True Crime with Kendall Rae - Fake Veteran Plots Wife’s Murder With Motorcycle Gang?! The Death of April Kauffman
Episode Date: June 13, 2024April Kauffman was described as part princess, part bulldog… She was beautiful, funny, charismatic, generous, incredibly philanthropic, and would stop at nothing to give back to the causes she belie...ved in. One of the things she believed in most was helping Veterans. Her passion for helping Veterans is what drew her to Jim Kauffman, her third husband. But after 10 years of marriage, she wanted out. After finding out he lied about being a veteran and that he was running an illegal pill mill with a local motorcycle gang, April asked for a divorce. But rather than risk losing half of his net worth, Jim paid someone in that motorcycle gang to murder her. After years of her case going cold, her daughter pushed for justice and ultimately landed those responsible behind bars, thanks, in part, to a member of the gang who snitched. Donate to NCMEC through my campaign! https://give.missingkids.org/campaign... Shop my Merch! https://kendallrae.shop This episode is sponsored by: 3 Day Blinds - For their buy 1 get 1 50% off deal, head to3DayBlinds.com/KENDALLRAE Nutrafol - promo code: KENDALLRAE Rocket Money ZocDoc Check out Kendall's other podcasts: The Sesh & Mile Higher Follow Kendall! YouTube Twitter Instagram Facebook Mile Higher Zoo REQUESTS: General case suggestion form: https://bit.ly/32kwPly Form for people directly related/ close to the victim: https://bit.ly/3KqMZLj Discord: https://discord.com/invite/an4stY9BCN CONTACT: For Business Inquiries - kendall@INFAgency.com
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Hello everyone and welcome back to True Crime with Kendall Rae.
Thank you so much for joining me today and if you're new then welcome.
So happy to have you.
So today guys, I'm going to be telling you about a case that I had personally never heard
of and I was pretty shocked I haven't heard of this one,
but so many of you had requested it
through my case submission form,
which if you didn't know is always linked
in the description box.
And we're gonna be talking about
the murder of April Kaufman.
And the details in this case and how everything unfolded
is, it's so absurd,
it's so upsetting, it's angering,
and it's one that definitely needs to be talked about.
April Kaufman was a literal force to be reckoned with.
She was such a strong and powerful woman.
She was a good-spirited person.
She was compassionate and pathetic.
And what happened to her is so hard to wrap your mind around the circumstances that led
to her murder are so outrageous that it's almost hard to believe.
And the amount of greed and evil involved in this case truly shocked me.
And honestly, with how many cases I've covered, it takes a lot to shock me these days.
There are so many ups and downs, twists and turns. It's really one of those roller coaster cases and there's a lot to shock me these days. There are so many ups and downs, twists and turns.
It's really one of those roller coaster cases and there's a lot to go over. So let's just go ahead
and get into it starting with a background on April and who she was. April Christine Favazza was
born on October 27th, 1964 in Atlantic City, New Jersey, and her childhood was quite rocky.
Her father was mostly absent from her life. and when April was only 11 years old, her
mother placed her other four siblings into foster care, which, you know, can be extremely
difficult.
And April was left with that guilt and sort of heavy burden of being the only child that
her mother decided to continue raising.
And April herself was primarily raised
in her early childhood by her grandmother.
And that's because her mom got involved in a lot of,
how do I put this, toxic and concerning relationships
with men that April should not have been around.
And so luckily her grandmother was able to step in
and take care of her a lot of her childhood.
So to say that she didn't have an easy childhood is really an understatement.
I mean, things were really tough for her a lot of her early years, but I think a lot
of that really built her into who she was.
And when she was 17, her life started kind of turning around.
And that's because when she was 17 years old,
April gave birth to her one and only daughter, Kimberly.
And it was the type of love that she had always longed for.
And because she didn't have that motherly support growing up,
she knew she wanted things to be different for her daughter.
And so she was committed to being the best mother
that she possibly could for Kimberly.
And I really believe that she lived up to that promise and more.
And I know Kimberly would completely agree.
After April dropped out of high school and got her GED, she started working right away
to support them.
And she started her career by training as a hairstylist and eventually went on to open
her own salon as well as a catering business.
And if there's truly one defining characteristic of April,
I would say that she was tenacious. If she had set her mind to something, nothing was going to stop
her. She was determined and hardworking and believed in herself. And I actually read that
a lot of people described her as part princess, part bulldog, which I really loved that. I think that's the perfect way to describe April Kaufman.
And aside from having a great personality
and great characteristics,
April was also a very beautiful person,
but her looks aren't everything that people remembered her by.
She was memorable because she was that type of person
that if she had her mindset on something
or if there was any cause that she was passionate about, then she would stop at nothing until her voice was heard. And a big way
that April would vocalize her passions and belief and share other encouraging words for people out
there listening was through her radio show. April actually hosted a weekly radio show in Atlantic
City and sort of became a local celebrity
there. And she was really known for being passionate about many different causes, but
the biggest one that she advocated for was better treatment of our veterans. This was
something that was super, super important to her. She believed that those who serve
our country deserve to be treated like superheroes. And it was really one of her missions in life
to make a positive difference for anyone who
did.
If you don't vote, I will find out.
I'm going to your house.
I'm dragging you outside.
Homelessness is a big, a big issue in our country right now for our veterans.
She regularly supported charities that focused on veterans' rights and was often chosen
to speak at events where entire audiences were captivated by her words.
In fact, she managed to get close with elected officials
and government leaders in the area
and had plans to affect a lot of positive change.
And April was someone who was really respected
and liked in her personal life,
but also in her professional life as well.
There were many people who looked up to her,
wanted to spend time talking to her.
That's one thing her daughter really said
is people loved talking to April
because she was so interesting and passionate.
You know, that spark that she had
was really inspiring and interesting to people.
She was kind of one of those people
who you talk to even briefly,
even if you had just met her
and you walk away feeling like
she's almost your close friend.
And those who really knew her And those who really knew her,
and those who barely knew her,
just spent some time speaking with her,
said that her passion was genuine,
that they could tell she was the real deal
and really stood by what she said.
And just to give you an example of this,
every Thanksgiving, April would host a dinner at her house
for the recruits from the US Coast Guard Station in Cape May.
So these young men and women who were, you know,
unable to spend Thanksgiving with their friends and family
were welcomed into April's home and treated as her family.
