Young and Profiting with Hala Taha - David Eagleman: The Inside Story of the Ever-Changing Brain | E209

Episode Date: February 13, 2023

At age 8, David Eagleman fell off the edge of a roof. While he was falling, he felt the world slow down, and he saw his life flash before his eyes. His fall made him want to study the neural basis of ...time perception in crisis situations, and years later, David became a neuroscientist and expert on topics like time perception, brain plasticity, and neurolaw. In this episode, David talks about sensory substitution, the plasticity of the brain, and the potential future state of the human experience. He also breaks down what he calls “livewiring.” David Eagleman is a neuroscientist at Stanford University and an internationally bestselling author. He is co-founder of two venture-backed companies, Neosensory and BrainCheck, and he also directs the Center for Science and Law, a national non-profit institute. He is best known for his work on sensory substitution, time perception, brain plasticity, synesthesia, and neurolaw. In his latest book, Livewired, he tells the story of brain plasticity.  In this episode, Hala and David will discuss:  - Why a childhood injury influenced David to study time perception - How we have evolved our senses based on our environment  - What a “half-baked” brain looks like - Brain Plasticity over time - David’s “Mr. Potato Head” Model - The new discoveries of Neosensory - Why we dream  - How science and religion are related - What it means to be livewired - And other topics… David Eagleman is a neuroscientist at Stanford University and an internationally bestselling author. He is the writer and presenter of the international PBS series, The Brain with David Eagleman, and the author of the companion book, The Brain: The Story of You. He is also the writer and presenter of The Creative Brain on Netflix. He is the co-founder of two venture-backed companies, Neosensory and BrainCheck, and he also directs the Center for Science and Law, a national non-profit institute.  Beyond his 120+ academic publications, he has published many popular books. His latest book Livewired: The Inside Story of the Ever-Changing Brain tells the story of brain plasticity: how your forest of billions of neurons reconfigures every moment of your life. Eagleman is a TED speaker and a Guggenheim Fellow. He also serves on several boards, including the American Brain Foundation and The Long Now Foundation. He serves as the academic editor for the Journal of Science and Law, was named Science Educator of the Year by the Society for Neuroscience, and was featured as one of the Brightest Idea Guys by Italy’s Style magazine. David’s new podcast The Story Inside with David Eagleman will drop in the Spring of 2023 with iHeartMedia.  Resources Mentioned: David’s Website: https://eagleman.com/  David’s LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/davideagleman/ David’s Twitter: https://twitter.com/davideagleman  David’s Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davideagleman/ David’s Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/David.M.Eagleman    David’s Podcast: https://eagleman.com/podcast/ David’s book Livewired: https://eagleman.com/books/livewired/ PBS series, The Brain with David Eagleman: https://www.pbs.org/show/brain-david-eagleman/ LinkedIn Secrets Masterclass, Have Job Security For Life: Use code ‘podcast’ for 40% off at yapmedia.io/course. Sponsored By:  Shopify - Sign up for a $1 per month trial period at shopify.com/profiting Just Thrive - Use promo code YAP for 15% off sitewide at https://justthrivehealth.com/discount/YAP More About Young and Profiting Download Transcripts - youngandprofiting.com   Get Sponsorship Deals - youngandprofiting.com/sponsorships Leave a Review - ratethispodcast.com/yap Watch Videos - youtube.com/c/YoungandProfiting Follow Hala Taha LinkedIn - linkedin.com/in/htaha/ Instagram - instagram.com/yapwithhala/ TikTok - tiktok.com/@yapwithhala Twitter - twitter.com/yapwithhala Learn more about YAP Media Agency Services - yapmedia.io/ Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 This episode of YAP is sponsored in part by Shopify. Shopify simplifies selling online and in-person so you can focus on successfully growing your business. Sign up for a $1 per month trial period at Shopify.com slash profiting. Imagine that you are a dog. Imagine you got this long snout with 200 million cent receptors in it. Everything for you is about scent. Lots of animals have magnetoreception, which means they're picking up on the magnetic field
Starting point is 00:00:26 of the earth. These are things that are just totally invisible to us. We don't pick this up at all. And I think this is a very counterintuitive thing to think that your biology actually constrains your perception of reality. The way we think about building all our technology now and the way that everything is set up, our factories are set up.
Starting point is 00:00:44 Okay, yeah, you make a hard-word layer and then you put software on top of it and that's been a great idea and it's been super successful, but it's just not the way that biology ever does anything. The future is going to be much more biological than the way we do it right now, which is we build hardware machinery that is inflexible. What is up, young and profitors? You're listening to YAP, Young and Profiting podcasts where we interview the brightest minds in the world and unpack their wisdom into actionable advice that you can use in your daily life.
Starting point is 00:01:20 I'm your host, Hallitaha. Thanks for tuning in and get ready to listen, learn, and profit. Welcome to Young Improfiting Podcast, David. Thank you, it's so great to be here. I'm super excited. I love to learn about the brain and so do my listeners. We've had a handful of episodes on the topic with renowned experts like Dr. Caroline Leif, Dr. Daniel Aiman, Jim Quick, and a few others. But I feel like we've still only scratched the surface on the topic.
Starting point is 00:01:58 There's so much to learn about the brain. And I guarantee you, the young and profitors, today is going to be an interesting episode because we have the brilliant David Eagleman joining us on, yeah. So David is a neuroscientist at Stanford University. He's also the co-founder of Neo-Censory and Brain Check. He also directs the nonprofit organization Center for Science and Law, and he's best known for his work on sensory substitution, time perception, brain plasticity, and neuro law. He's had a PBS series. He also has a show on Netflix called The Creative Brain. In addition to all of this, David is a best-selling author
Starting point is 00:02:30 and his latest book LiveWired, The Inside Story of the Everchanging Brain, covers decades of research about our brain. So in today's discussion, Michael is for us to learn the basics of some of David's main topics like time perception, sensory substitution and live wiring, while also focusing on the potential future state of the human experience.
Starting point is 00:02:49 We seem to be at a point in human history where for the first time ever we may have the power to do things like add a six or seven sense, and I think it's super fascinating. I can't wait to get into it with David. So David, let's open up this conversation with some background on your childhood. You had an accident when you were eight years old where you fell 12 feet from a roof.
Starting point is 00:03:08 So tell us about that accident and how it influenced you to then learn about time perception years later. Yeah, so I slipped off the roof, ended up breaking my nose on the brick floor below, but the thing that really struck me about it was that it seemed to take a long time to fall from the roof. And so I was thinking about Alice in Wonderland as I was falling and how this must have been what it was like for her. It felt like lots of time as I felt.
Starting point is 00:03:33 And later when I got to high school and I took physics and I learned D equals one half 80 squared, I realized, wow, the whole fall took place in 0.6 of a second. And I couldn't reconcile that. I couldn't figure out how those, how it had seemed to have taken so long. So I got really interesting perception. I grew up, I became a neuroscientist, and I've studied a lot about time perception in my laboratory. And so one of the experiments I ended up doing then was dropping people from 150-foot tall tower backwards and freefall, and they're caught by a net below.
Starting point is 00:04:05 And I measured time perception on the way down. I made a series of discoveries there. Essentially, the bottom line is we don't actually see in slow motion. Instead, it's a trick of memory when you're in a life-threatening situation. You're laying down really dense memories such that when you read it back out and you say, what just happened? What just happened? It feels like it must have taken a very long time.
Starting point is 00:04:28 Yeah, that's super interesting. So essentially, it's the way that we're perceiving time. It's not that time actually slows down. Our brain has evolved to perceive time in that way. And it turns out that the whole world is sort of like an illusion in that sense. Can you talk to us about that? Well, that's right.
