The Daily - The Life and Legacy of Jimmy Carter

Episode Date: December 30, 2024

In 1976, after the Watergate scandal and the country’s withdrawal from the Vietnam War, American voters elected Jimmy Carter, a Washington outsider who had served one term as governor of Georgia, to... the presidency. Mr. Carter brought a new humility to the Oval Office but, by 1980, many Americans had tired of his modest sensibility and chose not to re-elect him. As it would turn out, the qualities that hurt Mr. Carter in the White House formed the foundation of a post-presidential period that helped redefine, and redeem, his legacy in the final decades of his life.Peter Baker, chief White House correspondent for The New York Times, explains the life, death and legacy of former President Jimmy Carter.Background reading: Read an obituary of Jimmy Carter, whose post-presidency was seen as a model for future commanders in chief.Mr. Carter defied the unwritten rule of former presidents: Don’t criticize the occupant of the Oval Office.In a never-before-seen interview with The Times, in 2006, Mr. Carter reflected on his life and work as a leader during the Cold War, a Middle East peace broker and his post-presidential career as a citizen diplomat.For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily.  Unlock full access to New York Times podcasts and explore everything from politics to pop culture. Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 From New York Times, I'm Michael Bobarro. This is The Daily. Today, the presidency of Jimmy Carter, who died at the age of 99, has become synonymous with failure. But as my colleague, Peter Baker, explains, the very qualities that hurt Carter as president were the foundation of a post-presidency that both redeemed and rewrote his legacy. It's Monday, December 30th. Peter, you are a White House reporter who has covered the last five presidents.
Starting point is 00:00:55 You're also a historian of the presidency itself. And in those roles, I'm curious how you've been thinking about the life and now the death of Jimmy Carter. Yeah, it's really interesting, Michael, because I've spent the last few years writing Jimmy Carter's obituary, and I know that sounds a little weird, but that's something we do at the newspaper, right?
Starting point is 00:01:15 To be prepared for these big moments. And researching and reflecting on his legacy, I've concluded that it's really hard to imagine anybody like Jimmy Carter ever being elected president again. I mean, he was a very unusual man and it was a very unusual presidency. Well, talk about that.
Starting point is 00:01:33 This unusual man and his unusual presidency. And what in your mind is the first chapter of that story that we should understand? Right, well, first of all, we should know that Jimmy Carter, it's the American story in the sense of our mythology, how we believe in ourselves. He comes from very humble beginnings in rural Georgia, you know, as a peanut farmer. He wore blue jeans and had dirty fingernails. You know, his childhood home had no running water or electricity.
Starting point is 00:02:02 And he was openly religious. He talked about the Bible a lot. He liked to quote verses from it. By the time he's running for president of the United States, he'd basically been a one-term governor with no connections to Washington. And that meant that he was running a campaign as an outsider. I see an America poised,
Starting point is 00:02:22 not only at the beginning of a new century. Now, I mean, today that's kind of a cliche, right? A lot of people run for president these days as an outsider, but he really was an outsider in every possible sense of that word. It defined his identity and it defined his campaign and ultimately would define his presidency. I see an America that is turned away from scandals and corruption. I see an American president who governs with vigor
Starting point is 00:02:47 and with vision and affirmative leadership. And he was the man that was right for that moment, it felt like, because the country was hungry for an outsider. This is my vision of America. I hope you share it. You know, in 1976, when he was running for president, you know, America had been through these multiple traumas.
Starting point is 00:03:06 The war in Vietnam, which killed over 50,000 American troops and divided the nation, and the angry and often violent reactions to the civil rights movement, and you had Watergate, the scandal that forced a president to resign for the first time. Things that really sort of tore apart our society in a lot of ways as we struggle with who we were and what we wanted to be.
Starting point is 00:03:28 And so Carter shows up at this particular moment is kind of a theoretically, at least an antidote to some of that. And he tells the country, I'll never tell a lie. I'll never make a misleading statement. I will never lie to you at a moment when that really matters and unlike a lot of politicians people really thought he may have meant it. He
Starting point is 00:03:51 might have actually been telling the truth about telling the truth. He might have actually been telling the truth. Now it's really hard for politicians to not lie ever but he was committed to that. ABC News presents political spirit of 76. And that does it. ABC now projects Carter is the winner with 272 electoral votes. And he wins the election. By our projection, James Earl Carter, the next president of the United States. He beats an incumbent president, Gerald Ford, who was Nixon's former vice president, and in many ways the final shadow of the Watergate era.