And it was through April's advocacy and charity work
that she ended up meeting Dr. James Kaufman,
who also went by Jim.
And Jim was everything in a man
that April was looking for, at least on paper.
She'd actually been married two times prior.
Those marriages didn't work out obviously,
but Jim seemed to be the total package.
Not only did he tell her that he was a veteran,
specifically a member of the Army Special Forces,
but he also had the same passion for fast cars
and motorcycles that April did.
Which is something I haven't shared about her yet.
April was definitely one of those work hard,
play harder types of people.
She enjoyed the fun in life.
She loved her red Corvette and her motorcycles,
and I imagine she was a bit of an adrenaline junkie.
And so here was Jim who was successful, who was an army veteran and also shared that same
passion for motorcycles.
I mean, Jim really loved motorcycles, which I will get more into.
So it seemed perfect.
So on Valentine's Day in 2003, the two of them got married and quickly became sort of a celebrity
power couple of Linwood, New Jersey.
April was this beautiful radio host known for her charity work and veteran advocacy,
and Jim was a wealthy and well-respected endocrinologist and, of course, like I said, a veteran.
And over the years, Jim would often attend April's veteran advocacy programs and talk
about having completed two tours in Vietnam.
And he also frequently appeared on her radio show, speaking on behalf of veterans.
But it wasn't long before some weird things started to happen with Jim.
And one example is April's daughter Kim actually had to interview a veteran for a school project
and she asked Jim to do it and he agreed
but what was strange is he told her he couldn't tell her mother which made no sense. And in that
interview he told a story about having survived a brutal attack in Vietnam where everyone in his
platoon was killed except for him and he survived by licking water off leaves while he waited to be rescued.
And he also added this part about collecting all the dog tags from the fallen soldiers
to bring home to their families.
Which of course would be wildly heroic and impressive if it were true.
Keyword, if.
And of course I will explain what I mean by that here in a minute. But for the most part, on the outside, everything seemed to be perfect when it came to their lives and their relationships
and the people that they were. But as we all know, oftentimes relationships are not what they seem.
Oftentimes, they are far from perfect, even some of the better relationships out there.
But it didn't take long until close friends and families started
to see the cracks in their relationship, especially April's daughter, Kim. Kim and her mom were
incredibly, incredibly close. I mean, April having her at age 17 really meant that they sort of grew
up together. That's one thing Kim has really talked about is she not only was her mother of course
but she also saw her as her best friend and her sister in a lot of ways and she truly admired her and
They just had a really really special bond. And so of course
Kim was able to learn a lot about the inner workings of
her marriage and her being so close to the relationship meant that she saw a
lot of things that other people didn't and she saw a lot of concerning behavior
from Jim and one of the most concerning behaviors was that he was a very
controlling person and I mean that.
So I am someone who needs to sleep in absolute darkness.
I cannot stand when a little bit of window light is getting in in the morning.
It just instantly wakes me up.
And so I feel like quality blinds are so important.
And if you're looking to upgrade your blind game, look no further than three day blinds.
There's a better way to buy blinds and window treatments.
It's called three day blinds.
They are the leading manufacturer of custom window treatments in the United States.
And right now they are running a buy one get one 50% off deal. We can
shop for almost anything at home so why not shop for blinds at home too. 3-day blinds has local
professionally trained design consultants who have an average of 10 years plus of experience and they
can provide expert guidance on the right blinds for you in the comfort of your own home. Just set
up an appointment and you'll get a free and no obligation quote the same day.
And if you're not very handy, like we are not in our house,
the expert team at 3DayBlinds handles all the heavy lifting.
They design, measure and install so you can sit back,
relax and leave it to the pros.
And they have some really good looking options too,
very aesthetically pleasing.
I was just looking at their Instagram account.
Definitely tons of options no matter how you decorate.
And no matter what your unique needs are,
from motorization to home automation to room darkening
or even child safety, with 3-Day Blinds,
you can choose from thousands of options
that fit any budget or style with actual samples,
so you won't be guessing about
what your blinds will look like.
3-Day Blinds has been in business for 45 years,
and you may not hear it in the name,
but they make an incredibly high quality product.
That's why they are the highest rated blinds company
on TrustPilot with 4.7 out of five stars. So right now you can get 3-day blinds buy one get one 50% off deal on
custom blinds, shades, shutters, and drapery. For a free no charge no obligation consultation just
head to 3dayblinds.com slash Kendall Rae that's buy one get one 50% off when you head to 3dayblinds.com
slash Kendall Rae one last time that's the number 3 day d-a-y blinds.com slash Kendall Rae. Kim says that Jim controlled all aspects of April's finances, despite the fact that it
was her money, of course, her money that she worked for.
And he would do weird things like turn off the lights in a room that she was clearly
still using.
So there were little things like that.
He seemed to be jealous of her oftentimes, that people were so enamored by her and he
didn't like the spotlight not being on him at all times. But there were even more concerning
things, I would say. One of those being that a neighbor was made aware of the fact that
things weren't going well between them and April actually showed this neighbor bullet holes in the living
room where Jim had shot his gun during a heated argument, which is obviously a giant red flag
and totally terrifying. And that's really one thing you got to know about Jim right
away is that this man loved his guns. He was really a self-proclaimed tough guy.
And the ego on this dude was astronomical.
And one of the most important things to Jim in life
besides his guns was money.
He wanted to be perceived as someone who was rich,
who was powerful, who was the leader
like the man of the house type situation.
And it drove him fucking nuts that many people saw April
as the leader of their household.
I think in a lot of ways he was just threatened by her.
And this is interesting.
One thing that really drove him nuts
is a lot of people referred to him as Mr. April.
So I can't imagine that was good for his ego.
It seemed like he was truly threatened by April's success and how well liked she was.
Like they would go to parties and events and people would want to speak to her and he couldn't
stand that if that were the case and he started feeling like in the shadow, he would want
to leave.
So even though he tried to be this powerful man, he really had such a fragile side to
him that really couldn't take being with a successful,
powerful woman, which is just one of the things
about him that made him a coward.
And he wasn't just a coward, dude was also a big liar.
And I say that because it turns out that Jim,
this heroic veteran, had actually never served
in the army at all.
He had made the whole thing up and was telling lies
about it for over a decade.
And one day April found out about it.