Starting point is 00:04:45 In there's a sense of what you're never perceiving time directly, you're always living at least half a second in the past. So it takes right, you know, photons hit your eyes or air compression waves hit your ears or whatever, you know, I touch your toe. And those signals have to travel along nerves, which are very slow.
Starting point is 00:05:02 I mean, thousands of times slower than, you know, electronic signals travel in your computer. So it takes time for this stuff to move around along nerves, which are very slow. I mean, thousands of times slower than, you know, electronic signals travel in your computer. So it takes time for this stuff to move around in the brain, get to different places in the brain, and then it has to get stitched together with other senses. And by the time all of this gets done and you're served up a conscious perception of what happened, the event's already long on by that point point and you're living in the past. So and by the way, I've been pursuing a hypothesis that taller people live farther in the past than shorter people because it takes longer to get all the signals there. So anyway, yes, we're never perceiving time directly and when you are thinking back
Starting point is 00:05:40 on an accident situation, you are probing your memory. You're saying, what just happened a moment ago? And so all you're ever perceiving is your conscious perception. Now, by the way, of course, your body can do things much faster than that unconsciously. Like when your foot gets halfway to the brake, when you realize a car is pulling out of the driveway ahead of you, that happens before you're consciously aware.
Starting point is 00:06:03 You become aware by the time your foot's already on the move, so your brain can do lots of things that way, you know, when you're hiking with friends and you find yourself ducking out of the way of a tree branch that's swinging back towards you before you even realize that you're ducking, you know, that kind of stuff can happen. But as far as our conscious perception of the world, that's always an old story. So so so interesting. So I mentioned that I'm going to try to talk about the future in a lot of our conversation. And so you may not have the answer, but I'm curious.
Starting point is 00:06:35 I'm sure you've thought about it. Humans hate to wait, especially as we get more technologically advanced. We don't even like to wait for our files to download on the computer. So do you think there's going to be some sort of a future where we can manipulate time in that way, where we feel like we're at least not waiting? I don't think so, actually. Only because the human brain is enormous compared to, let's say, a fly, a house fly brain. The reason it's really hard to swat a fly is because the signals are moving around fast in that brain. Sorry, I should say, the signals are moving along the neurons in a fly brain, exactly
Starting point is 00:07:08 the same speed that they're moving with us, but it can get across the brain and do everything it needs to and get to the motor system of the fly really quickly because there's just not that much territory to cover. In contrast, the human brain is enormous. You have to cross vast swathes of territory with these signals to get stuff to happen. So there's a sense in which we are always going to live in the past. Happily, technologically, things have sped up a lot. It's always struck me so funny the way that we, when something speeds up, we say, oh, I never realized I could save
Starting point is 00:07:40 time there. And then you can never go back. But often we don't realize there are ways that we could have saved time. Like for example, if somebody invents something where you can wash all your dishes or wash all your clothes, you know, like in one second and then the thing's done and unloaded automatically, you would say, oh great, I'm never going back.
Starting point is 00:07:58 But you know, we do washing machines and laundry machines now and it doesn't bother us too much. Yeah, so interesting. So one concept that I think is really important as we start to get a foundation of your work. And I think a lot of my listeners are really beginners, right? I think a lot of the terms that we're gonna talk about in this episode are gonna be brand new terms.
Starting point is 00:08:16 And one of them is this concept of um-velt. Um-velt, yeah. Um-velt, so that's it. Yeah, it's, yeah. It sounds German, right?. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being.
Starting point is 00:08:28 It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being.
Starting point is 00:08:36 It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being.
Starting point is 00:08:44 It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. It sounds like a human being. explain that concept to us. Cool. Well, the easiest way to think about the Ounvelta is that looking across the animal kingdom, so, you know, for a tick, for example, all it can detect is temperature and body odor. That's, that's its only signaling mechanisms. And so its world is built out of that or for the blind echolocating bat. Its world is built out of these echoing sound signals. Let's out a chirp and it gets an echo back and that's how it figures out the three-dimensional structure of the cave it's flying through. Or for the black coast knife fish, it has electrical fields around it and it's detecting when that gets perturbed by, let's say, a rock or some predator there.
Starting point is 00:09:19 And those are the only signals that it has that it can pick up on from the world. And so that's this concept of the umveilt, which is, you know, that's how it constructs its reality. And what I've always found interesting is that presumably we all, you know, every animal species accepts its reality as the entire reality out there. Because why would you stop to ever question or think that maybe there's something beyond what you can detect. But what you said is also correct, and this is actually the topic of my next book, which
Starting point is 00:09:48 is the difference from human to human has been fascinating to me, just as one example. Well, an easy example is colorblindness, right? So let's say this person's colorblind, this person's not there, actually seeing the scene differently. And we now know that a small fraction of women have not just three types of color photoreceptors in their eye, but four types, which means they're seeing colors. The rest of us aren't seeing or it takes something like synesthesia, which is where you, someone let's say, looks at letters or numbers and it triggers a color experience
Starting point is 00:10:19 or where they taste something and puts a feeling on their fingertips or they hear something and that causes a visual for them. There are many forms of synesthesia, but the point is it's not a disease or a disorder. It's just an alternative perceptual reality and different people, you know, like 3% of the population has synesthesia and others don't. Or something that I've been studying a lot lately is what's called hyperfantasia, or at the other end of the spectrum, afantasia, which is how you visually image something. So if I ask you to imagine an ant crawling on a tablecloth towards a jar of purple jelly, for some people that's like a movie in their head,
Starting point is 00:10:57 they can see the whole thing. Other people, it's just conceptual. There's no picture there at all. So the first group is called hyperfantasy, the second group is called aphantasy, and it turns out that across the population, everybody is smeared way out here. And so, although we would assume that everyone has mental imagery that's like ours, in fact, everybody's totally different with this stuff. So this is, this is what I've been spending my time writing about lately is the differences between humans, extremely fascinating to me.
Starting point is 00:11:26 Yeah, and I feel like there's so many ways we can go. I'm going to do my best to try to navigate this conversation in a way that I feel like we'll really lock in the most important things for my listeners. So I feel like I do want to stick on the topic of animals. I think this is really interesting. You alluded to it before that as humans, we experience things that are normal to humans, or five senses, but then some like a dog has this amazing experience with their nose and smells, right? And all of these other animals have senses that we can't even imagine what that would be like. And so help us understand what are the different senses out there
Starting point is 00:12:06 that humans are essentially missing out on? Well, okay, so almost all animals have a sense of smell that's so much better than ours. I don't know if you saw my TED talk, but I did this example of really imagine that you are a dog. Imagine you've got this long snout with 200 million scent receptors in it. And everything for you is about smell, Imagine you've got this long snout with 200 million scent receptors in it.
Starting point is 00:12:25 And everything for you is about smell. And you've got these wet nostrils that attract and trap, you know, scent molecules. And you've got floppy ears to kick up more scent. Everything for you is about scent. And what it would be like if one day you looked at your human master and you thought, what is it like to have the pitiful little nose of the human. You might imagine erroneously that they're sort of this missing black hole of smell and we all realize we have this missing smell, but of course, we're all trapped inside of our own umvehlt and so we think, oh yeah, I've got a great umveh,
Starting point is 00:12:56 I'm detecting everything out there. We don't realize typically that there's so much that we could be sensing. Now, lots of animals have magnetoreception, which means they're picking up on the magnetic field of the earth, and that's how they navigate, that's how they know north and south. So insects, birds, they've all got this. Turns out cows have good magnetoreception as well. There's, you know, some animals see in the infrared range. So rattlesnakes, for example, they have these heat pits and they're picking up on infrared radiation. Others like honey bees see in the ultraviolet range.