Starting point is 00:04:31 And pretty much from the get-go, Carter begins redefining the presidency as an institution. You know, he banned the playing of Hail to the Chief when he walked in the room. He sold the presidential yacht called the Sequoia. He carried his own bags onto Air Force One when he traveled. Good evening. Tomorrow will be two weeks since I became president. He gave these fireside chats once, most famously, of course, in a cardigan sweater, very casual looking from the White House,
Starting point is 00:05:01 something we were not used to in a president. I'll report to you from time to time about our government, both our problems and our achievements. He was really trying to be something different than we had seen in the White House before. Right, a kind of president who in some ways is unpresidential, like a president who despite holding the most powerful office in the country, is constantly projecting humility. Exactly. And in the process demystifying, in a way, the presidency. But in some ways that doesn't go over well.
Starting point is 00:05:35 You know, he brings this Georgian style to Washington, but he also brings this small coterie of Georgia advisors to Washington who didn't know the place very well, didn't know Congress, didn't know how it worked, didn't know national politics, and didn't seem to want to adjust to it. Certainly he didn't. And so even though Carter has this really powerfully strong Democratic majority in Congress, he ends up misplaying his relationship with them from the get-go.
Starting point is 00:06:02 How so? Well, one of the very first things he does is he attacks a ritual that lawmakers really love, bipartisan, by the way, local water projects. These are pork barrel spending things that allow them to go home to their constituents and say, I built this and I built that. And he basically tried to pull the plug on them.
Starting point is 00:06:20 And he just refused to curry favor with lawmakers. He didn't schmooze or dine with them. He wasn't like an LBJ or a FDR. It just didn't, it wasn't his style of governance. One time the Speaker of the House, Tip O'Neill, shows up at the White House for a breakfast with the Congressional leadership with Carter and all there are are pastries
Starting point is 00:06:40 and he's mad that there's not a hot breakfast. Small as that is, he feels like he's disrespected. And that's the kind of thing Carter disdains. He disdains that sort of what he thinks is kind of a pomposity of Washington. Why should I have to serve you a hot breakfast because you're so full of it? And instead of adjusting, right,
Starting point is 00:06:59 another politician would simply adjust, serve him some breakfast, serve him some eggs, whatever. He stands on principle. And what we learn about Carter here is he's actually very stubborn, really stubborn as a George Amule, if you will. And he's very certain of his own rectitude. As the guy who's the outsider,
Starting point is 00:07:16 he has the mandate, he believes, to shake up Washington. And that's all well and good, but it means he's not playing the game, and the game players don't want to help him Get his agenda through and there's a cost to that stubbornness. Hmm and The problem began to mount and they were the problems of his own creation and the problems that were not of his own creation OPEC the organization of oil producing countries, which has thrown the industrial world into grave turmoil. Inflation starts rising because of an oil crisis
Starting point is 00:07:48 in the Middle East. The prices in many San Diego stations have gone up 12 cents a gallon since last summer. Gas prices skyrocket. This gas line at one station on the Upper West Side ran from 96th Street and West End Avenue all the way up to 102nd Street. Shortages mean that you can't fill your tank on any given day.
Starting point is 00:08:07 Lines stretch out around the block at gas stations. Nightmareous scenes on the evening news. Isn't this disgusting? Why doesn't anybody contact the president? Why is he letting this happen to us? And Carter responds by giving out a series of energy speeches. All of us must learn to waste less energy. Basically telling people how they can conserve energy. We simply must balance our demand for energy with our rapidly shrinking resources.
Starting point is 00:08:36 Small sacrifices they can make. If we learn to live thriftily and remember the importance of helping our neighbors, then we can find ways to adjust. Ways that can be more responsible. Mr. President, recent polls show that job rating is dropping and continues to drop. And people are just not hearing it. His approval ratings are tanking.
