway.
Peloton is for all of us, wherever we are, whenever we need it.
Download the free Peloton is for all of us. Wherever we are, whenever we need it. Download the free Peloton app today.
Peloton app available through free tier or pay to description starting at 12.99 per month.
Butter being butter boom.
That's too much, that's too intimate.
Welcome to this week's mini-sode. Is it gonna be a mini-sode? You'll just have to find out.
Now, after Wednesday's really thick-ooms episode, did you think that I was going to come back
with another serial killer series? No you didn't, but neither did I, but that's what's happening
today. We're talking about Sacramento's kind of creepy serial killer. Is this my second female
serial killer mini-sode? Yes it is. Sacramento, California, a woman walks into the police station. Her
name is Judy and her occupation is a social worker This is really important and she comes with this really intense story
She says I have a friend. I have a friend named Bert Montoya and he is missing now. Here's the catch
I know exactly where he is
I know what's happened to him and I need you guys the officers to come with me and bring some shovels
The police are like okay lady. This is this is an odd story
You need to give us more information.
We can't just go around knocking around people's doors, go into the local parks with shovels.
So she sits down and she tells them one of the wildest stories ever.
So Judy, she tells them that she met this man by the name of Bert Montoya. He is in his mid-50s
and he actually has a mental disability. And the way that they met is interesting So she would frequent a place called the detox center which essentially is like this shelter for homeless people who are also
Struggling with addiction. It's not a glamorous place
It is not a place where you're gonna get like this nice full-size bed and people are gonna come in and be like do you want an IV drip?
No, it's a place with like a giant concrete floor where they give you these, um, not even a fold-up mattress or an air mattress,
but you know those vinyl sheets. Like almost like a plastic tarp.
They give you one of those, they give you a blanket and you just lay next to each other and you sleep.
You got a roof over your head for the night and he has a mental disability.
I could not find his actual diagnosis, but many people report him to have, you know, the kind of cognitive ability of a 10 or 12-year-old.
That is what a lot of sources say.
So he would wander around the streets a lot.
He would talk to trees.
It seemed that Spanish was his main language, and he wasn't really entertaining the idea
of talking to people.
If someone asked him a question, he would just say like, yeah, or no, and that's it.
He would also be constantly seeing talking to someone that we can't see.
Imaginary voices, right? Voices inside of his head and people would say, oh, well,
who are you talking to? And he would say, well, I'm talking to these spirits.
And then he would just kind of walk away. So Judy, she meets them and she's like, well,
this guy, he just something about him, even though he's in his 50s, there's something so vulnerable
about him. It's so hard not to like him.
He seems almost too nice for his own good. Like if you were to go to the detox center and you just
look at him and his mattress that he was handed out to looks better than yours, he will swap it with
you. Like that's the type of guy Bert was. So she immediately takes a liking to him and she's a
volunteer there. So she starts kind of like trailing him not in a creepy way and she sees him again
in front of a graveyard. So she's like okay like what are you doing inside of the graveyard and
he's having a verbal argument with nothing so she's like um bird what's going on and he says well
all these demons in the graveyard are talking to me so I don't know what to do so she starts
befriending him and she's trying to tell him it's okay it's okay like we can we can maybe get
you to a doctor we can maybe this, but it didn't seem like
anything was going through.
Like, nothing was penetrating.
Weeks go by and Judy's like, okay, I can't do this anymore, like I can't see Bert just
on the side going through this mess.
Like, every time he's at the detox center, he's getting taken advantage of.
I just feel nervous about him, you know?
And he should be on disability checks and maybe the government can pay for some sort of housing. This is crazy. So she starts talking to our other social
worker volunteer buddies and they decide, okay, why don't you find a boarding house for him?
So essentially what these boarding houses do is they take people from the government. That
sounds like a kidnapping scheme. So they will house people that the government has deemed
like that they need help and assistance
with taking their medication.
So the government is like, oh, this person maybe
doesn't have a place to say,
or this person can't stay by themselves
because they are not taking their medications
on a daily basis.
So think like Alzheimer's,
like these types of things where you need to take your medication.
And so they decided we're gonna put BART in a boarding house.
So she starts scouting all of these boarding houses
Finally, she settles on one on F straight
Literally called F straight. So she's like, okay, well, I've heard good things about this place
The woman who runs at her name is Dorothea Puente and she seems like this cute little grandma
That's how everyone describes her. She's got this white hair
And she's got these big old owl-looking glasses
Just massive her teeth have all fallen out so she wears these dentures if you see her in the morning
She'll be gardening. She's got this really intense passion for gardening
She will have her hair in the rollers just like the sweetest lady in town
She gave people a place to sleep. She would cook food every single day for her borders
I mean she just seemed super caring. Someone who cares
about the most vulnerable population. Judy is like, well, let me go to F-Street. Let me go meet
Dorothea and see if she wants to take on Bert because we've just got him applied for social security.
We've just got him applied for disability because Bert was at a state where he didn't really
remember anything. Like, he didn't have an ID. he didn't have any of this, so he wasn't getting assistance from the government,
which he should have been.
So they go and they meet with Dorathea.
And instantly, it was like sparks were flying.
Dorathea was just like the sweetest little lady ever.
She opened the door, she's got her little hair and curlers,
and she's like, come in, come in.
Now once they get in, Judy feels good about this.
I mean, the whole house, there's like,
knickknacks everywhere.
It's almost got a Mexican traditional, cultural knickknacks.
Do you know what I mean?
Every culture has one.
If you go into my grandma's house,
you're like, oh man, this woman's Korean, right?
Like that type of vibe.
And she's like, wow, it just feels so homie in here.
What, what, what, what, what is that smell? And she's like, well, it just feels so homie in here. What, what, what, what, what is that smell?
And she's like, well follow me into the kitchen
and she's flipping these burgers, which is crazy.
Judy was like, I've never seen this before.
Boarding houses will usually take all the government money
and feed mac and cheese all day, like boxed mac and cheese,
but she's making like half pound burger patties right now.
Not even a quarter pounder, like a half pound burger patty.
And she's like, so I just cut all this lettuce,
oh these tomatoes are in front of my little garden.
Like she's just like the perfect woman.
Does she have any, is she housing anyone else right now?
Yeah, about eight different people.
They're currently residing.
Yeah, and so they're like in and out of the house.
Now she has a mix of different people.
So she has like the sick and elderly,
but she also has the groups of them,
like people that kind of move around a lot.
Like men who are on government assistance,
but they're also stuff that they're struggling with,
whether it's alcohol or drugs, right?
So they'll be kind of in and out of her place,
but she had about eight people.
And they all seem to like it there.
And Bert, Bert seemed really happy
because Bert was only speaking like little bits of English even though he was fluent and
Dorothea she's books vanish. So they start speaking in Spanish together and she almost instantly takes on this like mothering vibe of like no
Oh, Bert don't do that. Let me okay. Take your hand out of there. She just seemed really caring
So Judy and Bert they're enjoying this experience and eventually they leave and Judy's like okay I think this is good but Bert you should really think
about it. We can always go look at all these other boarding houses and then make a
decision but he was all about it. He was like no I'm gonna stay here Dorothy is
amazing. So he starts staying there and he gets his own little room which these
rooms are very interesting so it has like a bed and a TV but it's clean right and
for someone who is sleeping in this giant room with like 50 other dudes on like a vinyl piece of paper,
as a mattress, this is a luxury.
So he's having a good time.
Now the next time Judy visits, he's got a new haircut, he's got new clothes, new shoes, and he's talking to her.
She was shocked, like at this point, after weeks of knowing him, they had non-exchange a conversation.
It was just like, yep, nope, that's it.
So she would do all of the talking,
but this time he was like, oh, how are you feeling?
I heard you were a little sick.
She's like, wait a minute, what is happening?
And it just seemed like mentally, physically, emotionally,
everything was getting amazing.
So months go by and then all of a sudden,
Bert tells Judy that he doesn't want to be there anymore.
Out of nowhere. He just says, I don't want to stay here anymore and it seems so sudden, so Judy reaches out to Dorothya and is like, hey, what's going on?
Is everything okay with Bert? Like, is he taking his medication still? And she says, oh yeah, don't worry about it. I actually have plans to take him to Mexico.
Wait, what?
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
So my grandparents, you know, I have some relatives that are doctors.
Because I come from a family of doctors and people in the medicinal field.
Did you know that I was a nurse in World War II?
Anyway, that's besides the point.
So Dorothy has like 70 years old, by the way, straight up grandma, okay?
And so she's like, yeah, I'm going to take him to Mexico and we're going to fix him in
Mexico. Fix him. Yeah so she's like, yeah, I'm gonna take in to Mexico and we're gonna fix him in Mexico.
Fix him.
Yeah, and Judy's like, no,
because I think he has like a remnants of tuberculosis.
So Judy's like, I don't think that's a good idea.
Like he's just getting his disability checks.
I just don't think that's safe.
And I mean, for how many weeks,
I can't even imagine Bert being comfortable with that.
Like did you talk to Bert about it?
And so she was like, well don't worry about it. And she's just hangs up. And Judy's like, did you talk to Bird about it? And so she was like, well, don't worry about it.
And she just hangs up.
And she's like, what?
What does that even mean?
So then the next couple of months passed,
and she cannot get in contact with Bird,
and she's getting confused.
Like, did he just, like, stay in Mexico?
That doesn't make any sense.
And so she keeps calling Dorothy yet.
No, I'm stopped. Like, where's Bird?
I want to talk to Bird.
But Dorothy is picking up.
Yeah, and she's making all these excuses.
No, we didn't go to Mexico. No, he's just out for the day.
Oh, he must have gone to church.
Like it just random stuff.
So Judy finally tells her if he's not there next Monday,
when I get there, I'm going to call the police.
So then Monday rolls around. She's putting on her clothes.
She's getting ready to storm into Dorothy's little place.
And then she gets a phone call.
