Snapped: Women Who Murder - Crystal Weimer

Episode Date: September 15, 2024

A young man is brutally murdered and a woman is found covered in blood just hours later. She is adamant that she is innocent, and later a twist in the case shocks everyone involved.Season 22 Episode 07Originally aired: January 14, 2018Watch full episodes of Snapped for FREE on the Oxygen app: https://oxygentv.app.link/WatchSnappedPodSee Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

At a time when we're debating where policing is going, we're going to tell you where the police came from. From Wondery in Crooked Media, I'm Chinjirah Kumanika, and this is Empire City, the untold origin story of the NYPD. Follow Empire City on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. From Wondery comes a new series about a lawyer who broke all the rules. Need to launder some money?

Broker a deal with a drug cartel? Take out a witness? Paul can do it. I'm your host Brandon James Jenkins. Follow Criminal Attorney on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. Crystal Weimer was a young mother doing her best to make ends meet. I was a single mother raising three girls and I had a part-time job. Curtis Hayth was a young man trying to make it on his own.

We worked in the factory for a little while, kind of struggled a little bit. Their paths crossed one night at a party. Everything was going good. We were drinking a couple beers, socializing. And that night of drinking would change both of their lives forever. A neighbor heard gunshots. Curtis Hathes was found lying outside of his apartment. He was severely beaten and also shot in the face.

Within hours, the police were at Crystal's door. Someone had come to the police and said, well, I know I saw these people together. But did that mean she had something to do with Curtis' death? The investigators found Crystal covered in blood. You've got to look at her as a suspect. But why would Crystal kill someone she barely knew? They got a lot of conflicting stories.

There had to be a reason. The search for that reason would haunt investigators in this small Pennsylvania town for years. They were forced to try to figure out who was lying and who might actually be culpable in this crime. And many fingers were pointing at Crystal Weimer. Here's the thing about investigations. You look at a suspect to exclude them,

and when you can't exclude them, then you know you got them. MUSIC January 27, 2001, Connellsville, Pennsylvania. Fifty miles southeast of Pittsburgh, the mountains that surround this town of 8,000 once fueled the furnaces that forged America. It has a deep history of coal, so it has seen a lot of boom and bust over the years. But by 2001, the mines were mostly a memory as the fading town struggled to survive. There's some people that have been there all their lives and would never leave. Some people just want to get out.

It has its fair share of crime. And at 4.50 that Saturday morning, a neighbor of 21-year-old Curtis Hafe made a harrowing call to 911. A neighbor heard gunshots, heard Curtis playing for his life. And when Connellsville police arrived on the scene minutes later, they found Curtis lying on the sidewalk outside his apartment on the city's south side. He had been beaten very severely,

and there was a gunshot wound to his face. Despite the efforts of EMTs on the scene, Curtis didn't make it. The patient was dead at the scene. The patient was the victim of some type of external trauma and possibly gunshot. As paramedics packed up, investigators at the crime scene began looking for clues that might indicate what had happened in the moments before Curtis was beaten and shot.

In a case like the Hath murder, the crime scene obviously is very important. Although beyond the fact that Curtis had been both beaten and shot, the investigators had little else to go on. There were witnesses who lived next door who said that they had heard some noises, but they weren't able to identify anything that had happened. Which meant that the only option for the investigators was to try and retrace Curtis's final steps and interview the last few people to see him alive, a list that would include 23-year-old Crystal Weimer. Born in 1977, Crystal Weimer grew up in a working-class Connellsville family,

back before the mines and mills closed down. My father worked on a shipyard growing up, and my mom was always at home with us, and she always cooked and made sure we were off to school and things like that. She was there for us. She was a sweet little girl. Had a lot of friends she played with. She was a sweet little girl growing up.

Never gave me no problems. And one of four sisters, Crystal had no problems standing out in a crowd. I was very outgoing. Whenever I was in school, I was involved with softball. I played on the cheerleading squad and I also was on the swim-in team. Whatever sports or whatever I could get involved with,

I was ready. However, it wasn't just athletics and cheerleading that made Crystal's school years memorable. She got pregnant when she was 16. Crystal gave birth to a little girl, but never finished school. She stayed home taking care of her baby until she got old enough and then she got a job at Wendy's. And over the next couple of years, Crystal and her boyfriend had two more children. But the relationship eventually ended.