Starting point is 00:08:57 ... So he knows his presidency isn't going smoothly and he's talking about giving another energy speech and everybody says, not another energy speech. Even Rosalind, his wife says, nobody wants to hear you give another energy speech. They just wanna know that you're gonna fix the problem. And it really causes him to think through
Starting point is 00:09:20 what's going on here. And his advisor, Pat Cadell says, you need to talk about where the country is. The country is having a crisis of confidence. And Carter takes that to heart. He goes up to Camp David and he basically retreats from the world for about 10 days. He won't come back out of Camp David
Starting point is 00:09:35 while he's thinking through what he wants to do, what he wants to say to the country. And he brings dozens of people in and out of this mountain retreat through the course of more than a week. Jesse Jackson shows up, Bill Clinton shows up. He was the governor of Arkansas at the time to give them their ideas of what they think
Starting point is 00:09:52 is going on in the country. And there's Jimmy Carter in the lodge at Camp Davis, sitting on the floor, taking notes as people are giving him their ideas. And he's crafting this speech he wants to give to the country, he's crafting this this speech he wants to give to the country. He's crafting this address. He wants to connect to the country and address their shared issues. And so he comes down off the mountain at last and he tells his staff, I'm ready to speak
Starting point is 00:10:15 to the country. I think it's time. And they arranged with the networks to have him get an address from the Oval Office. He puts on the suit and he sits at the desk, the Resolute Desk, in the summer of 1979. Good evening. This is a special night for me. And for 30 minutes, he tells the country what he thinks is going wrong. It's clear that the true problems of our nation
Starting point is 00:10:44 are much deeper. Deeper than gasoline lines or energy shortages. Deeper, even, than inflation or recession. And he delivers this very risky speech. The kind of speech you never hear from a president. It's a president who in a very bracing and blunt way is telling the country to get his act together. He's diagnosing a larger problem with the American public, not just politics. Human identity is no longer defined by what one does, but by what one owns.
Starting point is 00:11:35 He talks about the notion that we worship self-indulgence and consumption. This is a very, much of a preacher's speech in some ways rather than a president's speech. And these wounds he's talking about are very deep. And he's also talking about himself in a way that presidents generally don't do. I want to share with you what I've heard. First of all, I got a lot of personal advice. Let me quote a few of the typical comments
Starting point is 00:12:04 that I wrote down. Very self-critical. You're not leading this nation. You're just managing the government. He quotes some of the people who come through Camp David telling him how he's getting it wrong, how he's not doing it right. You don't see the people enough anymore. He's not doing it right. And it's this remarkable self critique that I think in some ways really actually resonates at first with the audience that they've never heard a
Starting point is 00:12:34 president open up like this and admit that he isn't leading to his own satisfaction, that he's willing to accept that his presidency is not going the way he wants it to be. Working together with our common faith, we cannot fail. Thank you and good night. Imagine a modern president doing that today. Right, I really can't. But it very much seems to reflect that campaign promise, Peter, that Jimmy Carter would never
Starting point is 00:13:13 lie to the American people. In some ways, this is a rather extraordinary dose of truth. It is exactly right. He is the truth teller in this instance. In his view, he is being very honest with the American public about how he sees the problems of the country and it goes over Well at first because it is so unusual because it is so refreshing in its own way It was sort of celebrated for its candor and you know at first people think he has actually broken through but then he does something to undermine the
Starting point is 00:13:47 whole purpose of it. Which is what? He fires his whole cabinet. He fires his whole cabinet? Yeah, he asked for all of the resignations, all of them. He ends up keeping most of them, but he ends up using it as a way of cleaning out a few of them. And it sends a statement that he may not have intended to the country. It may have been meant as a cleansing idea, a fresh start,
Starting point is 00:14:08 but it actually caused a lot of Americans to doubt his judgment. They don't think he knows what he's doing. And even his own vice president, Walter Mondale, was so upset about this that he started contemplating whether he was gonna stay on the ticket or maybe even resign as vice president. He thought this was such a hand-handed,
Starting point is 00:14:25 badly handled move. It was amateurish in his mind. So this reset that Jimmy Carter has attempted to undertake with those meetings at Camp David, with this speech, with this theoretical cleansing of his cabinet, it is all very much seeming to backfire. Yes, and after all that drama, that self-critical speech that he delivered