A man calls Judy saying,
hey, this is Bert's uncle and I picked him up. He's not going to be living at that boarding
house anymore. He's going to be living with me. And she's like, what? Like, who even are
you? I've never heard of you. I mean, this doesn't even make any sense. Bert has never
mentioned an uncle. Where were you all this time? Like, and then the same day that I threatened
to call the police, you like randomly call me,
and she's like just really put off by this, so they hang up the phone, and she immediately goes to the police station
and files a missing person's report, and she's telling them this whole story.
Now the police, they decided to go look in the boarding house, and they start interviewing all of the tenants.
And sure enough, all of them confirmed,
oh yeah, bird!
On Sunday, I think his uncle or something came and picked him up.
Hmm.
So please don't like damn.
I mean, he's a full grown man.
Technically, Dorothea isn't like legally liable for him, so I mean, if they say that he was
picked up, okay, so that officer is on his way out when he gets a tap on the shoulder.
And one of the tenants by the name of John Sharp sneaks him a note.
And then runs back into the house.
He opens up that note and it was a secret arrangement to meet later that day away from the house.
And then one sentence, she's making me lie.
So the officer is like, all right, that's really creepy, that's really strange.
So they, they meet later than that day and John Sharp tells him everything.
This is a tenant and he is one of the tenants that Judy had actually recommended the police
talk to.
She said John Sharp is, you know, someone who's around, he's been there for a minute,
he is almost always sober.
So technically in the eyes of the law, he would be an amazing witness.
So you should talk to him So this is the same person that the officer meets up with outside of Dorothy's house and he starts telling him everything
Before Bert disappeared by the way, I haven't seen him in months
So they're like what you just said last Sunday like literally a couple days ago that he was picked up by the relative
That's all I I have not seen Bert in months. Before he disappeared, Dorothy and
Bert were having problems. She was constantly yelling at him. One time he locked himself
in the bathroom and kept calling the postal service, asking them, hey, why am I not getting
my disability checks? And they kept telling him, no, you should have gotten this mail arrived
at this day. And he was like getting upset because he then now he's like assuming that
Dorothy is like stealing his checks, but then nobody could even understand what was happening because Dorothya the whole time is
screaming in the background while he's on the phone with the postal workers so that happens
and then one night Bert comes home from the bar now he was confused because Bert was acting like
he was drunk like there was just something so strange about the way that bird was walking,
the way that he was, I mean,
he's never seen bird like this before.
Now, during his time there,
what's even more suspicious is that John Sharp says,
in the middle of the night,
he would hear some weird noises, some banging noises.
So he had the room right underneath the stairs,
like Harry Potter, and he would just hear,
thump thump thump thump thump.
As if you're just like dragging a suitcase down the stairs in the middle of the night.
Then the next morning, there would be a fresh hole in the yard.
Oh my god.
An attendant would have moved out, and when you asked Dorothy about that tenant, oh, a relative
came and picked them up.
Sometimes Dorothy would hire people
to dig holes for different, quote-unquote, garden projects. But he never saw this.
So this happens multiple times? Multiple times. And he said, he started
kind of putting two and two together. He doesn't know what to do. He doesn't know if he should
accuse someone because that's a really big accusation. Imagine pointing your finger at this old cute
little lady and saying, you, you are varying people in your garden aren't ya? What's under that rose
bush? You crazy lady? Like that sounds like a really big accusation, you know? I
would want some CCTV footage to back that claim up. And so he said, you know,
you should always be doing these different garden projects, but I would never
see a new tree. I would never see a new rose bush. I mean, something's weird. So the
officers confused by this. He's like, okay.
Like really though, you genuinely think that this cute little old 70-old grandma is killing people, it sounds crazy.
So the next day the police show up, they knock on the door again, and she opens it up and they say, hey, we have this problem.
Judy's breathing down our neck. You know, she just won't leave a phone. She's like a Karen at the police station right now. Why don't we just look around your house look you Lou?
And then we can just tell Judy yeah, we searched her house. There's nothing to worry about
And so Dorothy is like oh, yeah, of course. I mean I get it
She just cares a lot so they start looking around the house. They go to the second floor
Now this is where Dorothy is bedroom is they see a dresser full of these blue pills all the way to the top. It just didn't seem like she was taking it. It just seemed weird.
So they note that and then they see another sleeping pill bottle. But this time instead of Dorothy
of Puente's name it says Dorothy Amilla. So they're like who's Dorothy Amilla? Is that a, is that
another name you're going by? Is that you're made in And she says, no, no, no, no, no.
She's a relative.
She used to stay here, but now she's gone.
So they're like, OK, that's odd.
So they finish searching the rooms,
and they don't really find anything.
They don't find birth.
They don't find tons of blood.
They don't find any crazy tools that would indicate
that he's murdered.
So write us there about to leave.
The officer turns around and says, hey, I have a weird question.
Do you mind if I um dig in your yard?
What?
So he said, you know, it's just something that I feel like I need to do.
I brought a shovel.
It's in my car.
We can just go grab it.
Wait, is this police here after the story?
Yeah.
So remember, Judy kept saying you got to bring a shovel, right?
The reason that she kept saying that is,
she's been there multiple times,
and there would just be mounds of dirt.
She's digging holes in her backyard.
Who does that?
Why are there mounds of dirt?
Why is this the pig farm?
That doesn't make any sense.
You live in Sacramento in a very busy area.
Why are you doing so many DIY projects?
And so she's like, yeah, sure, go ahead.
Dig in my yard. She even offered them another shovel, because she's like, yeah, sure, go ahead. Dig in my yard.
She even offered them another shovel,
because she was like, well, you only have one shovel.
For two men, that doesn't make sense.
Here's another one.
So they bring their shovels out to the back
and they just start digging in the garden area,
like right underneath her avocado tree, her rose bushes,
just start digging.
Now, this is the part where you're gonna get
really frustrated with the police,
because like, what?
Absolutely, what are you thinking, sir? They start digging. Now this is the part where you're gonna get really frustrated with the police because like, what? Absolutely, what are you thinking, sir?
They start digging and they see cloth material.
They start picking it out.
They're like, what is this?
It looks like clothing.
They start picking out some more.
And then they find what they describe to be thin pieces
of leather.
They assumed that someone had cut up a leather jacket
and buried it.
Now, why would anyone do that?
No one would do that later.
It would be tested positively for a flush, for human flesh.
But they were like, ooh, leather jacket,
must be some clothing.
Like imagine?
You're just sitting there as a police officer
thinking that this is a leather jacket.
Oh, wait.
They take up human.
But they thought it was leather.
Because it had dried up and it wasn't big pieces.
It was very tiny pieces, but I don't know why in their head they were like a leather jacket,
like strips of leather.
To me that doesn't sound, especially you know why you're digging in the first place.
But you're like, no, it's a leather jacket.
Maybe there's just noobs that never seeing any.
They don't listen to true crime podcasts.
These police officers sometimes genuinelys, these police officers.
Sometimes I genuinely believe that some police officers should listen to more True Crime Podcasts.
Yeah, I think so too.
I think so, you know?
Because I'm like, are they dumb?
That one police officer listening to this right now, angry.
Sorry.
Okay.
But yeah, he was like, no, it's a lot of their jacket.
It gets worse.
So as they're digging, they hit something really hard.
And the police officer just assumes that it was a tree root.
Because a couple feet away from them, there's this huge avocado tree, which if you guys don't
know, avocado trees have pretty thick roots.
So they're thinking, okay, must be a root.
Let's just start aggressively shoveling, aggressively banging at this root.
Oh no. Their idea. They said their game plan. I'm laughing because of how freaking ridiculous
this is, okay? They said, okay, let's try to cut the root in half. That was their thought.
So they're like jumping on it. They're like, we need to cut the root in half because like,
we need to go deeper because we're looking for a human body
But we found a leather jacket. It's weird. Okay. They're like saying I don't know what's right
So they try to cut the root in half with their shovels. It doesn't work
So the main officer he he tries to dig it out
He like goes in there all hands in and he starts pulling and pulling and pulling and finally it pulls out and he plops down onto his butt
And he looks at it. It is not yeah, you guessed it. It's not an avocado tree root
But in fact it's a femur bone a human femur bone
So he's like
Now he knows and Now he knows.
Okay.
Thank God.
Now he knew immediately that this wasn't birthed though because birth has only been missing
for, let's say, three months, right?
This was skeletal remains.
There was not flesh on there.
The leather pieces were flesh that had somehow fallen off the body and then decomposed separately,
but I mean, this is strange.
Nobody else was reported missing from the same house that showed up on their feed, you know. None of that. Who is this? So they're not
gonna door. And Dorothy comes out and she looks so shocked. She's like, oh my god, is that
what I think of it? That's crazy. Like, do you want to explain this? She's like, no, no way,
that's human. If that's human, I don't know anything about it. You know, there are other people that live here.
You would have to ask them.
Now, the police have to go along with this
because the house has been around since 1898.
Like, this is an old house.
This is like in Sacramento.
There's a lot of history there, right?
And people actually used to just bury
their loved ones in the backyard.
And like the 1800s, they wouldn't like get a coffin.
They wouldn't go to like an actual graveyard.
They would just kind of bury their loved ones. so not only can they not accuse Dorothea
But they can't even necessarily assume that this is a homicide victim in the backyard
Like it could have definitely just been a loved one of someone who lived here in like the I don't know early
1900s so they brought in experts, but they can't arrest Dorothea
They can't arrest her so they just ask her politely can you come into the police station? Because we just want to ask you like for a statement. So she comes in and this entire
interview was recorded and it's weird. It's weird. So first she lies about her name. They're like,
well, your name is Dorothea Plente. And she says, yeah, yeah, well, my birth name is Dorothea Montalvo.
But that's a lie. Like all of this is a lie. And the police know that. I don't know. She was born Dorothy Agree.
She married a Montalvo in she married a Puente.
So her real name is Dorothy Agree.
But I mean legally, she kept getting married to a bunch of different people.
So she kept changing her name.
But she kept saying no.
It's either Montalvo or Puente.
Like she never mentioned the fact that her name was Dorothy Agree.
