Something Was Wrong - S20 E9: The Real Brody
Episode Date: June 6, 2024*Content Warning: sexual abuse of a minor, cyberstalking, stalking, catfishing, fraud, psychological violence, death, medical trauma, suicide, suicidal ideation, emotional abuse, harassment, ...childhood trauma, sexual abuse, physical violence, bullying, interpersonal violence.This season, our theme Song U Think U, by Glad Rags, is covered by Palehound. For music and tour dates, go to palehound.com.Follow El of Palehound and @bachelor_band: https://www.instagram.com/palehound/ Palehound on SoundCloud: https://soundcloud.com/palehound-1 Free + Confidential Resources + Safety Tips: somethingwaswrong.com/resources FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3): https://www.ic3.gov/ Stalking Prevention, Awareness, Statistics & Resource Center (SPARC): https://www.stalkingawareness.org/ Follow Something Was Wrong:Website: somethingwaswrong.com IG: instagram.com/somethingwaswrongpodcastTikTok: tiktok.com/@somethingwaswrongpodcast Follow Tiffany Reese:Website: tiffanyreese.me IG: instagram.com/lookieboo See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Wondery Plus subscribers can listen to Something Was Wrong early and ad free right now.
Join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts.
We've all been there, turning to the internet to self-diagnose our inexplicable pains, debilitating
body aches, sudden fevers, and strange rashes.
Though our minds tend to spiral to worst-case scenarios, it's usually nothing, but for
an unlucky few, these unsuspecting symptoms can start the clock ticking on a terrifying
medical mystery.
Like the unexplainable death of a retired firefighter, whose body was found at home
by his son, except it looked like he had been cremated.
Or the time when an entire town started jumping from buildings and seeing tigers on their
ceilings.
Hey, listeners, it's Mr. Ballin here, and I'm here to tell you about my podcast. It's called
Mr. Ballin's Medical Mysteries. Each terrifying true story will be sure to keep you up at night.
Follow Mr. Ballin's Medical Mysteries wherever you get your podcasts.
Prime members can listen early and ad free on Amazon Music.
She was a romance mystery writer. They glommed on the fact that she writes stories like this. members can listen early and ad free on Amazon Music. Something Was Wrong is intended for mature audiences and may be distressing for some
listeners. For a full trigger warning for each episode and for a list of resources for
survivors and their loved ones, please see the episode notes. Pseudonyms are given to all minors
and some survivors in these stories for their privacy and protection.
Testimony shared by guests of the show is their own, and does not necessarily reflect the views
of myself, broken-cycle media, or Wondery. This podcast and any linked materials should not be
construed as medical advice, nor is the information a substitute for professional medical expertise or treatment.
In response to the allegations against Jessica Pauley, she responded with no comment.
Thank you so much for listening. At all You think you know me
You don't know me
Well, at all
At all
At all
At all You don't know anybody You don't know anybody
You don't know anybody till you talk to someone
to someone.
Here's Bree. So we had our little group chat of the initial victims, Monica, myself.
Danny's not a victim, but she was very closely related into this.
Lauren and then Reagan was initially in it. We had all talked, compared
stories and I want to say it was maybe a few days, maybe a week. It wasn't long into figuring
everything out before the real Brody was invited into the group chat. Basically, this had been
going on the entire time I lived with her in Iowa and this was so much more than just
Lauren and I. Even today we find out new things and honestly nothing surprises me
at this point because we keep hearing things and piecing things together and
it just gets crazier and crazier and he told us the history he had with Jessica
Pauley. I'm honored to be here. My name is the real Brody so I'm excited to be here. My name is The Real Brody. So I'm excited to be a part of this
and also get justice for all the victims of Jessica Pauley.
So when I was 15, I was a beach patrol lifeguard. I would get up six, seven o'clock in the morning,
go surf a little bit. This is up north, but I would head out and just enjoy my day
and then towards the middle of my shift
is usually when I have a break.
And we would do lifeguard workouts
as well as go introduce yourself
to like a couple of the families,
people you haven't seen before.
So I headed out, said hi to all my regulars,
and I saw another family and I went up
and introduced myself, I was like,
hello, nice to meet you.
I'm the lifeguard on duty today.
Like there's a couple of things to look out for.
We got some rip currents that are pretty strong
with the storm that had just passed through the day before.
Just introduced myself, my name, et cetera.
And then I saw Jess and I was like,
hey, like you look like you're close to my age.
Just being a friendly kid.
I was like, well, if you're not doing anything later, me and some of my friends, we do stuff after work. And if you
don't have anything going on, I know it's tough being like around your family on vacation,
just hit me up. So that's what ended up happening. She Facebook messaged me on July 25th of 2009.
The day after my 15th birthday, she reached out to me and was like, what are you
doing?
What's your number, et cetera.
I never responded after that first initial encounter because she sent me her phone number
and was like, text me.
And I said, all right, I will.
And then I never did.
And that's when she was like, you're a piece of shit.
And then I didn't get another message until March of 2016.
She sent me a smiley face.
So I feel like that could have been the direct correlation of all of this is that you're gonna
get obsessive that quickly when we shared maybe 45 words together. It's mind-blowing.
I know we're gonna get into everything but like finding all this information out and the length of things
that she went to to destroy these innocent girls lives.
Well and yours too, but we'll get to that. So semi related slash we're not positive it's
related but let's be honest it's probably related. Someone actually tried to catfish
you. Can you walk us through that and what you recall about that experience?
I believe it was my junior,
or it might've been senior year.
A friend of mine got like a random friend request
on Facebook, and then he showed me
her name was like Hunter Dillon.