Now this wasn't only devastating to her on a personal level.
I mean, to find out that this person you're married to
and really respected ended up lying to you
about such a massive detail in their life.
But professionally speaking, she also had big concerns that her credibility would be
tainted because of what he had done.
I mean, she is this advocate for veterans and bringing him on her radio show, sharing
his stories.
And turns out it was all a lie.
And she knew if people found out about that, that not only would he obviously look horrible,
but people could perceive her in a bad light as well.
This wasn't like an ego thing for her.
It wasn't a way that she just wanted people to see her
as caring for veterans.
She truly did.
This was a big passion for her.
She ultimately decided that she wanted a divorce
because of it.
But of course, Jim did not want that to happen,
probably because he didn't wanna be outed to some degree,
but the biggest thing was because he didn't wanna
have to give her half his money in a divorce.
And of course, in true crime, we see this all the time
where people, rather than just getting a divorce,
sucking it up and understanding
that you do have to, you know, sometimes split all of your earnings with your partner, they
will resort to extreme measures.
Now it's estimated that Jim's net worth was approximately $4.6 million and apparently
it wasn't an option in his mind to let April have any of it.
So when she came to him and told him that she wanted a divorce, his answer was straight
up no, absolutely not.
You are not divorcing me and you are sure as hell not going to take half of my money.
So at some point, April goes to lunch with her daughter Kim and tells her all of this
and she specifically tells her that Jim told her
that he would go nuclear on her if she ever left him
or tried to take half of his money.
And not only that, she also told her
that Jim told her he would kill her
before he ever let her take half of his money.
Now, Kim always said that her mom would tell her
that he would never actually have the guts
to go through with it, but unfortunately he did. Because this is April we're talking about and
because she wasn't going to sit back and do nothing, she threatened to expose Jim for a
pill mill that he was operating out of his medical office, which of course I will explain the pill
mill a little later, but I mean,
really April just needed a way to get out of this relationship somehow.
And so if he wasn't going to give her a divorce, she was going to go to the police.
And so what did he do in response to that?
Well, he devised a plan to have her killed, which brings me to a huge element of this
case and that is the Pagans Outlaw Motorcycle Club.
Now, just picture any motorcycle gang that you've seen in any TV show or movie, and that's the Pagans.
They were a bunch of big, tough guys wearing matching jean vests and riding around on motorcycles doing less than legal activities.
Now, I do want to say not all motorcycle gangs out there or clubs are
doing illegal things. A lot of them actually out there are doing good things and we love that for them.
But the Pagans have been linked to organized crime in Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, and New York.
But for the sake of this case, I'll mostly be talking about the Kate May chapter in New Jersey.
This chapter of the club was led by President Andrew Glick,
who will end up being a big central figure in this case,
but more on him in a minute.
But first, I wanna talk about Jim's connection
to the pagans, which, as you probably could guess,
had to do with the pill mill that he was operating.
Now, I'm sure a lot of you out there
know what a pill mill is already,
but for those of you who don't, it's essentially where a doctor will prescribe pills like painkillers and
other medications to people who don't need them.
And then those people will go on to sell them for a lot of money out on the streets and
in illegal markets, things like that.
Or they'll just take them themselves.
And as you can imagine, things like this have made the opioid
epidemic in America so, so much worse. According to the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy
Research, the prescription of opioids in the United States quadrupled between the years
2000 and 2010. And during that time, there was sadly a 300% increase in opioid related
deaths. And obviously, it's gotten much worse since then.
But I bring up this time period because it was the approximate time where Jam was running
his pill mill and the Pagans were his customers.
Members of the Pagan Motorcycle Club, as well as their girlfriends and associates, became
heavily involved in this operation and everyone was making
a lot of money.
And there are a few people in particular who are very important to this case who were especially
involved.
And that was Ferdinand or Freddy Augello and Andrew Glick.
Now like I said earlier, Andrew was the president of the Cape May chapter of the Pagans, but
Freddy was sort of like his mentor.
He taught Andrew everything he needed to know about being a Pagan and the two of them were
about as close as two members could be.
And among the many things he taught him, Freddy taught him the most cardinal rule of being
a Pagan, which was to never rat on a brother.
And no matter what the crime was, how serious it was,
or how violent it was, pagans never told on other pagans.
And I'm sure you can all imagine what would happen
if you did rat on another pagan.
Which of course meant things like the pill mill
had to be kept very discreet.
And all things considered,
things were going pretty smoothly for them.
That is until April threatened to divorce Jim, take half his money and expose the whole
thing.
Today I want to talk to you about one of my favorite products and that is Nutri-Full.
I have been taking Nutri-Full for about a year and a half now and have had amazing results.
I truly stand by this product.
In fact, I started using it before they even started sponsoring my show and just have had
such a great experience. I recommended it to so many friends and family. I started using it
because after I had my baby, my hair started thinning, shedding. I was having just like
weakness and breakage and I started looking into a ton of treatments, but they were really expensive
and some of them sounded painful, quite frankly.
So that's when I found Nutriful online and the results have seriously been amazing.
And every time I go to the salon, my stylist points out how much my hair has grown since
I was last there.
Nutriful is the number one dermatologist recommended hair growth supplement with over one million
people seeing thicker, stronger, faster growing hair with less shedding.
Now everyone's root cause of hair thinning is different.
So a one size fits all approach to hair just doesn't cut it.
So Nutri-Full has multiple formulas
that are tailored to give your hair what it needs
to grow throughout different stages
such as postpartum, menopause,
as well as for different lifestyles
such as plant-based diets.
And while many supplements rely on ingredient studies,
Nutri-Full clinically tests final formulations
to ensure their efficacy.
In a clinical study, 86% of women reported hair growth after taking Nutriful, women's hair growth supplement for six
months. So get results that you can run your fingers through. For a limited time, Nutriful
is offering our listeners $10 off your first month subscription and free shipping when you go to
nutriful.com and enter promo code Kendall Rae. Find out why over 4,500 healthcare professionals
and stylists recommend Nutriful for healthier hair. That's nutriful.com spelled N-U-T-R-A-F-O-L dot com promo code Kendall Rae. Nutri-ful dot com promo code Kendall Rae.