Starting point is 00:14:48 that so many people originally connected with suddenly looked different through a different lens. People will start to see the speech as a sign of weakness. And it becomes known as the Malay speech, even though he never even uses the word Malay is in it. But it's a marker at this point for his presidency. For years to come, people would remember that speech as an example of somebody who couldn't lead. Right, and the reason it's called the Malay speech is not just because it was
Starting point is 00:15:17 about American Malays, because it seemed to embody Jimmy Carter's Malays as president, right? Right. He had alienated his own party, and when it came to the domestic side of his presidency, he was being seen as a disappointment. But what was making him unsuccessful at home, his outsidersness, his stubbornness,
Starting point is 00:15:38 his image of himself as this unvarnished truth teller, all of that helps him make a success in one particularly intractable problem overseas. We'll be right back. Peter, after all these domestic stumbles, tell us about this success that Carter has overseas. So, amid all these troubles at home, Carter decides he's going to try to do something
Starting point is 00:16:14 that no president had ever done before, which is to resolve one of the biggest conflicts in the Middle East at that time between these two long-time enemies, Israel and Egypt. I mean, people may not remember this now, but Egypt was one of the strongest Arab nations at the time and like the rest of the region, hadn't even accepted Israel's right to exist since it had been established in 1948. And so they basically been at war for 30 years
Starting point is 00:16:39 at this point off and on and it was the core instability of the region. So he wants to dive on in. He believes through this same stubbornness that he is uniquely qualified to bring them together. Good evening. The scene is Camp David, the president's mountain retreat 75 miles northwest of here. The participants... So he invites Menachem Begin, the Prime Minister of Israel, and Anwar El-Sadat, the president of Egypt, to Camp David in September 1978.
Starting point is 00:17:08 How long they'll stay in the mountains and what they'll say when they come down, nobody knows. For what would become 13 days of pretty remarkable negotiations. It's an insanely complex negotiation over land and politics and religion and history. Throughout these 13 days, it's Carter singularly holding the whole thing together, this crazy enterprise that seems like it's going to break down at any moment. He's almost literally physically throwing himself in the door to prevent this side or that side from throwing up their hands and leaving. At one point, you know, the Egyptians packed their bags and singled, they were done
Starting point is 00:17:49 with these talks and it's Carter who has to talk them out of leaving. At another point, he brings photographs of himself to sign for each of Begin's eight grandchildren, which reminds the two of them at that moment what they're doing this for, for the next generation. Carter, he's appealing to anything he can think of to get these two enemies to come together and make peace. When we first arrived at Camp David, the first thing upon which we agreed was to pray that our negotiations would be successful.
Starting point is 00:18:21 Those prayers have been answered far beyond expectations. And it works. They actually reach a deal. One of the most extraordinary moments in the history of diplomacy. Israel and Egypt have agreed to two documents taking a giant step toward achieving peace in their troubled corner of the world. And later it's immortalized in this photo. It's one of the most famous photos of his presidency, probably, of him standing between these two leaders, Begin and Sadat, at a ceremony on the lawn of the White House. And the three of them are holding hands together, and they have these big grins on their faces.
Starting point is 00:18:55 And it feels like such an invigorating, inspiring moment. The Camp David Conference should be renamed. It was the Jimmy Carter conference. And everybody agrees that had it not been for him, it never would have happened. And here we see Carter's stubbornness paying off. He was single-minded in his pursuit. He was the only one there at Camp David who thought he could pull it off. President Carter, for long days and nights,
Starting point is 00:19:33 you devoted your time and energy to the pursuit of peace. Sadat later called him the unknown soldier of the peacemaking effort. And Begin agreed, he says, that Carter would be, quote, remembered and recorded by generations to come. As far as my historic experience is concerned, I think that he worked harder than our forefathers did in Egypt building the pyramids. It is, in fact, this singular accomplishment that is probably the one most lasting, enduring,
Starting point is 00:20:08 and triumphal moment of the Carter presidency. But of course, there's another moment, a final chapter of this presidency that's just as defining as the Camp David Accords and that is remembered for generations to come. So tell us about that. Yeah, just as defining, but not at all triumphant. In fact, this really is the moment that leads to the end of Carter's presidency, and that's the Iran hostage crisis.