Starting point is 00:13:28 These are things that are just totally invisible to us. We don't pick this up at all. And I've been studying this for many years because I'm fascinated by the idea that there may be things that animals are picking up on that we can't even get. We're not even going to know for the next, you know, 50, 100 years when someone realizes, oh my gosh, it turns out, you know, Antelope are picking up on this thing that we didn't realize was the thing. So, when you really study the biology across the kingdom, you find that there's lots of information out there, and we are extremely limited. And I think this is a very counterintuitive thing to think that your biology actually
Starting point is 00:14:05 This is a very counter-intuitive thing to think that your biology actually constrains your perception of reality. Yeah. It is mind-blowing to think that animals are having a totally different experience than you are. I can be sitting here. There might be sounds that are going on that I don't even hear right now, and you don't even hear right now, which to me is just so crazy to even think about. We're so set on, this is the way that the world is,
Starting point is 00:14:25 that we never stop and actually think about these things. Oh yeah. And by the way, sounds, yeah, there are lots of animals that hear in what we call the infrasonic range and the ultrasonic range. So we hear from the details no matter, but you know, from 20 hertz to 20,000 hertz. Don't worry if you don't know that.
Starting point is 00:14:43 But you know, it's just, that's the range of human hearing, but there are animals that are communicating way above that and having conversations all the time, lots of insects and frogs and whatever. And elephants are communicating at the ranges below that. They're feeling it with their feet in the ground. They're feeling these bumps and so on and signals from other elephants. And it's totally invisible to us. Do all animals and humans have we evolved our senses
Starting point is 00:15:08 based on our environment? Yeah, that's exactly right. The reason that we see in this very narrow range that we call visible light is precisely because that big ball of fire in the sky, the sun is optimally giving photons that bounce off things on our planet's surface in that range.
Starting point is 00:15:28 In other words, lots of stuff doesn't get through the atmosphere, so it wouldn't be useful for us to pick up on many of these other ranges. And so yeah, we pick up on stuff that's super useful to us. Yeah, and then I guess we just evolve and start to focus on certain senses that are more helpful than others, which I guess is why humans really focus on vision and hearing, I think, more than other
Starting point is 00:15:50 senses. That's right. Now, it's not clear, for example, why we have lost so much skill with smell, but everything is constrained. So if you're getting better at this and you're devoting more real estate in your brain towards vision, then you're going to lose some real estate and smell, for example. And so, somehow, when everything balances out, we've ended up exactly as we are. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:16:13 So, something else that is found really fascinating when I was studying your work is this idea that we all have these different senses. All the animals have different senses, but the material of our brain, from my understanding, is very similar, at least with primates and mammals, right? Yeah. So I'd love to hear about this. It's to me that I thought that our brains would be totally different.
Starting point is 00:16:35 I mean, humans have took over the world, right? So we think we're really special, but in fact, our brain is made up of the same thing. So talk to us about that. That's right. Well, both statements are true. I mean, we are really special because our brains are running algorithms just slightly differently, and I can talk about that why we have taken over the whole planet compared
Starting point is 00:16:52 to all our brethren in the animal kingdom. But yes, it's all made of the same stuff. If I showed you a brain cell, a neuron, from a human, a horse, a cow, an insect, a squid, you couldn't tell me what's, I mean, they all look the same. They're doing exactly the same thing. It's just a cell that has these things, these sort of roadways that come off of it, and we give them fancy names, and they have, you know, but it's just a cell. It's just trafficking proteins around and putting receptors there and spinning out chemicals.
Starting point is 00:17:21 And it looks exactly the same across the animal kingdom. And so all that we're doing, all Mother Nature is doing, I should say, is just wiring this up in different ways. Yeah. So I think this is a great place to kind of get an understanding of plasticity and live wiring and the difference between it. You called your book LiveWired and you could have called it Brain Plasticity, but you called it LiveWired, and you could have called it Brain Plasticity, but you called it LiveWired for a reason. So talk to us about the distinction
Starting point is 00:17:47 between plasticity and your concept of LiveWired. Yeah, Brain Plasticity is what we term this in the field. And this just means the ability of the brain to reconfigure itself. So neurons, the cells in the brain, are spending their whole lives plugging and unplugging and seeking and finding other places and changing the strength of their connection with other neurons. Each neuron connects to about 10,000 other neurons.
Starting point is 00:18:13 And this changeability is what we call plasticity. I call it live wired nowadays, live wiring because plasticity feels to me just a bit like an outdated term. In the sense that, this was coined about a hundred years ago because people were impressed by plastic manufacturing. And the idea with the material plastic is that you mold it into a shape and then it holds onto that shape. And that's what's useful about plastic.
Starting point is 00:18:38 So the analogy to the brain that people saw was, oh, you know, you learn the name of your fifth grade teacher. And all these years later, you still remember that name. So it's like the system got molded by the information that came through and it held on to that information. And so that, you know, stance is a very good analogy. The only thing is with 86 billion neurons constantly changing every moment of your life reconfiguring, it seemed to me that plastic was maybe a little too milk toast to term. That's why I'm using
Starting point is 00:19:12 the term live wired because what really opens up when we start studying this in depth is an entirely new way to think about this and to build technologies moving forward and that's one of the things I'm going to be doing speaking of the future of the brain is building live wired devices. So instead of being something like, you know, a phone which becomes outdated and eventually the technology is not good enough and you just throw it out because it's a layer of hardware with a layer of software
Starting point is 00:19:40 on the top, what if you could build something like a brain that is constantly reconfiguring and learning and getting better with time? Yeah. So, David, I really want to get an understanding of how the brain works. From my understanding, neurons are essentially fighting with each other for relevancy in the brain. This is the framework that I put forward in the book, is that the right way to think about
Starting point is 00:20:03 the brain actually is like a Darwinian competition, where each neuron is fighting for its own survival and when you look at single cell organisms They're spinning out chemicals as a defense mechanism and when you look at neurons in the brain that are doing the same thing It's just that we call those neurotransmitters and we say oh look you're passing information along but I don't think that was the intention I think it sells all fighting for survival. And in one of these amazing bizarre biological results, you get a human brain out of this. But yes, many of the neurons in your brain die. And what you get in your first two years of development is this massive overgrowth of all these things growing like
Starting point is 00:20:45 like a garden that's going nuts. And then from about the age of two onward, all you're doing is you're really pruning the garden. You're taking things away and cells all of your body actually have this way of committing suicide. It's called apoptosis where it's not that they're dying because of injury or something and releasing inflammatory chemicals. It's that they're saying, okay, I'm done here and they fold up shop and they carefully killed themselves. And so this is a majorly important part of how the brain develops. Let's hold that thought and take a quick break with our sponsors. Young and profitors, do you have a brilliant business idea but you don't know how to move forward with it?
Starting point is 00:21:27 Going into debt for a four-year degree isn't the only path to success. Instead, learn everything you need to know about running a business for free by listening to the Millionaire University podcast. The Millionaire University podcast is a show that's changing the game for aspiring entrepreneurs. Hosted by Justin and Tara Williams, it's the ultimate resource for those who want to run a successful business and graduate rich, not broke. Justin and Tara started from Square One, just like you and me. They faced lows and dug themselves out of huge debt.