We wasn't very compatible. Therefore, I wasn't ready for marriage and stuff. So we just went our separate ways. Crystal was left a single mom. And to support her family, she traded part-time fast food work for a full-time job at a local factory. I worked at Sony, and I worked online, assembling the TVs. But after I was there for a while, they ended up moving the company, and the whole corporation got sold out.

By 2001, the 23-year-old was struggling to get by. I was a stay-home mom, taking care of my children, and raising them and working part-time. She was barely getting by, just like a lot of people in the dried-up coal country area of the United States. Although as hard as things were for Crystal, her sisters faced even tougher obstacles.

Her family, she has several sisters and a lot of them have had trouble with the law. Still, for all their troubles, Crystal remained close to her siblings. And on the evening of January 26, 2001, they got together at her sister's house in Uniontown, a small community 20 minutes from Connellsville, to hang out and catch up. We were at a party at my sister's, and we had a few friends over there that night. One of those friends was 21-year-old Curtis Hayth.

Although born in Michigan, in his teens, Curtis and his family had moved to Connellsville, his mother's hometown. I was in Detroit, Michigan, really struggling, you know, to raise my children. And Detroit seemed like such a rough city to raise them. And so that's what brought me back to Connellsville. The family didn't leave their struggles behind though. While Curtis's single mother worked multiple jobs to support the family,

young Curtis took over the family meals and soon showed a flare for it. He loved to cook. I remember him winning a big package. It was like steaks, a big steak package and things like that. And he was just happy about that. And we ate steaks like all day.

And when he graduated high school, his passion for food took him to culinary school in Pittsburgh. He went to Pittsburgh. He wanted to manage some sort of restaurant or something. So he went to college in Pittsburgh. It was a shock to me that he was going to go away because none of us ever really been away from home. But I was so happy it was only Pittsburgh. It was a shock to me that he was going to go away, because none of us ever really been away from home. But I was so happy it was only Pittsburgh.

But despite his ambition, he wouldn't stay there long. We couldn't afford it, so then he came back to Cottonistville. Back home, Curtis took a job to make ends meet, but his dreams of being a chef slipped further and further away. He worked in the factory for a little while. He kind of struggled a little bit. Still, he wasn't bitter about the disappointment. He was just as sweet as could be, you know, kind heart,

would do anything for you. And while he'd only been living in Pennsylvania a few years, he'd built a strong support network, too, which included a cousin of Crystal's. Curtis had went to a school and grew up with my cousin and that's whenever I first met Curtis. That was on the evening of January 26th when Curtis and Crystal's cousin dropped by the party at Crystal's sister's house in Uniontown. We were drinking a couple beers, socializing, talking about, you know, our life and different things,

and we were enjoying ourselves. Everything was good. However, despite the good time, Curtis was eager to get back to Connellsville, where he was supposed to meet up with some friends for a belated birthday toast. His birthday was January the 8th, and he was having a celebration

out and about in Connellsville. So around 10 o'clock that evening, Crystal's cousin drove Curtis Hayth the 12 miles back home to Connellsville, and Crystal tagged along. Curtis did eventually arrive at the bar and celebrate with his friends, and they would end up continuing the party back at Curtis' apartment.

But the mystery of what exactly happened in the final hours of that night would raise questions for years to come and be the central missing piece in a murder investigation. Coming up, is Curtis' murder a drug deal gone bad? Two little polyvinyl packets of marijuana. Or will a surprising discovery point police in a different direction? Officer Hagrid told me either you come with me for questioning or I'm going to the local magistrate to get a warrant. It was around 430 on the morning of January 27, 2001, when a neighbor of 21-year-old Curtis

Haith made a harrowing call to 911. A neighbor heard gunshots, heard Curtis playing for his life. And when Connellsville police reached the scene minutes later, they found Curtis lying on the sidewalk outside his apartment on the city's south side. He had been beaten very severely and there was a gunshot wound to his face. He had been beaten very severely and there was a gunshot wound to his face. And by the time the paramedics arrived, the extent of Curtis's injuries meant that all they could do was pronounce him dead. There was what looked like oozing out some brain tissue in that area.