Starting point is 00:20:36 Good evening. A tearful shah of Iran left his country today on a vacation from which he may never return. In 1979 in Iran, Muslim clerics lead a revolution that overthrows the leader of the secular government there. That's the Shah of Iran, who'd been a close ally of the United States. And after the Shah was overthrown and left the country, he became sick and needed medical care.
Starting point is 00:21:00 And as a US ally, wanted to come to the United States for help. There was a ton of pressure on Carter to let him in. When you had people like Henry Kissinger and David Rockefeller, they're all pushing Carter, let him in, let him in. It's the right thing to do for an ally. But Carter knew how risky this was, and maybe in a way almost nobody else did. He told his aides that he feared it would lead to violence
Starting point is 00:21:22 against American diplomats in Iran. And why did he fear that? Well, he had seen what had happened in an earlier stage of the uprising that had led to a short-lived siege of the embassy in Tehran. It didn't last long and there were only a few casualties, but he saw the potential for violence there and he realized that if the Shah came,
Starting point is 00:21:42 the United States would be so offensive to this newly ascendant crowd in Tehran that it would put the embassy in danger. But given the pressure on him from the Shah's American allies from within and outside the government, Carter invites him to the U.S. anyway. And just like he predicted, Several hundred young people, mainly students at Tehran University, have taken over the embassy. We are not occupiers, they said.
Starting point is 00:22:07 We have thrown out the occupiers. Militants in Tehran storm the U.S. embassy and hold scores of U.S. government workers there hostage, demanding that the Shah be returned to Iran to stand trial. This morning, for the first time since the hostages were put under lock and key, one of the captives blindfolded was brought out into the open. Yankee go home, they cried, but they made no attempt to harm him. Carter refuses to send the Shah back to Iran
Starting point is 00:22:33 and the militants refused to release these hostages. And it becomes this incredible standoff, really of a generation, an enormous story heard around the world. The special report that we plan to bring you tonight was about domestic politics, but we think the crisis in Iran is more urgent right now than the campaign here at home. It's on round-the-clock TV coverage. Families of the employees are on television pleading for the release.
Starting point is 00:22:57 Americans are tying yellow ribbons around trees in front of their houses. It's an all-consuming story for much of America. 222nd day of captivity. The 285th day of captivity. The 377th day of captivity for American hostages in Iran. Every night, you had the anchors saying, day 138 of the hostage crisis, day 420 of the hostage crisis. under the hostage crisis.
Starting point is 00:23:31 And it really just consumed the country and it consumed Carter's presidency. How does it consume Carter's presidency? Well, you know, he had a choice of putting this to the side or at least making it one issue of many, but instead he chose to cancel speeches out of town, to cancel campaign events. He made this the number one priority of many, but instead he chose to cancel speeches out of town, to cancel campaign events. He made this the number one priority of his presidency. And these same qualities we're talking about, the sort of stubborn single-minded determination that
Starting point is 00:23:54 we saw at Camp David that worked well for him there, really kind of works against him here because he wants to solve this problem and he's going to do nothing but focus on it, no matter what else is happening basically and that becomes in effect The sine qua non test of his presidency if he can solve this then he is successful if he can't solve it It means he's not and he inadvertently creates the the metric by which he's going to be judged What is your understanding of why President Carter would make this hostage crisis? Which of course looks terrible for any president. It's a hostage crisis.