Starting point is 00:21:57 Now they're financially free and they're sharing their hard-earned lessons with all of us. That's right, millionaire university will teach you everything you need to know about starting and growing a successful business. No degrees required. earn lessons with all of us. That's right, millionaire university will teach you everything you need to know about starting and growing a successful business. No degrees required. In each episode, you'll gain invaluable insights from seasoned entrepreneurs and mentors
Starting point is 00:22:12 who truly understand what it takes to succeed. From topics like how to start a software business without creating your own software, to more broad discussions such as eight businesses you can start tomorrow to make 10K plus a month, this podcast has it all. So don't wait, now is the time to turn your business idea into a reality by listening to the Millionaire University podcast. New episodes drop Mondays and Thursdays, find the Millionaire
Starting point is 00:22:35 University podcast on Apple Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. Okay, I want people to understand, like, how senses work and why somebody who's blind, for example, can hear really well and how those neurons actually can be, I guess, reutilized for something else. So, it turns out that in the brain, not no territory lies, follow everything is going to get used. And so we think about this area at the back of the head. We think of that as the visual cortex. But yes, if you go blind,
Starting point is 00:23:13 it's no longer the visual cortex. It gets taken over by hearing, by touch, by memorization of words, by lots of things, because it's perfectly good territory. Now, the territory I'm talking about is called the cortex, which is the outer wrinkly bit of the brain. We have more of it in relation to our body size than anybody in the animal kingdom. This is sort of the magical stuff that makes this really good at what we're doing. So, it turns out that cortex is a one
Starting point is 00:23:43 trick pony, which is to say, it's not that this is fundamentally visual and that's fundamentally auditory and for touch and for controlling the motor system. But instead, any of it can trade off with any other of it. And so the really special thing with humans being live wired is that we drop into the world half-baked and we absorb everything around us. That's how you absorb your language, your neighborhood, your culture, your parents, your way of acting, your way of acting in the 21st century. In other
Starting point is 00:24:10 words, if you were born with exactly your DNA, 1,000 years ago, you'd be a really different person. If you were born 10,000 years ago, exactly you with the same DNA and you ended up in the world 10,000 years ago, you'd be totally different in terms of your cultural beliefs, whatever. Weird, you know, animistic religion you believe in, whatever kind of, you know, thing is appropriate for, you know, burning people at the stake or whatever. Or how you hunt a lion or stuff like that, you would just be a different kind of person. And this is because we absorb the world around us. And this is what I flagged a little bit earlier, what separates us from our closest cousins and the animal kingdom is that most animals are still dropping into the world, essentially pre-programmed. So if you drop in as a goat or an alligator,
Starting point is 00:24:58 you essentially know, okay, here's how I eat, mate, sleep, whatever. And that's it. And you're doing the same thing that goats did 10,000 years ago. When you drop in as a human, you, in your first several years, essentially get to learn everything that humans have discovered up until now, and then you springboard off the top of that. And that's what has led to the success of our species. We've taken over every corner of the planet. We've gotten off the planet. We've invented the internet and quantum computation and so on, precisely because we're able,
Starting point is 00:25:29 we're not starting from square one every time, but we start from where humans have already gotten. Yeah. I think this is such an important point. So essentially what you're saying is that we're born and you kind of use the analogy of a computer very often. We're born with all these software packages that unpack at certain timelines, for example,
Starting point is 00:25:50 the puberty software package that unpacks around 13 years old for everyone. But at the same time, we're supposed to interact and be social animals and absorb information, right? So what happens to people or children who don't get a chance to absorb information? Yeah, so happily these examples are rare, but they're very heartbreaking, which is sometimes you
Starting point is 00:26:10 find a child who's had such neglect and abuse that they haven't had all the normal input. So Mother Nature is taking a gamble when she drops a half-baked brain into the world. She's assuming, okay, well, you should get all the normal language and love and touch and interaction with other humans. And occasionally, you'll find a child who's locked up by their parents and they're not talked to. And they have terrible cognitive development. They just don't develop correctly. As in, they can never get language. They don't even know how to chew. They can't see very far. Yeah, it's just a half-baked brain that never gets cooked all the way. And they have real IQ deficits.
Starting point is 00:26:52 It turns out there are these things in brain development called critical periods. And one of those is if you don't get enough exposure to language, lots of language in your first several years, you can never get language at that point. So often these children are rescued at some point and a whole horde of psychologists move in and give them lots of love and lots of training and language and things like that, but it turns out it's too late. And to me, as somebody who's not a brain scientist or anything like that, I thought that the brain was supposed to be plastic,
Starting point is 00:27:26 you know, this idea of plasticity. So is it true then that there's certain parts of the brain that just cannot keep, I guess, changing or adapting? Plasticity diminishes with age and it doesn't do it smoothly. It does it with these sort of punctuated moments. So you've got, yeah, these critical periods for lots of different things. So for example,, yeah, these critical periods for lots of different things. So for example, learning language you have to do in the first, let's say four, five years, if you're not exposed to language, you just can't get it. But other things like let's say accent, if you move to a new country before the age of 13, you typically won't have any accent in, you know, in the new country. But if you move after the age of 13, it's very difficult
Starting point is 00:28:06 to, to sonically morph into that culture, you'll always retain an accent. So I use in the book, an example of Mela Kunis and Arnold Schwarzenegger, both of whom were born outside of America, but they, you know, Mela Kunis moved here when she was seven from Ukraine. She'd never spoken English before, but she doesn't have, you can't tell that she has any accent to your American English, but Arnold Schwarzenegger moved here when he was 20, so it was too late for him to get rid of his accent. So anyway, the point is there are many critical windows that happen here with learning. That said, there are many things where you retain plasticity your entire life. So, for example, your body, as controlled by your motor system and your sensory system from your body, this is plastic, your whole life. You can learn
Starting point is 00:28:51 how to kite board or parachute or do any, you can learn all kinds of new stuff. Take up a Pogo stick if you want at any age, but things like your visual system that gets less and less plastic with time because it says, okay, I got it. This is what the world looks like, and it sort of hardens into place. So interesting. So I'd love to get your breakdown of how it actually works to hear or see, like what's the mechanics behind that? And if you can go over your Mr. Potato Head model.
Starting point is 00:29:22 Yeah. Well, so it turns out that we've got these sensors like our eyes, which are these two spheres in the front of your skull that pick up on photons, and they have chemical reactions that they pick up on photons, and they send electrical signals back into the darkness of the brain. And you've got your ears which are picking up on air compression waves, and they have, it's a very sophisticated little machine, and it breaks frequencies of sound down into different areas, and it sends spikes into the darkness of the brain, and so on. And it turns out that, I mean, this is the weird and wild part, is that we sort of feel like, oh yeah, I'm just,
Starting point is 00:29:59 I'm just seeing the world, it's like I'm piping light into my head, and I'm piping sound into my head, but that's not it at all. Your brain is locked in silence and darkness, and all it has are these billions of neurons sending electrical signals around, and that leads to chemical signals, and that's it. And so all of this is a construction of the brain, what you're seeing, what you're hearing, and this is a very wild and deep thing to get your head wrapped around, but anyway, that's just the biological truth of it. And so my potato head model that I proposed a little while ago was that actually doesn't matter how you get the information into the brain as long as you get it there.
Starting point is 00:30:36 You can send information through a very unusual channel, and as long as the information gets there, the brain will figure out what to do with it. And so this was first shown, actually at the end of the 1800s, where some experimenters took someone who was blind and they had a little photo detector that would detect light, and they turned that into patterns of vibration on the head, and the person could essentially come to see via patterns of vibration on their forehead. And this is so unusual to think about sight that way. And then I'll mention in 1969, another scientist put blind people
Starting point is 00:31:16 into a modified dental chair, which had this little grid on the back, and it would sort of poke you in the back in various ways. And he set up a video camera and whatever the video camera was seeing, you would feel that poked into your back. So if it was a face or a square or a coffee cup or a telephone, you'd feel the shape of that poked into your back
Starting point is 00:31:34 and blind people got really good at being able to see the world this way. And so it turns out it doesn't matter how you get the information in there. The brain will say, oh, I got it. That's correlated with something out there that's useful, and I'll figure out how to perceive it. Really, really interesting stuff. So I know that you've been using skin
Starting point is 00:31:54 in a really unique way, and now you have a product, a wristband, where you're actually helping deaf people. Can you tell us about that? Yeah, so I got interested in my lab many years ago about this question of could we make sensory substitution for people who are deaf? Could we feed in the information that would normally going to the ears via a different channel?