Limited the chances of resuscitating and saving this gentleman. And while the paramedics packed up and left, the crime scene investigators went to work, searching for any clues that might shed some light on why Curtis had been killed. And almost immediately, the investigators found something that might be significant. In one pocket, he had two little polyvinyl packets

of a grassy substance, suggestive of marijuana. The investigators found more incriminating evidence when they went inside the apartment. There was drug paraphernalia in his home. Was Curtis's death the result of a drug deal gone bad? There had to be a reason for him being beaten and shot, possibly a drug transaction. Unfortunately for the investigators, there were no eyewitnesses who had seen what happened. Even the neighbor who called 911 admitted that paralyzed by terror, she hadn't looked out the window or even dialed 911 until after she heard a car door slam and tires squealing as it sped off.

However, while the neighbor couldn't identify the killer or the getaway car, she did have some additional information for the investigators. She told them that Curtis had people over prior to his death. The reports were that he was at a party and then later come home, and some of the people came to his home.

And according to the neighbor, the murder later come home and some of the people came to his home. And according to the neighbor, the murder occurred only a few minutes after the party broke up. From witness statements, the last partygoer is from his party, left his house 4-4-30. Could one of the party guests be the killer? The neighbor said that she hadn't noticed any trouble prior to the shooting. Everything seemed to be okay. He was having a good time. There wasn't any problems. Curtis's mother was just as adamant that her son wasn't a troublemaker

when she arrived on the scene later that morning. My aunt called me and said, Oh my God, they just found Curtis dead. And so I jumped in the car and went out to where he lived at. And while they didn't have any leads, the investigators did what they could to reassure Curtis's mother. When I went to Curtis's apartment, the first detective told me, promised me,

I'm going to find out who did this. Although at that point, all the investigator could do was track down and talk to everyone who'd been seen with Curtis the night before and hope for a lead. They really didn't know who might have been involved. And the list of people Curtis had come into contact with that night included 23-year-old Crystal Weimer. Friends had told investigators that Crystal and Curtis had been seen earlier that evening, partying.

When they knocked on Crystal's door that afternoon, all the investigators were hoping for was a little insight into Curtis's movements in the hours prior to his murder. Investigators were just simply working through a list of people who had been seen with Curtis that evening. This interaction with Crystal was just supposed to be another routine interview. But that all changed as soon as Crystal came to the door. It appears as though there is blood on her clothing. She had dirt on her. She had a black eye and she had a broken toe. And the blood and dirt immediately led the investigators

to an inescapable conclusion. Even if you've never investigated a murder in your life, you have to look at Krystal Weimaran. You've got to look at her as a suspect, right? And based on her appearance, investigators asked her to come down to the station. Officer Haggerty told me that I was coming with him, that there was a crime committed last night and a murder.

And that's whenever I said, well, I'm not going anywhere. Crystal's refusal to cooperate triggered a stern response from the investigators. He threatened me, either you come with me now for questioning or I'm going to the local magistrate to get a warrant. Facing possible arrest, Crystal accompanied the officers to the Connellsville police station. And once there, Crystal explained to the police that, yes, she had seen Curtis the night before his murder. He was with Crystal's cousin.

They were hanging out and were drinking and everything. And so that's how Crystal came around in the area for them to all be together that day. Crystal said that she and her cousin had last seen Curtis at around 10 o'clock when they dropped him off at a bar in Connellsville. But if that was the last time she saw Curtis, the investigators wanted to know how she'd ended up bloody and bruised. According to Crystal, the fight that she had been in occurred after she had dropped off Curtis and she returned to Uniontown. Her story is, I was brutalized by an ex-boyfriend, right?

She's got a broken toe. She walks with a limp. She's got a black eye. She's got blood all over her shirt. Was she telling the truth? There was one way to find out. Investigators asked for Crystal's clothing. They wanted to determine if indeed the blood on her clothing was Curtis's or not.

Would the forensics exonerate Crystal? It would take time to get the results. So that night after sending Crystal home, the investigators reviewed the results of Curtis's autopsy. It revealed that the gunshot wound to his face had passed painfully, but harmlessly through his cheek. The gunshot wound didn't turn out to be lethal, as we'd expect.