Which by the way, I don't know her exact heritage.
But she doesn't look Hispanic.
But she's not a big fan of her.
She's not a big fan of her.
She's not a big fan of her.
She's not a big fan of her.
She's not a big fan of her. She's not a big fan of her. She's not a big fan of her. She's not a big fan of her. Like she never mentioned the fact that her name was Dorothy Agree, which by the way, I don't know her exact heritage, but she doesn't look
Hispanic, but she swore up and down that she was born in Mexico. But when you look at
her birth certificate, she wasn't born in Mexico. So I don't know what's going on over
there. She's born in like Washington or something. But she was like, yep, Mexico. It's only
like the other side of the North American continent.
She tried to build rapport with the police officer because his last name was Hispanic, so she was like, oh my god.
Are you Mexican? I'm Mexican. And he was just like, okay, what are you even talking about?
So we ignored that record show that she's only 59 years old.
Only 59 years old. But she went around telling all of her friends and
all of her neighbors told the police that she's in her 70s at the very least. So this is
all getting so strange, so they start questioning her and she's just so calm in all of this.
She denied knowing anything about birth, anything about the remains in the backyard. Didn't
even seem nervous. I mean a crazy good liar. They kept threatening her. They said, I'm
gonna dig some more and I'm sure is how gonna dig up some more bodies
Am I not Doraphia? Am I not?
She just said well, I don't know
I don't know what you're talking about not wants to cheat hesitate
She stuck to her story. She didn't even break a sweat. It was crazy
It's crazy. So her main thing that she kept telling them is that there is no way that I could drag out
Bert into my garden.
I mean, he's like, what?
200 pounds?
Look at me.
I'm a grandma.
I'm tiny.
Like, I'm like 70 years old.
Do I think I shut up?
You're 59.
We have your records.
But she's like, look at me.
I'm so old and frail.
I don't even have teeth.
I can't even mash my own potatoes in my mouth.
Like, she was just doing the absolute most.
And she kept saying, I believe in God.
I know he's going to show up. Just super stubborn. They're like, what? What do you mean? And she she kept saying, I believe in God, I know he's going to show
up just super stopper and they're like, what, what do you mean? And she just kept saying,
no, he's going to show up. You can't just like say that at the police station. No, no,
he is. I believe in God and he's going to show up. Now, the police were intensely confused
about this because other people that they had interviewed with this type of level of just stress, high tension, non-stop accusations, they were usually in tears, just bawling their
eyes out.
They would be hardened criminals, like you know the ones that are all tatted up that are
like, I'm not scared of anybody, get out of here.
They would be crying in the interrogation room.
Dorothea is straight, chillin'.
And so the press, they get a wind of this, that there has been a body dug out out of this
grandma's garden and they start freaking out.
And Dorothea, it turned out that she was actually on parole.
When this was all, this was all happening.
She was on parole.
She was actually legally prohibited from running any type of boarding house.
But social workers over the years had sent close to 19 people to her door. So now it's like a question of what's going on with these social workers.
Why are they sending her people?
Or why is she on probation?
Oh, it gets worse.
So she was on probation for poisoning elderly people essentially.
I'm not laughing.
Well, that's some heavy, heavy clue, isn't it?
I'm not laughing at what happened, but I'm laughing because like, what?
Like, imagine being a journalist and be like, well, she on probation for it.
And it's like, oh, poisoning elderly people.
So what does she do now?
Oh, she runs a boarding house for elderly people.
Like, what is happening?
So in the city, there was a loophole to open a boarding home.
You only need a business license.
No background check, no fingerprinting or regulation,
so she got a license to run a boarding house
without anyone knowing that she wasn't allowed,
because she was on parole.
She was actually visited by parole officers
at that exact address, and nobody asked,
hey, who are these people?
Nobody asked that.
They just, they just were like, oh, maybe they're friends.
And then they would leave.
This went on for years.
And she was running a boarding house where people would go missing.
So the next day, the police show up and they continue to dig.
Now, meanwhile, like I said, Dorothea has not been arrested, so she's chilling inside
her house.
She got ready for the day, she's drinking some.
It's said that she drank vodka and orange juice the same morning that all of these police
officers are digging a par
of wands like just have an casual day. So when they get to a specific part in the backyard with newly laid cement in it and they start digging
John McCalley comes out. Now this is Dorothy's friend and also a fellow tenant
He's very interesting because he lives on the second floor with her
Which none of the other tenants have been allowed to do.
So it seems like maybe they're really close or maybe they're even dating.
He lives under the...
That's a different John.
There's two John's.
Oh, okay, that's my bad.
So we'll just call him the friend, right?
So the friend comes out and he's watching them while they're digging up the backyard,
which again, I mean, I guess he's permitted to do that.
So he's standing there just watching them like as if he's watching
Gardener's like do work in the backyard just chillin and then all of a sudden he says oh wait
Dorothy I want to ask you a question you guys have to come back in and she says this to the main officer
So if he leaves then the whole digging stops for a little bit, right?
Oh, John says that. Yeah, he just like taps him all of a sudden
I don't know where it says says Dorothy, I need you.
So he goes into the house, and he sits down with Dorothy, and she's like, hey, am I arrested?
No, Dorothy, oh, you haven't been arrested.
You wouldn't be here if you've been arrested.
Why, what's wrong?
And she says, well, all of this, you know, nonsense in the police, and all the press outside
is making me so nervous.
Do you mind if I just walk to the hotel nearby and grab some coffee?
So this is yeah, well, I mean I can walk you there
It's only a couple blocks away and there's just so much press outside that I I don't think I feel good with you
Just walking by yourself through all of this. So she's like, okay, that would be so great
So she puts on her red dress with a red jacket with a red purse just all red with this snow white hair
I mean, it's just like the weirdest thing ever and she looked like she was going to send a church service with a red jacket, with a red purse, just all red with this snow white hair.
I mean, it's just like the weirdest thing ever.
And she looked like she was going to Sunday church service with her little purse.
And she walks outside with the police officer.
And now the press, they're snapping these pictures.
And everyone thought that she was being led to a secluded area.
It didn't look like a purplock. It didn't look like she was getting arrested.
It just looked like, you know, maybe they're taking her to the police station for safe keeping.
So does the press know that this was all her doing right now?
No, they just know that a body's been dug up in her yard. And that she's kind of on
probation. So it's all a little weird. But no one was like, even when the press saw
her, they were like, ah, man, it is sketchy that she's on probation. But like, look at
her. She's like a grandma. That doesn't make sense.
So he drops her off at the hotel, run straight back to the house and starts digging again.
This has only been about 20 minutes since he had walked her to the hotel and ran back.
And he starts digging and they hit something.
They got another body.
So now this is the second body.
Before even taking off the cloth though, they knew it wasn't burnt.
It was a female.
Like very small.
Just, it's crazy.
There's no missing reports of females at this address.
This, why are there two female bodies?
Like we were expecting burnt this whole time.
If anything, right?
So it becomes this really hectic scene.
The police come back and they're like,
all right, well, we should probably arrest or a fear.
Now, you've got half of the police there that are like alright
Let's go to the hotel and arrest her and then the rest of the police they keep digging and sure enough they hit another body
So this is the third body and that is when the police come running back freaking out saying she's not at the hotel
I mean are you real? So I mean this is nuts I mean the price that's not
that the police were absolute idiots because how do you and he walked her to the
hotel too like he was just so. Yeah and he just left her there. Yeah this is the
same guy that thought it was so leather jacket. I'm confused why did he walk her
there? Because technically he felt I'm not. Why did he walk her there? Because technically he felt, I'm not agreeing with this.
He felt that they hadn't found a second body yet.
So maybe it was just that one body
and maybe the body dates back before Dorothy
even lived here.
So they just like walked her there.
For what purpose?
Oh, because the press.
He didn't want the press to like hound her.
Also he's, oh, so he was shielding her.
Yeah, because you know, there was so many reporters outside,
he was like, you're gonna get hounded this old little lady.
Who's really not that old? She's like 59 calm down.
But she looks 70s, purposely.
That's so weird.
So she gets to the hotel and she runs away.
So the police, I mean, the press are chasing the police.
The police are running to the hotel and they just look like absolute idiots.
I don't know what else to say.
They interview the hotel staff and they say,
oh yeah, the little lady with the red coat.
Oh yeah, she called a taxi service
and got into a taxi and left.
So now they're like, oh my freaking god.
The press are outside the hotel,
snapping these pictures, even the police chief.
He had to go on the stand
and this is not something that they could even, they couldn't even remotely come up
with something.
So they said, yeah, we let her walk away.
We shouldn't have.
She's a killer.
There's no excuses for how this happened.
Straight up, have you ever heard the police take that strong
accountability for something?
He straight up said, yeah, what the fuck?
We fucked up.
I've never heard that before.
There was no spinning this. You can't even...
Can you imagine? It's just so dumb, right?
It just is so freaking dumb.
There's no way the police could like spin it into way, way, that's like,
Oh, no, this was better for the investigation. You know, like there was,
there was nothing. This is like our hands were tied. Like they couldn't,
they couldn't do anything. So they keep searching for her and they keep digging.
Now that third body was found with lime all over the body,
which I think Dorothy had thought
that this was gonna speed up the process,
but it actually sometimes preserves the body
from decaying so much that it gets really intensely,
like smelly and odorous, I guess.
And it was a rather big body, the third body.
I mean, a huge bundle, like seven or ten layers, shower curtains,
tarp, like this body had been wrapped diligently. And you know, it seemed like this person
wasn't in the ground for that long and the weight of the person, the height, it all just
kind of fit burnt. So they believe the third body was burnt. There was a plastic garbage
bag over his head, which kind of comes to the question later where some of these people buried alive. So the
police, they go, they go to the press, they say, hey, so we done goofed and we
need some help. If you guys see this fugitive, we think that she's headed for
Mexico. Please let us know. They let the Mexican border know and they're like,
please don't let her get into Mexico,
because usually once they flee to Mexico,
and they speak Spanish, and maybe they have ties
and Mexico, they can't spend all that money
to bring in all these American cops in there
and just find this person, right?