Starting point is 00:32:14 And there are actually two hundred and twelve different reasons you can go deaf genetically. And most of these are not something that you can do anything about at the moment. So what I did first as I built a vest with vibratory motors on it, and the vest captures sound and turns that into patterns vibration on the skin. So, sound is broken up from high to low frequency, which is exactly what your inner ear is doing,
Starting point is 00:32:36 and then that's going on your skin, and up your spinal cord and into your brain, and deaf people could learn how to hear this way. So, I gave a talk on this at TED, and then I spun this alpha my lab as a company, called Neocensory, and we ended up shrinking the vest down to a wrist band. And the wrist band does the same thing.
Starting point is 00:32:55 It's capturing sound, and it's turning that into panorzoid abrasion on the skin, and deaf people can come to understand the auditory world around them. Like, oh, that's somebody calling my name. That's the doorbell. That's a baby crying. That's a dog barking, things like that.
Starting point is 00:33:08 So we're on risks all over the world now. Lots of deaf schools, lots of individuals wearing this. And it's been so gratifying to take something that's a theoretical neuroscience idea and move it all the way to product that people are using every day. Yeah, it's really awesome what you're doing. And so I'd love to understand how long does it take for someone to get these vibrations and then eventually have them mean something. So the answer is it's a linear increase. So people just get better and better each day. So on day
Starting point is 00:33:42 one, we test people after they've been wearing it for the first 10 minutes or so, and they're slightly above chance on being able to recognize certain sounds. But then through time over the course of weeks, they just get better and better and better. And the really wild part is that by about, let's say four months, people will describe it as hearing.
Starting point is 00:34:00 So I'll say, look, when the dog barks and you feel vibrations on your wrist, do you think, okay, wait, I just felt something, what is that? It must be something, you know, maybe there's a dog out there. They say, no, I just hear the dog, which sounds crazy, except that's what you're, that's what's going on with your hearing. You feel right now like you're just hearing my voice out there. Even though it's all taking place in your head, you've got spikes running around and you think, oh yeah, that sounds like Eaglemman's voice. And then you attribute it to some source outside of you. But that's what it becomes when you're listening through the wristband.
Starting point is 00:34:32 Yeah. And from my understanding, this is called qualia, right? Yeah, qualia is the term we use for the private subjective experience we have of something. For example, colors don't exist in the outside world. There's just different wavelengths of light of electromagnetic radiation. But we perceive it as, oh, that's red, that's green, that's fuchsia, whatever. That's a qualia, that's a private subjective experience we have of what's going on out there, even though it's really just spikes in the dark. Yeah. So then would you say that humans eventually could have a sixth or seventh sense that just
Starting point is 00:35:09 feels natural to us? So that's what I've been working on for a while now, which is given that all these other animals have other kinds of things they can pick up on, what does it mean if we feed in that information? And the answer is yes, we can absolutely have six cents, maybe many more, we don't have any idea yet what the limit is on that. But the idea is what can we pick up on computationally
Starting point is 00:35:34 or with any machine or whatever, and then feed that into you. So for example, you know, something I've been very interested in is perceiving infrared light. So you can set up, we've set this up with the wristband, very inexpensively for five bucks, you set up these infrared millimeters, they're called, they're just picking up on infrared light. And you can walk around and feel the temperature of things around you. And as I'm walking through a parking lot, I can feel which cars have been parked
Starting point is 00:36:01 there for a while versus which have just arrived in the last 20 minutes because the engine block is a totally different temperature. But it's just something I know as I'm walking through, I'm just feeling that information where if I come across two chairs, I can tell which chair was more recently sat in because there's still a temperature signature on it and so on. There's a million things about this that one can just come to perceive a new sense, but you can have much wackier things. We've actually have 70 projects in progress. If anybody's interested, go to neo-sensory.com slash developers. And you can see our blog of all these different projects
Starting point is 00:36:34 we have. So stock market or feeling social media with your skin or firemen or blind people or people with prosthetics or there's a million different projects we have where we're feeding in new data streams and you can come to have a perception of it. One of the things we've been doing is for drone pilots where you feel the pitch, y'all roll,
Starting point is 00:36:56 heading, and orientation of the drone on your skin. So it's like you're becoming one with the drone. It's like you stretched your skin up there where the drone is. And pilots can become much better at flying drones this way in the fog and in the dark. And in fact, right now, I'm working with a couple of young engineers in Ukraine to implement this for their defense. Very interesting. Okay, so I want to switch back to what we were talking about a little bit earlier when we were talking about our senses or our neurons,
Starting point is 00:37:26 sort of fighting for their territory, because I wanna get into the concept of dreaming, I think it's super interesting, and I want you to explain why we actually dream. So this is hypothesis that my student I came up with some years ago, which is the following. If you go blind, as we mentioned earlier, if you go blind, that territory or visual cortex
Starting point is 00:37:48 gets taken over by neighboring kingdoms of data, like hearing and touching. But the surprise neuroscience is how fast this can happen. So some colleagues in mind at Harvard did this experiment where they took normally sighted people and they blindfolded them and they put them in the brain scanner. And what they found to their surprise
Starting point is 00:38:06 is that after about an hour, they could start seeing activity in the visual cortex when you touch somebody or when you play a sound for them. You're actually seeing the visual cortex start responding to that. And what that means is that this takeover process can start happening really fast because essentially everything in the brain is wired up to everything else.
Starting point is 00:38:26 There's these very long distance connections such that everything has roadways to get wherever it needs to get. And so somehow this takeover starts after about an hour. So what we realized was, given the rotation of the planet, this causes a real problem for the visual system because you end up in the dark for half the cycle. And obviously the thing of interest here is evolutionary time before we had lights, which is just the last, you know, nanosecond of evolutionary time where we had lights or even fire. Most of our history has been extremely dark at nighttime and that means your visual system is disadvantaged during the night. You can still hear and smell and taste and touch during the night, but you can't see. And so we realize the problem is the visual system needs some way of defending itself against takeover.
Starting point is 00:39:11 And that is what dreams are about. So every 90 minutes, you've got these very ancient circuits in your mid-brain that just blast random activity just into your visual cortex. That's the only place that's hitting. It's just primary visual cortex. And every 90 minutes just blasts random activity, just into your visual cortex. That's the only place that's hitting. It's just primary visual cortex. And every 90 minutes, just blasts random activity in there. And so dreaming is the brain's way of defending the visual cortex against takeover.