So like I said, that's when Jim devised a plan to have her killed and he did it with the help of
Freddie Augello. Now like Andrew, Freddy was also a leader
among the pagans and if Freddy wanted something done he made it happen and this included having
April killed. Jim offered Freddy $50,000 to kill his wife and was explicit that he wanted her dead
because he didn't want her taking his money or risk their operation being exposed.
And rather than do it himself,
Freddie decided to outsource another member
of the Pagans to do it for him at a cheaper price.
His brilliant plan was to keep 40 to $45,000
of that 50,000 to himself and then find another Pagan
who would be willing to do it for five to 10,000.
And at first, hard to imagine, no one was down.
Now, Andrew himself was well aware of what Freddy was trying to do,
and he didn't try to stop it and he wanted no part of it.
So for months, no one in the pagans wanted to do this.
I mean, for many different reasons, of course, but I had imagined
a big part of it was why would they get paid five to $10,000
for actually doing it?
And the guy who has nothing to do
with the actual murder himself gets to take 40 to 45,000.
Doesn't really sound like something anyone would agree to.
But after a while, there was one person
who agreed to the job.
However, this person wasn't technically a pagan himself, a man named Frank,
who was known around town as the junkie. And when Andrew found out about this, he said
that he thought it was a terrible idea for Frank to do it because of his struggles with
addiction, knowing that if he got caught, there was a good chance he'd rat them all
out, especially because he wasn't a official member of the Pagans. But of course, Freddie didn't care about any of these concerns.
He just wanted to get his big payday.
So he contracted Frank to do the job.
And on Thursday, May 10, 2012, he actually went through with it.
Just after 5am that morning, 47 year old April Kaufman was asleep in bed, of course, having
no idea what was about to
happen to her, and Jim was getting ready for work and left before the sun came up.
He stopped by Wawa, a local convenience store, on his way to the office and everything seemed
to be business as usual.
That is until a few hours later when April was found face down on the floor of her bedroom.
And her body was found by a man named Billy Gonzalez, who she had hired a while back to
help take care of her pet birds.
That's another thing I haven't mentioned.
April was a big animal lover and loved birds.
Billy says that on the morning of May 12th, he received two calls from Jim asking if he
could go over to the house to check on April.
And Billy thought that this was a
really strange out of left field request because Jim had actually never called him before, but
he cared about April so he decided to go over there and check things out. And of course, when he got there, he found a horrific scene. He found April's body and he was the one to call 911.
And April had been shot twice, once in the elbow and once again through the side of her rib cage, which pierced
her lungs and her heart and ultimately ended her life.
Now according to Jim, the reason he called Billy to go and check on April is because
She wasn't answering his calls according to him
He would call her every morning at 830 and she didn't answer and he became concerned and wanted someone to go check on her
No, I think we can all agree and I've said this in other episodes before
That it is truly fucked up to send
an innocent person who has nothing to do with any of this over to a house when you know
that they are going to walk in on such a traumatizing scene to see someone in that condition murdered.
I mean, it's truly evil to send someone unsuspecting over to witness something like that
The fact that he full well knew what he was about to walk in on and just sent him
Anyway, just says so much about Jim's character
But is it surprising considering the man he is absolutely not but anyway
Billy ends up calling Jim and tells him the state that he found April in.
And that's when Jim goes ahead and makes his own call to 911.
This is Dr. Kaufman. I just got a call from my house person that my wife is spaced out on the floor.
My partner's sending out the email as we speak.
Okay.
Okay.
I'm just, yeah, I'm getting there fast as I can.
Detective Michael Mattioli was among the first to arrive to the scene,
and he had
the displeasure of interviewing Jim who over the course of a few conversations
gave varying accounts of his story. For example, at one point he claimed to have
run upstairs and checked for a pulse on April and another time he said he ran
upstairs but that he never actually touched her. And to be clear neither of
these stories are true because Billy, who was there,
said that once Jim came back to the house,
he never actually went upstairs once.
Also, a neighbor said that they saw Jim
standing outside of the house,
and it looked like he was waiting for police to show up.
And according to this neighbor,
when police did end up turning onto their street,
Jim saw them, and then he ran
into the house and quickly as they pulled up, he ran back outside, absolutely hysterical,
making a huge scene.
And he really did put on quite the performance for the police.
He collapsed onto the lawn, which is super strange, but everything about this case is
super strange.
And of course, the question on everyone's mind is who would want to kill April Kaufman?
I mean, she was super, super loved
and admired in the community.
Well, two people at the scene knew the answer to that
and one was Jim, who sure as hell
wasn't going to give himself up
and the other was her daughter Kim.
And from the second that she got the call from him
that her mother was dead,
Kim knew exactly
who was responsible. And she did not hesitate to let investigators know. She told them that if they
wanted to find the person responsible for her mother's death, they needed to look into Jim.
But he wasn't named a suspect. Not at first. And not for quite a long time. The fact that he was
seen on surveillance footage entering the Wawa at the same time
it's believed that April was murdered apparently was enough for investigators to determine
that he couldn't have been the one to shoot her.
Which of course, yes, most likely he wasn't the one to shoot her considering there's
footage of him somewhere else during that time.
But come on, y'all know that you can still be involved in a murder without actually
being the one to pull the trigger.
And so for many years, Kim's murder remained unsolved and Jim told Kim that it was going
to stay that way.
And for a while it looked like that really might be the case.
April's funeral was held at Beth-El Synagogue in Margate and her service was absolutely packed.
More than 500 people showed up and there were many people who wanted to speak at the service,
people who spoke so lovingly about the woman who had always given back to her community.
And Kim was forced to sit alongside the man that she knew was responsible for her mom's murder
and had to listen as he had the audacity to say that he was always Mr. April and didn't know what he was going to do without her.
But aside from having to sit next to Jim, which I truly cannot imagine how awful that
would be and listen to his lackluster attempt to, you know, seem like he was grieving the
death of his wife, really for the most part, the day was filled with people who truly loved her
and were there to support and honoring her life.
And moving forward,
Kim never let her mother's memory be forgotten.
She held vigils in her mom's honor.
She was constantly doing things to make sure that,
you know, people really knew the woman that she was.
She said, the person who murdered my mom
took her away from me, but they can't take away my hope. And luckily Kim held on to that hope for a
very long time and eventually it did pay off. Atlantic County prosecutor Jim
McLean seemed both uninterested and unmotivated to solve this case despite
the fact that Kim spent months and then years pushing for answers. So on top of the devastation
she felt over losing her mom, she had to bear the weight of knowing that nobody was trying
hard to do anything about it and really take on that role or advocate. And that's something
that always blows me away about families of these victims is in their time of grief and
despair. So many of them are able to step up and fight back.