Starting point is 00:24:27 Why does he decide to make it so central to his presidency in this moment? Why not basically put it in the background? He took it very personally. He felt responsible for these diplomats who in fact work for him, right? He's the president of the United States, and they were there in trouble in some ways
Starting point is 00:24:44 because of a decision he made to let the Shah in. So he took it very personally. And it's a little like the Malay speech in the sense that he can't help himself but to communicate that to the public, right? He's communicating what he thinks and feels in a way that most presidents might not. Most presidents might try to focus on other things
Starting point is 00:25:02 so as not to elevate this particular crisis among the many he had to deal with, but that wasn't Carter's way. He always wants to be transparent with the country about what he's thinking, what he's feeling. Right, he wears his worry in a very big public way. He wears his worry in a very big public way, it's a good way to put it,
Starting point is 00:25:18 and therefore the country worries with him. And instead of being able to sort of judge it among the many different priorities that a president has, it becomes the singular focus of not just the president, but the country as a whole. And in effect, what he tries is what he did at Camp David, which is that if he simply puts enough determination into what he feels, he can solve the problem.
Starting point is 00:25:40 So what does Carter do to try to free these hostages and turn this test into a success? He engages on this sort of marathon diplomatic negotiation through intermediaries, other countries, anything he can find to try to, you know, obtain the release of these hostages. That goes nowhere. The Iranians are not willing to budge. They're not willing to make the deal that he wants them to make and and he finds himself frustrated time after time without any great success to show for it. And so five months into the crisis he then finally turns to the military and he says okay it's your turn. And he sends in a mission meant to rescue the hostages from the embassy in the middle of a big urban city. Big challenge, really hard idea.
Starting point is 00:26:32 Late yesterday I canceled a carefully planned operation to position our rescue team for a later withdrawal of American hostages. And that failed. Equipment failure in the rescue helicopters made it necessary to end the mission. Eight of the crewmen of the two aircraft which collided were killed. And several other Americans were hurt in the accident.
Starting point is 00:26:56 They miscalculate the number of helicopters they need, number of American military personnel are killed, and instead of this dramatic rescue of Americans from Tehran, you have this enormous embarrassment on the international stage, a failed military rescue operation that leaves Carter in a worse position than he was even before.
Starting point is 00:27:16 We will seek to continue, along with other nations and with the officials of Iran, a prompt resolution of the crisis without any loss of life and through peaceful and diplomatic means. Thank you very much. Right. And because he is so fixated on this, and as a result, the media is so fixated on this, that failure becomes a kind of political disaster.
Starting point is 00:27:49 It's a complete political disaster. His secretary of state resigns, says he never thought that was a good idea in the first place. People question his effectiveness as a commander in chief. He looks weak and people begin to lose faith in him. And so, you know, the crisis just continued to go on and on for day after day, week after week, month after month. 1979 drags into 1980. And while at first voters were kind of supportive of him because they were rallying around their president in a
Starting point is 00:28:15 time of crisis, as the ordeal goes on and drags on and on, they lose faith in him. He loses support among the public. And of course, unfortunately for Carter, he is up for reelection that same year. Right. He's facing a challenge in the primaries from Ted Kennedy. He beats him back, but then he has to face this charismatic former actor and governor of California, Ronald Reagan. And Reagan is attacking him for failing to end this crisis, basically saying he will be the one to end it if he is elected president. And it just puts Carter on the defensive.
Starting point is 00:28:50 He has a hard time arguing the case of his presidency when he feels so much under siege by the day-to-day diplomacy and this failed military operation. So he runs what is called a Rose Garden campaign, which is to say that he doesn't leave the White House that much to do the traditional stump speeches and rallies and so forth,
Starting point is 00:29:10 because he feels that would be inappropriate with these American diplomats facing life and death in Tehran. And he ends up losing by a wide margin. Reagan ends up winning a pretty substantial landslide and then of course is gonna take office in January of 1981. And I'll never forget that day, because on that day, the inauguration,
Starting point is 00:29:31 Carter is trying up until the last minute to get these hostages out, and he thinks he finally has a deal. Around 6.30 in the morning, they tell him, yes, we've got a deal. The hostages are gonna be released before noon, before you leave office, and he's excited. He calls Reagan to tell him, but Reagan is asleep
Starting point is 00:29:47 and the aides won't wake up the president-elect to tell him. So he's frustrated by that, and he goes with Reagan later in the morning to the Capitol, and even then, the hostages are still on the plane, but the plane hasn't been released yet. It hasn't been allowed to take off. He's watching his watch, he's waiting for the word, nothing happens, and there is Reagan taking the oath allowed to take off. He's watching his watch. He's waiting for the word. Nothing happens.