The critical cause of death here was a significant blunt force trauma. Curtis had been beaten to death. Or was it possible he'd been kicked to death? She had a broken toe. It was too coincidental. And when the analysis of Crystal's clothes came back from the crime lab, the mud on her garments added another unlikely coincidence. It's consistent or similar to the dirt that was

found outside of his apartment. But while the mud on Crystal's clothes put her at the crime scene, would the blood analysis make the case complete? As it turned out, the blood on her clothing was not Curtis'. It actually didn't implicate her. In fact, rather than Curtis, the blood matched her ex-boyfriend's DNA, just as Crystal had claimed.

The investigators were shocked to find out that the blood on Crystal's clothing did not match Curtis. It appeared to actually confirm that alibi and that she wasn't involved in the case at all. It looked as if the investigators' only lead had turned into a dead end, but new evidence would soon surface that would take the case in a stunning new direction. Coming up, investigators discover a detail that was missed during the autopsy. On Hayth's hand, there was a bite mark. And an eyewitness comes forward. He was in the car the night that Curtis Hayth died.

At a time when we're debating where policing is going, we're going to tell you where the police came from. They wanted me to write about the New York City Police Department, but without using the words violence or corruption, which is effectively impossible. A story of how the largest and most influential police department in the country became one of the most violent and corrupt organizations in the world. It doesn't matter if you're a self-emancipated black person or if you're a free... They're just sending people back to the South, kidnapping them. When officers with the power to fight the danger become the danger.

I was terrified. I'm not going to talk to the police because they're the ones who are perpetrating this. Who am I going to talk to? From Wondry and Crooked Media, I'm Chinjirah Kumanika, and this is Empire City, the untold origin story of the NYPD. Follow Empire City on the Wondry app or wherever you get your podcasts. You can binge all episodes of Empire City early and ad-free right now by joining Wondry

Plus. Hey, podcast listeners, have you heard you can listen to your favorite podcasts ad free? That's good news. With Amazon Music, you have access to the largest catalog of ad free top podcasts included with your Prime membership. To start listening, download the Amazon Music app for free or go to amazon.com slash ad free podcasts. That's amazon.com slash ad free podcasts to catch up on the latest episodes without the ads

By October of 2002 it had been nearly two years since 21 year old Curtis Hayth had been beaten to death outside his Connellsville Pennsylvania apartment the case went cold because there wasn't Any indication of how he ended up dead in his yard. Initially, the investigators suspected that 25-year-old Crystal Weimer had been involved. Someone had come to the to the Connellsville police and said, well, I know I saw these people together.

And when they found her the next morning still wearing bloody clothes, Crystal became their lead suspect. But then the test results came back from Crystal's clothes. They tested it, and lo and behold, it in fact was not what the government thought or hoped it would be. The source of it was an ex-boyfriend that she'd gotten into a skirmish with that evening. It seemed as if Crystal was off the hook and police were back at square one with no leads on Curtis's killer.

The police have a lot of public pressure with people saying that, you know, we don't feel safe until you find this person. Was it possible something had happened between the time that Crystal and her cousin dropped Curtis off at the bar around 10 p.m. and 4.30 that next morning when Curtis was killed, something that had led to murder.

Here's the thing about investigations. You don't look at a suspect to include them in a crime. You look at a suspect as a detective to exclude them. But Curtis's family wasn't convinced that Crystal Weimer should be excluded. It's always been Crystal Weimer from day one. If you didn't know anything, you would sympathize with the family members,

you know, and you would want to help some type of way. I'd never seen that from Crystal, never. But would Curtis's family be able to prove Crystal was involved? I thought some stuff would come out eventually because it's a small town. I thought maybe people would start talking about it. And in October of 2002,

more than a year and a half after the murder, someone finally did. The person who talked was 35-year-old Thomas Jefferson Beale. Beale was an ex-boyfriend of Crystal's, but he was not the ex-boyfriend who she had apparently gotten to a fight with on the evening of the murder. According to Beale, Crystal had confessed to killing Curtis one evening to him. Had the investigators been right about Crystal all along? Beale's story seemed to back it up, but they needed more than the word of a convicted criminal.