And I just don't know if I would ever have the courage
or the strength I should say to do that.
I mean, that's just something
no family member should have to do.
But Kim, just from the clips I've seen of her
and interviews with her, she is just like her mom.
I mean, she is a fighter. She is
strong. She is powerful. She believes in herself and she is not going to give up. And Jim was
off scot-free. You know, he had no reason to look over his shoulder. And so he moved
on with his life and kept living it well. And a year after she was killed he was already auctioning off her belongings and getting married again to real big red flags
If I were to ask you how many active subscriptions you have would you be able to tell me a number off the top of your
head probably not and if you had asked me before I started using rocket money
I would have thought I had a general idea
But I had no idea how many subscriptions that I forgot about how many that I had paid twice for and
Didn't even realize it
it's so easy to you know start a subscription and forget to use it or start a free trial and forget to cancel it and then
It's really easy to just ignore the process of canceling it because it can be a pain
It's time-consuming oftentimes you have to talk to customer service and beg them to cancel your subscription
Did you know over 74% of people have subscriptions that they've forgotten about? Like I said,
I definitely did but thanks to rocket money
I'm no longer wasting money on the ones that I forgot about rocket money is a personal finance app that finds and cancels your unwanted
Subscriptions monitors your spending and helps you to lower your bills so that you can grow your savings
Most Americans think they spend about $62 a month on subscriptions, but get this, the real number is closer to $300. That is literally thousands of dollars a year, half of
which you've probably forgotten about. With Rocket Money, I can see all of my subscriptions in one
place and if I see something I don't want at any time, Rocket Money can help me cancel it with a
few taps. That's the best part of it is it's so easy and I love how the dashboard shows me this
month's spending compared to last month so I can clearly see our family's spending habits.
Plus, they can help you create a custom budget and keep your spending on track.
Rocket Money has over 5 million users and has saved a total of 500 million in cancelled
subscriptions saving members up to $740 a year when using all of the app's features.
So stop wasting money on things you don't use.
Cancel your unwanted subscriptions by going to rocketmoney.com slash Kendall Rae.
Once again, that's rocketmoney.com slash Kendall Rae. Rocketmoney.com slash Kendall Rae. Once again, that's rocketmoney.com slash Kendall Rae.
Rocketmoney.com slash Kendall Rae.
It was like April never existed to him
and her death didn't impact him in the slightest.
And the only thing left tying him to her
was the fact that he was trying to cash out
on her $600,000 life insurance policy.
And when Kim found out about this, of course, she was like, oh, hell no, there's no way
I'm going to let my mother's killer get a cent off of her death.
And that's when she came up with the idea to pursue a civil lawsuit against him.
She knew that he had to be involved.
She knew that he did it.
She just needed help proving it.
And so that's when she turned to a law firm
to help her. This law firm really stepped up. They agreed to help. They really supported Kim.
And not only were they helping her keep Jim from getting that life insurance money, but they also
filed a wrongful death lawsuit against him, which was genius because when they did that,
they were able to schedule a deposition where he would have to answer questions under oath and
on camera. Mind you, this is two years after the murder was committed and it was the first time
that he was questioned under oath. And during this a few things were uncovered and most importantly
out of those things was the fact that Jim ended up saying that there's a possibility the Pagans were involved in April's murder.
Who do you think did it?
I thought it could be someone who was one of the veterans.
The last choice was someone in a motorcycle gang.
What motorcycle gang?
The Pagans.
Now, the strategy that Kim's civil attorney had was to collect any and all evidence they
could find and hand it over to investigators.
And the hope with that being that if they did the heavy lifting, there would be no other
option but for this to be pursued as a criminal case, not just civil.
For example, one of the things that they turned over was Jim's phone records.
And in those phone records, they found a history of calls being made from Jim's phone to a
burner phone.
And those calls just randomly stopped the day before April was murdered, which obviously
they believe there had to be a connection there.
I mean, what are the chances?
It's just a total coincidence those calls stopped to a burner phone the day before she's
killed.
I don't think so.
And luckily, this strategy paid off.
So then in 2017, a new county prosecutor took over the case
and he, Damon Tyner, did in a few months
what Jim McClain failed to do in five years.
And that was actually push for this case to be solved.
Tyner put an investigator on the case
who was known for being tough
and he truly did a fantastic job.
And by this point, there was definitely a lot of talk about the Payne's being involved
in April's murder and talk about the fact that Jim wanted her dead.
But the one major drawback was the evidence.
They needed something more concrete to make an arrest.
Luckily for them though, the FBI was already looking into Jim for unrelated charges.
It turns out that in addition to running his pill mill, Jim was also suspected of committing
insurance fraud.
And what's good about this is they can essentially charge him with one thing and then in the
meantime collect more evidence to charge him with the other.
And on June 13th, 2017, the feds and local authorities showed up at his office to execute
a search warrant.
Now, this did not go as they anticipated.
They planned on going in, seizing some documents, and leaving.
But what actually happened was far more dramatic.
When the agents attempted to execute the warrant, Jim came out of his office with a gun, threatening
to unalive
himself and saying that he wasn't going to jail for something he didn't do.
And had he taken literally two seconds to hear the agents out, he would have realized
that they weren't there about April's murder, as he clearly thought they were.
They weren't even there to arrest him.
They were there to seize documents related to the insurance fraud and only that.
But now that he was acting completely unhinged, waving his gun around and threatening to take
his own life, arresting him was exactly what they did.
Jim was taken to the local hospital for a psychiatric evaluation of course, and from
that point forward he remained in police custody.
And that's because agents found a lot more than just incriminating documents in their
search.
After searching both his office and his home, they seized several illegal weapons and more
than $100,000 in cash, which was likely attributed to one of the many schemes that he was running.
So on top of the other pending charges, Jim was now facing several weapons charges, which
allowed them to keep him behind bars. And what's interesting is even though Jim
had no prior record and no reason really
to not be released on bail,
the judge denied him that opportunity,
which was a miracle really, and we love him for that.
And that means from June 13th on, he remained behind bars,
which like I said earlier,
gave investigators more time
to collect evidence.