I mean, let's be real, that sounds like a foreign star's name.
But he got the friend request,
and then literally 10 minutes later,
I got the friend request and then accepted it. We went about our night, right? And then
randomly the next couple days we both got DMs on Facebook. Originally I was like, I'm
not talking to them. If they message you first, you go ahead, talk to them. It was all via
like the same thing. It's all via phone, right? No FaceTime, nothing. I mean, I don't even know if FaceTime was around back then.
But there was like Skype. They would always refuse to Skype. We just want to see your face. We just want to see your face.
But then they would send pictures that were pretty much like how they looked on Facebook but clearly weren't taken at that moment.
It was different for the girls because the girls were talking to another girl that was
pretending to be me or a guy.
This was a girl pretending to be a girl so you could talk on the phone with her.
So that's what we did.
We did talk on the phone with her.
So I was like, well, maybe she is real.
This went on for a couple months at least and then it got bad, fast.
I have all the messages, screenshots. She was also pretending to be this
other girl. I think her name was Kayla. And she had reached out to me and was like, Hunter sent
me this before she took off. She was going on vacation or something before she took off. And
she was saying how much she loves you and this and this and this, but I don't think that you're good
for her. It was so manipulative.
It was ridiculous.
They were trying to make it seem like it was my fault or whatever it was going on at the
time.
When I read those messages again, and then I look at the message that was sent to Lauren
and sent to Brie, I'm like, this is the same person.
But I didn't realize that until, you know, 15 years later, that it was just from
the beginning. She had all the access to my Facebook pictures. I don't know how she got
my Instagram.
So, the fake names that she used, I did try to background search and find these women
and I couldn't find any women from the information that was given. Hunter Dylan and then Kayla
Wilmont was the other name. Did
you just get sick of her not going on Skype and you were like, fuck this or what ended
up ending it?
Well, yeah, we realized it was bullshit. It was only a couple of months. And then I was
like, dude, this is not a real human being. And I swear to you, I remember that we found
the real Hunter Dylan. And we like reached out to her and told her
that someone was using her like exactly what the girls did to me.
Do you remember what her name was at all?
No, I have no idea.
It was just some random good looking girl in Georgia.
I don't know if they've met before or something.
I have no clue.
And I would love to one day if I could look Jess in the face and be like, were you Hunter?
Because it seems like it is,
because they use the same exact dialogue
and the way they talk to people,
it sounds the exact same.
And the name too is such a Jess name.
She picks these very specific types of names.
And Lauren pointed it out to me
that their birthdays are all like a couple days apart.
It was all like April something.
Which is around her real birthday.
Exactly.
It's like all the flags are pointing in the same direction
but I don't know 100% but I would love to,
if I ever confront her in real life after 15 years,
I would hopefully honor court date.
I was 21, so this is six years after I had met Jess, a place that I'm not born but raised
at.
I was at the beach, we were at a pregame and a good friend that I went to college with,
she comes up to me, she's like, look.
I was like, what?
It's a picture of me in high school on a Tinder profile.
And I was like, what?
I was like, what?
I was like, add them,
see if they'll meet up with us at the bar.
Because back then, I thought this was all a joke.
I actually like laughed at it.
I was like, that's so funny.
I'm honored, someone's using my pictures.
But like now looking back, obviously,
that's terrible because I was 16 or 17 years old
in that picture.
But they had me at 24 years old on Tinder.
When things started to click, I reached out to my friend
and I was like, hey, I know this was a long time ago,
but do you happen to remember the name of the profile
that was using my pictures in Ocean City?
And she said Brody.
And that was like, boom.
That just hit me in the face.
Now I know that she has actually been doing this
for that long.
But she wasn't there.
With Tinder, you can use geolocation
and move your location to other places.
With everything she's done, it's even sickening to say
that she's kind of smart in a diabolical way,
but like, she knew she would get caught.
She knew that I would find out that she was doing that.
So I was like, why would you do that?
What's the end game there?
Honestly, maybe she was just looking for new victims.
Maybe she had a planned vacation with her family to go there and then start that
whole cycle again, like what she started with Reagan, with Monica, with Lauren, Bree, everything
to like gain a friend, get them close to her and then do what she's been doing this whole
time.
It was on Christmas, December 25th, 2017.
She reached out to me saying, hey, do you remember me?
I didn't answer because I think at that time I didn't follow her.
So it was under my message requests.
Oh, here it is.
December 25th, 2017, do you remember me?
And I didn't answer until January 2nd, 2018.
I think I do.
She goes, you think question mark the MySpace days.
That's even more crazy is that I only have messages from her on Facebook because
obviously I don't even think MySpace is a URL anymore. So I couldn't find those if I wanted to.
Jess asked how I was doing, where I was living now, what I was doing for work, how to playing
pro soccer workout for me. Like she knew that I went to Germany
and I have no idea how.
And then randomly, after I'm talking about me being injured
and having surgery, she just goes, do you have Snapchat?
So I added her Snapchat because I didn't know anything.
I didn't know she was using my pictures.
I didn't know the kind of person she was.
I thought she was just reaching out after a long time and that was it. And then she sent me a message at 4pm and I never responded
to her again. And that was the last time I spoke to her other than when I found out about
Reagan. I found out about Reagan mid COVID. It was like the summer of 2020, closer to
fall. I was at work. I was in the middle of a call talking to this
person, like a client, and then I look at my phone and it was like message request from XYZ,
her Instagram handle. So I opened it and it was a big, pretty much a book of her telling me that
some girl in Iowa has been using my pictures and catfishing, she got catfished
for like the last like year and a half, two years.