In fact, when Beale reached out to the investigators, he was sitting in the Fayette County jail on burglary charges. Jailhouse snitches are looking for something, and sometimes they're telling the truth, but you have to be very leery of that. What the investigators needed was something to confirm Thomas Beale's story. They really had no physical evidence tying her to it. Or did they?

After Thomas came forward claiming that Crystal had confessed, the investigators went back over the case file and found something they'd previously overlooked in the autopsy photos of Curtis's body. On Hayth's hand, there was a bite mark, and it was sent away for analysis with the dentist. It may have actually been missed during the first autopsy.

Could it be the evidence the investigators needed to confirm Thomas Beale's confession story and link Crystal to the murder? Could it be the evidence the investigators needed to confirm Thomas Beale's confession story and link Crystal to the murder? In early 2003, two years after Curtis Haight's murder, investigators were back on Crystal's doorstep. Investigators asked Crystal to provide dental impressions in the hopes of confirming who actually made the bite marks

on Curtis's body. Would comparing the dental impressions to the bite mark be another bust, like the blood stains on Crystal's clothing? In May of 2003, the crime lab came back with its results. It was a match. It was Crystal who bit my brother because the bite mark and the impression matched up. Her teeth were straight in his arm.

You know, it matched right up. They showed his teeth impressions. And her bite mark, it matched perfectly. And since the identity of the bite mark appeared to confirm the information provided by their jailhouse snitch, the investigators were finally convinced they'd found Curtis's killer. All the evidence the investigators had,

Tom Beale's story, the bite mark, they both pointed to Crystal. Not long after receiving the lab results in August of 2003, investigators got another break in the case when an inmate at the Fayette County Jail contacted the investigators and claimed to have information about Curtis's murder. The informant, who just happened to be locked up

in the Fayette County Jail, was an old friend of Crystal's, Joey Stanger. And a month earlier, in July of 2003, while Joey was in the Fayette County jail on burglary charges, he'd allegedly talked to his cellmate about Curtis Haith's murder and Crystal Weimer. He's in jail. He says, she did it.

I was there. I saw it. Here's what happened. He said he was in the car the night that Curtis Haith died. Joseph Stanger said that evening he was out at the bar and he said he was drinking and having a good time. But according to what Joey told his cellmate, as he left the bar later that night, he ran in to Crystal.

Crystal pulled up and said, hey, get in. I need to talk to you. And allegedly, when Crystal pulled up outside the bar to speak to Joey that night, she was already sporting a black eye. Crystal told him, hey, there's somebody that put their hands on me. And according to what Joey told his cellmate, that someone was Curtis.

He hit her, is what she said. There was some indication that she may have had a fight with him earlier in the day. And it was a fight that Crystal apparently aimed to finish. I want to go do something, take care of her, whatever. You know, would you ride with me? According to what he'd allegedly told his cellmate, Joey had gotten into the car with Crystal,

and together they'd driven to Uniontown. Joey Stinger's story was they picked up a couple guys who are still unidentified. After that, Joey, Crystal, and the two men had allegedly driven to Curtis's apartment. Crystal, as Joey tells it, walked up to the door, lured him out. And when Curtis came downstairs with Crystal, as Joey tells it, walked up to the door, lured him out. And when Curtis came downstairs with Crystal, her two friends were waiting in ambush. Then they beat him with a baseball bat and a crowbar.

They beat Curtis to death, all while Crystal watched. It was far more damning than Thomas Beals' claim that Crystal had confessed to killing Curtis. Joy was not only a witness, he was a participant. He was someone that could give the jury a direct account of just how Curtis died. But could the investigators and prosecutors get him to cooperate? When the investigators went to the jail and confronted Joey with his cellmate story, he

denied the whole thing. Did that mean the cellmate's story wasn't true? Not necessarily. Over the next few weeks, several of his friends, including his own mother, told investigators they had heard him say the exact same story. The fact that several people who knew Joey basically confirmed his cellmate's claims once again gave the investigators confidence in their jailhouse snitch. And on January 20, 2004, the investigators drove back out to Crystal's house,

placed her in handcuffs, and told her she was under arrest for the murder of Curtis Hayth. I was literally sick. I was sick to my stomach. I was more than in shock. And crying, I was so upset. I just kept crying. I lost it. Like, I was so nervous and upset, and it was a lot. Curtis's family was relieved that three years after the murder,

the police had finally made an arrest. It was frustrating to wait that long to have her brought in. And the family hoped that more arrests would follow. I thought maybe that she would give up the names of the other two people because she knew who they were. But would Crystal's arrest finally bring closure to the case? Coming up, Crystal is determined to stand trial. I didn't take a plea deal.