So they're like, if you guys could just let us know.
So the taxi driver calls in, and it's like, oh yeah,
I think she was headed south.
I dropped off at a train station,
and she was headed straight for Los Angeles, which is about like a six-hour
um, is it a six-hour drive, right?
So look at an even shorter plane ride, but like train ride I'm sure it's like anywhere between like five or six hours, right?
So the headed straight for Los Angeles, so they're like okay, well we need to call LAPD, we need to call all these people
Meanwhile the digging continues. So within three days four bodies uncovered, all wrapped in blankets, bed sheets, plastic,
shower curtain, just all of that.
Now, the crazy thing is, out of these four bodies, nobody other than Bert has ever been
reported missing.
So, they have no idea who these people are.
They have no idea.
They're trying to identify the bodies.
The social workers that were recommending people to this boarding house, they're freaking out. They're straight
up calling every single person that they have ever come in contact with is because
this is their biggest nightmare. They are in this business to help people and
they just straight up send people to their death. So they start freaking out,
calling everyone and underneath the patio, yet again, they find another body. So
they find seven bodies in total now
one of them had no hands no feet and not even ahead it was decapitated and there
was evidence that at least one of the victims might have been buried alive
because there was evidence that it seemed like someone was trying to kick up
to get out after being buried. Oh, God.
So around this time, a next door neighbor comes forward to the police and says,
hey, so I found this really suspicious box just like seemed like it was thrown into my yard.
I'm right next door to Dorothea, but you should probably look inside.
They look inside that box and it was just filled with teeth.
So it seems like she had probably tossed it on her way out,
because she was like, oh no, maybe the teeth is going to identify them. So she's probably tossed it on her way out because she was like, oh no,
maybe the teeth is going to identify them.
So she's like tossed it in the yard.
So he keeps their teeth?
Yeah, so you know, the question is, who is Dorothy a Helen Gray?
Because now she is on the absolute loose.
She's running wild in California.
Where is she?
Who is this serial killer?
Why are there seven people buried in her backyard?
So mind you, I'm sorry, I apologize.
She was actually born in Redlands, California,
with she was the sixth of seven siblings.
Now her parents, they were super abusive.
They were alcoholics, they did not make enough money
to support the kids, and they just were like,
not in a good situation.
So this was one of those cases where the mom,
she was engaging in sex work,
but she would bring it home a lot of the times.
So she would just have these men coming in and out of the house and I mean this is not really like the most well-built house, so the kids would hear things that they didn't want to hear.
So it was just really traumatic.
And then the mom, she would do this thing where she would go on these crazy party benders.
She would just like leave the kids with a husband and be like, bye, I'm gonna go out with the clients for the weekend and just be gone for days
at a time. Now the dad, he was incredibly abusive. He wanted to do his own thing. He didn't
want to look after the kids, so they came to the decision. They compromised. You know how
parents do it? They like sit down, they compromise. So the compromise was that we're gonna
lock the kids into a confined closet. Because if they can run free, they might go into
the kitchen and grab a kitchen knife.
But if they're stuck and locked up in this walk-in closet, then they can't hurt themselves.
So we'll just put some food in there.
So like imagine, like a small little walked-in closet with seven kids,
which is like piles of food.
At one point in Dorothy's life, the dad actually tried
to hang himself in front of all of his children.
So there was a lot of trauma involved.
Now the dad passes away when Dorothy is eight,
and then a year after that, the mom gets into a motorcycle
accident and passes away.
So it's just back to back to back trauma.
But I think something was wrong with Dorothy,
because like I said, she has a lot of different siblings,
and none of them else turned out to be serial killers, right?
So it's like we can feel sympathy, but it's not an excuse.
We can feel a lot of sympathy because she was a kid at the time.
And she started spending a lot of time in these various foster homes and she suffered
from sexual abuse, from these foster parents.
So then we've got another traumatic situation.
So finally, she's taken in by these relatives
in Fresno, California.
And it just seems weird.
So this is when she starts developing this fascination
with lying.
Like, she becomes a full-on pathological liar.
And she starts lying about the strangest things.
She would tell people that she was born and raised in Mexico,
which is like fine, OK?
And then she would tell another person, no, no, no,
I was born in Mexico,
but then I came to California,
and my parents abandoned me under a bridge,
and this like random family
picked me up from under the bridge,
and now I'm living with them.
But that's a lie, because this isn't a random family.
These are literally your relatives.
What is happening right now?
So then she would lie that she had 18 siblings,
but four of them are already dead,
so she only has 14 siblings now.
But she used to have 18 siblings and we get worse later in life. So Dorithia later in life she
would go into these bars and she would, um, it's the weirdest thing, she would go into these local
bars and she would just like slam her hand down on the bar and be like, oh man, I need a vodka.
They'd give her a vodka and they'd be like rough day at work and she's like Yeah, they called me in for this emergency surgery on this like seven-year-old girl. Oh
My god, I was I was in the OR for like 12 hours. I need a shot
She's not a doctor
I don't understand these lies. They're so insane and she would do this all the time
It got so bad that the local community members, some of them just called
her the doctor. Like they thought she was a retired doctor that was now running a boarding house.
So her first marriage happened when she was 16 years old and she got married to a 22 year old man.
If that man, his name is Fred McFall and he was a soldier. So they end up moving to Washington
together and she just gets into the sex work. She was already kind of doing sex work before she met him but it got worse once they met. Not for the reason that you
were thinking which is the fact that oh yeah maybe he's like pimping her out definitely taking
advantage of her definitely grooming her right but on top of that he would encourage her in the
weirdest way. He would kept saying you know the reason I love you right Dorothea it's because you're
so independent. You're like one of the most independent women I know because you are willing to do anything
to have independence, such as sex work. Which is like a backhanded compliment if you're 18,
but like when you're 16, it's like, what? That's like so rude. What is happening? That's creepy.
That's creepy. I'm 16. This is illegal. I shouldn't be doing this
But like why are you saying that? So they end up having two daughters together and they were both
Sent away to live with other people one for adoption another one went with Dorothy as relatives
And she ended up having like a miscarriage after that and it was just like I said
16 years old trauma after trauma after trauma not an excuse
But just giving you the picture.
So then Fred files for divorce, and she too starts lying about it again.
She tells all of her friends he like died one of the most tragic deaths ever.
Sometimes it would be in war.
Sometimes like a car crash splinted to cut him in half, you know?
Found him on the side of the road, found a leg.
Like it was just really strange stuff.
Like just kept telling people different stories.
Sometimes it's a little innocent heart attack.
Sometimes he was murdered by Ted Bundy.
Like you know what I mean?
I don't know if the Ted Bundy thing, but like you get it.
It's just really, really strange lies.
So people were really sympathetic about this.
I mean, this is crazy.
How are you gonna live Doraphia?
So she starts doing more sex work and starts, you know committing petty crime
Just pretty much stealing from stores forging these checks and she's just really lazy at it
That's all I have to say when she's 19 years old she walks into this store and she forges the check, right and the cashier is like
Something about this feels weird. So she calls the police and she's like, okay. Well you guys are gonna come okay?
So I have to stall and she's like, okay, well, you guys are gonna come? Okay, so I have to stall.
So she's like, okay, so she starts stalling Dorothy.
Like, oh, you should try this one on, right?
Dorothy is catching on to this.
So she runs out, just leaves everything.
Runs out, hops on a bus.
Now the police happen to get there at the same time.
So they see her running on the bus and they notice
that that bus is headed in this direction.
So they go to the local bus stop, she gets arrested and she does four months in prison. Now during this four months, they do a
psychiatric assessment and it's just said that she had super low self-esteem. The reason that she
steals all these clothes and stuff and makeup is to make people like her. They also wrote in her
report that they believe that she will be a repeat offender if she does not get rehabilitated.
And in prison, her lies only got weirder. She said, I'm a lawyer.
And the prisoners were like, oh, that's cool. Can you help me? Like, appeal my gaze.
And she's like, yeah, I have ties to the royal family. I actually dated someone in the royal family.
I, um, I'm in jail because the Illuminati, like really weird stuff.
Like she claimed that she was an actor dating these actors
and just, do you get what I'm saying?
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Just odd stuff.
So she gets out and she decides, you know what,
I'm gonna violate the terms of my parole.
Move out of Washington and move to San Francisco
where she continues her sex work.
So her second marriage was to a guy by the name of Alex Johansson.
She told him that she was half black and half Asian and Muslim.
Which like none of those were true.
Then she lies about not being a sex worker and her husband is a fisherman, so he's gone
a lot at the time.
And eventually she decides, okay, I need to just open up a brothel.
She becomes, you know, essentially a brothel owner and she doesn't take on clients anymore.
So she rents out this space.
She tells the landlord, it's for a book club.
Oh, these lies.
They get weirder.
She's like, yeah, it's for a book club.
Look at me, I'm like a cute little housewife.
I'm doing book club.
So he believes it.
Turns it into a brothel.
And eventually the landlord's catching up.
That's not no book club. Like like let's be real, right?
Like why are you guys wearing this to a book club?
Why are there suddenly so many men at this book club?
It's just something's weird so he calls the police the police go undercover and sure enough
Straight up in this book club, you know Dorothy is like hey, you want a blowjob?
So he's like all right, this is a brothel.
Let's arrest the shit out of everyone.
So she gets arrested and she spends 90 days in prison.
So after she's released, her husband gets her admitted into a psychiatric ward
because he's like, you must be crazy to be doing something like this.
And they say that she is a pathological liar with an unstable personality
that requires anti-psychotic medication.
And they prescribed it to her.
It's springtime.
So it's that time.
There's two sounds inside of this house that are consistent with spring.
Me sneezing because of pollen, but also my dogs licking their paws,
biting on their legs because they have crazy allergies in the springtime. And the only thing that I have found that has been super helpful during this time is solid
gold pet foods.
Did you know that 80% of the immune system is influenced by your gut?