Starting point is 00:30:05 And there is Reagan taking the oath of office and ending the Carter presidency. Day one of Ronald Reagan's presidency and day one of freedom for 52 Americans. And only at that point... The new president had not been in office an hour when the former hostages became free men and women again. Did the Iranians finally let the plane take off. One last cruel indignity meant to torture Jimmy Carter that he could not release them on his watch. They were released in the first minutes of the Reagan presidency.
Starting point is 00:30:34 The last indignity for a humbled president. Peter, it's almost as if the Iranians, having already contributed to Carter's re-election loss, want to further humiliate him even after that defeat. Well, it definitely felt that way at the time. And Carter certainly felt that way, that they were tormenting him in effect, that they were adding insult to injury.
Starting point is 00:30:57 Look, it's important to remember, there were other factors going on in that election as well, and it's possible Carter would have lost anyway. I mean, there was kind of an exhaustion with him at this point, and Americans were struggling with inflation and unemployment and economic troubles. Reagan famously said in one of the debates, are you better off than you were four years ago?
Starting point is 00:31:16 And a lot of Americans thought the answer was no. And Reagan was this more optimistic figure at a time when the country was looking for it. He was the anti-Malays candidate in a way, right? He talked about America as a shining city on a hill. And he didn't appear in a cardigan. He believed in the grandeur of the office. And so where Carter wanted to make the presidency smaller, more accessible, more approachable,
Starting point is 00:31:42 less pomp and circumstance, Reagan was this Hollywood actor-turned-governor who wanted to bring back kind of black tie swagger to Washington and convince America that it was this exceptional place in the world, which is what a lot of Americans wanted to hear then. It feels complicated though, right, Peter? Because as you explained a little bit earlier, the idea of Jimmy Carter in 1976, when he's first running as an outsider after all these excesses, Watergate in 1976, when he's first running as an outsider, after all these excesses, Watergate in Vietnam, was indisputably alluring, the kind of smaller version of the office.
Starting point is 00:32:15 But then it seems the reality of Jimmy Carter turned out to be less appealing. Yeah, I mean, I think these are attributes that really worked for him in 1976 when there was this Watergate hangover, this Vietnam hangover. They just didn't work for him in 1980 when there was kind of a Carter-Malays, if you will, right? That they didn't serve him as effectively while he was president and running for reelection as they did the first time he asked voters to put him in office in the first place. And he didn't adjust, he didn't adapt.
Starting point is 00:32:43 But when he leaves office, it turns out that it wasn't an act, this was who he was. Well, just explain that. What about his post presidency shows us that this is who Carter was? Well, what distinguishes it is its utter modesty, right? Most presidents after leaving office become rich. They sign multimillion dollar book deals is its utter modesty, right? Most presidents after leaving office become rich.
Starting point is 00:33:05 They sign multimillion dollar book deals or like with President Obama podcasts and TV deals, they give paid speeches and they live a life that resembles the splendor of the office that they had held. But Carter didn't do that. He first literally goes back to Plains, Georgia to the same house, this little ranch house
Starting point is 00:33:25 that he and Rosalynn had lived in since 1961. Modest, very unassuming. At one point, the house, in fact, is worth less than the large Secret Service vehicles that are parked outside of it. And the first thing he does is start teaching Sunday school. Wow.
Starting point is 00:33:42 And when he does finally reappear in the public arena, it's when he opens the Carter Center in 1982, just two years after his defeat in the election. And it's through this nonprofit group that we witness a post presidency of service and civic mindedness that's really unlike anything we've seen in the modern political era. He travels the world, promoting human rights and monitoring elections in emerging democracies, countries like Panama and Nicaragua and Venezuela. Well, we have five minutes to go here on voting.