I believed I was coming back home because I didn't do anything. But will an expert witness's testimony make Crystal regret her decision? Everything just fell into place. By April of 2004, 26-year-old Crystal Weimer had spent three and a half months in jail, awaiting trial on murder charges. Crystal was charged with orchestrating the death of 21-year-old Curtis Hafe, who'd been beaten to death

outside his Connellsville, Pennsylvania apartment in January of 2001. When Crystal was arrested, I was excited. I was ready. I wanted to know what happened. I wanted some justice. But after years of waiting, would Curtis's family finally get the closure they so desperately sought? The case against Crystal was a complicated one, based on a single bite mark on Curtis's arm

and testimony from a series of informants and witness statements. The Connellsville police just had a lot of conflicting stuff, and they're trying to piece it all together. And the key to piecing it together was 22-year-old Joey Stenger. In February, he'd also been arrested on murder charges, after numerous people told the investigators that he'd been with Crystal on the night of the murder and helped her pick up the two men who'd actually killed Curtis.

He is the one that in the process of not only implicating Crystal, implicates himself. And he says that he was part of this alleged conspiracy. Earlier, when confronted with what he'd apparently told others about the crime, Joey had denied everything. But that changed once he was booked on murder charges. After his arrest, Joey finally broke down and told the investigators that his cellmate's story was true. He was involved in Curtis' murder. Joey's decision to cooperate was a major break for the prosecutors.

And they would need it, too, because they would soon be short a witness. That April, at a pre-trial hearing, the prosecutors put their first jailhouse informant on the stand, Crystal's ex-boyfriend Thomas Beale. Thomas Beale was the boyfriend that claimed Crystal had confessed to killing Curtis. They brought him forward, expecting him to implicate Crystal in this crime. But instead, Thomas made a confession of his own. As it turned out, he shows up on that day, tries to take the Fifth Amendment, the court won't let him, and he ultimately recants his entire testimony. In the process of recanting it,

looks down at the prosecution's table and says that the detective, the lead detective, is the one that told him what to say. And in fact, he goes so far as to say, I just wrote whatever he told me to put down. Confronted with Beal's bombshell allegations, the judge had no choice but to drop the charges against Crystal. That demonstrates the weakness of the prosecution's case. But was it only a temporary reprieve?

While Thomas had recanted his story, Joey Stanger remained in custody. And in September of 2004, when he pleaded guilty to conspiracy charges for his role in Curtis's murder, he not only admitted that he had been present when Curtis was killed, Joey confessed that he was more involved

than he'd originally let on. He has one hell of a story to tell. He says, I shot Curtis. He said he didn't mean to hit or shoot Hayes. He said he saw the beating going so bad, he tried to stop it, got out of his car, fired his weapon toward that area. And in all the confusion, Joey said that he'd accidentally shunned Curtis.

It looked like his confession was genuine to me. If he's not telling the truth, why is he willing to go to jail for it? Joey Stanger's confession was the break in the case that investigators had been waiting for. I don't think there was anything really that the state could have gotten any better than what they had. I mean, you had an individual who was there, Stanger, who described the beating in detail, the gunshot and the getaway.

On September 27, three days after Joey pled guilty, the investigators were back on Crystal's doorstep with a new arrest warrant charging her with Curtis' murder. I was very upset. I was above and beyond being upset because of them ripping me out of my life. I got away from my kids for the second time for something I hadn't done. But just how confident were the prosecutors in their case against Crystal?