So let's talk about what investigators knew at this point.
They knew that of course Jim had mentioned the pagans in his deposition, and they also
knew that he was filling prescriptions for them for oxy to several different pagan members
and their associates.
So they were connecting the dots here that a lot of
them had to be involved in this pill mill operation. Investigators then believed that through
the relationship Jim established with the gang over the years that he was able to solicit April's
murder. But what they didn't know at this point was who exactly he worked with to make that happen.
And so of course their best hope to figuring out that
information was to find a pagan member who was willing to cooperate, which of course
would not be an easy task because remember the cardinal rule for the pagans is never
rat on a brother. Thankfully though, there was one member who cared more about staying
out of jail than the cardinal rule and that man was Andrew Glick.
And I do need to rewind a little bit here on our timeline
to bring this all back full circle, so stick with me.
Back on the morning of May 10th, 2012, when April was killed,
Andrew said that when he woke up and saw the news,
he knew that it was over for them.
He knew that the police were going to link it back
to the pagans eventually, and it was only a matter of time before they came knocking on his door.
To his surprise though, for a while that didn't happen. Weeks turned into months, months turned
into years and during all that time no one was arrested, which really shocked Andrew.
And so with all that time having passed with nothing happening, he became less and less concerned.
And what eased his concern even more was the man who actually killed April, Frank,
had actually died. And I'm sure this will not surprise you to hear at all, but he actually died
from an overdose of pills that were prescribed to him by none other than Dr. Jim Kaufman.
And if you're thinking that maybe that was intentional on Jim's part, you're probably
right.
We're not 100% sure on that, but apparently Jim told Freddie, who told Andrew, that he
took care of the junkie so they didn't have to worry about him anymore.
And because Frank was dead and because the case seemed to go cold, everyone else who
knew about the murder pretty much moved on with their lives.
Freddie spent the money that he got from Jim on a bunch of equipment for his band,
and Andrew continued dealing drugs and working his day job as a chef.
And for a while, it seemed like they may actually get away with it.
But of course, that all changed when Jim got arrested,
and Andrew put himself in the middle of the investigation, quite literally.
It turns out that after Jim's arrest,
Andrew called the prosecutor's office,
asking if he could stop by to pick up his medical records.
He knew from watching the news
that they had seized a bunch of records
when they executed that search warrant,
and he wanted to go and pick his records up.
And this was such a gift to investigators,
they saw this as the perfect opportunity.
They knew who Andrew was,
they knew that he was a member of the Pagans,
and so when he came into their office,
Investigator Jim Scopa ended up holding him for questioning.
And at first they got nothing out of him,
which isn't totally surprising.
Of course, he didn't wanna snitch on any of the brothers,
so he stayed silent and there was no reason
to hold him there, so he was allowed to leave.
He was warned though, that they were confident they were eventually going to catch April
Kaufman's killer and that he would be better off if he worked with them rather than against
them.
But of course he did not listen.
Not only that, he kept dealing drugs and put himself in a terrible position where he obviously
would eventually be caught.
And on November 1st, 2017, FBI agents and officers from the prosecutor's office raided
Andrew's home after finding pounds of drugs and piles of cash and they arrested him for
real this time.
And whether or not he was willing to talk about the murder, he was going to be faced
with a mountain of other charges.
Luckily for investigators though, Andrew was willing to cut a deal and talk,
but not right away.
And after refusing to give up any information
on the murder at the FBI field office,
he was taken to the county jail where he sat for six days.
And after those six days, he was released on bail,
but he knew he would not be free for long
because he was facing up to 40 years for those drug charges. And so what did he do? He called up Jim Scopa and he told him that he was
ready to talk.
You know when you get cornered by that person at the family gathering that you
feel like you have to kind of bend the truth when you're talking to them? You
know the one that asks when you're getting married or what's going on with
that promotion or why you still haven't moved out of mom and dad's basement,
whatever it is, only for her to not really listen
and just judge you.
And while you may have to grin and bear it
with a family member, you shouldn't feel that way
when talking to your doctor.
ZocDoc is a free app and website
where you can search and compare highly rated
in-network doctors near you
and instantly book appointments with them online.
Once you find the doc you want,
you can book them immediately.
There's no more awkwardly waiting on hold with the receptionist,
which I can't stand. And all these docs have verified reviews from actual real patients.
Now I've been using ZocDoc since far before they started sponsoring me and I've had a wonderful
experience with them. I found a couple great medical professionals that make me feel like I
can really open up and I can trust them. I don't ever feel judged and that is crucial
because for a long time I had a lot of really bad doctors
and for a while there I just kind of stopped going
to the doctor, but that all changed
when I started using ZocDoc.
And we're talking about booking appointments
with tens of thousands of top rated patient reviewed
credible doctors and specialists.
You can filter specifically for ones
that take your insurance, are located near you
and treat basically any condition you're searching for.
And the typical wait time to see a doctor booked on ZocDoc is just between 24 and 72
hours.
That's it.
Sometimes you can even score same day appointments.
So go to ZocDoc.com slash Kendall Rae and download the ZocDoc app for free then find
and book a top rated doctor today.
That's Z-O-C-D-O-C dot com slash Kendall Rae.
ZocDoc.com slash Kendall Ray, zocdoc.com slash Kendall Ray.
And on November 16th, Andrew Glick gave a full recorded statement, not only giving up
the details regarding April's murder, but also everything related to the pale mill.
He confirmed that Jim was illegally prescribing oxy to members of the pagans and that through
this operation, Freddie Agello was taking a cut of all transactions.
He also said that Freddie was the one
who had orchestrated the murder with Jim
and shared the details of how they eventually made it happen.
And for as much as this sounds like a slam dunk
at this point that they can just go and arrest Freddie,
investigators still wanted more.
If they were going to take him to trial,
they wanted more than just witness testimony. They wanted a recording of him talking about the murder. And so Andrew
agreed very reluctantly, of course, because he's, you know, breaking that cardinal rule to wear a
wire and go talk to Freddie. And starting in November of 2017, Andrew wore a wire in 14
meetings with Freddie in order to get that irrefutable evidence.
And it wasn't easy to get him to talk about the murder.
He was definitely suspicious that Andrew was wearing a wire and several times he would
ask him about that and Andrew would assure him that he definitely wasn't.