Supporting the immune system through a proper diet and digestive health enables pets to
better fight environmental allergies.
Solid gold is passionate about this.
They are passionate about your pet's got health because a healthy digestive system
Positively impacts the immune system and just overall wellness of your pets, which here's the cool thing about solid gold
They have been here for over 45 years and they have revolutionized the holistic pet food category
They even have a recipe for any of your dog or cats's dietary needs, which includes healthy whole grain,
grain-free options, wet food supplements like seameal. We have been adding seameal into our dog food.
Their skin and coat, my dog has skin issues and the other one, I mean, they didn't have like the
softest coat, but now it's silky smooth and they also have a hundred percent human grade bone broth,
which my dogs are obsessed with this and their whole nutritional platform is
inspired by their founding belief that high quality food is the best way to impact our
pets mind, body and spirit.
Solid gold foods is the way to do it and they're a little bit different because they like
to cleanse the digestive system with whole super foods balance, with living probiotics
and fuel your dog with omega-3 and six fatty acids.
So they support that gut health, they nourish your pet. So right now, to save 30% off on select solid gold products, go to solidgoldpet.com-
slash rotten. That's solidgoldpet.com slash rotten. To save 30% on select solid gold products,
remember, solidgoldpet.com- slash rotten. Now, they get divorced.
And her third marriage was to Roberto Puente.
20 years younger than her really weird couple.
People said that they did not get along.
They didn't even have anything in common.
So the belief was that he was using her for citizenship.
And they just pretty much broke up almost immediately after the marriage. and they stayed married for years because neither of them officially filed for divorce
but they weren't in each other's lives if that makes sense.
And that is when she decides to take on a new job, no more sex work she said, I'm gonna
be a little 8, like a caretaker.
It's called like a nurse's 8 but technically she's not a nurse, right?
So she would go into these elderly people's houses and take care of their cleaning make sure that they take their meds give them these
sponge baths stuff like that now she doesn't love the job Dorothea does not like this job at all
but you know money is money with that she buys a house in Sacramento on F straight that's three stories
tall you say F street it's literally called f street. Just letter f. Yeah
Very cool. Yeah, very cool. Right
No, yeah, and there's like tons of bedrooms and she sets up a boarding house
So the second floor the top floor was all to herself. She's had this bedroom this office in this office
She hung up fake nursing diplomas. She's like doing the most
She had tons of like syringes like cabinets and had tons of like syringes, like cabinets,
and drawers full of like syringes, and like nurse stuff. But she didn't even know how to use it.
She's not a nurse. So it's just weird. It's like all for show. And then the ground floor and the
basement was where the tenants stay. So the ground floor had the kitchen and all of these rooms were
single rooms. So they would have a TV and a bed in each room, and these are for the high payers.
These are much more expensive.
You're completely alone.
It also had in-unit bathrooms, but these weren't bathrooms that were attached to the room.
Someone had installed a toilet into the room, just into the room.
If that makes sense.
Not like, oh, yeah, there's a bathroom connected.
So they DIY, uh,
yeah, so everyone gets their own like little bathroom
inside of these rooms.
So then in the basement, it was kind of like what you imagine
in those scary hospital scenes where it was really dim,
it was really dark, one big room,
and she would just have these like single beds
separated by curtains in one single room.
So now this was for the low paying tenants, I guess. And the rules of the boarding house were very simple.
The only rule is that you have to sign over all of your benefit checks to her to
ensure that you would not forget to pay her or come up with some excuse because a
lot of the people that she was housing they had addictions. You know, so this
was her saying, I'm just this is my safety deposit. I will take the check take your rent
Take all the food because she feeds them, you know
Take all the utilities and then give you the rest and you can do whatever you want
So it kind of makes sense. It's not the most. Oh my god
I don't believe this situation, right? Yeah, now she was really shady with it though
She didn't give them an itemized receipt. She never told them even how much rent was. Like nobody living there knew how much rent was. If they asked, she would say, oh well,
I mean, some of that's for food. Blah blah blah. Like it was just strange. So she's trying
to...
But how much are they, like let's say they're getting paid?
Like hundreds.
Like, does she take majority of it?
majority.
Ah, okay. So she's that, okay, I'll leave you a little bit.
Yeah. Some of them complained. Some of them didn't, because some of them kind of liked her.
I mean, she does cook for them.
She does seem to be nice.
Randomly, she'll buy them like small gifts here and there.
So it's just weird.
I think that's why people have such a hard time with Dorothy
and I think I have a hard time with understanding Dorothy
because she is a walking contradiction.
So she does actually take care of these people.
Maybe not to the best ability,
but it's not like she is abusing the shit out of them.
It's not like your standard like elderly abuse center where they're just like beating
up the elderly people and stealing all their money.
It seems like she does try to take care of them to a certain extent.
Okay.
Like she is really busy like cooking non-stop.
It's weird.
So then she starts making a lot of money and she likes it.
I mean, she starts spending money on clothes
Go into the bars all the time paying for shots buying pizza's to the bar
What a popular person and the community loved her because this is a woman who's lived a full life
I mean she's a former actress and a surgeon
A surgeon this is crazy. You know, she had so many hard surgeries on little children
that were successful. I mean, wow! She, she's connections with the royal family. Did
you know that? Yeah, it's crazy. She has 14 siblings. She was born and raised in Mexico,
super cultured. I mean, it's, this is a woman of experience. And the community loved
her. So they started inviting her out
all to these community events.
And she started giving back to the community.
She would buy local school kids
who were really struggling just by them backpack, food,
school supplies.
She would donate tons of money to the police association
and all these other charitable things.
She would donate money.
And so I didn't know it's like,
this is just like the sweetest old lady.
She's got all this money from being a surgeon and an actress in movies that I've never seen before. But she must be an actress. And now she's
donating it. And this boarding house, she would constantly tell people that she lived such a privileged
life and she just wanted to give back. So people believed her because she's given all this money away. I mean, if she was
just using these people for money, then she wouldn't give it away to charity,
would she?
Would she?
She hires a groundskeeper by the name of Pedro Montalvo
and gave him a room in the house,
pretty much hired him because he was really attractive,
much younger than her, and they just start dating, you know?
She starts taking him out on these lavish dinners.
He thought that this was true love.
They have so much in common.
They're both from Mexico.
She's not from Mexico.
And so he's just like, wow, I found the woman of my dreams.
She's 45.
He's like at his 20s or something when they got married.
And it was just getting worse.
I feel like immediately he felt strange about Dorothy.
Like she's stealing Chuck, she's stealing jewelry.
Just something strange.
And she was cheating on Pedro.
She was still going to these bars, robbing men at these bars,
and so one month later instead of divorcing her,
he just like runs away.
Just runs away.
The police get on to her.
Because they realize that sometimes they would arrest these men,
and while they're sitting in prison, their Czechs were getting signed.
And the police can see that.
They're like, wait a minute, how would I arrest arrested them and they have to sign off on their disability checks?
But it's like getting signed off on I'm so confused. They're sitting in prison right now
How are they that doesn't make any sense?
So they go to the address where these checks are being signed off on and it was Dorothy us signing these checks
She did this to about 40 people and that's that's illegal
You can't be signing these disability checks, right?
So she has 40 people's
checks coming in every month. Yeah
So they're gonna rest her and they tell her hey, you can't run a boarding house
Okay
And she's like okay, so they do a psychiatric check on her and they diagnosed her with schizophrenia
and she was given five years probation.
She was not put in prison, just five years probation.
So during this five years would be a time
of just inventing herself, okay, she would go around
meeting all these other men, stealing their money
and she started changing up her look.
She decided, you know what, I like the boarding house business.
Way more than robbing people at the bars.
So she starts growing out all of her white hairs.
She would dress older, she would walk older, get all the styles about like the people who were in their 70s when in reality she's like in her 50s.
She really looked the part of this cute little grandma.
So she starts renting a room with a family that lives on F street. So the same street.
So she starts renting a room in that boarding house,
and I mean, she just starts scamming around some more.
She pretended to be a nurse, targeted these elderly sick people,
and then she would go to their house, give them some medicine,
they would pass out, wake up, and have all of their valuables taken.
She loves stealing people's checkbooks,
and then forging the checkbooks with their fake signatures,
trying to steal money into her account. While n nannying she gets this little side hustle. So
these men at the bars let's talk about that right? Dorothy O. would start
meeting people. One of them was Malcolm McKenzie. He is the one that kind of
jump started all of this crazy why she's on probation in the first place. They
meet at a bar. They're having a great time. He's like in his 70s. She's in her
50s and he suggested hey why don't we go back to my place?
Listen, I, I hope that when I'm in my 70s, I'm like, we're still porkin', okay?
Like, we're still doing the nasty in our 70s. So he's like, why don't we go back to
my place? Do the nasty and she's like, Oh my god, that's so exciting. Yes, let's
do it. So they get into a taxi and on their way back to his apartment, he
starts feeling strange. Like, this has never happened before. I mean, his 70 years old is something going on. Is he about to die?
We don't know. Like he's freaking out. He's drunk before, but now he's feeling like his limbs are
just out of control. He feels like jello. And finally, they make it into his apartment. Somehow,
he's able to unlock the door and he just collapses onto his couch. But the weird thing he said is that he felt paralyzed,
but his mind was sharp.
He was conscious, and that's when he starts watching her,
just calmly, coldly walking through his apartment,
finds his small red suitcase, opens it up in front of him,
and starts dumping all of his valuables in there.
And at the end, she walked up to him,
and took off his rings.
Dumped it into the suitcase, locked it up, and rolled out of there.
What?
So he wakes up the next morning and he vividly remembers all of this,
so he goes to the police and he is, you know, what's going on?
I saw all of this, I think she drugged me, the police arrest her,
and she just kept saying, it's a gift, it's a gift.