Starting point is 00:39:34 It's essentially a screensaver. So we published this and we studied 25 different species of primates and looked at how plastic they are. In other words, humans are extraordinarily adaptable and plastic in their brains, and that means they're at higher risk of the visual cortex getting taken over. Whereas other primates, like the gray mouse lemur, it's called, it happens to be very, let's call it pre-programmed, where it hits
Starting point is 00:40:01 adolescents fast and there's had a walk fast and weans from its mother fast and all this stuff reproduces fast. And so we looked at how much dreaming there is and it turns out humans have lots of dreaming to take over the visual cortex whereas other less flexible animals have less dreaming because they just don't need it as much. So if I have this right and feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, basically our visual neurons are being active at night and dreaming, even though we're not actually seeing anything in our head, those same neurons are basically working so that they can keep their territory, so that they can stay relevant in the brain. That's exactly right. Yeah, it's so interesting. And I've heard you say,
Starting point is 00:40:45 you think dreams are meaningless and you feel like it's sticking your head in a night blender when you go to sleep. So I'd like to understand like why are dreams meaningless then? Because a lot of people make up these stories like I can tell the future with my dreams and things like that, but you say that's nonsense. Yeah, it's just random activity. What happens is the synapses, the connections that are hot during the day are the ones when you blast random activity in there. Those tend to be the stories that get activated. So, you know, if I'm thinking about my boss who said this to me, or I'm thinking about this big thing that I have to do tomorrow, then it's likely that that's going to come up in
Starting point is 00:41:23 my dreams. But we all know dreams are just, they're so weird in their plot lines. And because the brain is a natural storyteller, we end up imposing narrative. And by the way, when you wake up and you tell somebody else your dream, you're doing a whole nother layer of imposing narrative on it. Because even just saying it out loud, you have to sort of make things make sense. But truthfully, it's just random activity. And it's kind of like a Rorschach blot. If you just look at some random blob of ink, can you see things that you think are relevant to your life? And you say, oh, yeah, that looks like, yeah, this is sort of
Starting point is 00:42:00 a blob that's telling me that I should go change careers and whatever. We can do that with our dreams as well. It's just random activity and you can say, yeah, that really thought of something here, whatever. But yes, it's all random activity and what we do is we impose meaning on it. Some of us do. Yeah, some of us do. I mean, I've done it.
Starting point is 00:42:18 I think a lot of people try to make dreams just like magical experience, right? And I feel like so much of the human experience can be pretty silly in this way. We'll be right back after a quick break from our sponsors. Your dog is an important part of your family. Don't settle when it comes to their health. Make the switch to fresh food made with real ingredients
Starting point is 00:42:41 that are backed by science with nom nom nom. Nom nom delivers fresh dog food that is personalized to your dog's individual needs. Each portion is tailored to ensure your dog gets the nutrition they need so you can watch them thrive. Nom nom's ingredients are cooked individually and then mixed together because science tells us that every protein, carb, and veggie has different cooking times and methods. This packs in all the vitamins and minerals your dog needs, so they truly get the most out of every single bite. And nom nom is completely free of additives, fillers, and mystery ingredients that contribute to bloating and low energy. Your dog deserves only the best, and nom nom delivers just
Starting point is 00:43:19 that. Their nutrient packed recipes are crafted by board-certified veterinary nutritionists, made fresh and shipped to your door. Absolutely free! Nom-nom meals started just $2.40, and every meal is cooked in company-owned kitchens right here in the US, and they've already delivered over 40 million meals, inspiring clean bowls and wagging tails everywhere. Ever since I started feeding my dog Nom-nom, he's been so much more energetic, and he's getting older, he's a senior dog, but now we've been going on longer walks and he's much more playful. He used to be pretty sluggish and sleeping all the time, but I've definitely noticed
Starting point is 00:43:57 a major improvement since I started feeding him Nom Nom. And the best part, they offer a money back guarantee. If your dog's tail isn't wagging within 30 days, they'll refund your first order. No fillers, no nonsense, just nom nom. Go right now for 50% off your no risk 2 week trial at trinom.com-shap. That's trinom-n-o-m.com-shap for 50% off, try num.com slash app. Hear that sound, young and profitors? You should know that sound by now,
Starting point is 00:44:30 but in case you don't, that's the sound of another sale on Shopify. Shopify is the commerce platform that's revolutionizing millions of businesses worldwide. Whether you sell edgy t-shirts or offer an educational course like me, Shopify simplifies selling online and in person so you can focus on successfully growing your business.
Starting point is 00:44:49 Shopify is packed with industry leading tools that are ready to ignite your growth, giving you complete control over your business and brand without having to learn any new skills in design or code. And Shopify grows with you no matter how big your business gets. Thanks to an endless list of integrations and third party apps, anything you can think of from on-demand printing to accounting to chatbots, Shopify has everything you need to revolutionize your business. If you're a regular listener, you probably know that I use Shopify
Starting point is 00:45:17 to sell my LinkedIn Secrets Masterclass. Setting up my Shopify store just took me a few days. I didn't have to worry about my website and how I was going to collect payments and how I was going to trigger Abandoned cart emails and all these things that Shopify does for me was just a click of a button even setting up my chat Bot was just a click of a button. It was so easy to do like I said just took a couple of days And so it just allowed me to focus on my actual product and making sure my LinkedIn masterclass was the best it could be. And I was able to focus on my marketing. So Shopify really, really helped me make sure that my masterclass was going to be a success right off the bat and enabled focus. And focus is everything when it comes to entrepreneurship.
Starting point is 00:45:59 With Shopify single dashboard, I can manage my orders and my payments from anywhere in the world. And like I said, it's one of my favorite things to do every day is check my Shopify dashboard. It is a rush of dopamine to see all those blinking lights around the world showing me where everybody is logging on on the site. I love it. I highly recommend it. Shopify is a platform that I use every single day and it can take your business to the next level.
Starting point is 00:46:26 Sign up for a $1 per month trial period at Shopify.com-profiting. Again, go to Shopify.com-profiting, all lowercase, to take your business to the next level today. Again, that Shopify.com-profiting, Shopify.com-profiting, all lowercase. This is Possibility powered by Shopify. slash profiting all lower case. This is Possibility powered by Shopify. So I'd love to talk about the intersection between science and religion. You've been studying the brain
Starting point is 00:46:55 and I feel like you probably have a very unique perspective on the world. I mean, it's parts about our brain and our life is still really mysterious, right? We don't really know how consciousness exactly works still. Yeah. And so there is mystery and sort of magic to like still because we don't understand everything. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:47:14 But I'd love to understand what you feel about all this now. My general feeling on it is the world is full of mystery. The amount of stuff we know in science and have written down in big fat textbooks is a tiny fraction of what's going on out there. Actually, I wrote an article in the Discover Magazine back in 2004 called 10 Unsolved Mysteries of Neuroscience and they're still unsolved. I mean, we are in deep mysteries all around us. And yeah, take consciousness. I mean, consciousness, somehow you put together all this physical stuff of the brain and you experience qualia as we talked about, you know, experience pain and the beauty of a sunset and the taste of cinnamon and, you know,
Starting point is 00:47:54 the smell of lemon pie and all these things that we experience. But we have no idea how to build pieces of art. We can't build with transistors or computer and say, oh, yeah, it's enjoying this. Even though I'm laughing at this YouTube video that I'm watching, the computer presumably is just moving around zeros and ones and not entertained by it. But somehow our brains, we think, were just made of cells and yet we are feeling stuff. So there's lots of mystery around us.
Starting point is 00:48:21 To my mind, the best way to tackle these mysteries is the scientific method. And this is so new for humans. I mean, this is really just the last few hundred years that we've kind of gotten this right, essentially, since the Renaissance about doing science, which is just, it's nothing but a method of saying, okay, we're going to lay out our hypotheses on the table and we're going to do careful experiments We're not going to fool ourselves into into believing something unless there's evidence that supports it And so to my mind that's the way to tackle it now the Issue is we have a world full of religions there are two thousand different religions on on this little planet that we're on and The part that's always struck me is crazy is that people are willing to fight and die for their version of their religion. So there's a real lack of intellectual humility
Starting point is 00:49:11 there. Obviously, if one religion were true, we might expect that it spreads around the world. And everyone says, oh, yeah, that one seems pretty right. But obviously, they're all made up. And when you look at stuff like Judeo-Christian, Islamic religion, it has this idea that the earth is 6,000 years old. Well, the Japanese were making pottery 7,000 years ago and people were writing on caves 30,000 years ago and so on. So you'd have to explain how they got there before the end.