With her trial date looming, they approached Crystal with what appeared to be an incredible offer, a mere two to four-year sentence if she pleaded guilty and named her alleged co-conspirators. She'd already spent almost two years in Fayette County Prison at that point in time. So in essence, she could have been offered to be able to walk out that day or soon thereafter. What does she do? She refuses the deal. No matter how much her court-appointed attorney tried to convince her to take it. The public defender just continued to come over to question me like every day until I

went through trial. Are you sure, Crystal, you don't want this to end before? I said, no, I'm going home and I'm not taking something I didn't do. She absolutely believed in renaissance. It was April 3, 2006, more than five years after Curtis's murder, when Crystal finally stood trial. In the prosecutor's opening statement, she argued that Crystal had been the mastermind who orchestrated Curtis's murder.

They said that her and Curtis might have fallen out, and she was upset. That's what Joey Stanger claimed when he took the stand for the prosecution. He indicated Weimer was involved and that she wanted revenge because Hayes had struck her at an earlier time. No one made him say anything that he didn't want to say. And then to build on Joey's testimony, prosecutors called Dr. Constantine Karazoulis, a forensic odontologist and bite mark expert, to the stand.

In his testimony, Karazoulula stated that the bite mark on Curtis's hand was definitely Crystal's. He also found that the bite mark must have occurred within seven minutes of his death. It was powerful testimony. With respect to expert testimony and expert witnesses, I think that if you're listening as a juror and you hear, you know, a prominent witness coming in from out of state, I think that's compelling.

And then, after five long years dogged by accusations that she was a killer, Crystal took the stand to tell her side of the story to the jury. I told the truth. We dropped Curtis Hayes off at the Arch Cafe, and that was the last time I'd seen him. I was never at Curtis Hayth's house. Crystal's impassioned testimony did little to sway Curtis's friends and family. There was a lot of people that was just shocked

that she could still be claiming that she was innocent. But would her words be enough to sway the jury? When the jurors retired to consider their verdict on April 6th, Crystal was confident. It took, um, uh, like, I believe four hours into one day and like two and a half hours maybe into the next day. And I thought maybe that's a good thing. The truth has come out, and I'm gonna go home.

But would her hopes be validated? I thought maybe that's a good thing. The truth has come out and I'm gonna go home. But would her hopes be validated? When the jury came back, they found Crystal guilty of murder. After waiting so long for justice, the verdict was an emotional moment for Curtis's family. I was in the court when they found Crystal guilty. I was happy.

You know, I wanted to thank people. I was pretty sure that she was going to be convicted. And everything just fell into place. Crystal, on the other hand, was surprised by the outcome. When the jury come back and they're just like, guilty, guilty, guilty, guilty, I was just like, what? I just felt empty because I knew that she wasn't involved and they convicted her.

I was just devastated. Because in the end, there was no way she could overcome the evidence that the prosecutors had presented to the jury. You had an eyewitness, actually not just an eyewitness, you had one of the perpetrators, and he was testifying about what role Crystal Weimer had in it. And then the bite mark evidence. Very bluntly, that was very, very strong evidence to convict her. — After the verdict, the judge sentenced Crystal to 15 to 30 years in prison. — I was in shock. I couldn't believe it.

I was more than heartbroken. I was like, where is the truth at it. I was more than heartbroken. I was like, where is the truth out in this place? Like, nobody's hearing me. What is going on? The sentence may have been a shock to Crystal, but Curtis's family found it far too light. At the end of his life, he suffered, you know, and I just think people should pay for that.

I couldn't understand it because how do you only get 15 to 30 years for something that you plan to do? Crystal maintained her innocence, however. I was confident I swore in my heart and I believed I was coming back home because I didn't do anything. And once in prison, she was determined to prove it too. I got access to law library.

I know the only way you can come home is to fight your case in case law and educate yourself on it. She begins to become her own lawyer, studying her case, obsessed with proving her innocence. And the result of all that study was an 80-page handwritten letter that she sent to government officials

across the state of Pennsylvania, arguing that the Connellsville Police Department had ignored dozens of witnesses and scientific evidence that supported her innocence. It was clear that she was very desperate to get her point across. She was calling it a fundamental miscarriage of justice. But her desperate calls for help went unanswered. She wasn't able to get representation for the appeals that she was making, and so she was having to do it on her own.