I don't know what you're talking about, this is all a gift, he gifted it to me, you guys are crazy,
so they said, alright well you guys have to show up to court in a couple of months, just show up to
court and fight it out in court, this is all we can do, so now she's out waiting for her court date,
you would think that she's gonna lay it low, right? No, so she had this best friend, the only friend
really named Ruth, and Ruth's husband was dying
So Dorothea was like oh no when your husband's dead
How are you gonna support yourself and Ruth is like I know I don't know I'm freaking out
So Dorothy is like well, we should start our business together. I catering business. Oh, it'll be so good
But I don't have money. Do you have money?
You have two thousand dollars saved up. Why don't we open up a joint account for our business, right?
And you put the money in there and we will get straight to work.
Not only is this a great investment, you will get your money back and more.
So they put that $2,000 into that little joint banking account and then Ruth's husband passes
away and she's super sad.
So Dorothea offers her, why don't you move in with me?
In my room, in this little house that I'm renting in,
she's like, okay, I mean, I guess that makes sense.
Ruth's kids thought this was perfect.
I mean, yeah, Dad's gone now.
You can spend time with your best friend.
You're, this is amazing, right?
But slowly, her health starts declining.
She starts acting really strange.
She just seems zoned out anytime the kids would come over
or they would go out to lunch.
I mean, what's coming on with our mom?
So they straight up asked Dorothy and she said,
oh God, she's been having these nervous breakdowns
and I took her to the local hospital
and they keep giving her these tranquilizers.
I mean, she's just, she's so depressed about,
you know, your dad's passing.
When it makes sense, So they thank her.
They're like, wow, thank you so much for taking her to the hospital.
And then a little while later, Dorothy, I call the kids, freaking out.
She's like, you need to come over to the house right now.
So they rush on over and roost.
Their mother is just sitting there on the ground in a fetal position, staring at a wall.
Can't talk to them.
Can't move.
Just staring at a wall.
They're so confused by this, but maybe they can get her some help.
But that next morning, before they can even get her out, they get a call.
Roof is dead.
So Dorothy, I believe, that Ruth took more medication than she should have, because, you know,
is prescribed to her, she was either losing it mentally or she took her own life.
It's so sad, but that is what it is.
So the autopsy was done on Ruth's body, and it showed that she had a drug overdose of Tylenol and Coding. Now these were never
prescribed to her, so this is strange. I mean, just all of it is strange. She didn't
leave a note for the kids. She didn't even tell the kids. Just super weird. Everyone was
super suspicious of Dorothya. They start investigating. The autopsy also showed that Ruth had pills
in the back of her throat that hadn't dissolved yet. Which, I mean, you just take that much pills that you
don't even finish swallowing and letting it dissolve later on. Like, that just seems
really crazy. They also do some digging into that hospital that Dorothea allegedly took
Ruth to because she's having these nervous breakdowns and they tranquilize star, right?
Turns out the hospital has no record of these visits.
So the kids are suspicious of her.
Yeah.
And they keep telling the police, I mean, you got to arrest this girl like she is, she killed
our mom.
And they tell the kids, this is all circumstantial evidence.
There is no proof that she is the one that administered the medicine to her.
And we are ruling her death as suicide, Which is the biggest blow to these kids.
They will eventually get some sort of justice but just insane.
And the police were a little bit confused.
You know the ones that were waiting for her court date to happen.
They were like, oh, well she was being investigated briefly for her best friend's death.
So this is all strange and then they find out, wait a minute, we just heard from her friends
that Dorothy about a plane ticket to Mexico.
She took out that $2,000 in that joint account and now something weird is happening.
Dorothya ends up at another friend's house, pretty much drugs her and steals all of her
valuables and she actually gets arrested while holding all of the valuables of her good
friend Dorothy.
Dorothya stole friend Dorothy? Yeah and she literally got arrested with all of her stuff like of her good friend Dorothy. Dorothy, a still friend Dorothy?
Yeah, and she literally got arrested with all of her stuff,
like all of her IDs, her rings, like her cards,
or cash, and she was like, it's a gift!
So she was just going around stealing.
I think Dorothy was trying to steal from more of her friends
so that she had enough to go to Mexico.
Like she would feel good about, oh, I have enough cash
because she only had about $2,000 in cash.
I see.
So she gets sentenced to five years in enough cash because she only had about $2,000 in cash. I see.
So she gets sentenced to five years in prison but she only spent three years.
Now in prison her lies got even worse.
So Hathi and Mates knew her as this crazy surgeon who was being taken down by a big
pharma or something of that sort.
Like something really crazy, okay.
I don't know if it was big pharma, I don't know if it was other surgeons.
Like a doctor starvation moment, she was just like all these men around for me, you know?
They just like can't handle a woman in this field.
That was like the vibe, then some people knew her as a lawyer, some people said that she
was always getting scouted by acting agencies, you know, dated so many A-list celebrities,
dated royal family members, just all of that.
And she started having pen pals during her prison sentence.
One of them was a 77 year old man by the name of Everton Gilman, who lived in Oregon.
This is a really sad story, so his wife passed away and he was looking for a new wife.
I don't know why he was writing to female prisoners, but he was, okay, he was a little
bit lonely, started correspondence with female prisoners, and she was not into him until he wrote in a letter that he was on government pension.
So suddenly she's like, wow, you're really hot. So she's released. She's only 56 years old, and the psychiatrist told her that she should never be allowed to tell, like, take care of sick people.
to tell like take care of sick people. The psychiatrist straight up told her, told the courts,
she cannot take care of younger, older, sick, and needy, vulnerable people.
She just cannot be trusted around the vulnerable population point blank.
And they were supposed to have more sessions, but she never really showed up for them
and no one ever really pursued that.
So after her release, it gets worse.
She gets picked up by ever said, and he's moving with her.
He's brought all of his stuff for more again.
He's said by his family that he's met the love of his life.
She lives in California.
She's gone, he's gone now.
So they moved back into that family house where she used to nanny.
Now at this point, the whole family had moved to a new house and they're renting her the
entire house.
Side note, I do think that this family was in on it.
I don't think that they were in on the murders, but I think that there was some later on some sort
of agreement because a lot of these checks from disability were being signed
off by some of you know the family members was weird. So it seemed like they
knew something about it or maybe like a scheme. Yeah, so that's like the vibe
that I'm getting allegedly don't sue me.son he's living in this house in a new state where he doesn't know anyone and all of a sudden he stops
Mailing his family stops cuts off contact with them. So his family in Oregon. They freak out his kids
They're like, oh my god. I got to call this Sacramento police. What's going on?
So the police in Sacramento they do a wellness check knock knock. We're looking for an everson and guess what?
He's there. He's there. He's super there. Just super alive Since Sacramento they do a wellness check, knock knock, we're looking for an ever-scent. And guess what?
He's there, he's there.
He's super there, just super alive, just chilling.
And he gets super pissed off, he's like, oh, this is why I cut off my kids, like they're
so annoying, like they won't let me live my life.
They can't be happy for me that I found this young fine thing in California, you know,
like let me live.
So he cuts off his family for good, but Dorothya being the sweet, amazing person that she is, she keeps writing to them.
She's like, hey, I know that he's a little bit upset right now,
but I'll keep you guys in the loop on what's going on in our lives.
So now they're like, oh my god, Dorothy, you're amazing.
Thank you.
And she starts accepting borders again.
So I mean, around this time that she's accepting these borders, ever since family, they get a letter that he's moving down south.
He's done with Dorothea, she's heartbroken, he's moving out now.
He says that he's going to update you guys eventually, but, you know, that is what it is.
But he had been murdered.
So the theory is, either he had been slowly drugged or he had been drugged and then suffocated.
So when the kids got the letter, they were like, oh, it's fine.
Yeah, they were just like, I mean, this is so weird, but I guess, right?
I mean, it just like made sense a little bit enough.
Like, it was, it's that weird, it's the edge of like, oh man, if I call the cops and do this crazy thing again,
it's gonna make us look dumb, it's gonna make him look down, he's gonna be more mad at us.
But if I don't do anything, it's like, you know what I mean?
Just like a really great area.
So she drugs him, she murders him, and this time she does, so this is before any of her,
like this is her second murder.
Ruth had passed away in the hospital, she is not buried anyone in any of the gardens yet,
and she has no idea what to do with ever since body.
So she drags him into a spare room of the house which later, all of the reports called
the death room.
Because it smelled like death.
She brought all of the bodies in there until it was time to bury them.
It's really bad.
So she kept them in there for days.
She didn't know what to do with the body, So she starts getting desperate and she starts freaking out.
What do I do?
So she hires a handyman, a random handyman and says,
hey, I need you to build me a box, a storage box.
Well, what is the box for?
For my books, you know, because I'm like such an educated person.
So I need to put my books in a box
and I need you to make this storage box.
I'm thinking six feet by two feet.
What's it? You know like a coffin but not it's obviously not a coffin. It's for my
books but kind of like a coffin shape. You know kind of like a lengthen with like a coffin
but like not a coffin. So he's like um yeah okay I'll build you that box. So he starts building
that box and then she comes up to and she's, hey, I have this random red pickup truck.
You know, that was ever since.
Do you want to buy it for like $800?
It's in good condition and he's like $800.
It looks like an amazing deal.
Yeah, I want to buy it.
I don't have a car.
So he buys this pickup truck from her for $800.
Builds the storage box and she loves that
she's like oh my god I'm gonna fill it with books and do you have a lid for it? Oh
that's the lid. Okay so I can just like nail it, shout or something. Oh this is
good. So he leaves and then she calls him back and she's like hey I put all my
books in there. Can you help me move it to like my um my storage unit with that
new truck? I know you have a truck now because I sold it to you,
so can you help me?" So he's like, uh, okay, sure. So he drives up to our house. They load that big
box that had been nailed completely airtight shut into the truck and they start driving to the
storage unit. But before they get to the storage unit, she sees the Sacramento River and she says,
Hey, can you pull over? So they pull over and she says,
you know, I'm thinking about it.
And these books are not even expensive, you know?
And my storage unit is expensive
and I'm paying a lot for all the space.
And I don't think I can even make space for these books.
I think I should just leave it on the side of the river.
So he's like, I mean, I, okay.