Starting point is 00:49:38 Anyway, it's so goofy, this idea of like Adam and Eve and creation and so on. It's so clearly incorrect that there's absolutely no reason to believe in this religious story. But I have felt that it's difficult to say, given the amount of mystery that we face, to say, okay, well, we've got this all figured out. And so it's a cold universe and there's nothing
Starting point is 00:50:01 but deterministic physics and so on. We just don't know enough to say that. That may well be so on. We just don't know enough to say that. That may well be the case. We just don't know enough to pretend that science has it all figured out. And so I call myself a possibility and that means I'm interested in the possibility space. In other words, this is the scientific temperament is saying what could be going on here? How did we get here? What is our purpose here, if any of the,
Starting point is 00:50:26 what is happening around here? And the best way to tackle that is with the tools of science, which means anything gets to be on the table at first, and then we use the tools of science to rule out particular things, like that the Earth is 6,000 years old. And we use the tools of science to open up new folds in the possibility space
Starting point is 00:50:44 that we hadn't even thought of before. But the idea is the scientific temperament always allows lots of hypotheses on the table, and then we gather evidence to weigh in favor of some of those and against others. That's what I think we should be doing. That's what I call post-abilianism. I actually presented this in a TEDx talk many years ago. I got hundreds of emails right afterwards from people saying, hey, I think I'm a post-bullion too.
Starting point is 00:51:15 It became this worldwide movement. There were newspapers and articles that people sent me from India, from Uganda, from whatever Facebook groups sprang up. Now 11 years after this original talk, there's so much activity about possibilityism. And I'm so happy about this because I feel like there wasn't a position that people could take if they happened to feel the way
Starting point is 00:51:36 I did about this. The only thing that was available is to say, okay, either I'm religious, and I believe what my parents and my culture told me, or I'm a strict atheist on the other end of the spectrum where I think Nothing interesting is going on here. There's nothing else in the universe to understand or you would call yourself an Agnostic which means I don't know. That's all agnosticism means is not knowing but Possibility is a much more active thing of saying hey, we're gonna go out and explore the possibility space and shine a flashlight around this and try to figure out what's going on.
Starting point is 00:52:07 And I feel like this is so positive for mankind. I feel like it could really help solve a lot of the self-inflicted issues that we have as people. Yeah. To this day, every time I see religious conflict, it just blows my mind. I mean, the whole history of Europe was really to fight over the last 500 years was defined by fights between the Catholics and the Protestants. I don't mean fights, I mean killing, like murdering. And, you know, it feels like you look at this stuff
Starting point is 00:52:36 and it's so goofy. Mm-hmm. And yet, this is the history that we have been surrounded with and still have to deal with in a lot of the world. I feel like I think I'm correct in looking at the world now in 2022 and thinking, okay, we're maturing a bit at least much of the world is maturing out of this idea of, okay, this particular ancient religion that I was taught is the truth. Yeah, but anyway, I hope that's right. is the truth. Yeah, but anyway, I hope that's right. Okay, so let's talk about the feature a little bit and then we can close this out, David. Thank you so much for your time. I want to talk about
Starting point is 00:53:13 your book LiveWired, right? Much of the world and how we view it is very much like hardware and software. And so I'd love to have you help us imagine what a feature could be like if live wired was put in the picture in addition to this hardware and software world that we live in. Yeah, I mean, so this is gonna be my next, so I'm running three companies right now, but this is gonna be my next one is called live wired. Because I'm really interested in building this. I mentioned this before. I just feel like the way we think about building all our technology now and the way that everything is set up, our factories are set up and our education system is set up, it's, okay, yeah, you make a hard word layer and then you put software on top of it and that's been a great idea and it's been super successful, but it's just not the way that biology ever does anything and biology can do extraordinary things that computers cannot. And as I mentioned earlier, computers are obsolescent from the day they come off the factory. So I'm very, I'll give an
Starting point is 00:54:09 example, which is the Mars rover, Kimmerville's spirit of curiosity, one of them. Anyway, you got up to Mars, they did an extraordinary job, rolled around the red planet and saw lots of stuff, but then it got its right front wheels stuck in the Martian soil, and it couldn't move out of there, and it died. Okay. Contrast that with what happens when a wolf gets its leg caught in a trap, the wolf chooses its leg off and then figures out how to walk on three legs.
Starting point is 00:54:37 It's not that it was pre-programmed to walk on three legs, it just figures it out, it figures out how to make that happen, because it is driven by motivations. It wants to get to food, to water, back to its pack, and so on. So it just figures out how to run its body differently. And wouldn't it be great if we could build a billion dollar Mars rover if we're spending all that money and effort on it if it could just, you know, saw off its wheel and then figure out how to operate in a different way? So this is the idea of live wiring and it's still the case that almost everything we program and the robots we build and the Mars servers we build
Starting point is 00:55:09 are all totally pre-programmed. This is what your body looks like. This is how you're gonna operate it. As opposed to letting it operate like a human infant where it has to figure out its body. I mean, imagine building a robot that flops around for years and eventually crawls and eventually learns how to walk.
Starting point is 00:55:26 That's the kind of thing we need to do if we want it to be flexible and live wired. Yeah. And so I'm very interested in the possibilities. I think the future is going to be much more biological than the way we do it right now, which is we build hard-wired machinery that is inflexible. Yeah. And so my next question for you is, what's the difference between live wired and AI? Because from my understanding, AI is supposed to be self, you know, it learns and can adapt. So I'd love to understand the difference there.
Starting point is 00:55:58 I mean, the thing about AI can do very impressive things, but it's still not nearly as good as a kid. A five-year-old can walk into a room, navigate a very complex room between the couches and under the table and whatever can find her way to food and put food in her mouth, can socially manipulate adults, can do all these things. AI is really stupid in comparison to that. It's very good. It's extraordinarily good at, for example, image recognition or categorization of things, but it can only tackle problems that are discrete and rule based. So, for example, AI is great at chess and it go. It's beat the world champions at that. But that's only because that's a constrained
Starting point is 00:56:46 rule based system that doesn't have anything outside of it, and the real world is nothing like that. And so by the way, even though people often think, oh my gosh, yeah, I can do anything, it's taking over everything, it can't even do any sort of strategy-based video game where you're running around with a gun and you're having to do strategies where it can't do well at any of that stuff. So that's the difference. Is that a live wire child can figure out all kinds of things in the world? AI can only do these very basic things right now. Yeah, and this makes me feel good because I think all of us are really worried about AI.
Starting point is 00:57:20 We're told to get worried about it, right? We're sort of fed this. So as somebody who studies the brain, do we have anything to worry about? I mean, eventually, we might. Certainly not right now. I mean, you can just turn the computer off. I mean, there's a...
Starting point is 00:57:34 Yeah, it's still doing what it is told as in, hey, I want you to absorb a billion pictures of cows and horses and then get really good at being able to determine the difference between you. So what it does is it trains on a training set of let's say billion images where it's labeled. This is a cow. This is a horse.
Starting point is 00:57:54 And then it's extraordinarily good, better than human at discriminating cows from horses. But in real life, we don't have training sets with billions of examples. We don't have that lecture. You have to learn everything on the fly. All animals do. You have to learn the world on the fly and get good at it. And this is where we outshine AI by a long way. OK, my last question to you on the future.