I don't remember exactly how long it was.
I was like, can I call you?
She gave me her number and I called her.
She explained everything to me,
like how everything happened
and I think she met him on Hinge
and there was a fake Instagram, fake TikTok,
everything utilizing my pictures.
And we'll definitely get into how crazy it is about some of the pictures that she has.
I confronted Jess after Reagan.
I don't know the steps she took.
Granted, this was four years ago now, so I'm not 100% sure exactly what she did.
I reached out to Jess.
I found her number in my phone and it was the same number. And I called, I was like,
hey, you know, I wasn't too aggressive. But I was like,
pretty much was like, what the fuck are you doing? Why are you
using my pictures to catfish all these girls? Like, how'd you
find out? I explained, well, this poor girl reached out to me
on Instagram, and tells me that you've been like catfishing her.
She was kind of shocked because then she found out that Reagan knew.
I think it just spiraled out of control there and she packed up all her stuff.
Oh Jess didn't know that Reagan knew when you called?
Yeah, I don't think she knew.
Or maybe she was playing stupid, but it didn't seem like she knew.
And then what happened?
She packed up and moved because she was caught.
That was Iowa. I'm curious to know if Monica and Reagan were at the same time.
Yeah, there's definitely some overlap there. What did Jess have to say for herself when
you asked her about it?
I said, listen, I'm going to be very calm about this. And I was like, if you do this
again, I'm going to ruin your life. You're literally using my image to destroy people and
It's making me look bad. Even though it's not really me
I was so shook about the whole thing and then she was like, I know I'm sorry. I won't do it again
I promise and I was like, okay, I'm not kidding
I will go to the full extent of my ability to ruin your life if you do this again."
I wanted to reiterate it so she knew.
I think I got my message across, but clearly not, because it seems like the next week she
was doing it again, a whole new group of women.
Nancy's love story could have been ripped right out of the pages of one of her own novels.
She was a romance mystery writer who happens to be married to a chef.
But this story didn't end with a happily ever after.
When I stepped into the kitchen, I could see that Chef Brophy was on the ground and I heard
somebody say, call 911.
As writers, we'd written our share of murder mysteries.
So when suspicion turned to Dan's wife, Nancy,
we weren't that surprised.
The first person they look at would be the spouse.
We understand that's usually the way they do it.
But we began to wonder, had Nancy gotten so
wrapped up in her own novels.
There are murders in all of the books.
That she was playing them out in real life?
Follow Happily Never After, Dan and Nancy on the Wondery app or wherever you get your
podcasts.
You can binge all episodes of Happily Never After, Dan and Nancy early and ad free right
now by joining Wondery Plus.
So fast forward 2023, you hear from Lauren, right?
Correct.
It's the same thing at work, reaches out to me and I'm like, not again.
I was like, there's no way I can look back at this because I still have my messages with
Lauren.
It was just a random day.
It was August 23rd.
It's like four o'clock.
Hey, this is really weird, but I just found out that I had been catfished by someone using
your pictures for the last three years.
Any chance we can talk?
And I said, this is the second time this happened, I'm so sorry. And
then she goes, you know, how long ago was it? I know who did it and would love for you
to press charges. I said, who did it? She goes, my roommate. And my heart just sank
for her. And then I was like, what's their name? Because I was like, there's no way there's
two different people doing this. And then she said, Jessica Polly. And I was I was like yep she's the one who did it the
first time and she was like shut the fuck up tell me everything I was like yeah to this girl named
Reagan and then Lauren was like I literally live with her and I was like are you in Iowa or what
and she goes no I'm in North Carolina and that's how I realized that she had moved. So we talked about everything and
she said the guy's name is Brody. I was just like, are you kidding me? There's no way this girl
really wants me to ruin her life. And this is when I was in that relationship and how it affected all
that again. I was like, there's no way this is doing this again, because I already dealt with
the trust issues once and then it's been years and then she reaches out to me again.
So now I have to re prove that it's not me. Someone else is doing this.
Wait, so that happened twice with your ex?
Yeah. Yeah.
Wait, walk me through that piece if you don't mind.
No, of course. We already had mistrust between us in the beginning of the relationship.
When did you start dating your ex?
It was the end of 2019. When the Reagan stuff happened, there was a huge fight. Everything
weren't really together for about a month or two. It was just over mistrust. She thinks
I'm using a fake profile and other places to talk to girls and it was just ridiculous.
Because I was like, there's proof right here
that it's not me.
I don't have a single dating app on my phone.
So I mean, we already had the issues,
but then we got over it, three years down the line
happens again, end of the relationship.
I'm so sorry.
It's crazy how many people her behavior has impacted in such a real way,
you know?
Very much so.
So you hear from Lauren and do you confront Jess again?
Yes. I got her number from Lauren. I believe she had changed it. But who knows how many
number one how many phones this girl has. But I called her and I was in the garage at my complex where I live.
And it was not a very pleasant phone call. I'll tell you that she had someone else with her.
And I was like, I told you that if you do this again, like I'm going to ruin your life.
And I meant it, I want to make sure your kid gets taken away from you.
The things that you are doing to people
You should not be responsible for a child. And so the other girl was like, oh, she's a really good mom. I was like
How what what how can you say that? How can you say she's a good mom?
Do you even know this situation and Jess was like don't say anything else. Don't say anything else
And I was like no, I'm gonna say whatever I want
I'm gonna tell her because obviously this girl doesn't know what a lunatic you are. You have done this for years
This is the second time obviously at this point. I don't know about Brie. I don't know about Monica
I don't know about other people but just the two girls alone is enough for me not to be okay with this situation
And I was like I told you Jess, I'm going to ruin
your life. I'm going to get your kid taken away from you. I'm going to go to every lawyer, I don't
care how much they cost, I am going to destroy you. And luckily, I was able to be a part of this and
meet with the FBI and et cetera. I'm not finished. I'm not gonna rest until this girl is either in prison or is banned from every IP address on the planet
So she can't use her phone to manipulate and catfish and ruin people's lives. Hell fucking yeah
We are did just cry. Did she laugh? Did she say sorry? Like what is her mood?
So for a second she did laugh about it and I was like, are you fucking serious?
You're gonna sit here and laugh about this. This is not a joke Jess. You're ruining people's lives
I was like you had this poor girl move from a different state back home to be your roommate
You're using sex toys on her from the room next door. You're fucking sick
Then she was like, I'm sorry and I was, that's not good enough. It's not.
What you're doing is absolutely atrocious. I don't understand how you can live with yourself.
This is ridiculous. And I was like, I'm telling you, your kid deserves better. All these other
people that you are hurting deserve better. And that was it. And I hung up the phone.
I was like, I'm done. Absolute insanity.
So after the Lauren incident, when do you find out about Brie?
It was through Lauren. She had just mentioned to me there's actually other girls involved
in this. I had spoken on the phone with Lauren. I think we were on like a three way phone
call, I believe. And that's when I've met or I spoke to Brie and then everyone else
came out of the woodwork. I went to Bree and then everyone else came out of
the woodwork. I went to the lawyers that I know here and they're like, well, we don't
have jurisdiction in North Carolina. We can't do anything. And then Lauren told me she got
a restraining order and Bree got a restraining order. But there was literally nothing I could
do because like I wanted to get the full extent of the law to take care of this at that time,
but then I had no options.
I didn't know what to do. So I just kept my mouth shut. I was like, well, maybe they'll
figure this out on their own.
You did talk to the police though, right? Because you're in the police report.
Yeah. It was a detective. She's told me the case was getting transferred to someone else,
but that was pretty much it. It was a very simplistic phone call asking X, Y and
Z, how are you related to this? Anything information you can give us. And then after that she was
like, well, we'll see what we can do. They already got restraining orders. If you want
to go to your local police department and get a restraining order, be our guest. But
I don't know if that's going to do anything because at this time we didn't know miss Jess Pauley was moving to Florida
So it was like I don't know what else I'm supposed to do
after
Reagan happened I
Blocked her on everything. I got rid of her on Snapchat. I got rid of her on Instagram
Facebook everything so I didn't understand how she was still getting some of my pictures.
Some of the pictures she has are less than a year old, like to this date. Like
when I was getting my leg sleeve done, she had a picture of that. She had a
picture of my cat. I've had them for two years. So it was like how does she still
getting these? And she has pictures that my ex-girlfriend had that she took on her phone,
posted it, maybe posted it. I'm not sure. We didn't really do the whole social media thing
together. So like, I don't know. And then she has pictures that are on my camera roll that was never
uploaded anywhere. So I was like, how is this possible? I didn't understand that. Like I was
dumbfounded by that. I was like, how does she have pictures of me?
She has a video of me and my best friend in college that I've never seen before.
It made no sense to me how she was able to do this.
I'm like, is this girl like a tech wizard with a child and a full-time job while trying
to be three different people at the same time?
How do you do that?
I feel like I'm living split the movie.
So many different personalities. Like
how are you able to handle all this at once? Have you seen the movie The Roommate? I don't
think I have. She made all the women watch it with her and it's about this girl who has
a creepy obsession with her friend. And it's just so fucking crazy when I watched it because
of the context. Oh, I mean, yeah, it's like foreshadowing. She's literally doing that. I feel like she has the
urge and it gets her off to being this close to being caught and then not being caught.
And I think she has some weird voyeurism obsession because even in high school, somebody I spoke to
said that they like went through her phone during gym class because everybody knew she had
catfish, Shana and such. They went through her razor flip phone and they found her texting two
people, a woman named Victoria as a dude, and then texting the dude as Victoria and essentially
making herself the middleman in their relationship, catfishing them both. She loved inserting herself into all
of these relationships that she had with the women, not only as Brody, but as herself.
I feel like she has some weird voyeurism fetish as well, the risk. And then I also think she has a
tickle fetish, which is just a random side note, but that's atrocious. How would you articulate the impact that her behavior has had on you?
That's tough, man.
It's upsetting because I've tried to strive my whole life
to be a good person.
Just how I was raised, I have amazing parents.
Christian, since I was a kid, went to church, everything.
Everyone obviously strays off the path a little bit.
You know, I'm not saying I'm a perfect human being by any means, but when you're utilizing
my image to absolutely destroy people and diminish their character and break them down
so low to a point where some maybe even suicidal, then they have to look me in the face and
all they see is pretty much red,
you know?
It's sad.
You're making me look like a bad human being when these people don't even know me.
I won't lie to you, it caused me to drink a little bit more than I used to.
And when I see these girls struggling and all the stuff that they went through, it affects
me too.
Obviously, with my past relationship and how that helped it spiral out of control than it already was,
she helped ruin that as well. She's done a lot of things to make me question myself. It's been tough.
I'm curious, do your parents know about this?
Yeah, I told my dad and my mom about it. They think what pretty much everyone else does,
like it's a horrible situation. It's not your fault because like you honestly didn't do anything. My
mom was involved in it. You're putting my mother's picture out there, putting now
her in a sense of jeopardy because she cares about her identity being very
secure. She wasn't very happy about it and then on top of that this bitch told
her like everyone that my mom died, that she had brain cancer. You're putting that very secure. She wasn't very happy about it. And then on top of that, this bitch told her
like everyone that my mom died, that she had brain cancer. You're putting that out in the
universe. She said my dog died. I was like, this is unbelievable.
Well, and she used your friend's photos too, right?
Yeah, God forbid, like what I just spoke about, she goes crazy more than she already is. One
of the person in the photo lives here where
I live. I just didn't understand it. Obviously, there's a lot of pictures with my friends. So
that's probably why she utilized them so much. But it was just the storytelling and in general,
putting that out in the universe, wishing ill or bad intention on my friends and family,
that really had me distraught. Because God forbid
something happens to them. What do you hope for the future in terms of justice? What would justice
look like for you? Her in prison for a long time, as well as her kid never looking at her as a mother.
And I hope he grows up and when he's old enough to realize and understand
The monster that the mother that he has
Because the way she went about all of this and the damage that she did all these people she deserves nothing
But just the rot so that's honestly what I hope for and I hope Monica Brie Reagan
Lauren everyone else that maybe I don't know
about that they can move on with their lives and leave this behind and they can
be happy because they're all amazing human beings. I'm blessed that I was able
to talk to all of them and be like a helping hand or you know a shoulder to
cry on so to speak virtually because I feel for them. It's terrible. And I know what I went through in high school was very small compared to what they
dealt with. But I knew like when you get that feeling for someone, even though they're not real,
it has effect on you. I hope we all get justice. And I hope she can't run from the reality of she's going to prison for a long time anymore.
Here's Dani.
We just kept finding more and more victims and I'm at work and it's so overwhelming.
I felt like I had to tell someone I didn't know what to do because I'm at work and she works with me and this psychopath is in healthcare.
I use the term psychopath loosely, but still.
I go into my educator's office and start like bawling and having like a panic attack and
she's like, oh my goodness, what's wrong?
And I feel so bad for spilling all this on her, but I didn't know what to do.
I was like, Jess is crazy.
She's like your best friend. I was like, she's my friend and she's like what what happened? I told her
everything and she just kind of backed up and she was like I'm gonna go get our boss and I was like
okay. So I went into his office and told him everything and he then told me that Jess called in. So what happened was is when we were all
tying things together the day prior, it was around 6, 6 37 o'clock and we get out of work at 7.
So Jess was at work that day, I wasn't, but now that it's been passed and we've talked to other people, they've told us that
she was up in the unit she was in and around six, seven o'clock she just started bawling her eyes
out freaking out. So I'm assuming Bri might've texted her because she sent me the text. I think
she said like, you're a monster or something. It was crazy. And then blocked her. But just knew that we knew everything. I texted her
saying, take care of your child and blocked her. So she knew. And
then she started freaking out at work. Everyone said she went
home bawling her eyes out and then called in to work that
night like on her way home crying and told the charge that she
wouldn't be able to come into work.
I think she even said that I was spreading rumors about her or something along the lines.
And then she needed to be with her family right now. And she also said that Lauren,
her roommate, was being cruel and shutting off the power for her kid at home. I don't think
Lauren ever did that. I think she was just trying to victimize herself.
My boss said I gave her a week off so she could just go get her stuff together and be with her family or whatever. I think she went back to Iowa. She might have, I don't know the full spectrum of
what she did in that week. And he said that he was being nice to her and said that he fully
supported her before he knew what I was telling him.
And then I told him everything and he was like so shocked.
He's not like a young boss, he's not old.
But he was like, back up.
What is catfishing?
So I explained everything and he looked at me.
He's like, I don't think I can even email this to HR.
I think it has to be a phone call.
So I think he called them.
And after all of that happened
He told me he was like what I hope will happen is she just doesn't come back
They said I can't just fire someone due to this because there's no incriminating evidence
Etc. There's nothing charging her and we were like great. We were scared
She was gonna come back to work, but everybody was like, no, she's not gonna come back.
She didn't ever end up coming back.
I think after a week, she called back to my boss
and said, I'm not gonna come back to work,
which we were very thankful for.
And this entire time, I couldn't tell anybody I worked with.
I like was just holding this horrible, horrible secret,
even from some of my friends.
It was awful.
It was probably like a week or two.
And finally, when we got confirmed
that she wasn't coming back,
I was able to tell people what had happened.
And they were just like, what the fuck?
Cause I brought her to work with us.
I literally referred her to our job and it was my bad.
Whoops.
Here's Lauren.
I met Lonnie through Jess.
Jess and her son met him through soccer.
I believe he coached.
Lonnie became a friend of ours.
He worked as the sheriff
at the Pender County Sheriff's Office.
He really became a second dad to her son.
He would always help with drop-offs or pickups.
We spent a few holidays with them.
We spent Halloween going trick or treating
with their family.
He was actually there nearby
when the peeping tom situation happened.
He brought his flashlight and searched and hung out with us until
my parents got there to come pick us up. There were several times where he came and helped us
hang up the cameras and do jobs that we were not capable of, whether it be we needed a tall person
to hang up cameras or we needed assistance. He was a cool guy and he was nice and helped us a lot. So there
were a few times where Jess would hang out with him. He would come to the bar where she
was at. He, from my understanding, wouldn't drink, but he would just kind of hang out
there with some of his friends. She told me that him and his wife were swingers. She told
me that he had showed her some nudes of him. There were many occasions where she said
uncomfortable things about him that he claims aren't true.
Also, Lonnie was involved when Jess first told me
that she had catfished somebody else.
I know I'm gonna sound really stupid for listening to this
and continuing to stay in a relationship,
but she texted me saying something
like, hey, we need to talk when we get home. And I come home and she's crying and I'm thinking
something small probably happened and she's just upset about it. And she immediately thinks that
she's going to go to jail. She said, I think I might be going to jail. I asked her what was going on. She basically framed it as it being a harmless prank as well that she played on somebody for talking to her
ex boyfriend or something. And she had used their photos to catfish them. And I asked
her about the nudes. She said that didn't happen. I was trying to get information and
digging into the details because I was trying to help her legally figure out if she was going to get in trouble. So I remember
reading about how illegal is catfishing, how much trouble can you get in, what happens
if you get caught, what evidence is enough to convict them. What she told me was somebody named Sammy.
She told me another guy had gotten involved
because he found out who she was
and that she was catfishing Sammy.
And he knew who she was
and he was gonna go to the police about it.
She told me it went on for three years,
which was another red flag as soon as she said that.
That was when I turned to her and I said,
if you have something to do with Brody
and you don't tell me right now, I'm gonna kill you.
I didn't mean I was gonna kill her,
but I was very serious when asking her about that.
She shook her head and said, no, that it's not.
And she was afraid that I was gonna think that
and that's why she was scared to talk to me about it.
She told me that it happened a bit ago.
That's when the other person came in and said, look, I know who you are. You're gonna be going to jail. that and that's why she was scared to talk to me about it. She told me that it happened a bit ago.
That's when the other person came in and said, look, I know who you are. You're going to be going to jail. We know everything. When I don't think they knew who she was. I suggested to call
Lonnie because he'd helped us with a lot of things like that before. And she was hesitant at first.
And that's when I started asking deeper questions.
She told me not to tell anybody, and I kept that secret for a long time.
What had Lonnie said about it that you recall?
He was kind of asking like why the victim stayed that long.
He was concerned by Jess and her doing that,
but then he also was asking questions about the nudes and what all it entailed.
From what I remember, he said that there's not much trouble that she can get in just for catfishing.
We just looked up things and talked about it and I said, look, you need to be as honest with
everybody as you can about what's going on so we can help you. Did you talk to him after you found out?
He called me. I have that call recorded.
Sitting there and trying to help her through that and trying to clear her name, even though I knew she was guilty of it, she was doing it to me that whole time.
So she called and gets looking with, you know, freedom or whatever and you know me, I told her, I said, well, I got a new position. So I can't act as a lawyer to you.
He said, oh, I didn't know that. I'm like, yeah, because I see the law and decided to come press charges. We got to do the
charges regardless. So I'm like, I don't want to say like, I'm biased or unbiased, you know, or whatever like that.
I'm being, I think, great today. And then she was telling the other
girl that I was trying to sleep with her and that I really want her and everything. I'm
like, what?
Yeah, she told me that too.
I'm like, no, I'm trying to get her to benefit of the doubt. Well, you know, y'all have in
that situation, you know, with the, uh, with that stuff or whatever.
Yeah, it was most likely her. The peeping Tom thing, that was most likely her.
Because she was texting as that guy saying
that she knew about these kids
that were going around banging on doors.
And how would she know that if it wasn't,
if she wasn't there?
I think she keyed my car.
I think she did all that.
That's crazy.
Yeah.
And then my whole thing was like,
I already, I told him, I'm like,
I was talking to a cordial, you know,
cause this is how I am.
But I'm,
I'm not saying nothing to her.
And if she do call, I may adore it.
But for her to say that about me,
and I haven't been nothing but good to her like everybody being
nothing but good to her and she come down and causing havoc like that. Yeah, that's her. That's
what she does. I don't know how much fool I got in third city. I'm trying to be cool with you about it.
Okay, so I have a question. If you guys are aware of how like how, why was her case dismissed with Bree?
I don't, so with Bree, I told Bree, I think because,
and this is between us as a friend or whatever,
I think because Bree got a 50B instead of a 50C,
because you got a 50C.
I got a 50B.
You got a 50B?
Yeah, because I lived with her.
And I tried, so I tried to fill out the 50C and the lady in the civil office.
No, I didn't. You didn't get an asparte as well? No.
I think that's probably why I could brief her to get an asparte.
That's emergency, like as of now, like right now.
So I think, guess what it is? And I think she probably, I told Marie,
probably basically in the 50 C and not the aspartame.
I'm like the aspartame is the emergency,
like emergency that you need like right now.
Many people that get aspartame,
and they're not gonna really tell it up there
because they can't ask that as a lawyer or nothing.
Yeah.
But normally with aspartame is,
that's for like people that have been in a domestic violence relationship
and they need to get away from their spouse ASAP.
You see what I'm saying?
Yeah.
Well, Jess was staying with them.
And so I think that's why.
And also because it's a past roommate, she just did the 50-day whatever.
And they're not going to tell her any different up there because they...
But I would tell her and the other girl, try like a 50c try the mar with a 50c or whatever don't get no esparte
because esparte meaning that hey this person been beating on you too or they um you got a
means that they gonna freaking try to kill you or they made some type of
theory they gonna kill you so this mainly with esparte. Yeah. Yeah. So the fetus should still be good.
Because they're gonna give her the resource to stay away from her or whatever, you know? Yeah.
Well, there's several people that want to press charges. So. Well, so I did, I didn't do Bree, I just, I swore in and Ashley was gonna do it because
like I was telling Bree, I don't want to put my name on there and then she, you know, saying
that, you know, well, he knew all of her and so he should be a unbiased party or whatever.
So just so the cake could keep going.
I just told her like Ashley did George,
that's what did George, bachelor career walk.
She's the one that did George.
So she gonna do Bre when she come back in tomorrow.
And then I'll be back here Friday.
I told Bre I'll let her know when everything
is gonna put it in all that stuff.
Yeah.
Okay.
But I don't, that, I'm, I'm,
like y'all lived together, like y'all were in a room. Okay. But I don't, yeah.
Like y'all lived together, like y'all were in a room. Look, I, oh my God.
Yeah.
Just wait till everything else comes out
cause there's a lot, there's a lot to know.
Because,
so did you, you met her in Tennessee, right?
I met her in Nashville, yeah.
I met, so I matched with the guy.
Y'all say together in Nashville,
y'all just met there in Nashville.
No, I matched with the guy in Nashville,
and then he introduced me to Jess,
which is the same story with all these other people as well.
So she matches with these girls
and then becomes friends with them,
and then weasels her way into their lives.
Cause that's cause Bri was saying that
Jessica had no reason to move to the morning
and whatever she was saying that,
whatever Bri was saying that.
Yeah, I don't know.
And I'm like, oh my gosh.
I'm like, holy, like that's like freaking
some cereal stuff or whatever.
Yeah, yeah.
Yeah.
It's pretty bad.
Cause she would ask me, she's like, yeah, so what can she do?
Like, I'm like, well, I'm like, I don't know.
I knew you had her straight on my way.
You got her straight on my call to share.
Well, they should have it.
And then I talked to Ashley, I'll tell you, Ashley, my hey,
it's only come up here.
Oh, yes, you already came up there.
Blah, blah, blah. I said, well, I don't want to be the one for my name on it. I knew you were going to come. I'm like, long and smart girl. So she know to come
up here to go and do that or whatever. Yeah. Yeah. I was the first to come up. Yeah. So I'm like,
she kept asking me about like, like, lawsuit. I'm like, yeah, I'm like, she can like she had the option
to do all this. So like, I can't tell them them I just I don't know how much proof she got.
But she only being invaded me.
I got it all. I got everything.
I could do it. I can't tell you that.
But I'm going to ask you to.
I'm ready to go to court with her.
I don't think she's going to show up, but if she does and wants to prove her
that her innocence somehow, which she's not going to be able to, then go for it.
Oh my God.
I'm just, I'm sorry you got to go through all that.
Yeah.
Well, I'm out of it now and I'm safe and everything is good.
That's good.
Yeah.
That's good.
That's good.
Well, I just wanted to reach out to you anyway, to talk to Bree, and just wanted to reach
out and reach out.
All right, well, I appreciate it.
All right, well, have a good one, and I'll be around.
Okay, you too.
All right.
Bye.
Bye.
It felt like he was kind of doing damage control, and he was contacting everybody.
But you never texted him, you never reached out to him.
Yeah, but he called me.
And we did see him at the courthouse a couple times for the hearing.
Here's Bree.
I believe the cyberstalking came up after I had met with Detective Cable.
I talked to at least five different detectives. They asked what would
warrant this and I had explained, of course, the whole catfishing situation, how she had
had my location and used it to basically terrorize me. But then the thing that really got them
was us having that camera that she still had access to and I didn't know that she had access
to.
They said, yeah, you can definitely try and file charges for that one.
But here in North Carolina, cyberstalking is a misdemeanor charge.
One of the things that I wanted to ask you about was the Mr. Clean story.
Yes.
So I want to say like it was either the second or third week in October of 2022.
I was travel nursing. I was in Washington DC and I loved this place. I hadn't been there
maybe like a month at this point so I was still pretty new. Hadn't had anybody out to
visit at this point. I worked night shift but when I would have a night off and felt like getting out of the house and exploring, I usually just checked out new restaurants or something like
that. So this one night I had gone to this little taco place. They had a bar outside on the street.
It was just in like a cute little outdoor shopping area. I went by myself. The first time I grabbed
takeout, being a girl, not anyone's favorite thing to do,
like sit at a bar and eat by yourself.
So the first time I grabbed takeout
and there was a bartender there who had said something,
he was really friendly, it wasn't creepy.
I didn't even really take it as flirty at that point,
but made a comment, I think it was my license,
because you could get a margarita to go there,
which I thought was super cool.
And he had noticed that I was from Iowa.
I said, yeah, I'm a travel nurse, blah, blah, blah.
He's like, well, hope to see you around. That was that.
Two weeks later, I had gone back
and the same bartender was working.
This time I decided I was just going to stay there and eat.
It was just nice to get out,
be out of the hotel in a new scene.
I was sitting at the bar by myself It was just nice to get out, be out of the hotel in a new scene.
So I was sitting at the bar by myself and he talked to me a little bit more that time.
We just seemed to have a lot of similar interests, but I did not think this man had any interest
in me at all.
I don't know if I'm naive or what, but that's not how it came across.
But he had mentioned a restaurant and I said,
oh, that's by where I'm staying.
And he said, well, we could go get dinner sometime.
And I was just like, well, fuck it.
I wanted to get out of the house.
It was so nice to talk to somebody
that wasn't screaming at me
and just had like an interest in my life.
I could compare it to Lauren saying she
had a taste of the other side and I feel like this was maybe that moment for me. I wasn't fully
quite out of it at this point but I was like, wow, you can go out to dinner with someone and
it be normal and fun and not weird and not feel any guilt or pressure. So I agreed to go to
dinner with this guy and it was a really casual bar place, nothing fancy, but I was told they
had really good food. I met him at the bar, we both drove separately. We sat at the actual
bar and I say that because I had been ignoring Brody at this point. I didn't
want to argue with him. I didn't want to fight with him. I just wanted a night to
clear my head and not focus on this and do my own thing. So I hadn't talked to
him and I want to say it was like two or three hours. We're at dinner talking
super friendly and then I checked my phone that had been blowing
up the entire time and Brody had told me that he was so stupid for trying.
He had driven to DC to surprise me that weekend and at this point Brody was staying in Wilmington
or he said he had a travel contract here so he was staying in Wilmington or he said he had a travel contract here. So he was living in Wilmington, which is about seven-ish hours away from there.
He had told me that he wanted to surprise me and drove up that weekend only to be
feeling and looking so stupid as I'm sitting at the bar with another guy.
And you know what happens
from here. He started making the threats. It was, I was such a slut. How could I do
something like this? But what's so wild to me is looking back Brody had referred
to this guy as Mr. Clean and I can only assume that he said that because this man was bald.
Brody had no idea who this person was, nor did Jess at this point. I have no idea. Unless
Jess was outside of the restaurant staring at me, seeing me and this guy sitting at the
bar and being able to describe where I was, the restaurant I was at, knowing what he looked like. There's no way unless she was actually there watching me. But if
that were the case, I don't know what her end game would have been. Say I hadn't met
a guy there and I had just grabbed dinner. Was she just going to be like, surprise, I
came to see you and drove seven hours? But that was something I thought about a lot way
after the fact after
everything was found out. Because there's no way unless she was actually there, there's
no way she could have known. And that's where the stalking aspect came in because Jess did
have my location as my quote to one of my best friends, she always had our location
for her safety purposes and whatnot. And I was alone in a new city. I didn't think that was
too weird, but it didn't cross my mind twice at that point. And I got yelled at for weeks after
that. And before, during and after were all times I had kept telling Brody that I wasn't happy doing
what we were doing. And it was relentless. He wouldn't give up and then he'd want to see me and then he
wouldn't want to see me. I didn't dare ask to make plans for a very long time and when
I did, that would get thrown in my face. It's just one of the crazier aspects of the whole
Brody saga.
I had gotten my restraining order granted September 1st, but I think it was eight days
to serve my restraining order and then the misdemeanor cyberstalking charges as well.
We had talked to the DA and he got a five-minute rundown of what had been going on, which is,
I guess, policy or how it goes for everybody. But he had five minutes to digest everything. Lauren
and I could word vomit to him and try and come up with something. I mean, I don't really
blame him or anyone. Nobody could think like that in five minutes because it's something
that nobody's ever thought about, really. It was Lauren, Lauren's friend, me, and then
Lauren's mom was there. And we were there
all day.
LESLIE KENDRICK-KLEIN Listening to other people go first?
KATE BOWEN Yep. And then the DA was like, I'm going to be pretty frank with you. I don't
think this judge is going to go for these charges. We can either drop them and try for
something else, or we can go ahead and try and get these. And then he brought up the
plea about,
I don't even know what it's called,
getting banned from social media.
I was like, how is that ever gonna happen?
She's never herself.
And then we were all just pretty flustered at that point.
We were all in line to talk to,
I want to say it was like the DA's assistant,
because she was just reviewing like what we were there for,
what the charges were, seeing if both parties were there. We were in line and she's like, yeah, it looks like
you guys are both present as is Jessica Pauley. And I looked at Lauren and she turned around and
looked back at me and she goes, she's right behind you. And I was like, what? And she was there with
her mother and wouldn't look at me. Her mom wouldn't stop looking at me, but she wouldn't look
at me. Lauren and I were in heels, like business casual. We had blazers on, as we should in a
courtroom, and she was wearing ripped American Eagle jeans, a flannel, and I think tennis shoes,
like white kicks. We were both very caught off guard.
We did not think she would have shown up.
It was super weird to be in the same setting.
No words were ever exchanged and we were on the opposite side of the courtroom.
I'd noticed I got up and went to the restroom and her mom was staring at me and when I came
back in was staring at me.
Just weird.
Meanwhile, the entire time she's like catfishing other people still.
Next time on Something Was Wrong.
The district attorney that we talked to, or the DA assistant, she took one look at our
papers and she's like, what? I didn't know any of this was like, she had no clue what we
were talking about or what we went through and she had took
Two seconds to look over the paper before she decided what to do with our case
They start texting us. She's here. She's here. She showed up and I was like, oh my god
We just didn't expect it at all. Her lawyer was there
They had been talking for a couple months and she had planned to fly out to
Omaha to go see him.
The plan was for Camden to come pick her up.
He essentially said, like, I can't make it to the airport, but my best friend Jess would
be okay with picking you up.
You guys would have a lot in common.
The day after I found out about the podcast being recorded and being scheduled, Jess attempted
to follow me on Instagram.
I didn't do anything wrong, but still, like, I was so nervous. I was like, it's the fucking FBI.
Thank you so much for listening. Until next time, stay safe, friends.
Something Was Wrong is a Broken Cycle Media production created and hosted by me, Tiffany Reese.
This season, our theme song, You Think You, by Gladrags, is covered by Palehound.
For music and tour dates, go to palehound.com.
If you'd like to support the show further, you can share episodes with your loved ones,
leave a positive review, or follow Something Was Wrong on Instagram at SomethingWasWrongPodcast.
As always, thank you so much for listening. They're false They think they know me, they don't know me
Well, at all
At all, at all Music You think you know me, you don't know me well at all
At all, at all, at all
You don't know anybody You don't know anybody
You don't know anybody
Till you've talked to someone If you like Something Was Wrong, you can listen early and ad-free right now by joining Wondery
Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts.
Prime members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music.
Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey at Wondery.com slash survey.