So he helps her, takes coffin shaped one in parks to the side of the river and they just leave it there
And he went home he said wow I helped a I helped a cute little grandma day. I love elderly people. I love seniors
Not even considered a senior. She really had no clue. Huh? Yeah, no clue
Oh my god, I know, allegedly, you know?
And so, New Year's Day, a fisherman
is trying to look for a place to fish on the Sacramento River.
And he sees a big wooden box.
And he's like, well, that is oddly like a coffin shape.
Seems weird, at a river bank.
Wow, really strange.
So he walks towards it and he's like, what is that smell?
So he opens up the box and he sees the badly decomposed body of an elderly man.
So bad that they can't even ID this person.
He calls the cops in and they only know that he's an elderly man.
But other than that, he's kept in the morgue as a John Doe.
That's it.
Wow.
Meanwhile, she's still getting his pension checks every single month.
Yeah.
So these pension checks don't stop until it was notified that they passed.
Yeah.
So technically it can go on forever.
It seems like it.
Wasn't there the story of that one woman who had her husband in the freezer to get those pension checks?
I feel like that happens a lot.
Like more than I'd like to think it does.
That is really odd.
But then like sometimes it's so sad because I don't even think there's anything sinister.
Like I don't think that they murdered each other, but maybe they just like can't make
money.
I don't know.
Not this one.
This is straight up sick and twisted and murder.
Dorothy is boarding house.
Her tenants.
Like I said, she has a variety of different tenants.
Some of them were just elderly sick people who were not able to take their own medications
on a daily basis.
Like they would either forget, they would either not do it. So now the government is paying, you know, her place to house them from
these checks, you know, she's getting a portion of it. So that was some of them. Those were her
patients that she liked, like the tenants that she liked. These are the ones that she actually
cared about them. She fed them, she gave them their medication every day, and then she had the other
tenants that were on disability or that were on this or this support system, and they would pay her to live
there, but they were just, they were, you know, succumbing to their addictions, they were
drinking a lot, they were, you know, doing other drugs.
One of these women was Betty Palmer, who was 80 years old, and she was a super active
old lady, like just flirted with her doctors on stop, like that type of lady, like the
ones that people love, you know, and she's like's like oh stop hitting on me doctor I'll come too young for you
like that type of 80-year-old lady like the fun ones she moved into the boarding house and she suddenly
starts getting sick I mean she was there for a month and then suddenly she vanished so Dorothy
tells everyone oh her daughter picked her up went to live with her you know Betty you know how she is
so she had taken Betty's body to the death room, locked her in there, and last time she's
thinking, that was too dangerous, you know, I can't just, I can't just commission these
coffin like boxes from handyman all the time.
So what do I do?
Maybe I can just bury her in the backyard.
But what if one day the body is dug up, you know?
What if one day I move out, I think I'm free of all of this and then someone digs up the body.
A dog, you know, the next family is gonna have a fucking
golden retriever, gonna go into the back
and just dig, dig, dig, oh my God, a human body.
Then she's gonna be ID'd and it's gonna be linked to me.
Okay, I have to get rid of all the identifying features.
So she saw it off her hands, her feet,
because your footprint works, your fingerprints,
and then decapitated her.
Rapped the rest of her remains in cloth in the middle of the night
went to her little fruit garden.
And, you know, the tenants heard all of this.
They heard the bangin', they heard the digging.
But they all thought to themselves,
I mean, she's so busy during the day,
and this woman loves gardening,
so maybe this is the only time that she can garden in peace.
And she buried the body.
The head's hand and feet to this day have never been found.
Betty's daughter starts coming to the house and this is when the tenants were like, wait a minute!
Betty's daughter, the one that Dorothy acclaimed, that took Betty, is like, hey, where's my mom?
And so all of the tenants they confront Dorothy and they're like, hey Betty's daughter just stop by and ask where's her mom?
And so she said, oh, okay, this is so embarrassing. You guys know I'm getting so old.
I couldn't take care of Betty anymore and I just felt so ashamed that I couldn't take
care of her even though I said that I would.
So I put her in a care home.
I'll tell the daughter, don't worry.
So the tenants just moved on.
There was a man by the name of James Gallup and she had met him at a bar one night and he
was a struggling alcoholic.
He was on government assistance and she wanted him to stay with her one night and he was a struggling alcoholic. He was on government assistance
and she wanted him to stay with her
so that she could take care of him.
She was like, you're using all of your government assistance
on alcohol.
I can help you with this.
I can help you get clean.
Don't worry, my parents were alcoholics.
I have a problem with alcohol.
Sometimes I can help you.
So he's thinking, you know what?
Maybe this boarding house doesn't sound so bad.
So he is about to move in, but she says on one condition, I have to be able to have all
of your checks, sign them over to me, and then I will give you the rest of the money minus
the boarding fee and the food and everything. And he's like, wait a minute, no, I'm not doing
that. No, I'm not doing that. That's on shady. And then he had a brain tumor. So he had
to get surgery, brain surgery. So he's like,
okay, I'm having all these health issues. Maybe this is the only way that, you know, someone will
take care of me. So he moves in, he didn't sign over his checks, but when they got to the house,
she was the only one with a key to the mailbox. So she would intercept all of his checks.
So she's in control of making sure he takes his medication every day, right? But he starts feeling more sick after this brain surgery.
But what is she feeding them?
Oh, well, I'll tell you.
Yeah, and he starts getting more sick, but I mean, how can you really say that's not the brain surgery?
Brain surgery is intense.
How are you supposed to know what the symptoms of that are?
So he just kind of deals with it.
And then one day, he just like vanishes.
The tenants are like, hey, where's that really sick guy that just had brain surgery that probably
shouldn't be like traveling
or shouldn't leave, should be bed ridden
for like, I don't know months.
Where'd he go?
Oh, he just like packed up his stuff and left, I don't know.
And then there was that smell again
because she had taken him to the death room.
This time she didn't take away any of his like identifying
features like she didn't cut off the hands and feet.
She just wrapped her in plastic and cloth and buried him in the garden.
So now at this point she starts freaking out because she realizes, oh my god, I'm an idiot.
He just had brain surgery. He's gonna have doctors appointments that he needs to go to because
he has brain surgery is not one of those things where you're like, alright, thanks doc and then you never see them again.
So she calls the doctor and says, hey, I know this is going to sound crazy,
but I just want to let you know that he moved out.
Yeah, I just like don't want to live here anymore.
Also, he didn't like you guys.
He found a new doctor.
No hard feelings.
Yeah, no hard feelings, but he wanted me to tell you that you guys are shit.
Like, it's just, the doctor was like, no, that doesn't make any sense.
Like after brain surgery,
so they started thinking about, okay, what could this be?
What could this be?
But they didn't really get anywhere.
Because I don't know.
They were busy.
So what she was using, good question, right?
So there's this sedative called Dolman, I think.
It's pretty much like this really intense sleeping aid.
It's a sedative that stays in your system a really long time.
It is actually not prescribed that often at all from what I can tell. I'm not really into like drugs.
Well, how did she try it? So you can get it, you know, she got it prescribed.
She would actually convince all of her borders to get it. She would tell them, go to your doctor,
say exactly ABC&D and ask them for this because you've been on it before and it worked amazing, it worked wonders for you.
Eventually she stalked about thousands of them because she would never use them.
And then when she had a victim, she would slowly start using it on them.
And it was such an intense, slowly working sedatives that eventually they would just, you know,
it would start attacking their organs.
They would start dying from it.
Now that's where it's kind of up in the air.
Is this how they died?
Or did she get to a place where they couldn't move
and then she suffocated them?
We don't really know.
So then the next victim was Vera Martin, who was 64 years old.
And she had tons of health conditions.
So Dorothy has started getting really upset.
See, it seems like with Dorothy,
if you're slightly sick, she loves you.
She can take care of you.
Take your government checks, take care of you a little bit, and that's it.
And you just sit in one of those rooms.
Maybe if they require too much of her time.
Yes, but if you're really sick, and you're gonna like, she's gotta like help you to the bathroom.
You're not worth the time.
Does she give you up though?
No, because then you should have to give up your government checks.
So Vera Martin, within one week of going to this boarding house
She disappeared and she was murdered then we have Leona Carpenter who is 78 years old now
She was one of Dorothy's favorites favorites. I mean just absolutely a gem never questioned where the money was going
Never had any questions never any complaints just lived by herself in one of those rooms
It had her checks come in lived by herself in one of those rooms,
had her checks come in, Dorothy took control of everything,
but then her health conditions started deteriorating.
So then Dorothy had killed her and buried her in the backyard.
Then we have Benjamin Fink.
Now this one is kind of different from the rest,
so he's 55 years old.
He had been living there for over a year
and he was an intense alcoholic
and they never really got
along.
Dorothy I never really liked it.
Now one night he gets super drunk and starts making a scene at the house, like just yelling
in the middle of the living room and she drags him to his room and tells the other tenants,
don't worry I'm going to make him feel better.
Drags him to the room and she was visibly angry the next day he's gone and they're like,
what happened?
Nobody questioned anything? No, and's been a question to anything.
No, and she just said, well, we had that really nasty fight last night and you know, he left.
Now, this one it seemed like she'd suffocated him because there was no indication or suspicion that he was being drugged.
Like, all of the other ones, it seems like all the other victims, she was slowly drugging them with the sedative and then eventually they met their deaths.
But this one seemed like, maybe she drugged him and then suffocated him or just straight-up
suffocated him and then sent to the death room which again is just becoming stinkier and stinkier.
The tenants did not care about missing tenants. They cared about that. What's that smell?
And she would straight-up tell them it's the new fertilizer for my garden.
So the whole house probably smells like that?
Yeah, because it was carpeted and she would leave them in there for days. So there would be a lot of
fluid that would leak into the carpet and even into the flooring underneath the
carpet in the death room. And her backyard, I mean this is Sacramento, California,
she didn't have a Texas-sized backyard. At this point it was jam-packed. It was
like a graveyard. So then Dorothy Miller, 65 years old, the one with the ID, or the pill bottles and the
ID found in Dorothy's room the day that the police came, was she disappeared.