As a result, Crystal spent nearly a decade in prison. Her three daughters grew up and started families of their own. Then, in 2014, her 80-page letter eventually found its way to the Pennsylvania Innocence Project, whose staffers were surprised by what they read. It spoke to me that here's a woman who is confident in her innocence and needs a voice. And then substantively, you started looking at the facts of the case and seeing that they just simply had the wrong target of their investigation since the beginning. And when you add all of that up, you see an innocent woman that's lost a decade of her

life. Determined to get justice for Crystal, the Innocence Project took her case. That's whenever I knew the windows were opening and I knew there was hope. So I knew that God was here in my prayers. And in October of 2015, almost 10 years after her conviction, with her new attorney at her side, 38-year-old Crystal Weimer was back in court, hoping to convince a federal judge to grant her a new trial. We went into that courtroom and I knew I was coming home and the truth was going to set

me free. Coming up, a witness makes a stunning reversal. He told me, Jeff, I would have told them whatever they wanted me to say. And Crystal's case takes a surprising turn. Where does justice lie? Are we ever going to find justice in this murder? On October 1, 2015, ten years after her conviction for the murder of Curtis Haith, 38-year-old Crystal Weimer was back in court, preparing to make her case for a new trial.

Since day one, the proper investigation was never done. And the attorneys from the Pennsylvania Innocence Project agreed with her. You ask yourself, how is it this possibly could lead to a conviction? At Crystal's 2006 trial, a forensic odontologist had testified that a bite mark found on Curtis' hate's body matched dental impressions made from Crystal's teeth. The state's expert on the bite mark, who was so sure about it 10 years ago, now says, you know what? I misinterpreted the data.

I was wrong. I've never seen an expert witness ever recant their testimony at a later time. Curtis's family was stunned by the reversal. I do not understand how a scientist can support one thing and say, hey, this is what I support, and then change his mind. The testimony was enough to convince a judge that Crystal's case should be retried. But would Crystal ever stand trial again? Because in 2016, when the prosecutors started preparing for the retrial, they ran into trouble when they reached out to Joey Stenger,

the friend who'd claimed he'd ridden along with Crystal on the night Curtis died. Stenger's attorney said his client was going to plead the fifth. And the reason was obvious, according to Crystal's attorney. He made the whole thing up. He told me, Jeff, I would have told him whatever they wanted me to say. I was looking for a deal, and it didn't matter. I know it's wrong, but the reality is I was willing to say whatever they wanted me to say to help myself.

And with that, the entire case against Crystal collapsed. The district attorney said, we're just going to dismiss the charges. We don't have the sufficient evidence to proceed. After 11 years behind bars, Crystal could finally go home. I was just so overwhelmed and happy that God had finally set me free. I was just so more than overwhelmed and so thankful.

But the victory was bittersweet. Not only had Crystal lost a decade of her life, Curtis's murder remains unsolved. If Crystal Weimer didn't kill Curtis, his killer is still walking this planet free from this crime. Which means that for now, all Curtis's family can do is cherish his memory. I think he would have done really good things with his life. That's what hurts the most. And continue to hold out hope that justice will eventually come. I know this isn't over. I believe in my heart that one day that the truth will be out. It is finally over for Crystal though. Almost 40 and finally out of prison,

she's making a fresh start. I'm grateful and happy that the truth set me free and that I'm home. You know, I have each moment to be grateful and thankful for. Crystal Weimer has been fully exonerated for the murder of Curtis Hayth. Crystal lives in Connellsville with her three daughters and three grandchildren. Curtis Hayth's murder remains a cold case. Are you in trouble with the law? Need a lawyer who'll fight like hell to keep you out of jail?

We defend and we fight just like you'd want your own children defended. Whether you're facing a drug charge, caught up on a murder rap, accused of committing war crimes, look no further than Paul Bergrin. All the big guys go to Bergrin because he gets everybody off. You name it, Paul can do it. Need to launder some money? Broker a deal with a drug cartel? Take out a witness?

From one dream, The Makers of Dr. Death and Over My Dead Body comes a new series about a lawyer who broke all the rules. Isn't it funny how witnesses disappear or how evidence doesn't show up or somebody doesn't testify correctly. In order to win at all costs. If Paul asked you to do something, it wasn't a request. It was an order. I'm your host Brandon James Jenkins. Follow Criminal Attorney on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts.

You can listen to Criminal Attorney early and ad-free right now by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts.