Ten Percent Happier with Dan Harris - The Harvard Scientist Who Says You Can Use Your Thoughts To Improve Your Health | Ellen Langer
Episode Date: September 23, 2024The connection between your psychology and your health, and how to work with it.Ellen J. Langer is the author of eleven books, including the international bestsellerMindfulness, which has bee...n translated into fifteen languages, and Counterclockwise:Mindful Health and the Power of Possibility. Most recently, she is the author of TheMindful Body: Thinking Our Way to Chronic Health.Langer is the recipient of, among other numerous awards and honors, a GuggenheimFellowship, the Award for Distinguished Contributions to Psychology in the PublicInterest from the American Psychological Association, the Award for DistinguishedContributions of Basic Science to the Application of Psychology from the AmericanAssociation of Applied and Preventive Psychology, and the Adult Development andAging Distinguished Research Achievement Award from the American PsychologicalAssociation.She is the author of more than 200 research articles and her trailblazing experiments insocial psychology have earned her inclusion in The New York Times Magazine’s “Yearin Ideas” issue. A member of the psychology department at Harvard University and apainter, she lives in Cambridge, Massachusetts.In this episode we talk about:The power of placebosWhy she isn’t a fan of positive thinking as it is talked about in new age circlesHer version of mindfulness, which is quite different from the version we usually talk about here on the show, which comes out of BuddhismPsychological treatments for chronic illness Smart strategies for reframing aging. Why the world would be boring if you knew it allWhat she means by her concept of a “mindful utopia”And her favorite one liners Related Episodes:The Science Of Manifestation: Can This Stanford Neuroscientist Convince A Skeptical Dan To Give It A Shot? | Dr. James R. DotyHow to Get the Wisdom of Old Age Now | Dilip Jeste Tripping Out with a Legend: Jon Kabat-Zinn on Pain vs. Suffering, Rethinking Your Anxiety, and the Buddha's Teaching in a Single SentenceSign up for Dan’s weekly newsletter hereFollow Dan on social: Instagram, TikTokTen Percent Happier online bookstoreSubscribe to our YouTube ChannelOur favorite playlists on: Anxiety, Sleep, Relationships, Most Popular EpisodesFull Shownotes: https://happierapp.com/podcast/tph/ellen-langer-832See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Wondery Plus subscribers can listen to 10% happier early and ad free right now.
Join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple podcasts.
This is the 10% happier podcast.
I'm Dan Harris.
Hello, everybody.
How we doing? Hello, everybody.
How we doing?
You might have looked at the title of this episode and thought has Dan lost his mind?
He built his career, at least in part, on rebutting the power of positive thinking,
that magical notion that you can use the so-called law of attraction to control your health or make yourself rich, making matters worse perhaps, is the fact that today's
episode comes on top of an interview a few weeks ago where I talked to a Stanford neuroscientist
who got me to open my mind to the possibility of manifestation.
I'll drop a link to that episode in the show notes if you missed it.
Anyway, the short answer here is no, I have not lost my mind that Stanford scientist
who talked about manifestation readily admitted
that his version involves no magic whatsoever.
And the same holds true for the Harvard scientist
you're gonna hear from today who has spent several decades
over her illustrious career,
demonstrating that there is a very powerful connection
between the way you think and your physical health.
In fact, she makes a compelling case
that that famous phrase, the mind-body connection,
actually understates the truth of the matter.
She calls it mind-body unity.
Ellen J. Langer is a member
of the psychology department at Harvard.
She's the author of more than 200 research articles.
She's also written 11 books.
Her latest is called The Mindful Body,
Thinking Our Way to Chronic Health.
We talked about the power of placebos,
why she's not a fan of positive thinking,
as it's talked about in new age circles.
Her version of mindfulness,
which is quite different from the version
we usually talk about here on the show,
which emerges out of Buddhism.
Psychological treatments for chronic illness,
smart strategies for reframing aging,
why the world becomes boring if you know it all,
what she means by her concept of a mindful utopia,
and her favorite one-liners for doing life better.
Ellen Langer, coming right up.
You know, I'm never sure how long to keep up
an announcement here on the show
because on the one hand, I don't wanna bang you
over the head with something you've already heard me say
a million times.
On the other hand, there's some evidence
that you need to hear something about seven times
before you take action.
I leave with that caveat because I'm aware
that some of you might be annoyed
that I'm reminding you yet again
about this big new venture I just launched called danharris.com. But I'm doing so because I really aware that some of you might be annoyed that I'm reminding you yet again about this big new venture
I just launched called danharris.com.
But I'm doing so because I really do want you
to come check it out.
As you know, I went through a big professional transition
recently after a multi-year negotiation
with my now former partners over at the 10% Happier app.
I am no longer part of that company.
This is a big change for me, and so I'd love your support in this new thing I'm now doing.
My initial focus and my post app life
is really on this show.
It's a huge part of my life.
Hope it will be for a long time.
And we've heard from you, the listeners,
that the practicality and the virtual community
of this show are super important.
So that's what we're focusing on over at danharris.com.
If you sign up, you'll get a gentle IV drip
of aha moments via email.
You'll also be able to chat directly with me.
You'll get cheat sheets that help you remember
all the practical wisdom we drop on the show.
And you'll get monthly AMAs where you can join me live
and ask me anything.
It's eight bucks a month or $80 a year,
and it's free for anybody who can't afford it.
If that's you, just send me an email.
I'll hook you up, no questions asked.
Also, just to say, while I'm super excited
about doing my own thing right now,
for the next few months, I'm gonna keep you posted
on what the folks over at the app are up to.
They have changed their name.
Now, instead of 10% happier, it's just plain happier. They've also re-imagined the app are up to. They have changed their name. Now instead of 10% happier, it's just plain happier.
They've also reimagined the app,
reflecting the belief that no two journeys are the same
and your meditation app should meet you where you are
to help you achieve more than you thought possible.
Happier introduces new ways to meditate
and updated features that bring mindfulness to you
on and off the cushion.
The app checks in with you monthly
and adapts to your needs and goals, whether you've been
practicing mindfulness for three minutes or 30 years.
Download the new Happier app today to discover meditation that evolves with you.
Listening to Audible helps your imagination soar.
Whether you listen to stories, motivation, expert advice, any genre you love, you can
be inspired to imagine new worlds, new possibilities, new ways of thinking.
Listening can lead to positive change in your mood,
your habits, and ultimately your overall wellbeing.
Audible has the best selection of audiobooks
without exception, along with popular podcasts
and exclusive Audible originals, all in one easy app.
Enjoy Audible anytime while doing other things,
household chores, exercising on the road,
commuting, you name it.
My wife Bianca and I have been listening to many audiobooks
as we drive around for summer vacations.
We listen to Life by Keith Richards.
Keith, if you're listening,
I'd love to have you on the show.
We also listen to Sapiens by Yuval Noah Harari.
And Yuval, if you're listening to this,
we would also love to have you on this show.
So audio books, yes, audible, yes, love it.
There's more to imagine when you listen.
Sign up for a free 30 day audible trial
and your first audio book is free.
Visit audible.ca, audible.ca.
Hello, I'm Dak Shepard.
And I'm Monica Padman.
Monica and I do three weekly shows with celebrities on Monday, experts on Wednesdays, and crazy
stories from listeners on Fridays.
We're so excited to officially be a part of the Wondry Network.
So follow Armchair Expert on the Wondry app or wherever you get your podcasts and subscribe
to Armchair Expert on YouTube.
Alan Langer, welcome to the show.
Hi, nice to see you, Dan.
Likewise.
I have so many questions for you.
The book is called The Mindful Body,
Thinking Our Way to Chronic Health.
What does that mean, thinking our way to chronic health?
That means that the control we have over our health
is far greater than most
people realize and essentially a function of our thoughts. People think of
a mind and a body as if they're two distinct things which creates the
problem of how do you get from this fuzzy thing called a thought to something
material called the body. When you put the two together and realize it's one thing,
then wherever you're putting the mind,
you're necessarily putting the body.
So when you put the mind in a healthy place,
so too will the body be there.
The mindful body is full of fun research
that I've done over the past 45 years
to support the idea of unity.
Right, so there's a term of art that most people have heard, the mind-body connection.
You tweak that to mind-body unity.
Yeah, well, because it's not connected.
If it's connected, it means it's two things.
And if it's two things, then you have the problem,
how do you get from one of these to the other?
To speak of a mind-body connection is a one step or five steps better than the way things
used to be because it suggests that the mind has something to do with the body.
Way back when, the medical model believed that the only way you were going to get sick
was the introduction of an antigen.
And I'm sure doctors at that point thought it was
nice for people to be happy, also not experience stress, but essentially that was irrelevant to
their health. So when you talk about mind-body connection, they're saying, okay, yeah, there's
a relationship. I'm saying the relationship is far greater than most people believe. And I have support throughout this book to convince people of that work of my
own, but also work of other people.
I think that placebos are actually our strongest medicine and placebos
support the idea of mind, body unity.
You take this pill, that's nothing.
It's a sugar pill.
You think it's something, then magically you
get better. Perhaps the research that people are most aware of. Interestingly, most people
are not aware of research on the nocebo effect. So a placebo, you take something that's nothing,
thinking it's something and it does its magic. A nocebo, you take something that's something,
you think it's nothing and it doesn't have an effect no, Cibo, you take something that's something, but you think it's nothing, and it doesn't have an effect.
So, for example, an early study on this was with people who were vomiting, and they were given Ipecac.
Now, Ipecac is what you give people to make them vomit. So, if somebody has just ingested a poison, unintentionally, presumably. You give them Ipacac, they vomit and they're fine.
People are vomiting and they're told that Ipacac will make you stop vomiting
and they stop vomiting. It's very important because people, medicine in
general, may not work if we don't support it with our mindsets. So an early study
we did on the Nocebo effect was we took chambermaids
and the first question we asked them is how much exercise do you get? Now these
people are exercising all day long but they think exercise is what you do
after work and after work they're just too tired. So we divide them into two
groups and we simply teach one of the groups that their work is exercise.
They're told making a bed is like working at this machine at the gym, doing this exercise,
whatever, is like washing windows and so on.
So now we have two groups.
One group that's oblivious to the fact that their work is exercise, the other that now
has changed their mind.
We make sure there are no differences between the groups on as many measures as we could think of. The group that perceives their
work now as exercise isn't working harder than not eating differently. Yet,
we find the simple change of mind resulted in weight loss, a change in
waist to hip ratio, body mass index, and their blood pressure came down. Okay,
so the exercise that they were doing wasn't effective without them believing
that it was effective. Very powerful. You go to a doctor and you're given
medication. It doesn't work. What the doctor is likely to do is up the dosage.
This work suggests what they should do is teach people to collude in their own health,
so to speak.
But that was the second study we did on this mind-body unity.
The first one is a famous study, Dan.
How dare I call one of my own studies famous?
That's because if you watch The Simpsons Go to Havana, they talk about the study.
And what we did was retrofit a retreat to 20 years earlier
and had elderly men live there as if they were their younger selves. As close
as I could on a very low budget make it like a Hollywood scene from 20 years
earlier. They would discuss topics from the past as if they were just unfolding
and all of this took place in a week. As a result, their vision improved, vision,
hearing, memory, strength, and they looked noticeably younger. Now I don't know about
you, but to this day, and that study was run quite some time ago, I've never heard
of old people's hearing improved without medical intervention, nor even with
medical intervention. So the
results were very exciting. Mind and body together, you make the mind young and it
shows itself on the body. I have a host of these studies. People will read the
book if they're interested. I'll just give you one more. The most recent I did
this with my graduate student Peter Ungle. So we inflict a wound. Now, we're not
sadists or something like that. So the wound is a small wound, but a wound nonetheless. We have people in front of a clock. Unbeknownst to them, for a third of the people, the clock is going twice
as fast as real time. For a third of the people, the clock is going half as fast as real time.
For a third of the people, it's going real time.
The question is, is that healing influenced by that clock?
Now most people think things are going to heal when they heal,
but it turns out that that's not the case.
The healing time was the clock time, your perception of the time that passes. So we have lots of very exciting studies
suggesting our
ability to cure ourselves
and prevent illness in the first place is so much greater than people think.
And I do this thing with my Harvard students. I'll ask them, how far is it humanly possible to run?
They know a marathon is 26 miles, so they start 28, 30.
Somebody else yells out 35.
Anyway, somebody eventually says 45 or 50.
Everybody groans.
That's impossible.
Then I turn on a YouTube of the Tarayamora, which
is a tribe in Copper Canyon, Mexico. They, as a rule,
run over 200 miles without stopping. I would get exhausted running a mile and a half at this point,
but I could get myself to the marathon. And to imagine the difference between 26 miles and 200
miles represents, in some sense in my mind the difference from
where we are to where we can be if we just change our minds.
Let me ask in a friendly way a kind of skeptical question just to give you a
little bit of background. I spent a lot of time when I was a network news
correspondent covering all sorts of shysters. Some of the shysters and con men that I covered
were involved in the power of positive thinking or manifestation, basically telling people,
you don't need to go to a doctor, you can think your way to curing your breast cancer,
which I believe is a very dangerous thing to be telling people. So what is the difference
between what you're saying?
Okay, what's the difference between you and them?
A big difference is, it's funny you should ask me this.
I've never been approached with this kind of disbelief,
but it's all right.
First of all, let me say that snake oil salesmen,
part of the reason that they're effective
when they're effective is because the pains you experience
follow a normal distribution. Sometimes they're big, sometimes they're small,
so you get a regression to the mean, which means that now all of a sudden the pain is killing me,
so I have to do something about it. I go to this con man and he gives me snake oil and I'm going to actually be better because
the natural course of pain is that it will revert to the main. So I go ask for help when
it's enormous and if nothing happens the next time around it's not going to be as bad. And
I attribute the improvement to the snake oil salesman. Another thing to be aware of, Dan,
is that sometimes the wrong people
may actually give some of the right advice
without knowing why.
But I would say the major difference
is that all of my work is based on 45 years of research
with lots of additional work that's out there
by other people that supports all of it.
Let me give you a fun study that Frank Beach did many years ago.
So he took a little boy rat and a little girl rat.
They're going to copulate.
And then, as I'm sure you're aware,
a little boy rat at some point is going to be exhausted.
He needs a refractory period.
If immediately you introduce a new little girl rat, he doesn't need that
refractory period. He's ready to go. So we have a sense of things like fatigue
is wired in, there's nothing we can do about it, and as I've already shown you
with the tariamora, there's a great deal we can do. So we had a study where we
had people in a sleep lab, they wake up and the clock tells them they got two hours more sleep than they got,
two hours fewer, or the amount of sleep they actually got.
And biological and cognitive functions follow the perceived amount of sleep.
You'd have to show me the particular person that is annoying you, and I can tell you what it is he's saying that makes no sense,
or where he's picked up some of the research
and I've been doing this, as I said, for 45 years. It's out there in the general world.
All one needs to do to be persuasive is sprinkle whatever nonsense they're saying with some actual facts.
I don't know what to tell you except that I stand by all of this work.
The medical world seems to agree because it has gone
from the psychology has nothing to do with our health
to acknowledging that yes,
it has a great deal to do with our health.
But you know, this comes from lots of labs, not just my own.
To be clear, I'm not skeptical of you,
but I am very skeptical of people who talk about
the power of positive thinking and manifestation.
And so I'm just trying to figure out how do I draw the line?
Like, what's the difference in the actionable advice?
So for example, the snake oil salesman to whom I'm referring will just say, look, it's
all about making sure you think positively at every step of the way, which is a very
hard thing to do.
And what's the difference between that advice and what you would say we should do when we're
trying to use the power of our mind to impact our health?
Yeah.
Well, the first thing is, I'm considered the mother of positive psychology, not because
I'm telling everybody to be positive.
My message to everybody first is to be mindful.
Now, what I mean by mindful has nothing to do
with meditation. It's the very simple process of actively noticing new things
and when you actively notice new things that puts you in the present, right? And
that gives you choices and all sorts of things that our mindlessness robs us of.
When you're mindful and you have many explanations for any event and
explanation A and B get you crazy, explanation C makes you feel good.
Chances are you would lean towards the one that's positive. If you see the world
as positive and negative or even just positive, that makes real the negative.
The concept of toll suggests short,
that there are these dimensions that matter.
And I don't think we should try to be positive.
I think that what we should do as much as we can
is to get rid of the mindlessness that controls our lives.
My research suggests that virtually all of us
are mindless almost all the time.
So Dan, I'm gonna ask you something.
How much is one plus one?
This is the thing everybody thinks they know.
How much is one plus one?
I've never been good at math, but I think it's two.
Okay, and so much so that you probably
are gonna disparage me silently, right,
for asking such a silly question.
But it turns out this thing that we think we know better
than anything else is not always true. If you add one watt of chewing gum plus one watt
of chewing gum, one plus one is one. You add one cloud plus one cloud, one plus one is
one. You add one pile of laundry plus one pile of laundry, one plus one is one. And
somebody who heard me on some podcast speaking sent me something that said, if you add one pizza and put on top of it one pizza,
you have two pizzas.
However, if you have one lasagna
and you add on top of it another lasagna,
one plus one is one.
It's just a bigger lasagna.
All right, so in the real world,
one plus one probably doesn't equal two
as a morph and as it does.
Not only that, but
mathematicians probably know that 1 plus 1 equals 2 if you're using a base 10
number system. If you're using a base 2 number system, 1 plus 1 is written as 10.
Alright, so what does all this mean? This means that the things we think we know,
maybe we don't know them. Now when you know you don't know, you tune in, right?
If you knew what I was going to say next,
why would you listen to me?
And what I'm telling people is that uncertainty
is the rule, it's not the exception.
Everything is changing, everything looks different
from different perspectives.
And so when you think you know,
it's because you're confusing the stability of your mindset with the stability of the underlying phenomena.
Things are changing. You want to hold them still in your head, do so, but they're
changing. So I met a horse event and that will go to new stories, which I've told
these before. I met a horse event. This man asked me, can I watch his horse for
him because he wants to get his horse a hot dog? Well, I'm Harvard Yale all the way through.
I'm the A plus student you hated in school.
I know, nobody knows better.
Horses don't eat meat.
He comes back with a hot dog, he gives it to the horse, and the horse ate it.
That moment, I realized everything I thought I knew could be wrong.
Now, what people don't realize is that science only gives us probabilities.
It says if you were to do this exact same study again,
which you can never do exactly the same study,
but if you were to do exactly the same thing again,
you're likely to get these findings.
But the world, parents, teachers, periodicals
report these probabilities as absolutes.
If you know something absolutely,
you don't pay any attention to it.
So there are two ways to become mindful as I study it.
One is bottom up, as I just said,
take things you think you know
and notice new things about them.
And then you'll see you didn't know it as well as you thought, then your attention will
naturally go to them. Or top-down, which is to accept that everything is changing.
So uncertainty is a myth and that means everything then is new. Now the reason
people have so much difficulty accepting uncertainty
is because they think other people do know. I know I don't know, but you seem to know,
so I'm going to pretend I know or I'm going to avoid the situation. I'm here to free everybody.
Nobody knows. And so the posture I think that is most successful in life is to be confident but uncertain.
You know, if you were going to come visit me, you've never been to my house, you wouldn't
have to practice anything.
You'd walk in and you'd notice things.
You'd say, oh, did she do those paintings?
What is that?
All that noticing would enable you or be the essence of you being engaged.
So as you're actively noticing new things, the neurons are firing.
And the 45 years of research has shown me that that's literally and figuratively enlivening.
In very early studies, we took elderly people, we gave them instructions in this mindfulness
act of noticing, and they did, they live longer.
We have that in
a few studies. Not only that, but when you're actively noticing in the present and people out
there, it's very sweet. They say be in the moment, but that's an empty instruction. Why? Because when
you're not there, you're not there to know you're not there. And most of the time we're just not
there and we're oblivious to it. And being there is fun. It's what you're doing when you're having fun,
rather than being more or less like a robot where the past is dictating the present. You
know, when you're actively noticing, you understand things can be understood in many ways. You
have all sorts of choices. Your behavior tends to be rule and routine guided,
rather than those rules and routines determining everything you do. Now, and what happens is that
when you're actively noticing, you seem alive to people. It's the essence of charisma. So,
it's fun for you, people are going to like you more, you have more control, more
ways of understanding any event, and we have other research where that
mindfulness leaves its imprint on what you're doing. The products tend to be
better. People think it's hard because they confuse it with thinking, and even
thinking has gotten a bad rap. Thinking isn't hard. What's hard is when we are
worried that we're not going to get
the right answer. People in their spare time away from schools and work do all sorts of puzzles and
games that require them to use their minds for pleasure. I want to get back to the impact on
health. So let me give you a concrete example.
Right before I came to this interview,
I was talking to my wife who's having a tough day.
She has a complex headache syndrome,
so she gets awful headaches, and it's really terrible.
So I walk from that conversation into this interview
and I'm thinking, okay, well, what could I advise my wife who's in terrible pain based on what I'm hearing from you?
Sure. Well, there are many things. Towards the end of the mindful body, I talk about
a psychological treatment that we've used successfully for many chronic
illnesses. I call it attention to symptom variability.
That's just a fancy way of saying being mindful. So when you're mindful, you're noticing change.
So when people have whatever illnesses, the headaches for example,
they tend to think that your wife would think she's in pain all the time and
big pain all the time. Well, no one is
experiencing any symptom all the time and big pain all the time. Well no one is experiencing any symptom
all the time but the moments you're not experiencing you're just living so
you're oblivious to the fact that you have that relief. Anyway what we do is we
call people periodically and we simply ask them how is the symptom now? Is it
better or worse than before? And then the important question is why? Alright, so several things happen with this. The first is that when you're
diagnosed with a chronic illness, people tend to think that there's nothing they
can do about it. And that's wrong. It's just that the medical world hasn't found
a solution for them. So now you notice, gee, right now it's a little better than before, so you feel good.
Second, you notice sometimes you are better. Now when you're looking for why now am I better than
before, that starts a mindful search and that mindfulness itself is good for your health.
And finally, I think that you're more likely to find a solution if you're looking for one than if you're not.
Now, we've done this with people who have Parkinson's, multiple sclerosis, chronic pain, arthritis, stroke, real things.
And in each case, we get success.
Once I realized that how powerful placebos were, which was to me such strong evidence
that we're doing it ourselves,
I wanted to see is there a way for us to do it ourselves
without involving the medical world?
And this is the closest I've come to it.
Now, you might say, well, I'm calling your wife or whomever.
Everybody has a smartphone these days.
Set the smartphone to ring in an hour.
Ask yourself, how is the symptom?
Is it better or worse than before and why? Then set it to ring in two hours and
ten minutes. Just keep bearing it over the course of a week, maybe two weeks. The
good thing about this is that there's no downside. There are no effects that you
might get with medication or what have you. And I'm not suggesting that people
shouldn't see their physicians, but there's often a long wait period then. The physicians, remember now
we've just determined, don't know because none of us know. They have some
good answers, but they can't be sure. And so no matter what, you have to
participate actively in your own health care.
People don't understand that.
This is a little confusing, easy I think when it's being read, but prediction is an illusion.
You can predict to the group, but you can't predict the individual case.
And when you're suffering, it's good to know that whatever it is helps lots of people,
but you want to know is it going to help you.
So let me give you an example that I've used before. I will
give you a million dollars. We're going to go to a Mercedes shop, lots of fancy
cars. Pick one at random. You can pick the one. If you turn the key and the
engine starts, I'll give you a million dollars. If the engine doesn't start, you give me, let's say $500,000.
People won't take the bet.
Even the best of us make mistakes,
products are not uniformly excellent.
We just know that if we did this at a used parking lot,
that more of the Mercedes will start than the used cars,
but not every single one.
Michael Jordan occasionally misses a foul shot.
Ellen Langer occasionally makes a foul shot.
If we're only gonna each shoot one basket,
we wanna be careful, right?
And so the doctor's information is all about probabilities,
not what is necessarily going to be good for you.
The advice that you gave that I would give to my wife about paying attention to the symptom
variability, it's interesting because you said earlier that your version of mindfulness
is different, doesn't require meditation.
Oh no, it has nothing to do with meditation. Oh, no, it has nothing to do with meditation. Yes. And the way a meditation teacher would tell someone to
work with pain is to pay close attention to it and notice its
changing nature.
The meditation teacher would tell your wife to meditate.
Right? And meditation is not mindfulness. Meditation is a practice you engage in
to result hopefully in post meditative mindfulness. I did some early research on
meditation. I'm not anti meditation, but what I'm talking about is just different.
It's not a practice. It's a way of being that naturally flows from recognizing
you don't know.
So when your wife says, I'm always in pain, she thinks she knows she's always in pain.
If she were mindful, she'd know nothing is always, and she would naturally tune in.
But when the meditation teacher, and I don't think they would do this, but say, follow
that pain, it's not the same thing because I'm talking about the changes in
the pain and when those changes occur. I think it's quite different but it's the same wonderful
two ways to get better and probably many more out there or just take an aspirin.
Coming up, Elin Langer talks about how to increase your mindfulness quotient.
Again, mindfulness as she defines it.
We'll also talk about the differences between her definition of mindfulness and the one
that emerges out of Buddhism.
And we'll talk about some of her favorite one-liners for doing life better.
Being a part of a royal family might seem enticing,
but more often than not,
it comes at the expense of everything,
like your freedom, your privacy,
and sometimes even your head.
Even the Royals is a podcast from Wondery
that pulls back the curtain on royal families,
past and present, from all over the world
to show you the darker side of what it means to be royalty.
Like the true stories behind the six wives of Henry VIII,
whose lives were so much more than just
divorced, beheaded, died, divorced, beheaded, survived.
Or Esther of Burundi, a princess who fled her home country
to become France's first black supermodel.
There's also Queen Christina of Sweden,
an icon who traded in dresses for pants,
had an affair with her lady-in-waiting,
and eventually gave up her crown
because she refused to get married.
Throw in her involvement in a murder
and an attempt to become Queen of Poland,
and you have one of the most unforgettable legacies
in royal history.
Follow Even The Royals on the Wondery app,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can binge Even The Royals ad-free right now
on Wondery+.
Hey, it's Guy Raz here, and you might know me as the host of How I Built This. Well,
did you know about my other show, The Great Creators? It's where I interview some of the
most celebrated actors and musicians of our time about their life, their craft, and where they find
their ideas. You'll hear giants like Tom Hanks. Very rarely do I have a conversation quite frankly, like
this one guy.
Jason Sudeikis talked about how he became Ted Lasso.
People will say to us, you know, this is the show saved me, I
will say back me too.
Plus musicians like Ellie Golding, Bjork and Lainey
Wilson.
I remember having that crazy feeling of I am going to do
this. I'm going gonna be on that stage.
You can check out our newest season
and browse our whole catalog, 80 plus episodes
by following the great creators on the Wondery app
or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can listen to the great creators early
and ad free right now on Wondery Plus.
A quick reminder to come check out what I'm doing
over at danharris.com.
This is a huge new venture for me.
I'd love to get your support and your feedback.
And a reminder that the 10% Happier app
is now called Just Happier,
and they've got personalized meditation plans
and fresh ways to meditate on and off the cushion.
Download the new Happier Meditation app today
to discover meditation that evolves with you.
Say a little bit more about how if,
and I agree with you on this,
meditation is a way to improve your mindfulness,
but you don't believe we absolutely need to meditate
in order to be mindful.
So what would you recommend that we could do in order to increase our mindfulness
quotient? Well, you know, I've already said two ways.
One is top down, which is hard for most people because the world,
everything you learned in school, your parents tells you that, you know,
you know, one in one is two horses don't't eat meat, whatever are the facts you have.
But if you were able to accept uncertainty,
then you'd approach everything as brand new.
The other is to take the things you know,
so go home, you think you know your wife,
I don't think you know her as well as you think you do,
and notice five new things about her.
And you'll see
those new things and that'll be good for you. And she, by the way, will feel seen
and more cared for. So it actually improves relationships. So it's bottom up
or top down. It's not a practice. It's an understanding that the world is in flux
and that it's a false thing to try to
control things by holding everything still because everything is actually there.
Anyway, so, you know, again, I hope nothing I'm saying suggests that I'm anti-meditation.
It's just something different from what I'm talking about.
For many people that meditation is, you know, is a little woo-woo.
And for those people, they can immediately make changes
based on what I'm saying.
Now, on the other hand, what I'm saying in some ways
is so simple that there are some people that are like,
no, this big problem I have can't be solved
by what Ellen Langer says.
And, you know, so maybe they should meditate.
There are many ways to get to where we wanna go.
Yes, based on my experience as a meditator,
much of what you're describing
is trained through meditation.
And I don't think everybody needs to do it
in order to get what you're describing.
But there are some real differences, Dan.
You know, so magically,
meditators are supposed to become less judgmental.
And I don't see how that happens.
But in my scheme of things,
it's very clear how it happens.
Because once you recognize that behavior makes sense
from the actor's perspective,
or else the actor wouldn't do it,
you change immediately your understanding. So you don't like me because I'm so gullible,
but nobody from their perspective is gullible. You don't wake up in the morning and say,
today I'm going to be gullible, obnoxious, and clumsy. So when we see people doing these things,
what's actually going on? Well, it's because I'm trusting. Now that you know I I'm trusting you're probably not going to want to change me. But if you do want
to change me, the way to change me is not to get me to meditate. The way to change
me is to get me to stop valuing being trusting. So it turns out each and every
negative description has an equally strong but oppositely valence alternative.
Somebody boring is stable. I did this study quite a while ago, you might like has an equally strong but oppositely valence alternative.
Somebody boring is stable.
I did this study quite a while ago, you might like this.
I give people like two or three hundred behavior descriptions.
And I said, check off those things you keep trying to change about yourself and you fail.
So for me I check off impulsive, gullible, I won't tell you the others.
Then you turn the sheet of paper over
and in a mixed up order are the positive versions of these.
And now the task is check those things
you really value about yourself.
My spontaneity, am I being trusting?
And as long as I value being spontaneous,
I'm going to seem impulsive at times.
As long as I value being trusting, I'm going to end impulsive at times as long as I value being trusting I'm going to end up gullible and so much of the time when we're trying to change people it's because we have a fixed notion and
Also think that they do these things all the time and nobody does anything all the time
So if you're inconsiderate your wife says to you, I should ask you to make it more fun,
what does she accuse you of, Dan?
What does she accuse me of?
Oh, don't tell me.
It doesn't matter.
So let's say your wife says you're inconsistent.
She's going to pay attention every time you're inconsistent.
Yeah, he's done it again.
But what she needs to do is notice all the times you're not inconsistent and then realize that no, it's not a good
thing to have given you that label that holds things still because your behavior is also
varying.
In general, you have all these people trying to change people and the only way you're going
to successfully change people is if you change what they're doing from the perspective from
which they're engaging in.
An example I use is like drinking.
You have people who are heavy drinkers and say, oh my God, you know what you're doing
your liver?
Nobody's going to stop drinking because their drinking has nothing to do with their liver.
But if you said to people, a person gets anxious and does X, and that relieves
the anxiety. Is it a good thing to do X? And you'd probably say yes. And then we say, well, X is
consuming alcohol. So if instead of diminishing people for what they do, we understood the
advantages to what they do, then we can provide alternative
ways of reaching that same goal.
We have a study, a wine tasting study that I report in the book.
People think it's a wine tasting.
We just had heavy drinkers who were participants.
And they're told to give us the answers about the particular wines they can drink as much
as they want.
Now the experimenter is either mindful or mindless.
So when the experimenter is mindless, they're just repeating numbers themselves or whatever.
They're not noticing anything new.
Always in these studies, the mindful is new, the mindless is same old, same old.
And so the mindful people are noticing things about the participant and what have you.
When you're in the presence of the mindful experimenter, you drink less.
So I think that some of this heavy drinking is because people are ultra sensitive to other
people's behavior and they don't know what to call it.
Being with people who are mindless is very uncomfortable.
For the heavy drinker, I think it might be even more uncomfortable.
Well, this is a great asset that they have, that many have not been made aware of.
This picking up all sorts of social cues to which other people are blind. And once you call it what it is, then you can find alternative ways
of making use of that skill, rather than trying to get rid of that.
It's a very profound idea, I think.
As you know, having done all this research for so many years,
some of the findings are big.
But this one idea turned out to be more
important to me than anything else I've ever written. The idea that behavior
makes sense from the actor's perspective or else they wouldn't do it.
And that's what makes you non-judgmental. Now meditators are supposed to become
non-judgmental by meditating and I just, I don't see how that happens. I think that somebody says,
you know, I'm really a nasty SOB. Maybe I'll learn how to meditate so I can be a nicer person.
And so when they meditate with the goal of being less judgmental, but I don't see how the meditation
itself leads to that. I could venture a theory. Sure, go on. It's your show.
to that. I could venture a share. Go on. It's your show.
I don't know if I could say this is true for everybody, but in my own experience, doing some meditation, the more you get familiar with how wild your mind is, the more you understand that everybody's got a wild mind. And that can inexorably lead to empathy. Yeah, I don't buy it, but I'm happy to do a study where we teach people that everybody
has a wild mind and then we'll have them step on your toes and we see how much empathy you
have.
But be that as it may, my desire is not in any way to diminish. Meditation is very good.
I would think that you would have answered and said, it's calming.
And when you're calm, there's less need to be evaluative and judgmental in the first
place.
But calm.
Yeah, maybe that too.
No, that one, not two.
But I think that mindfulness as we study it also has a very powerful effect on stress,
which by the way I believe is the major killer.
And I think the world eventually will come to that view.
But if you open up medical journals, somebody will show its effect on this disease and somebody
else on that disease without generalizing across all.
But at the least everybody now knows
stress is bad for you and stress is psychological. Events don't cause stress.
What causes stress are the views you take of events. The more mindful you are, the
more potential views you have. If you have three views, you know, you no longer
believe that this thing is going to happen. It's interesting because stress
requires two things. Firstly, it requires a belief that something's going
to happen. Second, that when it happens it's going to be awful. So to believe that
something's going to happen, the more mindful you are, the easier it is. But
anyone can say to themselves, what are three, five reasons that it won't happen?
So you went from thinking this thing is going to happen to now maybe it'll happen maybe it won't. You immediately feel a little
better. But now is the harder part. Let's assume it does happen. How is that
actually a good thing? Because people don't realize that outcomes are they're
not good, they're not bad, they're nothing until we frame them. So let's say for
example right now my internet goes out.
I'm not gonna panic, I'm gonna go have lunch.
It's gonna be very nice,
rather than sitting here being hungry.
The point is that Shakespeare said,
how did Shakespeare say it?
Things are neither good nor bad.
Life is what we make it, or something like that.
Epictetus has said that.
It goes all the way back, all the way forward
to Ellen Langer, that. It goes all the way back, all the way forward to Ellen Langer.
That the way we understand the world determines how we respond to it. The more mindful we are,
the more choices we have as to how to understand it. I'll give your listeners something. I have
these one-liners and some of my friends find them very useful, put them on their refrigerator. So
next time you're stressed, ask yourself,
is it a tragedy or an inconvenience? It's almost never a tragedy. Oh my god, the dog ate my homer,
I banged the car, I burned the dinner, I missed the... you know, so what? And then you immediately
become calmer. But the larger point is that stress hurts us physically and stress is psychological.
Now, here's where I differ from many people out there,
but if we're around in 50 years,
we can see if I'm right.
I wanted to do this research right before COVID,
but I didn't get around to it.
That if we took 500 people who were just told they have cancer,
vary the cancer, it doesn't matter either, nobody is going to be happy with
a diagnosis like that. So let's give people three weeks to deal with it, to
come to some terms with it. Now if we measure their level of stress every
three weeks or every month, I believe, I don't have data yet, I believe that that level of stress
will predict the course of the disease over and above genetics, over and above nutrition,
and dare I say over and above treatment. That's how important stress is. Well, if stress is
really this killer that I'm suggesting and we can control our stress by being more mindful,
that's a tool we don't want to pass up.
Let me tell you something else. The way the book starts, because this book, The Mindful Body,
was at first going to be a memoir. So there are lots of personal stories, some sexy stories like
my interactions with Hell's Angels, but you'll have to read it to find out about that one.
I have two pancreas stories, which I'm very proud of, because I don't know anybody who
has two stories about the pancreas.
All right.
So I was married, secretly married, when I was very young.
So I was 19 going on 30.
We went to Paris on our honeymoon, and we go into this restaurant, and I ordered the
mixed grill, and on the mixed grill is pancreas. Well, I don't know if I can get myself to eat it, but I think now I'm a
married woman I have to eat it. It doesn't follow logically, but in the mind
of a young girl it made sense. Alright, so I asked my then husband, which of these
is the pancreas? He points to something. I eat everything else with gusto. Now the moment of decision. Can I get myself to eat that pancreas? And I start eating it
and I literally get sick. He starts laughing. I say, why are you laughing? So
inappropriate, right? And he said, because that's chicken. You ate the pancreas a
long time ago. So I made myself sick. The other pancreas story is my mother had
breast cancer. The cancer had metastasized to her pancreas. Well, as you know, that's the end game,
right? And then magically it was totally gone. The medical world couldn't explain it. And I was going
to spend the next several decades to see if I could. And the mind-body unity goes a long way in that regard.
Now, spontaneous remissions, the medical world doesn't tell you,
you know, you think you're in some ways giving people false hope, but you can't know.
The example that I'm fond of using, I'm in the hospital and I'm dying,
and I decide I want to die in my own bed. I'm not attached to my own bed,
but a lot of people seem to be.
So you go home and let's say you're spontaneously okay,
and you go through a spontaneous remission, the cancer is gone.
I don't think people would say,
gee, I have to call my doctor to say he was wrong or she was wrong.
So there are all of these spontaneous remissions that are not recorded.
There are people who don't go to the hospital in the first place, who don't know they have
tumors.
The tumor is there, the tumor is gone.
We don't know how frequent or infrequent this is.
But I think that, you know, the medical world, and I have great respect, you know, I teach
these students before they end up going to medical school. They're very smart and caring, but there's information that they're taught, that they
give to people, that in some sense they have no right to give anybody.
You cannot, no matter who you're with, no matter what their condition is, you cannot
say to them things like, you have three months to live.
Or the more mindful doctor might say you have three months to live or you know the more
mindful doctor might say you have three to six months they have no way of
knowing but often these diagnoses become self-fulfilling prophecies now to go
back to chronic illnesses so people believe a chronic illness is nothing
they can do about it there's so much you can do about it. I've already said now several times that actively noticing the neurons are firing and that seems to be very good
for our health. Most people, I think when given this terrible diagnosis turn inward, close out
everything, start to shut down. Instead, what they need to do is increase their mindfulness. Now you have people
who believe exercise is good for you. This is why, Dan. Exercise is good for you, but
they're stuck in bed. Well, out of other people's labs, there's evidence that imagined exercise
is virtually as good as real exercise. And it comes from many labs around the country,
around the world.
Our minds are just so powerful and we don't recognize it
because we're taught very differently.
We're taught, oh, normal distributions, you know,
whatever the dimension, some people don't have any,
most of us have a middle and some have a lot.
It doesn't matter what that is, talent, beauty, money, no matter what. There are so many questions we could ask
that argue against that normal distribution. Ways that I can find myself
to be a winner even though all those measures that other people derive led me
to fail. I'm throwing a lot at you and I also don't know where to go because I'm very
excited as you can see. It's like I want to tell everybody everything and I guess I should say if
if they care about any of this and they read the book they'll find many of the things that
I would have liked to tell them now. Coming up Ellen talks about how to operationalize the wisdom
from her famous counterclockwise
study, why the world would be boring if you knew it all, and what she means by a mindful
utopia.
One thing that's coming up in my mind as I listen to you talk is how we frame getting
older in our minds. I'm 53 and sometimes I can find myself looking
in the mirror at the wrong moment and telling myself some whole story about how I'm getting old,
I'm going gray, everything's over. I have this suspicion that that is a very unhealthy line of
thought to follow. It is because it becomes self-fulfilling. If when you're younger, you're
told when you get older, you're going to fall apart,
then you get older and you start to fall apart. You say, well, what do you expect? And you don't do anything about it.
It's interesting because so many people worry about getting dementia.
So as soon as they forget something, not at your age, but at my age, I'm 77. So you're a baby, right?
Now all of my friends, somebody forgets something,
everybody starts looking, are they losing it? And I do this thing with my classes.
I teach this health class on Tuesday and Thursday, and on Thursday before I give a
lecture on aging, I'll ask them, what was the last thing I said on Tuesday? Nobody
remembers. So they're 20 years old, they don't remember,
but the not remembering doesn't mean they're falling apart.
It just means they didn't remember.
There are lots of reasons why you think
that you're not remembering that have nothing to do
with anything important.
To me, the most salient is if you were to introduce me
to three important people
when I was 40 years old, I would have learned their names, known something about
them. If you introduce me to three important people today, Dan, frankly, I
don't care. So I'm not going to learn their names. Now, ten minutes later, when
I don't know their names, I didn't forget them, right?
You have to have learned something in the first place to forget it in the second place.
So as you get older, your values change, you take in different information.
So there are many possible reasons for not remembering.
Also, you know, when you're younger, let's say you're working or you're in school, you're
that young, everybody is talking about the party next week and their flyers up and whatever.
Or now you're 75 and you're invited to the department party because they want you to
feel cared for.
So you get one invitation and that's it, no reminders.
So that person is going to forget the party is next week. If you forgot,
Jane is going to say to you, Danny, you're going to the party, and then you'll remember. So lives are very different,
and I think the best thing is to see yourself as changing rather than
deteriorating. To me, there are so many ways where we just get better and better. And that doesn't mean that when I'm playing tennis,
I'm slower than I was before, but I'm also wiser.
I don't have to run around as much
because I have a better sense of where that ball is going
to arrive based on your position when you're hitting that.
I talked about when I was 19, at that point in my life,
if I spilled something on this white shirt, like a fool,
I'd walk around like this all day so no one would see it.
Which is really bizarre to me because it's like I didn't realize people could think I'm
strange.
Strange but clean versus that I have this spaghetti sauce on me.
Then you get older and who cares?
People who know me know that I'm usually wearing clean clothes.
People who don't know me, why do I care?
The older you get, the more times you experience the same sort of thing,
and you see it goes different ways each time.
You become less certain about consequences.
You get to choose more.
You know, when you're two years old and you fall,
you scream bloody murder that you have a
raspberry as it's called. And you're seven years old and Johnny or Janey didn't send you a
valentine. Oh my God, nobody's going to love me. You're 15 years old and you have a couple of
pimples. You get to a certain point in your 40s where all of this starts to feel silly.
So for me, there's a very real way where it gets better and better.
And it does for other people, although I don't think they either realize it or are willing
to admit it. When I did the counterclockwise study, so here I'm going to make people younger.
I don't think they would let themselves fully go back in time. I don't want to be 40 or 50 again, or even 60.
The more mindful you are, the more you're getting out
of every day you're living.
I wouldn't want to give that up,
although surely I would like to have maybe the strength,
what have you, that I had before.
But we need to see growth in late adulthood
rather than focus on the ways we are missing things.
And for things not to be a self-fulfilling prophecy.
You brought back up the counter-clockwise study.
Yeah.
Given that we're talking about aging, and I know I brought it up again as somebody who's 53 and thinking about it involuntarily sometimes,
how could I operationalize some of the wisdom from counterclockwise into my life now?
Sure, sure. I'm not suggesting, although it might be a fun thing.
If people go to their reunions and listen to songs from the past,
all of that could have a positive effect.
But I didn't do the study to suggest that people should
rearrange their houses to seem like the past or whatever.
It was done basically to show the amount of control
we have over these things.
That you think you can't, well, I have study after study
that shows people like you can.
And there's something else with that
that people don't realize.
People think they want to always be successful and they need to rethink that.
So let's say I'm playing golf.
I get so good, Dan, every time I swing the club I get a hole in one.
There's no game anymore.
So you can either do things imperfectly mindfully or perfectly mindlessly.
And when it's mindless, it's essentially a non-event.
So the challenge is the little setbacks, those are actually good things.
If you want to win all the time, go play tic-tac-toe against a four-year-old, six-year-old.
We don't really want that. We like the challenge.
What we need to do though is not make the attribution
that the momentary failure means somehow we're less than
in some ultimate sense.
Right now, the world is set up vertically.
People, bad, can't do anything.
And then you have those at the top who pretend
and lead everybody to believe that they belong there
and nobody else should be there. And I want to take this vertical and make it horizontal. So I wrote this little song from
my grandkids. It was actually effective. It goes to the tune of the old Sarah Lee commercial,
which you may be too young for. Sarah Lee is everybody doesn't like something but nobody
doesn't like Sarah Lee. So this is everybody doesn't know something but everybody knows something else.
Everybody can't do something but everyone can do something else. I was so pleased. I'm driving in
the car with them, twins. They were I think six at the time. They're nine now. One of them starts to
whistle. I say Theo you're such a good whistler. And the other one, Emmett, then says, Grandma L,
when Theo was learning to whistle,
I was learning something else.
It's wonderful because rather than feel bad
about what he can't do, rather than try to diminish
the person who can do it, and this is the way
most of us live, right?
We're worried you're better than I am.
I either feel bad about myself or I try to take you down and so on and
the whole world has been
Constructed in a way. I think that spreads on happiness and it needn't be
It seems like what your grandson was demonstrating was what you said earlier, which is the posture of being
Confident but uncertain.
Yeah, yeah, which is fine not to know because again, if you knew it all, it'd be boring.
Remember you're a little kid and you're in the elevator and you try to reach for that
button and you're not tall enough, a parent picks you up and then you press it, okay.
Now you're a little tall, you still can't reach it.
So it's fun, you can't wait to get in the next elevator to see if you've grown.
Then you're tall enough, you press the button, it's over.
When was the last time you were excited about being able to press the button in an elevator?
So it's the going from not knowing to knowing that's fun.
And the problem is that too often we go from not knowing to thinking that we know and
then freeze that.
Horses don't eat meat, one in one is two.
You have three months to live and what have you.
Back to counterclockwise, one thing that came up in my mind is, while I'm not going to reconstruct
my 1989, the year of my senior year in high school in my house and try to live that way, but to be friends with younger people,
to make sure my life is filled with novelty.
Yeah, or you can fill your life with older people
and see yourself as the baby, you know?
Yes, yes.
Right?
If you spend time with me and my friends,
you're gonna feel, since you're so much younger,
you're gonna feel good.
But I think that the better way is to recognize
that our age is just a number.
It doesn't dictate how we have to be
or should be in this world.
We have too many things where we make an age appropriate.
And one of the titles I almost used for the book
was Who Says So?
Because there are so many rules that to me make no sense.
When I'm giving talks on this, sometimes then,
I'll look in the audience to see if there's a tall man,
tall person, it's usually a man.
I invite him to the stage.
He's 6'5", I'm 5'3".
He looks silly, right?
I'll ask him to put his hand up.
His hand is three inches larger than mine.
And then I just raised the question,
should we do anything physical the same way?
Now, if he wrote the rules to how you do it,
and I play by those rules, I'm never gonna do it
as well as I might otherwise be able to.
The whole world,
everything that is, was at one point a decision. And a decision means there was
some uncertainty. And that means it could have been other. And most of us just take
everything as it is. Let me give you an example. There's a silly example, but it
comes to mind. A friend of mine had created the first gay pride parade in Boston.
So on the blackboard I'll put, here's the route the parade took.
Still takes.
And I'll ask them why.
Harvard kids, smartest can be, they say, maximum viewing, maximum safety, maximum this, minimum
that.
And the answer was she was down here and she had to go to her friend's house up here and deliver a package. All right so every time we take
what is and we find good reasons for it we sort of more or less lock ourselves
in there may be better ways. You know I'm a tennis player the rules of tennis were
not handed down from the heavens so the fact that there are two serves, somebody decided two serves.
Well, if you're going to play with me, Dan, we're going to have three serves.
Because the first serve, I kill it, it doesn't go in.
Now, in the regular game, the next serve is a wuss serve,
because I'm playing doubles and I don't want to upset everybody by double folding, right?
But if I rule the world, you have three serves.
I kill it, it doesn't go in.
I kill it again, now I'm getting better.
And I still have the backup third serve.
So this doesn't mean we have to change the rules
to everything, but people need to know
that some of the things they see as their incompetence
is not because they're incompetent,
it's because they differ in some way from whoever
created the activity.
Somebody who is too big for a chair is not big, it's just they're bigger than the person
who created the size of that chair thought they should be.
If you're an American and you go to Vietnam, you're going to see yourself as very big because
those chairs are very small, and so on.
The bottom line to all of this is that everything is mutable.
Everything can be changed.
Now, as long as it's working for you, do it.
But when it stops working for you,
rather than make the personal attributions
to your own incompetence, or an attribution to there's
no way you can help yourself physically
with your health and so on, you need to rethink those things.
And I have a massive amount of data from our lab, from other people's lab that make me
feel comfortable in making this statement.
Yeah.
You talk in the book about a mindful utopia.
What do you mean by that?
Okay.
So I have a slide when I give some of these talks, used to at least, where it says that
virtually all of our problems, personal, professional, interpersonal, global, are the direct or indirect
result of our mindlessness? I say
virtual and it's on the slide because I don't feel comfortable writing all in
an academic, but then I tell everybody just among us and the other millions of
people, I believe all of our problems and that means that if we could teach people
which I think we can easily actually, to be more mindful
right from the start, we'll end up in a very different world. We'll end up in the world
where you can whistle and I can't and I can do this other thing that you can't and isn't
that glorious? I'm not better than you are, I'm not worse than you are, resources that
we're fighting over are not really limited, the things that we
care about.
It's interesting to me, we have a world where people struggle to get status, to get money,
and towards what end?
It's just really so that they'll respect themselves and like themselves, and there's a whole other
way of getting there.
And so the things that really matter in life are available to all of us,
but not the way we've all been educated. And it's interesting to me when we give grades in school,
so the kids who fail or get Ds, these kids never end up feeling good about themselves. The kids who
get the Bs and the Cs, so they're told they're average. Who wants to be average? But the fun
thing is for me to think about is those of us who got the A's don so they're told they're average. Who wants to be average? But the fun thing is, for me to think about,
is those of us who got the A's don't like it anymore either
because everybody expects that you're going to get A's
and you're not sure why you got it
or whether you'll get it again.
And all of it denies the knowledge,
the personal knowledge, the skills
that all of these people have.
I won this Genius Award then, and it was great,
but I can't tell you, every time I do something stupid,
somebody around me says,
and you're supposed to be a genius?
No.
I think it should all be different.
There should be a way for all of us to value who we are.
And I think some of the differences are exaggerated.
I think we're more alike, each of us to each other,
than most people think.
If you felt what I felt, you'd do what I did.
If you thought what I thought, you'd respond the way I did.
So you and I both have our hand on a radiator, and it's hot.
I take my hand off right away, you keep yours on.
The world now says, Dan, you can endure pain.
You're just, you know, you're best.
You're really high on this dimension, Ellen.
You're a weakling.
But what I'm saying now is if you felt what I felt
when I took my hand away,
you would have taken your hand away also.
I think that the world needs to be reorganized
from the ground up.
So we have ways of changing schools, simply things like teach conditionally,
not one-in-one is two.
Because if you teach kids one-in-one is two and then you say to a next class,
how much is one-in-one, and Danny says one, the teacher disparages you,
then all the kids look at you as if you're stupid
and it's very hard to ever shake that off.
In this mindful school, the teacher would say, Danny, how did you come to that?
And you'd say one wad of chewing gum plus one wad of chewing gum and so on.
Things need to be taught conditionally.
When you ask somebody a question, we should be looking for multiple answers to the question,
not just a single answer.
So many ways, and I outline this and would like to put up mindful schools, mindful hospitals.
If you think about it, I don't know about you, but I don't know anybody when they're
ill who goes to a hospital that doesn't feel stressed as soon as they walk through the
door.
Now, this is supposed to be a place that's going to heal you.
And then everybody is wearing uniforms that says, I'm not you.
It needs to be changed in ways that are not that hard.
And I'm actually beginning some of this in Canada, the people I've spoken to,
not yet wanted to start with a whole mindful hospital.
I said, let's make a mindful cancer ward and in a mindful emergency room.
But in Mexico, we are talking about
starting from the ground up, rebuilding the whole thing.
You know, so I think that the world as I see it
can be a very different place.
And the more people who are mindful,
the quicker we'll get to that better place.
And there's also this part
of the book, you know, I had a whole chapter that I called the woo-woo chapter.
This is worse than your snake oil salesman. This is stuff that's so hard to
believe, but it was real. And I let the publishers talk me out of putting all of
it in print, but I did save some of it. And what we find is that mindfulness is contagious.
Now there's a way the contagion is easy to accept because if you, by virtue of your meditation, Dan,
or because you become a Langerian, a not judgmental, I can feel that.
And so interacting with you is going to be fun and I'm going to be more mindful myself.
But the mindful contagion that we've found, it needs to be replicated. It's just bizarre.
Okay, so if you give somebody a common phrase, let's say, Mary had a little lamb.
And let's say, it's on an index card. It says, Mary had a little lamb.
People don't see the double A. They just don't see it.
Now, if you're next to somebody who is mindful,
you will see it.
Their mindfulness somehow affects you.
It's interesting.
I just realized the importance of all of this in many ways relies on people understanding
just how mindless they are.
And I say again, almost all of us are mindless, but when you're not there, you don't know
it.
So there's this wonderful study that Simon and Chabris did where people are watching
a basketball game with different instructions.
In the middle of the game, a person dressed in a gorilla suit
walks on the court. People do not see it. And when if you were in a study like
that and you saw that you didn't see it, then all of a sudden you realize
you're not seeing, you're not tasting, you're not hearing
lots of what the world provides for you. But when we had people be mindful and we
said to them, you know, all basketball games are like all basketball games or
else we wouldn't call them basketball games. But just as certainly, each
basketball game is different from each basketball game. What I want you to do
when you watch this video is notice the ways it's the same as most basketball
games and also notice the ways it's different. as most basketball games, and also notice the ways it's different.
And that's going to keep you mindful.
And when we do that, people tend to see the gorilla.
With studies like this, it becomes clear to me
that it's not really that hard,
big a change to go from where most people are now
to where they could be for their own health and wellbeing.
That's so fascinating. You called it woo woo.
But actually the contagion makes complete sense to me.
Just in my own life of being around people who are awake and engaged and curious and open.
You mirror that in your own mind naturally.
But before I let you go, Ellen, for those of us who are interested in becoming Langerians ourselves
Can you remind us of the name of your new book and also anything else you've put out that you'd like us to know about?
The name of the new book is the mindful body thinking our way to chronic health
It's funny Dan for all of my books and translated in many languages
There seems to always be an American version and an English version.
Yes.
Not very many differences,
but the English version is the mindful body
thinking our way to lasting health,
because they didn't think people could wrap their minds
about chronic health,
because chronic always means bad.
And that's why I chose it to, at any rate.
That's the name of the new book.
And I've written many books that people can check out
on my website, ellenlanger.me, or just Google my name.
Such a pleasure to talk to you, Ellen.
Thank you so much.
It was fun.
Thanks for having me, Dan.
Thanks again to Ellen Langer.
Great to talk to her.
I'm gonna drop in the show notes some links to episodes
that hit on similar themes.
We've got one from Dr. Dilip Jeste
about how to get the wisdom of old age right now.
Plus, I'm going to drop an episode
with the legendary meditation teacher John Kabat-Zinn,
where we talk about pain versus suffering.
Before I go, I want to thank everybody who worked so incredibly hard to make this show happen.
Our producers are Tara Anderson, Caroline Keenan, and Eleanor Vasili.
Our recording and engineering is handled by the great folks over at Pod People.
Lauren Smith is our production manager. Marissa Schneiderman is our senior producer.
DJ Cashmere is our managing producer. and Nick Thorburn of the band Islands,
ROTAR theme.
If you like 10% happier, and I hope you do, you can listen early and ad free right now
by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple podcasts. Prime members can listen
ad free on Amazon Music.
Before you go, tell us about yourself
by filling out a short survey at Wondry.com slash survey.