She was also a tenant, you know.
It was just a lot.
It seemed like Dorothy was one of the tenants that got suspicious about the government checks.
And then, you know, Bert, like we were talking about in the beginning of the podcast, he disappeared.
So that's leading you up to the beginning of the story.
And that is when the public start giving tips.
You know, like I said, the taxi driver was like, oh, she's had it's a Los Angeles.
You know, all the digging continues.
The social workers are freaking out.
They found seven bodies in total.
And then, you know, Mexico's freaking out because they're like, uh, we don't want her.
Like, get her out of here.
Why is she trying to come here?
And so they start collecting evidence from her house.
They found 300 separate items of evidence.
She had books on drugs.
Like a heavy duty book on prescription drugs.
What each one does, the side effects of each, like, why do you have that, ma'am?
You're not a nurse.
What's going on?
She had massive amounts of pill bottles.
They took pieces of the carpeting from the death room, and they reached out to the government pension people, and they got a list, a master list,
of anyone who has ever sent their pension checks to this address.
And so from there, they went on a spree of contacting and tracking down each person
because they don't have ideas for these seven bodies.
They need to know who these people even are.
Yeah.
To be able to even tie them to her.
Yeah.
So then they get a call from a local halfway house.
So a halfway house is kind of one of those,
well, I think maybe there's different versions,
but this specific one was when you're released from prison,
sometimes you go to a halfway house,
where you still have to check in at night,
but during the day, maybe you can look for a job,
during the day, you can go do your thing and then at night, it's kind of like your transition point
from being full-on-free to like, prison. And they said, hey, we know Dorothea, and we were the ones
digging the holes in the garden. So now the press is like, what? The police is like, what? So she would
ask Pearl Least come dig these holes in the garden and she would pay them and she was really nice
She was providing these people with work and she would constantly tell them, you know
The rest of society is shining you guys out, but I won't dig these holes in my garden because I want a plant
Elementary, but she would never plant a lemon tree and one of the Pearl Least went to the police and said
So Dorothy had asked me for a huge favor one time. And she asked me to call this person named Judy
and pretend that I'm this guy's relative.
I think his name is Bert.
And I was supposed to say that I picked him up,
but I didn't.
I just felt bad for her, so I called.
So they're like, oh my gosh.
Now, I mean, this is international news.
She's a fugitive serial killer, an old lady serial killer
who hid bodies in her little rose bush garden.
And now she's a freaking fugitive.
And that is when all this news breaks out, the Everton family, you know, Everton's family,
they hear about it in Oregon.
His kids are like, wait a minute.
This is the lady that was dating our dad.
What?
So they call the police, they take down these notes, and you know, the police are like,
well, we haven't identified any of the bodies yet.
Like, just give us a minute, but they kept counting the police
So we'll get to that. This is all gonna like come together now you would think that Dorothy is gonna lay low
She's gonna be challenged. She's gonna be hiding. She's gonna be making it racing to Mexico
No, she started hanging out in LA and go into these bars
And she would sit there and she would talk to these men and she would constantly ask
So do you get checks from the government?
Are you on social security?
Now one of them when he was asked that his ears perked up because he had just recently remembered seeing something on the news
Now he didn't know this was the same lady, but like what's the coincidence?
Right, I mean he didn't notice her by her look like was oh, that's the woman on the news, right?
But was like oh all that's the woman on the news right but was like oh that's weird that's a really odd question and I think she was at a place of desperation you know so she's
like really just not trying to be smooth and slick with it so he was like oh yeah well where you
staying oh the motel down the street oh yeah yeah maybe I can like visit you and he's like getting
all this information out of her they don't't hang out that night. Thankfully, the next morning, he calls the police, they show up, and the LAPD arrest her.
Just like that.
Just like that. And she gets taken back to Sacramento.
They were able to slowly identify the rest of the bodies. They found Mr. Fink because he had tattoos and then Dorothy Miller. She was identified, Burt was identified,
and then slowly the rest were working.
Now, the only thing is like, okay,
well, are these the only victims?
So the Everson family, they keep pounding the police.
Like, we know that our dad is one of those victims,
but we only found two males in their accounted for,
you know, Mr. Fink and Burt.
This just makes sense.
Oh my God, that elderly man in the box.
From the Sacramento River.
That's weird.
Well, let's try to do that.
So finally, it was put to rest.
It was verified to be the remains of Everson.
And then Ruth's family start reaching out to the police.
Like, hey, we told you guys.
We were the first one that told you guys that she's weird
and that she's a murderer,
but you ruled our mom's death a suicide.
So they finally reopened the case and she was considered one of the victims of Dorothy
S. So she went on trial for nine murders.
She was offered a plea deal, but she wanted to go to trial.
She was like, no, no, I am an assent because nobody saw me bearing the bodies.
The cause of death isn't even determined and all of this is just circumstantial evidence.
Do you know how many people were in and all of this is just circumstantial evidence
do you know how many people were in and out of that boarding house?
why do you think it's me that killed them? I'm not even the owner, I'm just renting the place
caching the checks
caching the checks and then she tried to argue you know if I did hype them
if I did hypothetically it's because you know they died of natural causes they were all sick
and I was scared because I'm running this illegal boarding house, you know, I just did what I had to do.
But all of them had the same sedative in their systems and she had over a thousand pills stockpiled.
So it just didn't look good for her. The jury deliberates for a few weeks and it was a super messy verdict.
A few weeks?
Yeah, it was a while. This is a long one. I think it was like three to four weeks.
What?
Yeah, because one jur.
Eleven were like, oh yeah, she's guilty for sure on everything.
Nine counts.
Give her some more.
A little sprinkle on the side.
Dorothy Appuente is guilty.
But there was one juror who said, nope.
I don't think so.
Just kept holding out.
So finally, the twelve jurors, they came to an agreement
that she would be found guilty of first degree murder
of Dorothy Miller and Benjamin Fink
and second degree murder of Leon Carpenter.
And the rest were deemed a mistrial
because the juror could not decide.
Thankfully, I mean, with even just that,
she was sentenced to life in prison without parole.
Now, in prison, she has tons of pen pals.
And in 2004, she wrote a book.
It's called Cooking with the Serial Killer.
Dorothy has favorite cooking recipes.
Oh, no.
Cooking with the Serial Killer.
And then in March of 2011,
she passed away of natural causes.
And then, that same year, the murder house was, you know, everyone calls it a murder house because
any time a murder happens in a house you have to call it a murder house.
It's like a thing I guess.
So it was purchased by Tom and Barbara a couple who were out shopping.
They were actually touring the house next door.
And they were like, hey, where about this one? This one's on sale, no?
Yeah, but...
Do you guys know what happened there?
Like you really want to live here and they're like, oh, we're from like out of town.
So they explain the whole thing with Dorothy and all of that.
And they're like, well, let's tour it.
So they tour that house and the couple is like, this home is beautiful.
Now here's the thing, the owner of this house is evil.
The house didn't do it and all of the remains are dug up. It's not like we're living with these remains. So let's buy the house
So they buy the house and they start doing some strange things which I mean inside note
It's kind of like I guess if people are looking because they said that the neighbors were looking non-stop
Like oh my god what couple bought this house like this is crazy. What kind of people would live here, right?
Mm-hmm. So they started doing these really strange things. They had a mannequin out front on the front porch that really resembled Dorothea
that they would dress up in a red coat without red purse the day that she became a fugitive.
And sometimes they would put a shovel in the mannequin's hand. They would have jokes on
the house. They had a sign on the staircase that said them them them
like thumping the bodies down the stairs they had signs around the house that
says do not park across the driveway the ghosts like to get out to terrorize you
another one said trespassers will be drugs and buried in the yard wait so
what's going on they have a dark sense of humor yeah it seems like it they
had two two signs that were coming from the house.
So, you know, they're saying like the house is saying it, right?
And the first one, it was that crazy bitch that did it.
Don't blame me. Signed the house.
And then another one at the very front that says,
it was that awful, awful woman that did it.
Don't blame me, signed the house.
But little weird, like it's weird,
because I can't hate them.
Okay, like the mannequins really, wow.
Like the mannequins a little out of pocket.
Maybe not the mannequin.
But like this little sign that's like, it wasn't me.
I thought you were gonna say that
they turn it into a...
It's like a tour.
Yeah, I think that's worse.
That's worse, yeah.
Like this seems like as long as the victim's family
are not offended.
Yeah, this seems more like, hey, please stop staring
at our house.
I think that's kind of what they were going for maybe.
But maybe it just didn't translate well
because if I'm looking at your house,
because it's Dorothy as old house,
and then you put a mannequin of Dorothy
on the front, like I'm going to be looking a little bit harder. We're like wow. I'm gonna loosen it. Is that Dorothea? What's going on? And then is the story
of Dorothea pointe? I think what's chilling is she's doing all of this in front of so many people.
Yeah and just getting away with it and she's on probation. She's like drug drugging people nonstop. And I think what's worse is that this is literally
the vulnerable population, the people that are getting
government assistance or pensions or disability checks,
and now you're just like, okay, I'm gonna kill you
because I want to go buy drinks at a bar
and pretend I'm a heart surgeon.
I don't even understand the motive
because if you tell me motive is greed,
it's hard to think because
I mean she really didn't get that much money out of it. I mean she was getting a lot monthly
Collectively for like you know stealing these checks, but murder
Yeah, not that much. Yeah to commit murder like it wasn't even these life insurance policies that she was cashin in like
Oh a hundred K here a hundred K there
Maybe she's she likes cash flow. Oh
She's one of those girl buses that are like oh, yeah, you need to have multiple streams of income
That's dark
Okay, that was out of pocket. I got to go. I hope you guys enjoyed today's podcast
out of pocket. I gotta go. I hope you guys enjoyed today's podcast, somewhat mini-sode, and I'll see you guys on Wednesday for a Japanese case that I'm really excited about.
That's really dark, that I'm excited to share with you. And I'll see you guys on
Wednesday. Bye!