And Freddie would say things to him like, oh, you know, you're right, man.
You know, you always have my back.
You're one of my best friends.
You're one of the most trusted people I have in this world, which obviously made it harder for Andrew. And by this point, Jim
was behind bars and he knew that Andrew had also been arrested and released on those drug charges,
so it wasn't like he was just going to openly talk about the murder. He did, however, talk about how
there was one more loose end that needed to be tied up, and that was Jim.
Freddie was worried that he was going to cut a deal
with prosecutors and turn him in
for a lesser sentence for himself.
And so what was his plan to prevent this?
I'm sure you can guess, he wanted to have him killed.
Freddie told Andrew that he wanted to have Jim killed
in jail and that he was going to make that happen
with the help of his friends in the mafia.
Surveillance footage even showed Freddie at meetings with the people that investigators
believe were being contracted to do the job. And when his plan ultimately fell through,
Andrew stepped in with a solution of sorts. While he was wearing a wire, Andrew tells Freddie that
he can have Jim taken care of with the help of his friends in the Mexican cartel. He told him that someone was going to inject Jim
with a syringe full of fentanyl,
but it was going to take some time to coordinate.
And what was good about this solution
and pretty obvious since he was wearing a wire
is that he wasn't actually going to have Jim killed,
but he was going to convince Freddy that he was.
This would keep Jim safe,
so obviously he could be held accountable
later on, but it would incriminate Freddie for being part of it. And with this, they
finally had enough evidence to make an arrest. And so on January 9th, 2018, Freddie Augelo
was arrested and charged with murder, conspiracy to commit murder, and racketeering. And that
same day, Jim was finally charged with both murder and racketeering. And that same day, Jim was finally charged with both murder and racketeering.
Today, James Kaufman, age 69, and Ferdinand Augelo, age 62, were charged with murder in
connection with the death of April Poffman in addition to racketeering related to the
illegal distribution of narcotics through Kaufman's former medical
practice.
Additionally, Augelo is charged with conspiracy to commit the murder of James M. Kaufman.
Upon information and belief known to my office, an individual named Francis Frank Mulholland
was paid a sum of money to kill April Kaufman. Almost 18 months after April Kaufman's murder,
Frank Mulholland died in October of 2013
by at the time what was determined to be an accidental rug overdose.
Through our investigation, we determined that a long-term alliance
between members of the Pagan Outlaw Motorcycle gang
and James Kaufman was created for the mutual financial gain
through the use of Kaufman's medical practice
for illegal drug distribution.
This relationship ultimately culminated on May 10, 2012,
with the murder-for-hire of April Koppel.
Prior to 2011, defendant Kaufman and Ferdinand Augelo
had a relationship which centered around
the medical practice.
And then the summer of 2011,
James Kaufman solicited Augelo to murder his wife.
And following these arrests,
Kim spoke out at a press conference.
And as you can imagine, she felt so much relief
knowing that her mother's murder was finally solved
and that justice was on the horizon.
And I just have to say I truly have so much admiration for Kim. The fact that she never gave up and
really honored her mother's tenacity and spirit by fighting so hard for so long. She just seems like
a really amazing person. Super, super tough. I just don't know how she did it for so long.
And she just knew from the beginning that Jim was involved in some way, and she found a
way to make sure that he didn't get away with it.
You know, May 10th, 2012 forever changed my life. I have been waiting patiently for justice,
and today I was lucky enough to be granted justice.
I do understand that this is going to be a very long process,
and this is by no means over.
I think for the first time today, I can actually breathe.
For the past five and a half years,
I have felt like I've been holding my breath
on a daily basis.
I couldn't even begin to describe to you today the emotions that I feel.
I feel like I'm standing before you and I'm shaking.
I want to really take time to thank my attorneys here at Darcy Johnson Day.
And most importantly, these two men that stand beside me, they have been like
my guardian angels. They stood by me when it wasn't popular and when, you know, I didn't
really know that I was ever going to obtain justice. They have fought for me since day
one and I am forever grateful for these two gentlemen. This firm has believed in me and allow me the platform to speak up and stand up for
justice for my mom.
And the arrest did not stop there.
Six other people were arrested and charged with drug distribution and racketeering.
Authorities say they believe these individuals were sent to Jim's office by Freddie and
that he received up to $1,000 per visit.
Multiply that by hundreds of visits,
and Jim was definitely raking in the cash
with this whole scheme.
Federal authorities also linked him
to the insurance fraud scheme that I mentioned earlier,
which was also earning him thousands of dollars
on the side of his already successful medical practice.
So to say that he was facing a lot, a lot of prison time
would definitely be an understatement.
And they also had to transfer him to a different local jail while he was awaiting trial because
they were afraid that if Freddy and him were put together that Freddy may try and kill him.
Which considering he did try to have him killed in the past, this probably was the right move.
And less than two weeks later, Jim was back in court. On January 18th, Jim appeared back in court.
And let me tell you, in just a span of a few months,
this man looked like he had aged like 50 years.
He was hunched over and looked like he could hardly
nod his head yes or no when the judge spoke to him.
And he ultimately didn't detest the ruling
that he would remain behind bars,
but he did still maintain his innocence.
As for Freddie, it was also ruled that he had to stay behind bars until trial.
However, he and his lawyers did try and protest this.
Unsuccessfully, I might add.
Because of course, Freddie is a clear threat to the community considering the fact that
he had already orchestrated one murder and had been arrested while he was trying to orchestrate
a second.
As we all know, though, justice does take time and it was
going to be a few months before either of their trials began. But, and this pains me to say,
there only ended up being one trial because on January 26, 2018, Jim ended up taking his own life
while in his jail cell. And of course, the reason I say it pains me to say that is not because he's
dead. I mean, whatever,
but it's the fact that he was not held accountable
in the end, that there was no justice when it comes to Jim.
And in doing so, he left behind a six-page note
where he denied any involvement in April's murder,
even stated that she was the one who introduced him
to the pagans, essentially blaming her
for getting involved with them,
even though there was no proof. And really, it makes no sense why she would have connected them with him. I
mean, come on, it's just ridiculous. And to still, even after you're going to take
your own life, try and say that you had nothing to do with this. It's just sick. I mean,
that's the very least that you could give her loved ones, especially Kim, who really cared about Jim at parts in her life.
I mean, she talked about when he took his own life how painful it was for her, even though obviously she hated him and...