Starting point is 00:58:17 And then we'll round out this interview. Is really about how you imagine mankind in the future in terms of our brains, in terms of maybe live wired materials. Tell us about how you imagine the future knowing all that you know. It's going to be pretty different. I mean, for one thing, we'll be much better at actually being able to measure what's going on in the brain. So for example, right now, our best technology is called
Starting point is 00:58:43 Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging, FMRI. technology is called functional magnetic resonance imaging, FMRI. You stick somebody in the brain scanner and you can tell sort of crudely where the activity is happening in the brain. And you know, we make all kinds of theories and we do, you know, I've written hundreds of papers on this topic. But the fact is it's a crude technology. What we really need to understand how the brain is working is to be able to see the activity
Starting point is 00:59:06 in each one of the 86 billion neurons in real time and they're each chattering along, you know, 10 to hundreds of spikes per second. We're nowhere near that kind of technology, but eventually we will get there and that will generate a completely different kind of understanding of how the brain actually works. We're still missing really most of how the brain actually works. We're still missing really most of how the brain is actually doing what it does. And when we get to that point, we'll be able to read and write from the brain to the brain. And that's going to change everything. Right now, the brain is really locked in this armored bunker plating of the skull. And we can't do much with it,
Starting point is 00:59:41 except for I can read your, I can try to read your intentions and you mine by our words and by our behavior, but it's pretty limited. So there may be in the distant future straight brain to brain communication, which is a very different sort of bandwidth of communication. So that's one thing. I think another thing is that we will be experiencing completely new senses. It'll just be trivial for everybody to experience, you know, whatever infrared and stock market data and what's going on on social media, you know, these things will just be like getting eyeglasses for a kid will have all that. So I think we have more in common with our ancestors of 5,000 years ago than we have in common with our descendants of a hundred years from now. Wow.
Starting point is 01:00:33 That is powerful. Awesome, David. Well, I end this show with two questions that I ask everyone and then we do something fun at the end of the year with them. So you're right at the end with us. What is one actionable thing are young and profitors can do today to become more profitable tomorrow? Seek novelty. So the key is doing things that you're not already good at because that's how you exercise the brain and
Starting point is 01:00:59 build a stronger brain is by doing things you have not done before. Okay, so challenging your mind to learning new things. Yes. And what is your secret to profiting in life? Relationships. It's all about other people. The brain has an extraordinary amount of its circuitry devoted to other people in making models of them and understanding them. And I think one of the key things in life, especially now during our polarized era, is to
Starting point is 01:01:24 really try standing in the shoes of other people, especially people that you're disagreeing with, and try to understand the world from their point of view. Awesome, that's awesome. You know, that was one of the biggest themes this year, is everybody was talking about relationships. So, very cool, David, where can everybody learn more about you and everything that you do?
Starting point is 01:01:41 Eagleman.com. Awesome, well, thank you so much for your time. Thanks, great to be here. that you do. Eagleman.com Awesome. Well, thank you so much for your time. Thanks. Great to be here. Young and profitors! What an insightful and different conversation that we had today with David Eagleman. It may be a thing about a lot of things that I never really thought about before. Like for example, our senses.
Starting point is 01:02:02 We take our brains and senses for granted. I mean, we never really stop to smell the roses, so to speak. We just smell and we see and we touch and we feel and we hear and we don't realize like how much is really going on and how magical it all is. Our brain is literally a three pound miracle when you think about it. And a lot of us are born with five senses. We're really lucky, you know, we should be really grateful for that. repound miracle when you think about it. And a lot of us are born with five senses. We're really lucky, you know, we should be really grateful for that.
Starting point is 01:02:28 But it's interesting to think that for those of us who may be deaf or blind or missing one of their senses, that their brain is actually making up for those lost senses and strengthening other senses, so they still live a rich life, you know, their senses are richer in different ways. And it's so wild that David is now able to help people live a better life by creating inventions that allow people to do things like hear from their skin. I mean, that's wild. It was so interesting to hear what he thought the future of mankind would be like, and I can't wait to see it all unfold. I have to say. Scientists are just scratching the surface in terms of how the brain works. kind would be like, and I can't wait to see it all unfold. I have to say, scientists are just scratching the surface in terms of how the brain works. One of the things that
Starting point is 01:03:10 really stuck in my mind after this interview was David's perspective on God and religion. I've been talking about this a lot to my friends, my family. I brought this up in conversations now maybe 10 times since this interview. And we don't talk about this a lot on YAP, but it was really powerful for me to hear one of the world's foremost experts on the brain admit that we don't know how consciousness works. I don't think I ever realized that scientists can't prove technically or scientifically how consciousness actually
Starting point is 01:03:41 works. It's sort of like we're a bunch of cells, we've got a brain, we've got all these body parts and then poof, we're alive or we're dead, right? Nobody can explain consciousness. And so we don't talk much about religion on this podcast and that's definitely on purpose. But this is like beyond religion. This is about like mankind in general. And what David believes makes so much sense. He says he's a possibility. And possibility is a philosophy which rejects claims of traditional theism and the positions of certainty in atheism in favor for a middle exploratory ground.
Starting point is 01:04:22 And honestly, I'm super aligned with that. I think you would solve a lot of the world's problems and pain and all the discrimination that we have right now. If we just took a scientific approach to all of this, reveling in the alternatives and imagining other possibilities and testing those ideas against available evidence, that is what we need to do. I hope more people adopt this mindset,
Starting point is 01:04:45 and I hope we take a more logical approach to everything, because that's the only way we're going to survive as humanity, and really push through as we get more scientifically advanced. And it's just, it's really interesting, it was eye-opening. And if you enjoyed this episode like I did, tell your friends about it, tell your friends and family, I love it when you guys share the show. Let's make young and profiting word of mouth viral in 2023.
Starting point is 01:05:11 We're already dominating the charts, but I wanna go even further, yeah, family. I need your help. I need you to tell your friends and family about your favorite way to listen, learn and profit. You guys can also find us on YouTube. If you wanna watch any of our videos, we have all of our videos on there. You can also find us on YouTube if you want to watch any of our videos. We have all of our videos on there.
Starting point is 01:05:26 You can also find me on Instagram at YappwithHalla or LinkedIn. Just search for my name. It's Halataha. And as always, thanks to my amazing Yapp team for putting out the show. This is your host, Halataha, signing off. Are you looking for ways to be happier, healthier, more productive, and more creative? I'm Gretchen Ruben, the number one best-selling author of the Happiness Project. And every week, we share ideas and practical solutions on the Happier with Gretchen Ruben podcast. My co-host and Happiness Guinea Pig is my sister Elizabeth
Starting point is 01:06:10 Kraft. That's me, Elizabeth Kraft, a TV writer and producer in Hollywood. Join us as we explore fresh insights from cutting-edge science, ancient wisdom, pop culture, and our own experiences about cultivating happiness and good habits. Every week, we offer a try this at home tip you can use to boost your happiness
Starting point is 01:06:28 without spending a lot of time energy or money. Suggestions such as follow the one-minute rule. Choose a one-word theme for the year or design your summer. We also feature segments like know yourself better, where we discuss questions like are you an over buyer or an under buyer? Morning person or night person, abundance lever or simplicity lever? And every episode includes a happiness hack, a quick, easy shortcut to more happy. Listen and follow the podcast, Happier with Gretchen Ruben. Ever notice what happens when your home is beautifully organized? You have more space, more room to breathe. At California clososets, our designers note just what
Starting point is 01:07:05 questions to ask to create exactly what you want. Your personalized experience includes custom design and installation to deliver a result that truly reflects your style and needs. That's the California Closets difference. We call it practical magic. Book your free design consultation today at californicclosets.com Book your free design consultation today at CaliforniaClosets.com

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.