Starting point is 00:34:14 And at this particular place, the turnout has been 83%, which is quite good. He physically shows up during these elections. He stands at the polls and watches people vote election after election to assure that the process is free and fair. The worm comes out and joins say in your knee. It swells up and destroys a tissue. He starts a program to eradicate Guinea worm, the very painful and debilitating disease in the developing world that in the 1980s affected millions of people. And of
Starting point is 00:34:44 course these kids can't go to school. The pain is too great and they need medical care. And he persuades volunteers in tens of thousands of villages to treat the water where the worms grow. And the Carter Center hands out millions of specialized drinking straws that filter out these worms. And basically Guinea worm is almost gone now as a result of some of the things that he did.
Starting point is 00:35:04 And. And... And now I call upon the Peace Prize laureate of 2002, Jimmy Carter. All this finally, I think, leads to the Nobel Peace Prize that he didn't win while he was in office. Members of a Nobel committee from Norway. It is with a deep sense of gratitude that I accept this prize. And during his acceptance speech,
Starting point is 00:35:31 Carter demonstrates his humility, a genuine humility. The scope and character of our sinners' activities are perhaps unique, but in many other ways they are typical of the work being done by hundreds of non-governmental organizations that strive for human rights and peace. He praises the tireless efforts of other
Starting point is 00:35:50 humanitarian workers. God gives us a capacity for choice. We can choose to alleviate suffering. We can choose to work together for peace. And he urges others to devote themselves to the small humble work that had defined the last several decades of his life. We can make these changes. And we must. Thank you. And you know, it's this service and modesty that he demonstrated that finally, I think in some ways allows him to redeem himself for the failures of the time when he was in office. In fact, a lot of people say Carter was a better former president than he was president. At one point, one of his biographers, Kai Bird, said Carter's the only president ever to use the White House
Starting point is 00:36:47 as a stepping stone to doing bigger things. And it earned Carter a lot of respect, even among Republicans who otherwise didn't particularly like him, and Democrats who were kind of disappointed in him. But certainly I think the way most Americans remember Carter today is the man from Plains, Georgia, who's trying to use his platform of a former president
Starting point is 00:37:08 to achieve things that, in fact, he couldn't do while in office. The modern presidency in some ways requires compromises he wasn't really willing to make and kind of performances that he wasn't maybe capable of. And every successor, everybody who's come after him, has thought about how not to be the kind of president Jimmy Carter was, even as they respect the kind of man
Starting point is 00:37:35 that Jimmy Carter was. And that's why, for good or bad, it feels like we're never going to see someone like Jimmy Carter in the presidency again Peter thank you very much. Thank you. Appreciate it. I Prayed more when I was in the Oval Office at any other time in my life and I prayed more when I was in the Oval Office than any other time in my life. And I never did pray that I would be popular
Starting point is 00:38:08 or that I would be reelected. I prayed that I could keep my country at peace, that I could find peace for others, that I could have patience and an adequate element of wisdom, judgment. Paul said these are the only things that are important, justice, truth, humility, service, compassion, love, those are the things that make a great life.
Starting point is 00:38:35 Over the next week, the body of former President Carter is expected to be taken by motorcade from his home in Plains, Georgia to Atlanta, where he will lie and repose at the Carter Center. After that, he will be flown to Washington, where he will lie in state at the U.S. Capitol, before a formal funeral at the National Cathedral. Per Carter's wishes, he will be interred back in Georgia at a simple family plot. We'll be right back. Here's what else you need to know today. Investigators are trying to determine what caused a South Korean passenger plane to skid
Starting point is 00:39:40 across a runway on Sunday morning and crash into a barrier, killing nearly all 181 people on board. It was one of the deadliest aviation disasters in years. Shortly before the crash, the control tower at the airport warned of a possible bird strike, and soon after, the plane's pilots issued a Mayday. Today's episode was produced by Carlos Prieto and Sydney Harper, with help from Alexandra Lee Young and Will Reed. It was edited by Lisa Chow and Devin Taylor, fact-checked by Susan Lee, contains original music by Marian Lozano, Dan Powell, Rowan Yamisto, and Sophia Landman, and was engineered by Alyssa Moxley.
Starting point is 00:40:35 Our theme music is by Jim Brunberg and Ben Landsferk of Wonderly. That's it for the Daily. I'm Michael Bobarro. See you tomorrow.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.