I mean, I can't imagine what a mixed bag of emotions that would be, but she said that he really was a big part of her life and meant a lot to her in some
ways. And even though she had all this hatred and understandable anger against
him, it still was just shocking and hurtful and especially hurtful that she
wouldn't be able to see him face what he did.
Kauffman and alleged co-conspirator Ferdinand Augello were ordered to remain
detained until trial.
It would be the last time that Kaufman would appear publicly.
Friday morning, the Atlantic County Prosecutor's Office stated that Kaufman was found dead
in his Hudson County jail cell.
Sources tell eyewitness news that the apparent suicide was carried out using a bed sheet.
So Freddie Augello's trial began on September 17th, 2018, and among the many who testified
against him was Andrew Glick.
Andrew's testimony lasted a whopping five days, and his testimony was obviously super
crucial, as was all the recorded evidence against Freddie that they collected through
the wire.
And a guy named Joseph also testified against Freddie, and he was among those who was arrested
and charged back in January.
And he actually was part of the conspiracy to commit murder. Joseph was the person who drove
Frank to April's house that day and pleaded guilty and testified in exchange for a lesser
sentence. A different pagan member named Joseph also testified that Freddie tried to ask him
to commit the murder in the fall of 2010, which just added to the evidence against Freddie's
leadership in the whole scheme.
And if I sat here today and went through all of the evidence
and testimony, we would be here for hours.
So let me just skip to the most important part.
And that is that he was found guilty on all charges
and sentenced to life in prison plus 25 years.
And Freddie will have to remain behind bars
until he's eligible for parole in 55 years,
which will not happen because he would be
117 by then. So yeah, ain't no chance he's getting out ever.
Today, Superior Court Judge Bernard DeLorey sealed the fate of Ferdinand Freddie Augelo for
his responsibility in the murder-for-hire scheme of April Kaufman on May 10, 2012, by sentencing him to life
in prison plus 25 years. If he survives, Augelo will be approximately 117 years old before
he is eligible for parole, which will all but ensure he will spend the remainder of
his natural life behind bars for the crimes that he committed.
Now, as for Andrew, he received no jail time and all charges against him were dropped in
exchange for his cooperation.
And despite walking away from all of this unscathed, he said he did not feel good in
the end being an informant.
And he's kind of an interesting person to listen to.
There's like documentaries and interviews on him and he's just like kind of all over
the place in my opinion.
In the end, he was just really upset that he broke the cardinal rule of being a pagan,
and he really got dragged through the mud for that.
Like tons of people in the pagans just hate him to this day and call him a rat and whatever.
But one thing that really does bother him a lot lot and he's trying to come to terms with,
and he will always have to live with this,
is the fact that he didn't stop April's murder
when he had every opportunity to do so.
And so I'm really curious to hear what you guys think.
Do you think it was fair that he got no jail time?
Because at the end of the day,
I mean, you can make the point
that if he didn't choose to cooperate,
that no one would have been held accountable.
He definitely was a crucial piece in getting Freddie locked up.
But at the end of the day, he knew that April was going to be murdered and he didn't do
anything to stop it.
Not to mention he was dealing drugs and he was part of the pill mill operation.
So it's it's tough.
I mean, in my opinion, I think there should have been some sort of accountability,
like definitely a lesser sentence for cooperating. Obviously, that's really valuable and has to be
rewarded in some way. But I think just walking away with nothing, it makes no sense to me.
But maybe you disagree. Maybe you think that his cooperation deserved full immunity.
I want to hear from you. Regardless, though, at the end of the day,
even though it took way too long,
April did get the justice she deserved.
And I'm really, really happy for Kim
that she can hang her hat on that at the end of the day.
And a lot of that was because of her
and how hard she pushed.
Freddie being sentenced to life in prison
was the best possible outcome Kim could have hoped for.
But like we hear from so many families,
it doesn't change the fact that her mom was taken from her.
At the end of the day, nothing will bring her back.
And that is something that I can't imagine living with.
Kim says that she misses her mother's smile, her laugh and her wisdom.
And that as great as it is to have those responsible guilty, like I said, it doesn't bring her back.
Like I've continued to say, I really do have the utmost respect for Kim.
And she's just a testament for, I I think so many other people out there who are
fighting against the justice system that is broken in so many ways. And I mean, you can really apply
to anything in life that you should never, never give up. She did whatever she could to make sure
that at the end of the day, the people who were responsible for her mother's murder were held accountable and it paid off.
Unfortunately, Jim wasn't able to be held accountable, but I mean, at least he's no
longer alive and he can't hurt anyone else.
And so this week in April's honor, I wanted to make a donation to Community Hope, which
is the largest nonprofit serving homeless veterans and families in New Jersey.
And I chose this charity because of the dedication that she showed to veterans in her community. And I really felt like this
was the best way to give back in her honor. Community Hope works to address the underlying
source of veteran homelessness, which includes high rates of mental illness, trauma, and
substance abuse. Their Hope for Veterans program has rescued more than 6,000 veterans and their
families from experiencing homelessness. And they offer programs such as suicide prevention, support
services for veteran families, women veterans housing and more.
Their mission is to be a beacon of hope within the community and connect veterans and their
families with life-changing support, services and housing that foster independence and resiliency.
I love what they stand for.
And I know that April would love it too.
And as always, I'll have their website linked
in the description if you would like to make a donation
yourself maybe for a veteran in your life or for April.
At the end of the day, what happened to April
was so unnecessary, so horrific,
and really came down to the greed of a man
who didn't want to part
ways with his money which is unfortunately what we see in so many of
these cases. It's so hard to understand I see comments from you guys all the time
that you know why not just get a divorce and oh it's just it's so frustrating
man. I just will never wrap my head around how killing someone who you must
have loved at some point in your marriage right and someone who is a
mother seems like a better option to you than getting a divorce and potentially
losing some of your money. It seems like a better idea to you to risk life in
prison and to live with that guilt for the rest of your life. I just, like I said, it just will never get it.
That is going to be it for me today, guys. Thank you for joining me for another episode
and make sure you follow the show on Spotify and Apple podcasts. It really does help me
out. If you want to watch the video version of this show, you can find it on my YouTube
channel, which will be linked, or you can just search Kendall Rae. I will be back with another episode soon but until then stay safe out there.